Reflex and intrinsic changes induced by fatigue of human elbow extensor muscles

Fatigue-induced changes in intrinsic and reflex properties of human elbow extensor muscles and the underlying mechanisms for fatigue compensation were investigated. The elbow joint was perturbed using small-amplitude and pseudorandom movement patterns while subjects maintained steady levels of mean joint extension torque. Intrinsic and reflex properties were identified simultaneously using a nonlinear delay differential equation model. Intrinsic joint properties were characterized by measures of joint stiffness, viscous damping, and limb inertia and reflex properties characterized by measures of dynamic and static reflex gains. Fatigue was induced using 15 min of intermittent voluntary isometric (submaximal) exercise, and a rest period of 10 min was taken to allow the fatigued muscles to recover from acute fatigue effects. Identical experimental and data analysis procedures were used before and after fatigue. Our findings were that after fatigue, joint stiffness was significantly reduced at higher torque levels, presumably reflecting the reduced force-generating capacity of fatigued muscles. Conversely, joint viscosity was increased after fatigue potentially because of the reduced crossbridge detachment rate and prolonged relaxation associated with intracellular acidosis accompanying fatigue. Static stretch reflex gain decreased significantly at higher torque levels after fatigue, indicating that the isometric fatiguing exercise might be associated with a preferential change in properties of spindle chain fibers and bag(2) fibers. For matched pre- and postfatigue torque levels, dynamic reflexes contributed relatively more torque after fatigue, displaying higher dynamic reflex gains and larger dynamic electromyographic responses elicited by the controlled small-amplitude position perturbations. These changes appear to counteract the fatigue-induced reductions in joint stiffness and static reflex gain. The compensatory responses could be partly due to the effects of increasing the number of active motoneurons innervating the fatiguing muscles. This shift in operating point gave rise to significant compensation for the loss of contractile force. The compensation could also be due to fusimotor adjustment, which could make the dynamic reflex gain much less sensitive to fatigue than intrinsic stiffness. In short, the reduced contribution from intrinsic stiffness to joint torque was compensated by increased contribution from dynamic stretch reflexes after fatigue.     

Neural compensation for muscular fatigue: evidence for significant force regulation in man

We have investigated the role of reflex regulation of muscle force in normal human subjects by comparing changes in the stretch-evoked increments in elbow joint flexor electromyogram (EMG) and elbow joint torque before and after fatigue. Elbow flexor muscle fatigue was induced by repetitive voluntary isometric contractions. To assess the appropriateness of the EMG signal as an index of neural excitation of muscle under fatiguing conditions, we examined the time course of recovery of joint torque and EMG power spectrum following fatigue. Fatigue-related changes in the EMG power spectra recovered within 5-10 min after fatiguing exercise was terminated, yet the muscle weakness induced by the exercise lasted greater than 7 h and was substantial in magnitude. The decoupling of torque and EMG recovery allowed us to compare pre- and postfatigue EMG stretch responses without adjusting for differences in EMG spectral content. Torque and EMG responses to stretch were quantified by time-averaging over 250-ms "isometric" and "steady-state" periods, just before and just after a ramp angular stretch of the elbow joint, respectively. The torque increment elicited by stretch was lower following fatigue in seven of eight experiments. However, the average decrease of 20.13 +/- 14.42% in these seven subjects was somewhat smaller than the corresponding average shift in the slope of the isometric EMG-torque relationship of 85.84 +/- 90.29% (n = 8). Furthermore, the stretch-induced EMG increment was larger following fatigue in all eight sessions (average of 56.14 +/- 28.96%, n = 8), with six of the shifts reaching statistical significance for alpha = 0.05. Because the pattern of torque and EMG responses before and after fatigue suggested the presence of an active force regulator, we used a simple model of the neuromuscular system to estimate a loop gain value for each session. When pre- and postfatigue responses were matched by isometric background torque level, an average loop gain value of 7.9 was computed, whereas for responses matched by average prestretch EMG level, the loop gain estimates averaged 2.1. Although our assessment of force regulation was essentially static and derived from the responses to a single type of perturbation, the change in the incremental torque and EMG stretch responses indicates that meaningful neural compensation for fatigue occurred. Moreover, the loop gain estimates derived from these responses are an order of magnitude larger than those previously reported in animal models, suggesting that force regulation may be important in the control of human muscle contraction.     

