Suspected skin malignancy: a comparison of diagnoses of family practitioners and dermatologists in 493 patients

BACKGROUND: In the Irish health system, dermatology patients present to their family practitioner for diagnosis and treatment, and are referred to a dermatologist for a second opinion where diagnosis is in doubt or when there has been therapeutic failure. The level of expertise in dermatology amongst family practitioners varies considerably. AIM: To compare the diagnoses of general practitioners and dermatologists over a selected period in patients with a possible diagnosis of skin cancer. METHODS: Four hundred and ninety-three patients were seen by one of two dermatologists over a 1-year period at a rapid referral clinic for patients suspected by their family practitioners of having unstable or possibly malignant skin lesions; 213 of these patients had a diagnosis made on clinical examination by the dermatologist, while 264 had diagnostic or therapeutic biopsies performed; 16 patients defaulted on surgery. RESULTS: The diagnoses of the family practitioners agreed with the diagnoses of the dermatologists on patients diagnosed clinically in 54% of cases. Thirty-eight patients had histologically proven skin malignancy. These were diagnosed accurately by the referring family practitioner in 22% of patients, while the dermatologists made the correct diagnosis prior to biopsy in 87%. CONCLUSIONS: In over 50% of cases diagnosed clinically, the dermatologist and family practitioner agreed. Histologically proven skin cancers were diagnosed accurately in only 22% of cases by family practitioners, compared to 87% of cases by dermatologists. Specific areas of diagnostic difficulty for family practitioners include benign pigmented actinic and seborrheic keratoses, squamous cell carcinoma, and melanoma. Postgraduate education for family practitioners should be directed towards these areas of deficiency. Dermatologists had difficulty distinguishing pigmented actinic keratoses from melanoma.     

Analysis of heterogeneity of atypia within melanocytic nevi

BACKGROUND: Incisional biopsy of clinically atypical nevi continues to be a common practice. Questions can arise as to the adequacy of these partial biopsies. OBJECTIVE: To determine whether incisional (partial) biopsy specimens may be considered representative of the entire lesion, atypical nevi submitted to our dermatopathology laboratory were examined for the presence or absence of heterogeneity of atypia within the individual nevi. DESIGN: The study included 250 histologically atypical nevi that were selected consecutively from pigmented lesions that were submitted to our dermatopathology laboratory by community and academic dermatologists for histopathologic analysis. Also, 23 moderately to severely atypical and 25 severely atypical nevi from consecutive submissions were added for statistical reasons. Lesions with both clear and involved margins were used. Lesions were considered homogeneous if the atypia involved the entire lesion or heterogeneous if either the atypia was focal or if different degrees of atypia occurred within the same lesion. Atypia was defined by the usual parameters of architectural and cytologic atypia and host response. Also, the degree of atypia in relationship to heterogeneity and to patient age was determined. SETTING: The Dermatopathology Laboratory, University of California, Irvine. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Outcome measures included the percentage of nevi exhibiting heterogeneity of atypia, heterogeneity of atypia in relation to patient age, degree of atypia in relation to patient age, and degree of atypia in relation to the presence of heterogeneity of atypia. RESULTS: Of the 298 nevi examined, 107 (35.9%) were heterogeneous in atypia and 191 (64.1%) were homogeneous in atypia. There was no significant difference in age between patients with heterogeneous lesions and those with homogeneous lesions. There was a statistically significant correlation between the degree of atypia and patient age. The average age of patients with a lesser degree of atypia was 36.9 years, while the average age of patients with a greater degree of atypia was 44.8 years (P<.005). There was no significant correlation between degree of atypia and heterogeneity of atypia (correlation coefficient, 0.1). CONCLUSIONS: A clinically significant proportion of atypical nevi exhibited heterogeneity of atypia. Also, there was a significant relationship between the degree of atypia and increasing age (P<.005). Therefore, if a clinically atypical nevus warrants a biopsy, these results give additional support for complete excisional biopsy (which can include shave or punch) to assure adequate histopathologic sampling of the lesion.     

