Impact of different inhibitor reactivities with commercial factor VIII concentrates on thrombin generation

In order to describe the haemostatic role of a variation in inhibitor reactivity with different factor VIII (FVIII) concentrates, we have compared inhibitor titres against a panel of FVIII concentrates and correlated titre with the capacity to inhibit thrombin generation. Three plasma-derived concentrates were tested in vitro in mixing experiments with inhibitor plasmas from 11 patients with severe haemophilia A: Fanhdi, which contains von Willebrand factor (VWF) with a final ratio of approximately 1:1 (VWF IU per IU FVIII:C); Haemate-P with a ratio of 2.5:1 and Hemofil-M containing only trace amounts of VWF. In addition, the recombinant FVIII concentrate Kogenate Bayer containing no VWF was included. Inhibitor titres and the capacity to generate thrombin were measured. A statistically significant difference in measured titres was found with the highest titres recorded against Hemofil-M. The inhibitor titres needed to inhibit 50% maximum thrombin generation were the lowest for Kogenate Bayer and the highest and similar for Fanhdi and Haemate-P with intermediate titres needed for inhibition of Hemofil-M. In this study, the thrombin generation assay provides additional indications for the role of VWF in the treatment of patients with inhibitors. The VWF-containing concentrates Fanhdi and Haemate-P, added to FVIII-deficient plasma with the presence of inhibitor, generate more thrombin than do the purified concentrates Hemofil-M and Kogenate Bayer.     

von Willebrand factor in factor VIII concentrates protects against neutralization by factor VIII antibodies of haemophilia A patients

We investigated the neutralization activity of factor VIII (FVIII) antibodies of 12 haemophilia A patients, acquired during treatment with plasma-derived FVIII concentrates. All plasma samples, drawn in a clinically stable situation before any immunotolerance treatment, contained anti-A2 domain and anti-light-chain FVIII antibodies. In nine patients' plasmas, containing relatively high amounts of FVIII light-chain antibodies (53-96%), a higher neutralization activity was found against recombinant FVIII concentrate (Recombinate) than against plasma-derived von Willebrand factor (vWF)-containing concentrate (Haemoctin SDH). No difference in neutralization of the two concentrates was found in two patients' plasmas with almost equal content of FVIII light- and heavy-chain antibodies, or one plasma with predominantly heavy-chain antibodies. These results suggest that haemophilia A patients with relatively high amounts of FVIII light-chain antibodies in plasma might benefit by infusion of FVIII concentrates containing vWF because vWF appears to have some protective effect on FVIII. This hypothesis should be tested by a clinical study.     

Inhibitor development in haemophilia A: the role of von Willebrand factor/factor VIII concentrates

Summary.  The presence of inhibitors that neutralize the function of factor VIII (FVIII) decreases the haemostatic efficacy of replacement clotting factor concentrate and increases morbidity among patients with haemophilia A. Certain genetic and environmental variables have been linked to a higher incidence of inhibitors. Conversely, the presence of von Willebrand factor (VWF) in some plasma-derived FVIII products may provide some measure of protection against inhibitor development, although the evidence is not conclusive. Clinical trials are needed to resolve this issue and determine the appropriate role of VWF-containing FVIII concentrates in the treatment of haemophilia A patients.     

Validation of an automated chromogenic assay of potency of factor VIII in commercial concentrates

The determination of factor VIII (FVIII) potency in FVIII concentrates can be performed using both manual and automated methods. This work aimed to validate the use of the chromogenic kit Coamatic^® FVIII (Chromogenix) on the automated ACL^® Elite PRO analyzer for evaluating the potency of FVIII in commercial preparations in pharmaceutical analytical laboratories. After setting the activation and reading times to 2 min and 3 min, respectively, the validation parameters, according to the International Conference on Harmonisation of Technical Requirements for Registration of Pharmaceuticals for Human Use guideline Q2 (R1), were as follows: linearity, expressed by the adjusted model: log (Absorbance) = 1.848 + 0.777?log (Concentration), with r² = 0.998; accuracy was verified (P‐value = 0.6959); and the coefficient of variation for repeatability and intermediate precision was ≤6.5%. The Coamatic^® FVIII kit method has been adapted to the ACL Elite PRO analyzer with improved performance compared with a manual microplate method.     

