Localization of cells of the prospective neural plate, heart and somites within the primitive streak and epiblast of avian embryos at intermediate primitive-streak stages

By constructing avian transplantation chimeras using fluorescently-labeled grafts and antibodies specific for grafted cells, we have generated a prospective fate map of the primitive streak and epiblast of the avian blastoderm at intermediate primitive-streak stages (stages 3a/3b). This high-resolution map confirms our previous study on the origin of the cardiovascular system from the primitive streak at these stages and provides new information on the epiblast origin of the neural plate, heart and somites. In addition, the origin of the rostral endoderm is now documented in more detail. The map shows that the prospective neural plate arises from the epiblast in close association with the rostral end of the primitive streak and lies within an area extending 250 microm rostral to the streak, 250 microm lateral to the streak and 125 microm caudal to the rostral border of the streak. The future floor plate of the neural tube arises within the midline just rostral to the streak, confirming our earlier study, but unlike at the late-primitive streak stages when both Hensen's node and the midline area rostral to Hensen's node contribute to the floor plate, only the area rostral to the primitive streak contributes to the floor plate at intermediate primitive-streak stages. Instead of contributing to the floor plate of the neural tube, the rostral end of the primitive streak at intermediate primitive-streak stages forms the notochord as well as the rostromedial endoderm, which lies beneath the prechordal plate mesoderm and extends caudolaterally on each side toward the cardiogenic areas. The epiblast lateral to the primitive streak and caudal to the neural plate contributes to the heart and it does so in rostrocaudal sequence (i.e., rostral grafts contribute to rostral levels of the straight heart tube, whereas progressively more caudal grafts contribute to progressively more caudal levels of the straight heart tube), and individual epiblast grafts contribute cells to both the myocardium and endocardium. The prospective somites (i.e., paraxial mesoderm) lie within the epiblast just lateral to the prospective heart mesoderm. Comparing this map with that constructed at late primitive-streak stages reveals that by the late primitive-streak stages, prospective heart mesoderm has moved from the epiblast through the primitive streak and into the mesodermal mantle, and that some of the prospective somitic mesoderm has entered the primitive streak and is undergoing ingression.     

Multiple mesoderm subsets give rise to endothelial cells, whereas hematopoietic cells are differentiated only from a restricted subset in embryonic stem cell differentiation culture

In the developing mouse, vascular endothelial cell (EC) and hematopoietic cell (HPC) lineages are two initial cell lineages that diverge from mesodermal cells, which have been roughly subdivided into three subtypes according to their geographical location: the organizer, embryonic mesoderm in the primitive streak, and extraembryonic mesoderm during gastrulation. Although the initial progenitors that become the two lineages appear in both vascular endothelial growth factor receptor 2(+) (VEGFR2(+)) lateral and extraembryonic mesoderm, little is known about the underlying molecular events that regulate the derivation of ECs and HPCs. Here, we describe an experimental system consisting of two types of embryonic stem cell lines capable of distinguishing between organizer and the middle section of the primitive streak region. Using this system, we were able to establish a defined culture condition that can separately induce distinct types of mesoderm. Although we were able to differentiate ECs from all mesoderm subsets, however, the potential of HPCs was restricted to the VEGFR2(+) cells derived from primitive streak-type mesodermal cells. We also show that the culture condition for the progenitors of primitive erythrocytes is separated from that for the progenitors of definitive erythrocytes. These results suggest the dominant role of extrinsic regulation during diversification of mesoderm.     

Development of the chick embryo endoderm studied by S.E.M

Summary The endoderm of a series of chick embryos from the unincubated egg to Hamburger and Hamilton stage 5 was examined by scanning electron microscopy (SEM). During this period the endoderm develops from a few scattered cells to a complete epithelial layer. Prior to the formation of the primitive streak endoderm cells can be observed delaminating from the ectoderm. These cells are round and have few processes except where they contact each other. At stage 2 cells appear in the endoderm over the primitive streak which have broad flat processes. This suggests that the cells originate directly from the streak. Away from the streak the endoderm cells are either smooth or have short microvilli. In later streak stages a mixture of smooth and some microvillous cells form a hexagonal pattern. This pattern is occasionally modified and holes are found in the endoderm with cell processes protruding from below the endoderm level. Sometimes whole cells, smaller and rounder than the majority of the endoderm cells are associated with this disturbance of the pattern. These cells are connected to the mesoderm by a long cytoplasmic process and it is suggested that they could be cells entering the endoderm from the middle layer, having accompanied the mesoderm cells through the primitive streak.     

