Comparison of PCR-ribotyping, arbitrarily primed PCR, and pulsed-field gel electrophoresis for typing Clostridium difficile

Clostridium difficile is now recognized as the major agent responsible for nosocomial diarrhea in adults. Among the genotyping methods available, arbitrarily primed PCR (AP-PCR), PCR-ribotyping, and pulsed-field gel electrophoresis (PFGE) have been widely used for investigating outbreaks of C. difficile infections. However, the comparative typing ability, reproducibility, discriminatory power, and efficiency of these methods have not been fully investigated. We compared the results of three methods-AP-PCR with three different primers (AP3, AP4, and AP5), PCR-ribotyping, and PFGE (with SmaI endonuclease)-to differentiate 99 strains of C. difficile that had been previously serogrouped. Typing abilities were 100% for PCR-ribotyping and AP-PCR with AP3 and 90% for PFGE, due to early DNA degradation in strains from serogroup G. Reproducibilities were 100% for PCR-ribotyping and PFGE but only 88% for AP-PCR with AP3, 67% for AP-PCR with AP4, and 33% for AP-PCR with AP5. Discriminatory power for unrelated strains was >0.95 for all the methods but was lower for PCR-ribotyping among serogroups D and C. PCR-based methods were easier and quicker to perform, but their fingerprints were more difficult to interpret than those of PFGE. We conclude that PCR-ribotyping offers the best combination of advantages as an initial typing tool for C. difficile.     

Comparison of ribotyping, arbitrarily primed PCR, and pulsed-field gel electrophoresis for molecular typing of Listeria monocytogenes.

Fifty-one clinical isolates of Listeria monocytogenes (15 isolates from two outbreaks and 36 epidemiologically unrelated isolates) were typed by conventional serotyping, ribotyping (RT), pulsed-field gel electrophoresis (PFGE), and arbitrarily primed PCR (AP-PCR). Serotyping was unable to distinguish between related and unrelated strains of L. monocytogenes. Each of the three molecular methods showed excellent typeability and reproducibility. Restriction with EcoRI and PvuII gave 16 and 23 RT patterns, respectively. Restriction with ApaI or SmaI generated 22 and 26 PFGE profiles, respectively. ApaI profiles were easier to interpret, with 10 to 15 bands each, while SmaI profiles had 15 to 20 bands each. AP-PCR with two different primers yielded 29 and 31 randomly amplified polymorphic DNA patterns, respectively. Strains from the same outbreak shared concordant patterns by each of the three methods. Of the three techniques evaluated, RT was the least discriminating and could not distinguish between strains from the two outbreaks. The abilities of AP-PCR and PFGE to differentiate between strains were comparable. However, AP-PCR was more rapid and easier to perform. We conclude that the DNA profiles generated by either AP-PCR or PFGE can be used to differentiate outbreak strains from epidemiologically unrelated strains and to clearly identify unrelated strains as being distinct from one another. We recommend that at least two independent primers be used for AP-PCR typing in order to improve its discriminatory power.     

Molecular typing of Legionella pneumophila serogroup 1 isolates from patients and the nosocomial environment by arbitrarily primed PCR and pulsed-field gel electrophoresis.

The ubiquity of Legionella pneumophila in aquatic habitats means that epidemiological evaluation is important for the investigation and control of nosocomial outbreaks of legionellosis. Pulsed-field gel electrophoresis (PFGE) of chromosomal DNA following digestion with SfiI is considered to be one of the most discriminative methods for detecting DNA polymorphisms amongst L. pneumophila serogroup 1 (Lp1) isolates. This paper describes an arbitrarily primed PCR (AP-PCR) method with three different primers (20-mers) for detecting DNA polymorphisms of Lp1 isolates. The AP-PCR assay was compared with PFGE analysis. Both experimental methods were found to have good discriminatory power (discrimination index of 98% and 94.3%, respectively) with 27 unrelated isolates from different geographical areas collected between 1987 and 1997. Furthermore, when the AP-PCR was used in the epidemiological investigation of nosocomial cases of infection, convergent results with the three primers allowed an epidemiological link to be established between isolates from patients and their environment. The AP-PCR method, which is rapid and easy to perform, gave results at least as discriminatory as those obtained with the PFGE method and is proposed for use in the molecular typing of Lp1 outbreaks.     

Comparison of Legionella pneumophila isolates by arbitrarily primed PCR and pulsed-field gel electrophoresis: analysis from seven epidemic investigations.