Histopathological analysis of the therapeutic response to cryotherapy with liquid nitrogen in patients with multiple actinic keratosis

Actinic keratoses are premalignant lesions of the skin caused by excessive sun exposure. Lesions may become mainly squamous cell carcinoma. Cryotherapy with liquid nitrogen is one of the main treatments. In order to evaluate the response of actinic keratosis to cryotherapy by histopathology, two lesions were selected in each of 14 patients with multiple actinic keratoses. In one lesion a biopsy was performed and in the other lesion a biopsy was performed after cryotherapy. Subsequently, both biopsies were compared histologically. Of the thirteen patients who completed the study, the best results were obtained in lesions undergoing cryotherapy concerning the atypia of keratinocytes, epithelial thickness and corneal layer and lymphocytic infiltrate. Despite the small number of patients, it was concluded that, if performed correctly, cryotherapy has high efficacy in the treatment of actinic keratoses.     

Evaluating invasive cutaneous melanoma: is the initial biopsy representative of the final depth?

BACKGROUND: An accurate initial biopsy of the deepest portion of the melanoma is vital to the management of patients with melanomas. OBJECTIVE: Our goal was to evaluate the accuracy of preliminary biopsies performed by a group of predominantly experienced dermatologists (n = 46/72). METHODS: A total of 145 cases of cutaneous melanoma were examined retrospectively. We compared Breslow depth on preliminary biopsy with Breslow depth on subsequent excision. Was the initial diagnostic biopsy performed on the deepest part of the melanoma? RESULTS: Of nonexcisional initial shave and punch biopsies, 88% were accurate, with Breslow depth greater than or equal to subsequent excision Breslow depth. Both superficial and deep shave biopsies were more accurate than punch biopsy for melanomas less than 1 mm. Excisional biopsy was found to be the most accurate method of biopsy. CONCLUSIONS: Deep shave biopsy is preferable to superficial shave or punch biopsy for thin and intermediate depth (<2 mm) melanomas when an initial sample is taken for diagnosis instead of complete excision. We found that a group of predominantly experienced dermatologists accurately assessed the depth of invasive melanoma by use of a variety of initial biopsy types.     

Utility of step sections: demonstration of additional pathological findings in biopsy samples initially diagnosed as actinic keratosis

OBJECTIVES: To discover additional diagnostic findings on step sections of biopsy samples showing features of actinic keratosis on the initial section and to correlate such findings with clinical and histological variables. DESIGN: Prospective study comparing initial histological findings with those noted on deeper tissue levels. SETTING: University-based dermatopathology practice. PATIENTS: Fifty-seven patients (36 men and 21 women) with biopsy samples from 69 skin lesions. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Identification of additional pathological diagnoses in step sections and correlation with clinical diagnosis, size and location of lesion, history of skin cancer or immunosuppression, size and handling of specimen, and presence of ulceration on the initial level. RESULTS: Additional diagnostic findings were present on step sections in 23 specimens (33%), including 9 (13%) with squamous cell carcinoma in situ, 3 (4%) with basal cell carcinoma, and 2 (3%) with invasive squamous cell carcinoma. Three variables were significantly correlated with the discovery of cancer on step sections: (1) ulceration on the first level, (2) clinical diagnosis of skin cancer, and (3) history of skin cancer diagnosed by biopsy examination. The latter 2 variables were also correlated with the discovery of any additional finding, whether benign or malignant, on step sections. CONCLUSIONS: In biopsy samples initially diagnostic of actinic keratosis, examination of step sections contributes clinically important information. Step sections are particularly useful when a clinical diagnosis of skin cancer is present. The results of this study confirm the pathogenetic importance of actinic keratosis as a precursor to fully evolved malignant neoplasia and suggest that such lesions merit thorough histological study.     

