2009年河北省饮水型地方性氟中毒病情调查

目的 了解饮水型地方性氟中毒的病情动态和评价防治措施的落实效果,为及时调整防治策略提供科学依据.方法 2009年,采用单纯随机抽样的方法,在河北省饮水型氟中毒病区县中抽取38个县(市、区),采用系统抽样方法,将各病区县所有病区村分成轻、中、重3类,从每类病区村中各抽取1个病区村,对全部病区村进行水氟监测;调查病区村全部8～12岁儿童氟斑牙患病情况,从每个年龄段选择6人,检测尿氟;对各病区村全部16岁以上常住人口开展临床氟骨症检查,并检测20人份(男、女各半)尿氟.结果 共调查112个病区村,其中改水村66个,未改水村46个.采集改水工程水样236份,水氟范围为0.1～4.3 mg/L,有20个工程水氟＞1.2 mg/L,占总数的33.3%(20/60);采集未改水村水样230份,水氟范围为0.2～4.6 mg/L,水氟＞1.2 mg/L的水源数占总数的76.1%(35/46).共对5169名8～12岁儿童进行了氟斑牙患病情况调查,氟斑牙检出率为36.43%(1883/5169),氟斑牙指数为0.81.调查16岁以上成人71 497人,临床氟骨症检出率为4.81%(3438/71 497),中度以上临床氟骨症检出率为1.56%(1114/71 497).分别测定了2876和2021份儿童和成人尿氟,几何均数分别为2.30、3.32 mg/L.结论 水氟＜1.2 mg/L的已改水村儿童氟斑牙检出率均在30%以下,儿童氟斑牙检出率和成人临床氟骨症检出率随着改水时间的延长呈现逐渐下降的趋势.未改水病区,儿童氟斑牙检出率和成人临床氟骨症病情随水氟升高而上升.河北省饮水型氟中毒流行仍然较为严重,应该加快改水降氟进度并提高改水工程合格率.

Abstract：

Objective To understand the status of drinking-water-borne endemic fluorosis and the effect of preventive measure in Hebei province, so as to provide a basis to prevent and cure the disease. Methods Thirtyeight affected counties(cities, districts) with drinking-water-borne endemic fluorosis were sampled by random sampling in Hebei in 2009. All affected villages in every county were divided into mild, moderate and severe endemic fluorosis areas and a village was randomly selected from each category of the area to carry out the monitoring of endemic fluorosis. Dental fluorosis of children aged 8 - 12 were examined and 6 copies of urine samples were randomly collected in each age group in the above-mentioned villages. Clinical skeletal fluorosis was diagnosed among adults aged 16 and over and 20 copies of urine samples were tested for fluorosis in every village.Results A total of 112 affected villages were investigated, among which the drinking water quality of 66 villages were improved and 46 villages were not improved. A total of 236 copies of water samples from the 66 villages were measured and the fluoride content ranged from 0.1 to 4.3 mg/L, among which 20 copies of water samples exceeded the fluorine standard of 1.2 mg/L, accounting for 33.3%. A total of 230 copies of water samples were collected in the 46 villages and the fluoride content ranged from 0.2 to 4.6 mg/L, among which 76.1% (35/46) of the water samples exceeded the fluorine standard of 1.2 mg/L. A total of 5169 children aged 8 - 12 were examined of dental fluorosis, the dental fluorosis rate was 36.43%(1883/5169) and the dental fluorosis index was 0.81. A sum of 71 497 adults aged over 16 years were examined, and the rate of skeletal fluorosis was 4.81%(3438/71 497), moderate or severe clinical detection rate of skeletal fluorosis was 1.56%( 1114/71 497). A total of 2876 copies of children urine samples and 2021 copies of adult urine samples were tested and the geometric mean of fluoride content was 2.30,3.32 mg/L, respectively. Conclusions The prevalence of dental fluorosis of children in the areas with improved water is less than 30% and the rate of dental fluorosis and skeletal fluorosis decline gradually with time.The rate of dental fluorosis and skeletal fluorosis increases with the increase of water fluoride in the water quality not improved areas. The endemic fluorosis is still comparatively serious in Hebei. The progress of improving water quality in the areas with endemic fluorosis should be accelerated and the acceptability of improved water should be enhanced.     

2009年青海省湟源县地方性氟中毒病情监测结果分析

目的 掌握青海省湟源县饮水型地方性氟中毒病情变化和防治措施落实效果.方法 2009年将湟源县所有地方性氟中毒病区村按改水前水含氟量分为轻、中两类,分别抽取1、2个病区村作为监测点,共抽取3个监测村;每村采集出厂水和末梢水水样进行水氟测定;对监测村所有8～12岁儿童进行氟斑牙检查,并按年龄组采集儿童尿样进行尿氟测定;对监测村16岁及以上成人进行临床氟骨症检查,并采集20人份的尿样,检测尿氟;在3个监测村中选择1个村进行X线氟骨症检查.按照<生活饮用水标准检验方法非金属指标>(GB/T 5750.6-2006)测定水氟,尿氟测定采用氟离子选择电极法(WS/T 89-1996),氟斑牙诊断采用Dean法,成人氟骨症诊断按<地方性氟骨症临床诊断标准>(WS 192-2008).结果 共检测12份水样,水氟为(0.35 ±0.43)mg/L.共检查8～12岁儿童122名,氟斑牙检出率为34.43%(42/122);检测96例儿童尿样,尿氟几何均数为0.89 mg/L.对834名16岁及以上成人进行氟骨症检查,临床氟骨症检出率为47.72%(398/834):检测65例成人尿样,尿氟几何均数为1.10 mg/L;对甘沟村35名成人进行了X线氟骨症检查,检出率为31.4%(11/35).结论 湟源县的3个监测村饮用水含氟量正常,但氟中毒病情仍然很严重,应密切监测,分析原因,改进防治措施.

