Roles of clinical criteria, computed tomography scan, and adrenal vein sampling in differential diagnosis of primary aldosteronism subtypes

CONTEXT: In patients with primary aldosteronism (PA), it is fundamental to distinguish between subtypes that benefit from different therapies. Computed tomography (CT) scans lack sensitivity and specificity and must be followed by adrenal venous sampling (AVS). Because AVS is not widely available, a list of clinical criteria that indicate the presence of an aldosterone-producing adenoma (APA) has been suggested. OBJECTIVE AND DESIGN: The objective of the study was to test the sensitivity and specificity of the last generation CT scans, test prospectively the usefulness of clinical criteria in the diagnosis of APA, and develop a flow chart to be used when AVS is not easily available. SETTING: Hypertensive patients referred to our hypertension unit were included in our study. PATIENTS: Seventy-one patients with confirmed PA participated in our study. Intervention: All patients had a CT scan and underwent AVS. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE: Final diagnosis of APA was the main measure. RESULTS: A total of 44 and 56% of patients were diagnosed as having an APA and a bilateral adrenal hyperplasia (BAH), respectively. Twenty percent of patients with PA displayed hypokalemia. CT scans displayed a sensitivity of 0.87 and a specificity of 0.71. The posture test displayed a lower sensitivity and specificity (0.64 and 0.70, respectively). The distribution grades of hypertension were not significantly different between APA and BAH. Biochemical criteria of high probability of APA displayed a sensitivity of 0.32 and a specificity of 0.95. CONCLUSIONS: This study underlines the central role of AVS in the subtype diagnosis of PA. The use of the clinical criteria to distinguish between APA and BAH did not display a satisfactory diagnostic power.     

Comparison of adrenal vein sampling and computed tomography in the differentiation of primary aldosteronism

Determination of the etiology of primary aldosteronism remains a diagnostic challenge. The most common types of primary aldosteronism are bilateral adrenal hyperplasia (BAH), aldosterone-producing adenomas (APA), and primary adrenal hyperplasia. Computed tomography (CT) and adrenal vein sampling (AVS) are the primary modalities used to differentiate these subtypes. The purpose of this study was to compare AVS and CT imaging of the adrenal glands in patients with hyperaldosteronism in whom CT imaging was normal or in whom focal unilateral or bilateral adrenal abnormalities were detected. The diagnosis of primary aldosteronism was made in 62 patients based on an elevated plasma aldosterone to PRA ratio and an elevated urinary aldosterone excretion rate. Thirty-eight patients had CT imaging and successful bilateral adrenal vein sampling and were included in the final analysis. AVS was considered the gold standard in determining the specific subtype of primary aldosteronism. There were 15 patients with APA, 21 patients with BAH, and 2 patients with primary adrenal hyperplasia. Plasma aldosterone was significantly higher in patients with APA (46.3 +/- 8.5 ng/dL; 1284 +/- 235 pmol/L) than in those with BAH (29.3 +/- 2.4 ng/dL; 813 +/- 11 pmol/L; P < 0.05). Plasma potassium was significantly lower in patients with APA (3.1 +/- 0.1 mmol/L) than in patients with BAH (3.5 +/- 0.1 mmol/L; P < 0.02). There was considerable overlap in the other biochemical indices (e.g. PRA and urinary aldosterone) in patients with the different subtypes. In patients with APA proven by AVS, eight had concordant findings with CT imaging, four had discordant findings, and three had normal CT imaging. In patients with BAH proven by AVS, four had concordant findings with CT imaging, eight had discordant findings, and nine had normal CT imaging. Compared with AVS, CT imaging was either inaccurate or provided no additional information in 68% of the patients with primary aldosteronism. We conclude that adrenal CT imaging is not a reliable method to differentiate primary aldosteronism. Adrenal vein sampling is essential to establish the correct diagnosis of primary aldosteronism.     

