Results of a Nationwide Veterans Administration Cooperative Study Comparing the Efficacy and Toxicity of Carbamazepine,Phenobarbital, Phenytoin,and Primidone

Summary: : In 1985 a 5-year multicenter Veterans Administration Cooperative Study was completed that compared the efficacy and toxicity of phenobarbital, carbamazepine, phenytoin, and primidone in a double-blind prospective study design. A total of 622 patients, either previously untreated or undertreated, were entered into the study. Strict exclusion criteria limited confounding factors such as drug or alcohol abuse. Results showed that each of the four drugs used as monotherapy were similarly effective in the treatment of generalized tonic-clonic seizures, but carbamazepine was significantly more effective in the treatment of complex partial seizures as measured by 100% control. When the results for all four drugs were combined, the data showed that approximately 80% of the patients were adequately managed on monotherapy. Differences in toxicity were the most significant factor that discriminated between these four drugs. Both carbamazepine and phenytoin were associated with significantly lower incidences of intolerable side effects than were primidone or phenobarbital. A behavioral toxicity battery was performed whenever possible prior to administration of any antiepileptic drug and at 1, 3, 6, and 12 months after initiation of monotherapy. Significant differences in performance on all subtests of the battery were found between patients with epilepsy and a control group matched by age, sex, and education. When the differential effects of all four drugs on behavioral toxicity were compared, few statistically significant differences emerged. However, carbamazepine consistently produced fewer adverse effects on tests of attention/concentration and motor performance than did the other three antiepileptic drugs.     

Fatal Liver Failure in 16 Children with Valproate Therapy

The data of 16 children who died while receiving valproate (VPA) therapy in West Germany were analyzed. Five were normally developed, 5 were receiving VPA-monotherapy, and only 2 patients were aged less than 3 years. The first clinical symptoms of impending hepatotoxicity usually included nausea, vomiting, and apathy; pathologic laboratory tests reflected liver failure. Liver histology revealed microvesicular steatosis, cell necrosis, and bile duct proliferation of varying degree. An abnormal metabolite, 4-ene-VPA, was detected in all examined patients (six of six) and persisted after drug withdrawal. The pathogenesis of fatal liver failure during VPA treatment remains unknown. World-wide, approximately 100 fatalities have been reported in relation to VPA treatment. More than 90% were aged less than 20 years, 95% developed their first symptoms within the first 6 months of treatment, and 16 were treated with VPA alone. Since it is difficult precisely to define a group at risk for fatalities with VPA, careful clinical and laboratory monitoring with a special focus on vomiting and apathy, liver enzymes, and coagulation tests seem mandatory during the first 6 months after introduction of VPA. Taking into account the considerable number of fatalities during VPA treatment, the indication for its use requires careful reevaluation.     

Clinical Side Effects of Phenobarbital, Primidone, Phenytoin, Carbamazepine, and Valproate During Monotherapy in Children

The rate of onset of side effects was examined in 392 pediatric outpatients who received long-term monotherapy with phenobarbital (PB), primidone (PRM), phenytoin (PHT), carbamazepine (CBZ), or valproate (VPA) for epilepsy or febrile convulsions. The severity of side effects (based on need to alter treatment), the nature of each drug's most common side effects, and the doses and plasma levels of occurrence were recorded. Our results show that usually accepted therapeutic ranges are well tolerated. Indeed, although some form of side effect occurred in 50% of patients, treatment had to be changed in only 18% and the drug had to be stopped in only 7%. In decreasing order, the rates for side effects were PHT (71%) greater than PB (64%) greater than CBZ (43%) greater than VPA (43%) greater than PRM (29%). Serious side effects requiring withdrawal of treatment occurred at the following rates: PHT (10%) greater than VPA (8%) greater than PRM (8%) greater than PB (4%) greater than CBZ (3%). Among our patients, the best tolerated antiepileptic drug (AED) was CBZ, and the least tolerated was PHT. Behavioral disorders were most common with PB, neurologic disorders with PHT, digestive tract disorders with VPA, and gingival hyperplasia and hirsutism with PHT. Behavioral disorders involving excitement seen with PB and PRM occurred most commonly at low plasma levels. Behavioral disorders involving depression seen with PB and VPA, those involving excitement seen with PHT and VPA, and digestive disorders seen with VPA occurred particularly when plasma levels were high.     

