Early Failure of the Durom Prosthesis in Metal-on-Metal Hip Resurfacing in Chinese Patients

Hip resurfacing (HR) is being used increasingly as an alterative to total hip arthroplasty in osteonecrosis (ON) and ankylosing spondylitis (AS) of the hip. We performed 141 consecutive HR arthroplasties in 111 patients comprising 3 etiology groups: ON, AS, and osteoarthritis (OA). After retrospective study of retrieved components, we hypothesized that the main reason for revision was femoral loosening in the ON group (4 of 46 hips; 8.7%) and femoral-neck fracture in the AS group (3 of 58 hips; 5.2%). Necrotic areas were seen on femoral heads retrieved from patients with femoral loosening, whereas femoral heads were fixed tightly to components in patients with femoral-neck fractures. Etiology may be an important risk factor for postoperative complications.     

Improved cementing techniques and femoral component loosening in young patients with hip arthroplasty. A 12-year radiographic review.

To assess the effect of improved methods of femoral cementing on the loosening rates in young patients, we reviewed 50 'second-generation' cemented hip arthroplasties in 44 patients aged 50 years or less. The femoral stems were all collared and rectangular in cross-section with rounded corners. The cement was delivered by a gun into a medullary canal occluded distally with a cement plug. A clinical and radiographic review was undertaken at an average of 12 years (10 to 14.8) and no patient was lost to follow-up. No femoral component was revised for aseptic loosening, and only one stem was definitely loose by radiographic criteria. By contrast, 11 patients had undergone revision for symptomatic aseptic loosening of the acetabular component and 11 more had radiographic signs of acetabular loosening.     

Revision total knee arthroplasty with cemented components and uncemented intramedullary stems

Sixty-three failed total knee arthroplasties in 60 patients (27 females, 33 males; average age, 66 years) were treated consecutively with revision using cemented component fixation and an uncemented stem. Patients were followed for a mean of 5.75 years (range, 2–10 years); none were lost to follow-up. There were 12 (19%) re-revisions: 6 (10%) were revised for aseptic loosening, 4 (6%) for recurrent infection, and 2 (3%) for instability. Knee Society Pain Scores improved from 56 to 81, and function scores improved from 49 to 62 points. Latest radiographs in retained knees showed none with definite femoral loosening but 4 with tibial component loosening. Combining those revised for aseptic loosening and radiographic aseptic loosening, mechanical failure occurred in 10 patients (16%).     

Total hip arthroplasty in young patients. 8- to 13-year results using an uncemented stem

One hundred eight uncemented total hip arthroplasties were performed in 91 patients who were 50 years of age or younger using the Taperloc femoral component. The average age of the patients at time of surgery was 37 years (range, 20-50 years). The mean followup was 10.2 years (range, 8-13 years). No patient was lost to followup. Seven patients (eight hips) died before obtaining the minimum time of 8 years for inclusion in this study. All seven died with their femoral components in place. Of the remaining 100 total hip arthroplasties, no femoral component required revision for aseptic loosening. One femoral component was revised to correct a leg length discrepancy, and one well-fixed femoral component was revised for sepsis. In the 98 total hip arthroplasties that had not undergone femoral component revision, complete radiographic and clinical followup was obtained. Radiographically, 96 (98%) femoral components were determined to have fixation by bone ingrowth, two (2%) femoral components showed stable fibrous ingrowth, and no femoral component was unstable. Femoral cortical osteolysis occurred in seven (7%) hips; major lysis was present in only one (1%). Clinically, 91 (93%) total hip arthroplasties were rated good or excellent; six (6%) were rated fair, and one (1%) was rated poor. Thirty-nine patients with 47 total hip arthroplasties (48%) were engaged in moderate to strenuous manual labor. These results indicate that excellent fixation and minimal lysis can be achieved with an uncemented femoral component in young and active patients at 10 years.     

