Development of ocular dominance columns in the absence of retinal input

The initial establishment of ocular dominance columns in visual cortex is believed to involve the segregation of overlapping geniculocortical axons into eye-specific patches based on patterns of correlated activity. However, we found that total removal of retinal influence early in visual development did not prevent segregation of geniculocortical axons into alternating stripes with periodicity normal for ocular dominance columns. Because the patterning of geniculocortical afferents resists this dramatic change in the level, source and pattern of spontaneous activity, we propose that formation of ocular dominance columns relies on molecular cues present on thalamic axons, cortical cells or both.     

Topographic relations between ocular dominance and orientation columns in the cat striate cortex

Summary In the visual cortex of four adult cats ocular dominance and orientation columns were visualized with (³H)proline and (¹⁴C)deoxyglucose autoradiography. The two columnar systems were reconstructed from serial horizontal sections or from flat-mount preparations and graphically superimposed. They share a number of characteristic features: In both systems the columns have a tendency to form regularly spaced parallel bands whose main trajectory is perpendicular to the border between areas 17 and 18. These bands frequently bifurcate or terminate in blind endings. The resulting irregularities are much more pronounced in the ocular dominance than in the orientation system. The periodicity of the columnar patterns was assessed along trajectories perpendicular to the main orientation of the bands and differed in the two columnar systems. The spacing of the ocular dominance stripes was significantly narrower than the spacing of orientation bands. The mean periodicity of a particular columnar system was virtually identical in the two hemispheres of the same animal but it differed substantially in different animals. However, the spacing of orientation columns covaried with that of the ocular dominance columns, the ratios of the mean spacings of the two columnar systems being similar in the four cats. The superposition of the two columnar systems revealed no obvious topographic relation between any of the organizational details such as the location of bifurcations, blind endings and intersections. We suggest the following conclusions: 1. The developmental processes generating the two columnar systems seem to obey the same algorithms but they act independently of each other. 2. The space constants of the two systems are rigorously specified and appear to depend on a common variable. 3. The main orientation of the bands in both columnar systems is related to a) the representation of the vertical meridian, b) the anisotropy of the cortical magnification factor, and c) the tangential spread of intracortical connections.     

The pattern of ocular dominance columns in flat-mounts of the cat visual cortex

Summary Ocular dominance (OD) columns in the cat visual cortex were visualized with autoradiography after intravitreal injection of (³H)proline. Extending previous studies, a flat-mount technique was applied that enabled the analysis of the distribution of label throughout extensive regions of the visual cortex without requiring reconstructions from serial sections. OD-columns were confined to layer IV and consisted of isolated patches and short bands. The latter were parallel to each other and regularly spaced, the main trajectory being orthogonal to the 17/18 border. This pattern of the geniculo-cortical terminals was similar in the hemispheres ipsi- and contralateral to the injected eye. The mean periodicities of the OD-bands were virtually identical in the two hemispheres of the same animal: 850 m and 830 m in cat D1 and 770 m and 800 m in cat D2. However, the ipsilateral OD-columns appeared smaller, more heavily labeled and more sharply delineated than the contralateral columns.     

Inheritance of ocular dominance

Evidence for an inherited component in the determination of the preferred eye in sighting dominance is presented that replicates the earlier findings by Merrell (1957). Significantly more left-sighting-preferent individuals were found in the progeny of R×L and L×L matings than in the R×R matings.The preparation of this study was supported by National Institute of Mental Health Grant MH-21989.     

Two-dimensional analysis of the spacing of ocular dominance columns in normally raised and strabismic kittens