Neural control: novel evaluation of stretch reflex sensitivity

We evaluated the stretch reflex activities of the elbow flexor and extensor muscles considering the relationship between the reflex electromyographic (EMG) responses and their corresponding standardized muscle stretch velocities. Specifically, muscular stretch velocity was estimated by using ultrasonograms. Stretch reflex EMG responses were elicited in the biceps brachii, brachioradialis and triceps brachii with a ramp-and-hold rotation at the elbow joint, which consisted of various angular velocities for the extension- or flexion-direction. The whole muscle stretch velocity induced by each ramp-and-hold rotation was calculated on the basis of fibre length changes associated with the elbow joint angle. A linear regression equation was fitted to the relation between the whole muscle stretch velocity and the reflex EMG responses, and the variables from the equation were used to quantify sensitivity of each reflex EMG component. The reflex EMG responses were increased as the ramp-and-hold rotational velocity increased. There were no significant differences in the recorded magnitudes of reflex EMG responses with equivalent joint rotational velocity between the brachioradialis and the triceps brachii medial head. These muscles showed the highest reflex responses in the flexor and extensor muscles, respectively. To the contrary, the reflex EMG response elicited by the standardized muscle stretches was significantly greater in the extensor muscles, indicating a higher reflex sensitivity. This was because of the lower muscle stretch velocity of the triceps brachii with an equivalent elbow joint rotation. The stretch reflex sensitivity in both the elbow flexor and extensor muscles might be regulated so as to make the reflex responses the same when the equivalent joint rotational velocity is applied to these muscles.     

Isometric torque-angle relationship and movement-related activity of human elbow flexors: implications for the equilibrium-point hypothesis

Since the moment arms for the elbow-flexor muscles are longest at intermediate positions of the elbow and shorter at the extremes of the range of motion, it was expected that the elbow torque would also show a peak at an intermediate angle provided the activity of the flexor muscles remained constant. We measured the isometric elbow torque at different elbow angles while the subject attempted to keep constant the electromyographic activity (EMG) of the brachioradialis muscle. The torque-angle relationship thus obtained exhibited a peak, as expected, but the shape of the relationship varied widely among subjects. This was due in part to differences in the variation of the biceps brachii EMG with elbow angle among the different subjects. The implications of these observations for the equilibrium-point hypothesis of movement were investigated as follows. The subject performed elbow movements in the presence of an external torque (which tended to extend the elbow joint) provided by a weight-and-pulley arrangement. We found in the case of flexion movements that invariably there was a transient increase in flexor EMG, as would seem necessary for initiating the movement. However, the steady-state EMG after the movement could be greater or less than the pre-movement EMG. Specifically, the least flexor EMG was required for equilibrium in the intermediate range of elbow angles, compared to the extremes of the range of motion. The EMG-angle relationship, however, varied with the muscle and the subject. The observation that the directions of change in the transient and the steady-state EMG are independent of each other militates against the generality of the equilibrium-point hypothesis. However, a form of the hypothesis which includes the effects of the stretch reflex is not contradicted by this observation.     