Charnley total hip arthroplasty with use of improved cementing techniques: a minimum twenty-year follow-up study.

BACKGROUND: In total hip arthroplasty, techniques for cementing the femoral component have changed over time. The purpose of the present study was to determine whether a cementing technique that includes use of a distal cement plug and retrograde filling of the femoral canal affects the fixation of the femoral component at a minimum of twenty years after the operation. METHODS: Between 1976 and 1978, the senior one of us (R.C.J.) performed 357 total hip arthroplasties with use of a Charnley flatback polished femoral stem and a contemporary cementing technique (insertion of a distal cement plug and retrograde filling of the femoral canal with cement) in 320 patients. The results after a minimum follow-up of twenty years were compared with those after 330 total hip arthroplasties performed, between 1970 and 1972, with the same femoral stem by the same surgeon with use of a hand-packing technique of cementing in 262 patients. The clinical and radiographic evaluation as well as the duration of follow-up were identical in the two groups. RESULTS: In the group managed with the contemporary cementing technique, six (1.8%) of the 336 hips that had not been lost to follow-up or revised because of infection or dislocation were revised because of aseptic loosening of the femoral component. Of the ninety-one hips in the eighty-two patients who were alive at a minimum of twenty years, five (5%) had a revision because of aseptic loosening of the femoral component. Only one hip was revised during the fifteen-to-twenty-year follow-up interval. (The revision was performed because of a fracture of the femoral component.) The rate of failure when radiographic signs of loosening were included was 4.8% (sixteen of 336 femoral components that had not been revised because of infection or dislocation) for the group managed with the contemporary cementing technique compared with 6.3% (twenty of 319 hips) in the group managed with the hand-packing technique; the difference was not significant (p = 0.40). Adequate filling of the femoral canal with cement was found to be associated with improved survival of the femoral component (p = 0.03). CONCLUSIONS: While no significant difference between the two cementing techniques could be identified, the ability to deliver adequate cement around the femoral component was more predictable with the contemporary cementing technique. In addition, the prevalence of loosening of the femoral component was low with use of either technique, a tribute to the Charnley flatback polished femoral component design.     

Total knee arthroplasty in rheumatoid arthritis. A comparison of the polycentric and total condylar prostheses

From 1971 to 1985, 393 total knee arthroplasties (TKAs) were performed in patients for rheumatoid arthritis. Of these, 112 used polycentric prostheses and 131 used total condylar prostheses. One hundred seven of the patients with polycentric prostheses and 102 of the patients with total condylar prostheses were followed for a minimum of two years (average, 61 and 55 months, respectively). At the time of the latest examination, nine knees with polycentric prostheses required revision surgery: six for tibial component loosening and instability and three for patellofemoral pain. Five knees with total condylar prostheses required revision: one for chronic instability, one for a late posttraumatic patellar fracture, and three for late hematogenous infections. The total condylar prostheses with patellar resurfacing had better scores for pain (8.5 points) than the polycentric prosthesis without patellofemoral resurfacing (7.0 points). The total condylar prosthesis appeared more durable in terms of fixation, with no evidence of aseptic loosening of femoral or tibial components noted in this series thus far.     

Five-year results of metal-on-metal resurfacing arthroplasty in Asian patients

Clinical results of 50 metal-on-metal resurfacing arthroplasties in 45 Japanese patients were evaluated to a minimum follow-up of 5 years. The predominant diagnosis was developmental dysplasia or dislocation of the hip (70%). One patient died of an unrelated cause and another was lost to follow-up. Two hips received revision surgery, including 1 femoral neck fracture and 1 septic loosening. In the remaining 46 hips, 1 hip showed femoral component loosening. Clinical scores of the 46 hips were satisfactory at the final follow-up. The survival rate at 5 years was 96% when failure was attributed to revision for any reason. Metal-on-metal resurfacing arthroplasty in Japanese patients, who have a different distribution of hip diseases from European and American patients, showed similarly promising early clinical results.     