In the primary visual cortex of cats, ferrets and macaque monkeys, the thalamocortical afferents conveying signals from the two eyes terminate in alternating regions of layer IV known as ocular dominance columns. Previous experiments have indicated that the periodicity of these columns can be influenced by visual experience: compared to normally raised animals both strabismic cats and cats raised with alternating monocular exposure displayed an increased spacing of adjacent ocular dominance columns in the primary visual cortex (area 17). However, recently it was shown that the formation of ocular dominance columns begins much earlier than previously supposed, indicating that early visual experience might only have a limited influence on the development of the spatial pattern of ocular dominance columns. We therefore visualized the complete pattern of ocular dominance columns in area 17 of normally raised and strabismic kittens during early postnatal development (age 3-6 weeks), particularly focussing on littermates. In addition, we used a previously developed spatial analysis (period statistics) to quantify columnar spacing two-dimensionally. We observed a pronounced interindividual variability in both normally raised and strabismic animals, with column spacings ranging from 783 to 1362 microm. In contrast to previous reports, there were no significant differences in columnar periodicity between normally raised and strabismic cats. These data indicate that rearing has less influence on column spacing while the interindividual variability is much greater than previously supposed, suggesting that genetic differences have an influence on column spacing.     

Theoretical and experimental studies of relationship between pinwheel centers and ocular dominance columns in the visual cortex

In the visual cortex, pinwheel centers, which appear as point singularities in orientation maps, are likely to be found at the centers of ocular dominance columns in normal cats and monkeys. To elucidate the mechanism underlying the geometrical relationship, we performed computer simulation based on our correlation-based self-organization model. The simulation showed that pinwheel centers tended to be located at the ocular dominance centers at higher correlations of activities between the left- and right-eye specific pathways, whereas they tended to appear along the borders of ocular dominance columns at lower correlations. This tendency was mathematically analyzed with a formula describing the condition determining the geometrical relationship between pinwheel centers and ocular dominance columns. Moreover, to examine the effect of activity correlations in the eye-specific pathways on the column formation, we conducted intrinsic signal optical imaging using normally reared cats and dark-reared cats. The between-eye activity correlation in dark-reared cats is expected to be lower than that in normal cats due to the lack of common visual input in the two eyes. The statistical analysis of experimental data showed that while more pinwheel centers tended to be located in the center subregion of ocular dominance columns than in the border subregion in the normal cats, a weak tendency in the opposite direction was found in the dark-reared cats. Based on the consistent results from the model and experiment, it is suggested that the activity correlation between the left- and right-eye specific pathways has influence on the establishment of geometrical relationship in the cortical representation between orientation preference and ocular dominance.     

Radioautographic assessment of ocular dominance columns on Golgi-impregnated sections of the primary visual cortex in monocularly deprived monkeys

In a study of morphological modifications of primary visual cortex in monkeys deprived, at birth, in one eye by lid suture, sections of area 17 were prepared by the rapid Golgi method combined with radioautography of transsynaptic transport of labeled amino acids following intraocular injection. The morphology of neurons in layer IV could be compared according to their innervation from the open or closed eye in the same animal.     

Non-stationarity of ocular dominance in cat striate cortex

Summary Interocular relationships, based on monocular directional tuning curves derived simultaneously for bar and for texture motion interleaved, are described for complex cells in the lightly-anaesthetised feline striate cortex. The results confirm earlier reports of stimulus-dependent differences in ocular dominance (Hammond 1979a, b) and demonstrate that ocular-dominance may be time-dependent and influenced by secondary stimulus characteristics including velocity of motion. Temporal and apparently spontaneous shifts in ocular dominance may take place other than in parallel for different classes of stimuli and may even occur simultaneously but in opposite directions. Thus absolute shifts in eye preference, as well as relative shifts between differing stimuli, must both occur with time, perhaps as the result of non-visual influences. The results present a challenge to strategies classically employed in defining cortical ocular dominance.     

The contribution of genetic factors to ocular dominance

Ocular dominance was measured in 561 mother-father-first-born offspring triads. Some evidence was found for an effect of parental mating pattern on offspring eye dominance. Effects were strongest when a regression analysis, against the number of left-eyed parents, was conducted. Previous data also show stronger familial effects when reanalyzed using this method.Dr. Brackenridge died while this paper was in review. Dr. Stanley Coren took responsibility for its revision and the editors are very grateful to him.     