Arbitrarily primed PCR (AP-PCR) and pulsed-field gel electrophoresis (PFGE) subtyping were applied to clinical and environmental isolates from seven unrelated outbreaks of Legionnaires' disease. The patterns observed with each method matched patient isolates and the epidemiologically linked source of disease for each of the seven outbreaks. PFGE allowed more discrimination among various isolates, although AP-PCR usually gave comparable results. With both methods, certain patterns appeared to predominate in the comparison of the seven outbreaks. Of five clinical isolates not associated with the outbreaks, three gave profiles distinct from those observed in the outbreaks by both methods. This suggests that there are at least two predominant subtypes of Legionella pneumophila serogroup 1 associated with outbreaks. Investigations of outbreaks of legionellosis should employ either PFGE or AP-PCR in addition to monoclonal antibody analysis.     

Comparative typing of Pseudomonas aeruginosa by random amplification of polymorphic DNA or pulsed-field gel electrophoresis of DNA macrorestriction fragments.

Eighty-seven strains of Pseudomonas aeruginosa were typed by random amplification of polymorphic DNA (RAPD) and pulsed-field gel electrophoresis (PFGE) of macrorestriction fragments. Stains were clustered on the basis of interpretative criteria as presented previously for the PFGE analysis. Clusters of strains were also defined on the basis of epidemiological data and subsequently reanalyzed by RAPD. It was found that in an RAPD assay employing the enterobacterial repetitive intergenic consensus sequence ERIC2 as a primer, single band differences can be ignored; in this case, clonally related strains could be grouped as effectively and reliably as with PFGE. These data could be corroborated by the use of other primer species. However, some primers either showed reduced resolution or, in contrast, identified DNA polymorphisms beyond epidemiologically and PFGE-defined limits. Apparently, different primers define different windows of genetic variation. It is suggested that criteria for interpretation of the ERIC2 PCR fingerprints can be simple and straightforward: when single band differences are ignored, RAPD-determined grouping of P. aeruginosa is congruent with that obtained by PFGE. Consequently, this implies that RAPD can be used with trust as a first screen in epidemiological characterization of P. aeruginosa. The ability to measure the rate of molecular evolution of the P. aeruginosa genome clearly depends on the choice of restriction enzyme or primer when RAPD or PFGE, respectively, is applied for the detection of DNA polymorphisms.     

Genome macrorestriction analysis of diversity and variability of Pseudomonas aeruginosa strains infecting cystic fibrosis patients.

Genome macrorestriction fingerprinting with XbaI and DraI was used to analyze the relatedness of 166 Pseudomonas aeruginosa isolates collected from 31 cystic fibrosis patients over a 1- to 20-month period and to correlate their genotype with patterns of resistance to 14 antimicrobial agents. Quantitative comparison of intra- and interpatient similarities of P. aeruginosa macrorestriction patterns disclosed two discrete ranges that clearly discriminated subclonal variation (> 80% relatedness) and clonal diversity (10 to 70% relatedness). Cloning-derived mutants exhibited up to 20% divergence of genomic macrorestriction patterns during the course of chronic colonization of individual patients. Change of susceptibility to multiple antimicrobial agents developed in 50% of sequential pairs of isolates from individual patients. Only 19% of these susceptibility changes were attributable to strain substitution, while the majority (56%) of resistance changes were associated with minor genomic variations of a persistent strain. Sixty-six percent of patients harbored one strain, and 33% carried two strains. Three common strains colonized 5 (28%) of 18 patients attending a cystic fibrosis clinic, and another two strains colonized two patient pairs (31%) of 13 patients staying at a rehabilitation center, suggesting potential cross-infection in these settings. By indexing regional polymorphisms throughout the chromosome structure, macrorestriction analysis can monitor subclonal evolution of P. aeruginosa and identify isogenic resistance mutants. Quantitative macrorestriction fingerprinting enables discrimination between clonal variants and clones of distinct origins and should therefore provide a reliable tool for investigating the mode of acquisition of P. aeruginosa in cystic fibrosis patients.     

Multilocus sequence typing compared to pulsed-field gel electrophoresis for molecular typing of Pseudomonas aeruginosa

For hospital epidemiologists, determining a system of typing that is discriminatory is essential for measuring the effectiveness of infection control measures. In situations in which the incidence of resistant Pseudomonas aeruginosa is increasing, the ability to discern whether it is due to patient-to-patient transmission versus an increase in patient endogenous strains is often made on the basis of molecular typing. The present study compared the discriminatory abilities of pulsed-field gel electrophoresis (PFGE) and multilocus sequence typing (MLST) for 90 P. aeruginosa isolates obtained from cultures of perirectal surveillance swabs from patients in an intensive care unit. PFGE identified 85 distinct types and 76 distinct groups when similarity cutoffs of 100% and 87%, respectively, were used. By comparison, MLST identified 60 sequence types that could be clustered into 11 clonal complexes and 32 singletons. By using the Simpson index of diversity (D), PFGE had a greater discriminatory ability than MLST for P. aeruginosa isolates (D values, 0.999 versus 0.975, respectively). Thus, while MLST was better for detecting genetic relatedness, we determined that PFGE was more discriminatory than MLST for determining genetic differences in P. aeruginosa.     