Femoral Fixation Methods in Hip Resurfacing Arthroplasty: An 11-Year Retrospective Comparison of 4013 Cases

BackgroundThe optimal femoral fixation method remains unclear. To evaluate the role of femoral fixation techniques in hip resurfacing, we present a comparison of 2 consecutive groups: group 1 (739 hips) with cemented femoral components; group 2 (3274 hips) with uncemented femoral components.MethodsWe retrospectively analyzed our clinical database to compare failures, reoperations, complications, clinical results, and radiographic measurements. Groups were consecutive, so cemented cases had longer follow-up. However, all patients from both groups were at least 2 years out from surgery. Two-year clinical and radiographic data were compared. Longer-term comparison data as well as Kaplan-Meier implant survivorship curves specifically focusing on femoral failure modes were analyzed.ResultsKaplan-Meier 10-year implant survivorship using nontraumatic femoral failure as an end point was 98.9% for the cemented and 100% for the uncemented femoral component. The uncemented, group 2 cases showed a significantly lower raw failure rate (1.1% vs 4.6%), 2-year failure rate (0.8% vs 2.8%), 2-year femoral failure rate (0.4% vs 0.9%), and a lower combined rate of femoral complications and failures (0.6% vs 1.8%). In cases that did not fail, patient mean clinical scores, pain scores, and combined range of motion were all significantly better for group 2.ConclusionWe have demonstrated that in the fully porous-coated ReCap device, uncemented femoral fixation is superior to cemented fixation at 11 years follow-up (0.0% vs 1.1% late femoral loosening) in this single-surgeon cohort. Early femoral fractures also reduced from 0.8% to 0.3%, but this may be partially or completely due to a new bone density management program. This study demonstrates better femoral implant survivorship for the uncemented device compared to the cemented femoral resurfacing component for this implant design.     

Long-term survival of the T-28 versus the TR-28 cemented total hip arthroplasties

Between 1974 and 1980, 550 total hip arthroplasties (THAs) (479 patients) were performed using T-28 and TR-28 cemented prostheses (TR-28 is shot-blast chrome and T-28 is polished stainless steel). There were 379 cemented THAs in 321 patients in the T-28 group and 171 cemented THAs in 158 patients in the TR-28 group. Average follow-up of the patients still alive at the end of the study was 20.96 years in the T-28 group and 17.54 years in the TR-28 group. When considering failure as revision of the hip for aseptic acetabular loosening, there were 36 (9.5%) failures in the T-28 group and 12 (7%) failures in the TR-28 group. This difference was statistically significant (P = .0132). When considering failure as radiographic acetabular loosening with or without radiographic femoral loosening, there were 52 failed acetabula (13.7%) in the T-28 group and 18 failed acetabula (10.5%) in the TR-28 group. These differences were not statistically significant. When considering failure as revision for aseptic femoral loosening with or without acetabular component loosening, there were 42 failures (11.1%) in the T-28 group and 22 failures (12.8%) in the TR-28 group. This difference was not statistically significant. When considering failure as radiographic femoral loosening with or without acetabular component loosening, there were 42 failures (11.1%) in the T-28 group and 27 failures (15.8%) in the TR-28 group. This difference was statistically significant for log-rank test (P = .0318) and Wilcoxon's test (P = .0083). Surface finish may be an important contributor to the survival of cemented femoral stems.     

Long-term followup of the Miller-Galante total knee replacement.

