Thoracic outlet syndrome: influence of personal history and surgical technique on long-term results.

OBJECTIVE: Long-term results after surgery for thoracic outlet syndrome (TOS) are reviewed in terms of personal histories and surgical techniques. METHODS: Forty-eight operations were performed in 37 patients. In 21 instances, the picture was one of ordinary TOS, in eight TOS was traumatic and in nine the picture was sub-acute. Cervical ribs were excised through a supraclavicular approach (in seven cases), and first ribs through transthoracic, transaxillary or supraclavicular approaches (in 25, 15 or one, respectively). Long-term follow-up was obtained in 41 cases and averaged 11.7 years. RESULTS: Surgical decompression was successful in 28 cases (68%), including all patients with traumatic TOS (8/8) and seven with sub-acute symptoms (7/9). Outcome was good in five of seven supraclavicular cervical rib resections, and in 23 of 34 first rib excisions. First rib resections performed transaxillary had shorter post-operative stays, fewer complications. CONCLUSION: Surgical decompression is more successful when TOS is traumatic or sub-acute. When involved, a cervical rib can be resected through a supraclavicular approach, since the procedure is easy and has little morbidity. The transaxillary approach should be preferred for first rib resections because of shorter post-operative stays and fewer complications than after the transthoracic approach.     

Supraclavicular Approach for Thoracic Outlet Syndrome

The authors' experience with the supraclavicular approach for the treatment of patients with primary thoracic outlet syndrome (TOS) and for patients with recurrent TOS or iatrogenic brachial plexus injury after prior transaxillary first rib resection is presented. The records of 33 patients (34 plexuses) with TOS who presented for evaluation and treatment were analyzed. Of these, 12 (35%) plexuses underwent surgical treatment, and 22 (65%) plexuses were managed non-operatively. The patients who were treated non-operatively and had an adequate follow-up (n = 11) were used as a control group. Of the 12 surgically treated patients, five patients underwent primary surgery; four patients had secondary surgery for recurrent TOS; and three patients had surgery for iatrogenic brachial plexus injury. All patients presented with severe pain, and most of them had neurologic symptoms. All nine (100%) patients who underwent primary surgery (n = 5) and secondary surgery for recurrent TOS (n = 4) demonstrated excellent or good results. On the other hand, six (54%) of the 11 patients from the control group had some benefit from the non-operative treatment. Reoperation in three patients with iatrogenic brachial plexus injury resulted in good result in one case and in fair results in two patients; however, all patients were pain-free. No complications were encountered. Supraclavicular exploration of the brachial plexus enables precise assessment of the contents of the thoracic inlet area. It allows for safe identification and release of all abnormal anatomical structures and complete first rib resection with minimal risk to neurovascular structures. Additionally, this approach allows for the appropriate nerve reconstruction in cases of prior transaxillary iatrogenic plexus injury.     

The treatment of thoracic outlet syndrome: a comparison of different operations

Although transaxillary first rib resection is one of the popular treatments for thoracic outlet syndrome today, recurrences and nerve injuries have led to investigation of other operations that might reduce complications and improve results. This article compares the results of transaxillary first rib resection with (1) scalenectomy (anterior and middle) and (2) supraclavicular first rib resection with scalenectomy. Between 1964 and 1987, 668 primary operations were performed for thoracic outlet syndrome on 491 patients. Seventy-one percent were women. Eight-six percent gave histories of neck trauma, often a whiplash injury (traumatic thoracic outlet syndrome); 4.5% had cervical ribs. Common symptoms included paresthesia in the hands (90%); arm pain (80%); neck pain (86%); and occipital headaches (69%). On physical examination, tenderness over the scalene muscles and duplication of symptoms with the arms abducted to 90 degrees in external rotation were present in over 90% of patients. By use of life-table analysis methods, success after surgery was found to be the same for all operations: 91% to 93% at 3 months; 76% to 79% at 1 to 2 years; 70% to 73% at 3 to 5 years; and 69% to 72% at 5 to 10 years. After rib resection plexus injuries occurred in 2.6%, with partial disability in 0.5%. No plexus injuries occurred after scalenectomy, but temporary phrenic nerve palsy occurred in 4.4%. Scalenectomy is as successful an operation as first rib resection for traumatic thoracic outlet syndrome and has fewer serious complications.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Pediatric thoracic outlet syndrome: a disorder with serious vascular complications

Background

Thoracic outlet syndrome (TOS), caused by compression of the neurovascular structures between the clavicle and scalene muscles, typically presents with neurologic symptoms in adults. We reviewed our experience with 25 adolescents and propose a diagnostic/treatment algorithm for pediatric TOS.