Differences in stretch reflex responses of elbow flexor muscles during shortening, lengthening and isometric contractions

Stretch reflexes were evoked in elbow flexor muscles undergoing three different muscle contractions, i.e. isotonic shortening (SHO) and lengthening (LEN), and isometric (ISO) contractions. The intermuscle relationships for the magnitude of the stretch reflex component in the eletromyographic (EMG) activities of two main elbow flexor muscles, i.e. the biceps brachii (BB) and the brachioradialis (BRD), were compared among the three types of contractions. The subjects were requested to move their forearms sinusoidally (0.1?Hz) against a constant pre-load between elbow joint angles of 10° (0°?=?full extension) and 80° during SHO and LEN, and to keep an angle of 45° during the ISO. The perturbations were applied at the elbow angle of 45° in pseudo-random order. The EMG signals were rectified and averaged over a period of 100?ms before and 400?ms after the onset of the perturbation 40–50 times. From the ensemble averaged EMG waveform, the background activity (BGA), short (20–50?ms) and long latency (M2, 50–80, M3, 80–100?ms) reflex and voluntary activity (100–150?ms) components were measured. The results showed that both BGA and reflex EMG activity of the two elbow flexor muscles were markedly decreased during the lengthening contraction compared to the SHO and ISO contractions. Furthermore, the changes of reflex EMG components in the BRD muscle were more pronounced than those in the BB muscle, i.e. the ratios of M2 and M3 magnitudes between BRD and BB (BRD:BB) were significantly reduced during the LEN contractions. These results would suggest that the gain of long latency stretch reflex EMG activities in synergistic muscles might be modulated independently according to the model of muscle contraction.     

Effect of Muscle Biomechanics on the Quantification of Spasticity

The impact of muscle biomechanics on spasticity was assessed by comparison of the reflex responses of the elbow and metacarpophalangeal (MCP) flexor muscles in individuals with chronic spastic hemiplegia following stroke. Specifically, methods were developed to quantify reflex responses and to normalize these responses for comparison across different muscle groups. Stretch reflexes were elicited in the muscles of interest by constant velocity ramp-and-hold stretches at the corresponding joint. The muscles were initially passive, with the joint placed in a midrange position. Estimates of biomechanical parameters were used to convert measured reflex joint torque and joint angle into composite flexor muscle stress and stretch. We found that the stretch reflex response for the MCP muscle group had a 74% greater mean stiffness modulus than that for the elbow muscle group, and that the reflex threshold was initiated at an 80% shorter mean muscle stretch. However, we determined that initial normalized fiber length was significantly greater for the experiments involving the MCP muscles than for those involving the elbow muscles. Increasing the initial composite fiber length of the elbow flexors produced significant reduction of the reflex threshold (p < 0.001), while decreasing the initial length of the MCP flexors significantly reduced their measured reflex stiffness (p < 0.001). Thus, biomechanical parameters of muscle do appear to have an important effect on the stretch reflex in individuals with impairment following stroke, and this effect should be accounted for when attempting to quantify spasticity. © 2001 Biomedical Engineering Society. PAC01: 8719Rr     

Transient reversal of the stretch reflex in human arm muscles.

1. Load perturbation responses can violate the law of reciprocal innervation between antagonist muscles under particular conditions. Thus flexor and extensor muscles of wrist and elbow joints are reflexly coactivated by the impact of a ball on the hand during a catching task. The aim of this study was to determine whether reflex coactivation can be preset within the central nervous system (CNS) or whether it is entirely due to the peripheral stimulus. To this end, we studied the behavior of stretch reflex responses of arm muscles evoked by torque motor perturbations applied before and during the catching task. 2. Subjects were instructed to catch a ball dropped from 1.6 m. A torque motor delivered perturbations to the elbow joint, resulting in angular motion at both elbow and wrist joints because of their dynamic mechanical coupling. Two series of experiments were performed that differed in the perturbation waveform. In the first series, a single torque pulse could be randomly applied at different times during the task. The corresponding responses were recovered by subtracting the average of the unperturbed trials from the averages of perturbed trials. In the second series of experiments, a train of pseudorandom pulses was applied continuously during each trial. The time-varying impulse responses were computed at 20-ms intervals by cross-correlation methods. 3. The pattern of the short-latency electromyographic responses evoked by either single pulses or pseudorandom perturbations obeyed the law of reciprocal innervation of antagonist muscles under basal conditions. However, the pattern of the responses evoked by the same perturbations around the time of ball impact on the hand consisted of a substantial coactivation of both stretched and shortening muscles. Reflex coactivation resulted from response patterns that differed at different joints. At the elbow, reflex coactivation resulted from a transient reversal of the direction of the short-latency responses of flexor muscles, with little changes of the responses of extensor muscles. At the wrist, instead, reflex coactivation resulted from simultaneous changes in the response waveform of both flexor and extensor muscles. 4. The peripheral conditions associated with the applied perturbations were constant before the time of ball impact. Thus, because the changes of the stretch reflex responses began before that time, they must have been generated within the CNS. It is here hypothesized that the reversal of the reflex responses is centrally gated by switching from the pathways of reciprocal inhibition to those of coactivation of antagonist alpha-motoneurons.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