Effect of adrenocorticotropic hormone stimulation during adrenal vein sampling in primary aldosteronism

Adrenal vein sampling (AVS) is fundamental for subtype diagnosis in patients with primary aldosteronism. AVS protocols vary between centers, especially for diagnostic indices and for use of adrenocorticotropic hormone (ACTH) stimulation. We investigated the role of both continuous ACTH infusion and bolus on the performance and interpretation of AVS in a sample of 76 patients with confirmed primary aldosteronism. In 36 primary aldosteronism patients, AVS was performed both under basal conditions and after continuous ACTH infusion, and in 40 primary aldosteronism patients, AVS was performed both under basal conditions and after ACTH IV bolus. Both ACTH protocols determined an increase in the rate of successful cannulation of the adrenal veins. Both ACTH infusion and bolus determined a significant increase in selectivity index for the right adrenal vein and ACTH bolus for the left adrenal vein. Lateralization index was not significantly different after continuous ACTH infusion and IV bolus. In 88% and 78% of the patients, the diagnosis obtained was the same before and after ACTH infusion and IV bolus, respectively. However, the reproducibility of the diagnosis was reduced using less stringent criteria for successful cannulation of the adrenal veins. This study shows that ACTH use during AVS may be of help for centers with lower success rates, because a successful adrenal cannulation is more easily obtained with this protocol; moreover, this technique performs at least as well as the unstimulated strategy and in some cases may be even better. Stringent criteria for cannulation should be used to have a high consistency of the diagnosis.     

Predicting surgically remedial primary aldosteronism: role of adrenal scanning,posture testing,and adrenal vein sampling

Distinguishing surgically remedial forms from other causes of primary aldosteronism (PA) may be difficult, and it is made more challenging by the earlier detection of milder disease. The technical demands of bilateral adrenal vein sampling (AVS)-increasingly advocated for localizing a unilateral autonomous lesion (UAL)- and lack of agreed criteria for establishing unilateral autonomy, add further to the diagnostic challenge. This retrospective review of 49 hypokalemic patients with unequivocal PA (41 with surgically proven and remedial UAL, eight patients with bilateral adrenal hyperplasia) analyzes the value of computerized tomography adrenal scanning (n = 32), 4 h erect posture testing (n = 42), and AVS (n = 27) in predicting and lateralizing a surgically remedial lesion. A fall in plasma aldosterone during 4 h erect posture (positive test) occurred in 63% of patients with UAL and in none with bilateral adrenal hyperplasia. A positive posture test or computerized tomography adrenal scan (single focal macroadenoma) both had high positive predictive value (100% and 89% respectively), but low sensitivity for diagnosis of UAL. AVS, undertaken during low dose ACTH stimulation, localized the UAL in all cases (positive predictive value 100%) where the aldosterone/cortisol ratio of blood drawn from the uninvolved gland was less than that of peripheral blood (contralateral ratio <1). Biochemical severity, reflected by overnight supine plasma aldosterone, was strongly correlated with the degree of contralateral gland suppression (n = 16, r = 0.79, P < 0.001). Importantly, the AVS findings show that when bilateral access is not possible, UAL can be successfully lateralized when only one adrenal vein (the contralateral) is accessed, or the ipsilateral vein is sampled in subjects whose posture test was positive. In this series of patients with overt (hypokalemic) PA, preoperative testing successfully identified a surgically remedial lesion in 39 of 41 cases. Confirmation of the recommended diagnostic approach must now await larger prospective studies.     

New concepts in adrenal vein sampling for aldosterone in the diagnosis of primary aldosteronism

Improved diagnostic techniques and adoption of a systematic and thorough diagnostic workup can lead to identification of the surgically correctable forms of primary aldosteronism (PA) far more frequently than expected. Adrenalectomy can provide long-term normalization of blood pressure and correction of PA in most patients with an aldosterone-producing adenoma. Forms needing surgical correction are generally held to be less common than forms requiring medical therapy; however, this can be a misconception arising from the lack of systematic use of adrenal vein sampling (AVS). Currently AVS still remains the “gold standard” for identifying unilateral causes of PA that are surgically curable. The criteria for selecting patients to undergo AVS, the technique for performing AVS, and the criteria for analyzing and interpreting its results are summarized here.     