Abstract：

Objective To investigate the prevalence change of drinking water type of endemic fluorosis and the effect of control measures implemented in Huangyuan county of Qinghai province. Methods In 2009, all the endemic fluorosis villages in Huangyuan county were divided into two degrees, light and medium, according to the water fluorosis content before implementing the improving water project, 1 to 2 villages were selected from each degree village, respectively,as monitoring sites, and a total of 3 villages were selected. Source water and tap water samples were collected from each village and water fluoride concentration was determined. Dental fluorosis of all children aged 8 to 12 of monitoring villages was examined, and urine samples were collected by age group of children for determination of urinary fluoride. Clinical skeletal fluorosis of adults over 16 years of age was examined, and 20 copies of adults urine samples were collected to determine urinary fluoride. One village was selected in the 3 villages monitored to conduct X-rays examination of skeletal fluorosis. Water fluoride was tested in accordance with the "Non-metallic Targets Test Methods for Drinking Water" (GB/T 5750.6-2006); urinary fluoride was tested by fluoride ion-selective electrode method (WS/T 89-1996); dental fluorosis was diagnosed using Dean method;adult skeletal fluorosis was diagnosed by "Clinical Diagnostic Criteria for Endemic Skeletal Fluorosis"(WS 192-2008). Results Twelve water samples were assayed, water fluoride was (0.35 ± 0.43) mg/L. The detectable rate of dental fluorosis of 122 children aged 8-12 was 34.43%(42/122) and the geometric mean urinary fluoride was 0.89 mg/L of the 96 children. Of the 834 adults aged 16 and over, clinical detection of skeletal fluorosis was 47.72% (398/836) and geometric mean urinary fluoride was 1.10 mg/L of the 65 cases of adult urine samples assayed, detection rate of X-rays was 31.4% (11/35) in Gangou village of the 35 adults examined.Conclusions In Huangyuan county, water fluoride of the 3 surveyed villages are normal but the endemic fluorosis is still serious. It should strengthen monitoring and analyze the causes and improve prevention measures.     

2008年江苏省苏北地区饮水型地方性氟中毒病情监测结果分析

目的 掌握江苏省苏北地区饮水型地方性氟中毒(简称地氟病)病情及降氟改水工程使用情况.为进一步开展地氟病的防治工作提供科学依据.方法 2008年,在徐州、连云港、宿迁市的10个饮水型地氟病重点县(区),按照以往水氟调查资料,采用分层抽样的方法,抽取40个病区村,对所有8～12岁儿童进行氟斑牙检查;对所有16岁以上成人进行临床氟骨症检查.在40个病区村中,抽取30%的病区村,每个病区村选择20名16岁以上成人进行X线氟骨症检查,抽取50%病区村,每个村采集30名8～12岁儿童的任意一次尿样 检测尿氟.在每个市,选择1个县,对分层抽样方法抽取剑的病区村的改水工程现状、供水能力及覆盖范围等进行调查.结果 共计对3560名8～12岁儿童进行氟斑牙检查,检出率为38.51%(1371/3560).缺损率为5.34%(190/3560),氟斑牙指数为0.8;共抽取708份尿样,尿氟中位数为1.47 mg/L,范围为0.08～10.08 mg/L;16岁以上成人临床氟骨症检出率为21.3%(1294/6083),X线氟骨症检出率为39.2%(123/314).共调查了248个集中式改水设施,无经费运行或损坏的有49个,水氟>1.0 mg/L的有18个.结论 江苏省苏北地区饮水型地氟病病情尚未完全控制,并有回升趋势,须进一步加强降氟改水监管力度.

Abstract：

Objective To investigate the state of endemic fluorosis, running status of water improvement project to reduce fluoride in Jiangsu province, and to provide a scientific basis for prevention and control of endemic fluorosis. Methods In 2008, in the ten key counties of endemic fluorosis (zone), in Xuzhou,Lianyungang and Suqian, a stratified sampling method was employed to select 40 diseased villages according to their past water fluoride survey data. All children aged 8 to 12 were examined dental fluorosis, and all adults over 16 years were examined clinical skeletal fluorosis. Thirty per cent of the 40 diseased villages were selected, and 20 adults over the age of 16 in each selected village were examined by X-ray, respectively;50% of the 40 diseased villages were selected, and 30 any time urine samples of children aged 8 to 12 in each diseased village were tested urine fluoride. In each city, select a county, the status of water improvement project to reduce fluoride, water supply capacity and coverage in the county were investigated. Results A total of 3560 children aged 8 to 12 were examined, the detection rate of dental fluorosis was 38.51% (1371/3560), tooth defect rate was 5.34% (190/3560), and dental fluorosis index was 0.8. Seven hundred and eight urine samples were tested, the median urinary fluoride was 1.47 mg/L and the range was 0.08 ~ 10.08 mg/L. Clinical detection of skeletal fluorosis was 21.3% among adults over the age of 16, and X-ray detection rate of skeletal fluorosis was 39.2% (123/314).Investigated a total of 248 facilities of centralized water improvement projects, no funds to run or damaged 49, the water fluoride > 1.0 mg/L was 18. Conclusions Endemic fluorosis in Northern Jiangsu province has not been controlled completely, but has a rising trend, we should further strengthen the supervision of water fluoride reduction.     

