Shear Wave Speed Estimation Using Reverberant Shear Wave Fields: Implementation and Feasibility Studies

Elastography is a modality that estimates tissue stiffness and, thus, provides useful information for clinical diagnosis. Attention has focused on the measurement of shear wave propagation; however, many methods assume shear wave propagation is unidirectional and aligned with the lateral imaging direction. Any deviations from the assumed propagation result in biased estimates of shear wave speed. To address these challenges, directional filters have been applied to isolate shear waves with different propagation directions. Recently, a new method was proposed for tissue stiffness estimation involving creation of a reverberant shear wave field propagating in all directions within the medium. These reverberant conditions lead to simple solutions, facile implementation and rapid viscoelasticity estimation of local tissue. In this work, this new approach based on reverberant shear waves was evaluated and compared with another well-known elastography technique using two calibrated elastic and viscoelastic phantoms. Additionally, the clinical feasibility of this technique was analyzed by assessing shear wave speed in human liver and breast tissues, in vivo. The results indicate that it is possible to estimate the viscoelastic properties in each scanned medium. Moreover, a better approach to estimation of shear wave speed was obtained when only the phase information was taken from the reverberant waves, which is equivalent to setting all magnitudes within the bandpass equal to unity: an idealization of a perfectly isotropic reverberant shear wave field.     

Fast Shear Compounding Using Robust 2-D Shear Wave Speed Calculation and Multi-directional Filtering

A fast shear compounding method was developed in this study using only one shear wave push-detect cycle, such that the shear wave imaging frame rate is preserved and motion artifacts are minimized. The proposed method is composed of the following steps: 1. Applying a comb-push to produce multiple differently angled shear waves at different spatial locations simultaneously; 2. Decomposing the complex shear wave field into individual shear wave fields with differently oriented shear waves using a multi-directional filter; 3. Using a robust 2-D shear wave speed calculation to reconstruct 2-D shear elasticity maps from each filter direction; and 4. Compounding these 2-D maps from different directions into a final map. An inclusion phantom study showed that the fast shear compounding method could achieve comparable performance to conventional shear compounding without sacrificing the imaging frame rate. A multi-inclusion phantom experiment showed that the fast shear compounding method could provide a full field-of-view, 2-D and compounded shear elasticity map with three types of inclusions clearly resolved and stiffness measurements showing excellent agreement to the nominal values.     

Assessment of the Cervix in Pregnant Women Using Shear Wave Elastography: A Feasibility Study

The quantitative assessment of the cervix is crucial for the estimation of pre-term delivery risk and the prediction of the success of labor induction. We conducted a cross-sectional study using shear wave elastography based on the supersonic shear imaging technique. The shear wave speed (SWS) of the lower anterior part of the cervix was quantified over an 8-mm region of interest in 157 pregnant women. Cervical SWS is slightly but significantly reduced in patients diagnosed with pre-term labor and in patients who actually delivered pre-term.     

Non-invasive Assessment of Liver Fibrosis in a Rat Model: Shear Wave Elasticity Imaging Versus Real-Time Elastography

The purpose of this study was to investigate the diagnostic value of shear wave elasticity imaging (SWEI) and real-time elastography (RTE) in liver fibrosis induced by dimethylnitrosamine (DMN) and to compare the accuracy of these methods. Seventy male Wistar rats given a single intra-peritoneal injection of DMN and 10 control rats given a saline injection underwent SWEI and RTE to determine their shear wave velocity (V_s) and liver fibrosis (LF) index, respectively. Correlations between V_s or the LF index and histologic stage of liver fibrosis (S0–S4) were analyzed, and the diagnostic values of the techniques were assessed using a receiver operating characteristic curve. A positive correlation was found between V_s and stage of liver fibrosis (r = 0.947, p < 0.001) and between LF index and stage (S) of liver fibrosis (r = 0.662, p < 0.001). For V_s, the areas under the receiver operating characteristic curve for the diagnosis of fibrosis, S ≥ S1, S ≥ S2, S ≥ S3 and S = S4, were 0.983, 0.995, 0.999 and 0.964, respectively; for the LF index, the values were 0.871, 0.887, 0.761 and 0.839, respectively (all p < 0.001). V_s and the LF index values in rats with severe inflammatory activity were significantly higher than those in controls (p < 0.001). In conclusion, positive correlations exist between V_s or the LF index and the severity of liver fibrosis in rats. V_s is more accurate than the LF index in predicting liver fibrosis in rats. However, severe inflammatory activity may reduce the accuracy of both techniques.     