A Bayesian approach to the assessment of inhibitor risk in studies of factor VIII concentrates

The assessment of inhibitor risk is a crucial component in the clinical development of new and modified factor VIII (FVIII) preparations. There has been a recent discussion about the design of studies and the assessment of inhibitors and inhibitor risk in such studies at a recent FDA-sponsored FVIII Inhibitor Workshop, and new requirements for the success of these trials have been proposed to evaluate inhibitor data based on the use of an upper 95% confidence bound. We review the consequences of these requirements and demonstrate that for any product to succeed, it must have an extremely low underlying risk of inhibitor development. Furthermore, several existing commercially available FVIII products with an excellent safety record would not necessarily pass these endpoints. As a result, we propose an alternative set of acceptance criteria based on a Bayesian statistical paradigm. This approach is based on the determination of a probability that the product in question actually has an inhibitor risk below some pre-set limit, a concept that we believe is more intuitive than the traditional confidence interval method. We show that all existing products would pass this approach, but a product (Bisinact) with known inhibitor risk would not.     

In vitro kinetics of factor VIII activity in patients with mild haemophilia A and a discrepancy between one-stage and two-stage factor VIII assay results

In some mild haemophilia A patients (discrepant haemophilia), factor VIII coagulant activity (FVIII:C) levels, by one-stage assay are more than double than those by two-stage assay. This may be due to the longer incubation times (10-12 min) in the two-stage assay. This study aimed to determine the time course of the activation phase of the two-stage assay, using both classical coagulation and chromogenic detection methods. In both systems, for equivalent patients (equivalent FVIII:C levels by one-stage and two-stage assays, n = 6, all different mutations), similar FVIII:C results were obtained with short- or long-incubation times. In contrast, plasma from discrepant patients (n = 8, five different mutations) showed higher FVIII:C at shorter incubation times than after longer incubation times. In the chromogenic assay, FVIII:C levels were higher after incubation for 2 min (23-56%, mean 41%) than after 10 min (19-41%, mean 29%). In the classical coagulation assay, FVIII:C levels were higher at shorter incubation times (21-64%, mean 37%) than with the longer incubation times usually used (13-29%, mean 23%). These time-course experiments have verified that the longer incubation time used in the two-stage assay is at least partly responsible for the lower FVIII:C measured by that assay in discrepant haemophilia.     

A modified chromogenic assay for the measurement of very low levels of factor VIII activity (FVIII:C)

A precise and sensitive chromogenic assay for the measurement of very low levels of factor VIII (FVIII) in plasma has been developed. The assay is based on modifications of a commercially available chromogenic assay. The modifications include reduction of sample final dilution factor and prolongation of the development period. The modified assay allows accurate and precise measurement of FVIII in the range of 0.001-0.02 IU mL(-1). The detection limit is 0.0005 IU mL(-1) and the quantitation limit is 0.0015 IU mL(-1). This assay can be used in research and to study the clinical efficacy of low circulating levels of FVIII in haemophilia A patients.     

Abnormal factor VIII Hiroshima: defect in crucial proteolytic cleavage by thrombin at Arg1689 detected by a novel ELISA

We have established an ELISA for detecting thrombin cleavage of the FVIII light chain at Arg¹⁶⁸⁹. The method used a coating alloantibody which recognized amino acid residues 2248–2312 in the C2 domain, together with a second monoclonal antibody, NMC-VIII/10, which recognized residues 1675–1684 in the amino-terminal region of the light chain. FVIII antigen (FVIII:Ag) was measured after treatment of plasma with various concentrations of thrombin. The FVIII:Ag of normal plasma was reduced in a dose-dependent manner by the thrombin, falling to 28% in the presence of 100 U/ml enzyme. The concentration of thrombin that achieved 50% reduction (IC₅₀) was approximately 1·0 U/ml. The plasma of four haemophilia A positive (A⁺) and two haemophilia A reduced (A^R) patients were analysed. The IC₅₀ of all patients was more than 1·0 U/ml, indicating that thrombin cleavage of the FVIII light chain was defective. One haemophilia A⁺ plasma did not respond to thrombin in this ELISA system. The patient (TI) was a haemophiliac with FVIII coagulant activity of 0·04 U/ml and FVIII:Ag of 1·78 U/ml. In addition, immunoblotting of the purified FVIII from TI showed that thrombin cleavage of the 80 kilodalton (kD) light chain was impaired. The patient's DNA was amplified using the polymerase chain reaction with a set of synthetic oligonucleotide primers spanning amino acid residues 1646–1714. Sequence analysis of the amplified DNA fragments revealed a cytosine to thymine transition, converting an arginine 1689 to cysteine. This abnormal FVIII was designated as FVIII Hiroshima. Our ELISA system is a simple and useful method of evaluating the proteolytic cleavage by thrombin at Arg¹⁶⁸⁹.     