Treatment of Intractable Childhood Epilepsy with High-Dose Valproate

Forty-six children with refractory epilepsy (12 with symptomatic generalized epilepsy, 14 with symptomatic partial epilepsy, and 20 with undetermined epilepsy) were treated by high-dose (serum level above 100 micrograms/ml) valproate (VPA) therapy. Monotherapy was used with 34 patients and two drugs with 12. Serum VPA concentrations ranged from 105.1 to 198.4 micrograms/ml. Assessment of initial response to treatment, after the serum level had reached the appropriate level, showed seizures to be completely controlled in 15 (32.6%) of 46 patients and improved in 12 (26.1%) (50% or more). Follow-up of more than 6 months after the time of initial response showed control of seizures in 14 (30.4%) and improvement in 11 (23.9%). The initial effect on EEG was the disappearance of epileptic discharges in 3 (6.5%) of 46 patients and marked improvement in 15 (32.6%). Follow-up revealed the disappearance of epileptic discharges in 7 (15.2%) and marked improvement in 9 patients (19.6%). High-dose VPA therapy was especially effective for West syndrome and for epilepsy with continuous spike-waves during slow-wave sleep. Control of atypical absences and myoclonic seizures was relatively good. Hypofibrinogenemia and thrombocytopenia were sometimes encountered but these side effects were reversible with reduction of dosage.     

Valproate Metabolites and Hepatotoxicity in an Epileptic Population

Idiosyncratic hepatotoxicity, although rare, is of major concern when one is treating patients with valproate (VPA). Several clinical criteria are associated with an increased risk of developing this complication, but more specific predictors are needed. It has been postulated that 4-en-VPA or one of its further metabolites may be responsible for the hepatic toxicity and that under certain conditions the metabolism of VPA is shifted to this product. We postulated that measurement of serum concentrations of 4-en-VPA or another metabolite might be a simple technique that would be predictive of risk for developing idiosyncratic hepatotoxicity. Because this complication is rare, we chose to analyze our data by a multiple linear regression model, exploring associations between VPA or three of its metabolites and clinical risk factors for hepatotoxicity. 4-en-VPA correlated with older age and absence of encephalopathy. 4-en-VPA was only seen in patients receiving polytherapy; all patients were also receiving CBZ. 2-en-VPA correlated with poor nutritional status. We conclude that routine measurement of serum 4-en-VPA is unlikely to be a useful predictor of risk for developing fatal hepatotoxicity. Serum concentrations of 4-en-VPA may not reflect presence or effects in the liver as it may be metabolized to further intermediates or be bound to tissue. Thus, serum levels of 4-en-VPA do not reflect its important role in the pathogenesis of hepatotoxicity. This metabolite was detected only in patients receiving polytherapy, a potent risk factor for developing this rare complication.     

Serum Copper and Zinc Levels in Epileptic Children with Valproate Treatment

Valproate (VPA) induces zinc (Zn) deficiency in experimental animals, but whether VPA treatment induces deterioration of serum trace metal homeostasis in humans is uncertain. We measured serum copper (Cu) and Zn levels in epileptic children treated with VPA and/or other antiepileptic drugs (AEDs). Patients treated with VPA monotherapy had significantly lower levels of serum Cu (82.2 +/- 16.6 micrograms/dl) than normal controls (97.3 +/- 23.0 micrograms/dl). Patients treated with VPA in addition to some other AED also had significantly lower levels of serum Cu (84.8 +/- 20.0 micrograms/dl). Serum Cu concentrations in patients treated with AEDs except for VPA (87.7 +/- 19.1 micrograms/dl) were not statistically different from those of control subjects. In contrast to the reported results of animal experiments, serum Zn levels were not altered in patients with VPA treatment. Although none of our patients showed any symptoms of Cu deficiency, we should pay attention to potential Cu deficiency in patients with VPA treatment.     

Vigabatrin in the Treatment of Childhood Epilepsies: A Single-Blind Placebo-Controlled Study

Sixty-one pediatric patients (12-229 months of age) with refractory epilepsy were treated with vigabatrin [gamma-vinyl GABA (GVG)] in a 16-week, single-blind, add-on, placebo-controlled trial. Twenty-three patients (38%) showed a reduction of more than 50% in seizure frequency; 12 patients (20%) experienced a seizure increase; and the remaining 26 did not show significant differences between placebo and GVG treatment. Among the 216 patients who entered the long-term phase after having experienced more than 50% decrease in seizure frequency, 14 continued with the same degree of improvement after 2-11 months of follow-up (mean 7.7). GVG was particularly efficient in cryptogenic partial epilepsy. Conversely, nonprogressive myoclonic epilepsy tended to be aggravated. Agitation was the most commonly observed side effect, mainly at onset of therapy in mentally retarded patients, but was easily reversed by dose reduction. GVG is a promising drug in the treatment of refractory epilepsies of childhood.     