2008年青海省贵德县地方性氟中毒病情监测结果分析

目的 掌握青海省贵德县地方性氟中毒病情与流行状况,进一步做好氟中毒监测防控工作.方法 2008年,选择贵德县大磨、温泉、保宁村(已改水村)和太平村(未改水村),分别采集枯水期和丰水期末梢水样各1份,按照<生活饮用水标准检验方法>(GB/T 5750.5-2006)检测水氟;对全部8～12岁儿童采用Dean法进行氟斑牙检查,每个年龄组抽检6人采集尿样,用氟离子选择电极法(WS/T 89-1996)检测尿氟;按照<地方性氟骨症诊断标准>(WS 192-2008),对16岁以上成人进行临床氟骨症检查,每个村抽取男女各10人,进行氟骨症X线诊断.结果 大磨、温泉、太平、保宁4个村水氟均值分别为0.58、0.38、2.28、0.57 mg/L,其中太平村水氟均值超过国家生活饮用水卫生标准(1.0 mg/L).共检查8～12岁儿童193人,儿童氟斑牙检出率为49.74%(96/193);共检测儿童尿样116份,尿氟中位数为1.49 mg/L.共检查16岁以上成人1503人,临床氟骨症检出率为51.63%(776/1503);共对82人进行X线拍片,X线氟骨症检出率为20.73%(17/82),X线表现以关节退行性改变及骨间膜骨化为主.结论 贵德县儿童氟斑牙和成人临床氟骨症检出率较高,氟中毒流行较重,防治形势刻不容缓.

Abstract：

Objective To investigate the prevalence of endemic fluorosis in Guide county of Qinghai province, in order to provide appropriate measures to monitor and control the disease. Methods Damo, Wenquan, Baoning villages(water source has been changed) and Taiping village(water source has not been changed) in Guide county were involved in the study in 2008. One tap water sample was collected in dry and rainy seasons, respectively. Water fluoride was tested in accordance with the "Standard Test Methods for Drinking Water" (GB/T 5750.5-2006); of all the children aged 8 to 12, dental fluorosis was diagnosed using Dean criteria; 6 copies of urine samples were collected in each age group, urinary fluoride was measured using fluoride ion-selective electrode (WS/T 89-1996). According to the "Clinical Diagnostic Criteria of Endemic Skeletal Fluorosis "(WS 192-2008), clinical skeletal fluorosis was determined in adults over the age of 16 by X-ray examination for 10 people in each selected village. Results The mean water fluoride was 0.58,0.38,2.28,0.37 mg/L in Damo, Wenquan, Taiping, and Baoning villages, respectively, and that of Taiping village exceeded the national standard(1.0 mg/L). One hundred and ninety-three children aged 8-12 were checked, the detection rate of dental fluorosis was 49.74% (96/193); urine samples of 116 children were tested, median urinary fluoride was 1.49 mg/L A total of 1503 adults over the age of 16 were examined, the clinical detection of skeletal fluorosis was 51.63%(776/1503); a total of 82 people were X-rayed, X-ray detection of skeletal fluorosis was 20.73%(17/82). The characteristic of X-rays were degeneration and ossification of interosseous membrane. Conclusions Prevalence of dental fluorosis of children and adult clinical skeletal fluorosis are higher. The endemic fluorosis is still comparatively serious. Prevention efforts need to be further strengthened.     

山西省浑源县农村饮用水卫生状况及地方性氟中毒病情监测结果分析

目的 了解浑源县农村饮用水卫生状况,评价高氟区改水降氟效果,为今后农村饮水安全工作提供依据.方法 2008-2010年,按照<中央补助山西省公共卫生专项资金农村改水项目实施方案>,在浑源县共选择54个监测点,采集水样,检测感官性状、理化、微生物等19项指标.同时抽取全县17个乡(镇)40个改水村进行水氟监测.2009年6月在浑源县抽取3个高氟村,对3个村中所有8～12岁儿童进行氟斑牙诊断(Dean 法),并抽取儿童尿样,进行尿氟测定,并对3个村的饮用水氟进行测定.水氟、尿氟测定均采用离子选择电极法.结果 3年共检测水样188份,合格率仅为35.1%(66/188),主要超标指标为菌落总数(109项)、总大肠菌群(47项)、耐热大肠菌群(39项)和氟化物(21项).共检测40个村160份饮用水,水氟超标率为12.50%(20/160).共对522名8～12岁儿童进行了氟斑牙诊断,氟斑牙检出率为7.66%(40/522),氟斑牙指数为0.16;共对74名8～12岁儿童进行了尿氟测定,尿氟几何均数为1.17 mg/L,范围为0.31～3.92 mg/L.结论 浑源县农村改水工作取得成效,但卫生状况较差,今后应加强水质监测和管理,确保农村饮用水安全.

