Future research in immunology for composite tissue allotransplantation

Hand and composite tissue allotransplantation (CTA) holds great potential for reconstructive surgery but its development is currently limited by the side-effects of the immunosuppressive drugs. Induction of specific tolerance, a situation where the recipient does not mount an immune response against the allograft but remains fully immunocompetent, holds exciting promise. Generation of mixed hematopoietic chimerism by infusing the recipient with donor bone marrow cells has been shown to induce tolerance without chronic immunosuppression. Genetic matching of the donor and the recipient is another option for transplanting composite tissues with only an initial course of immunosuppression. Experiments demonstrated long-term survival of musculoskeletal allografts between MHC-matched miniature swine. Finally, new immunosuppressive agents with a more targeted action will reduce side-effects and may prevent the development of chronic rejection. Skin-specific immunosuppression is particularly useful for limb transplants since skin, regarded as the most antigenic component, is easily accessible to topical or irradiation therapies.     

Long-term results of a controlled prospective study with transfusion of donor-specific bone marrow in 57 cadaveric renal allograft recipients

Experimental studies have shown that antilymphocyte globulin combined with transfusion of donor-specific bone marrow cells can induce partial tolerance to allograft tissue. We have adapted these protocols to clinical use and present the results of 57 cadaveric renal allograft recipients who received Minnesota ALG followed by the transfusion of cryopreserved donor-specific bone marrow. A group of 54 patients received the contralateral kidney and similar immunosuppression without the marrow transfusion and serve as controls. Both groups received quadruple immunosuppression with MALG, cyclosporin, azathioprine, and prednisone. In the bone marrow group, after a 10-14 day induction course of ALG, cryopreserved marrow was transfused on the seventh day after the last dose of ALG. The median follow-up in both groups is 16 months, (range 2.5-33 months). Six grafts have been lost in the bone marrow group, (three rejections, 2 deaths [Cr 2.0, 2.3], 1 recurrent disease). In the control group 16 grafts have been lost (13 rejections, 3 deaths [Cr 1.7, 2.5, 3.0]). Five patients in the control group have biopsy-proved chronic rejection compared to one in the bone marrow group. 17 patients in the bone marrow group have been tapered off the prednisone, and three of these patients have had mild late rejection episodes without graft loss. The two groups were compared for differences in the number of rejection episodes, estimated renal plasma flow, glomerular filtration rate, and urine protein. No differences were found. The allograft survival of the bone marrow group was significantly greater (P less than .01) than the control group. The graft survival rates for the bone marrow group at 12 and 18 months were 90% (confidence limits [CL] 85-94) and 85% (CL 78-90), respectively. In the the control group the 12 and 18 month allograft survival rates were 71% (CL 63-78) and 67% (CL 58-74), respectively. The survival in the control group was similar to our overall transplant experience with quadruple therapy. Mixed lymphocyte culture analysis shows a trend to diminished donor-specific responsiveness in the bone marrow group. The use of cryopreserved donor-specific bone marrow is associated with improved allograft survival in cadaveric kidney allograft recipients. However, a more effective induction protocol is needed to reduce the overall number of rejection episodes.     

New trends and future directions of research in hand and composite tissue allotransplantation

Hand and composite tissue allotransplantation (CTA) holds great potential for reconstructive surgery but its development currently is limited by the side effects of the immunosuppressive drugs. Induction of specific tolerance, a situation in which the recipient does not mount an immune response against the allograft but remains fully immunocompetent, holds exciting promise. The generation of mixed hematopoietic chimerism by infusing the recipient with donor bone marrow cells has been shown to induce tolerance without chronic immunosuppression. Genetic matching of the donor and the recipient is another option for transplanting composite tissues with only an initial course of immunosuppression. Experiments showed long-term survival of musculoskeletal allografts between major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-matched miniature swine. Finally, new immunosuppressive agents with a more targeted action will reduce side effects and may prevent the development of chronic rejection. Skin-specific immunosuppression is particularly useful for limb transplants because skin, regarded as the most antigenic component, is easily accessible to topical or irradiation therapies.     

The future of immunotherapy for composite tissues allotransplantation

Hand and composite tissue allotransplantation (CTA) holds great potential for reconstructive surgery but its development is currently limited by the side effects of the immunosuppressive drugs. Induction of specific tolerance, a situation where the recipient does not mount an immune response against the allograft but remains fully immunocompetent, holds exciting promise. Generation of mixed hematopoietic chimerism by infusing the recipient with donor bone marrow cells has been shown to induce tolerance without chronic immunosuppression. Genetic matching of the donor and the recipient is another option for transplanting composite tissues with only an initial course of immunosuppression. Experiments demonstrated long-term survival of musculoskeletal allografts between MHC-matched miniature swine. Finally, new immunosuppressive agents with a more targeted action will reduce side effects and may prevent the development of chronic rejection. Skin-specific immunosuppression is particularly useful for limb transplants since skin, regarded as the most antigenic component, is easily accessible to topical or irradiation therapies.     