Methods

From 1993 to 2005, 25 patients were treated with TOS. A retrospective chart review was performed with institutional review board approval. Demographics, clinical presentation, diagnostic studies, and treatment were evaluated.

Results

Seven male (28%) and 18 female (72%) patients presented between the ages of 12 to 18 years. Thirteen (52%) had vascular TOS (11 venous, 2 arterial), 11 (44%) had neurologic TOS, and 1 had both. Vascular TOS included subclavian vein thrombosis (7), venous impingement (4), and arterial impingement (2). Three patients had hypercoagulable disorders, and 6 had effort thrombosis. Venography was diagnostic in 10 cases. Neurogenic TOS was diagnosed by clinical symptoms. Five patients with subclavian vein thrombosis underwent thrombolysis, with 3 maintaining long-term patency. Of 25 patients, 24 underwent transaxillary first rib resection.

Conclusion

Vascular complications are more common in adolescents with TOS than in adults. A diagnostic/treatment algorithm includes urgent venography and thrombolysis for venous TOS and a workup for hypercoagulability. Neurogenic TOS is diagnosed clinically, whereas other studies are rarely beneficial.     

Effect of paraesophageal hernia on sphincter function and its implication on surgical therapy

Transaxillary resection of the first rib alone was performed 97 times to relieve symptoms of irritation of the brachial plexus. Persistent or recurrent symptoms occurred in a fifth of the patients (7 and 13 patients, respectively), and necessitated reoperation using the supraclavicular approach. In all patients, at least one anomaly or acquired deformity was found that could not have been identified or safely removed by the original transaxillary approach alone. Subsequently, 94 combined operations, including supraclavicular radical scalenectomy with neurolysis of the brachial plexus and transaxillary resection of the first rib, were performed for irritation of the brachial plexus. The improved results using the combined procedure has led us to recommend it for the majority of symptomatic patients with irritation of the brachial plexus. The combined approach allows precise assessment of the thoracic outlet anatomy, facilitates first and cervical rib resection, and permits removal of any additional congenital or acquired lesions. It is associated with a low failure rate and results in few postoperative complications. However, the transaxillary approach alone may be suited for the patient with localized lower plexus symptomatology, keeping in mind the risk of recurrent symptoms associated with this technique.     

Safety and efficacy of the supraclavicular approach to thoracic outlet decompression

BACKGROUND: Thoracic outlet syndrome (TOS) is a clinical diagnosis encountered by both thoracic and vascular surgeons. The goal of surgical therapy involves relieving compression of the neurovascular structures at the superior thoracic aperture. The traditional approach to thoracic outlet decompression has been transaxillary; however more centers are moving toward a more tailored approach through a supraclavicular incision. METHODS: The medical records of 67 patients who underwent surgical decompression between 1993 and 2001 for TOS were retrospectively reviewed. Patient demographics and early outcome were assessed through clinic follow-up. RESULTS: Seventy-two thoracic outlet decompressions were performed on 67 patients with the diagnosis of TOS. Five patients underwent bilateral thoracic outlet decompression. All operations in this time period were safely accomplished through a supraclavicular approach. The syndromes associated with thoracic outlet compression were neurogenic (n = 59), venous (n = 10), and arterial (n = 3). Forty-six of 72 (63.9%) operations resulted in complete resolution of symptoms, 17 cases (23.6%) had partial resolution, and 9 patients (12.5%) had no resolution. There were no deaths and morbidity was minimal with 6 complications (8.3%). CONCLUSIONS: The supraclavicular approach is a safe and effective technique in managing all forms of thoracic outlet compression.     

