Bone scintigraphy and radiography in young athletes with low back pain

Radiographs and bone scans of 40 young athletes with low back pain were reviewed retrospectively to correlate the imaging findings and assess the value of scintigraphy in the diagnosis of these patients. The radiographs were positive for spondylolysis with or without spondylolisthesis in 15 (38%), and scintigraphy showed focal disease in the posterior vertebral elements in 14 (35%). Five patients had positive radiographic studies but normal scans, indicating old injuries; four patients had positive scintigrams but normal radiographs, suggesting early or active injuries. The authors use radiography as the initial examination in the evaluation of patients with low back pain. Scintigraphy is most useful in early stages, when radiographs may be normal; and in cases in which the age and activity of a radiologic abnormality cannot otherwise be accurately determined before therapy.     

腰椎SPECT显像对关节突关节源性下腰痛的诊断价值

目的 探讨腰椎SPECT显像对关节突关节源性下腰痛的诊断价值.方法 2006年7月至2007年3月共35例下腰痛患者被纳入该研究,根据腰椎SPECT显像结果分为腰椎关节突关节阳性组和阴性组.阳性组行关节突关节注射治疗,阴性组行保守治疗或手术治疗.记录治疗前腰痛情况和显像阳性组随访治疗后1,3及6个月的腰痛情况,并比较分析,阴性组记录相关治疗和治疗后6个月的腰痛情况.采用SPSS 10.0软件,2组患者治疗前相应参数比较用完全随机设计的成组比较t检验,显像阳性组患者治疗前后视觉模拟比例尺(VAS)评分比较采用配对t检验.结果 腰椎SPECT显像检出关节突关节病变15例,随访行关节突关节注射治疗的14例患者(另1例因治疗后在外院又行手术治疗,排除在外),治疗后1,3和6个月疼痛缓解人数比例分别为12/14(85.7%),11/14(78.6%)和7/14(50.0%).治疗后1,3和6个月疼痛评分[VAS分别为(31.33±7.69),(38.21±10.67),(44.64±12.63)mm]与治疗前[VAS为(69.67±5.81)mm]相比差异有统计学意义(t值分别为12.55,8.36,5.54,P均<0.01).显像阴性20例,其中手术治疗3例,保守治疗17例,随访6个月14例(70.0%)患者治疗有效.结论 腰椎SPECT显像有助于检出关节突关节源性下腰痛,筛选适合行关节突关节治疗的患者,以减轻疾病症状,提高患者生活质量.     

Low back pain: prediction of short-term outcome of facet joint injection with bone scintigraphy

PURPOSE: To prospectively evaluate use of bone scintigraphy with single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) for identification of patients with low back pain who would benefit from facet joint injections. MATERIALS AND METHODS: The protocol was reviewed and approved by the institutional review board. All patients provided informed consent. Forty-seven patients (23 men and 24 women) with low back pain, who were scheduled for facet joint injections, were prospectively enrolled and randomized into groups A and B (mean ages, 43.3 and 44.2 years, respectively) with a group A-group B ratio of 2:1. Group A patients underwent bone scintigraphy with SPECT prior to injection. Group A patients with bone scans positive for facet joint abnormalities received injections at the levels where abnormalities were identified on the scan (group A1). Group A patients with negative scans (group A2) received injections at the levels that were decided as in group B. Group B patients received injections at the levels indicated by the referring physician and did not undergo bone scintigraphy. All patients completed a pain and function questionnaire before injection and at 1, 3, and 6 months afterward. The change in the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons pain scores after 1, 3, and 6 months compared with baseline scores was analyzed with analysis of variance and post hoc Bonferroni multiple-comparison tests between groups. Cost analysis was performed. RESULTS: The change in the pain score at 1 month was significantly higher (P < .004) in group A1 than it was in the other two groups. In group A1, 13 of 15 patients had improvement in pain score of greater than 1 standard deviation at 1 month, whereas improvement occurred in only two of 16 patients in group A2 and five of 16 patients in group B. In patients with positive scans, the number of facets treated with injection was decreased from 60, which was the number originally indicated by the referring physician, to 27. The Medicare cost was reduced from $2191 per patient to $1865 with the use of SPECT. CONCLUSION: Bone scintigraphy with SPECT can help identify patients with low back pain who would benefit from facet joint injections.     

