Stress lactate in mitochondrial myopathy under constant, unadjusted workload

As it is under debate if determination of lactate during cycle ergometry (lactate stress testing, LST) under a continuous, unadjusted, low workload is a valuable diagnostic tool for mitochondrial myopathy (MMP), the present study aimed to investigate how sensitive the LST is in a large cohort of patients with indications for MMP (MMP patients). Serum lactate was determined once before, three times during, and once after a 15-min, constant 30 W-workload on a bicycle ergometer in 115 healthy controls, 166 patients with neurological disorders other than MMP, and 291 MMP patients. Serum lactate's upper reference limit at rest, 5, 10, 15 min after starting, and 15 min after finishing the exercise was 2.0, 2.0, 2.1, 2.0 and 1.7 mmol/l, respectively. Resting lactate was increased in 75 MMP patients (26%). The specificity of resting lactate determination was 84%. The sensitivity of the LST was 66% and the specificity 84%. Among the 192 MMP patients with abnormal LST, 120 (63%) had a normal resting lactate. The LST is abnormal in two thirds of the MMP patients. The sensitivity of the LST is higher than that of resting lactate determination. The LST is a simple and cheap but effective and reliable screening method for detecting the impaired oxidative metabolism in MMP.     

Cycle ergometry is not a sensitive diagnostic test for mitochondrial myopathy

Cycle exercise has repeatedly been used to diagnose patients suspected of having mitochondrial myopathy (MM), in whom exercise intolerance and lactic acidosis are common. No standardized test, however, has been established. We evaluated the diagnostic value of incremental and constant workload (20 min at 65 % VO(2max)) cycle tests for the diagnosis of MM. Plasma lactate and oxidative capacity (VO(2) and workload) were measured in 15 well-characterized MM patients during cycling. Findings were compared with those in 10 myotonic dystrophy patients and 18 sedentary, healthy subjects.All MM patients had ragged red or COX-negative fibers on muscle biopsy. VO(2max) and maximal workload were lower in MM than in control groups (P < 0.02). Resting plasma lactate was higher in MM than in control groups (P < 0.005; sensitivity = 93 %; specificity = 85 %), while exercise-induced increases in plasma lactate were only higher during the constant workload protocol in MM patients vs. control groups (P < 0.05; sensitivity = 27 %; specificity = 86 %). The findings indicate that the diagnostic value of a constant workload protocol is superior to an incremental cycle test, but that the test is less sensitive for MM than simple testing of resting lactate and muscle morphology. Cycle testing of MM patients remains an important research tool, but should not be a standard diagnostic procedure for MM.     

Lactate-stress testing in 54 patients with mitochondriopathy

Since there are only few data available about the lactate stress test in a group of patients with mitochondrial myopathy, we investigated the sensitivity of this test in a larger cohort of such patients. Serum lactate was determined before, during and after a 15 minute, constant 30 W workload on a bicycle ergometer in 47 controls, aged 15 to 72 years and 54 patients with mitochondrial myopathy, aged 15 to 74 years. Lactate’s upper reference limits at rest, 5, 10, 15 minutes after starting, and 15 minutes after finishing the exercise were 2.0, 2.1, 2.1, 2.1 and 1.8 mmol/l respectively. The sensitivity of the lactate-stress test was 69%. The lactate-stress test complements electrophysiological and bioptical findings and proved to be helpful in diagnosing mitochondrial myopathy. Received: 2 March 1999 / Accepted: 25 October 1999     

31P NMR spectroscopy and ergometer exercise test as evidence for muscle oxidative performance improvement with coenzyme Q in mitochondrial myopathies.