Performance of Shear Wave Elastography in Delineating the Radiofrequency Ablation Boundary: An in Vivo experiment

This study was aimed at exploring the cutoff value of Young's modulus of ablated tissue and the optimal scale at which shear wave elastography (SWE) can delineate the ablation boundary. The livers of 30 rabbits were radiofrequency (RF) ablated, and ultrasonic imaging, including SWE and contrast-enhanced ultrasound (CEUS), was performed. The ablation boundary in the SWE image was located using CEUS, and the SWE parameters of the boundary were measured to calculate the cutoff value of Young's modulus. The cutoff value of the ablated tissue was 48–50 kPa 2 h to 28 d post-ablation. The regions of increased stiffness in SWE images at a scale of 0–50 kPa overlapped well with the non-enhanced regions of CEUS images in 88% of specimens. Therefore, elasticity values differed significantly between ablated and non-ablated tissues, and the cutoff value for Young's modulus differentiated these tissues. SWE delineated the ablation boundary well at the optimal SWE scale with respect to the cutoff value.     

Non-invasive Assessment of Changes in Muscle Injury by Ultrasound Shear Wave Elastography: An Experimental Study in Contusion Model

The present study investigated the potential of ultrasound shear wave elastography (SWE) in assessment of muscle stiffness in muscle injury. SWE was performed on the injured muscle in 30 New Zealand rabbits that were randomly assigned to three groups: the contusion group, which was not treated with an efficient therapeutic strategy after muscle injury; the treatment group, which was treated with a therapeutic scheme after muscle injury; and the healthy group, which was not injured and served as a control. Both the mean Young's modulus (E_mean) and the maximum Young's modulus (E_max) were obtained pre-injury and 0.5, 1, 3, 5, 7, 14 and 28 d post-injury. At these time points, a rabbit in each group was randomly selected for biopsy for histopathological observation as well as comparison with Young's modulus. Eventually, all muscle tissues were collected for histologic analysis of collagen fiber formation. The contusion group had the highest Young's modulus, followed by the treatment group and then the healthy group (p < 0.05). In both the contusion and treatment groups, E_mean and E_max gradually increased within 1–3 d after injury, followed by a gradual decrease. Compared with the healthy group, histopathologic analysis of the contusion and treatment groups revealed the myofibril destruction process, inflammatory reaction and myofibril regeneration. The amount of collagen fibers in the contusion group was maximal compared with the treated and healthy groups (p?=?0.001 and p < 0.001, respectively). There were more collagen fibers in the treatment group than in the healthy group (p?=?0.003). The abundance of collagen fibers was positively correlated with the value of Young's modulus (E_mean: r?=?0.706, p < 0.001; E_max: r?=?0.761, p < 0.001). Thus, SWE can be used to detect pathologic changes in injured muscle and to monitor therapeutic effects.     

Cardiac Shear Wave Velocity Detection in the Porcine Heart

Cardiac muscle stiffness can potentially be estimated non-invasively with shear wave elastography. Shear waves are present on the septal wall after mitral and aortic valve closure, thus providing an opportunity to assess stiffness in early systole and early diastole. We report on the shear wave recordings of 22 minipigs with high-frame-rate echocardiography. The waves were captured with 4000 frames/s using a programmable commercial ultrasound machine. The wave pattern was extracted from the data through a local tissue velocity estimator based on one-lag autocorrelation. The wave propagation velocity was determined with a normalized Radon transform, resulting in median wave propagation velocities of 2.2 m/s after mitral valve closure and 4.2 m/s after aortic valve closure. Overall the velocities ranged between 0.8 and 6.3 m/s in a 95% confidence interval. By dispersion analysis we found that the propagation velocity only mildly increased with shear wave frequency.     

Measurement of Liver Stiffness Using Shear Wave Elastography in a Rat Model: Factors Impacting Stiffness Measurement with Multiple- and Single-Tracking-Location Techniques