Numerous sites of increased uptake shown on bone scintigraphy in a case of adult T-cell leukemia

Bone scintigraphy was performed in a 69-year-old male patient with adult T-cell leukemia suffering from right lower limb pain. Numerous sites of increased uptake were seen in the skull, left clavicle, bilateral humeri, bilateral radii and right femur and tibia. Bone radiographs showed multiple osteolytic lesions, most of which corresponded to the abnormal deposits on the bone scans with 740 MBq of^99mTc-hydroxymethylene diphosphonate. This pattern is rarely reported, but bone involvement of adult T-cell leukemia is not uncommon. Bone involvement was remarkable on the appendicular skeleton when compared with common metastatic bone tumors. Bone scintigraphy may be useful in detecting bone involvement in adult T-cell leukemia.     

Correlative radionuclide and magnetic resonance imaging in evaluation of the spine

The authors retrospectively compared magnetic resonance images and bone scintigraphy obtained from 144 patients. Fifty-six patients having a known primary malignancy were evaluated for metastases (Group 1), and 88 patients were evaluated for back pain (Group 2). Interpretation was normal in 36/144 patients (11 in Group 1 and 25 in Group 2), and similar abnormal foci were visualized in the osseous spine in 54/144 patients (32 in Group 1 and 22 in Group 2). Magnetic resonance imaging showed abnormalities in the osseous spine that were not visualized on bone scintigraphy in 43/144 patients (10 in Group 1 and 33 in Group 2); these included bone metastasis, benign neoplasm (hemangioma), Schmorl's node, intervertebral disk disease, and bone disease (osteophyte, spondylolisthesis, facet hypertrophy). In addition, magnetic resonance imaging showed epidural or paravertebral extension of the tumor or infection in 37/144 patients (30 in Group 1 and 7 in Group 2). Bone scintigraphy demonstrated abnormalities not visualized on magnetic resonance imaging in 11/144 patients (3 in Group 1 and 8 in Group 2). Bone scintigraphy showed abnormalities in locations not evaluated by magnetic resonance imaging but relevant to the symptomatology or disease in 42/144 patients (37 in Group 1 and 5 in Group 2). These data indicate that magnetic resonance imaging and bone scintigraphy are complementary. Bone scintigraphy remains the best screening procedure to show the location of abnormal areas in the spine and elsewhere in the skeleton. Magnetic resonance imaging is useful in differentiating neoplasm, infection, intervertebral disk disease, and, in some instances, degenerative bone disease.     

SPECT in the management of patients with back pain and spondylolysis

PURPOSE: Single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) bone scans of the lumbar spine were evaluated in the management of patients with low back pain and suspected spondylolysis. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Thirty-three patients (mean age, 30 years) with high clinical suspicion of pars interarticularis defects were included in the study. The results of lumbar radiographs and SPECT bone scintigraphy were compared and the influence of these results on patient management was evaluated. RESULTS: Twenty-six of the 33 patients had abnormal results of lumbar radiographs. Of the 21 patients with radiographs indicating spondylolysis, six had abnormal uptake in the pars regions on bone scintigraphy. One patient with normal results of lumbar radiographs had a SPECT bone scan showing uptake in the region of the pars interarticularis. CONCLUSIONS: SPECT bone scanning of the lumbar spine has a role in the treatment of patients with symptomatic spondylolysis.     