Two patients with mitochondrial encephalomyopathy due to complexes I and IV deficiencies received 150 mg/d of coenzyme Q10 (CoQ). We studied them with a bicycle ergometer exercise test and 31P NMR spectroscopy before and after 10 months of treatment. Before treatment, we observed a low phosphocreatine/inorganic phosphate (PCr/P(i)) resting value along with abnormally high resting lactate concentration. During exercise, there was a pronounced acidosis with delayed kinetics of postexercise recovery for blood lactate, pH, PCr, and PCr/P(i) ratio. Oxygen uptake during exercise was reduced while the lowering of the ventilatory threshold indicated an early activation of glycolysis. After treatment, the bicycle ergometer exercise test indicated a significant improvement with a decrease in resting blood lactate level, an increase in oxygen consumption during exercise, and an increase in the kinetics of lactate disappearance during the recovery period. A shift of the ventilatory threshold to higher workload was present. 31P NMR spectroscopy confirmed the improvement, showing a significant increase in the PCr/P(i) ratio at rest and in the kinetics of recovery for pH, PCr, and PCr/P(i) ratio following exercise in patient 1. For patient 2, we observed a less pronounced acidosis correlated with a lesser amount of Pi produced during exercise. These observations indicate an improvement of mitochondrial function and a shift from high to low glycolytic activity in both patients consequent to CoQ treatment.     

Lactate production upon short-term non–ischemic forearm exercise in mitochondrial disorders and other myopathies

BACKGROUND: The nonischemic forearm exercise test (NIFET) has been shown to be as effective as the classic ischemic forearm exercise test (IFET) in the diagnosis of patients with McArdle disease. Recently, the lactate increase normalized to the mechanical energy production in NIFET was suggested to have a intermediate sensitivity and satisfactory specifity for the screening of mitochondrial disorders. METHODS: NIFET at 80% maximal contraction force (MCF) was performed in normal controls (n = 41), patients with mitochondrial disorders (n = 15) and other myopathies (diseased controls, n = 20). 26 healthy volunteers also underwent IFET at 80% MCF. The ratio of lactate increase and workload was defined as specific lactate production (mmol x s/N x l). RESULTS: In normal controls there was no significant different lactate increase during NIFET and IFET. The workload performed showed only a weak significant positive correlation with the lactate increase in the NIFET in normal controls (r(2) = 0.20) but not in IFET and NIFET with patients. A moderate negative correlation of specific lactate production and the absolute workload was found in all groups and in both protocols (r(2) = 0.22-0.34). The specific lactate production was highest in patients with other myopathies, intermediate in patients with mitochondrial disorders and lowest in normal controls. NIFET showed a sensitivity of only 20 % and a specifity of 95% for normal controls, but only 75 % for diseased controls. CONCLUSION: The specific lactate production during NIFET is neither sufficiently specific nor sensitive for the diagnosis of mitochondrial disorders. Increased specific lactate production during rest-to-work transition period might be caused by increased acetyl group deficits.     

Effects of aerobic training on lactate and catecholaminergic exercise responses in mitochondrial myopathies

The aim of this study was to evaluate the effects of an aerobic training program on the metabolic and sympathetic responses to exercise in 12 patients with mitochondrial myopathies. A 10-week course of aerobic training, consisting of supervised exercise every other day on an electrically braked pedal-rate bicycle ergometer was prescribed to each patient and four healthy controls. Venous lactate, epinephrine (EP) and norepinephrine (NEP) levels were assessed at baseline and after the aerobic training by means of constant-workload exercise performed at near lactate threshold (LT). In patients, a decrease in exercise peak values, significant for lactate (-38.6%, P < 0.01) but not for catecholamines (EP: -26.0%, NEP: -22.1%) was observed after training, findings confirmed by the lactate/EP and lactate/NEP area ratios. The results show that lactate accumulation during exercise is decreased after aerobic training in mitochondrial myopathies and that the effect is partially dissociated from the catecholaminergic response. This in turn suggests that the lactate decrease can be explained, at least in part, by the improved muscle oxidative metabolism consequent to the proposed training program.     