肾上腺静脉插管取血在原发性醛固酮增多症分型诊断中的意义

目的　探讨肾上腺静脉插管检查在原发性醛固酮增多症 (原醛 )分型诊断中的应用价值。方法　临床 14例明确为原醛患者 ( 11例腺瘤及 3例增生 )经肾上腺静脉插管检查 ,取双侧肾上腺静脉以及肾静脉水平下的下腔静脉采血 ,测各点醛固酮和皮质醇水平 ,并将结果与影像学检查及术后病理结果进行比较。结果　腺瘤患者插管结果与影像学检查及术后病理结果无统计学差异 ,符合率为 81 82 % ( 9/ 11) ,3例增生患者插管结果与影像学检查结果均相符。结论　肾上腺静脉插管检查在原醛的分型诊断中有较好的准确性 ,是影像学检查有疑问时可选择的良好方法。     

Prognosis of adrenalectomy guided by computed tomography versus adrenal vein sampling in patients with primary aldosteronism: A systematic review and meta‐analysis

Adrenal vein sampling (AVS) is recommended to be the gold standard for patients with unilateral subtypes of primary aldosteronism to clinical diagnosis and surgery therapy. However, it is uncertain whether AVS is better for prognosis than computed tomography (CT), which is the most widely used. Pubmed, Embase, and Cochrane Library were searched for articles with no start date restriction. The last search was conducted on Jun 15, 2021. Eligible studies compared the distinct subtypes of primary aldosteronism by AVS with CT (as a control group) and reported the prognosis at follow‐up. Evaluation of cohort studies referred to Newcastle ‐ Ottawa Quality Assessment Scale, and randomized controlled trials referred to Updated Cochrane Collaboration tool. A random‐effect model or fixed‐effect model was chosen according to the heterogeneity test. All processes were performed following the PRISMA 2020 statement. Eleven studies were identified, including 1325 patients based on AVS and 907 patients based on CT. Compared with patients guided by CT, patients who underwent AVS had an increased possibility of complete biochemical success (odds ratio [OR] 2.78, 95% CI 1.88–4.12) and a decreased chance of absent biochemical success (OR 0.23, 95% CI 0.13–0.40) at follow‐up. Nevertheless, the rate of complete clinical success (OR 1.09, 95% CI 0.89–1.35) and absent clinical success (OR 0.96, 95% CI 0.68–1.33) had no significant difference. Therefore, distinguishing subtypes by AVS for early treatment may be crucial since it can promote biochemical improvement.     

Measurement of 18-hydroxycorticosterone during adrenal vein sampling for primary aldosteronism

CONTEXT: In primary aldosteronism, elevated serum 18-hydroxycorticosterone (18OHB) suggests aldosterone-producing adenoma (APA) rather than bilateral, idiopathic hyperaldosteronism (IHA), but little is known about the relative production of 18OHB and aldosterone (A) in APAs compared with IHA. OBJECTIVES: We measured 18OHB, A, and cortisol (F) in blood from adrenal vein sampling (AVS) studies. We compared the discriminatory power of gradients in 18OHB/A and 18OHB/F ratios with A/F ratio gradients for distinguishing APA from IHA. DESIGN, SETTING, AND SUBJECTS: We measured 18OHB and A in excess serum from 23 AVS studies performed at our university hospitals. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: We calculated the ratios 18OHB/A, 18OHB/F, and A/F for all specimens, and determined the adrenal vein gradients for these ratios. RESULTS: The 18OHB/A ratios were much lower in blood draining APAs (2.17 +/- 0.62) than in blood draining the contralateral adrenals (12.96 +/- 12.76; P < 0.001) but similar to blood draining IHA adrenals (4.69 +/- 4.32; P = 0.02). In contrast, the 18OHB/F ratios were elevated in specimens from APAs (26.03 +/- 11.51) compared with IHA adrenals (9.22 +/- 5.18; P < 0.001) or the contralateral adrenals (6.23 +/- 2.97; P < 0.001). Using 18OHB/F gradient greater than two or 18OHB/A gradient less than 0.5 as criteria for lateralization, interpretations agreed with lateralizations based on A/F gradients in 21 of 23 cases. CONCLUSIONS: High serum 18OHB in APA reflects augmented production of both 18OHB and A, not disproportionate 18OHB secretion relative to A. The 18OHB/A and 18OHB/F gradients are useful adjuncts but not as reliable as A/F gradients for A lateralization during AVS.     