The clinical use of elastography for monitoring fibrosis progression is challenged by the subtle changes in liver stiffness associated with early-stage fibrosis and the comparatively large variance in stiffness estimates provided by elastography. Single-tracking-location (STL) shear wave elasticity imaging (SWEI) is an ultrasound elastography technique previously found to provide improved estimate precision compared with multiple-tracking-location (MTL) SWEI. Because of the improved precision, it is reasonable to expect that STL-SWEI would provide improved ability to differentiate liver fibrosis stage compared with MTL-SWEI. However, this expectation has not been previously challenged rigorously. In this work, the performance of STL- and MTL-SWEI in the setting of a rat model of liver fibrosis is characterized, and the advantages of STL-SWEI in staging fibrosis are explored. The purpose of this study was to determine what advantages, if any, arise from using STL-SWEI instead of MTL-SWEI in the characterization of fibrotic liver. Thus, the ability of STL-SWEI to differentiate livers at various METAVIR fibrosis scores, for ex vivo postmortem measurements, is explored. In addition, we examined the effect of the common confounding factor of fluid versus solid boundary conditions in SWEI experiments. Sprague-Dawley rats were treated with carbon tetrachloride over several weeks to produce liver disease of varying severity. STL and MTL stiffness measurements were performed ex vivo and compared with the METAVIR scores from histological analysis and the duration of treatment. A strong association was observed between liver stiffness and weeks of treatment with the liver toxin carbon tetrachloride. Direct comparison of STL- and MTL-SWEI measurements revealed no significant difference in ability to differentiate fibrosis stages based on SWEI mean values. However, image interquartile range was greatly improved in the case of STL-SWEI, compared with MTL-SWEI, at small beam spacing.     

Evaluating the Benefit of Elevated Acoustic Output in Harmonic Motion Estimation in Ultrasonic Shear Wave Elasticity Imaging

Harmonic imaging techniques have been applied in ultrasonic elasticity imaging to obtain higher-quality tissue motion tracking data. However, harmonic tracking can be signal-to-noise ratio and penetration depth limited during clinical imaging, resulting in decreased yield of successful shear wave speed measurements. A logical approach is to increase the source pressure, but the in situ pressures used in diagnostic ultrasound have been subject to a de facto upper limit based on the Food and Drug Administration guideline for the mechanical index (MI <1.9). A recent American Institute of Ultrasound in Medicine report concluded that an in situ MI up to 4.0 could be warranted without concern for increased risk of cavitation in non-fetal tissues without gas bodies if there were a concurrent clinical benefit. This work evaluates the impact of using an elevated MI in harmonic motion tracking for hepatic shear wave elasticity imaging. The studies indicate that high-MI harmonic tracking increased shear wave speed estimation yield by 27% at a focal depth of 5?cm, with larger yield increase in more difficult-to-image patients. High-MI tracking improved harmonic tracking data quality by increasing the signal-to-noise ratio and decreasing jitter in the tissue motion data. We conclude that there is clinical benefit to use of elevated acoustic output in shear wave tracking, particularly in difficult-to-image patients.     

Beyond Cervical Length: A Pilot Study of Ultrasonic Attenuation for Early Detection of Preterm Birth Risk

The purpose of this study was to determine whether cervical ultrasonic attenuation could identify women at risk of spontaneous preterm birth. During pregnancy, women (n = 67) underwent from one to five transvaginal ultrasonic examinations to estimate cervical ultrasonic attenuation and cervical length. Ultrasonic data were obtained with a Zonare ultrasound system with a 5- to 9-MHz endovaginal transducer and processed offline. Cervical ultrasonic attenuation was lower at 17–21 wk of gestation in the SPTB group (1.02 dB/cm-MHz) than in the full-term birth groups (1.34 dB/cm-MHz) (p = 0.04). Cervical length was shorter (3.16 cm) at 22–26 wk in the SPTB group than in the women delivering full term (3.68 cm) (p = 0.004); cervical attenuation was not significantly different at this time point. These findings suggest that low attenuation may be an additional early cervical marker to identify women at risk for SPTB.     

Assessment of Structural Heterogeneity and Viscosity in the Cervix Using Shear Wave Elasticity Imaging: Initial Results from a Rhesus Macaque Model

Shear wave elasticity imaging has shown promise in evaluation of the pregnant cervix. Changes in shear wave group velocity have been attributed exclusively to changes in stiffness. This assumes homogeneity within the region of interest and purely elastic tissue behavior. However, the cervix is structurally/microstructurally heterogeneous and viscoelastic. We therefore developed strategies to investigate these complex tissue properties. Shear wave elasticity imaging was performed ex vivo on 14 unripened and 13 misoprostol-ripened cervix specimens from rhesus macaques. After tests of significant and uniform shear wave displacement, as well as reliability of estimates, group velocity decreased significantly from the distal (vaginal) to proximal (uterine) end of unripened, but not ripened, specimens. Viscosity was quantified by the slope of the phase velocity versus frequency. Dispersion was observed in both groups (median: 5.5 m/s/kHz, interquartile range: 1.5–12.0 m/s/kHz), also decreasing toward the proximal cervix. This work suggests that comprehensive assessment of complex tissues such as cervix requires consideration of structural heterogeneity and viscosity.     