Lactate stress testing in sporadic amyotrophic lateral sclerosis

Mitochondrial dysfunction is frequently observed in ALS. Mitochondrial dysfunction may result in increased serum lactate at rest or low levels of exercise, being used for diagnostic purposes. The study investigated if resting-lactate-determination is superior to lactate-stress-testing (LST) in demonstrating mitochondrial dysfunction in ALS. Included were 15 ALS patients, 4 women, 11 men, aged 37-72. Severity of the disease was assessed by the Norris-score. The control group comprised 66 healthy subjects, 40 women, 26 men, aged 36-76. Serum lactate was determined before, three times during, and once after a constant workload with 30 W on a bicycle ergometer. According to the EIEscorial criteria 8 patients had definite, 4 probable, 3 possible ALS. Resting lactate was increased in 2 patients, 1 with definite and 1 with possible ALS. The LST was abnormal in 5 patients with definite, 1 with probable and 1 with possible ALS. The mean Norris-score was 67.8 in patients with abnormal LST and 74.6 in patients with normal LST. In conclusion, the LST is more suitable than resting-lactate-determination in demonstrating mitochondrial dysfunction in ALS. The LST suggests mitochondrial dysfunction in half of the ALS patients. Mitochondrial dysfunction in ALS is related to the clinical severity of the disease.     

LACTATE STRESS TESTING IN SPORADIC AMYOTROPHIC LATERAL SCLEROSIS

Mitochondrial dysfunction is frequently observed in ALS. Mitochondrial dysfunction may result in increased serum lactate at rest or low levels of exercise, being used for diagnostic purposes. The study investigated if resting-lactate-determination is superior to lactate-stress-testing (LST) in demonstrating mitochondrial dysfunction in ALS. Included were 15 ALS patients, 4 women, 11 men, aged 37–72. Severity of the disease was assessed by the Norris-score. The control group comprised 66 healthy subjects, 40 women, 26 men, aged 36–76. Serum lactate was determined before, three times during, and once after a constant workload with 30 W on a bicycle ergometer. According to the EIEscorial criteria 8 patients had definite, 4 probable, 3 possible ALS. Resting lactate was increased in 2 patients, 1 with definite and 1 with possible ALS. The LST was abnormal in 5 patients with definite, 1 with probable and 1 with possible ALS. The mean Norris-score was 67.8 in patients with abnormal LST and 74.6 in patients with normal LST. In conclusion, the LST is more suitable than resting-lactate-determination in demonstrating mitochondrial dysfunction in ALS. The LST suggests mitochondrial dysfunction in half of the ALS patients. Mitochondrial dysfunction in ALS is related to the clinical severity of the disease.     

<Superscript>31</Superscript>P-MRS of skeletal muscle is not a sensitive diagnostic test for mitochondrial myopathy

Clinical phenotypes of persons with mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) mutations vary considerably. Therefore, diagnosing mitochondrial myopathy (MM) patients can be challenging and warrants diagnostic guidelines. (31)phosphorous magnetic resonance spectroscopy ((31)P-MRS) have been included as a minor diagnostic criterion for MM but the diagnostic strength of this test has not been compared with that of other commonly used diagnostic procedures for MM. To investigate this, we studied seven patients with single, large-scale deletions-, nine with point mutations of mtDNA and 14 healthy subjects, who were investigated for the following: 1) (31)P-MRS of lower arm and leg muscles before and after exercise, 2) resting and peak-exercise induced increases of plasma lactate, 3) muscle morphology and -mitochondrial enzyme activity, 4) maximal oxygen uptake (VO(2max)), 5) venous oxygen desaturation during handgrip exercise and 6) a neurological examination. All MM patients had clinical symptoms of MM, > 2% ragged red fibers in muscle, and impaired oxygen desaturation during handgrip. Fourteen of 16 patients had impaired VO(2max), 10/16 had elevated resting plasma lactate, and 10/11 that were investigated had impaired citrate synthase-corrected complex I activity. Resting PCr/P(i) ratio and leg P(i) recovery were lower in MM patients vs. healthy subjects. PCr and ATP production after exercise were similar in patients and healthy subjects. Although the specificity for MM of some (31)P-MRS variables was as high as 100%, the sensitivity was low (0-63%) and the diagnostic strength of (31)P-MRS was inferior to the other diagnostic tests for MM. Thus, (31)P-MRS should not be a routine test for MM, but may be an important research tool.     