Reflex Torque Response to Movement of the Spastic Elbow: Theoretical Analyses and Implications for Quantification of Spasticity

A parametric model of the human reflex torque response to a large-amplitude, constant angular velocity elbow extension was developed in order to help quantify spasticity in hemiparetic stroke patients, and to better understand its pathophysiology. The model accounted for the routinely observed leveling of torque (i.e., a plateau) at a mean angular increment of 51°±10° s.d. (n=98) after the initial rise. This torque plateau was observed in all eight subjects, and in 98 of 125 trials across 25 experimental sessions. The occurrence of this plateau cannot be explained by decreases in elbow flexor moment arms during elbow extension. Rather, the plateau is attributable to a consistent leveling in muscle activation as confirmed both qualitatively from recordings of rectified, smoothed electromyograph (EMG) activity, and quantitatively using an EMG coefficient model. A parametric model was developed in which the pattern of muscle activation in the stretch reflex response of elbow flexors was described as a cumulative normal distribution with respect to joint angle. Two activation functions, one related to biceps and the other to brachioradialis/brachialis, were incorporated into the model in order to account for observations of a bimodal angular stiffness profile. The resulting model yielded biologically plausible parameters of the stretch reflex response which may prove useful for quantifying spasticity. In addition, the model parameters had clear pathophysiological analogs, which may help us understand the nature of the stretch reflex response in spastic muscles. © 1999 Biomedical Engineering Society. PAC99: 8719Rr, 8719Xx, 8719St, 8719Nn, 8719Ff, 8710+e     

A re-examination of the effects of instruction on the long-latency stretch reflex response of the flexor pollicis longus muscle

We re-examined the issue of how a subject's intention to react to a joint perturbation may modulate the long-latency M2 stretch reflex response. The experiments were done on the flexor pollicis longus muscle (FPL) of the human thumb, for which there is evidence that its M2 reflex response is mediated, at least in part, by a pathway that traverses the motor cortex. The participation of the cerebral cortex in the genesis of the M2 reflex response may allow for a modulation of its amplitude, based on the intention of the subject. To test whether the M2 response is genuinely modulated by the subject's intention, we examined the magnitude of this response as a function of the FPL background level of activation, measured by the surface rectified and filtered EMG. The subject was instructed either to oppose the perturbation as quickly as possible, not to react, or to relax as quickly as possible after the onset of the perturbation. The time integral of the long latency FPL EMG response, computed between 40 and 70 ms following the onset of stretch, was plotted against the mean torque produced by the distal inter-phalangeal joint of the thumb, or against the mean background FPL EMG. There were no significant differences in the FPL M2 EMG responses for different instructions. The amplitude of the reflex response was dependent only — in an approximately linear manner — on the background level of muscle activation. The total joint stiffness (intrinsic plus reflex) was also calculated for each combination of instruction and background torque. This variable was calculated over a time interval (from 75 to 105 ms) that included the torque due to the M2 reflex response superimposed on the background torque, but was well before any voluntary reaction. Again, there were no significant differences in joint stiffness as a result of the instruction. We therefore conclude that, despite a cortical contribution to the M2 stretch reflex response, this response is not influenced by the intention of the subject on how to react to a perturbation.     