Variation in factor VIII inhibitor reactivity with different commercial factor VIII preparations

Summary. During treatment of a haemophilia A patient with a high-responding inhibitor against factor VIII coagulant activity (VIII:C), we observed a difference in recovery of VIII:C depending upon which factor concentrate was infused. Inhibitor plasma samples or IgG fraction from seven patients were tested against a panel of seven different commercially available factor VIII concentrates of which five were plasma-derived and two recombinant. In two of the plasma samples, inhibitor titres manifested a wide range of values depending upon which concentrate was used in the test system. Thus, inhibitor neutralization was less and VIII:C recovery greater when factor VIII concentrates containing large amounts of von Willebrand factor were used than when highly purified concentrates containing no von Willebrand factor or only trace amounts were used. In both of these two patients the inhibitor was directed against the light chain of factor VIII, and it is possible that the epitope of the light chain with which the inhibitor reacts is partly blocked by the von Willebrand factor.
We conclude that inhibitors may differ in their reactivity with factor VIII molecules contained in clotting factor concentrates, and that there is factor VIII epitope variation between different concentrates. These findings have implications for the selection of concentrates for the treatment of inhibitor patients and the haemostatic effect may be improved if a concentrate giving the lowest inhibitor titre is chosen. Thus, in vitro testing of inhibitor reactivity with a panel of concentrates is recommended when treatment of inhibitor patients with factor VIII concentrates is considered.     

Familial discrepancy between the one-stage and two-stage factor VIII methods in a subgroup of patients with haemophilia A

A higher result for plasma factor VIII:C measured by the one-stage as compared with the twostage method has been described in some patients with haemophilia A or with von Willebrand's disorder. We used both methods to measure FVIII:C in 95 patients with haemophilia A. The results were equivalent in all 21 patients with severe haemophilia (16 families) and in 45 of the patients with mild or moderate haemophilia (18 families). However, the results were discrepant (FVIII: C by one-stage assay 2-7-fold higher than by two-stage assay) in the other 29 patients with mild or moderate haemophilia (12 other families). For each patient with discrepant FVIII: C results the classification was the same for all other affected members of his family. In some families with haemophilia A the gene defect leads to a discrepancy between the one-stage and twostage FVIII: C results and may be more widespread than previously recognized.     

Relationships between factor VIII:Ag and factor VIII in recombinant and plasma-derived factor VIII concentrates

A variety of plasma-derived (pd) and recombinant (r) factor VIII (FVIII) concentrates are used to prevent and treat bleeding in severe hemophilia A patients. A significant side effect of FVIII replacement is the development of FVIII neutralizing antibodies (inhibitors) in up to 30% of patients receiving FVIII concentrates. The FVIII protein content (FVIII:Ag) per unit of FVIII:C in FVIII concentrates, and how effectively the FVIII:Ag in FVIII concentrates binds to von Willebrand factor (VWF) may provide information relevant for the survival of FVIII:C in vivo and for estimating the risk for inhibitor development. The FVIII:Ag content of nine r-FVIII and nine pd-FVIII concentrates were quantified in this study using two enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) platforms. The two ELISA platforms were based on the use of a monoclonal anti-(FVIII light chain)-IgG and polyclonal anti-FVIII antibodies as capture antibodies and both ELISAs were equally able to detect > or =0.005 IU of FVIII:Ag. Measured in international units, the r-FVIII concentrates contained significantly higher FVIII:Ag per unit of FVIII:C than the pd-FVIII concentrates. The VWF-binding profiles of the r-FVIII and pd-FVIII concentrates were also determined by gel filtration chromatography. Unlike the plasma-derived products, the r-FVIII concentrates invariably contained a fraction of FVIII:Ag molecules (approximately 20%) which was unable to associate with VWF. Given that VWF regulates both factor VIII proteolysis and survival of FVIII:Ag in vivo, the fraction of FVIII:Ag unable to bind to VWF may have a reduced survival and be more susceptible to proteolytic degradation in vivo. The extent to which the fractions of FVIII:Ag in concentrates able and unable to bind to VWF contribute to inhibitor development in severe FVIII-deficient patients is unknown.     