Lactate increase and oxygen desaturation in mitochondrial disorders – Evaluation of two diagnostic screening protocols

Background Mitochondrial disorders are characterized by an accumulation of lactate and an insufficient oxygen extraction from blood during exercise. Therefore, both parameters (lactate and oxygen saturation) can be used as screening tests in mitochondrial disorders. However, conflicting results regarding sensitivities and specifities of both tests have been reported. Method We examined 27 patients with genetically defined mitochondrial disorders (single deletions n = 15,multiple deletions n = 5, A3243G mutation n = 7), patients with other neuromuscular disorders, and healthy controls. In the first test subjects performed intermittent isometric handgrip exercise (0.5 Hz) at 80 % (3 minutes) and 30 % (3 and 15 minutes) of maximal contraction force (MCF). Oxygen saturation and partial pressure in cubital venous blood from the exercising arm were measured. In the second test subjects underwent cycle ergometry at 30 W for 15 minutes. Venous lactate at rest, during and 15 minutes postexercise was determined. Result Both tests showed specificities of 92–96%. Sensitivities for changes of venous oxygen partial pressure and oxygen saturation ranged from 21–26% at 80% MCF for 3 minutes to 47–58% at 30% MCF for 15 minutes. Sensitivities for venous resting, peak, and post–exercise lactate was 33%, 58%, and 67%, respectively. The degree of deoxygenation, however,was independent of the intensity and duration of the applied forces. Oxygen desaturation and lactate increase in patients with mitochondrial disorders were not different in patients with and without clinical symptoms of myopathy. There were significant correlations between the heteroplasmy and both the degree of oxygen desaturation and lactate increase in patients with single deletions. In patients who performed both protocols (n = 16) a combination of both tests increased sensitivity up to 87%. Conclusion Oxygen desaturation in forearm exercise tests and lactate increase in cycle ergometry tests show a high specifity but only moderate sensitivity. Combination of the two screening test clearly increases the sensitivity.     

A non-ischemic forearm exercise test for the screening of patients with exercise intolerance.

BACKGROUND: The forearm exercise test is a common investigation that allows detection of some metabolic myopathies. It is not completely standardized and, when performed in ischemic conditions, may induce rhabdomyolysis in patients with glycogenosis. OBJECTIVE: To develop a standardized non-ischemic exercise test for a safe screening of patients with exercise intolerance. METHODS: Twenty-six healthy subjects and 32 patients with exercise intolerance performed an isometric exercise at 70% of the maximal voluntary contraction during 30 seconds in non-ischemic conditions. Blood concentrations of creatine kinase, lactate, and ammonia were analyzed. RESULTS: A nearly fourfold lactate rise was induced by exercise in healthy subjects. All patients with normal muscle biopsy showed values similar to those of healthy subjects. No significant lactate increase was observed in six patients with a myophosphorylase defect and one with a debrancher defect. Disparate lactate responses were observed in 14 patients with a mitochondrial myopathy. The blood lactate level at rest was abnormally high in four of these patients. The lactate surface normalized by the mechanical energy production was above the normal range in eight patients. CONCLUSIONS: The authors propose a standardized non-ischemic grip test that overcomes the main drawbacks of the classic ischemic forearm exercise test. It provides a specific, efficient, and safe screening test for patients with exercise intolerance. Its sensitivity was very good for patients with a glycogenolysis defect but remains partial in patients with a mitochondrial disorder.     

Lactate stress testing in 155 patients with mitochondriopathy

OBJECTIVE: Few data are available about the diagnostic yield of the lactate stress test (LST) in a large group of patients with mitochondriopathy (MCP). METHODS: Serum lactate was determined once before, three times during, and once after a 15-minute, constant 30W workload on a bicycle in 62 controls, aged 17 to 84 years, 155 patients with MCP, aged 17 to 87 years, and 31 patients with neurological disorders other than MCP. RESULTS: Lactate's upper reference limits at rest, 5, 10, 15 minutes after starting, and 15 minutes after finishing the exercise were 2.0, 2.1, 2.1, 2.1 and 1.8 mmol/l respectively. The test was regarded abnormal if more than two of the five lactate values exceeded the cut-off levels. Among the 103 patients with abnormal LST, 64 (62 %) had normal resting lactate. The sensitivity of the test was 67% and the specificity 94%. CONCLUSION: The LST proved to have a high sensitivity and specificity in the detection of patients with MCP, being thus a simple but powerful tool to assess the impaired oxidative metabolism in MCP patients.     