Identification of Static and Dynamic Components of Reflex Sensitivity in Spastic Elbow Flexors Using a Muscle Activation Model

Static and dynamic components of the stretch reflex were studied in elbow flexors of 13 hemiparetic brain-injured individuals. Constant-velocity joint rotations were applied to the elbow, and the resulting stretch reflex torque and electromyographic responses were recorded in the biceps brachii and brachioradialis muscles. Ten elbow extension velocities between 6 and 150 ° s^-1 were applied in random order. The resulting reflex torque response was plotted as a function of elbow angle and fitted with a mathematical model designed to depict elbow flexor activation. We found that four of the six model parameters were essentially independent of test velocity. Conversely, 73% (19/26) of cases involving the other two model parameters were dependent on velocity of joint extension (p<0.05). We conclude from these results that four of the model parameters reflect the static reflex response while the two remaining velocity-dependent parameters reflect the dynamic reflex response. To describe overall velocity dependence of stretch reflexes in spastic elbow muscles, the two dynamic reflex parameters were fitted to a fractional exponential function of velocity, similar to a model previously used to describe spindle firing rate in the cat hindlimb. We found that the mean velocity exponent of the dynamic reflex parameters was 0.24 + 0.17 (s.d.) (N = 13), a value similar to that for muscle spindle velocity sensitivity in reduced animal preparations. We conclude that both static and dynamic reflex sensitivities can be measured by examining different aspects of the torque/angle relation associated with the reflex response to a large-amplitude ramp stretch of the elbow. © 2001 Biomedical Engineering Society. PAC01: 8719St, 8719Ff, 8710+e     

A re-examination of the effects of instruction on the long-latency stretch reflex response of the flexor pollicis longus muscle

We re-examined the issue of how a subject’s intention to react to a joint perturbation may modulate the long-latency M2 stretch reflex response. The experiments were done on the flexor pollicis longus muscle (FPL) of the human thumb, for which there is evidence that its M2 reflex response is mediated, at least in part, by a pathway that traverses the motor cortex. The participation of the cerebral cortex in the genesis of the M2 reflex response may allow for a modulation of its amplitude, based on the intention of the subject. To test whether the M2 response is genuinely modulated by the subject’s intention, we examined the magnitude of this response as a function of the FPL background level of activation, measured by the surface rectified and filtered EMG. The subject was instructed either to oppose the perturbation as quickly as possible, not to react, or to relax as quickly as possible after the onset of the perturbation. The time integral of the long latency FPL EMG response, computed between 40 and 70 ms following the onset of stretch, was plotted against the mean torque produced by the distal inter-phalangeal joint of the thumb, or against the mean background FPL EMG. There were no significant differences in the FPL M2 EMG responses for different instructions. The amplitude of the reflex response was dependent only - in an approximately linear manner - on the background level of muscle activation. The total joint stiffness (intrinsic plus reflex) was also calculated for each combination of instruction and background torque. This variable was calculated over a time interval (from 75 to 105 ms) that included the torque due to the M2 reflex response superimposed on the background torque, but was well before any voluntary reaction. Again, there were no significant differences in joint stiffness as a result of the instruction. We therefore conclude that, despite a cortical contribution to the M2 stretch reflex response, this response is not influenced by the intention of the subject on how to react to a perturbation.     