The rostro-caudal position of cardiac myocytes affect their fate.

During chick embryogenesis, cells destined to form cardiac myocytes are located within the primitive streak at stage 3 in the same relative anterior-posterior distribution as in the prelooped heart. The most rostral cells contribute to the extreme anterior pole of the heart, the bulbus cordis, and the most caudal to the extreme posterior end, the sinoatrial region. After gastrulation, these cells commit to the myocyte lineage and, retaining their relative positions, migrate to the anterior lateral plate. From stages 5 to 10 they diversify into atrial and ventricular myocytes, with the former located posteriorly and the latter, anteriorly. To determine the effect of a change in the rostro-caudal position of these cells on their diversification, anterior lateral plate mesoderm and the underlying endoderm were cut and rotated 180 degrees along the longitudinal axis, at stages 4-8. The subsequent diversification of these precursor cells into atrial and ventricular myocytes was examined using lineage-specific markers. Our results showed that altering location along the longitudinal axis through stage 6 changed the normal fate of a precursor cell. The orientation of the overlying ectoderm did not alter normal morphogenesis or determination of fate.     

A survey by scanning electron microscopy of the extracellular matrix and endothelial components of the primordial chick heart

Scanning electron microscopy was used to study the morphogenesis of the primitive embryonic chick heart (stage 5 late primitive streak through stage 9+). Components of the developing heart (myocardium, endocardial endothelium, and extracellular matrix) were viewed from the ventral surface after removal of the endoderm. The myocardial component of the heart can first be seen by light microscopy at stage 5 as two darker oval-shaped areas located on either side of the embryonic axis in the cranial region of the embryo. Scanning electron microscopy demonstrates that as early as stage 6 an area of extracellular matrix, enriched in comparison to more lateral and medial splanchnic mesoderm, can be identified ventral to the myocardial primordium. As heart formation progressed we observed primordial endothelial elements in the splanchnic mesoderm lateral to the myocardial primordia. By late stage 7 these lateral primordial elements had anastomosed into small, loose plexuses. This process of anastomosis progressed rapidly, and by stage 8 the entire cranial surface of the myocardial primordium was covered with vascular plexuses. By late stage 8 the progressive fusion of these plexuses resulted in the formation of large multiple tubular elements near the midline. More medially the fusion of tubular elements resulted in a continuous endothelial sheet at the midline.     

Formation and differentiation of extraembryonic mesoderm in the rhesus monkey

Differentiation of extraembryonic mesoderm in the rhesus monkey was studied from the epithelial penetration stage of implantation (stage 4) through the first week of postimplantation development (to stage 6). It was found that the first cells that appeared between the primitive endoderm (hypoblast) and trophoblast were separated from the latter by a basal lamina but appeared to be either loosely attached to the endoderm or to have been detached from it. Cells in this intermediate position differentiated cytologically into mesenchymal cells, which, by stage 5, had a distinctive intraendoplasmic reticulum marker. This differentiation occurred prior to the time at which the primitive streak could be recognized. By the time the primitive streak was readily discernible (stage 6), the extraembryonic mesoderm had already produced substantial extracellular matrix. The sequence of differentiation was repeated, with a 1- to 2-day lag, in the secondary implantation site. No evidence of a contribution from cytotrophoblast or primitive streak to the extraembryonic mesoderm was found. It is concluded that the origin of the first extraembryonic mesoderm in the rhesus monkey is probably a two-step process, with formation of a reticulum from primitive endoderm followed by differentiation in situ into mesenchymal cells. The first blood vessels formed also differentiated in situ from the extraembryonic mesenchymal cells. Primitive capillaries were identifiable as early as the 13th day of pregnancy.     

