Probable geographical grouping of PVY(N) and PVY(NTN) based on sequence variation in P1 and 5'-UTR of PVY genome and methods for differentiating North American PVY(NTN)

An increasing number of countries in recent years have reported the occurrence of potato tuber necrotic ringspot disease (PTNRD), caused by tobacco veinal necrosis strain of Potato virus Y (PVY(N)), belonging to the sub-group tuber necrosis (PVY(NTN)). Methods for the differentiation of PVY(NTN), based on primer sequences often detect isolates of European (EU) type but not the North American (NA) type. To resolve this problem, the nucleotide sequence of 5'-untranslated region (5'-UTR) and the P1 gene of 11 isolates of PVY(N) and PVY(NTN) from the European Union and North America was determined. Sequence comparison and phylogenetic analysis of 5'-UTR and P1 region indicated that PVY(N) isolates from the European Union and North America formed their own separate groups. Intra-group sequence identity for all except one was over 98%, as opposed to the inter-group identity of 90%. Additionally, the PVY(NTN) isolates from the European Union and North America clustered with their respective PVY(N) isolates. This indicates a possible evolution of PVY(NTN) isolates from the PVY(N) isolates of a geographical region. With this information of regional relationships of PVY(NTN) and PVY(N) isolates, two approaches were developed based on a competitive RT-PCR and a restriction pattern, for the differentiation of NA-PVY(NTN) from the local PVY(N) and from EU-PVY(NTN). Thus sequencing of the P1 gene and use of competitive RT-PCR approach could be applicable for determining the possible origin of new occurrences of PVY(NTN) from other geographical regions.     

Single-step RT real-time PCR for sensitive detection and discrimination of Potato virus Y isolates

Potato virus Y (PVY) has a worldwide distribution and infects several economically important crops from the Solanaceae family. The emergence and spread of the PVYNTN strain, which is the causative agent of potato tuber necrotic ringspot disease (PTNRD), has lead to large economic losses and highlighted the need for accurate discrimination of the different PVY strains. Detection and differentiation of PVY isolates is mainly based on a combination of ELISA, RT-PCR and bioassays; however, PVYNTN isolates are particularly difficult to differentiate from standard PVYN without the use of time-consuming bioassays. A strong correlation has been identified previously between the ability to induce PTNRD and the presence of a recombination point in the virus coat protein. An RT real-time PCR assay has been developed to enable detection of isolates with the recombination point, therefore, enabling rapid differentiation between potentially tuber necrotic PVYNTN isolates and standard PVYN isolates. The assay is also able to detect the presence of PVYO isolates. To aid with routine testing, immuno-capture and post-ELISA virus release were introduced; when coupled with RT real-time PCR the sensitivity of the assays were up to seven orders of magnitude higher than ELISA. The assay was shown to be a suitable method for rapid large-scale diagnostic testing of PVY in different types of plant material including tubers, and specific screening for potentially tuber necrotic recombinant isolates.     

Detection of different strains of Potato virus Y and their mixed infections using competitive fluorescent RT-PCR

A competitive fluorescent RT-PCR assay (CF RT-PCR) was developed for the rapid and reliable detection and discrimination of the two most common strains of Potato virus Y (PVY) found in potato (necrotic and ordinary). The assay incorporates two strain specific primers labelled with fluorescent labels, used in conjunction with a universal PVY primer. The strain specific primers compete for the same annealing site which further increases specificity. Discrimination is conferred by the fluorescent labels; green PCR products for PVY(O) and red for PVY(N), whilst mixed infections are detected as orange PCR products without the need for staining agarose gels. The assay can be scaled up for the processing of 96 samples simultaneously, with the detection of PCR products directly using a fluorescent microtitre plate reader. The assay successfully discriminated between 20 isolates of PVY tested, and could be used for the direct detection of PVY in potato tubers.     

Specific detection of the PVY(N)-W variant of Potato virus Y

PVY(N)-W is one of the variant populations of Potato virus Y (PVY). This variant is of concern in seed potato production and requires a specific diagnosis since it induces more or less symptomless infections and is not detectable easily in field inspections. Moreover, this variant is serologically indistinguishable from the common strain PVY(O). This study describes a simple and specific molecular detection test for the PVY(N)-W variant using a PCR protocol based on the recombinant point within the HC-Pro/P3 region of PVY(N) variants (PVY(NTN), PVY(N)-W). To avoid both detection of recombinant PVY(NTN) and PVY(N)-W isolates, a forward PVY(N)-like primer located in the HC-Pro region coupled to a reverse PVY(O)-like primer located in the NIa region was designed to amplify a specific PCR product of 4114 nt from PVY(N)-W isolates. This technique was assessed on 41 PVY reference and field isolates. Only isolates referenced as PVY(N)-W were amplified and gave the expected PCR product of 4114 nt, whereas no band was obtained from PVY(N), PVY(NTN) or PVY(O) isolates. In conclusion, this PVY(N)-W diagnosis tool is rapid, easy-to-use and suitable for large-scale testing in laboratories of seed potato certification.     