Genome macrorestriction analysis of sequential Pseudomonas aeruginosa isolates from bronchiectasis patients without cystic fibrosis.

The respiratory tracts of bronchiectasis patients may be persistently colonized with Pseudomonas aeruginosa, despite intensive chemotherapy. The organism may undergo phenotypic changes in these patients, providing misleading typing results by conventional methods. We prospectively studied eight bronchiectasis patients without cystic fibrosis over a period of 1 year. A high microbial load of P. aeruginosa was found in 70% of sputum samples collected. Of these, 55 sequential P. aeruginosa isolates were characterized by a genotyping method, pulsed-field gel electrophoresis, to overcome the problem of differentiating the P. aeruginosa strains during chemotherapy. Genome macrorestriction fingerprinting patterns were analyzed after digestion with XbaI restriction endonuclease. Of the eight patients, six harbored a single dominant strain of P. aeruginosa, with an intrapatient macrorestriction similarity pattern range of 96 to 100%. The other two patients were infected with mixed bacterial isolates including P. aeruginosa. However, diversity was observed in the P. aeruginosa isolates from all eight patients, with a relatedness of only 55 to 65%. The study further strengthens the fact that pulsed-field gel electrophoresis can be used efficiently and effectively to differentiate P. aeruginosa strains in bronchiectasis patients without cystic fibrosis.     

Comparison of three typing methods for Pseudomonas aeruginosa isolates from patients with cystic fibrosis

The aim of this study was to compare two traditional pattern matching techniques, pulsed-field gel electrophoresis (PFGE) and random amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD), with the more reproducible technique of multilocus sequence typing (MLST) to genotype a blinded sample of Pseudomonas aeruginosa isolates from cystic fibrosis (CF) patients. A blinded sample of 48 well-characterized CF P. aeruginosa isolates was genotyped by PFGE, RAPD, and MLST, each performed in a different laboratory. The discriminatory power and congruence between the methods were compared using the Simpson’s index, Rand index, and Wallace coefficient. PFGE and MLST had the greatest congruence with the highest Rand index (0.697). The discriminatory power of PFGE, RAPD, and MLST were comparable, with high Simpson’s indices (range 0.973–0.980). MLST identified the most clonal relationships. When clonality was defined as agreement between two or more methods, MLST had the greatest predictive value (100?%) in labeling strains as unique, while PFGE had the greatest predictive value (96?%) in labeling strains as clonal. This study demonstrated the highest level of agreement between PFGE and MLST in genotyping P. aeruginosa isolates from CF patients. MLST had the greatest predictive value in identifying strains as unique and, thus, has the potential to be a cost-efficient, high-throughput, first-pass typing method.     

Nonopsonic phagocytosis of strains of Pseudomonas aeruginosa from cystic fibrosis patients

Pseudomonas aeruginosa is the predominant respiratory pathogen in patients with cystic fibrosis, but its mechanism of persisting in pulmonary secretions is poorly understood. We observed that three nonmucoid cystic fibrosis P. aeruginosa strains were phagocytized and one strain resisted phagocytosis by human polymorphonuclear leukocytes in the absence of serum. Phagocytosis was assessed by luminol-enhanced chemiluminescence, inspection of stained smears, bactericidal assay, reduction of nitroblue tetrazolium dye, and electron microscopy. Phagocytosis, determined by visual inspection, occurred at 35 degrees C but not at 4 degrees C. Nonopsonic phagocytosis was inhibited most efficiently by D-mannose, mannose-containing saccharides, and D-fructose. Opsonin-dependent phagocytosis of P. aeruginosa and of zymosan was not markedly inhibited by mannose, suggesting different leukocyte receptors for nonopsonic and opsonic phagocytosis.     

Multicenter evaluation of arbitrarily primed PCR for typing of Staphylococcus aureus strains.