The vanishing biopsy: the trend toward smaller specimens

Dermatopathologists have noted an increased number of smaller biopsy specimens. Our objective was to determine whether dermatologists are changing their choice of biopsy technique and the size of biopsy specimens. We conducted a retrospective study of 500 biopsies performed by dermatologists for the purpose of diagnosis in 1988, 1993, 1998, and 2003. Our study results indicate that dermatologists are performing fewer punch biopsies and more shave biopsies. What's more, there has been a decrease in the size of shave biopsy specimens. We believe that the decreased number of punch biopsies being performed combined with the decreased size of shave biopsy specimens may affect patient care.     

Diagnostic and surgical accuracy and economic aspects of dermatological surgery - a pilot study

BACKGROUND: Good skin care for oncological dermatological patients includes efficacious excision to achieve tumour control and economically reasonable costs. This field concerns dermatologists as much as other surgical specialities. METHODS: Of 944 excisions and biopsies, we studied 114 epidermal carcinomas excised by plastic surgeons and dermatologists. This allowed us to compare the accuracy concerning oncological surgical aspects as well as the extrapolated costs produced by these two specialities. RESULTS: Dermatologists are significantly more accurate concerning total excision of epidermal tumours compared to plastic surgeons. CONCLUSION: From an economic point of view, plastic surgeons are increasingly more expensive than dermatologists. Most expenses are due to the use of a hospital operating room.     

Actinic Keratosis

Actinic keratoses are hyperkeratotic skin lesions that represent focal abnormal proliferation of epidermal keratinocytes. Some actinic keratoses evolve into squamous cell carcinoma of the skin, while others resolve spontaneously. The conversion rate of actinic keratosis to squamous cell carcinoma is not accurately known, but appears to be in the range of 0.25 to 1% per year. Although there is a low rate of conversion of actinic keratoses to squamous cell carcinoma, 60% of squamous cell carcinomas of the skin probably arise from actinic keratoses. The main cause of actinic keratoses in otherwise healthy Caucasians appears to be the sun. Therapy for actinic keratoses begins with prevention which starts with sun avoidance and physical protection. Sunprotection with sunscreens actually slows the return of actinic keratoses in patients already getting actinic keratoses. Interestingly, a few studies are available that demonstrate that a high fat diet is associated with the production of more actinic keratoses than is a low fat diet. One of the mainstays of therapy has been local destruction of the actinic keratoses with cryotherapy, and curettage and electrodesiccation. A new addition to this group of therapies to treat individual actinic keratoses is photodynamic therapy with topical aminolevulinic acid and light. In patients who have numerous actinic keratoses in an area of severely sun damaged skin, therapies which are applied to the whole actinic keratosis area are used. The goal of treating such an area of skin is to treat all of the early as well as the numerous clinically evident actinic keratoses at the same time. The classical approaches for treating areas of photodamaged skin without treating actinic keratoses individually include: the use of topically applied fluorouracil cream, dermabrasion, and cutaneous peels with various agents like trichloroacetic acid. Both topically as well as orally administered retinoids have been used to treat actinic keratoses but retinoids alone are probably not an optimal monotherapy. Photodynamic therapy with topical aminolevulinic acid and light is a new therapy for actinic keratoses. Aminolevulinic acid is a precursor of protoporphyrin IX (PpIX) which is synthesized in the actinic keratosis when it is treated with aminolevulinic acid, and the PpIX photosensitizes the actinic keratosis so that light exposure can lead to its destruction. Photodynamic therapy with topical aminolevulinic acid is approved in the US to treat multiple individual actinic keratoses on the face and scalp and has similar cure rates to those reported for cryotherapy and fluorouracil therapy.     