The prospect of incidental detection of unsuspected skeletal tuberculosis by bone scintigraphy should not be overlooked

BACKGROUND: The potential roles of bone scintigraphy in the evaluation of tuberculosis are not well-defined. It is commonly considered that skeletal tuberculosis occurs only after pulmonary tuberculosis. Bone scintigraphy was not known to be an effective imaging modality in the evaluation of skeletal tuberculosis, especially in those without known systemic tuberculosis. PURPOSE: To assess the prospect of bone scintigraphy in the detection of skeletal tuberculosis in patients who came to the department of nuclear medicine to evaluate back pain. METHODS: Patient records and the images of 1817 cases of consecutive bone scintigraphy performed for the evaluation of unknown causes of back pain were retrospectively reviewed. The imaging findings were compared with the status of tuberculosis before and after scintigraphy. RESULTS: Sixteen patients had skeletal tuberculosis confirmed by histopathological examination. Six patients had solitary while 10 had multifocal skeletal lesions. Before bone scintigraphy, 2 patients were suspected but not confirmed to have pulmonary tuberculosis, 4 were suspected to have skeletal tuberculosis by other modalities while the remaining 10 patients were not suspected to have tuberculosis in any part of the body. Following bone scintigraphy, among those 10 patients who were unsuspected of having tuberculosis, further tests demonstrated that 3 had pulmonary tuberculosis in addition to skeletal tuberculosis and 1 had cervical tuberculous lymphadenitis. In total, among those 16 patients with confirmed skeletal tuberculosis, only 6 had concurrent extraskeletal tuberculosis while 10 patients had their tuberculosis limited to the skeletal system. CONCLUSIONS: Our results indicate that pulmonary or systemic tuberculosis is not a prerequisite for skeletal tuberculosis. Skeletal tuberculosis should be among the differential diagnoses when there is a positive bone scan in patients without a malignancy in an endemic region.     

The benefit of SPECT when added to planar scintigraphy in patients with bone metastases in the spine.

PURPOSE: This study compared the efficiency of SPECT with planar bone scans in differentiating malignant from benign lesions and in detecting metastases to the spine. METHODS: Planar scintigraphy and SPECT were performed in 37 patients with low back pain without known malignancy and in 38 patients with confirmed malignancy. The type, location, and intensity of tracer accumulation were compared on the planar and SPECT scans. The malignant or benign nature of lesions was proved by radiologic methods, histologic findings, 6 month follow-up, or all of these. RESULTS: More metastases were detected by SPECT (SPECT, 58 of 64; planar, 42 of 64; P < 0.01). In three of seven patients with known malignancy who had a normal result of planar scan, only SPECT detected metastases. Fifty-nine metastases were radiologically mainly osteolytic, one was osteoblastic and four were mixed. Most lesions showed increased radioactivity (40 of 42 on planar scans vs. 45 of 58 on SPECT) and 2 of 42 (5%) vs. 12 of 58 (21%) were cold with marginally increased uptake. One of 58 metastases was a cold lesion seen on SPECT only. Lesions were more often malignant than benign when seen on SPECT in a pedicle (n = 5; malignant = 3, benign = 2), in the body and pedicle (n = 22; malignant = 14, benign = 8), within the vertebral body (n = 5; malignant = 4, benign = 1) and in the whole vertebra (n = 6; malignant = 4, benign = 2). The lesion to background ratio was higher on SPECT than on planar scans (SPECT, 2.26; planar scans, 1.86; P < 0.05 in malignant lesions). CONCLUSIONS: SPECT of the spine improved the diagnostic accuracy of bone scans when added to a planar scan in patients with known malignancy and clinical suspicion of spinal metastases when the planar scan was borderline abnormal. It helps in differentiating between benign and malignant lesions of the spine.     

Bone scintigraphy in renal osteodystrophy.

Bone scintigraphy with Tc-99m HEDP was performed in 30 patients on maintenance hemodialysis, and the results of quantitative analysis were compared with those of a normal group. To permit this comparison, elevated background activity due to the absence of renal radiotracer excretion was reduced by hemodialysis to levels found in the normals. Histologic proof of renal osteodystrophy had been obtained in all patients. The incidence of radiographic abnormalities was 46%, whereas abnormal scans were found in 25 patients (83%); skeletal lesions were also more pronounced and detected earlier. However, even when the scans appeared normal, the quantitative analysis showed increased skeletal activity in all patients. The total skeletal activity proved to be a good index of the severity of renal osteodystrophy and appeared dependent on both osteomalacia and hyperparathyroidism. These findings show that bone scintigraphy is a sensitive method to detect skeletal involvement in renal osteodystrophy.     