Neurogenic thoracic outlet decompression: rationale for sparing the first rib

A total of 168 primary supraclavicular decompressions were performed on 146 patients with neurogenic thoracic outlet syndrome. This report compares the results of rib resection (supraclavicular anterior and middle scalenectomy and first rib resection) with rib-sparing (supraclavicular anterior and middle scalenectomy alone) operations. All patients with cervical ribs were excluded. In total, 125 rib resections and 43 rib-sparing procedures were performed between 1983 and 1992 by a single surgeon. The patients were otherwise comparable in symptoms and physical signs. During surgery there was a significantly higher proportion of pleural injury associated with rib resection (59%) than with rib-sparing (40%) procedures. The mean hospital stay was also prolonged by 1 day in patients undergoing rib resection (P = 0.005). There was no significant difference in early success between the two groups (83% for rib resection, 91% for rib sparing) and no difference in those resuming employment (52% and 63% respectively). Life-table analysis showed that the two groups have similar long-term results (69% and 76% at 2 years). The only important factor determining clinical outcome in primary supraclavicular thoracic outlet syndrome decompression was the duration of symptoms before operation. Some 83% of patients with symptoms less than 2 years had a successful result compared with only 68% in those with symptoms longer than 2 years (P < 0.05). Spontaneous or post-traumatic neurogenic symptoms responded to operation identically. The theoretical benefit of first rib resection to relieve mechanical compression of the brachial plexus is not evident from this review. Thorough removal of the scalene musculature and other myofascial anomalies, preferably through the supraclavicular approach, leads to less patient morbidity, shortens hospitalization, and is recommended for patients with neurogenic thoracic outlet syndrome requiring operative intervention.     

Neurovascular compression in the thoracic outlet: changing management over 50 years.

SUMMARY BACKGROUND DATA: During the past five decades, significant improvements have been made in the diagnosis and treatment of thoracic outlet syndrome (TOS) secondary to sports activities, breast implants, or median sternotomy. METHODS, RESULTS, AND CONCLUSIONS: Of more than 15,000 patients evaluated for TOS, 3914 underwent primary neurovascular decompression procedures and 1221 underwent second surgical procedures for recurrent symptoms. Of 2210 consecutive patients, 250 had symptoms of upper plexus compression only (median nerve), 1508 had symptoms of lower plexus compression only (ulnar nerve), and 452 patients had symptoms of both. Ulnar and median nerve conduction velocities confirmed the clinical diagnosis. Transaxillary first rib removal alone for neurovascular decompression relieved both upper and lower plexus symptoms (without a combined transaxillary and supraclavicular approach). There are two reasons for this: most upper compression mechanisms attach to the first rib, and the median nerve is also supplied by C8 and T1 as well as C5, C6, and C7 nerve roots. Axillary subclavian artery aneurysm or occlusion was treated successfully in 240 patients. Dorsal sympathectomy was performed concomitantly in 71 patients for occlusion or embolectomy. It was combined with first rib resection in 1974 patients for sympathetic maintained pain syndrome and causalgia that did not improve with conservative therapy. Of 264 patients with effort thrombosis (Paget-Schroetter syndrome), 211 were treated by urokinase thrombolysis and prompt first rib resection with excellent long-term results. Recurrent TOS symptoms required a second procedure using the posterior approach in 1221 patients with brachial plexus neurolysis and dorsal sympathectomy. The use of hyaluronic acid significantly reduced recurrent scarring.     

