Evaluation of arbitrarily primed polymerase chain reaction analysis for typing Legionella pneumophila

Objective: To evaluate the performance of arbitrarily primed polymerase chain reaction (AP-PCR) analysis in epidemiologic typing of Legionella pneumophila.
Methods: Sixty-two isolates of L. pneumophila of serogroups 1, 3, 6 and 10, including epidemiologically related and unrelated isolates, were analyzed by AP-PCR using the primer BG2. Twenty-six of the serogroup 1 isolates were typed by pulsed-field gel electrophoresis (PFGE).
Results: AP-PCR analysis showed 98% typeability and complete reproducibility. A majority of unrelated isolates of each serogroup could be distinguished (discrimination index: 92%). Clinical isolates showed AP-PCR patterns indistinguishable from those of the isolates of the related environmental source. PFGE and AP-PCR results were in agreement for 88% of isolates.
Conclusions: Single-primer AP-PCR analysis can be used as a simple and reproducible screening method for typing L. pneumophila strains of different serogroups.     

Molecular typing of Legionella pneumophila serogroup 1 isolates from patients and the nosocomial environment by arbitrarily primed PCR and pulsed-field gel electrophoresis.

The ubiquity of Legionella pneumophila in aquatic habitats means that epidemiological evaluation is important for the investigation and control of nosocomial outbreaks of legionellosis. Pulsed-field gel electrophoresis (PFGE) of chromosomal DNA following digestion with SfiI is considered to be one of the most discriminative methods for detecting DNA polymorphisms amongst L. pneumophila serogroup 1 (Lp1) isolates. This paper describes an arbitrarily primed PCR (AP-PCR) method with three different primers (20-mers) for detecting DNA polymorphisms of Lp1 isolates. The AP-PCR assay was compared with PFGE analysis. Both experimental methods were found to have good discriminatory power (discrimination index of 98% and 94.3%, respectively) with 27 unrelated isolates from different geographical areas collected between 1987 and 1997. Furthermore, when the AP-PCR was used in the epidemiological investigation of nosocomial cases of infection, convergent results with the three primers allowed an epidemiological link to be established between isolates from patients and their environment. The AP-PCR method, which is rapid and easy to perform, gave results at least as discriminatory as those obtained with the PFGE method and is proposed for use in the molecular typing of Lp1 outbreaks.     

Australian isolates of Legionella longbeachae are not a clonal population.

Legionella longbeachae is almost as frequent a cause of legionellosis in Australia as Legionella pneumophila, but epidemiological investigation of possible environmental sources and clinical cases has been limited by the lack of a discriminatory subtyping method. The purpose of this study was to examine the genetic variability among Australian isolates of L. longbeachae serogroup 1. Pulsed-field gel electrophoresis (PFGE) of SfiI fragments revealed three distinct pulsotypes among 57 clinical and 11 environmental isolates and the ATCC control strains of L. longbeachae serogroups 1 and 2. Each pulsotype differed by four bands, corresponding to <65% similarity. A clonal subgroup within each pulsotype was characterized by >88% similarity. The largest major cluster was pulsotype A, which included 43 clinical isolates and 9 environmental isolates and was divided into five subgroups. Pulsotypes B and C comprised smaller numbers of clinical and environmental isolates, which could each be further divided into three subgroups. The ATCC type strain of L. longbeachae serogroup 1 was classified as pulsotype B, subtype B3, while the ATCC type strain of L. longbeachae serogroup 2 was identified as a different pulsotype, LL2. SfiI macrorestriction analysis followed by PFGE showed that the Australian L. longbeachae strains are not a single clonal population as previously reported.     

Comparison of Legionella pneumophila isolates by arbitrarily primed PCR and pulsed-field gel electrophoresis: analysis from seven epidemic investigations.