Use of the one-legged hyperextension test and magnetic resonance imaging in the diagnosis of active spondylolysis

Background

Active spondylolysis is an acquired lesion in the pars interarticularis and is a common cause of low back pain in the young athlete.

Objectives

To evaluate whether the one‐legged hyperextension test can assist in the clinical detection of active spondylolysis and to determine whether magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is equivalent to the clinical gold standard of bone scintigraphy and computed tomography in the radiological diagnosis of this condition.

Methods

A prospective cohort design was used. Young active subjects with low back pain were recruited. Outcome measures included clinical assessment (one‐legged hyperextension test) and radiological investigations including bone scintigraphy (with single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT)) and MRI. Computed tomography was performed if bone scintigraphy was positive.

Results

Seventy one subjects were recruited. Fifty pars interarticulares in 39 subjects (55%) had evidence of active spondylolysis as defined by bone scintigraphy (with SPECT). Of these, 19 pars interarticulares in 14 subjects showed a fracture on computed tomography. The one‐legged hyperextension test was neither sensitive nor specific for the detection of active spondylolysis. MRI revealed bone stress in 40 of the 50 pars interarticulares in which it was detected by bone scintigraphy (with SPECT), indicating reduced sensitivity in detecting bone stress compared with bone scintigraphy (p  =  0.001). Conversely, MRI revealed 18 of the 19 pars interarticularis fractures detected by computed tomography, indicating concordance between imaging modalities (p  =  0.345). There was a significant difference between MRI and the combination of bone scintigraphy (with SPECT)/computed tomography in the radiological visualisation of active spondylolysis (p  =  0.002).

Conclusions

These results suggest that there is a high rate of active spondylolysis in active athletes with low back pain. The one‐legged hyperextension test is not useful in detecting active spondylolysis and should not be relied on to exclude the diagnosis. MRI is inferior to bone scintigraphy (with SPECT)/computed tomography. Bone scintigraphy (with SPECT) should remain the first‐line investigation of active athletes with low back pain followed by limited computed tomography if bone scintigraphy is positive.     

Kohler disease: diagnoses and assessment by bone scintigraphy

Limping is a frequent occurrence in children and may be caused by various conditions, including trauma, inflammation, infection, and malignancy. Nontraumatic avascular necrosis of the tarsal bones should be included in the differential diagnosis. Accumulated data have supported the superiority of bone scans to radiography in the early diagnosis of avascular necrosis. Bone scintigraphy is a useful tool for investigating pain when symptoms, laboratory examinations, and radiography do not point to a specific diagnosis. In the early phase of disease, bone scans may demonstrate decreased tracer uptake (photopenic region), subsequently a hot area is seen during the reparative process. Although magnetic resonance imaging has important implications in the diagnosis of avascular necrosis, bone scintigraphy with its ready availability has a significant role as a primary tool in the evaluation of a limping child.     

Radionuclide bone imaging in spondylolysis of the lumbar spine in children

Bone scintigraphy and radiography were performed in seven children with back pain. Six of the children with radiographic evidence of a pars interarticularis defect also had abnormal scintigrams. Increased uptake of the bone imaging agent occurred at six of the ten sites of radiographic pars interarticularis defects, implying increased bone metabolic activity. However, the location of scintigraphic abnormalities did not correspond to the location of radiographic abnormalities in several cases. Possible explanations for the discordant findings are: (a) normal bone metabolism at the site of an old spondylolysis and (b) radiographically inapparent stress fractures. Measurements of absorbed radiation dose indicate that plain radiography, including oblique views where appropriate, has a lower absorbed radiation dose than scintigraphy or tomography and should be performed prior to these studies.     