The diagnostic yield in submitting nevi for histologic examination

BACKGROUND: Dermatologists have expertise in the clinical diagnosis of benign melanocytic nevi. However, there are no data to confirm the accuracy of diagnosis. Differences in the diagnostic accuracy between dermatologists and nondermatologists with regard to cutaneous tumors has been infrequently studied. OBJECTIVE: We examined the rate of malignant tumors occurring in lesions submitted for routine microscopic examination that were clinically diagnosed as benign melanocytic nevi. METHODS: We conducted a study at a regional, non-hospital-based dermatopathology laboratory using specimens submitted by physicians of various specialties who were practicing in a 5-state Midwest region of the United States. The preoperative and postoperative diagnoses were examined on the basis of information provided by the clinician and of the subsequent histopathologic diagnosis. A total of 7734 cutaneous pathology reports were reviewed. Specimens submitted with a preoperative clinical diagnosis of mole or nevus, with or without a modifier, were examined and compared with postoperative microscopic diagnoses. RESULTS: Of 1946 specimens clinically diagnosed and submitted as benign nevi, 45 (2.3%) were histologically diagnosed as malignant tumors. This included 12 melanomas, 30 basal cell carcinomas, and 3 squamous cell carcinomas. For specimens submitted by dermatologists, the rate of malignant tumors increased when clinical information suggested findings beyond the classic benign clinical presentation with the addition of modifiers such as irritated or atypical, or if a malignancy was considered in the differential diagnosis (trend for increasing clinical suspicion: P = .00002). Fewer dermatologists than nondermatologists mistook a malignant tumor for a benign nevus (1.3% vs 3.8%, P = .003). CONCLUSION: Our data document that 2.3% of clinically diagnosed benign nevi were microscopically diagnosed as malignant tumors. Whether this malignancy rate in clinically diagnosed, benign, melanocytic nevi is above or below the threshold to establish a policy for submission for histopathologic examination remains to be determined as a collective societal and medical professional responsibility.     

Pitfalls in the clinical and dermoscopic diagnosis of pigmented actinic keratosis

Pigmented actinic keratosis and melanoma may exhibit overlapping clinical features, thus representing a diagnostic challenge for dermatologists. Although the differentiation between these two entities is traditionally done by histopathology, dermoscopy has been utilized as a useful additional aid for improving the clinical diagnostic accuracy of such pigmented skin lesions. We report the clinical and dermoscopic features of two pigmented actinic keratoses to discuss the difficulties in their preoperative differential diagnosis.     

Dysplastic naevi: To shave,or not to shave? A retrospective study of the use of the shave biopsy technique in the initial management of dysplastic naevi

The management of dysplastic naevi is a controversial subject. This study sought to assess the usefulness of the shave biopsy technique in the initial management of dysplastic naevi, and to demonstrate the advantages over the punch biopsy technique. We report a retrospective observational study of histopathology specimens examined in one histopathology practice over a 14-month period. Patients who had a clinical diagnosis of 'dysplastic naevus', which had initially been biopsied using either a shave or punch biopsy, and then followed up with a full-thickness elliptical excision, were included in the study. Histopathological concordance between the shave and punch biopsy specimens and their respective follow-up elliptical excisions was compared. We found that 21 of 22 (95.5%) shave biopsies were concordant with their respective excision specimens, and that 29 of 41 (70.7%) punch biopsies were concordant with their respective elliptical excision specimens. Of the shave biopsy specimens reviewed, 66% showed that the dysplastic naevi were completely excised with the initial biopsy, compared with 21.2% of the punch biopsy specimens. These findings confirm that shave biopsies provide accurate diagnostic information in the assessment of dysplastic naevi. Shave biopsies enable the entire lesion to be submitted for histopathological assessment, improving the chances of an accurate diagnosis.     