Arbitrarily primed PCR (AP-PCR) and pulsed-field gel electrophoresis (PFGE) subtyping were applied to clinical and environmental isolates from seven unrelated outbreaks of Legionnaires' disease. The patterns observed with each method matched patient isolates and the epidemiologically linked source of disease for each of the seven outbreaks. PFGE allowed more discrimination among various isolates, although AP-PCR usually gave comparable results. With both methods, certain patterns appeared to predominate in the comparison of the seven outbreaks. Of five clinical isolates not associated with the outbreaks, three gave profiles distinct from those observed in the outbreaks by both methods. This suggests that there are at least two predominant subtypes of Legionella pneumophila serogroup 1 associated with outbreaks. Investigations of outbreaks of legionellosis should employ either PFGE or AP-PCR in addition to monoclonal antibody analysis.     

Comparison of ribotyping and restriction enzyme analysis using pulsed-field gel electrophoresis for distinguishing Legionella pneumophila isolates obtained during a nosocomial outbreak.

Because of the ubiquity of Legionella isolates in aquatic habitats, epidemiologic evaluation of Legionella pneumophila strains is important in the investigation and subsequent control of nosocomial outbreaks of legionellosis. In this study, ribotyping and restriction enzyme analysis by pulsed-field gel electrophoresis (PFGE) were used to compare isolates of L. pneumophila obtained from patients and the environment during a nosocomial outbreak with unrelated control strains. Restriction enzyme analysis by PFGE resolved 14 different patterns among the L. pneumophila serogroup 1 and L. pneumophila serogroup 6 isolates involved in the study. Two of the patterns were observed in the three L. pneumophila serogroup 6 isolates from patients with confirmed nosocomial infections and environmental isolates from the potable water supply, which was, therefore, believed to be the source of the patients' infections. Three more patterns that were not present in isolates from patients with legionellosis were seen in isolates from the hospital environment, demonstrating the presence of multiple strains in the hospital environment. In the outbreak, one distinct pattern occurred among the L. pneumophila serogroup 1 isolates from patients with nosocomial infections, suggesting a common source; however, the source could not be determined. By comparison, ribotyping generated five patterns. However, some control strains of both L. pneumophila serogroups 1 and 6 possessed the same ribotypes as were present in the outbreak isolates. Both techniques were used successfully to subtype the isolates obtained during the investigation of the outbreak. Furthermore, restriction enzyme analysis by PFGE was useful for subdividing ribotypes and for distinguishing strains involved in the outbreak from epidemiologically unrelated strains.     

Molecular epidemiology of an outbreak of Legionnaires' disease associated with a cooling tower in Genova-Sestri Ponente, Italy

Fatty acid profile analysis, monoclonal antibody (MAb) subtyping, pulsed-field gel electrophoresis (PFGE), arbitrarily primed polymerase chain reaction (AP-PCR), and ribotyping were used to compare clinical and environmentalLegionella pneumophila serogroup 1 isolates from an outbreak of Legionnaires' disease presumptively associated with cooling towers. According to the Oxford subtyping scheme, the MAb subtype of patients' isolates and of two strains originating from a cooling tower was Pontiac, whereas the other isolates were subtype Olda. The strains showed no intrinsic strain-to-strain difference in fatty acid profiles, and ribotyping and length polymorphism of the 16S-23S rDNA intervening regions failed to reveal any differences between the isolates. Conversely, PFGE and AP-PCR appeared to be more discriminatory, as the same genomic profile was found for the clinical and some environmental strains. Meteorologic and epidemiological data and the results of molecular analysis of theLegionella pneumophila serogroup 1 isolates support the hypothesis that the infection was transmitted from one of the cooling towers to the indoor environment of the same building, to homes in proximity that had open windows, and to the streets. In fact, the outbreak diminished and later ended after a part in the tower was replaced. This investigation demonstrates the utility of combined molecular methods (i.e., phenotypic and genomic typing) in comparing epidemiologically linked clinical and environmental isolates. Finally, the outbreak confirms the risk of Legionnaires' disease posed by cooling towers, mainly when atmospheric thermal and humidity inversions occur. This finding emphasizes the need to determine whether the source of infection is in the living or working environment or somewhere else.This work was partially supported by a grant from MURST (Ministero della Università e della Ricerca Scientifica e Tecnologica).     