Omission of bone scanning according to staging guidelines leads to futile therapy in non-small cell lung cancer

The leading European and American professional societies recommend that bone scans (BS) should be performed in the staging of lung cancer only in those patients with bone pain. This prospective study investigated the sensitivity of conventional skeletal scintigraphy in detecting osseous metastases in patients with lung cancer and addressed the potential consequences of failure to use this method in the work-up of asymptomatic patients. Subsequent to initial diagnosis of non-small cell lung cancer, 100 patients were examined and questioned regarding skeletal complaints. Two specialists in internal medicine decided whether they would recommend a bone scan on the basis of the clinical evaluation. Skeletal scintigraphy was then performed blinded to the findings of history and physical examination. The combined results of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) of the vertebral column, positron emission tomography (PET) of skeletal bone and the subsequent clinical course served as the gold standard for the identification of osseous metastases. Bone scintigraphy showed an 87% sensitivity in the detection of bone metastases. Failure to perform skeletal scintigraphy in asymptomatic patients reduced the sensitivity of the method, depending on the interpretation of the symptoms, to 19–39%. Without the findings of skeletal scintigraphy and the gold standard methods, 14–22% of patients would have undergone unnecessary surgery or neoadjuvant therapy. On this basis it is concluded that bone scans should not be omitted in asymptomatic patients.     

Staging of patients with carcinoma of the breast by bone scans? [author's transl)

Bone scans were performed in 170 patients with widespread breast cancer and metastases which were confirmed by the clinical course. In 82% a positive x-ray and in 95% a positive bone scan could be demonstrated. In 43 patients without bone metastases the ratio of false positive scans was 5%. Seventeen out of 50 patients with early cancer had abnormal scans. In 12 cases there were metastases proven by follow-up of at least 18 months. Assuming an incidence of 25% for bone metastases in patients with early breast cancer, bone scans with a sensitivity and specificity of 95% will be valid in staging. To validate this high incidence we investigated a second group of 97 patients with early cancer in a prospective study: in only 3 cases there was an abnormal scan. Using this low incidence bone scanning is calculated to be not valid for staging of breast cancer.     

Staging bone scintigraphy in nasopharyngeal carcinoma

Bone scintigraphy was performed on 163 new cases of nasopharyngeal carcinoma without clinical evidence of distant metastases. Among the 10 abnormal bone scans one patient had radiographic skeletal metastases corresponding to the areas of increased tracer uptake. Two patients with abnormal bone scans subsequently developed radiographic metastases at the site of abnormal tracer uptake. The detection rate of asymptomatic skeletal metastases on presentation was thus 1.8% (3/163), and the predictive value of an abnormal scan for metastases 30% (3/10). Bone scintigraphy is not justified as a routine staging investigation for nasopharyngeal carcinoma, although it can be considered for a subset of patients considered at high risk of distant metastases.     

Bone scintigraphy in detection of bone invasion by oral carcinoma

Detecting osseous involvement is clinically important in the management of oral carcinoma. Thirtyone patients with osseous involvement due to oral carcinoma who underwent panoramic radiography and bone scintigraphy were evaluated retrospectively. Bone scintigraphy confirmed osseous involvement in all 31 (100%) of these patients. In 27 (87%) of 31 patients with osseous involvement, both the panoramic radiogram and bone scintigram were positive. In the remaining four patients (13%), bone scintigram was positive for mandibular or maxillary invasion, while panoramic radiogram was negative. There were no instances of an abnormal radiogram with a normal bone scintigram. These findings strongly suggest that bone scintigraphy is more sensitive than panoramic radiography in detecting osseous involvement of the mandible and maxilla due to oral carcinoma. Furthermore, bone scintigraphy was a critical pre-surgical tool in determining the extent of the osseous involvement.     

Lumbosacral transitional vertebral articulation: evaluation by planar and SPECT bone scintigraphy