Valproate Monotherapy in the Management of Generalized and Partial Seizures

Summary: For decades, therapeutic tradition has promoted the concept of polypharmacy in the management of epilepsy. In recent years, however, studies have shown that, for most patients, monotherapy can provide comparable or better seizure control than administration of multiple anticonvulsants, while diminishing the potential for adverse reactions, drug interactions, and poor compliance. Valproate is an important monotherapeutic agent that is highly effective in the control of idiopathic primary and secondarily generalized epilepsies, and partial seizures that do not generalize. Comparative studies have found that valproate is at least as effective as phenytoin and carbamazepine in the treatment of generalized and partial seizures. Given the similar efficacy, other factors such as pharmacokinetics and side effects may therefore determine anticonvulsant selection for monotherapy.     

Cognitive Function and Time-of-Day Variation in Serum Carbamazepine Concentration in Epileptic Patients Treated with Monotherapy

Different parameters of antiepileptic drug (AED) treatment have been shown to affect cognitive function. The drug, dose, and duration of treatment have been studied. The present study assessed cognitive function in relation to time-of-day variation in serum carbamazepine (CBZ) concentration in epileptic patients treated with monotherapy. We studied 10 males and 12 females with a mean age of 36 years and a mean duration of CBZ-therapy of 4.4 years. Patients had been seizure-free for at least 1 month and took two daily CBZ doses. The test battery included tests of motor speed, reaction time, attention, and memory. In the experimental design, the subjects were tested twice at times close to expected daily maximum and minimum serum CBZ concentration. They were studied in two balanced blocks (block 1 tested at 8 a.m. and noon, block 2 tested at noon and 8 p.m.). Blood samples were collected every 2 hr from 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. The subjects showed significant differences in serum CBZ concentration between testing times, with suggested maximum concentration between 10 a.m. and noon. The test battery showed no consistent differences between performance at times of high versus low serum concentration. A supplementary analysis of correlations between mean performance level on cognitive tests and variables related to CBZ treatment did not show consistent trends.     

Discontinuation of Phenytoin, Carbamazepine, and Valproate in Patients with Active Epilepsy

The effects of discontinuing individual antiepileptic drugs (AEDs) in patients with active epilepsy who are receiving combination therapy have not been studied systematically. We report a double-blind, prospective study of discontinuation of phenytoin (PHT), carbamazepine (CBZ), and valproate (VPA) in 70 patients with chronic active epilepsy. Each drug discontinuation was randomized to one of two relatively fast rates of reduction, and a control group of 25 patients continued with stable therapy. Patients who had CBZ removed had a significant increase in seizures that was maintained for 4 weeks after the end of drug reduction, and 10 of these 23 patients had to restart therapy with CBZ. There was no significant change in seizure numbers in the other groups. Two patients discontinued from VPA had to restart the drug; none had to restart PHT. The optimal rates of reduction of CBZ remain uncertain. There was no evidence for a clinically or temporally distinct burst of "discontinuation seizures" in any group. Any marked increase in seizures always resolved on reintroduction of the discontinued drug.     

Monotherapy for Childhood Epilepsies with Zonisamide

Abstract: Zonisamide was tried on 44 children, 18 girls and 26 boys, from 8 months to 15 years of age at the start of the trial. In 6 children the drug has been stopped because of side effects. The drug was introduced at a dose of 2–4 mg/kg/day and increased to 12 mg/kg/day unless a satisfactory response occurred at a lower dose. A 100% control of seizures was achieved in 5 of 5 cases of idiopathic generalized epilepsies, in 7 of 8 cases of symptomatic generalized epilepsies, in one of one case of idiopathic partial epilepsies, and in 17 of 24 cases of symptomatic partial epiSepsies. The main side effect was drowsiness, especially during the introduction.     