Abstract：

Objective To investigate the sanitary status of rural drinking water in Hunyuan county, evaluate the effect of water improvement project to reduce fluoride in high fluoride areas, and to provide the basis for rural drinking water safety. Methods Between 2008 and 2010, in accordance with the "Rural water supply project implementation plan entral grant special funds for public health in Shanxi province", in Hunyuan county, 54 monitoring sites were selected, collected water samples. Water sample sensory properties, chemical, microbiological and other 19 indicators were tested. Forty project villages from 17 townships in Hunyuan county were selected to test water fluoride. June 2009 in Hunyuan county 3 high fluoride villages were chosen, all children aged 8 to 12 in the villages were examined of dental fluorosis (Dean method), and children's urine samples were collected to measured urinary fluoride. Water fluoride of the 3 villages was determined. Water and urinary fluoride were measured by fluoride ion-selective electrode method. Results In three years, a total of 188 samples were detected,with a pass rate of 35.1%(66/188), the main indicators that exceeded the standard were colony count(109 items), total coliforms (47 items), heat-resistant coliform bacteria(39 items) and fluoride(21 items). A total of 160 water samples in the 40 villages from the 17 townships were tested, the water fluoride excessive rate was 12.50%(20/160). A total of 522 children aged 8 to 12 were examined dental fluorosis, dental fluorosis rate was 7.66%(40/522), dental fluorosis index was 0.16; a total of 74 urinary fluoride of children aged 8 to 12 were measured, geometric mean was 1.17 mg/L, urinary fluoride range was 0.31 - 3.92 mg/L. Conclusions The drinking water improvement project in Hunyuan county rural areas has been successful, but sanitary conditions is poor. Water quality monitoring should be strengthened to ensure safe drinking water in the areas.     

2006-2010年吉林省地方性氟中毒监测结果分析

目的 掌握吉林省地方性氟中毒病情变化,为调整防治策略提供科学依据.方法 2006-2010年,采用分层整群抽样方法,每年在全省14个病区县的轻、中、重病区中抽取5个屯作为监测点.水氟、尿氟测定采用离子选择电极法(GB/T 8538-1995);8～12岁儿童氟斑牙诊断采用Dean法;氟骨症诊断2006-2008年采用<地方性氟骨症临床分度标准>(GB 16396-1996),2009、2010年采用<地方性氟骨症临床诊断标准>(WS192-2008).结果 共监测25个病区屯,其中改水屯14个,常住人口8005人,受益人口7154人,占常住人口的89.37%;未改水屯11个.按照<国家生活饮用水卫生标准>要求,14个改水屯居民饮用水含氟量均合格(≤1.20 mg/L),14个改水屯学校中有3个饮水含氟量超标;检测11个未改水屯饮用水含氟量,有7个超标.共检查改水屯8-12岁儿童363人,氟斑牙检出率为39.12%(142/363);未改水屯303人,氟斑牙检出率为43.89%(133/303).共检查改水屯16岁以上成人6424人,氟骨症检出率为6.27%(403/6424);未改水屯3572人,氟骨症检出率为13.89%(496/3572).已改水的中、轻病区16岁以上成人氟骨症患者和8-12岁儿童的尿氟几何均值均在正常参考值(WS/T 256-2005,1.40 mg/L)以下.结论 吉林省改水病区氟中毒病情已得到一定程度的控制,未改水病区氟中毒病情仍然较重,氟中毒防治任务仍很艰巨.

Abstract：

Objective To identify changes in the occurrence of endemic fluorosis in order to provide scientific basis for making countermeasures. Methods Five villages from 14 counties of mild, moderate and severe fluorosis affected areas were selected by stratified cluster sampling every year in the whole province during 2006 - 2010. Water and urinary fluorine were determined by ion selective electrode method(GB/T 8538-1995); dental fluorosis of children 8-12 years old was diagnosed with Dean method; skeletal fluorosis was diagnosed according to "clinical indexing standards of endemic skeletal fluorosis "(GB 16396-1996), between 2006 and 2008, and "clinical diagnosis standard of endemic skeletal fluorosis"(WS 192-2008) between 2009 and 2010. Results A total of 25 diseased villages were surveyed, 14 with water sources changed, covered a resident population of 8005 people, beneficiary population 7154, and accounting for 89.37% of the resident population; not changed villages 11. In accordance with the "State drinking water health standards", in the 14 changed villages the fluoride in drinking water was qualified (≤ 1.20 mg/L), there were 3 schools whose water fluorine content exceeded the standard; among the 11 villages that did not change water sources 7 drinking water samples fluorine content exceeded the standard. Of the 8 to 12 years old children in villages with changed water sources, 363 of them were checked and 142 dental fluorosis were found, the detection rate of dental fluorosis was 39.12% (142/363); in villages with water sources not changed, 303 children were checked, the detection rate of dental fluorosis was 43.89%(133/303). Of sixteen and elder adults in water source changed villages, 6424 people were checked and 403 skeletal fluorosis were found, skeletal fluorosis detection rate was 6.27% (403/6424); 3572 people were checked in not changed villages, the detection rate of skeletal fluorosis was 13.89%(496/3572). In water sources changed areas, geometric mean of urinary fluoride was in the normal reference value(WS/T 256-2005, 1.40 mg/L)or less. Conclusions Endemic fluorosis is decreased in water improved areas, but in unimproved areas the disease is still severe, and control of endemic fluorosis is still an arduous task.     