It has been suggested that low back pain (LBP) may arise from lumbosacral transitional vertebral articulation (LSTVA) itself. It is known that bone scintigraphy is a valuable tool for the recognition of pain arising from bone and articular diseases. Therefore we aimed to show planar and SPECT bone scintigraphic findings of LSTVA and compare them with the LBP and X-ray findings. Twenty-eight patients (aged 20-63 years) in whom LSTVA had been identified radiographically were evaluated with planar bone scintigraphy, utilizing 99mTc methylene diphosphonate; and single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) bone scintigraphy. Eighteen patients had LBP whereas 10 had not. There were 25 type IIA, one type IIB and two type IIIA LSTV articulation. On planar images, normal or non-focal minimally increased uptake superimposed on the upper sacroiliac joint was seen in patients without degenerative changes regardless of LBP whereas SPECT showed non-focal mild increased uptake on the area medial to the upper sacroiliac joint. Planar scans showed normal to non-focal mild, and mild-to-moderately increased uptake whereas SPECT demonstrated focal mild-to-moderately and markedly increased uptake in patients with degenerative changes without LBP and with LBP, respectively. The X-ray results showed an association of LBP degenerative changes, and the SPECT results showed a focal, markedly increased, uptake. We conclude that this focal, markedly increased, uptake may show the metabolically active degenerative changes of LSTV articulation and may help to reveal the pain arising from LSTVA. Therefore we propose that bone scintigraphy may be considered for the evaluation of patients with LBP thought to arise from LSTV articulation.     

Bone scintigraphy in preschool children with lower extremity pain of unknown origin.

Small children often cannot describe the location of bone pain for parents or physicians. Bone scans were performed in 56 children under five years of age with lower extremity pain and/or gait abnormalities of unknown etiology. Patients with fever, and those known to have infection, child abuse, malignancy, and/or radiographic abnormalities were excluded. Thirty patients had abnormal bone scans. Abnormalities included evidence of hip synovitis (4), femoral head avascularity (2), various proximal femoral abnormalities (3), knee synovitis (3), toddler's fracture (1), various tibial or fibular abnormalities (4), and various abnormalities of the tarsal bones (16). Tarsal bone abnormalities included four with abnormal calcaneal uptake and nine with abnormal uptake in or adjacent to the cuboid bone. Correlative imaging studies were available for 26 sites, and focal bone findings were noted at only five locations. Tarsal bone abnormalities accounted for over half of the scintigraphic abnormalities in these preschool children with gait abnormalities. Abnormal uptake in/or adjacent to the cuboid bone was common and probably represented stress injury.     

Radionuclide bone scintigraphy in the detection of significant complications after total knee joint replacement

AIM: Post-arthroplasty knee pain is common and clinically it can be difficult to identify those patients with complications requiring active treatment. The aim of this study was to determine the usefulness of(99)Tc(m)-MDP bone scintigraphy. METHOD: A retrospective study of all patients having a(99)Tc(m)-MDP bone scintigram for a painful knee arthroplasty between 1993 and 1999 was performed. Bone scintigrams were classified as normal or abnormal by a single observer. The results of these investigations were correlated with clinical outcome. RESULTS: Seventy-five patients with painful knee arthroplasties were referred for investigation. A total of 80 bone scintigrams were performed. The average patient age was 66.2 years (42 female and 33 male). The mean time period between surgery and onset of knee pain was 3 years. A final clinical diagnosis based on arthroscopy, open surgery, and extended clinical follow-up was available for all patients. Forty-three (53.8%) of the scintigrams were normal and 37 (46.3%) abnormal. Two patients with a normal bone scintigram has loose prostheses. Thirteen patients with an abnormal study had normal prostheses on follow-up and these tended to be patients scanned less than a year after surgery. The sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value and negative predictive value of an unequivocally normal or abnormal bone scintigram was 92.3, 75.9, 64.9 and 95.0%, respectively. The pattern of isotope uptake in the abnormal studies was not specific enough to reliably differentiate aseptic from septic loosening. CONCLUSION: Radionuclide bone scintigraphy is useful in the assessment of the painful knee arthroplasty. A negative bone scintigram is reassuring and makes loosening or infection unlikely.     

Evaluation of plantar fasciitis by three-phase bone scintigraphy

Fifteen patients complaining of chronic heel pain underwent three-phase Tc-99m MDP bone scintigraphy. Ten patients demonstrated abnormal scan findings consistent with plantar fasciitis (PF) and had responded to conventional therapy. Two patients were found to have calcaneal stress fractures, and one patient demonstrated a calcaneal spur that required no treatment. The remaining two patients had normal scans and did not appear clinically to have PF. The three-phase bone scan is therefore very useful in diagnosing PF and in distinguishing it from other etiologies of the painful heel syndrome.