Stimulus for rapid ocular dominance plasticity in visual cortex

Although it has been known for decades that monocular deprivation shifts ocular dominance in kitten striate cortex, uncertainty persists about the adequate stimulus for deprivation-induced losses of cortical responsiveness. In the current study we compared the effects of 2 days of lid closure and 2 days of monocular blur using an overcorrecting contact lens. Our finding of comparable ocular dominance shifts in visual cortex indicates that deprived-eye response depression is not a result of reduced retinal illumination. The quality rather than the quantity of retinal illumination is the key factor for ocular dominance plasticity. These data have implications for both the mechanism and treatment of amblyopia.     

Stimulus dependence of ocular dominance of complex cells in area 17 of the feline visual cortex

Summary Stimulus dependence of ocular dominance of 31 deep-layer complex cells was assessed from detailed monocular directional tuning curves for motion of bar stimuli or fields of static visual noise, in area 17 of normal adult cats, lightly anaesthetised with N₂O/O₂ supplemented with pentobarbitone. Virtually all cells were binocularly driven, with the anticipated ocular dominance distribution. Interocular differences in directional bias and sharpness of directional tuning for noise were observed in eleven cells, whereas preferred direction and sharpness of tuning for bar stimuli were similar for each eye. In the majority of cells (20/31), any differences between noise and bar tuning in one eye were replicated in the other. Ocular dominance of about half the cells (17/31) for noise and for bar motion was similar, or marginally shifted by up to one ocular dominance group. Substantial shifts in ocular dominance were seen in 14 cells — by up to two ocular dominance groups in 12 cells and by up to three ocular dominance groups in two cells. In three cases these shifts involved a reversal of eye dominance. Notwithstanding these changes, there were no obvious trends in shifts of ocular dominance in favour of the ipsilateral or contralateral eye, nor was there any tendency towards increased binocularity for noise.     

Anatomical origins of ocular dominance in mouse primary visual cortex

Ocular dominance (OD) plasticity is a classic paradigm for studying the effect of experience and deprivation on cortical development, and is manifested as shifts in the relative strength of binocular inputs to primary visual cortex (V1). The mouse has become an increasingly popular model for mechanistic studies of OD plasticity and, consequently, it is important that we understand how binocularity is constructed in this species. One puzzling feature of the mouse visual system is the gross disparity between the physiological strength of each eye in V1 and their anatomical representation in the projection from retina to the dorsal lateral geniculate nucleus (dLGN). While the contralateral-to-ipsilateral (C/I) ratio of visually evoked responses in binocular V1 is ∼2:1, the ipsilateral retinal projection is weakly represented in terms of retinal ganglion cell (RGC) density where the C/I ratio is ∼9:1. The structural basis for this relative amplification of ipsilateral eye responses between retina and V1 is not known. Here we employed neuroanatomical tracing and morphometric techniques to quantify the relative magnitude of each eye's input to and output from the binocular segment of dLGN. Our data are consistent with the previous suggestion that a point in space viewed by both eyes will activate 9 times as many RGCs in the contralateral retina as in the ipsilateral retina. Nonetheless, the volume of the dLGN binocular segment occupied by contralateral retinogeniculate inputs is only 2.4 times larger than the volume occupied by ipsilateral retinogeniculate inputs and recipient relay cells are evenly distributed among the input layers. The results from our morphometric analyses show that this reduction in input volume can be accounted for by a three-to-one convergence of contralateral eye RGC inputs to dLGN neurons. Together, our findings establish that the relative density of feed-forward dLGN inputs determines the C/I response ratio of mouse binocular V1.     

Multiple periods of functional ocular dominance plasticity in mouse visual cortex

The precise period when experience shapes neural circuits in the mouse visual system is unknown. We used Arc induction to monitor the functional pattern of ipsilateral eye representation in cortex during normal development and after visual deprivation. After monocular deprivation during the critical period, Arc induction reflects ocular dominance (OD) shifts within the binocular zone. Arc induction also reports faithfully expected OD shifts in cat. Shifts towards the open eye and weakening of the deprived eye were seen in layer 4 after the critical period ends and also before it begins. These shifts include an unexpected spatial expansion of Arc induction into the monocular zone. However, this plasticity is not present in adult layer 6. Thus, functionally assessed OD can be altered in cortex by ocular imbalances substantially earlier and far later than expected.     