A hospital-associated outbreak of Legionnaires' disease caused by Legionella pneumophila serogroup 1 is characterized by stable genetic fingerprinting but variable monoclonal antibody patterns

An outbreak of 18 pneumonia cases caused by Legionella pneumophila serogroup 1 occurred at a Swedish university hospital 1996 to 1999. Eight clinical isolates obtained by culture from the respiratory tract were compared to 20 environmental isolates from the hospital and to 21 epidemiologically unrelated isolates in Sweden, mostly from patients, by using pulsed-field gel electrophoresis (PFGE), amplified fragment length polymorphism analysis (AFLP), and monoclonal antibody (MAb) typing. All patients and most environmental isolates from the outbreak hospital belonged to the same genotypic cluster in both PFGE and AFLP. This genotype was distinctly different from other strains, including a cluster from a second hospital in a different part of the country. The MAb subtype of the outbreak clone was Knoxville except for three isolates that were Oxford. A variation in the MAb reactivity pattern was also found in a second genotypic cluster. These changes in the MAb reactivity pattern were due to the absence or presence of the lag-1 gene coding for an O-acetyltransferase that is responsible for expression of the lipopolysaccharide epitope recognized by MAb 3/1 of the Dresden Panel. In all MAb 3/1-positive strains, the lag-1 gene was present on a genetic element that was bordered by a direct repeat that showed a high degree of sequence homology. Due to this homology, the lag-1 gene region seemed to be an unstable element in the chromosome. MAb patterns are thus a valuable adjunct to genotyping methods in defining subgroups inside a genotypic cluster of L. pneumophila sg 1.     

Molecular fingerprinting of Legionella species by repetitive element PCR.

Repetitive element PCR (rep-PCR) uses outward-facing primers to amplify multiple segments of DNA located between conserved repeated sequences interspersed along the bacterial chromosome. Polymorphisms of rep-PCR amplification products can serve as strain-specific molecular fingerprints. Primers directed at the repetitive extragenic palindromic element were used to characterize isolates of Legionella pneumophila and other Legionella species. Substantial variation was seen among the rep-PCR fingerprints of different Legionella species and serogroups. More limited, but distinct, polymorphisms of the rep-PCR fingerprint were evident among epidemiologically unrelated isolates of L. pneumophila serogroup 1. Previously characterized Legionella isolates from nosocomial outbreaks were correctly clustered by this method. These results suggest the presence of repetitive extragenic palindromic-like elements within the genomes of members of the family Legionellaceae that can be used to discriminate between strains within a serogroup of L. pneumophila and between different Legionella species. rep-PCR appears to be a useful technique for the molecular fingerprinting of Legionella species.     

Molecular epidemiology of Legionella pneumophila serogroup 1

The DNA of patient and environmental isolates of Legionella pneumophila serogroup 1 was analyzed by restriction endonuclease cleavage. The electrophoretic patterns of the DNA digests of isolates from a group of patients with Legionnaires disease acquired in a hospital were indistinguishable from one another and were identical to the DNA pattern of a strain isolated from the hot water supply of the hospital. On the other hand, they were easily differentiated from strains isolated from patients and hot water supplies in other hospitals in the same city. The homogeneity of populations of L. pneumophila serogroup 1 colonizing plumbing systems was also investigated by DNA restriction endonuclease analysis in three hospitals. We distinguished two subtypes in one hospital; the two other hospitals had homogeneous populations. Restriction endonuclease digest analysis of L. pneumophila serogroup 1 DNA enables subtyping and appears to be a useful method for examining the epidemiology of outbreaks of Legionnaires disease.     

Epidemiologic subtyping of Escherichia coli serogroup O157 strains isolated in Ontario by phage typing and pulsed-field gel electrophoresis