Recurrent neurogenic thoracic outlet syndrome

BACKGROUND: Although 90% of patients with neurogenic thoracic outlet syndrome (NTOS) experience "excellent" or "good" results after thoracic outlet decompression, recurrent symptoms may develop in certain patients. METHODS: This is a retrospective review of patients with NTOS who developed recurrent symptoms of upper extremity/shoulder/neck pain, weakness and limitation of motion at least 3 months after initial relief of symptoms by surgical decompression. Diagnostic procedures and outcomes of reoperative surgery were assessed. RESULTS: Among almost 500 patients undergoing initial successful thoracic outlet decompression for symptoms of NTOS during the last decade, 17 redeveloped classic NTOS symptoms (3 of them bilaterally) at intervals from 3 to 80 months (mean 18 months) after the initial operative procedure. Ultimate diagnoses included incomplete first-rib resection (n = 1), compression of the brachial plexus by an ectopic band (n = 1), persistent brachial plexus compression by an intact first (n = 2) or second (n = 1) rib, brachial plexus compression by the pectoralis minor tendon (n = 13) and adherent residual scalene muscle (n = 14). Anterior scalene muscle block was positive in 9 patients later found to have recurrent symptoms from adherent residual scalene muscle. Among these 20 cases of osseous or musculotendinous causes of recurrent NTOS, all had "excellent" or "good" results from repeat surgery to eliminate the underlying structural problem (removal of intact or residual rib, pectoralis minor tenotomy, brachial plexus neurolysis, or a combination of these). CONCLUSIONS: Complete excision of cervical or first ribs and subtotal excision (instead of simple division) of the scalene muscles will decrease the incidence of recurrent NTOS. Pectoralis minor tenotomy should be considered part of complete thoracic outlet decompression. Anterior scalene muscle block accurately predicts outcome of reoperation for certain types of recurrent NTOS.     

Upper plexus thoracic outlet syndrome--case report

A 47-year-old right-handed female became aware of proximal ache and muscle weakness in the right shoulder and elbow in 1997. Atrophy of the right biceps muscle was recognized and the right deltoid, triceps, supraspinatus, and infraspinatus muscles were weak. The Morley test and elevated arm stress test were positive. Neurolysis of the brachial plexus and anterior scalenectomy were performed via a right supraclavicular approach. An abnormal fibromuscular band was identified passing between the upper and middle trunks and constricting the middle trunk. Another scalene muscle anomaly was found passing between the C-5 and C-6 nerve roots and connecting the anterior and middle scalene muscles. These muscles were resected, and thorough neurolysis was performed around all nerves and the trunks. Postoperatively, all symptoms completely resolved and the patient was discharged 5 days after surgery. Thoracic outlet syndrome (TOS) manifests as symptoms of lower cervical nerve involvements with hypesthesia and paresthesia. However, upper plexus TOS manifests as symptoms due to the involvement of the C-5 to C-7 nerve roots, and is relatively rare. Transaxillary first rib resection is performed as the primary operation for TOS, but supraclavicular scalenectomy is effective for upper plexus TOS.     

Management of thoracic outlet syndrome

The experience with transaxillary first-rib resection and scalenotomy reported herein shows these to be safe and effective treatments for patients with thoracic outlet syndrome (TOS). The former operation usually offers the best possibility for complete resection of the first rib and all anomalous congenital bands, and is curative in most cases, regardless of the mechanism of the compression. Scalenotomy, or Powers' operation, is also helpful, in particular for cases of TOS with a vertebral arterial insufficiency. Accurate diagnosis of TOS and selection for surgery after a detailed history and proper physical examination will result in gratifying relief of symptoms in almost all patients with TOS.     

Management of thoracic outlet syndrome

Summary The experience with transaxillary first-rib resection and scalenotomy reported herein shows these to be safe and effective treatments for patients with thoracic outlet syndrome (TOS). The former operation usually offers the best possibility for complete resection of the first rib and all anomalous congenital bands, and is curative in most cases, regardless of the mechanism of the compression. Scalenotomy, or Powers' operation, is also helpful, in particular for cases of TOS with a vertebral arterial insufficiency. Accurate diagnosis of TOS and selection for surgery after a detailed history and proper physical examination will result in gratifying relief of symptoms in almost all patients with TOS.     

Clinical predictors of surgical outcome in patients with thoracic outlet syndrome operated on via transaxillary approach.

