Biomimetic collagen scaffolds with anisotropic pore architecture

Sponge-like matrices with a specific three-dimensional structural design resembling the actual extracellular matrix of a particular tissue show significant potential for the regeneration and repair of a broad range of damaged anisotropic tissues. The manipulation of the structure of collagen scaffolds using a freeze-drying technique was explored in this work as an intrinsically biocompatible way of tailoring the inner architecture of the scaffold. The research focused on the influence of temperature gradients, imposed during the phase of crystallisation of collagen suspensions, upon the degree of anisotropy in the microstructures of the scaffolds produced. Moulding technology was employed to achieve differences in heat transfer rates during the freezing processes. For this purpose various moulds with different configurations were developed with a view to producing uniaxial and multi-directional temperature gradients across the sample during this process. Scanning electron microscopy analysis of different cross-sections (longitudinal and horizontal) of scaffolds revealed that highly aligned matrices with axially directed pore architectures were obtained where single unidirectional temperature gradients were induced. Altering the freezing conditions by the introduction of multiple temperature gradients allowed collagen scaffolds to be produced with complex pore orientations, and anisotropy in pore size and alignment.     

Influence of freezing rate on pore structure in freeze-dried collagen-GAG scaffolds

The cellular structure of collagen-glycosaminoglycan (CG) scaffolds used in tissue engineering must be designed to meet a number of constraints with respect to biocompatibility, degradability, pore size, pore structure, and specific surface area. The conventional freeze-drying process for fabricating CG scaffolds creates variable cooling rates throughout the scaffold during freezing, producing a heterogeneous matrix pore structure with a large variation in average pore diameter at different locations throughout the scaffold. In this study, the scaffold synthesis process was modified to produce more homogeneous freezing by controlling of the rate of freezing during fabrication and obtaining more uniform contact between the pan containing the CG suspension and the freezing shelf through the use of smaller, less warped pans. The modified fabrication technique has allowed production of CG scaffolds with a more homogeneous structure characterized by less variation in mean pore size throughout the scaffold (mean: 95.9 microm, CV: 0.128) compared to the original scaffold (mean: 132.4 microm, CV: 0.185). The pores produced using the new technique appear to be more equiaxed, compared with those in scaffolds produced using the original technique.     

Paraffin spheres as porogen to fabricate poly(L-lactic acid) scaffolds with improved cytocompatibility for cartilage tissue engineering

Three-dimensional poly(L-lactic acid) (PLLA) scaffolds with high porosity and pore size ranging from 150 to 700 microm were conveniently prepared with paraffin spheres used as porogen. PLLA/1,4-dioxane solution containing a given amount of paraffin spheres was frozen at -25 degrees C to obtain a solidified mixture, followed with freeze drying and subsequent leaching with hexane to remove the 1,4-dioxane and paraffin spheres, respectively. The fabricated PLLA scaffolds were highly porous with evenly distributed and interconnected pores. The microstructures of the PLLA scaffolds as a function of paraffin-sphere size, paraffin-sphere dosage, and PLLA concentration were characterized by confocal laser scanning microscopy (CLSM) and scanning-electronic microscopy (SEM). To improve the cytocompatibility of the bioinert material, a hybrid PLLA scaffold containing Type I collagen was prepared by pressing the collagen solution into the scaffold under reduced pressure. The amounts of the collagen introduced in the scaffolds were detected by ninhydrin method. The distribution of the collagen in the scaffolds was studied with CLSM. Finally, in vitro cell culture was performed by injecting a chondrocyte suspension into the scaffolds. The results showed that the chondrocytes were more evenly distributed and more spread out in the collagen-modified PLLA scaffolds than in the unmodified ones.     