Valproate Metabolites in Serum and Urine During Antiepileptic Therapy in Children with Infantile Spasms: Abnormal Metabolite Pattern Associated with Reversible Hepatotoxicity

The purpose of this study was to identify abnormal metabolite patterns of valproate (VPA) as possible early indicators of VPA-induced liver toxicity. In a prospective study, we determined serum and urine levels of VPA metabolites by gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC-MS) during the course of therapy in 25 children treated for infantile spasms with high VPA doses (less than or equal to 100 mg/kg body weight/day). Most patients had similar metabolite profiles: The main metabolites in serum were the beta-oxidation products (2-en-VPA and 3-keto-VPA) and the major diunsaturated metabolite 2,3'-dien-VPA. Glucuronide conjugates and the oxidation products represent the most abundant metabolites in urine. Other metabolites, including the potential hepatotoxin 4-en-VPA, were detected only in low concentrations. Two children had transiently aberrant metabolite profiles, indicating altered beta-oxidation, (levels of 2-en-VPA, 2,3'-dien-VPA, and 3-en-VPA were markedly increased) in connection with hepatomegaly and increased liver enzyme activities at a time when both had febrile infections and were receiving dexamethasone comedication. At no time were increased levels of 4-en-VPA or its derivatives detected. Establishing the VPA metabolite profile may aid in evaluation of patients who show signs and symptoms of liver dysfunction during VPA therapy. The present study shows that initial stages of hepatotoxicity reactions to VPA may be accompanied by characteristic changes in VPA metabolism; early detection of such abnormal metabolite patterns might decrease the risk of severe hepatic injury.     

Valproate, Carnitine Metabolism, and Biochemical Indicators of Liver Function

The effects of valproate (VPA) on carnitine and lipid metabolism and on liver function were assessed in 213 age- and sex-matched outpatients from five centers, with the following distribution: VPA monotherapy, 54; VPA polytherapy, 55; other monotherapies, 51; and untreated, 53. Mean total and free carnitine levels were significantly lower in patients with polytherapy; acylcarnitine was significantly higher for VPA monotherapy and the ratio of acyl- to free carnitine was significantly higher in all patients receiving VPA. Ammonia, uric acid, and bilirubin were the only tests selectively impaired with VPA. A significant correlation was found between serum ammonia and VPA dosage. Glucose, beta-lipoproteins, triglycerides, acetacetate, and beta-hydroxybutyrate were unchanged in the four groups. Sex and age appeared to interact with total and free carnitine values. Adverse drug reactions were apparently unrelated to carnitine metabolism impairment. Only a few patients had abnormal carnitine values. Our data support the assumption that carnitine deficiency and abnormal liver function due to VPA are mostly subclinical events.     

Valproate Monotherapy in 30 Patients with Partial Seizures

This retrospective pilot study describes 30 patients diagnosed and treated for complex partial seizures (CPS) and simple partial seizures (SPS) with and without generalization who received valproate (VPA) monotherapy after lack of response or allergic reaction for carbamazepine (CBZ), phenytoin (PHT), or phenobarbital (PB). Seizures were tabulated daily on seizure calendars by the patients. Three time periods were examined for seizure frequency, 90 days before VPA treatment and 90 and 180 days after VPA treatment. Twenty-two were "controlled" or "improved" (reduction of seizure activity by greater than or equal to 51%) 6 months following the initiation of VPA. VPA was particularly effective in 17 patients who had secondarily generalized tonic-clonic seizures (GTCS) as a subtype of partial seizures. Failure of response to VPA in eight patients appears to be related to their type of partial seizure (SPS or CPS alone, without GTCS) and duration of uncontrolled recurrent seizures. Etiology and compliance were not related to treatment failure. This study supports the need for a double-blind controlled trial with VPA in patients with partial seizures.     

Valproate in the Treatment of Partial Epilepsies

Summary: Review of randomized controlled trials (RCTs) shows that valproate (VPA) is effective against partial seizures with or without becoming secondarily generalized. A number of RCTs show little difference in the efficacy of VPA and carbamazepine in this patient group, particularly where patients are randomized at the time of diagnosis. The length of time that it has taken to arrive at these conclusions emphasizes the importance of large active-controlled RCTs at an early stage in drug development in informing clinical practice.     