A single nucleotide polymorphism-based technique for specific characterization of YO and YN isolates of Potato virus Y (PVY)

One of the most important properties used to classify Potato virus Y (PVY) isolates is their ability to induce (PVY(N)) or not (PVY(O)) veinal necrosis symptoms on the indicator host plant Nicotiana tabacum cv. Xanthi. As an alternative to biological assays, several serological and molecular detection tools have been developed for PVY detection and characterization and these have evolved as our knowledge of PVY has improved. However, the assays that have been previously published are all based on the use of neutral markers (antigenic determinants, sequence data, recombination sites or restriction enzyme cleavage sites), which are unlinked to the biological property being characterized (e.g. veinal necrosis). Using the recently identified molecular determinants of the tobacco leaf necrosis symptom induced by PVY(N) isolates, a one-step fluorescent [TaqMan] RT-PCR assay, based on a single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) linked to the necrosis property of PVY isolates, has been designed. This assay reliably detects and distinguishes PVY(N) and PVY(O) isolates. The method is simple (leaf soak extraction process, gel-free, no post-PCR manipulations), rapid (96 tests in less than 3h from plants sampling to diagnostic results), sensitive (threshold in a range of 10(4)-10(5) PVY copies), reliable (correctly assigns 42 PVY isolates in their respective group) and allows co-detection of mixed samples containing close to equivalent PVY(N) and PVY(O) quantities. All these characteristics suggest that the newly developed SNP assay could be used to reliably classify PVY isolates, as a substitute for biological assays performed on N. tabacum cv. Xanthi.     

Development of a multiplex AmpliDet RNA assay for simultaneous detection and typing of potato virus Y isolates.

A multiplex AmpliDet RNA assay was developed for the specific detection of potato virus Y (PVY), and for the differentiation of the PVY^N, PVY^O/C strains and the tuber necrotic isolates (PVY^NTN). The assay is based on the generic amplification of a region within the coat protein coding region of all known PVY isolates by nucleic acid sequence-based amplification (NASBA™) and strain-specific detection by molecular beacons. PVY^NTN-specific diagnosis is achieved by detecting PVY^N and PVY^O-specific sequences flanking a recombination site that is associated with the tuber necrotic pathotype. The assay exhibited good specificity toward the various PVY strains in both single and mixed infections. The technique was validated by the use of 47 PVY isolates originating from six countries. The results of the AmpliDet RNA assay were identical or consistent with those of biological characterisation in the decisive majority of cases.     

Within plant distribution of Potato Virus Y in hairy nightshade (Solanum sarrachoides): an inoculum source affecting PVY aphid transmission

Potato virus Y (PVY) is vectored by several potato-colonizing and non-colonizing aphid species in a non-persistent manner and has a wide host range. It occurs naturally in several plant families. Myzus persicae and Macrosiphum euphorbiae are the most efficient potato-colonizing aphid vectors of PVY. Rhopalosiphum padi, a cereal aphid that migrates in large numbers through potato fields during the middle of the growing season, does not colonize potato plants but can transmit PVY. Hairy nightshade, Solanum sarrachoides, a prevalent annual solanaceous weed in the Pacific Northwest (PNW) of the United States, is an alternative host for PVY and a preferred host for M. persicae and M. euphorbiae. Hence, hairy nightshade plants might play an important role as an inoculum source in the epidemiology of PVY. We looked at titre accumulation and distribution of PVY(O), PVY(N:O) and PVY(NTN) in S. sarrachoides and potato after aphid inoculation with M. persicae and studied the transmission of PVY(O) and PVY(NTN), by M. persicae, M. euphorbiae and R. padi from hairy nightshade to potato plants. Virus titre at different positions on the plant was similar in S. sarrachoides and potato plants with strains PVY(O) and PVY(N:O). Titres of PVY(NTN) were similar in S. sarrachoides and potato but differences in titre were observed at different positions within the plant depending on the plant phenology. Percentage transmission of PVY(NTN) by M. persicae and M. euphorbiae was twice as high (46 and 34%, respectively) from hairy nightshade to potato than from potato to potato (20 and 14%). Percentage transmission of PVY(O) by M. persicae and M. euphorbiae was not affected by the inoculum source. No effect of the inoculum source was observed in the transmission of either PVY strain by R. padi. These results show that hairy nightshade may be an equal or better virus reservoir than potato and thus, important in the epidemiology of PVY.     