Growth of osteoblast-like cells on biomimetic apatite-coated chitosan scaffolds

Porous scaffold materials that can provide a framework for the cells to adhere, proliferate, and create extracellular matrix are considered to be suitable materials for bone regeneration. Interconnected porous chitosan scaffolds were prepared by freeze-drying method, and were mineralized by calcium and phosphate solution by double-diffusion method to form nanoapatite in chitosan matrix. The mineralized chitosan scaffold contains hydroxyapatite nanocrystals on the surface and also within the pore channels of the scaffold. To assess the effect of apatite and porosity of the scaffolds on cells, human osteoblast (SaOS-2) cells were cultured on unmineralized and mineralized chitosan scaffolds. The cell growth on the mineralized scaffolds and on the pure chitosan scaffold shows a similar growth trend. The total protein content and alkaline phosphatase enzyme activity of the cells grown on scaffolds were quantified, and were found to increase over time in mineralized scaffold after 1 and 3 weeks of culture. The electron microscopy of the cell-seeded scaffolds showed that most of the outer macropores became sealed off by a continuous layer of cells. The cells spanned around the pore wall and formed extra cellular matrix, consisting mainly of collagen in mineralized scaffolds. The hydroxyproline content also confirmed the formation of the collagen matrix by cells in mineralized scaffolds. This study demonstrated that the presence of apatite nanocrystals in chitosan scaffolds does not significantly influence the growth of cells, but does induce the formation of extracellular matrix and therefore has the potential to serve for bone tissue engineering.     

In vitro assessment of axonal growth using dorsal root ganglia explants in a novel three-dimensional collagen matrix

The goal of this study was the development of a bioartificial nerve guide to induce axonal regeneration in the peripheral nervous system (PNS). In this in vitro study, the ability of a novel, 3-dimensional (3D), highly oriented, cross-linked porcine collagen scaffold to promote directed axonal growth has been studied. Collagen nerve guides with longitudinal guidance channels were manufactured using a series of chemical and mechanical treatments with a patented unidirectional freezing process, followed by freeze-drying (pore sizes 20-50 microm). Hemisected rat dorsal root ganglia (DRG) were positioned such that neural and non-neural elements could migrate into the collagen scaffold. After 21 days, S100-positive Schwann cells (SCs) migrated into the scaffold and aligned within the guidance channels in a columnar fashion, resembling "Bands of Büngner." Neurofilament-positive axons (mean length +/- SD 756 microm +/- 318 microm, maximum 1496 microm) from DRG neurons entered the scaffold where the growth within the guidance channels was closely associated with the oriented SCs. This study confirmed the importance of SCs in the regeneration process (neurotrophic theory). The alignment of SCs within the guidance channels supported directional axonal growth (contact guidance theory). The microstructural properties of the scaffold (open, porous, longitudinal pore channels) and the in vitro data after DRG loading (axonal regeneration along migrated and columnar-aligned SCs resembling "Band of Büngner") suggest that this novel oriented 3D collagen scaffold serves as a basis for future experimental regeneration studies in the PNS.     

Fabrication of well-defined PLGA scaffolds using novel microembossing and carbon dioxide bonding

A novel biologically benign technique was developed to produce three-dimensional tissue engineering scaffolds with well-defined structure. Photolithography was used to design and pattern a planar scaffold skeletal structure on a photoresist (SU-8), and a variety of microembossing processes including sacrificial layer embossing and bilayer embossing were developed to transfer the skeletal pattern to the poly(DL-lactide-co-glycolide) substrate as scaffold skeletons. Subcritical carbon dioxide was then introduced to assemble these skeletons to a three-dimensional scaffold at a low temperature. Compared with conventional scaffolds, which have a broad pore size distribution and varying pore geometry, these microfabricated scaffolds have a uniform and well-defined geometry and structure. This uniformity of structural parameters allows for the studies of cell attachment, spreading, and proliferation in scaffolds in a controlled and logical manner. The cytocompatibility of these microfabricated scaffolds was tested by seeding three different cell lines with different morphologies and growth patterns into these scaffolds. All three cell lines attached well to the scaffolds and grew to high densities as observed with scanning electron microscopy. This study demonstrates a controllable method to fabricate tissue scaffolds with a well-defined 3D architecture that can be used to better elucidate the effect of structure parameters such as pore geometry and pore size on tissue growth in 3D scaffolds.     