Portal Venous Donor-Specific Transfusion in Conjunction with Sirolimus Prolongs Renal Allograft Survival in Nonhuman Primates

Pretransplant exposure to donor antigen is known to modulate recipient alloimmunity, and frequently results in sensitization. However, donor-specific transfusion (DST) can have a protolerant effect that is dependent on route, dose and coadministered immunosuppression. Rodent studies have shown in some strain combinations that portal venous (PV) DST alone can induce tolerance, and uncontrolled clinical use of PVDST has been reported. In order to determine if pretransplant PVDST has a clinically relevant salutary effect, we studied it and the influence of concomitant immunosuppression in rhesus monkeys undergoing renal allotransplantation. Animals received PVDST with unfractionated bone marrow and/or tacrolimus or sirolimus 1 week prior to transplantation. Graft survival was assessed without any posttransplant immunosuppression. PVDST alone or in combination with tacrolimus was ineffective. However, PVDST in combination with sirolimus significantly prolonged renal allograft survival to a mean of 24 days. Preoperative sirolimus alone had no effect, and peripheral DST with sirolimus prolonged graft survival in 2/4 animals, but resulted in accelerated rejection in 2/4 animals. These data demonstrate that PVDST in combination with sirolimus delays rejection in a modest but measurable way in a rigorous model. It may thus be a preferable method for donor antigen administration.     

诱导免疫耐受预防大鼠肾脏移植排斥反应的研究

目的 探讨具有临床应用前景的移植耐受诱导方法。方法 以Lewis大鼠和DA大鼠分别作为肾脏移植的受体和供体,采用注射抗淋巴细胞血清（ALS）、输入供体骨髓细胞（BMT）和环磷酰胺（Cp）注射方法进行移植耐受诱导,观察肾脏移植物的存活情况及受体对供体细胞抗原免疫应答改变。结果 经耐受诱导的大鼠肾脏移植物存活时间明显延长,7只鼠中5只移植物存活73－90 d时仍无排斥反应迹象,混合淋巴细胞反应及诱导迟发型超敏反应表现为供体特异性降低。结论 诱导免疫耐受预防肾脏移植排斥反应具有重要的临床意义,此方法有一定的临床应用前景。     

Ex vivo allotransplantation engineering: Delivery of mesenchymal stem cells prolongs rejection‐free allograft survival

Current pharmacologic regimens in transplantation prevent allograft rejection through systemic recipient immunosuppression but are associated with severe morbidity and mortality. The ultimate goal of transplantation is the prevention of allograft rejection while maintaining recipient immunocompetence. We hypothesized that allografts could be engineered ex vivo (after allotransplant procurement but before transplantation) by using mesenchymal stem cell–based therapy to generate localized immunomodulation without affecting systemic recipient immunocompetence. To this end, we evaluated the therapeutic efficacy of bone marrow–derived mesenchymal stem cells in vitro and activated them toward an immunomodulatory fate by priming in inflammatory or hypoxic microenvironments. Using an established rat hindlimb model for allotransplantation, we were able to significantly prolong rejection‐free allograft survival with a single perioperative ex vivo infusion of bone marrow–derived mesenchymal stem cells through the allograft vasculature, in the absence of long‐term pharmacologic immunosuppression. Critically, transplanted rats rejected a second, nonengineered skin graft from the same donor species to the contralateral limb at a later date, demonstrating that recipient systemic immunocompetence remained intact. This study represents a novel approach in transplant immunology and highlights the significant therapeutic opportunity of the ex vivo period in transplant engineering.     

Allopeptide-pulsed dendritic cells and composite tissue allograft survival

Composite tissue allografts (CTAs) contain their own reservoir of vascularized bone marrow, offering novel aspects for the induction of donor-specific tolerance. Additionally, the manipulation of recipient dendritic cells, pulsed with donor allopeptide, has been shown to engender solid organ allograft survival. To exploit these modalities, we have developed a protocol utilizing injection of recipient bone marrow-derived dendritic cells (BMDCs) pulsed with a donor-derived peptide for use in CTA transplantation. Six days prior to orthotopic hind-limb transplantation, Lewis rats received IV injection of donor allopeptide-pulsed, recipient BMDCs, in conjunction with a single dose of anti-lymphocyte serum. Control groups displayed signs of allograft rejection within 5 days postoperatively. Animals within the primary experimental cohort demonstrated prolongation of graft survival to an average of 8 days, and exhibited low numbers of donor T cells. The use of BMDCs in conjunction with transient immunosuppression has potential therapeutic application for induction of donor-antigen-specific tolerance to hind limb allografts.     