From the primitive streak to the somitic mesoderm: labeling the early stages of chick embryos using <Emphasis Type="Italic">EGFP</Emphasis> transfection

Mesoderm is derived from the primitive streak. The rostral region of the primitive streak forms the somitic mesoderm. We have previously shown the developmental origin of each level of the somitic mesoderm using DiI fluorescence labeling of the primitive streak. We found that the more caudal segments were derived from the primitive streak during the later developmental stages. DiI labeled several pairs of somites and showed the distinct rostral boundary; however, the fluorescence gradually disappeared in the caudal region. This finding can be explained in two ways: the primitive streak at a specific developmental stage is primordial of only a certain number of pairs of somites, or the DiI fluorescent dye was gradually diluted within the primitive streak by cell division. Here, we traced the development of the primitive streak cells using enhanced green fluorescent protein (EGFP) transfection. We confirmed that, the later the EGFP transfection stage, the more caudal the somites labeled. Different from DiI labeling, EGFP transfection performed at any developmental stage labeled the entire somitic mesoderm from the anterior boundary to the tail bud in 4.5-day-old embryos. Furthermore, the secondary neural tube was also labeled, suggesting that not only the somite precursor cells but also the axial stem cells were labeled.     

The establishment of a somitomeric pattern in the mesoderm of the gastrulating mouse embryo

Mesoderm formation in the mouse embryo begins at 6.5–6.75 days p.c. (postcoitum) when a primitive streak is formed along the posterior side of the egg cylinder. Epiblast cells in a localized region separate from one another and spread laterally between the primitive endoderm and the rest of the epiblast. The newly formed mesoderm contributes to both embryonic and extraembryonic regions. When the endoderm is removed, a definitive somitomeric pattern is first observed in the lateral wings of mesoderm of the mid-primitive-streak-stage embryo. The sequential appearance and the placement of somitomeres in the gastrulating mouse embryo are closely related to the general changes in physical dimensions and to the pattern of tissue growth which occur during the maturation of the egg cylinder. By the late-primitive-streak stage, about four somitomeres are present in the paraxial mesoderm on either side of the embryonic axis. These somitomeres will undergo morphogenesis and give rise to the cranial segments and head mesenchyme of neurulating embryos (Meier and Tam, 1982). The midline or axial mesoderm, consisting of prechordal plate and notochord, is derived from the head process mesoderm originating from the anterior end of the primitive streak. Cells of the head process are compact and adherent to the endoderm. The early presence of a somitomeric pattern which persists and is added to throughout subsequent phases of mesoderm formation suggests that spreading mesodermal cells have relatively stable neighbor relationships. This morphological evidence supports the idea that the expansion of the mesoderm during gastrulation results from tissue growth and progressive deposition of cells from the primitive streak. Cell migration may be limited principally to nonsomitomeric mesodermal cells found in the leading edge of the spreading lateral wings.     

Scanning electron microscopy of the development of the mesoderm layer in chick embryos

Summary The distribution of mesoderm, the structure of mesoderm cells and relationship between mesoderm and ectoderm were examined by SEM in embryos at stages 3 to 5. The mesoderm was displayed by removal of the endoderm and by fracturing the embryos through mesoderm containing regions. Within the mesoderm layer four zones could be distinguished by their cell shape and arrangement — the primitive streak, a multilayered compact area around the margins of the area pellucida, multilayered and loosely arranged cells near the primitive streak and a flattened monolayer of cells around the advancing lateral and anterior edges of the mesoderm sheet. Secretion of basement membrane by the ectoderm was seen to precede the arrival of mesoderm cells. This suggests that ectoderm alone can synthesize basement membrane without mesodermal contribution.     

Early mesoderm differentiation in the chick embryo

Summary Two groups of experiments were carried out. In the first group, grafts of quail mesoderm whose presumptive fate was to form somites or heart tissues, were taken from quail embryos (stage 4–5 of Hamburger and Hamilton 1951) and inserted beneath the ectoderm of chick embryos of stage 3–4 immediately lateral to the primitive streak. Whilst most grafts contributed to the somites and/or the heart, 22 out of a total of 46 were found to have contributed also to the pharyngeal endoderm. Although three of these grafts were known to have included some quail endoderm cells, the remainder were considered to consist of mesoderm alone. It is concluded that mesoderm at the primitive streak stages is still capable of forming endoderm.In the second group of experiments, grafts of quail somites (stage 10–14) were inserted beneath the ectoderm of chick embryos of stage 3–4. In 18 out of 23 cases the graft cells were found in somitic tissue, but they were also found in the endoderm (4 specimens), lateral plate (3 specimens) and endothelium (4 specimens). It is concluded that even at stages 10–14, the somite-derived cells are still not completely determined to form somite derivatives. In those cases where the grafted somites differentiated further, sclerotome cells which migrated from them did not necessarily move towards the host notochord.     