Stretch reflexes and joint dynamics in rheumatoid arthritis

In clinically diagnosed rheumatoid arthritis (RA), studies were conducted to investigate the reflex and passive tissue contribution to measured increases in joint stiffness in the resting upper limb and during constant contractions of an attached muscle. The tonic stretch reflex was induced by a servo-controlled sinusoidal stretch perturbation of the metacarpophalangeal joint of RA patients, and age- and sex-matched controls. The resulting reflexes and mechanical changes in the RA affected joint were explored. Surface electromyographic (EMG) measurements were obtained from first dorsal interosseus muscle. Reflex gain (EMG/joint angle amplitude ratio), phase difference (reflex delay after stretch), coherence square (proportion of EMG variance accounted for by joint angle changes), joint mechanical gain (torque–joint angle amplitude ratio) and mechanical phase difference (torque response delay after stretch) were determined. RA patients showed decreased reflex gain that was partly due to coexistent severe muscle weakness, as determined from maximum voluntary contraction and grip pressure estimates. The decreased reflex gain was most evident at high stretch frequency suggesting a disproportionate loss of the large diameter afferent response and also increased reflex delay in the patients. These changes ensemble suggest significant loss of neural drive to the motor unit population. Patients also showed increased joint stiffness (measured as torque gain) in the contracting muscle, but there was no evidence of reflex activity or increased stiffness at rest. This suggests that the increased joint stiffness in RA was due to changes in the mechanical properties of the active muscle–joint system rather than changes in reflex properties.     

Stretch reflex responses in the human elbow joint during a voluntary movement.

1. The responsiveness of the stretch reflex is modulated during human voluntary limb movements. The influence of this modulation on the limb mechanical properties (stiffness) was investigated. 2. Subjects were taught to replicate accurately a rapid (4.0 rad s-1) targeted elbow flexion movement of 1 rad. From the onset of 12% of the trials a sinusoidal position disturbance (0.05 rad) was superimposed on the normal (trained) movement trajectory. The net joint torque (muscle torque) resisting these stretches was computed from measurements of applied torque, acceleration and limb inertia. Electromyographic (EMG) responses in the triceps brachii (TB), brachialis (Br) and biceps brachii (BB) were monitored. 3. The EMG responses to sinusoidal stretches applied early in the movement were less than those responses to perturbations applied when the arm neared the target (especially in the antagonist muscle TB). These EMG responses caused fluctuations in the resistance to the perturbation (stiffness), as described below. 4. When the perturbation frequency was low (< 4 Hz) the resistance of the elbow muscles to the stretch increased as the arm approached the target (48% increase). In contrast, when the stretch frequency was 7 Hz the resistance decreased by 63%. This decrease can be explained by the increased reflex response, since at 7 Hz the reflex response is probably timed so that it assists, rather than resists, the stretching as a result of loop delays. This reflex timing was confirmed by observing that, after abruptly stopping the sinusoidal stretch, the reflex response persisted for 100 ms and was indeed in a direction that would have reduced the resistance, had the perturbation continued. 5. The time course of the net muscle stiffness was estimated for frequencies ranging from 4 to 8 Hz and for each 40 ms interval a Nyquist plot was constructed, forming a C-shaped curve as frequency was varied. The size of this curve gave a measure of the stiffness resulting from reflex activity. When the arm neared the target this reflexive stiffness reached a maximum, and was probably comparable in size to the intrinsic (non-reflexive) muscle stiffness. Also, in four of the five subjects the viscous component of stiffness at 7 Hz dropped significantly below zero when the arm neared the target, again indicating that at this frequency the reflex was large and acted inappropriately.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

Habitual level of physical activity and muscle fatigue of the elbow flexor muscles in older men

Reduced muscle performance, related to the loss of muscle mass and strength, is a common and natural part of ageing. Nevertheless, it is generally believed that regular participation in activities of moderate intensity may slow down these age-related changes. This study investigated the relationship between the habitual level of physical activity (PA), assessed by the modified Baecke Questionnaire, and the mechanical and fatigue characteristics of the right elbow flexor muscles, m. biceps brachii and m. brachioradialis, in men over the age of 55 years. Muscle fatigue was quantified both by measuring the maximal voluntary contraction (MVC) torque before and after a sustained isometric contraction at 25% MVC until exhaustion, and also by the temporal changes observed in the surface electromyographic (EMG) signal recorded during the fatigue task. Results showed a decreased MVC torque at the end of the fatiguing contraction. After 20 min of recovery, the MVC force was still significantly lower than the pre-fatigue value, except for the most active subjects. Typical myoelectrical indications of fatigue were also observed: a shift in the frequency spectrum of the signal towards lower frequencies accompanied by an increase in the EMG amplitude. We concluded from this study that the level of PA was related to the absolute isometric MVC values and the measurement of neuromuscular efficiency after 20 min of recovery, but did not influence the indications of muscle fatigue during an isometric fatigue task. Electronic Publication     