Outcomes of Renal Transplantation Following Bone Marrow Transplantation

This single center retrospective study was undertaken to determine the outcome of kidney transplantation (KT) after bone marrow transplantation (BMT) and also to determine the need for immunosuppressive therapy after KT when the BMT marrow donor is the KT donor. Kidney transplantation was performed in 10 patients with BMT nephropathy (BMTN). In six patients, the KT donor was the BMT donor; these individuals were given no long-term immunosuppression. Four other patients received KT from donors who were not the marrow donor (two living donors, two cadaveric donors). After median follow up of 34 months, no patient had an episode of acute rejection. All graft losses (n = 4) resulted from patient death. Three were because of infectious processes, including two infectious deaths in patients not on immunosuppression. Median estimated actuarial patient and graft survival (Kaplan-Meier) was 105 months. We conclude that patients with BMTN who receive KT from their marrow donor do not require immunosuppression. Whether immunosuppressive therapy is given or not, outcome appears to be determined largely by BMT-related immune dysfunction.     

Renal allograft tolerance in DLA-identical and haploidentical dogs after nonmyeloablative conditioning and transient immunosuppression with cyclosporine and mycophenolate mofetil

BACKGROUND: Canine models of bone marrow and renal transplantation have provided important preclinical data relevant to developing novel therapeutic protocols for hematopoietic and solid organ transplantation in human beings. Nonmyeloablative transplantation has been shown to induce stable mixed hematopoietic chimerism in normal dogs and correct the phenotype of canine pyruvate kinase deficiency and Glanzman's thrombasthenia. In this study, we investigated the potential for inducing renal allograft tolerance using a nonmyeloablative bone marrow transplantation strategy that induces mixed chimerism in DLA-identical dogs. METHODS: Reciprocal renal allografts were performed in 4 DLA-identical and 4 DLA-haploidentical dogs with nonmyeloablative conditioning (200 cGy total body irradiation [TBI]) and transient immunosuppression with cyclosporine (CSP) and mycophenolate mofetil (MMF) with and without simultaneous bone marrow transplantation. Two DLA-identical control dogs received reciprocal renal allografts without TBI or immunosuppression with CSP and MMF. Serum creatinine (Cr) concentration was monitored to assess renal allograft function. RESULTS: The renal allografts were acutely rejected in the 2 DLA-identical dogs without TBI or immunosuppression. There was long-term (>1 year) renal allograft survival as evidenced by a normal (<2.0 mg/dL) serum Cr concentration in both the DLA-identical and DLA-haploidentical dogs that underwent 200 cGy TBI and transient immunosuppression with CSP and MMF either with or without simultaneous bone marrow transplantation. CONCLUSIONS: Nonmyeloablative conditioning (200 cGy TBI) and transient immunosuppression with CSP and MMF induce renal allograft tolerance in DLA-identical and DLA-haploidentical dogs without donor/host mixed hematopoietic chimerism. These findings suggest it may be possible to induce tolerance to solid organ transplants without the need for chronic immunosuppressive therapy or stable hematopoietic chimerism in the setting of both DLA-matched and haploidentical transplants.     

The selective use of antilymphocyte serum for cyclosporine treated patients with renal allograft dysfunction.

Eighty-seven adult renal allograft recipients were initially treated with cyclosporine-prednisone immunosuppression. Thirty patients experienced no episode of rejection. Antilymphocyte antibody therapy (ALS) was administered to 21 of the 68 recipients of cadaveric donor allografts for either primary allograft dysfunction or acute rejection, and to 6 of 19 recipients of haploidentical, living-related allografts because of steroid-resistant rejection. The cumulative allograft and patient survival for the entire series (follow-up 9-36 months) was 84% and 95%, respectively. This improvement in the rate of successful transplantation can be attributed to the selective addition of ALS therapy to recipients with specific instances of renal allograft dysfunction. In this report, the indications for the use of ALS preparations following prophylactic CsA immunosuppression are reviewed. Experience with the protocols of the ALS administration is also discussed. In selected cases, the administration of either ATG or OKT3 can significantly benefit CsA recipients who experience either primary allograft nonfunction or an epidose of acute rejection.     