Mesoderm movement and fate during avian gastrulation and neurulation.

Quail/chick transplantation chimeras were constructed during stages of gastrulation and neurulation to follow the subsequent movement and fate of cells of the primitive streak. All grafts were placed solely within the confines of the primitive streak to prevent confusion between cells that had not yet ingressed and those that had already ingressed, and transplanted cells were distinguished from host cells on the basis of a naturally occurring cell marker. Pathways of movement of ingressing cells corresponded to their level of residence within the primitive streak. Cells residing within Hensen's node (the cranial end of the primitive streak) initially migrated mainly cranially, remaining on or near the midline, and then extended caudally along the midline as regression of Hensen's node occurred. Cells residing within the nodus posterior (the caudal end of the primitive streak) migrated caudally. Cells residing at levels of the primitive streak between Hensen's node and the nodus posterior typically migrated bilaterally, confirming that such cells had not already ingressed prior to their transplantation (in which case, they would have migrated unilaterally). Subsets of these cells residing at progressively more caudal levels of the primitive streak migrated incrementally more laterally. Hensen's node contributed cells to the gut endoderm, head mesenchyme, notochord, and median hinge-point (MHP) cells of the neural tube (future floor plate). At younger stages (i.e., stages 3a, 3b) Hensen's node contributed cells to principally the foregut endoderm and head mesenchyme, whereas at older stages (i.e., stages 3c, 3d, 4), it contributed cells to principally the notochord and MHP region. The remaining segments of the cranial half of the primitive streak contributed cells to the various mesodermal subdivisions of the embryo, and the lengths of the segments forming these subdivisions were estimated. The most cranial level of the streak (directly behind Hensen's node) contributed cells to the most medial mesodermal subdivisions (head mesenchyme, somites) and consecutively more caudal levels of the streak contributed cells to sequentially more lateral mesodermal subdivisions (intermediate mesoderm, lateral plate mesoderm). The caudal half of the primitive streak contributed cells to the extraembryonic mesoderm, with the nodus posterior contributing to the most caudal extraembryonic mesoderm, including the blood islands. Our results confirm and extend the previous avian prospective fate maps, increasing our understanding of the movement and fate of cells of the gastrula and neurula stages.     

Early endocardial formation originates from precardiac mesoderm as revealed by QH-1 antibody staining

The formation of endocardial endothelium in quail embryos was investigated using in vivo and in vitro systems. At stage 7+ (2 somite), the initial emergence of endothelial cells within the bilateral heart forming region (HFR) was detected in quail embryos by immunohistochemistry with QH-1 (an anti-quail endothelial cell marker) and confocal microscopy. We consistently observed more QH-1 positive cells in the right HFR than the left. At stage 8 (4 somite), the HFR, including QH-1 positive cells, were located in the splanchnic mesoderm after formation of the coelom. During stage 8, the HFR migrated along the margin of anterior intestinal portal in association with the endoderm. By stage 8+ (5 somite), the two HFR had fused at the midline and formed a plexus of QH-1 positive endothelial precursor cells. The definitive endocardium developed as a single, hollow, tube within this plexus. Posteriorly, QH-1 positive cells of the HFR established vascular-like connections with QH-1 positive cells that had formed outside (peripheral to) the HFR. During migration and subsequent determination, the precardiac mesoderm is continuously associated with the basement membrane of the anterior endoderm. To determine the role of endoderm on endocardial endothelial cell formation and development, precardiac mesoderm from stage 5 embryos, which does not express QH-1 antigen, was explanted onto the surface of collagen gels. When co-cultured with endoderm, the outgrowth of free cells from the mesoderm was much more extensive, many of which invaded the gel and expressed the QH-1 antigen; mesoderm cultured without endoderm did not seed nor express QH-1 antigen. These findings suggest that the segregation of endothelial and myocardial lineages may occur by an endoderm-mediated, mesenchymal formation.     