Effect of a 1-week treatment with 0.5% topical fluorouracil on occurrence of actinic keratosis after cryosurgery: a randomized, vehicle-controlled clinical trial

BACKGROUND: No long-term randomized controlled clinical trial has compared the efficacy of cryosurgery alone vs cryosurgery following fluorouracil applications for the treatment of actinic keratosis. OBJECTIVE: To determine the 6-month outcome of a 1-week course of 0.5% fluorouracil followed by cryosurgery. DESIGN: Prospective, multicenter, randomized, double-blind, vehicle-controlled clinical trial performed in community and academic outpatient clinics. PATIENTS: A total of 144 patients with 5 or more visible or palpable actinic keratoses on the face. INTERVENTIONS: Topical 0.5% fluorouracil or vehicle once daily for 7 days. At the 4-week follow-up visit, residual lesions were treated with cryosurgery. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE: Reduction in facial actinic keratoses from baseline to 4 weeks and 6 months. RESULTS: At 4 weeks, mean actinic keratosis lesion count was reduced by 62.4% in the 0.5% fluorouracil group vs 28.8% in the vehicle group (P<.001), and complete clearance was achieved in 16.7% of patients in the 0.5% fluorouracil group vs 0% of those in the vehicle group (P<.001). At 6 months, mean lesion count was reduced by 67.0% in the 0.5% fluorouracil plus cryosurgery group vs 45.6% in the vehicle plus cryosurgery group (P =.01), and significantly more patients in the 0.5% fluorouracil plus cryosurgery group than in the vehicle plus cryosurgery group had complete clearance (30% vs 7.7%; P<.001). CONCLUSIONS: A 1-week course of topical 0.5% fluorouracil before cryosurgery is significantly more effective in reducing patients' numbers of actinic keratosis lesions 6 months after treatment than cryosurgery alone. The high occurrence rate of actinic keratosis lesions at 6 months suggests a need for follow-up.     

Eccrine porocarcinoma arising in a seborrheic keratosis evaluated with dermoscopy and treated with Mohs' technique

A 78-year-old white woman returned for a routine 6-month skin cancer examination. She had a history of actinic keratosis and multiple basal cell carcinomas. She had no personal or family history of dysplastic nevi or melanoma. The patient was asymptomatic and unaware of any new or changing skin lesions. The patient had multiple lentigines, hemangiomas, and actinic and seborrheic keratoses on all sun-exposed areas. There were no less than 10 seborrheic keratoses on the right mid-back, and one was found to have a 1-cm, reddish nodule asymmetrically located within it (Figs 1 and 2). A clear papule on the left preauricular area was found on biopsy to be a basal cell carcinoma. The nodule on the back was still present 1 month later and it was felt that further evaluation was indicated. As melanoma has been reported to develop in seborrheic keratoses, we decided to examine the lesion using digital dermoscopy. With digital dermoscopy, a well-demarcated reddish nodule was asymmetrically located within a brown lesion. It blanched significantly with pressure. Within the nodule, there were dotted and irregular linear vessels (atypical vascular pattern; also known as polymorphous vascular pattern) and regular-appearing brown dots. Surrounding the reddish nodule, there were pale and pigmented, comedo-like openings, fissures, and ridges (brain-like appearance). Some of the follicular openings appeared to be within the wall of the nodule (Figs 3 and 4). Comedo-like openings, fissures, and ridges are primary dermoscopic criteria for the diagnosis of a seborrheic keratosis; however, the vascular pattern seen has not been reported in seborrheic keratosis. Due to the patient's age and the rarity of significant pathology arising in a seborrheic keratosis, a shave biopsy was performed. To our surprise, the specimen was interpreted by an experienced dermatopathologist as a well-differentiated eccrine porocarcinoma. Due to the high local recurrence rate and metastatic potential of this carcinoma, the patient was referred for Mohs' surgery. Both the basal cell carcinoma and the eccrine porocarcinoma were excised in one stage. A metastatic work-up was negative and the patient appears to be doing well.     