Phage typing and DNA macrorestriction fragment analysis by pulsed-field gel electrophoresis (PFGE) were evaluated for use in the epidemiological subtyping of Escherichia coli serogroup O157 strains isolated in Ontario, Canada. Among 30 strains isolated from patients with sporadic cases of infection, 22 distinct XbaI macrorestriction patterns were identified and 17 strains exhibited unique PFGE patterns. In contrast, phage typing identified only seven different phage types and 17 strains belonged to the same phage type. A total of 25 phage type-macrorestriction pattern combinations were identified among the strains from patients with sporadic cases of infection. PFGE subtyping differentiated between unrelated strains that exhibited the same phage type, and in one group of strains, phage typing differentiated between strains of the same PFGE subtype. Both typing procedures correctly identified outbreak-related isolates as belonging to the same type in four separate outbreaks. Each outbreak strain was characterized by a distinct macrorestriction pattern, while phage typing subdivided the outbreak strains into only three different types. A small percentage of outbreak-related isolates had PFGE patterns that differed slightly (one or two DNA fragment differences) from that of the outbreak strain. On the other hand, each isolate from the same outbreak belonged to the same phage type as that of the outbreak strain. We conclude that phage typing and PFGE fingerprinting represent complementary procedures for the subtyping of E. coli serogroup O157 and that the combined use of these procedures provides optimal discrimination.     

The role of arbitrarily primed PCR in identifying the source of an outbreak of Legionnaires' disease.

An outbreak of community-acquired Legionnaires' disease (LD) occurred in Providence, R.I., in fall 1993. To find the outbreak source, exposures of 17 case patients were compared to those of 33 matched controls. Case patients were more likely than controls to have visited a section of downtown (area A) during the 2 weeks before illness (11 [65%] versus 9 [27%]; matched odds ratio, 6.5; P = 0.01). Water samples were cultured from 27 aerosol-producing devices within area A. Legionella pneumophila serogroup 1 isolates underwent monoclonal antibody (MAb) subtyping and arbitrarily primed PCR (AP-PCR). All four L. pneumophila serogroup 1 isolates available from case patients who visited area A had identical MAb and AP-PCR patterns. Among 14 environmental isolates, 5 had MAb patterns that matched the case patient isolates, but only 1 had a matching AP-PCR pattern. This investigation implicates a cooling tower in area A as the outbreak source and illustrates the usefulness of AP-PCR for identifying sources of LD outbreaks.     

Paleoepidemiologic investigation of Legionnaires disease at Wadsworth Veterans Administration Hospital by using three typing methods for comparison of legionellae from clinical and environmental sources.

Multilocus enzyme electrophoresis, monoclonal antibody typing for Legionella pneumophila serogroup 1, and plasmid analysis were used to type 89 L. pneumophila strains isolated from nosocomial cases of Legionnaires disease at the Veterans Administration Wadsworth Medical Center (VAWMC) and from the hospital environment. Twelve L. pneumophila clinical isolates, obtained from patients at non-VAWMC hospitals, were also typed by the same methods to determine typing specificity. Seventy-nine percent of 33 VAWMC L. pneumophila serogroup 1 clinical isolates and 70% of 23 environmental isolates were found in only one of the five monoclonal subgroups. Similar clustering was found for the other two typing methods, with excellent correlation between all methods. Enzyme electrophoretic typing divided the isolates into the greatest number of distinct groups, resulting in the identification of 10 different L. pneumophila types and 5 types not belonging to L. pneumophila, which probably constitute an undescribed Legionella species; 7 clinical and 34 environmental VAWMC isolates and 2 non-VAWMC clinical isolates were found to be members of the new species. Twelve different plasmid patterns were found; 95% of VAWMC clinical isolates contained plasmids. Major VAWMC epidemic-bacterial types were common in the hospital potable-water distribution system and cooling towers. Strains of L. pneumophila which persisted after disinfection of contaminated environmental sites were of a different type from the prechlorination strains. All three typing methods were useful in the epidemiologic analysis of the VAWMC outbreak.     

Characterization of a tandem repeat polymorphism in Legionella pneumophila and its use for genotyping