Reflex and non-reflex torque responses to stretch of the human knee extensors

Reflex responses to unexpected stretches are well documented for selected muscles in both animal and human. Moreover, investigations of their possible functional significance have revealed that stretch reflexes can contribute substantially to the overall stiffness of a joint. In the lower extremity only the muscles spanning the human ankle joint have been investigated in the past. This study implemented a unique hydraulic actuator to study the contributions of the knee extensor stretch reflex to the overall knee joint torque. The quadriceps muscles were stretched at various background torques, produced either voluntarily or by electrical stimulation, and thus the purely reflex mediated torque could be calculated. The stretch had a velocity of 67°/s and an amplitude of 20°. A reflex response as measured by electromyography (EMG) was observed in all knee extensors at latencies of 26 – 36 ms. Both phasic and tonic EMG stretch responses increased with increasing background torques. Lines of best fit produced correlation coefficients of 0.59 – 0.78. This study is the first to examine the reflex contribution of the knee extensors to the total torque at background torques of 0 – 90% MVC. The contribution of the reflex mediated torque is initially low and peaked at background torques of 20 – 40% MVC. In terms of the total torque the reflex contributed 16 – 52% across all levels of background torque. It is concluded that during medium background torque levels such as those obtained during walking, the stretch reflex of the quadriceps muscle group contributes substantially to the total torque around the knee joint.     

Co-contraction modifies the stretch reflex elicited in muscles shortened by a joint perturbation

Simultaneous contraction of agonist and antagonist muscles acting about a joint influences joint stiffness and stability. Although several studies have shown that reflexes in the muscle lengthened by a joint perturbation are modulated during co-contraction, little attention has been given to reflex regulation in the antagonist (shortened) muscle. The goal of the present study was to determine whether co-contraction gives rise to altered reflex regulation across the joint by examining reflexes in the muscle shortened by a joint perturbation. Reflexes were recorded from electromyographic activity in elbow flexors and extensors while positional perturbations to the elbow joint were applied. Perturbations were delivered during isolated activation of the flexor or extensor muscles as well as during flexor and extensor co-contraction. Across the group, the shortening reflex in the elbow extensor switched from suppression during isolated extensor muscle activation to facilitation during co-contraction. The shortening reflex in the elbow flexor remained suppressive during co-contraction but was significantly smaller compared to the response obtained during isolated elbow flexor activation. This response in the shortened muscle was graded by the level of activation in the lengthened muscle. The lengthening reflex did not change during co-contraction. These results support the idea that reflexes are regulated across multiple muscles around a joint. We speculate that the facilitatory response in the shortened muscle arises through a fast-conducting oligosynaptic pathway involving Ib interneurons.     

Short- and long-latency reflex responses during different motor tasks in elbow flexor muscles

 Stretch reflex responses in three elbow flexor muscles – the brachioradialis and the short and long heads of the biceps brachii – were studied during different motor tasks. The motor tasks were iso-velocity (8 deg/s) elbow flexion movements in which the muscles performed shortening or lengthening contractions, or were isometric contractions. Care was taken to maintain constant background electromyographic (EMG) activity in the brachoradialis muscle at a 50-deg elbow angle across the tasks by changing the magnitude of the initial load. During each task, mechanical perturbations (duration 170 ms) were applied at pseudorandom intervals when the elbow angle was 50 deg. The magnitude of the perturbation was varied across tasks in order to induce an elbow extension velocity of 80 deg/s over the first 50 ms after the onset of perturbation. The stretch reflex EMG responses in all muscles varied across the three tasks, despite a constant EMG level and similar perturbation-induced angular velocity in the direction of elbow extension. In particular, both the short- and long-latency reflex EMG components were reduced during the lengthening contractions. Further, the task-dependent variations in the early (M2) and the late (M3) components of the long-latency reflex were different, i.e., the magnitude of M3 was considerably enhanced during the shortening task as compared with that of M2. These findings suggest that central modification was responsible for the task-dependent modulation of late EMG responses. Received: 24 April 1996 / Accepted: 24 January 1997     