2009年山东省地方性氟中毒监测结果分析

目的 了解山东省地方性氟中毒的病情现状,为制订防治策略提供科学依据.方法 按照国家<2008年地方病防治项目技术实施方案>的要求,在山东省选择34个县为项目县,各项目县将所有病区村按病情的严重程度分为轻、中、重3层,再在每一层各选择1个病区村,进行病情监测.水氟、尿氟测定采用氟离子选择电极法,8～12岁儿童氟斑牙诊断采用Dean法,16岁以上成人临床和X线摄片检查氟骨症.结果 在34个县中,调查70个改水村,水氟≤1.00 mg/L的村54个,占77.14%(54/70);＞1.00 mg/L的村16个,占22.86%(16/70);水氟最大值为4.46 mg/L.调查32个未改水村,水氟≤1.00 mg/L的村9个,占28.12%(9/32);＞1.00mg/L的村23个,占71.88%(23/32),水氟最大值为4.09 mg/L.8～12岁儿童氟斑牙总检出率为45.81%(1988/4340),氟斑牙指数为0.97,缺损率为6.91%(300/4340).儿童尿氟在1.40 mg/L以上的人数占55.33%(1417/2657),最高值为18.53 mg/L.16岁以上成人的氟骨症临床和X线检出率分别为4.25%(2462/57 968)、28.40%(23/81).成人尿氟在1.60 mg/L以上的人数占55.86%(1130/2023),最高值为25.44 mg/L.结论 山东省地方性氟中毒病情尚未得到有效的控制,防治形势依然比较严峻,须进一步加大防治力度.

Abstract：

Objective To investigate the current status of endemic fluorosis in Shandong province, and to provide the scientific evidence for making strategies for prevention and control of the disease. Methods According to "The National Technical Scheme for Endemic Disease Control in 2008", thirty-four counties were divided into mild, moderate and severe endemic fluorosis areas and a village was randomly selected from each category of the area to carry out the monitoring of endemic fluorosis. The content of fluoride in drinking water and urine was determined by F-ion selective electrode, dental fluorosis of children aged 8 to 12 was diagnosed by Dean method and skeletal fluorosis diagnosed by clinic and X-rays. Results The monitoring was done in 70 water-improving villages in 34 counties, among which 54 villages had water fluoride content ≤ 1.00 mg/L and accounted for 77.14%(54/70), 16 villages had water fluoride content ＞ 1.00 mg/L and accounted for 22.86%(16/70), the highest water fluoride content was 4.46 mg/L. The monitoring was also carried out in 32 non-water-improving villages in 34 counties, among which 9 villages had water fluoride content ≤ 1.00 mg/L and accounted for 28.12%(9/32), 23 villages had water fluoride content ＞ 1.00 mg/L and accounted for 71.88% (23/32), the highest water fluoride content was 4.09 mg/L. The total rate of dental fluorosis of children aged 8 to 12 was 45.81%(1988/4340), the index of dental fluorosis was 0.97 and the rate of dental damage was 6.91%(300/4340). The urinary fluoride values above 1.40 mg/L were found in 55.33%(1417/2657) of children aged 8 to 12, with the highest urinary fluoride concentrations was 18.53 mg/L. The rate of skeletal fluorosis by clinic and X-rays in adults older than 16 years were 4.25% (2462/57 968) and 28.40%(23/81 ), respectively. The urinary fluoride values above 1.60 mg/L were found in 55.86% (1130/2023) of adults older than 16 years, with the highest urinary fluoride concentrations was 25.44 mg/L. Conclusions Endemic fluorosis in Shandong province has not yet been effectively controlled,control situation is still grim. Prevention efforts need to be further strengthened.     

2009年西藏自治区饮水型氟中毒病情监测结果分析

目的 了解西藏饮水型地方性氟中毒的病情动态,评价防治措施的效果,为及时调整防治策略提供科学依据.方法 按照"2008年中央补助地方公共卫生专项资金西藏饮水型氟中毒防治项目"技术方案,于2009年9-10月选取日喀则谢通门和林芝察隅两县作为项目县,在每个项目县采用单纯随机抽样的方法选择3个项目村,以自然村为单位,对改水及改水工程运转情况、饮水含氟量、儿童氟斑牙和成人临床氟骨症进行调查.按照<生活饮用水标准检验方法非金属指标>(GB/T 5750.6-2006)测定水氟;尿中氟化物的测定采用离子选择电极法(WS/T 89-1996);氟斑牙诊断采用Dean法;成人氟骨症诊断按<地方性氟骨症临床诊断标准>(WS192-2008)进行.结果 已改水病区水氟均值在0.18～0.34 mg/L,未改水病区水氟均值在0.70～2.13 mg/L;已改水病区8～10岁儿童氟斑牙检出率为50.78%(65/128),氟斑牙指数为1.04,儿童尿氟均值为1.64 mg/L,未改水病区氟斑牙检出率为80.65%(25/31),氟斑牙指数为1.50,儿童尿氟均值为2.08;已改水病区成人氟骨症患病率为38.7%(104/269),尿氟为1.61 mg/L,未改水病区成人氟骨症患病率为15.4%(18/117),尿氟为3.54mg/L.结论 改水降氟使氟斑牙的检出率降低至控制水平,严重程度也在降低,改水病区尿氟低于未改水病区,说明改水仍对消除氟中毒的危害有重要意义,但氟骨症患病率出现了在改水病区反而高于未改水病区的现象.