Quantitative Assessment of Healthy Skin Elasticity: Reliability and Feasibility of Shear Wave Elastography

The goal of this study was to investigate the reliability and feasibility of shear wave elastography by assessing the elasticity of the healthy skin of 40 volunteers. Young's moduli for bilateral fingers, forearms, anterior chest (sternum), and anterior abdomen were determined with both transverse and longitudinal sectional measurements. Reliability of measurements was evaluated using intra- and inter-class correlation coefficients with two observers. Our results revealed that the elastic modulus values of the skin between symmetric parts of fingers and forearms did not statistically different. No differences were found between the transverse and longitudinal sections of forearms, anterior chest, and abdomen (p > 0.05), except for middle fingers (p = 0.004). Inter-observer and intra-observer repeatability (inter- and intra-class correlation coefficients) varied from moderate to excellent depending on the skin site (0.62–0.91). In conclusion, shear wave elastography reached a good consistency in measuring healthy skin elasticity. Further studies are needed to provide more information on the factors that influence the reliability of shear wave elastography measurements in both healthy and diseased skin.     

AdipoScan: A Novel Transient Elastography-Based Tool Used to Non-Invasively Assess Subcutaneous Adipose Tissue Shear Wave Speed in Obesity

We describe a novel device called the AdipoScan that was adapted from the FibroScan to specifically assess shear wave speed (SWS) in human abdominal subcutaneous adipose tissue (scAT). Measurement reproducibility was assessed on tissue-mimicking phantoms with and without repositioning, with resultant coefficients of variation of 1% and 0%, respectively, as well as in vivo (14% and 7%, respectively). The applicability of the AdipoScan was tested on 19 non-obese volunteers, and a scAT thickness >2 cm was found to be mandatory to perform a valid measurement. Abdominal scAT SWS was assessed in 73 severely obese subjects, all candidates for bariatric surgery. Subcutaneous AT SWS was positively associated with scAT fibrosis and obesity-related co-morbidities such as hypertension, glycemic status, dyslipidemia and liver dysfunction. These results suggest that the AdipoScan could be a useful non-invasive tool to evaluate scAT fibrosis and metabolic complications in obesity. Further investigation is required to evaluate the relevance of using the AdipoScan to predict patient weight trajectories and metabolic outcomes after bariatric surgery.     

剪切波技术对先兆子痫患者胎盘弹性的初步研究

目的：探讨剪切波弹性成像（shear wave elastography,SWE）技术定量分析先兆子痫患者胎盘弹性的临床应用价值。 方法：选取单胎妊娠妇女76例（先兆子痫组22例，健康对照组54例），常规测量脐动脉、双侧子宫动脉血流动力学参数（S/D、PI、RI），SWE测量胎盘中央胎儿面、中央母体面、边缘胎儿面、边缘母体面四个不同区域弹性模量值。根据胎盘四个区域平均弹性模量值绘制ROC曲线，获取诊断先兆子痫的最佳临界值，计算敏感性、特异性、阳性预测值、阴性预测值。 结果：先兆子痫组胎盘中央胎儿面、中央母体面、边缘胎儿面、边缘母体面弹性模量值分别为：8.54±3.74KPa、9.46±3.64KPa、8.48±2.66KPa、9.25±3.00KPa，健康对照组弹性模量值分别为：6.38±1.87KPa、6.51±1.52KPa、6.37±1.55KPa、6.48±1.58KPa，先兆子痫组四个区域弹性模量值均高于健康对照组，差异有统计学意义（P＜0.05）。两组资料胎盘四个区域之间弹性模量值差异无统计学意义（P＞0.05）。胎盘弹性模量平均值预测先兆子痫的ROC曲线下面积为0.754，界值为8.19KPa，敏感性、特异性、阳性预测值、阴性预测值分别为64%、96%、88%、87%，符合率87%。胎盘弹性模量值与双侧子宫动脉血流动力学参数低度相关（P＜0.05），与脐动脉血流动力学参数无显著相关性（P＞0.05）。 结论：先兆子痫孕妇胎盘硬度较正常孕妇高，SWE技术可以定量获得胎盘组织硬度，有助于评估先兆子痫孕妇胎盘功能。     

剪切波弹性成像检测肌肉骨骼系统的应用进展

剪切波弹性成像技术可评估肌肉、肌腱、韧带与神经等组织内部力学特性的变化,对早期诊断以上组织疾病及制定治疗方案具有重要的参考价值。本文综述了剪切波超声弹性技术的成像原理及其在肌肉骨骼系统的应用研究进展,并对此技术的前景进行展望。     