Cell proliferation and migration in silk fibroin 3D scaffolds

Pore architecture in 3D polymeric scaffolds is known to play a critical role in tissue engineering as it provides the vital framework for the seeded cells to organize into a functioning tissue. In this report, we investigated the effects of different freezing temperature regimes on silk fibroin protein 3D scaffold pore microstructure. The fabricated scaffolds using freeze-dry technique were used as a 3D model to monitor cell proliferation and migration. Pores of 200–250 μm diameter were formed by slow cooling at temperatures of ?20 and ?80 °C but were found to be limited in porosity and pore interconnectivity as observed through scanning electron microscopic images. In contrast, highly interconnected pores with 96% porosity were observed when silk solutions were rapidly frozen at ?196 °C. A detailed study was conducted to assess the affect of pore size, porosity and interconnectivity on human dermal fibroblast cell proliferation and migration on these 3D scaffolds using confocal microscopy. The cells were observed to migrate within the scaffold interconnectivities and were found to reach scaffold periphery within 28 days of culture. Confocal images further confirmed normal cell attachment and alignment of actin filaments within the porous scaffold matrix with well-developed nuclei. This study indicates rapid freeze-drying technique as an alternative method to fabricate highly interconnected porous scaffolds for developing functional 3D silk fibroin matrices for potential tissue engineering, biomedical and biotechnological applications.     

Characterization of mineralized collagen-glycosaminoglycan scaffolds for bone regeneration

Mineralized collagen–glycosaminoglycan scaffolds designed for bone regeneration have been synthesized via triple co-precipitation in the absence of a titrant phase. Here, we characterize the microstructural and mechanical properties of these newly developed scaffolds with 50 and 75 wt.% mineral content. The 50 wt.% scaffold had an equiaxed pore structure with isotropic mechanical properties and a Ca–P-rich mineral phase comprised of brushite; the 75 wt.% scaffold had a bilayer structure with a pore size varying in the through-thickness direction and a mineral phase comprised of 67% brushite and 33 wt.% monetite. The compressive stress–strain response of the scaffolds was characteristic of low-density open-cell foams with distinct linear elastic, collapse plateau and densification regimes. The elastic modulus and strength of individual struts within the scaffolds were measured using an atomic force microscopy cantilevered beam-bending technique and compared with the composite response under indentation and unconfined compression. Cellular solids models, using the measured strut properties, overestimated the overall mechanical properties for the scaffolds; the discrepancy arises from defects such as disconnected pore walls within the scaffold. As the scaffold stiffness and strength decreased with increasing overall mineral content and were less than that of natural, mineralized collagen scaffolds, these microstructural/mechanical relations will be used to further improve scaffold design for bone regeneration applications.     

Radially oriented collagen scaffold with SDF-1 promotes osteochondral repair by facilitating cell homing

The migration of cells from the side and the bottom of the defect is important in osteochondral defect healing. Here, we designed a novel collagen scaffold that possessed channels in both the horizontal and the vertical directions, along with stromal cell-derived factor-1 (SDF-1) to enhance osteochondral regeneration by facilitating cell homing. Firstly we fabricated the radially oriented and random collagen scaffolds, then tested their properties. The radially oriented collagen scaffold had better mechanical properties than the random scaffold, but both supported cell proliferation well. Then we measured the migration of BMSCs in the scaffolds in vitro. The radially oriented collagen scaffold effectively promoted their migration, and this effect was further facilitated by addition of SDF-1. Moreover, we created osteochondral defects in rabbits, and implanted them with random or oriented collagen scaffolds with or without SDF-1, and evaluated cartilage and subchondral bone regeneration at 6 and 12 weeks after surgery. Cartilage regeneration with both the radially oriented scaffold and SDF-1 effectively promoted repair of the cartilage defect. Our results confirmed that the implantation of the radially oriented channel collagen scaffold with SDF-1 could be a promising strategy for osteochondral repair.     

A Collagen/Smooth Muscle Cell-Incorporated Elastic Scaffold for Tissue-Engineered Vascular Grafts

Biodegradable tubular scaffolds have been developed for vascular graft application. This study was focused to improve the adhesion and proliferation of vascular smooth muscle cells (SMCs) in a tubular scaffold. Tubular scaffolds (ID 4 mm, OD 6 mm) were fabricated from a biodegradable elastic polymer, poly(L-lactide-co-ε-caprolactone) (PLCL) (50:50, M _n 1.58 × 10⁵), by an extrusion/particulate leaching method. SMCs suspended in a collagen solution were infiltrated in tubular PLCL scaffolds under vacuum and incubated for 1 h at 37°C to form a collagenous gel. Results from SEM image analysis showed that collagen was infiltrated into the inside of the scaffolds. Cell adhesion and proliferation rate increased in collagen/SMC-incorporated tubular PLCL scaffolds as compared with the scaffolds in which only SMCs were seeded. From SEM image and histological analysis, we further found that SMCs grew on the inside as well as on the surface of collagen/SMCs-incorporated scaffolds and the cells continued to grow as a monolayer on collagen fibers. In particular, cell proliferation and elastin contents were the highest in a PLCL scaffold with 50–100 μm pore size than any other scaffolds used in this experiment. A collagen/SMC-incorporated PLCL scaffold may support SMC growth and functions and can be used as a scaffold for tissue engineering to facilitate small-diameter vascular-tissue formation.     