Abstract：

Objective To find out the dynamics of drinking water borne endemic fluorosis in Tibet's, to evaluate the effect of control measures, and to provide a scientific basis for the timely adjustment of control strategies. Methods During september to october 2009, according to the "2008 Central Government Special Funds to Subsidize Local Public Health in Drinking Water Borne Fluorosis in Tibet", Xigaze Xietongmen and Nyingchi Zayu were selected as project counties, three project villages were selected with simple random sampling method in each county, the functioning of water improvement projects, drinking water fluoride content, children's dental fluorosis and adult skeletal fluorosis were investigated. Water fluoride was detected by the "standard examination methods for drinking water the non-metallic targets"(GB/T 5750.6-2006) determination of fluoride; urinary fluoride was tested by ion selective electrode (WS/T 89-1996); dental fluorosis was diagnosed using Deans method; adult skeletal fluorosis was diagnosed by "endemic skeletal fluorosis clinical diagnostic criteria" (WS 192-2008). Results Mean water fluoride was 0.18 - 0.34 mg/L in drinking water changed areas, and 0.70 - 2.13 mg/L in not changed areas; prevalence of dental fluorosis of children 8 - 10 was 50.78% (65/128), dental fluorosis index was 1.04,mean urinary fluoride was 1.64 mg/L in drinking water changed areas; prevalence of dental fluorosis of children 8 -10 years old was 80.65%(25/31 ) in not changed areas, dental fluorosis index was 1.50, mean urinary fluoride of children was 2.08; adult clinical skeletal fluorosis was 38.7%(104/269) in drinking water changed areas, the mean urinary fluoride was 1.61 mg/L, prevalence of skeletal fluorosis was 15.4% (18/117) in not changed areas, mean urinary fluoride was 3.54 mg/L. Conclusions The method of change the water to reduce fluoride decreases dental fluorosis to control levels, and severity is also reduced, urinary fluoride is decreased. However, the prevalence of skeletal fluorosis is higher than that of drinking water not changed areas.     

2008年山东省地方性氟中毒病情调查结果分析

目的 分析山东省地方性氟中毒的病情现状,为制订防治策略提供科学依据.方法 2008年按照国家<2007年地方病防治项目技术实施方案>的要求,选择山东省19个县(市、区)以村为单位进行流行病学调查,氟离子选择电极法测定水氟和8～12岁儿童尿氟,Dean法诊断儿童氟斑牙,临床和X线摄片检查16岁以上成人氟骨症.结果 在19个县(市、区)中,共调查了186个村,水氟均值≤1.00 mg/L的村44个,占23.66%(44/186);＞1.00 mg/L的村142个,占76.34%(142/186);水氟最大值为8.88 mg/L.8～12岁儿童氟斑牙总检出率为66.35%(4518/6809),氟斑牙指数为1.55,缺损率为15.39%(1048/6809).儿童尿氟＞1.40mg/L的人数占83.29%(2149/2580),最高值为31.92 mg/L.16岁以上成人氟骨症临床和X线检出率分别为6.37%(5577/87 607)、20.23%(229/1132).结论 山东省地方性氟中毒病情仍然比较严重,防治形势依然比较严峻,须进一步加大防治力度.

Abstract：

Objective To investigate the current status of endemic fluorosis in Shandong province, and to provide scientific evidence for the development of control strategies. Methods According to "The National Technical Scheme for Endemic Disease Control in 2007", 19 counties were chosen to carry out the epidemiological investigation in 2008. Water and urinary fluoride were determined by F-ion selective electrode, dental fluorosis of children aged 8 to 12 were diagnosed by Dean method and skeletal fluorosis of adults over the age of 16 were examined clinically and by X-rays. Results In 19 counties, 186 villages were surveyed, 44 villages were found with mean water fluoride ≤ 1.00 mg/L, accounting for 23.66%(44/186);the value ＞ 1.00 mg/L in 142 villages,accounting for 76.34% (142/186);maximum water fluoride 8.88 mg/L. Total detection rate of dental fluorosis of children aged 8 to 12 was 66.35% (4518/6809), dental fluorosis index was 1.55, and defect rate was 15.39%(1048/6809). Children with urinary fluoride ＞ 1.40 mg/L was 83.29%(2149/2580), and the maximum value was 31.92 mg/L. Detection rates of skeletal fluorosis clinically and by X ray among adults over 16 years were 6.37%(5577/87 607) and 20.23% (229/1132), respectively. Conclusions Endemic fluorosis in Shandong province is still serious, prevention efforts need to be further increased.     

1992-2006年山东省地方性氟中毒重点监测分析

Objective To understand the fulfillment of control measures of endemic fluorosis and find out the prevalent trend of this disease in Shandong Province from 1992 to 2006 in order to provide a scientific basis for the set up of control strategies. Methods According to "the National Survey Scheme of Endemic fluorosis", Huantai County in 1992-1996 and Liaagshan County in 1997-2006 were selected, where water-improving defluoridation and the contents of water fluoride were searched in two counties; dental fluorosis and urine fluoride in children aged 8-12 years old, clinical and X-ray skeletal fluorosis in adult over 16 years old were searched respectively in Lijia Village of Huantai County and Dongxu Village of Liangshan County. Results One hundred percent(304/304) high-fluoride villages of Huantai County in 1992 and 63.72% (137/215) villages of Liangshan County in 2006 had finished the project of water-improving defluoridation; the rate of high-fluorine water(>1.0 mg/L) in normal operation projects was 5.00%(5/100)-17.14%(18/105) in Huantai County from 1992 to 1996, and 18.97%(11/58)-45.61%(26/57) in Liangshan County from 1997 to 2006. The water fluoride of Lijia Village was<1.0 mg/L from 1992 to 1996, the water fluoride of Dongxu Village was<0.5 mg/L from 1997 to 2006. The detection rate of dental fluorosis of children aged 8-12 years at Lijia Village dropped from 30.86%(25/81) in 1992 to 10.13%(8/79) in 1996(χ2=12.41, P<0.05), and the Dongxu Village dropped from 68.95%(151/219) in 1997 to 0(0/38) in 2006(χ2=222.04, P<0.01). In the Lijia and Dongxu Villages, urine fluoride in children aged 8-12 years old was lower than 1.40 mg/L. In the adults over 16 years of the two villages, the positive rate of X-ray skeletal fluorosis of Lijia Village dropped from 30.0%(15/50) in 1992 to 13.95%(6/43) in 1996(χ2=3.41, P>0.05), and all the cases were in degree I, the rate of Dongxu Village dropped from 64.58%(31/48) in 1997 to 16.67% (4/24) in 2006(χ2=14.71, P<0.01), and no eases of degrees Ⅲ was detected. Conclusions The progress of water defluoridation was uneven in 2 counties, slow in Liangshan County; and the water fluoride in part of the project exceeded standard; the water fluorid of 2 surveyed villages was normal and the endemic fluorosis was under control. More financial input is requested to accelerate the process of water defluoridation and to reinforce the management of the projects and illness monitoring, thus to reduce the harm of fluorosis to the limit.     