OBJECTIVES: Although the transaxillary route appears to be the optimal approach in patients with thoracic outlet syndrome (TOS), the effect of clinical features on surgical outcome remains unclear. We conducted a study to determine the clinical predictors of surgical outcome in patients with TOS. METHODS: We examined the data charts of patients with TOS who underwent operation via transaxillary approach. We investigated the possible correlations between the clinical features and surgical outcomes, and analyzed the data with logistic regression model to clarify the effect of clinical features on surgical outcome. RESULTS: A total of 127 patients with a mean age of 32.1+/-10.0 years (range 14-62 years) were analyzed. The rates of favorable and poor surgical outcomes were 82.7 and 17.3%, respectively. The subgroups of symptom duration (P=0.023), the subgroups of ulnar nerve conduction velocity (P=0.033) and the presence of cervical rib (P=0.003) showed a significant correlation with surgical outcome. Multivariate analysis revealed that the shorter duration of symptoms (P=0.017) and the presence of a cervical rib (P=0.026) had a significantly unfavorable effect on surgical outcome. CONCLUSIONS: The shorter duration of symptoms and the presence of a cervical rib may imply an unfavorable surgical outcome in patients with TOS.     

The management of thoracic outlet syndrome in teenaged patients

While thoracic outlet syndrome (TOS) is known to afflict teenaged patients, reported data are limited to small groups or individual cases. Management of TOS in teenagers presents many issues, including performing surgery in patients whose skeletal growth may not be completed. Additionally, surgical intervention may result in loss of school time. The aim of this study was to assess our results with a large series of young TOS patients in order to provide insight toward achieving optimal care. Via a retrospective chart review, we identified all patients <20 years of age undergoing first rib resection for TOS during an 11-year period (August 1994-September 2005) at a single university hospital. History, indication, operative details, and pertinent follow-up were obtained from the records. There were 18 patients <20 who underwent first rib resection in the study period (all but one via a transaxillary approach). Ages ranged 13-19 years. Twelve patients had disabling neurogenic (NG) TOS, and six presented with Paget-Schroetter syndrome (PS). Seventy-two percent of patients were female. Most students (14/18) were forced to take a leave from school due to severity of symptoms. Eighty-five percent of female patients presented with NG TOS, whereas PS TOS affected 80% of male patients. All PS TOS patients were involved in high-intensity athletics, while 75% of NG TOS patients were student athletes. Follow-up ranged from 30 days to over 12 years. There were no significant operative complications in either group. Forty-two percent of NG patients experienced continued symptoms leading to anterior scalenectomy. All PS patients had successful lysis of their thrombotic processes. Overall, 25% of NG TOS patients also required postoperative trigger point injections. All patients eventually recovered and were able to resume academic as well as competitive athletic activities. TOS can be effectively and safely treated in the teenage years. PS responds well to standard thrombolysis and surgical decompression. NG TOS presenting in these young patients appears more likely to require extensive surgical decompression (both rib resection and total scalenectomy) in order to achieve optimal results. Given the psychosocial and academic implications of this disease, careful diagnosis and appropriate treatment are imperative.     

Combined surgical treatment of thoracic outlet syndrome: transaxillary first rib resection and transcervical scalenectomy

Transaxillary first rib resection and transcervical scalenectomy are common procedures used for treatment of thoracic outlet syndrome (TOS). In the early 1980s, some surgeons started to perform both procedures, starting with the scalenectomy and following with a transaxillary first rib resection. The author has found that performing these procedures in the reverse order, starting with the first rib resection and following immediately with a transcervical scalenectomy is an easier approach, providing total decompression, better relief of symptoms, and a lower recurrence rate.     

770 Consecutive supraclavicular first rib resections for thoracic outlet syndrome

During a 28-year period, 637 patients underwent 770 supraclavicular first rib resections and scalenectomies for thoracic outlet syndrome (TOS). The neurologic type of TOS was found in 705 cases (92%) and the remaining 65 cases (8%) had the vascular form of TOS. Of those extremities with brachial plexus irritation, the symptom complex consisted of paresthesia in 30 (4%), pain in 221 (31%), and pain with paresthesia in 454 (64%). In the cases of vascular TOS, 47 limbs (6%) had venous complications and 18 limbs (2%) had arterial sequelae. Following supraclavicular scalenectomy and rib resection, an excellent response was achieved in 59% (455 cases) and a good result was achieved in another 27% (206 cases). A fair outcome was present in 13% (95 cases) and a poor result was found in only 1% (13 cases). There was a single occurrence of lymphatic leakage and no brachial plexus injuries resulted. Postoperative causalgia requiring subsequent sympathectomy developed in two cases. No vascular or permanent phrenic nerve injuries occurred and only 12 patients (2%) required operative intervention for recurrent TOS. First rib resection and scalenectomy can be performed by the supraclavicular route with an acceptable outcome, minimal morbidity, and long-lasting results.     