Heart Fields: Spatial Polarity and Temporal Dynamics

In chick and mouse, heart fields undergo dynamic morphological spatiotemporal changes during heart tube formation. Here, the dynamic change in spatial polarity of such fields is discussed and a new perspective on the heart fields is proposed. The heart progenitor cells delaminate through the primitive streak and migrate in a semicircular trajectory craniolaterally forming the bilateral heart fields as part of the splanchnic mesoderm. They switch their polarity from anteroposterior to mediolateral. The anterior intestinal portal posterior descent inverts the newly formed heart field mediolateral polarity into lateromedial by 125° bending. The heart fields revert back to their original anteroposterior polarity and fuse at the midline forming a semi heart tube by completing their half circle movement. Several names and roles were assigned to different portions of the heart fields: posterior versus anterior, first versus second, and primary versus secondary heart field. The posterior and anterior heart fields define basically physical fields that form the inflow–outflow axis of the heart tube. The first and second heart fields are, in contrast, temporal fields of differentiating cardiomyocytes expressing myosin light chain 2a and undifferentiated and proliferating precardiac mesoderm expressing Isl1 gene, respectively. The two markers present a complementary pattern and are expressed transiently in all myocardial lineages. Thus, Isl1 is not restricted to a portion of the heart field or one of the two heart lineages as has been often assumed. Anat Rec, 297:175–182, 2014. © 2013 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

The primitive streak

Summary The emphasis of this review is on the primitive streak of the chick embryo, collated with such information as is available on the mouse embryo. Little modern work has been published on any reptile primitive streak.The following topics are considered: — evolutionary significance; formation of the primitive streak; ingression and de-epithelialisation; the basal lamina; migration from the primitive streak of the endoderm and mesoderm; the role of the extracellular matrix; changes in cell adhesiveness; regression of the primitive streak and its role in body patterning; the primitive streak and induction.     

Inhibition of Wnt activity induces heart formation from posterior mesoderm

In the chick, heart mesoderm is induced by signals from the anterior endoderm. Although BMP-2 is expressed in the anterior endoderm, BMP activity is necessary but not sufficient for heart formation. Previous work from our lab has suggested that one or more additional factors from anterior endoderm are required. Crescent is a Frizzled-related protein that inhibits Wnt-8c and is expressed in anterior endoderm during gastrulation. At the same stages, expression of Wnt-3a and Wnt-8c is restricted to the primitive streak and posterior lateral plate, and is absent from the anterior region where crescent is expressed. Posterior lateral plate mesoderm normally forms blood, but coculture of this tissue with anterior endoderm or infection with RCAS-crescent induces formation of beating heart muscle and represses formation of blood. Dkk-1, a Wnt inhibitor of a different protein family, similarly induces heart-specific gene expression in posterior lateral plate mesoderm. Furthermore, we have found that ectopic Wnt signals can repress heart formation from anterior mesoderm in vitro and in vivo and that forced expression of either Wnt-3a or Wnt-8c can promote development of primitive erythrocytes from the precardiac region. We conclude that inhibition of Wnt signaling promotes heart formation in the anterior lateral mesoderm, whereas active Wnt signaling in the posterior lateral mesoderm promotes blood development. We propose a model in which two orthogonal gradients, one of Wnt activity along the anterior-posterior axis and the other of BMP signals along the dorsal-ventral axis, intersect in the heart-forming region to induce cardiogenesis in a region of high BMP and low Wnt activity.     