2009年青海省饮水型地方性氟中毒监测结果分析

目的 掌握青海省饮水型地方性氟中毒病情变化和防治措施落实效果,为防治工作提供依据。方法 2009年,采用单纯随机抽样方法选择6个监测县,每个县根据历史资料将病区村分成轻、中、重3个类型,每个类型抽取1个病区村作为监测村。在已改水病区村采集出厂水1份和末梢水3份,在未改水病区村按东、西、南、北、中5个方位各采集1份水样,水氟测定按照《生活饮用水标准检验方法》(GB/T 5750--2006)。对监测村全部8～ 12岁儿童进行氟斑牙检查,氟斑牙诊断采用Dean法。对监测村全部16岁以上常住人口进行临床氟骨症检查,选择其中2个村,对有临床氟骨症症状的成人进行X线氟骨症检查,氟骨症诊断采用地方性氟骨症诊断标准(WS 192-2008)。每个监测村采集儿童尿样30份、成人尿样20份,采用尿中氟化物的测定离子选择电极法(WS/T 89-2006)检测尿氟。结果 6个县18个病区村中,14个村已落实改水项目,改水率为77.78％(14/18),其中5个改水工程供水正常、9个间歇供水;共检测水样75份,水氟均值为0.48 mg/L。8～ 12岁儿童氟斑牙检出率为31.95％(285/892);16岁以上人群临床氟骨症检出率为36.55％(1570/4295),X线氟骨症检出率为25.64％(20/78)。共检测儿童尿样571份,尿氟几何均数为1.04 mg/L;共检测成人尿样370份,尿氟几何均数为1.52 mg/L。结论 青海省饮水型氟中毒流行仍然较为严重,改水防氟措施应进一步加强和完善。     

河南省2011年饮水型地方性氟中毒流行状况

目的了解河南省饮水型氟中毒病区病情现状,为防治工作提供科学依据。方法按照《河南省2010年地方病防治项目技术方案》要求,在饮水型氟中毒病区抽取10个县(区),在每个县(区)随机抽取10个降氟改水工程,采用分层抽样方法按照轻、中、重原则随机抽取3个病区村。进行水氟含量及8～12岁儿童氟斑牙患病情况监测。结果在10个县(区)共监测100个降氟改水工程,99个能正常运行,改水工程水氟含量超标率21%(21/100)。共调查30个病区村,其中8个为已改水病区村,降氟改水工程水氟含量全部合格,8～12岁儿童氟斑牙的总检出率52.71%(496/941),缺损率5.84%(55/941),氟斑牙指数1.19,流行强度中等;22个为未改水病区村,8～12岁儿童氟斑牙检出率为47.34%(1015/2144),缺损型氟斑牙检出率为13.29%(285/2144),氟斑牙指数为1.15,流行强度中等。结论河南省改水工程水氟含量超标现象依然严重,氟中毒危害仍然较重。因此,应加强改水工程建设的科学论证和竣工时工程验收,杜绝不合格工程投入使用;坚持定期开展水质监测,对水质超标工程及时进行整改。     

2005-2007年陕西省饮用水含氟量和地方性氟中毒病情调查

目的 调查2005-2007年陕西省饮用水含氟量和地方性氟中毒病情,评价改水工程降氟效果.方法 根据以往调查资料,在陕西省选择地方性氟中毒病情流行的10个市作为调查地区,以村为调查点,每村按东、西、南、北、中5个方位抽取水源水5份,同时采集每个改水工程水源水1份、出厂水1份和末梢水2份,采用氟离子选择电极法或氟试剂分光光度法测定水氟;在饮用水含氟量>1.00 mg/L的人群中进行地方性氟中毒流行病学调查,采用Dean法进行8～12岁儿童氟斑牙诊断,成人氟骨症按<地方性氟骨症临床分度诊断>(GB16396-1996)诊断.结果 共测定6390个村的水源水含氟量,其中水氟在1.00～<2.00 mg/L的有2619个村,暴露人口为1 654 998人;水氟在2.00～<4.00 mg/L的有845个村,暴露人口为355 623人;水氟≥4.00mg/L的有272个村,暴露人口为111 466人.全省水氟中位数为1.15 mg/L.渭南、咸阳和榆林3个市水氟中位数>1.00 mg/L,为高氟水集中分布的地区.共检测了3115个改水工程水氟,其中水氟在1.00～<2.00 mg/L的有1269个,暴露人口为1 415 877人;水氟在2.00～<4.00 mg/L的有120个,暴露人口为43 888人:水氟≥4.00 mg/L的有14个,暴露人口为5960人.44 081名8～12岁儿童进行氟斑牙临床检查,检出16 489例氟斑牙患者,检出率为37.4%(16 489/44 081);对310 993名成人进行氟骨症临床检查,检出15 877例Ⅱ度以上氟骨症患者,检出率为5.1%(15 877/310 993).结论 高氟水在陕西省广泛分布,地方性氟中毒流行较严重,降氟改水工程质量有待进一步提高.     