Stability of factor VIII concentrates after reconstitution

Adjusted-dose continuous infusion of factor VIII (FVIII) has recently been shown to reduce the doses of the factor in patients undergoing surgery by 50-75%. The main limitation of this method has been the instability of factor concentrates. All manufacturers are recommending infusion of the concentrate within hours after reconstitution. We studied the stability of 15 different lyophillzed F VIII products. Reconstituted samples were stored for periods of 4, 24, and 72 hr and 1, 2, 3, and 4 weeks at temperatures of WC, 20-23°C, and 37°C in their original glass containers and in plastic tubes and then frozen. Assays were performed in duplicate, using a one-stage clotting method and a chromoge nlc assay for F VIII, wlth all samples from a single concentrate In the same run. Activation of the coagulation factor occurred In some concentrates, more often at 44°C than at 20-23°C or 3PC. The stability of all products was substantially better than that declared by the manufacturers. Several concentrates maintained factor activities above 80% of baseline for the entlre period of 4 weeks at 44°C or at 20-23°C. The results demonstrate that many of the F VIII concentrates may be used for continuous infusion. © 1994 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

In vitro reactivity of factor VIII inhibitors with von Willebrand factor in different commercial factor VIII concentrates

A relevant aspect in the treatment of patients with hemophilia A (HA) presenting inhibitor against factor VIII (FVIII) is the different antigenicity of FVIII used for replacement therapy. The aim of the study was to assess the effect of different products, with variable von Willebrand factor (vWF) concentration, in preventing the binding of inhibitor to FVIII. The reactivity of inhibitors from plasma of 18 patients with HA versus three commercial concentrates containing different amounts of vWF was compared. The results show that increasing amounts of vWF might have a protective effect on the transfused FVIII inactivation.     

Mechanisms of action of immune tolerance induction against factor VIII in patients with congenital haemophilia A and factor VIII inhibitors

In its most severe form, haemophilia A is a life-threatening haemorrhagic bleeding disorder that is caused by mutations in the factor VIII (FVIII) gene. About 25% of patients who receive replacement therapy with intravenous FVIII products develop neutralising antibodies (FVIII inhibitors) that inhibit the function of substituted FVIII. Long-term application of high or low doses of FVIII has evolved as an effective strategy for eradicating antibodies and inducing long-lasting immune tolerance. Despite clinical experience with the therapy, little is known about the immunological mechanisms that cause the down modulation of FVIII-specific immune responses or the induction of long-lasting immune tolerance against FVIII. This review summarises current knowledge of the immunological mechanisms that might be involved in the induction of immune tolerance against FVIII in patients with haemophilia A who have FVIII inhibitors. In addition to data from patients with haemophilia A, data from patients who have had organ transplants or have immune-related disorders, such as autoimmune diseases, are considered as well as data from animal models.     

Hydrolysis of factor VIII mediated by catalytic antibodies occurs in haemophilia A patients with or without factor VIII inhibitors

The major complication of the substitutive treatment of haemophilia A (HA) is the development of antifactor VIII (FVIII) antibodies. Most of these antibodies neutralize FVIII procoagulant activity, and are identified as FVIII inhibitor. A subgroup of these antibodies, ‘catalytic antibodies’, catalyses the FVIII hydrolysis. We investigated the frequency and the activity of catalytic antibodies, according to the phenotype of HA and the presence or absence of FVIII inhibitor. IgG from 16 patients with inhibitor and 17 patients without inhibitor were purified. Rates of FVIII hydrolysis and inhibitor titres were evaluated. Anti‐FVIII catalytic antibodies were detected in 63.6% of patients with HA, irrespective of the HA phenotype and the presence of FVIII inhibitor. The frequency was significantly higher for severe HA patients (73.3%) and patients with inhibitor (87.5%), but their FVIII‐proteolytic activity was not significantly different from patients with mild or moderate HA and patients without inhibitor. The evolution of both catalytic and inhibitory activities was studied for 11 patients with FVIII inhibitor. We observed two profiles. In the profile 1, 18.2% of patients, the catalytic activity and the inhibitor titre coevolved. In contrast, a dissociated evolution of these two parameters was observed in 72.8% patients in profile 2. These data confirm the importance of anti‐FVIII catalytic activity in patients with severe, moderate and mild HA. Interestingly, most of the patients presented a dissociated profile, suggesting that anti‐FVIII antibodies might not systematically act as FVIII inhibitors.