Photo-patterning of porous hydrogels for tissue engineering

Since pore size and geometry strongly impact cell behavior and in vivo reaction, the ability to create scaffolds with a wide range of pore geometries that can be tailored to suit a particular cell type addresses a key need in tissue engineering. In this contribution, we describe a novel and simple technique to design porous, degradable poly(2-hydroxyethyl methacrylate) hydrogel scaffolds with well-defined architectures using a unique photolithography process and optimized polymer chemistry. A sphere-template was used to produce a highly uniform, monodisperse porous structure. To create a patterned and porous hydrogel scaffold, a photomask and initiating light were employed. Open, vertical channels ranging in size from 360+/-25 to 730+/-70 microm were patterned into approximately 700 microm thick hydrogels with pore diameters of 62+/-8 or 147+/-15 microm. Collagen type I was immobilized onto the scaffolds to facilitate cell adhesion. To assess the potential of these novel scaffolds for tissue engineering, a skeletal myoblast cell line (C2C12) was seeded onto scaffolds with 147 microm pores and 730 microm diameter channels, and analyzed by histology and digital volumetric imaging. Cell elongation, cell spreading and fibrillar formation were observed on these novel scaffolds. In summary, 3D architectures can be patterned into porous hydrogels in one step to create a wide range of tissue engineering scaffolds that may be tailored for specific applications.     

Fabrication of channeled scaffolds with ordered array of micro-pores through microsphere leaching and indirect Rapid Prototyping technique

Advanced scaffold fabrication techniques such as Rapid Prototyping (RP) are generally recognized to be advantageous over conventional fabrication methods in terms architectural control and reproducibility. Yet, most RP techniques tend to suffer from resolution limitations which result in scaffolds with uncontrollable, random-size pores and low porosity, albeit having interconnected channels which is characteristically present in most RP scaffolds. With the increasing number of studies demonstrating the profound influences of scaffold pore architecture on cell behavior and overall tissue growth, a scaffold fabrication method with sufficient architectural control becomes imperative. The present study demonstrates the use of RP fabrication techniques to create scaffolds having interconnected channels as well as controllable micro-size pores. Adopted from the concepts of porogen leaching and indirect RP techniques, the proposed fabrication method uses monodisperse microspheres to create an ordered, hexagonal closed packed (HCP) array of micro-pores that surrounds the existing channels of the RP scaffold. The pore structure of the scaffold is shaped using a single sacrificial construct which comprises the microspheres and a dissolvable RP mold that were sintered together. As such, the size of pores as well as the channel configuration of the scaffold can be tailored based on the design of the RP mold and the size of microspheres used. The fabrication method developed in this work can be a promising alternative way of preparing scaffolds with customized pore structures that may be required for specific studies concerning cell-scaffold interactions.     

Effect of scaffold architecture and pore size on smooth muscle cell growth

Tissue engineering has the potential to replace damaged tissues and organs. Diffusion limitation of cell growth in three-dimensional (3D) scaffolds is a significant constraint in most tissue engineering applications. This study describes a scaffold architecture that improves mass transfer. Scaffolds with three different geometries of villi architecture (0.5, 1, 0.5; 0.5, 1, 1; 1, 1, 1 mm; villus diameter, height, intervillus spacing, respectively) were fabricated by indirect 3D printing technique. The ability of these scaffolds to support smooth muscle cell growth was investigated in vitro. Smooth muscle cells attached to the scaffolds uniformly after 1 day of culture, and the cell density in the scaffold with small villi feature (0.5 mm) was significantly higher as compared to that for the scaffold with large villi features (1 mm) after 14 days of culture. To evaluate the effect of scaffold pore size on cell growth, scaffolds with three different pore size ranges (50-100, 100-150, and 150-200 microm) were fabricated by the solvent casting and particulate leaching technique. Scaffold pore size did not significantly affect cell growth after 14 days of culture. Optimization in the architectural design of scaffolds provides an alternative method to improve diffusion limitation in the 3D constructs.     