Growth in the pre-fusion murine allantois

Prior to fusion with the chorion, the extraembryonic mesoderm of the murine (Mus musculus) allantois differentiates with distal-to-proximal polarity into at least two cell lineages: a chorio-adhesive cell lineage called mesothelium, and the endothelium of the umbilical vasculature. How the allantois grows is less clear, but cell proliferation and addition of mesoderm from the underlying primitive streak appear to play important roles. The aim of this study was to analyze growth in the murine allantois. Techniques of histology and microsurgery were used to examine pre-fusion allantoises at nine developmental timepoints that differed by approximately 2 h. Cell counts revealed that allantoic size increased over time. Two hours of exposure to colcemid enhanced mitotic figures, which were used to calculate the relative number of proliferating cells (mitotic index, MI) in pre-fusion allantoises at each developmental timepoint. Cell proliferation was highest in nascent allantoises and showed signs of slowing by two somite pairs. By five to six-somite pairs, when most allantoises are attaching to the chorion, the overall MI decreased significantly. No regional differences in the mitotic index were observed at any developmental stage. Total cell numbers and the mitotic index were then used to discover the extent of streak contribution to pre-fusion allantoises. Cell proliferation and streak activity were highest in nascent allantoises, after which growth occurred predominantly by cell proliferation. Formation of allantoic regenerates by microsurgical removal and culture in intact conceptuses provided independent confirmation that, as the allantois matured, the primitive streak ceased to be a major contributor to its growth. Thus, the allantois grows by both mitosis and addition of mesoderm from the streak. That the periods of highest cell proliferation and streak activity coincided raises intriguing questions concerning their interplay in the control of growth in the murine allantois. Accepted: 26 May 2000     

Growth in the pre-fusion murine allantois

Prior to fusion with the chorion, the extraembryonic mesoderm of the murine (Mus musculus) allantois differentiates with distal-to-proximal polarity into at least two cell lineages: a chorio-adhesive cell lineage called mesothelium, and the endothelium of the umbilical vasculature. How the allantois grows is less clear, but cell proliferation and addition of mesoderm from the underlying primitive streak appear to play important roles. The aim of this study was to analyze growth in the murine allantois. Techniques of histology and microsurgery were used to examine pre-fusion allantoises at nine developmental timepoints that differed by approximately 2 h. Cell counts revealed that allantoic size increased over time. Two hours of exposure to colcemid enhanced mitotic figures, which were used to calculate the relative number of proliferating cells (mitotic index, MI) in pre-fusion allantoises at each developmental timepoint. Cell proliferation was highest in nascent allantoises and showed signs of slowing by two somite pairs. By five to six-somite pairs, when most allantoises are attaching to the chorion, the overall MI decreased significantly. No regional differences in the mitotic index were observed at any developmental stage. Total cell numbers and the mitotic index were then used to discover the extent of streak contribution to pre-fusion allantoises. Cell proliferation and streak activity were highest in nascent allantoises, after which growth occurred predominantly by cell proliferation. Formation of allantoic regenerates by microsurgical removal and culture in intact conceptuses provided independent confirmation that, as the allantois matured, the primitive streak ceased to be a major contributor to its growth. Thus, the allantois grows by both mitosis and addition of mesoderm from the streak. That the periods of highest cell proliferation and streak activity coincided raises intriguing questions concerning their interplay in the control of growth in the murine allantois.     

Endoderm and heart development.

Since the first half of the 20th century, experimental embryologists have noted a relationship between endoderm cells and the development of cardiac tissue from mesoderm. During the past decade, the accumulation of evidence for an obligatory interaction between endoderm and mesoderm during the specification and terminal differentiation of myocardial, and more recently endocardial, cells has markedly accelerated. Moreover, the endoderm-derived molecules that may regulate these processes are being identified. It now appears that endoderm-derived growth factors regulate the formation of both myocardial and endocardial cells during specification, terminal differentiation, and perhaps morphogenesis of cells in the developing embryonic heart.     

Origin of hematopoietic progenitors during embryogenesis

It has been widely accepted that hematopoietic and endothelial cell lineages diverge from a common progenitor referred to as the hemangioblast. Recently, analyses of the potential of progenitor cells purified from mouse embryos as well as embryonic stem cells differentiating in vitro resolved intermediate stages between mesodermal cells and committed precursors for hematopoietic and endothelial cell lineages. There are two distinct hematopoietic cell lineages which have different origins, i.e., primitive hematopoietic lineage derived from mesoderm or hemangioblasts and definitive hematopoietic lineage derived from endothelial cells. The endothelium is suggested to provide a milieu in which the definitive hematopoietic lineage acquires multiple potentials.