Mixed allogeneic chimerism as a reliable model for composite tissue allograft tolerance induction across major and minor histocompatibility barriers

BACKGROUND: Although prolonged composite tissue allograft (CTA) survival is achievable in animals using immunosuppressive drugs, long-term immunosuppression of CTAs in the clinical setting may be unacceptable for most patients. The purpose of this study was to develop a model for reliable CTA tolerance induction in the adult rat across a major MHC mismatch without the need for long-term immunosuppression. METHODS: Mixed allogeneic chimeras were prepared by using rat strains with strong MHC incompatibility [WF (RT1Au), ACI (RT1Aa)] WF + ACI-->WF, n=23. The bone marrow (BM) of recipient animals was pretreated with low-dose irradiation (500-700 cGy), followed by reconstitution with a mixture of T cell-depleted syngeneic (WF) and allogeneic (ACI) cells. Additionally, the recipient animals received a single dose of anti-lymphocyte serum (10 mg) 5 days before bone marrow transplantation (BMT) and tacrolimus (1 mg/kg/day) from the day before BMT to 10 days post-BMT. Hindlimb transplants were performed 12 months after BMT. Five animals received a limb allograft irradiated (1000 cGy) just before transplantation. Rat chimeras were characterized (percentage of donor cells present within the bloodstream) by flow cytometry at 3 and 12 months after BM reconstitution and after hindlimb transplantation. RESULTS: Peripheral blood lymphocyte chimerism (WF/ACI) remained stable >12 months after BM reconstitution in 18/23 animals. Multi-lineage chimerism of both lymphoid and myeloid lineages was present, suggesting that engraftment of the pluripotent rat stem cell had occurred. In animals with donor chimerism >60% (n=18) no sign of limb rejection was present for the duration of the study. All animals with chimerism <20% (n=5) developed moderate signs of rejection clinically and histologically. Gross motor and sensory reinnervation (weight bearing, toe spread) developed at >60 days in 14/21 rats. Postoperative flow cytometry studies demonstrated stable chimerism in all animals studied (n=10). Five out of five animals with irradiated limb transplants showed no sign of GVHD at >100 days. CONCLUSIONS: Stable mixed allogeneic chimerism can be achieved in a rat hindlimb model of composite tissue allotransplantation. Hindlimb allografts to mixed allogeneic chimeras exhibit prolonged, rejection-free survival. Partial functional return should be expected. The BM transplanted as part of the hindlimb allograft plays a role in the etiology of GVHD. Manipulating that BM before transplantation may influence the incidence of GVHD. This represents the first reliable rat hindlimb model demonstrating rejection-free CTA survival in an adult animal across a major MHC mismatch without the long-term need for immunosuppressive agents.     

The effect of antilymphocyte serum, fractionated donor bone marrow, and cyclosporine on renal allograft survival in mongrel dogs.

The effect of combined treatment with antilymphocyte serum, fractionated donor bone marrow, and a limited course of cyclosporine on renal allograft survival in mongrel dogs was examined. Recipients were treated with ALS from day -5 to day +7, relative to transplantation on day 0 with an MLR-mismatched donor. Fractionated donor bone marrow cells (BMFr3) obtained by density gradient separation were infused 3-7 days after ALS treatment. CsA treatments were begun either 3-7 days after ALS plus BMFr3 infusion or 3-7 days after treatments with ALS alone. Extended allograft survival was achieved at all CsA doses in BMFr3-infused, ALS-treated recipients. Allografts were sustained throughout the CsA treatment period without rejection in the majority of recipients (6 of 8) receiving ALS plus BMFr3 and CsA at 20 Mg/kg/day for 60 days. By contrast, few grafts were sustained through 30 days of treatment with CsA at 3.2 (1 of 12) or 10 mg/kg/day (2 of 9) in ALS plus BMFr3-treated recipients. Cyclosporine treatment was ineffective at all doses in augmenting allograft prolongation in ALS-treated recipients that did not receive BMFr3. Nearly all (6 of 7) long-term survivors (greater than 180 days) were BMFr3-treated. Peripheral blood lymphocytes or bone marrow cells of these long-term survivors proliferated normally in response to Con A and PWM, and were MLR responsive to third-party cells but did not have reduced MLR responsiveness to donor alloantigen in all cases. These long-term survivors promptly rejected third-party renal allografts without adverse effects on the original transplant's function. These results show that long-term renal allograft survival with specific unresponsiveness to the donor can result from the combined treatment with ALS plus donor BMFr3 and a limited course of CsA.     