The effects of acute exercise and high lactate levels on 35% CO2 challenge in healthy volunteers

OBJECTIVE: To test the possible antipanic effects of acute exercise in healthy volunteers exposed to an inhalation of 35% CO2 challenge. METHOD: Twenty healthy subjects in a randomized separate group design, performed exercise in a bicycle ergometer reaching >6 mm of blood lactate and a control condition of minimal activity in the same fashion with no lactate elevation. Immediately afterwards an inhalation of a vital capacity using a mixture of 35% CO2/65% O2 through a mask was given on both conditions. RESULTS: Subjects under the exercise condition reported less panic symptoms than controls after a CO2 challenge on the diagnostic statistical manual-IV (DSM-IV) Panic Symptom List but no difference on the Visual Analogue Anxiety Scale. CONCLUSION: Subjects under the exertion condition had lactate levels comparable with those of lactate infusions but an inhibitory rather than accumulative effect was seen when combined with a CO2 challenge.     

Diagnostic yield of the lactate stress test in respiratory chain disorders under absolute and relative workload.

Usually, the lactate stress test is carried under a constant, low workload maintained for 15 min, although there are indications that the lactate response to exercise is a function of the relative workload, and that a workload for only 5 min does not decrease its sensitivity. Thus, this study compared the diagnostic yield of the lactate stress test when carried out under a constant workload of 30 W (LSTA) and under a workload of 30% of maximum (LSTR), and when the workload was maintained for 5 and 15 min. In 16 patients with respiratory chain disorders, 12 women, four men, aged 27--88 years, the LSTA and LSTR were carried out on 2 different days, within 48 h. For both tests serum lactate was determined before, during and after a 15-min workload on a bicycle. Upper reference limits at rest, 5, 10, 15 min after starting, and 15 min after finishing the exercise were 1.9, 2.0, 2.0, 2.0, and 1.6 mmol/l for the LSTA, and 2.3, 3.0, 3.2, 3.4 and 2.7 mmol/l for the LSTR. The sensitivity was 88% for the LSTA and 63% for the LSTR. The specificity of the LSTA was 94%. The diagnostic yield of both tests was similar when the workload was maintained for 5 or 15 min. In conclusion, the LSTA should be preferred to the LSTR. Three lactate determinations during 15 min have no advantage over a single lactate determination after a 5 min workload of 30 W.     

Lactate metabolism during exercise in patients with mitochondrial myopathy

Patients with mitochondrial DNA mutations often have elevated plasma lactate at rest and during exercise, but it is unknown whether the high lactate levels are caused by a high production, an impaired oxidation or a combination. We studied lactate kinetics in 10 patients with mtDNA mutations and 10 matched healthy control subjects at rest and during cycle exercise with a combination of femoral arterio-venous differences of lactate, and lactate tracer dilution methodology. During exercise, lactate concentration and production rates were several-fold higher in patients, but despite mitochondrial dysfunction, lactate was oxidized in muscle to the same extent as in healthy control subjects. This surprisingly high ability to burn lactate in working muscle with defective mitochondria, probably relates to the variability of oxidative capacity among muscle fibers. The data suggests that lactate is not solely an indicator of impaired oxidative capacity, but an important fuel for oxidative metabolism, even in muscle with severely impaired mitochondrial function.     

The relationship between anaerobic lactate threshold and plasma catecholamines during incremental exercise in hereditary spastic paraplegia

Lower limb muscle chronic hyperactivity in hereditary spastic paraplegia (HSP) is the consequence of motor corticospinal tract involvement, which in turn has been hypothesized to be of mitochondrial origin. In order to assess skeletal muscle aerobic metabolism and sympathetic response during exercise in 10 HSP patients, we evaluated their blood lactate and catecholamine levels during an incremental workload bicycle exercise. Lactate, but not epinephrine or norepinephrine, levels were significantly higher in the HSP patients than in control subjects, in both resting conditions and during exercise. In the patients, the anaerobic lactate threshold was reached prematurely (at 50% of the predicted normal maximal power output) when compared to normal controls. This finding was not related to any specific muscle morphology or histochemical activity. Although other factors, including chronic spasticity and muscle deconditioning, have to be considered in the interpretation of our data, our results suggest the possible involvement of a mitochondrial mechanism, independently of sympathetic system overactivation, in exercising skeletal muscle of HSP patients.     