Identification of the etiology of primary aldosteronism with adrenal vein sampling in patients with equivocal computed tomography and magnetic resonance findings: results in 104 consecutive cases

The objectives of this study were to investigate the usefulness of adrenal vein sampling in identifying the etiology of primary aldosteronism (PA) in patients with equivocal CT and MR findings. Between 1990 and 1999, 104 referred hypertensive patients (45 women and 59 men, aged 49.6 +/- 11.6 yr) were diagnosed to have PA with inconclusive computed tomography scan and magnetic resonance results, based on established criteria. Adrenal vein sampling (AVS) for measurement of plasma aldosterone (A) and cortisol (C) levels was performed in all. Selectivity of AVS was assessed by the ratio between C levels in each adrenal vein and in the infrarenal inferior vena cava plasma (C(side)/C(IVC)). A receiver operator characteristics analysis was carried out to establish 1) the best AVS-derived index, 2) the degree of selectivity that could provide an accurate diagnosis, and 3) whether a correct diagnosis could be made from a unilaterally selective AVS. An aldosterone-producing adenoma (average diameter, 12.2 +/- 0.08 mm) was eventually diagnosed in 41 patients (39.4%) and was excluded in the rest. Adrenal vein rupture leading to partial adrenal loss occurred in 1 patient (0.9% complication rate). By assuming a cut-off value of C(side)/C(IVC) > or = 1.1, AVS was selective in 85.7% and 94.1% of cases on the right and left sides, respectively, and bilaterally in 80.6% of cases. Of all AVS-derived indexes, the A/C of one over the A/C contralateral side [(A/C)(side)/(A/C)(contralateral side)] furnished the best diagnostic accuracy. With a bilaterally selective AVS, a value of (A/C)(side)/(A/C)(contralateral side) > or = 2 provided a conclusive etiological diagnosis of PA in 79.7% of cases. At variance, no accurate diagnosis could be made from unilaterally selective AVS. AVS was feasible and safe in most PA patients with inconclusive computed tomography and magnetic resonance scans. When bilaterally selective (i.e. C(side)/C(IVC) > or = 1.1) a ratio of (A/C)(side)/(A/C)(control) > or = 2 provided the best compromise of sensitivity and false positive rate for lateralization of the etiology of PA.     

肾上腺静脉采血在原发性醛固酮增多症分型诊断中的价值

肾上腺静脉采血是近年来在我国兴起的一项新技术,本文通过不同方案,采用不同的参数及切点,分析其在原发性醛固酮增多症分型诊断中的敏感性和特异性,并与肾上腺计算机断层扫描（CT）等手段相比较,阐明其在分型诊断中的地位和价值。     

Management of primary aldosteronism in patients with adrenal hemorrhage following adrenal vein sampling: A brief review with illustrative cases

The authors describe the clinical investigation of two cases of primary aldosteronism with adrenal hemorrhage (AH) following adrenal vein sampling. A literature review was conducted regarding the medical management of primary aldosteronism in patients with AH following adrenal vein sampling. Guidelines on the management of primary aldosteronism with AH following adrenal vein sampling are lacking. The two patients were followed with serial imaging to document resolution of AH and treated medically with excellent blood pressure response. Resolution of AH was achieved, but a repeat adrenal vein sampling was deferred given the increased morbidity risk associated with a repeat procedure.     

Reassessment of the predictive value of the postural stimulation test in primary aldosteronism

Postural stimulation tests (PST) from 146 patients with primary aldosteronism were reviewed: 83 had an aldosterone-producing adenoma (APA), 48 idiopathic hyperaldosteronism (IHA), nine primary adrenal hyperplasia (PAH), and six aldosterone-producing renin-responsive adenoma (AP-RA). Plasma aldosterone and cortisol levels were measured after overnight recumbency and in response to upright posture for 2 to 4 h. The test was considered invalid in 32% of the patients because cortisol levels increased during the maneuver. As both cortisol and aldosterone are responsive to ACTH in subjects with primary aldosteronism, as well as in normal subjects, we examined their percent variation instead of the absolute values. In order to validate those tests in which cortisol increased, we subtracted the percent cortisol change from the percent aldosterone response. An aldosterone increase of less than 30% (considered a positive response for the presence of an adenoma) identified 76 of the 89 patients with an adenoma (APA and AP-RA) (sensitivity of 85%). Among the 13 false-negative tests, six were proven cases of AP-RA. In each and every case an adenoma was detected by CT/MRI scanning (or bilateral adrenal vein catheterization). Hypertension was ameliorated or cured by surgery. A postural response of less than 30% was also present in 11 of the 57 patients who did not have a discrete adenoma confirmed by imaging techniques (specificity of 81%). Among these false-positive results there were the nine cases of PAH where the hypertension could be ameliorated or cured by partial removal of hyperplastic adrenal tissue.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)