Induction of stable chimerism and elimination of graft-versus-host disease by depletion of T lymphocytes from bone marrow using immunomagnetic beads

The goal of transplantation is the induction of immunologic tolerance. At present, nonspecific immunosuppression is used to prevent graft rejection and, commonly, graft-versus-host disease (GVHD). Nevertheless, nonspecific immunosuppressive therapy is frequently complicated by infection, malignant tumors, and drug toxicity. In order to examine whether hematopoietic chimerism can be used to induce specific allograft tolerance, we have reconstituted lethally irradiated Lewis rats with ACI bone marrow that has been depleted of T cells with use of immunomagnetic beads. This technique consists of binding OX-19, a mouse anti-rat pan-T lymphocyte monoclonal antibody, to magnetic polymer beads. Mixing of bone marrow or splenocytes with the bead/OX-19 complexes, followed by magnetic separation, results in significant depletion of T cells with minimal nonspecific cell loss. Immunomagnetic T-cell depletion of bone marrow, followed by reconstitution of a lethally irradiated host, allows for the development of stable, mixed hematopoietic chimerae without evidence of GVHD. These hosts are immunocompetent by clinical criteria. Recipients of untreated donor bone marrow that did or did not receive nonspecific immunosuppression demonstrated varying degrees of GVHD and reduced survival. The ability to rapidly and simply deplete T lymphocytes from bone marrow and produce stable, immunocompetent hematopoietic chimerae without GVHD may be an important method for tolerance induction to vascularized allografts.     

Immunomodulatory effects of pre-irradiated extremity allograft in the rodent model

Allogeneic human hand transplantation requires combination immunotherapy to maintain viability. Immunosuppression will be lifelong, with doses as high or higher than those required for solid organ allotransplantation. The risks associated with lifelong immunosuppression are unacceptable, particularly for younger transplant patients. It therefore becomes imperative to explore ways to reduce or eliminate the requirement for immunosuppression. Reconstructive surgery should consider, to a large extent, graft pre-treatment as a strategy for the transplantation of vascularised limb tissue allografts with reduced requirement for immunosuppression. In the clinical setting of composite tissue allograft (CTA), the graft is always procured from a cadaveric donor. Therefore, only a short time is available between harvesting the graft from the donor and transplanting into the recipient. This period provides the only opportunity to manipulate the CTA. Quite a few studies, however, have so far investigated donor pre-treatment and pre-transplant modification of the extremity allograft. Work from our group and others has demonstrated that removal of allogeneic bone marrow in the limb graft by irradiation and its rapid reconstitution with recipient marrow cells can significantly prolong the survival of limb allografts in the absence of immunosuppression. In the current work, we review these studies and discuss the immunomodulatory effects on the extremity allograft.     

Tolerance in renal transplantation after allogeneic bone marrow transplantation-6-year follow-up.

Despite significant advancements in clinical transplantation, very few reports describe the long-term acceptance of transplanted solid organs without indefinite immunosuppression. The immunosuppressive agents used are nonspecific and have serious potential side effects. We present a patient who received a living-donor renal allograft from the same person who had donated bone marrow to her several years earlier. Tolerance was expected based on previous acceptance of full-thickness skin grafts from the donor. Indeed, there has been no evidence of rejection during a 6-year follow-up period, and no induction or maintenance immunosuppression has been given. All noninvasive parameters of graft function remain normal. This and similar reports prove that genetically disparate solid organs can coexist without pharmacological immunosuppression.     

Donor skin allograft survival after bone marrow transplantation: Case report and systematic review of the literature☆

Background

We present a case of skin allograft survival in a patient who previously received a bone marrow transplant from the same HLA-matched donor. DNA fingerprinting of skin biopsies showed mixed cellularity originating from the donor and recipient (68% and 32% donor DNA in the allograft skin and the native recipient's skin, respectively). Histologic sections demonstrated both grade 3/4 rejection and graft-versus-host-disease. We have conducted a systematic review in search for other cases of donor skin allograft survival after a bone marrow or hematopoietic stem cell transplantation.

骨髓输注减轻大鼠肺移植急性排斥反应的研究

目的 研究供体骨髓细胞输注减轻大鼠肺移植急性排斥反应。方法 应用Cuff技术改进大鼠原位单肺移植模型，同时输注供体骨髓细胞，采集受体鼠外周血动态监测嵌合；存活4周大鼠杀死后切取移植肺进行排斥反应分级，切取脾应用免疫组织化学方法检测组织嵌合。结果 流式细胞术在骨髓输注组外周血中检测到明显的嵌合，在脾脏中得到组织嵌合。骨髓输注组移植肺急性排斥反应明显减轻。结论 肺移植同时输注供体骨髓细胞，可以产生显著的供体细胞与受体细胞嵌合，有效地抑制大鼠肺移植急性排斥反应。