Recurrent thoracic outlet syndrome

Recurrent symptoms develop in 15% to 20% of patients undergoing either first rib resection or scalenectomy for thoracic outlet syndrome. Over the past 22 years 134 operations for recurrence were performed in 97 patients. Four operations were used: transaxillary first rib resection (26); supraclavicular first rib resection with neurolysis (15); scalenectomy with neurolysis (58); and brachial plexus neurolysis (35). Complications included temporary plexus injury (0.7%), temporary phrenic palsy (3.7%), and permanent phrenic palsy (1.4%). The combined primary success rate of all four operations for recurrence was 84% in the first 3 months. This fell to 59% at 1 to 2 years; 50% at 3 to 5 years; and 41% at 10 to 15 years. No significant difference was found in results between the four operations used for recurrence. When recurrence was caused by trauma the results of reoperations were better than when recurrence was spontaneous. The primary success rates of three initial operations for thoracic outlet syndrome were compared to their secondary success rates (improved after reoperation). By use of life-table methods, reoperation improved the 5- to 10-year success rate of transaxillary first rib resection from 69% to 86% and for scalenectomy from 69% to 84%. Reoperation is successful in most cases of recurrent thoracic outlet syndrome and better when recurrence is the result of a neck injury.     

Computer-assisted instrumentation during endoscopic transaxillary first rib resection for thoracic outlet syndrome: a safe alternate approach

The purpose of this article is to discuss the feasibility of using computer-enhanced instrumentation to improve visualization and therefore patient safety during transaxillary first rib resection. From November 1998 to July 2005, 105 patients who had failed conservative treatment underwent 131 procedures for thoracic outlet decompression. Eighty-nine endoscopic transaxillary first rib resections were completed using Aesop/Hermes integrated voice control instrumentation (Computer Motion, Goleta, CA). Since February 2003, dissection in 42 procedures was performed using the daVinci Surgical System (Intuitive Surgical, Inc, Sunnyvale, CA). The surgical findings with cervical bands correlated with the preoperative symptoms. One hundred percent of patients with a combination of neurogenic and arterial thoracic outlet syndrome (TOS) requiring cervical rib resection had Roos type I and/or II bands. Additional surgical findings included the following: combination of neurogenic and arterial TOS without cervical ribs or neurogenic TOS alone had type III, IV, or V bands, and patients with venous compression (100%) had type VII bands. No mortalities or permanent neurovascular injuries occurred. There was a 6.1% postoperative complication rate. Persistent myofibrositis was found in 34% of patients with ongoing symptoms. CONCLUSION: The daVinci three-dimensional optical imaging system enhances visualization, thereby promoting telemanipulation of soft tissue structures in a relatively inaccessible working space. Endoscopic computerized instrumentation in transaxillary first rib resection decreases the risk of neurovascular injury, promotes complete decompression, and therefore provides a safe alternative to standard first rib resections.     

First rib resection in thoracic outlet syndrome

Most patients with thoracic outlet syndrome (TOS) present with exercise-induced upper extremity paresthesia. Neurogenic TOS is the most common type where the brachial nerve plexus is compressed against a tight thoracic outlet. Vascular compromise although rare can result from thoracic outlet pressure against the subclavian artery or more commonly the subclavian vein. This article reviews the pathophysiology of TOS and describes several effective surgical interventions. Complete first rib resection with surgical decompression is an essential part of the treatment for TOS. First rib resection via supraclavicular or a preferred transaxillary route should be considered when conservative modalities provide no symptom improvement.