Interaction of noradrenergic and cholinergic systems in regulation of ocular dominance plasticity

We studied interactions among the noradrenergic (NA) and the muscarinic cholinergic (ACh) systems in the regulation of ocular dominance plasticity in kitten visual cortex. The cortex was bilaterally infused with 6-hydroxydopamine (6-OHDA) for a week. Upon termination of the 6-OHDA infusion, one hemisphere was infused with a muscarinic ACh agonist, bethanechol, through the same, chronically implanted cannula for the second week together with monocular lid suture. The other hemisphere received an infusion of the vehicle solution alone. (1) Only in the hemisphere infused with bethanechol at relatively high concentrations did we obtain a clear shift in ocular dominance. We also found that the effect of bethanechol was concentration-dependent. (2) By comparing necessary concentrations of bethanechol and NA for the respective maximal effects, we noted that the former was at least 100-fold less effective than the latter in restoring the plasticity. (3) The cortical infusion of bethanechol did not restore the plasticity to the propranolol-pretreated cortex; the ocular dominance distribution remained virtually unchanged. This result was interpreted as suggesting that functioning beta-adrenoreceptors are needed for the cortical effect of activating the muscarinic ACh receptors to become detectable. (4) The expected shift in ocular dominance following monocular deprivation was partially suppressed, when highly concentrated scopolamine, a muscarinic ACh antagonist, was used, indicating that the involvement of the ACh system in this matter was indirect. The concentration of scopolamine needed for the half-maximum effect was 172-fold higher than that of propranolol. We thus conclude that the involvement of the muscarinic ACh system in ocular dominance plasticity is secondary to that of the NA-beta-adrenoreceptor system.     

Cyclic AMP-dependent protein kinase mediates ocular dominance shifts in cat visual cortex

Visual experience during a critical period early in postnatal development can change connections within mammalian visual cortex. In a kitten at the peak of the critical period (approximately P28-42), brief monocular deprivation can lead to complete dominance by the open eye, an ocular dominance shift. This process is driven by activity from the eyes, and depends on N-methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA) receptor activation. The components of the intracellular signaling cascade underlying these changes have not all been identified. Here we show that inhibition of protein kinase A (PKA) by Rp-8-Cl-cAMPS blocks ocular dominance shifts that occur following monocular deprivation early in the critical period. Inhibition of protein kinase G by Rp-8-Br-PET-cGMPS had no effect, indicating a specificity for the PKA pathway. Enhancement of PKA activity late in the critical period with Sp-8-Cl-cAMPS did not increase plasticity. PKA is a necessary component of the pathway leading to cortical plasticity during the critical period.     

Cortical activity blockade prevents ocular dominance plasticity in the kitten visual cortex

Summary Recordings from single units in kitten primary visual cortex show that a reversible blockade of the discharge activities of cortical neurons and geniculocortical afferent terminals by intracortical infusion of the sodium channel blocker tetrodotoxin (TTX) completely prevented the ocular dominance shift that would normally be seen after monocular deprivation. The blockade of cortical plasticity, like the blockade of discharge activity, was reversible, and plasticity was restored following recovery from the effects of TTX. These results extend previous work suggesting involvement of electrical activity at the level of the cortex in the phenomenon of cortical plasticity by demonstrating an absolute requirement for discharge activities in the primary visual cortex.This work was supported by the NIH (EY02874 and EY00213) and by grants from the March of Dimes Birth Defects Foundation and the University of California Academic Senate     

Involvement of β-adrenoreceptors in the shift of ocular dominance after monocular deprivation

Summary In the visual cortex of young kittens, the extent of ocular dominance shift following brief monocular lid suture was less than expected in the hemisphere which had been locally perfused with -adrenergic receptor blockers at a moderate concentration. The present result was not due to the effect similar to binocular deprivation, since local anesthetic effect of -adrenergic blockers was unlikely to be involved in the present paradigm. Thus, the present results are consistent with the idea that -adrenergic receptors within the visual cortex are necessary, at least in part, for the regulation of visuocortical plasticity.