Quantitative Viscoelasticity Mapping of Human Liver Using Supersonic Shear Imaging: Preliminary In Vivo Feasability Study

This paper demonstrates the feasibility of in vivo quantitative mapping of liver viscoelasticity using the concept of supersonic shear wave imaging. This technique is based on the combination of a radiation force induced in tissues by focused ultrasonic beams and a very high frame rate ultrasound imaging sequence capable of catching in real time the transient propagation of resulting shear waves. The local shear wave velocity is recovered using a dedicated time-of-flight estimation technique and enables the 2-D quantitative mapping of shear elasticity. This imaging modality is performed using a conventional ultrasound probe during a standard intercostal ultrasonographic examination. Three supersonic shear imaging (SSI) sequences are applied successively in the left, middle and right parts of the 2-D ultrasonographic image. Resulting shear elasticity images in the three regions are concatenated to provide the final image covering the entire region-of-interest. The ability of the SSI technique to provide a quantitative and local estimation of liver shear modulus with a millimetric resolution is proven in vivo on 15 healthy volunteers. Liver moduli extracted from in vivo data from healthy volunteers are consistent with those reported in the literature (Young's modulus ranging from 4 to 7.5 kPa). Moreover, liver stiffness estimation using the SSI mode is shown to be fast (less than one second), repeatable (5.7% standard deviation) and reproducible (6.7% standard deviation). This technique, used as a complementary tool for B-mode ultrasound, could complement morphologic information both for fibrosis staging and hepatic lesions imaging (E-mail: jl.gennisson@espci.fr).     

Shear wave elasticity imaging: a new ultrasonic technology of medical diagnostics

Shear wave elasticity imaging (SWEI) is a new approach to imaging and characterizing tissue structures based on the use of shear acoustic waves remotely induced by the radiation force of a focused ultrasonic beam. SWEI provides the physician with a virtual “finger” to probe the elasticity of the internal regions of the body. In SWEI, compared to other approaches in elasticity imaging, the induced strain in the tissue can be highly localized, because the remotely induced shear waves are attenuated fully within a very limited area of tissue in the vicinity of the focal point of a focused ultrasound beam. SWEI may add a new quality to conventional ultrasonic imaging or magnetic resonance imaging. Adding shear elasticity data (“palpation information”) by superimposing color-coded elasticity data over ultrasonic or magnetic resonance images may enable better differentiation of tissues and further enhance diagnosis. This article presents a physical and mathematical basis of SWEI with some experimental results of pilot studies proving feasibility of this new ultrasonic technology. A theoretical model of shear oscillations in soft biological tissue remotely induced by the radiation force of focused ultrasound is described. Experimental studies based on optical and magnetic resonance imaging detection of these shear waves are presented. Recorded spatial and temporal profiles of propagating shear waves fully confirm the results of mathematical modeling. Finally, the safety of the SWEI method is discussed, and it is shown that typical ultrasonic exposure of SWEI is significantly below the threshold of damaging effects of focused ultrasound.     

宫颈组织剪切波弹性成像技术对流产及早产的预测价值

目的 分析宫颈组织剪切波弹性成像技术预测流产及早产风险的临床应用价值.方法 随机选取我院行孕前检查的孕妇120例,行经阴道超声剪切波E成像技术检查,其中28例晚期流产及早产妊娠结局的孕妇设为观察组,其余92例纳入对照组,分析比较两组患者宫颈情况、不同孕周剪切波速度及宫颈组织超声弹性数值(杨氏模量)等.结果 观察组孕妇宫...     

Thyroid Nodules and Shear Wave Elastography: A New Tool in Thyroid Cancer Detection

This study determines the performance of virtual touch imaging quantification (VTIQ), a non-invasive shear wave elastography method for measuring thyroid nodule (TN) stiffness, in distinguishing benign from malignant TNs. This prospective study evaluates 707 TNs in 676 patients with fine-needle aspiration biopsy (FNAB). Before FNAB, both conventional B-mode ultrasound and shear wave elastography were performed. Surgical resection was recommended for FNAB results that were not clearly benign. Surgical pathology confirmed 82 malignant TNs. The receiver operating curve identified a single cut-off of 3.54 m/s as the maximum shear wave velocity (SWV) for predicting thyroid cancer (TC). The sensitivity and specificity were 79.27% and 71.52%, respectively. Positive predictive value (PPV) was 26.75% and negative predictive value (NPV) was 96.34%. Compared with B-mode US features for predicting malignancy, SWV ≥3.54 m/s has a higher sensitivity, specificity, PPV and NPV. TN stiffness measured by VTIQ-generated shear wave elastography is an independent predictor of TC.