Die Spiroergometrie in der Diagnostik mitochondrialer Erkrankungen

Cardiopulmonary exercise testing (CPX) is a non-invasive method of recording quantitative data from gas exchange and ventilation for the evaluation of oxidative metabolism at rest and during exercise. Determination of oxygen uptake (VO2) and carbon dioxide output (VCO2) describes the activity of anaerobic vs aerobic metabolism. An incremental exercise test measuring gas exchange, ventilation and lactate release was performed in healthy volunteers and in patients suffering from mitochondrial disorders. At rest as well as during exercise patients with mitochondrial disorders differ from healthy subjects with regard to gas exchange and ventilation parameters. During exercise, the decreased oxygen utilization of skeletal muscle and early activation of anaerobic metabolism in these patients are mirrored by a reduced anaerobic threshold, reduced maximal oxygen uptake and reduced oxygen pulse. Our study shows that CPX is a sensitive and practical clinical screening method of investigating mitochondrial disorders.     

Low anaerobic threshold and increased skeletal muscle lactate production in subjects with Huntington's disease

Mitochondrial defects that affect cellular energy metabolism have long been implicated in the etiology of Huntington's disease (HD). Indeed, several studies have found defects in the mitochondrial functions of the central nervous system and peripheral tissues of HD patients. In this study, we investigated the in vivo oxidative metabolism of exercising muscle in HD patients. Ventilatory and cardiometabolic parameters and plasma lactate concentrations were monitored during incremental cardiopulmonary exercise in twenty‐five HD subjects and twenty‐five healthy subjects. The total exercise capacity was normal in HD subjects but notably the HD patients and presymptomatic mutation carriers had a lower anaerobic threshold than the control subjects. The low anaerobic threshold of HD patients was associated with an increase in the concentration of plasma lactate. We also analyzed in vitro muscular cell cultures and found that HD cells produce more lactate than the cells of healthy subjects. Finally, we analyzed skeletal muscle samples by electron microscopy and we observed striking mitochondrial structural abnormalities in two out of seven HD subjects. Our findings confirm mitochondrial abnormalities in HD patients' skeletal muscle and suggest that the mitochondrial dysfunction is reflected functionally in a low anaerobic threshold and an increased lactate synthesis during intense physical exercise. © 2010 Movement Disorder Society     

A forearm exercise screening test for mitochondrial myopathy

BACKGROUND: The authors hypothesized that impaired oxygen extraction in mitochondrial myopathy (MM) results in a high oxygen saturation in venous effluent blood from working muscle and that this phenomenon can be used as a diagnostic tool for MM. METHODS: Twelve patients with MM, 10 patients with muscular dystrophy, and 12 healthy subjects were studied. All subjects performed intermittent static handgrip exercise (1/2 Hz) at 40% of maximal voluntary contraction (MVC) for 3 minutes. Cubital venous oxygen saturation and brachial artery flow were measured in the exercised arm. RESULTS: Exercise-induced venous oxygen desaturation was smaller in patients with MM (Delta - 7 +/- 5%) than in subjects with muscular dystrophy (Delta - 38 +/- 2%; p = 0.00001) and healthy subjects (Delta - 43 +/- 2%; p = 0.0000002). MVC and exercise blood flow were similar in patients with MM (18 +/- 3 kg; 436 +/- 65 mL/min) and patients with muscular dystrophy (15 +/- 3 kg; 460 +/- 85 mL/min), but were higher in healthy subjects (32 +/- 4 kg; 630 +/- 58 mL/min; p < 0.03). In seven patients with MM and seven patients with McArdle disease, studied with a slightly different protocol, exercise-induced oxygen desaturation was also impaired in MM (Delta - +/- 5%) compared with McArdle disease (Delta - 26 +/- 3%; p = 0.007). CONCLUSION: Oxygen desaturation in venous blood from exercising muscle is markedly lower in patients with mitochondrial myopathy than in subjects with other muscle diseases and healthy subjects, suggesting that a forearm exercise test can be a diagnostic screening tool for mitochondrial myopathy.