Fifty-nine isolates of Staphylococcus aureus and a single strain of Staphylococcus intermedius were typed by arbitrarily primed PCR (AP-PCR). To study reproducibility and discriminatory abilities, AP-PCR was carried out in seven laboratories with a standardized amplification protocol, template DNA isolated in a single institution, and a common set of three primers with different resolving powers. The 60 strains could be divided into 16 to 30 different genetic types, depending on the laboratory. This difference in resolution was due to differences in technical procedures (as shown by the deliberate introduction of experimental variables) and/or the interpretation of the DNA fingerprints. However, this did not hamper the epidemiologically correct clustering of related strains. The average number of different genotypes identified exceeded those of the more traditional typing strategies (F. C. Tenover, R. Arbeit, G. Archer, J. Biddle, S. Byrne, R. Goering, G. Hancock, G. A. Hebert, B. Hill, R. Hollis, W. R. Jarvis, B. Kreiswirth, W. Eisner, J. Maslow, L. K. McDougal, J. M. Miller, M. Mulligan, and M. A. Pfaller, J. Clin. Microbiol. 32:407-415, 1994). Comparison of AP-PCR with pulsed-field gel electrophoresis (PFGE) indicated the existence of strains with constant PFGE types but variable AP-PCR types. The reverse (constant AP-PCR and variable PFGE patterns) was also observed. This indicates additional resolution for combined analyses. It is concluded that AP-PCR is well suited for genetic analysis and monitoring of nosocomial spreading of staphylococci. The interlaboratory reproducibility of DNA-banding patterns and the intralaboratory standardization need improvement.     

Molecular typing of nosocomial strains of Legionella pneumophila by arbitrarily primed PCR.

Arbitrarily primed PCR with two different primers was compared with ribotyping and monoclonal antibody analysis for typing Legionella strains. Applied to 11 epidemiologically unrelated strains, arbitrarily primed PCR resulted in an index of discrimination of 100% with both primers. It was found able to identify an epidemic clone of Legionella pneumophila serogroup 1 that was isolated from both patients and a hot water circuit of the same hospital.     

Direct sputum analysis of Pseudomonas aeruginosa macrorestriction fragment genotypes in patients with cystic fibrosis

The distribution of bacterial populations in the airways of 13 patients with cystic fibrosis who were colonized for 6 – 23 years with Pseudomonas aeruginosa was investigated by genotyping of bacterial chromosomes directly isolated from 21 sputa. After removal of host material from sputum by hypotonic cell lysis and repetitive washing and centrifugation steps, agarose-embedded bacterial cells were lysed, residual eukaryotic DNA separated by field inversion gel electrophoresis, and the purified bacterial chromosomes subjected to macrorestriction fragment pattern and Southern analyses. Bacterial populations consisted of a single P. aeruginosa clone in 17 sputa, of which more than one clonal variant was apparent in two SpeI fragment fingerprints. Two clones of P. aeruginosa and another species co-existed in four samples. Genomically homogeneous populations of P. aeruginosa are characteristic for chronically colonized lungs in most cases of cystic fibrosis. Received: 25 April 1997     

PCR ribotyping and arbitrarily primed PCR for typing strains of Clostridium difficile from a Polish maternity hospital.

Detection of the source of Clostridium difficile strains is of importance for the control of the nosocomial spread of this microorganism. For this purpose, vaginal and rectal swabs from 183 mothers, duplicate fecal samples (taken on days 1 and 4 after birth) from 183 neonates, and 94 environmental samples were cultured for C. difficile. The microorganism was never detected in the meconium obtained on day 1 after birth. On the other hand, an incidence of 17% C. difficile positivity was noted in the fecal samples obtained on day 4 after birth. Forty-two percent of the 31 colonized neonates had been delivered with complications. The bacteria were never encountered in the rectal swabs of the mothers, and C. difficile was identified in only one vaginal swab. In contrast, 13% of the environmental samples were positive for C. difficile. No major difference was encountered between patient and environmental isolates with respect to toxigenicity (58 to 65% toxigenic isolates). All strains were subsequently typed by PCR amplification of the 16S-23S ribosomal intergenic spacer regions and by arbitrarily primed PCR (AP-PCR) with different primers and combinations thereof. All environmental isolates and 11 of 31 neonatal strains were of a single type. The vaginal strain was unique, and among the maternity ward- and neonate-related isolates, only two additional AP-PCR types were identified. When a collection of C. difficile strains from patients hospitalized in other institutions and suffering from antibiotic-associated diarrhea or pseudomembranous colitis was analyzed in a similar manner, it appeared that the strain from the maternity ward was unique.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Pyocin typing of Pseudomonas aeruginosa isolates from children with cystic fibrosis.