2008年陕西省饮水型地方性氟中毒调查分析

目的 掌握2008年陕西省饮水型地方性氟中毒流行现状,为防治工作提供依据.方法 根据陕西省饮水型地方性氟中毒历史资料,将榆林、渭南、咸阳市15个病区县(区)按照饮水含氟量或病情分为轻、中、重病区,在上述病区分别抽取12、39、45个调查村.对每个调查村全部8～12岁儿童进行氟斑牙检查,对16岁及以上人群进行I临床氟骨症检查.在轻、中、重病区中分别抽取30%的调查村,每个村抽取男女各10人进行X线氟骨症检查;在未改水调查村,按东、西、南、北、中采5份水样,水源不足5个的全部采集,对已改水调查村,采3份末梢水样及1份水源水样,水氟测定采用氟离子电极法.在各病区中抽取50%的调查村,每个村采集8～12岁儿童尿样30份,每个年龄组6份,总数不足30人或各年龄组不足6人时全部采集其尿样,采用氟离子电极法测定尿氟.结果 共调查8～12岁儿童3652人,检出氟斑牙患者1930例,检出率为52.85%,氟斑牙指数为1.22.其中定边、靖边、蒲城县的检出率较高,分别为90.43%(170/188)、82.89%(126/152)、80.65%(325/403).共调查16岁及以上成人加543人,检出临床氟骨症患者5935例,总检出率为14.64%.轻、中、重度检出率分别为9.17%(3717/40 543)、4.36%(1769/40 543)、1.11%(449/40 543).X线拍片706例,检出阳性人数280例,总阳性率为39.66%.轻、中、重度阳性率分别为17.28%(122/706)、17.00%(120//06)和5.38%(38/706).采集饮用水水样427份,水氟为(2.22 ±1.41)mg/L,超标率为85.01%(363/427).采集儿童尿样1393份,尿氟中位数为2.37 mr/L.结论 陕西省饮水型氟中毒流行仍然较为严重,改水防治措施应进一步加强和完善.、     

延安市饮用水含氟量和地方性氟中毒病情调查

目的 掌握延安市高氟水的分布和地方性氟中毒(简称地氟病)病情现状,评价降氟改水工程效果.方法 2006年,在延安市以村为调查点,每村按东、西、南、北、中5个方位共采集5份水源水样,同时采集每个改水工程1份水源水样、1份出厂水水样和2份末梢水水样,采用氟试剂分光光度法检测水氟;在水氟>1.00 mg/L的村中采用Dean法对所有8～12岁儿童进行氟斑牙检查,根据<地方性氟骨症临床分度诊断>法对所有成人进行氟骨症检查.结果 筛查293个村的水源水样726份,水氟中位数为0.59 mg/L,范围为0.10～3.50 mg/L;有25个村水氟超标(>1.00 mg/L),暴露人口为11 610人,高氟村主要在吴起、延川县.筛查25个改水工程,100份水样,水氟中位数为0.58 mg/L,范围为0.30～2.00 mg/L;其中延川、吴起县各有1个工程水氟超标,水氟分别为1.85、1.60 mg/L,暴露人口分别为3083、708人.对1281名8～12岁儿童进行氟斑牙检查,检出238例患者,检出率为18.58%;对13 900名成人进行氟骨症检查,检出375例Ⅱ度以上氟骨症患者,检出率为2.70%.结论 延安市高氟水分布范围广,水氟超标情况和病情比较严重,改水工程有待进一步提高,防治任务依然艰巨,必须加快落实降氟改水等综合防治措施.     

2005年甘肃省饮水型氟中毒病区水氟和改水降氟工程调查

目的 了解2005年甘肃省饮水型氟中毒病区水氟分布和改水降氟工程现状.方法 对甘肃省地方性氟中毒病区饮水和改水降氟工程进行水氟监测和工程运转情况调查登记.水氟测定用氟离子选择电极法.结果 筛查了11个市(州)的34个县(区)354个乡(镇)的1576个村的水源.检测水样7829份,检测出水氟超标水样1891份,占24.15%.水氟均值≤1.0 mg/L的村为1185个,占调查村的75.19%;1.0 mg/L的村为391个,占24.81%;水氟最低为0.04 mg/L,最高为6.78 ms/L,以庆阳市、平凉市及定西市总体水氟均值较高,大于或接近1.0 mg/L.调查了993处改水降氟工程,对876处工程的饮水含氟量进行了检测,共检测水样3528份,有408份水样含氟量1.0 mg/L.其中≤1.0 mg/L的工程768处,占87.67%;1.0 mg/L的工程108处,占12.33%;水氟最高为5.27mg/L.剔除能正常运转但水氟超标部分,实际水氟合格且正常使用的工程682处,占68.68%.改水降氟的主要形式为打井和引水.结论 甘肃省筛查村的水氟超标仍较严重,有近1/3的改水工程报废或处于非正常运转状态,须尽快落实防治措施和加强改水降氟工程的监测和管理力度.