Ischemic fasciitis: enhanced diagnostic resolution through clinical,histopathologic and radiologic correlation in 17 cases

Ischemic fasciitis is a pseudosarcomatous nodule or mass resulting from sustained or repeated pressure and consequent ischemia of soft tissue. Fibrin and hemorrhage expand its hypocellular epicenter bordered by enlarged (atypical, ischemic) fibroblasts and reactive vascular prominence resulting in diagnostically important histologic zonation. Although classically in bedridden patients, ischemic fasciitis owing to posture‐related intermittent pressure in ambulatory adults is not well characterized; there has not been a thorough review of its presentation in ambulatory patients in the dermatology/dermatopathology literature. This article reviews the clinical, pathologic and radiologic presentation of 17 cases of ischemic fasciitis diagnosed over a 14‐year period. Eighty‐six percent of the six cases submitted by non‐dermatologists were limb girdle/trunk lesions averaging 6.7 cm in greatest diameter while 90% of the eleven lesions submitted by dermatologists were elbow and forearm lesions averaging 2.3 cm. In no case was the diagnosis anticipated pre‐biopsy by clinician or radiologist. Dermatologists submitted the majority of cases. Because ischemic fasciitis may simulate soft tissue sarcoma clinically and histologically, diagnosis helps prevent overtreatment. Zonal histopathologic structure may be shown by any form of biopsy and should motivate correlation with available radiologic studies. Importantly, determining a history of postural pressure at the site confirms the histopathologic diagnosis and avoids unnecessary excision.     

The development of actinic keratosis into invasive squamous cell carcinoma: evidence and evolving classification schemes

Actinic keratosis is an incipient form of cutaneous squamous cell carcinoma. Consequently, actinic keratoses must be treated expeditiously to forestall their downward growth. Several classification schemes have been proposed to better categorize actinic keratoses, and to guide their diagnosis and treatment. Among these approaches is the "keratinocyte intraepithelial neoplasia" (KIN) system developed by Cockerell; Goldberg's concept of the "proliferative actinic keratosis" (PAK), and Berhane's emphasis on the "inflamed actinic keratosis" (IAK). In the future, disparate classification schemes may be unified into a single pragmatic approach which accurately reflects the biological process whereby actinic keratoses devolve into invasive squamous cell carcinoma.     

Immunohistochemistry of pigmented actinic keratoses, actinic keratoses, melanomas in situ and solar lentigines with Melan-A

Distinguishing lentigo maligna from solar lentigo, and pigmented actinic keratosis can sometimes be problematic. Melan-A is an immunohistochemical marker which that can be helpful in decorating the melanocytes of pigmented lesions. A recent report has suggested that Melan-A may spuriously label nests of junctional keratinocytes, potentially leading to the misdiagnosis of melanoma in situ. We compared Melan-A immunohistochemical staining in pigmented actinic keratosis , non-pigmented actinic keratoses , melanoma in situ of lentigo maligna type and solar lentigines. We found a statistically significant increase of Melan-A staining in melanoma in situ, but no statistical difference in the number of junctional Melan-A positively staining cells, in solar lentigines, pigmented actinic keratoses, and non-pigmented actinic keratoses, respectively. In the non non-melanoma samples, the Melan-A A-positive cells located at the dermal-epidermal junction were interspersed and not observed in clusters. Increased staining with Melan-A, in an actinic keratosis, or solar lentigo should raise the possibility of a contiguous melanoma in situ.     

Evaluation of the therapeutic results of actinic keratosis treated with topical 5% fluorouracil by reflectance confocal laser microscopy: preliminary study

Topical treatment for actinic keratosis with 5% fluorouracil has a recurrence rate of 54% in 12 months of follow-up. This study analyzed thirteen actinic keratoses on the upper limbs through confocal microscopy, at the time of clinical diagnosis and after 4 weeks of treatment with fluorouracil. After the treatment was established and evidence of clinical cure was achieved, in two of the nine actinic keratoses, confocal microscopy enabled visualization of focal areas of atypical honeycomb pattern in the epidermis indicating therapeutic failure. Preliminary data suggest the use of confocal microscopy as a tool for diagnosis and therapeutic control of actinic keratosis.     