We have analyzed the variability of minisatellite sequences (also called variable-number tandem repeats [VNTRs]) in the genome of Legionella pneumophila. Based upon the genome sequence of the Philadelphia-1 strain (serogroup 1), 25 minisatellites were selected and their polymorphisms were analyzed by PCR with the DNA of serogroup 1 to 14 reference strains. For 22 markers, a PCR product of the expected size was found with the DNA of the Philadelphia-1 strain. Most of these markers did not amplify the DNA of other Legionella species or other bacteria used as controls. A polymorphism was observed for seven markers among the L. pneumophila strains tested. To check whether these markers could be used to compare strains of L. pneumophila, we analyzed two groups of isolates from clinical and environmental samples which had been independently genotyped by other methods. The results showed that, for the isolates in these two sets of samples, VNTR typing is as informative as pulsed-field gel electrophoresis for comparison of strains. Sequencing of one minisatellite from 14 reference strains was performed. Comparison of the sequences allowed a classification and confirmed the existence of subspecies of L. pneumophila. We also tested the usefulness of one very polymorphic marker as a tool for the rapid screening of colonies grown from water samples. This allowed the rapid identification of the L. pneumophila colonies and gave a first hint as to the presence of several strains in a single sample.     

A method for typing strains of Legionella pneumophila serogroup 1 by analysis of restriction fragment length polymorphisms

A restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) typing method for Legionella pneumophila serogroup 1 was developed. The method depended upon the use of cloned EcoR1 fragments from L. pneumophila (Knoxville-1) probing Nci1 restriction fragments of chromosomal DNA. Examination of strains of L. pneumophila which were apparently unrelated showed that inter-strain RFLPs were common, and these formed the basis of the typing scheme. The technique was found to be highly reproducible and discriminatory. When the RFLP data were compared to that obtained by monoclonal antibody (MAb) subgrouping both methods of strain differentiation gave consistent results. The isolates examined by either method were also sub-divided by the alternative technique. The analysis of RFLPs by cloned probes should be of considerable epidemiological value.     

Molecular typing of nosocomial strains of Legionella pneumophila by arbitrarily primed PCR.

Arbitrarily primed PCR with two different primers was compared with ribotyping and monoclonal antibody analysis for typing Legionella strains. Applied to 11 epidemiologically unrelated strains, arbitrarily primed PCR resulted in an index of discrimination of 100% with both primers. It was found able to identify an epidemic clone of Legionella pneumophila serogroup 1 that was isolated from both patients and a hot water circuit of the same hospital.     

Subtyping of Legionella pneumophila serogroup 1 isolates by monoclonal antibody and plasmid techniques.

A group of environmental and clinical Legionella pneumophila serogroup 1 isolates was subtyped by monoclonal antibody dot immunoblotting and plasmid analysis. Monoclonal antibody analysis defined seven subtypes within three major groups. Plasmid analysis (including restriction endonuclease digestion) revealed 10 subtypes. By combining plasmid and monoclonal techniques, all 16 strains were shown to be distinct. Plasmid profiles and monoclonal antibody reactivities of selected strains were stable despite serial passage (greater than 100 times). No plasmid-associated antigen was defined by this panel of monoclonal antibodies. The observed dissociation of plasmid profiles and monoclonal antibody reactivity patterns suggests that accurate epidemiologic typing of L. pneumophila serogroup 1 strains will require use of both techniques.     

Multiple Types of Legionella pneumophila Serogroup 6 in a Hospital Heated-Water System Associated with Sporadic Infections

Five sporadic cases of nosocomial Legionnaires' disease were documented from 1989 to 1997 in a hospital in northern Italy. Two of them, which occurred in a 75-year-old man suffering from ischemic cardiopathy and in an 8-year-old girl suffering from acute leukemia, had fatal outcomes. Legionella pneumophila serogroup 6 was isolated from both patients and from hot-water samples taken at different sites in the hospital. These facts led us to consider the possibility that a single clone of L. pneumophila serogroup 6 had persisted in the hospital environment for 8 years and had caused sporadic infections. Comparison of clinical and environmental strains by monoclonal subtyping, macrorestriction analysis (MRA), and arbitrarily primed PCR (AP-PCR) showed that the strains were clustered into three different epidemiological types, of which only two types caused infection. An excellent correspondence between the MRA and AP-PCR results was observed, with both techniques having high discriminatory powers. However, it was not possible to differentiate the isolates by means of ribotyping and analysis of rrn operon polymorphism. Environmental strains that antigenically and chromosomally matched the infecting organism were present at the time of infection in hot-water samples taken from the ward where the patients had stayed. Interpretation of the temporal sequence of events on the basis of the typing results for clinical and environmental isolates enabled the identification of the ward where the patients became infected and the modes of transmission of Legionella infection. The long-term persistence in the hot-water system of different clones of L. pneumophila serogroup 6 indicates that repeated heat-based control measures were ineffective in eradicating the organism.     