Adaptation of the short latency component of the stretch reflex plays only a minor role in compensating for muscle fatigue induced by spontaneous hopping in humans

The influence of fatigue on the stretch reflex evoked in ankle extensor muscles by hopping was investigated in six healthy men. The men hopped on a force platform, at spontaneous frequency and amplitude, until they were unable to maintain the initial frequency or amplitude of the jumps. This task was done with the knees flexing normally during ground contact or under instructions to straighten the knees. Surface electromyograms (EMG) of soleus (SO), gastrocnemius medialis (GM), and tibialis anterior (TA) muscles were recorded simultaneously with the vertical component of the ground reaction force. Spectrum analysis of the EMG recorded during isometric tests performed immediately before and after the fatiguing hopping task demonstrated the existence of fatigue in SO and GM and often in TA. The stretch reflex was studied during the first and last ten jumps of every hopping series. The long-latency components of the reflex were too variable to be analysed. Whatever the hopping condition, latency and amplitude of the short latency component were not significantly modified by fatigue. Fatigue enhanced the occurrence of this reflex component in SO only. These data suggest that in fatiguing submaximal hopping, the neuromuscular system does not fundamentally change its stiffness regulation before the endurance time has been reached. Accepted: 1 September 2000     

Wrist muscle activation patterns and stiffness associated with stable and unstable mechanical loads

Summary The objectives of this study were to examine the effects of load mechanical characteristics and agonist-antagonist muscle cocontraction, on the stretch reflex response of wrist flexor muscles, and to measure the associated wrist stiffness. Subjects were required to maintain a constant wrist angle while operating against flexor loads with different stability characteristics (constant, elastic or unstable). We measured the stretch reflex responses and joint stiffness by applying step displacements of 3° and 10°. Subjects used very little cocontraction of wrist flexor and extensor muscles when the load was constant or elastic, but increased cocontraction dramatically when the load was unstable, in order to increase the wrist stiffness. Although the magnitude of stretch reflex responses also increased with cocontraction, this simply reflected the level of tonic flexor muscle activity. We found no evidence to suggest that phasic stretch reflexes contributed significantly to the joint stiffness in this task. Clear differences in flexor muscle synergy were observed in the presence and absence of cocontraction, particularly when comparing the FCR and FCU muscles.     

Fatigue induced changes in phasic muscle activation patterns for fast elbow flexion movements

The present study investigated how muscle fatigue influences single degree-of-freedom elbow flexion movements and their associated patterns of phasic muscle activation. Maximal unfatigued voluntary isometric elbow flexor and extensor joint torque was measured at the beginning of the experiment. Subjects then performed elbow flexion movements over two distances as fast as possible, and movements over the longer distance at an intentionally slower speed. The slower speed was close to what would become the maximal speed in the fatigued state. Subjects then performed a fatiguing protocol of 20 sustained isometric flexion contractions of 25 s duration with 5 s rest at 50% maximal unfatigued voluntary force. After a recovery period they repeated the movements. The fatigue protocol was successful in inducing muscle fatigue, the evidence being decreased isometric maximal joint torque of over 20%. Fatigued movements had lower peak muscle torque and speed. Our principal finding was of changes in the timing of the phasic patterns of fatigued muscle activation. There was an increase in the duration of the agonist burst and a delay in the timing of the antagonist muscle as measured by the centroid of the EMG signals. We conclude that these changes serve as partial but incomplete, centrally driven compensation for fatigue induced changes in muscle function. An additional, unexpected finding was how small an effect fatigue had on movement performance when using a recovery time of 10 min that is long enough to allow muscle membrane conduction velocity to return to normal. This raises questions concerning the behavioral significance of classical laboratory studies of human fatigue mechanisms.