Designed hybrid scaffolds consisting of polycaprolactone microstrands and electrospun collagen-nanofibers for bone tissue regeneration

Biomedical scaffolds used in bone tissue engineering should have various properties including appropriate bioactivity, mechanical strength, and morphologically optimized pore structures. Collagen has been well known as a good biomaterial for various types of tissue regeneration, but its usage has been limited due to its low mechanical property and rapid degradation. In this work, a new hybrid scaffold consisting of polycaprolactone (PCL) and collagen is proposed for bone tissue regeneration. The PCL enhances the mechanical properties of the hybrid scaffold and controls the pore structure. Layered collagen nanofibers were used to enhance the initial cell attachment and proliferation. The results showed that the hybrid scaffold yielded better mechanical properties of pure PCL scaffold as well as enhanced biological activity than the pure PCL scaffold did. The effect of pore size on bone regeneration was investigated using two hybrid scaffolds with pore sizes of 200 ± 20 and 300 ± 27 μm. After post-seeding for 7 days, the cell proliferation with pore size, 200 ± 20 μm, was greater than that with pore size, 300 ± 27 μm, due to the high surface area of the scaffold.     

The effect of anisotropic collagen-GAG scaffolds and growth factor supplementation on tendon cell recruitment, alignment, and metabolic activity

Current surgical and tissue engineering approaches for treating tendon injuries have shown limited success, suggesting the need for new biomaterial strategies. Here we describe the development of an anisotropic collagen-glycosaminoglycan (CG) scaffold and use of growth factor supplementation strategies to create a 3D platform for tendon tissue engineering. We fabricated cylindrical CG scaffolds with aligned tracks of ellipsoidal pores that mimic the native physiology of tendon by incorporating a directional solidification step into a conventional lyophilization strategy. By modifying the freezing temperature, we created a homologous series of aligned CG scaffolds with constant relative density and degree of anisotropy but a range of pore sizes (55-243?μm). Equine tendon cells showed greater levels of attachment, metabolic activity, and alignment as well as less cell-mediated scaffold contraction, when cultured in anisotropic scaffolds compared to an isotropic CG scaffold control. The anisotropic CG scaffolds also provided critical contact guidance cues for cell alignment. While tendon cells were randomly oriented in the isotropic control scaffold and the transverse (unaligned) plane of the anisotropic scaffolds, significant cell alignment was observed in the direction of the contact guidance cues in the longitudinal plane of the anisotropic scaffolds. Scaffold pore size was found to significantly influence tendon cell viability, proliferation, penetration into the scaffold, and metabolic activity in a manner predicted by cellular solids arguments. Finally, the addition of the growth factors PDGF-BB and IGF-1 to aligned CG scaffolds was found to enhance tendon cell motility, viability, and metabolic activity in dose-dependent manners. This work suggests a composite strategy for developing bioactive, 3D material systems for tendon tissue engineering.     

Design of scaffolds for blood vessel tissue engineering using a multi-layering electrospinning technique

Aiming to develop a scaffold architecture mimicking morphological and mechanically that of a blood vessel, a sequential multi-layering electrospinning (ME) was performed on a rotating mandrel-type collector. A bi-layered tubular scaffold composed of a stiff and oriented PLA outside fibrous layer and a pliable and randomly oriented PCL fibrous inner layer (PLA/PCL) was fabricated. Control over the level of fibre orientation of the different layers was achieved through the rotation speed of the collector. The structural and mechanical properties of the scaffolds were examined using scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and tensile testing. To assess their capability to support cell attachment, proliferation and migration, 3T3 mouse fibroblasts and later human venous myofibroblasts (HVS) were cultured, expanded and seeded on the scaffolds. In both cases, the cell-polymer constructs were cultured under static conditions for up to 4 weeks. Environmental-scanning electron microscopy (SEM), confocal laser scanning microscopy (CLSM), histological examination and biochemical assays for cell proliferation (DNA) and extracellular matrix production (collagen and glycosaminoglycans) were performed. The findings suggest the feasibility of ME to design scaffolds with a hierarchical organization through a layer-by-layer process and control over fibre orientation. The resulting scaffolds achieved the desirable levels of pliability (elastic up to 10% strain) and proved to be capable to promote cell growth and proliferation. The electrospun PLA/PCL bi-layered tube presents appropriate characteristics to be considered a candidate scaffold for blood vessel tissue engineering.     