Pyocin typing and serotyping of 433 strains of Pseudomonas aeruginosa from children with cystic fibrosis (CF) showed that pyocin type 9 was predominant, particularly in association with polyagglutinating serotype. The common pyocin groups, 1, 5 and 10, made up only 20% of these isolates in contrast to reported rates of up to 89% in other studies using non-CF strains. No strains of pyocin type 3 were found. Polyagglutinating strains made up 72% of strains from patients colonized with P. aeruginosa for more than 12 mths. Pyocin type 9 was associated with 93% of polyagglutinating strains. The parallel between pyocin type 9 and polyagglutinating serotype suggests that these may both be characteristics acquired by P. aeruginosa colonizing patients with CF. Because of confounding between duration of colonization and exposure to cross-infection, this study does not allow definition of the role of cross-infection in determining the characteristics of these strains in most patients. In siblings, however, evidence supports a role for cross-infection either between siblings or from a common source. In 6 pairs of siblings studied, each pair had at least 1 pyocin group in common concurrently, either at entry to the study or after an interval of several months. Identical and unusual pyocin groups were recognized in samples obtained on the same day from pairs of siblings. More studies are needed to compare results of pyocin typing with methods such as genome fingerprinting to characterize these strains and determine whether the observed distribution of pyocin groups in CF isolates is related to cross-infection or whether the combination of pyocin type 9 with polyagglutinating serotype is a characteristic of CF strains.     

Mucoid conversion by phages of Pseudomonas aeruginosa strains from patients with cystic fibrosis.

A total of 21 of 22 independent isolates of cystic fibrosis-associated Pseudomonas aeruginosa were found to be lysogenic for DNA-containing, complex capsid viruses. Several of the phages demonstrated the ability to select mucoid cells from populations of nonmucoid bacteria. Conversion to mucoid growth was more frequently achieved when phages were isolated from mucoid as opposed to nonmucoid cystic fibrosis-associated strains.     

Typing of Pseudomonas aeruginosa strains in Norwegian cystic fibrosis patients

Objectives   Typing of Pseudomonas aeruginosa isolates from Norwegian cystic fibrosis (CF) patients with chronic Pseudomonas lung infection in order to see whether cross-infection might have occurred.
Methods   Isolates from 60 patients were collected during the years 1994–98, and typed by pulsed field gel electrophoresis.
Results   Seventy-one strains were identified. One large cluster of identical strains included 27 patients, and 13 smaller clusters of 2–4 patients were found (26 patients). Seven patients had a strain not shared by other patients (private strains). Harboring the main cluster strain was significantly associated with participation in summer camps and training courses ( P  = 0.004, chi-squared test). There were no associations with regular admissions to hospital (intravenous antibiotic courses) or smaller social gatherings of short duration. Small clusters and private strains were not associated with any of the risk factors. All strains were sensitive to colistin. The minimal inhibitory concentrations were generally lower in Norwegian P. aeruginosa strains compared with isolates from Danish patients.
Conclusions   Our results indicate that cross-infection with P. aeruginosa between cystic fibrosis patients has occurred.     

Random amplified polymorphic DNA typing of Pseudomonas aeruginosa isolates recovered from patients with cystic fibrosis.

Pseudomonas aeruginosa isolates recovered from chronically colonized patients with cystic fibrosis (CF) are phenotypically different from those collected from other patients or from the environment. To assess whether alterations in motility, mucoidy, and serum susceptibility represented an adaptation to chronic infection or replacement by a new strain, sequential P. aeruginosa isolates of known phenotype collected from 20 CF patients were typed by random amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD) analysis. A total of 35 RAPD strain types were found among 385 isolates from 20 patients, and only two patients had P. aeruginosa strains of the same RAPD fingerprint. Eight strain pairs representative of the first eight RAPD types were also analyzed by SpeI macrorestriction followed by pulsed-field gel electrophoresis (PFGE); the strain types found by both fingerprinting techniques correlated exactly. In 11 of 20 patients, the RAPD types of serial P. aeruginosa isolates remained stable despite alterations in isolate motility, colonial morphology, and lipopolysaccharide phenotype. However, in isolates collected from one CF patient, a single band change in RAPD fingerprint and CeuI PFGE profile correlated with the appearance of an RpoN mutant phenotype, suggesting that the altered phenotype may have been due to a stable genomic rearrangement. Secretion of mucoid exopolysaccharide, loss of expression of RpoN-dependent surface factors, and acquisition of a serum-susceptible phenotype in P. aeruginosa appear to evolve during chronic colonization in CF patients from specific adaptation to infection rather than from acquisition of new bacterial strains.