Consistent EEG Focalities Detected in Subjects with Primary Generalized Epilepsies Monitored for Two Decades

Summary: Purpose: To describe the evolution of interictal findings in serial EEGs from patients with primary generalized epilepsy.
Methods: A cohort of 89 subjects with various primary generalized epilepsies were reviewed. Thirty-one did not meet a priori criteria. Of the 58 patients analyzed, 12 had only absence seizures, 28 had absence seizures followed by one or more generalized tonic-clonic seizures, 9 had generalized tonicclonic seizures followed by absence and/or myoclonic seizures, and 9 had juvenile myoclonic epilepsy. Patients were followed for a mean of 16 years. An average of 39 EEGs were obtained on each patient.
Results : Thirty-two patients (56%) had focal features present in up to 65% of the EEGs in each of the patients. Accepted focalities were only those that were consistent in lateralization, location and, often, morphology across the span of the study. Focal findings were most often temporal or frontal.
Conclusions : Patients with typical primary generalized epilepsies show a high incidence of focal EEG features that cannot be explained on the basis of structural lesions, coincidental factors, or to artifacts of the selection criteria. Although the data do not allow a definitive explanation, possible mechanisms include associated focal cortical pathology such as microdysgenesis, and development over time of localized, self-sustaining hyperexcitability in low-threshold cortical structures subjected to repeated generalized spike-wave activity. Either hypothesis implies the participation and interaction of genetic, ontogenic, and environmental factors.     

Seizure Aggravation in Idiopathic Generalized Epilepsies

Summary:  Seizures in the idiopathic generalized epilepsies (IGEs) usually remit completely with antiepileptic drugs (AEDs). Occasionally, however, they may be aggravated by AEDs. Before attributing exacerbation of seizures to an AED, alternative explanations need to be excluded. These include natural fluctuation of seizures, irregular compliance, maladjustment to the disease, comorbid illness, and development of tolerance. Aggravation may be due to a paradoxical reaction or drug-induced encephalopathy, sedative effects, or inappropriate use of a drug; and this need to be established, as it will guide management. An important caveat is that most data on aggravation of generalized seizures are based on anecdotal case reports or case series. Whether considering efficacy or aggravation, the interpretation of data from uncontrolled studies and case reports must be treated with caution. In practice, despite the fact that clear evidence is lacking, the possibility of seizure aggravation must be considered when treating people with IGEs. Predictive factors for seizure aggravation in a particular patient with a specific drug are yet to be fully defined. It is paramount to classify seizure type correctly in all patients. If this is not possible, a broad-spectrum AED should be used. Drugs that modulate Na⁺-channels and GABAergic drugs seem to be more prone to aggravating seizures, and therefore are best avoided in the initial management of IGE. Further studies are required to elucidate this phenomenon in full. It is interesting to speculate that paradoxical responses to AEDs may have pharmacogenetic value, serving as tools for a more precise and useful characterization of the epilepsies.     

Is 2-Propyl-4-Pentenoic Acid,a Hepatotoxic Metabolite of Valproate,Responsible for Valproate-Induced Hyperammonemia?

To investigate the association between valproate metabolism (VPA) and VPA-induced hyperammonemia together with the contribution of VPA hepatotoxicity risk factors such as young age, polypharmacy, and high serum VPA levels to VPA-induced hyperammonemia, plasma ammonia (NH3) levels, serum levels of VPA and its metabolites, and biochemical parameters were determined in 98 patients treated with VPA (53 monopharmacy cases and 45 polypharmacy cases). In monopharmacy patients, plasma NH3 levels did not depend on age, VPA dosage or serum levels. Serum level of 2-propyl-4-pentenoic acid (4-en) showed a negative correlation with plasma NH3 level in the monopharmacy group. In polypharmacy patients, plasma NH3 levels, serum glutamic pyruvic transaminase, and gamma-glutamyl-transpeptidase were significantly higher, while level/dose VPA ratio, 2-en-VPA serum level, and bilirubin were significantly lower than those in monopharmacy patients. These results suggest that young age and relatively high VPA serum levels within the therapeutic range were unlikely to be risk factors for common hyperammonemia associated with VPA therapy and that 4-en was not causally related to this adverse effect. The decreased serum level of 2-en-VPA in polypharmacy patients may be a reflection of a certain mitochondrial dysfunction, which might be a mechanism of the increased NH3 levels. The changes in biochemical parameters in polypharmacy patients were considered results of the enzyme-inducing activity of coadministered antiepileptic drugs (AEDs).