One hundred seventy-two consecutive cemented Miller-Galante-I total knee arthroplasties in 155 patients were compared with 109 consecutive cemented Miller-Galante-II total knee arthroplasties in 92 patients. The average followup was 11 years (range, 8-15 years) and 9 years (range, 8-10 years), respectively. Of the 172 Miller-Galante-I arthroplasties, there have been 21 revisions; 15 patellar revisions; two included femoral revisions attributable to abrasion. Six additional well-fixed femoral and tibial components were revised: two for early instability, one for pain, one for periprosthetic fracture, and two for infection. No component had aseptic loosening or osteolysis. Using revision or loosening of any components as the end point, the Kaplan-Meier 10-year survivorship was 84.1% +/- 4.1%. Of the 109 Miller-Galante-II arthroplasties, there have been no component revisions, no aseptic loosening, and no osteolysis. Using revision or loosening of any components as the end point, the Kaplan-Meier 10-year survivorship was 100%. The Miller-Galante knee systems showed excellent fixation with no loosening and no osteolysis at as many as 15 years. Additionally, there have been no component revisions for late instability at as many as 15 years. Finally, the high prevalence of patellofemoral complications with the Miller-Galante-I design has been obviated with the Miller-Galante-II design.     

Revision total hip arthroplasty with use of a cemented femoral component. Results at a mean of ten years

BACKGROUND: Revision of the femoral component of a total hip replacement with use of cement has been associated with early mechanical failure due to aseptic loosening. The purpose of the present study was to determine the long-term survival after revision of the femoral component with cement and to identify factors that were predictive of failure. METHODS: The results of 129 revision total hip arthroplasties that had been performed with use of a cemented femoral stem were reviewed to determine component survival. Ninety-seven hips that had been followed for a minimum of five years were included in survival analysis and tests of significance. Harris hip scores were used to quantify clinical outcomes. Clinical and surgical factors were analyzed to determine whether they were predictive of failure. RESULTS: The mean Harris hip score improved from 52 points preoperatively to 71 points at the time of the most recent follow-up (p < 0.001). The ten-year survival rate was 91% with rerevision of the femoral component because of aseptic loosening as the end point and 71% with mechanical failure as the end point. Patients who were more than sixty years old had greater long-term component survival and less pain than younger patients did (p < 0.05). A good-quality postoperative cement mantle was associated with better long-term radiographic signs of fixation (p < 0.001). Poor femoral bone quality was associated with an increased rate of rerevision for aseptic loosening (p = 0.021). CONCLUSIONS: Revision with use of a cemented femoral component remains an option for selected patients, with an acceptable ten-year survival rate and fair radiographic evidence of fixation. Our patients had acceptable clinical outcomes at ten years, and few had notable pain. The best results may be achieved in older patients (those who are sixty years old or more) with adequate bone stock who are managed with modern cementing techniques.     

Prospective analysis of Sheehan total knee arthroplasty

In a prospective study, the clinical results of 64 Sheehan total knee arthroplasties (TKA) were reviewed in 52 patients, with an average follow-up period of five and one-half years. Like most prosthetic designs in use in 1975, the Sheehan prosthesis did not incorporate patellar resurfacing. The initial clinical success achieved without patello-femoral replacement may become less acceptable with longer follow-up periods. Seventy-four percent of the patients in this study had complete relief of pain or mild discomfort not requiring analgesics. With patellar resurfacing as a secondary procedure in three additional cases, the percent successful results increased to 81%. Five knees (12%) required additional surgery, one because of infection, two because of secondary component failure, and two for loosening. The lack of patellofemoral replacement and prospective failure of both tibial and femoral components, possibly due to high stress-loading in a relatively small surface area, have led to the use of other newer TKA designs.     

A clinical,radiological and biomechanical study of the TARA hip prosthesis

Summary We reviewed 60 patients with 72 TARA (total articular replacement arthroplasty) resurfacing hip prostheses. To analyse the behaviour of the femoral component a radiographic study was done and a two-dimensional finite element model was constructed. The stem of the femoral component plays a role in the load transfer mechanism. Stress shielding is seen in the proximal femur but depends on the interface conditions. When only the dome of the cup is assumed to be bonded to the bone, the stresses in the head increase dramatically and there is no more stress shielding. Five years after implantation radiographic signs of loosening of the femoral component were seen in 6.8% of the implants placed without notching in the femoral neck and in 28.6% of the components with notching (significant difference, P = 0.0005). Signs of loosening of the acetabular component were seen in 37.7% 5 years postoperatively. The cumulative survival rates of the femoral and acetabular components were 89.7% and 85.6% respectively 5 years after implantation. The overall clinical results are represented by an integration of the clinical results (Harris Hip Score System), the radiographic results and the survival analysis. This gave a success rate of only 72% 5 years after implantation.     