Sensitivity of diagnosis of malignant melanoma: A clinicopathologic study with a critical assessment of biopsy techniques

Although most examples of cutaneous malignant melanoma are easily recognized by their clinical appearances, in some cases this serious neoplasm may clinically simulate other less serious forms of skin cancer or benign processes. This study was undertaken to assess both the sensitivity of clinical diagnosis of cutaneous malignant melanoma and the efficacy of biopsies of clinically unsuspected melanomas in yielding specimens on which complete and accurate histologic assessments could be made. A retrospective analysis of 1784 cases of histologically proven melanomas diagnosed between 1985 and 1990 was performed in search of lesions not clinically suspected. Biopsy techniques used to sample these lesions were subjected to critique of their efficacy in yielding specimens that could be accurately diagnosed and completely assessed histologically. Of 1784 histologically proven primary cutaneous melanomas, 583 were not clinically suspected, yielding a sensitivity of 67%. Clinical diagnosis included nevi (33%), no diagnosis (17%), multiple diagnoses (13%), basal cell carcinoma (12%), keratosis (9%), and lentigo (9%) among others. The biopsy methods used to sample these lesions were shave (56%), excisional (24%), punch (11%), curettage (2%), and undetermined (6%). Eighty-six percent of shave biopsies could be accurately assessed while only 32% of punches and no curettages provided sufficient material for both definitive and complete evaluation of melanomas. Eighteen percent of specimens histologically reviewed were considered inadequate for complete evaluation. In 34%, the actual diagnosis of melanoma was uncertain because of inability to assess diagnostic features as a consequence of the biopsy technique. Melanoma may be unsuspected clinically in a significant number of cases and may be mistaken for less serious cutaneous neoplasms.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Actinic keratoses and the epidermis on which they arise

The appearance of the epidermis and epidermal autoradiographic labelling indices were compared in actinic keratoses and paralcsional skin in seventeen patients after injection of tritiated thymidine. The skin of the buttock area was also studied as a ‘non-sun exposed’ control. Labelling indices obtained from skin removed after i h were as follows: actinic keratoses 17.4%; paralesional skin 11.2%; buttock skin 5.4%. Many of the epidermal cells in the keratoses that incorporated tritiated thymidine were bizarre and not restricted to the basal or suprabasal regions but were scattered through the thickness of the epidermis. Paralesional skin also showed epidermal thickening and cytological abnormalities including the formation of multinucleate epidermal cells. These findings suggest that the development of actinic keratoses takes place in epidermis that is itself abnormal. The changes suggest that there is a gradual stepwise progression of sun damaged epidermis via the clinically obvious keratosis to squamous cell epithelioma.     

Dermatological surgery: a comparison of activity and outcomes in primary and secondary care

Background  Dermatological surgery is carried out by a variety of practitioners in primary and secondary care.
Objectives  To explore the activity and histopathological outcomes among different groups of dermatological surgeons dealing with skin cancers.
Methods  Reports for all new skin tumour specimens processed by our histopathology department over a continuous 3-month period were reviewed retrospectively.
Results  One thousand, one hundred and eleven new skin tumour specimens were identified. General practitioners (GPs) were least accurate in clinical diagnosis, with 42·8% (59/138) of their request forms including the eventual histological diagnosis, compared with 69·5% (328/472) for dermatologists (odds ratio, OR 0·33, 95% confidence interval, CI 0·22–0·48). Inappropriate procedures were most often performed by plastic surgeons, usually involving large excision biopsies for benign lesions in elderly patients [6·6% (20/305) of their specimens vs. 0% for dermatologists, exact P  <   0·001]. Excision biopsies performed by GPs had the highest rate of margin involvement by tumour of any specialty [68% (15/22) of such specimens vs. 8% (9/116) for dermatologists; OR 25·47, 95% CI 8·26–78·53]. As per National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence guidance, 13·8% (19/138) of tumours operated on by GPs should instead have been referred to secondary care for initial surgical management.
Conclusions  This study presents a strong case for dermatologists to continue to provide the lead in diagnosis of skin lesions, and in selection and execution of dermatological surgical procedures.