Discussion paper: The naming of Potato virus Y strains infecting potato

Summary Potato virus Y (PVY) strain groups are based on host response and resistance gene interactions. The strain groups PVY^O, PVY^C and PVY^N are well established for the isolates infecting potato in the field. A switch in the emphasis from host response to nucleotide sequence differences in the virus genomes, detection of isolates recombining sequences of different strains, and the need to recognize isolates that cause necrotic symptoms in potato tubers have led to the assignment of new acronyms, especially to isolates of the PVY^N strain group. This discussion paper proposes that any newly found isolates should be described within the context of the original strain groups based on the original methods of distinguishing strains (i.e., tobacco and potato assays involving use of ‘differential’ potato cultivars). Additionally, sequence characterization of the complete genomes of isolates is highly recommended. However, it is acceptable to amend the names of PVY isolates with additional, specific codes to show that the isolate differs at the molecular, serological or phenotypic level from the typical strains within a strain group. The new isolates should preferably not be named using geographical, cultivar, or place-association designations. Since many new variants of PVY are being discovered, any new static classification system will be meaningless for the time being. A more systematic investigation and characterization of PVY from potato at the biological and molecular levels should eventually result in a biologically meaningful genetic strain concept. Correspondence: R. P. Singh, Potato Research Centre, Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada, P.O. Box 20280, Fredericton, New Brunswick, Canada E3B 4Z7     

Differentiation of Potato virus Y strains using improved sets of diagnostic PCR-primers

Potato virus Y (PVY) is one of the most important viruses of potato world-wide, several strain groups are recognized. In the past two decades, novel PVY variants have appeared causing necrotic symptoms on potato tubers. Implicated are two groups of recombinant strains: PVY^NW and PVY^NTN, and NA-PVY^NTN. While the first two are recombinants between PVY-N- and O-strains the latter is a recombinant between an N-strain and an unknown PVY strain or other Potyvirus. Available biological and molecular data on PVY suggest that classification of PVY strains has to be revised. Some drawbacks have been found with recently published primers used in RT-PCR based differentiation of PVY strains as some defined isolates could not be identified correctly. Consequently we developed new primers using both recently available sequences and newly generated complete sequences of PVY strains. The reliability of these newly developed primers and procedures was successfully demonstrated on nearly 100 biologically and serologically characterised PVY isolates.     

Nucleotide sequences of 5'-terminal parts of coat protein genes of various isolates of NTN strain of potato virus Y

Sequences of the first 300 nucleotides of coat protein (CP) genes of 7 isolates of NTN strain of potato virus Y (PVY, PVY(NTN)) were determined and compared with analogous published sequences of various isolates and strains of PVY. The sequence identity among the sequenced isolates ranged from 96 to 100%. The differences were found at different positions. The nucleotide sequence of this part of CP gene seems to be very conservative among the isolates tested that means that PVY(NTN) is the evolutionary youngest among all PVY strains.     

Whole genome characterization of Potato virus Y isolates collected in the western USA and their comparison to isolates from Europe and Canada

Summary. Potato virus Y (PVY) is a serious potato pathogen that affects potato seed and commercial production crops. In recent decades, novel PVY strains have been described that cause necrotic symptoms on tobacco foliage and/or potato tubers. The major PVY strains that affect potato include PVY^O and PVY^N, which have distinct serotypes that can be differentiated by immunoassay. Other economically important strain variants are derived from recombination events, including variants that cause tuber necrotic symptoms (PVY^NTN) and PVY^O serotypes that cause tobacco veinal necrosis (PVY^N-W, PVY^N:O). Although the PVY^NTN and PVY^N-W variants were first reported in Europe, apparently similar strains have been appearing in North America. Confirmation of the existence of these recombinant strains in North America is important, as is whether they spread from a common source or were derived by independent recombination. Whole genome sequencing can be used to positively identify strain variants and begin to address the issue of origins. Symptomology, serology, RT-PCR, and partial sequencing of the coat protein region were used to identify isolates of the PVY^NTN, PVY^N, PVY^NA-N, and PVY^N:O for whole-genome sequencing. Sequencing confirmed the presence of PVY^NTN and PVY^N isolates that were >99% identical to European sequences deposited in GenBank in the 1990’s. Sequences of the PVY^NA-N and PVY^N:O types were 99.0% and 99.5% identical to known sequences, respectively. There was no indication that recombinant strains PVY^NTN or PVY^N:O had different parental origins than recombinant strains previously sequenced. This is the first confirmation by whole-genome sequencing that “European”-type strain variants of PVY^N and PVY^NTN are present in North America, and the first reported full-length sequence of a tuber necrotic isolate of PVY^N:O.