Modular Fluted Tapered Stems in Aseptic Oncologic Revision Total Hip Arthroplasty: A Game Changer?

BackgroundModular fluted tapered (MFT) stems are the most frequently used femoral component in revision total hip arthroplasties (THAs). Despite this, no data are available on how they perform in revision THA for oncologic salvage. This is a unique population, often with severe bone loss and prior radiation that extends the limits of uncemented femoral reconstruction. The aims of this study were to evaluate the implant survivorship, radiographic results, and clinical outcomes of MFT stems used for revision oncologic salvage.MethodsWe identified 17 patients treated initially with primary THA for an oncologic diagnosis (15 primary oncologic, 2 metastatic disease) who underwent subsequent femoral revision with an MFT stem. Mean age at revision was 66 years and 35% of patients were female. Mean follow-up was 4 years. Before revision, 5 of 17 had undergone local radiation.ResultsTen-year survivorship free from aseptic loosening was 100%. The survivorship free of any reoperation was 76%. There were no femoral component fractures. Three patients were revised for recurrent instability, and 1 patient underwent irrigation and debridement for an acute infection. At most recent follow-up, no patient had radiographic evidence of progressive femoral component subsidence or failure of osteointegration. The mean Harris Hip Score improved from 29 preoperatively to 76 postoperatively (P < .0001).ConclusionIn this series of patients with cancer, many of whom had severe bone loss and/or prior local radiation, being treated with revision THA, there were no revisions for femoral component loosening and no cases of implant fracture.Level of EvidenceIII.     

Wagner resurfacing hip arthroplasty. The results of one hundred consecutive arthroplasties after eight to ten years

In a prospective study of 100 consecutive Wagner resurfacing hip arthroplasties in ninety-three patients, the outcomes for all hips were determined for an eight to ten-year follow-up period. By survivorship analysis, the rate of survival of the arthroplasty was calculated to be 70 per cent at five years, but only 40 per cent at eight years. The major cause of failure was aseptic loosening of the acetabular or femoral component, or both. Fracture of the neck of the femur occurred in three hips. Although the medium-term results (at fifty-six to eighty-three months) were better than those in most comparable studies of resurfacing arthroplasty, the poor long-term results (at ninety-one to 118 months) show that meaningful studies of new prosthetic designs must continue for at least eight years, and, if at all possible, must include 100 per cent follow-up. The survival curve for the resurfacing arthroplasties in this study can serve as the basis for comparison of the early, medium, and long-term results of future designs of resurfacing hip prostheses.     

Comparison of clinical outcomes in total hip arthroplasty using rough and polished cemented stems with essentially the same geometry