Characterization and cytocompatibility of biphasic calcium phosphate/polyamide 6 scaffolds for bone regeneration

Porous scaffolds of biphasic calcium phosphate (BCP)/polyamide 6 (PA6) with weight ratios of 30/70, 45/55, and 55/45 have been fabricated through a modified thermally induced phase separation technique. The chemical structure properties, macrostructure, and mechanical strength of the scaffolds were characterized by Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy, X-ray diffraction, thermogravimetric analysis, scanning electron microscopy, and mechanical testing. The results indicated that the BCP/PA6 scaffolds had an interconnected porous structure with a pore size mainly ranging from 100 to 900 μm and many micropores on the rough pore walls. The mechanical property of the scaffold was significantly enhanced by the addition of BCP inorganic fillers. The 55/45 BCP/PA6 composite scaffold with 76.5% ± 2.1% porosity attained a compressive strength of 1.86 ± 0.14 MPa. Moreover, the BCP/PA6 porous scaffold was cultured with rat calvarial osteoblasts to investigate the cell proliferation, viability, and differentiation function (alkaline phosphatase). The type I collagen expression was also used to characterize the differentiation of rat calvarial osteoblasts on BCP/PA6 composite scaffold by immunocytochemistry. The in vitro cytocompatibility evaluation demonstrated that the BCP/PA6 scaffold acted as a good template for the cells adhesion, spreading, growth, and differentiation. These results suggest that the BCP/PA6 porous composite could be a candidate as an excellent substitute for damaged or defect bone.     

Three-dimensional electrospun ECM-based hybrid scaffolds for cardiovascular tissue engineering

Electrospinning using natural proteins or synthetic polymers is a promising technique for the fabrication of fibrous scaffolds for various tissue engineering applications. However, one limitation of scaffolds electrospun from natural proteins is the need to cross-link with glutaraldehyde for stability, which has been postulated to lead to many complications in vivo including graft failure. In this study, we determined the characteristics of hybrid scaffolds composed of natural proteins including collagen and elastin, as well as gelatin, and the synthetic polymer poly(epsilon-caprolactone) (PCL), so to avoid chemical cross-linking. Fiber size increased proportionally with increasing protein and polymer concentrations, whereas pore size decreased. Electrospun gelatin/PCL scaffolds showed a higher tensile strength when compared to collagen/elastin/PCL constructs. To determine the effects of pore size on cell attachment and migration, both hybrid scaffolds were seeded with adipose-derived stem cells. Scanning electron microscopy and nuclei staining of cell-seeded scaffolds demonstrated the complete cell attachment to the surfaces of both hybrid scaffolds, although cell migration into the scaffold was predominantly seen in the gelatin/PCL hybrid. The combination of natural proteins and synthetic polymers to create electrospun fibrous structures resulted in scaffolds with favorable mechanical and biological properties.     

Collagen-based wound dressings: control of the pore structure and morphology

Collagen-based sponges have been used as both temporary and permanent coverings for dermal defects in animals and humans. Cellular ingrowth within such a sponge has been shown to depend on the porosity and the presence of fibrous structure. Collagen sponges were made by freezing and freeze-drying dispersions under acidic conditions. These studies involved the effects of dispersion pH and viscosity as well as freezing temperature on the surface and bulk morphology of collagen-based sponges. Using scanning electron and light microscopy, the results of these studies indicated that large surface pores that form connections (channels) with the interior of the sponge were formed using low-viscosity collagen dispersions. At high dispersion pH (3.2) and at a moderate freezing temperature (-30 degrees C), fibrous structure and a large number of channels were present. When a lower dispersion pH (2.0) and freezing temperature (-80 degrees C) were used, pores sizes were smaller with channels and fibrous structure, whereas a higher freezing temperature (-20 degrees C) resulted in a sheet-like structure and increased pore sizes. Differences in pore size and surface morphology were explained on the basis of ice crystal growth. In the case of abundant free water (high pH) and high freezing temperature, the pore size was greatest because of enhanced ice crystal growth.