Consensus sequence-based scheme for epidemiological typing of clinical and environmental isolates of Legionella pneumophila

A previously described sequence-based epidemiological typing method for clinical and environmental isolates of Legionella pneumophila serogroup 1 was extended by the investigation of three additional gene targets and modification of one of the previous targets. Excellent typeability, reproducibility, and epidemiological concordance were determined for isolates belonging to both serogroup 1 and the other serogroups investigated. Gene fragments were amplified from genomic DNA, and PCR amplicons were sequenced by using forward and reverse primers. Consensus sequences are entered into an online database, which allows the assignment of individual allele numbers. The resulting sequence-based type or allelic profile comprises a string of the individual allele numbers separated by commas, e.g., 1,4,3,1,1,1, in a predetermined order, i.e., flaA, pilE, asd, mip, mompS, and proA. The index of discrimination (D) obtained with these six loci was calculated following analysis of a panel of 79 unrelated clinical isolates. A D value of > 0.94 was obtained, and this value appears to be sufficient for use in the epidemiological investigation of outbreaks caused by L. pneumophila. The D value rose to 0.98 when the results of the analysis were combined with those of monoclonal antibody subgrouping. Sequence-based typing of L. pneumophila is epidemiologically concordant and discriminatory, and the data are easily transportable. This consensus method will assist in the epidemiological investigation of L. pneumophila infections, especially travel-associated cases, by which it will allow a rapid comparison of isolates obtained in more than one country.     

Molecular epidemiology of Legionella species by restriction endonuclease and alloenzyme analysis.

As part of an ongoing investigation into nosocomial Legionella infections at Stanford University Medical Center (SUMC), we applied the technique of restriction endonuclease analysis (REA) to determine strain differences among three species, including Legionella pneumophila, Legionella dumoffii, and Legionella micdadei. A total of 26 human and environmental water isolates from SUMC were selected for REA and compared with control strains that were not epidemiologically linked to SUMC. REA results were compared with results of alloenzyme typing, typing by monoclonal antibodies, and plasmid fingerprinting in all but L. micdadei strains. REA and alloenzyme typing showed that SUMC patient isolates were derived from distinct strains of three species. L. pneumophila strains from SUMC patients were genotypically identical to those isolated from potable water. REA was especially useful in proving that SUMC L. dumoffii patient isolates were derived from a single strain and that patients may have been exposed to a common source(s). REA typing correlated well with alloenzyme typing. These methods complement serologic typing of L. pneumophila and provide discriminating capability between strains of other Legionella species such as L. dumoffii, for which serologic types have not been identified. In addition, REA typing is somewhat easier to perform than alloenzyme typing and can be done in clinical laboratories.     

Antigenic and genetic variation in Legionella pneumophila serogroup 6.

Legionella pneumophila subsp. pneumophila serogroup 6 is second in importance only to L. pneumophila serogroup 1 as a cause of legionellosis. Monoclonal antibody (MAb) reactivity and multilocus enzyme electrophoretic analyses were used to subtype serogroup 6 isolates as a potential aid for epidemiologic and virulence studies. Forty-eight serogroup 6 isolates submitted to the Centers for Disease Control from 1980 to 1985 were examined by these methods. The isolates were divided into two groups based on differential reactivity with two MAbs. Thirty-two of the isolates were of a single electrophoretic type (ET) and were reactive with both MAbs. The remaining 16 isolates were distributed among 10 ETs and were reactive with one or both MAbs. The mean genetic diversity for serogroup 6, as determined from the degree of variability at 20 enzyme loci, was found to be essentially the same as that for L. pneumophila subsp. pneumophila as a whole. The ETs of serogroup 6 isolates were unique but closely related genetically to the ETs of L. pneumophila subsp. pneumophila serogroups 1 to 5, 7, and 8. The range of serogroup 6 subtypes distinguished by MAbs and enzyme electrophoresis suggests that the combination of these two methods can be useful as a typing system.