BACKGROUND: Aseptic loosening of the cemented stem is the most common cause of revision of total hip arthroplasties. The loosening is often associated with substantial lysis of the surrounding bone. The surface finish of femoral components is suspected as a contributing factor to this bone lysis. The purpose of this study was to compare the results associated with a rough surface and those associated with a polished surface in a consecutive series of cemented stems with essentially the same geometry. METHODS: The study included 244 consecutive total hip arthroplasties with a cemented femoral component performed by one surgeon. There was no difference in patient selection criteria or surgical techniques between the group treated with a polished stem and that treated with a grit-blasted stem. All arthroplasties were hybrid, with an uncemented acetabular component. Generally, patients were over the age of sixty years (mean age, 70.6 years). The stems inserted in the initial 122 hips had a grit-blasted surface with a roughness of 2.1 microm. The stem surface in the second 122 hips was polished (roughness, 0.1 microm). The results of clinical and radiographic assessments performed immediately after surgery were compared with those performed at the most recent visit. The average duration of clinical follow-up for the patients treated with the grit-blasted and polished stems was 5.98 years and 5.32 years, respectively. RESULTS: Four hips treated with the grit-blasted stem had aseptic loosening with substantial surrounding lysis and required revision. An additional two hips in this group had radiographic evidence of substantial lysis and were judged to have an impending need for revision. In contrast, no hip treated with the polished stem required revision, and only one had minimal lysis. This difference regarding failures and impending failures was significant (p = 0.05). The clinical results were comparable, with an Iowa hip rating of 98 points at the time of follow-up in both groups. CONCLUSIONS: There was a significant difference between grit-blasted and polished stems with respect to the prevalence of revisions and impending revisions, all of which were identified in a relatively short follow-up period. The results in this series favor the use of a polished stem when cement is employed for fixation of the femoral component.     

Early failure of revision total hip arthroplasty with cemented precoated femoral components: comparison with uncemented components at 2 to 8 years

This is a retrospective analysis of 2 methods of fixation of the femoral component in 86 consecutive revision arthroplasties, for which all clinical and radiographic data were recorded prospectively. There were 56 cemented revisions using precoated femoral components followed for 2 to 8 years (mean, 4 years) and 30 uncemented, proximally porous-coated femoral revisions followed for 2 to 6 years (mean, 4 years). Of the 56 cemented hips, 31 (55%) had a good or excellent clinical result. Rerevision has been performed in 10 hips, and revision of 3 loose femoral components is pending (23%). Radiographic review of 56 femoral components showed that 16 (29%) had probable or definite loosening. Of 30 cementless hips, 24 (80%) had a good or excellent clinical result. There was radiographic bone ingrowth in 22 of 30 hips (73%). Seven hips (23%) had nonprogressive subsidence, and 3 hips (10%) had progressive subsidence or loosening. Rerevision has been performed in only 2 hips (7%). The high rate of loosening (29%) and rerevision (23%) at a mean follow-up of only 4 years suggests that a precoated femoral component may place increased stress at the already damaged bone-cement interface.     

Lack of radiographic loosening signs in a hip resurfacing that failed by stem fracture

Fracture of the femoral stem is a rare manifestation of femoral component loosening in hip resurfacing. The patient had undergone successful hip resurfacing 3 years prior to presentation, presenting with complaints of groin pain, but without radiographic evidence of loosening. At 6 years post-operatively, the patient again presented with groin pain. Radiographs demonstrated a mid-stem fracture. Analysis of the retrieved implant and resected femoral head following conversion to total hip arthroplasty indicated that component failure and fracture appeared to be secondary to failed fixation and implant loosening not related to osteonecrosis or acute femoral neck fracture. The case report highlights the difficulty in diagnosing femoral component loosening in hip resurfacing in the absence of gross implant subsidence or stem radiolucency.     

Intermediate results of simultaneous alumina-on-alumina bearing and alumina-on-highly cross-linked polyethylene bearing total hip arthroplasties

This study compared the clinical and radiographic results and the prevalence of osteolysis between alumina-on-alumina and alumina-on-highly cross-linked polyethylene bearings after cementless total hip arthroplasties in the 100 patients younger than 50 years of age. There were 66 men and 34 women; the mean age at the time of surgery was 45.3 years (range, 25 to 49 years). The mean duration of follow-up was 5.6 years (range, five to seven years). The pre-and postoperative Harris hip scores were similar (39 and 41 points, respectively and 93 points and 94 points, respectively). No acetabular or femoral component had aseptic loosening in either group. The mean annual penetration of the highly cross-linked polyethylene was 0.06 ± 0.03 mm. No hip in either group had acetabular or femoral osteolysis.