Seizures occurring while driving in patients with and without diagnosis of epilepsy: Frequency and association with automobile accidents

Seizure may occur during any human activity, including driving. The objectives of this study were to report the frequency of seizure occurring while driving, clarify patient characteristics and analyze the behavioral patterns of drivers afflicted by seizure. A single-center, retrospective study was conducted using prospectively acquired data. Data of 658 adult seizure patients who visited our emergency department between January 2011 and December 2016 were used for analysis, focusing on daily activities immediately before seizure. Nineteen of the 658 patients (2.9%) sustained seizure while driving. The 658 patients were dichotomized on the basis of whether he or she had been diagnosed with epileptic seizure (ES). Seven of the 307 patients with ES vs. 12 of the 351 patients without ES sustained seizure while driving. The frequencies did not differ significantly between the two groups (2.3% vs. 3.4%, p = 0.49). Structural lesions on brain imaging studies were found in 6 of the 12 patients without ES (50%). Sixteen of the 19 patients (84%) caused automobile accidents after seizure. Among the 7 patients with ES, antiepileptic drugs had not been prescribed in 3 (43%). Although seizures occurring while driving have been studied extensively, most researchers focused on patients with ES. This study was unique because it focused on patients without ES, and the current findings that seizures in patients without ES outnumbered seizures in those with ES may be informative to clinical neuroscientists and emergency physicians. Prospective studies are expected to identify individuals at risk for first seizure occurring while driving.     

Epileptic auras and their role in driving safety in people with epilepsy

The aim of our study was to evaluate the role of auras in preventing motor vehicle accidents (MVAs) among patients with medically refractory epilepsy. The Multicenter Study of Epilepsy Surgery database was used to perform a case–control study by identifying patients who had seizures while driving that led to MVAs (cases) and those who had seizures while driving without MVAs (controls). We compared presence of reliable auras and other aura‐related features between the two groups. Two hundred fifteen of 553 patients reported having seizure(s) while driving; 74 were identified as “controls” and 141 as “cases.” The two groups had similar demographic and clinical features. The presence of reliable auras was not different between the two groups (67% in cases vs. 65% in controls; odds ratio [OR] 0.89, 95% confidence interval [CI] 0.49–1.61, p = 0.76). In addition, the groups did not differ in the proportion of patients who reported longer (>1 min) auras (OR 0.7, 95% CI 0.28–1.76, p = 0.47), or who thought that their auras were of sufficient duration to be protective (OR 1.19, 95% CI 0.62–2.00, p = 0.77). Our study questions the long‐held belief of a protective role of reliable auras against MVAs in people with epilepsy.     

Impact of mandatory physician reporting on accident risk in epilepsy

BACKGROUND: In some jurisdictions, physicians are required by law to report patients with seizures to the department of motor vehicles. We assessed the hypothesis that mandatory reporting reduces the risk of automobile accidents in people with epilepsy. METHODS: A retrospective survey of driving and accident rates was done by mailed questionnaire to two groups of subjects with epilepsy in Canada, one living in Ontario where reporting is mandatory and the other in Alberta where it is not. Responses were obtained from a control group without epilepsy for comparison. RESULTS: The epilepsy (n = 425) and control (n = 375) groups were comparable in age and sex. Seventy-three percent of the epilepsy group were or had been licensed drivers compared to 94% of the controls (rr 0.77, 95% CI 0.73-0.83, p < 0.001). Lifetime accident rate of licensed drivers was 58% in epilepsy and 60% in controls (rr 0.99, 95%CI 0.82-1.19, ns) while 9% of the epilepsy group and 9% of the controls had an accident in the previous year (rr 1.00, 95%CI 0.95-1.06, ns). All those with epilepsy in Ontario (n = 202) and Alberta (n = 223), also comparable in age and sex, had equal lifetime accident rates of 45 and 46% (rr 0.99, 95%CI 0.67-1.47, ns) and 1-year rates of 11 and 8% (rr 1.38, 95%CI 0.59-3.27, ns). In Ontario, 20% of drivers were unlicensed compared to 9% in Alberta (rr 2.39, 95%CI 1.17-4.89, p = 0.01) CONCLUSION: Although it is clearly dangerous for many people with ongoing seizures to drive, the findings provide no support for the hypothesis that mandatory reporting of patients by physicians reduces accident risk and suggest that concerns about the impact of epilepsy on driving compared to other medical and nonmedical risk factors may be excessive.     

中风后癫痫59例分析

对641例中风患者追踪观察1～3年,结果59例出现癫痫发作,中风后癫痫发生率为9.20％;脑出血与脑梗塞癫痫发生率间比较无已著差异(P>0.05);皮层损害者癫痫发生率显著高于皮层下损害者(P<0.01);脑出血继发癫痫发作多属早期发作(8/11),而脑梗塞多属迟发性癫痫发作(40/48)(P<0.01);早期癫痫发作需长期服抗癫痫药控制者显著低于迟发性癫痫发作(P<0.01)。提示:病损波及皮层是重要的致痫因素;早期发作与迟发性癫痫发作的发病机理不同,故表现出治疗与转归不同;迟发性癫痫尤其病灶波及皮层者长期规则服抗癫痫药是必要的。     

Driving prevalence and factors associated with driving among patients with epilepsy

PURPOSE: The goal of the work described here was to determine the prevalence of driving and associated variables among patients followed at a level 4 epilepsy center. METHOD: A survey was mailed out to patients seen at the University of Florida/Jacksonville Comprehensive Epilepsy Program. RESULTS: The study population comprised 308 respondents. Nearly 20% of patients with poorly controlled seizures continued to drive. Although several demographic and clinical variables were associated with driving, on univariate analysis, using multiple logistic regression, being employed, not receiving disability benefits, having less frequent seizures, and taking fewer antiepileptic drugs were the variables independently associated with driving. A subset analysis of patients with poorly controlled seizures indicated that being employed was still an independent factor associated with driving, along with higher annual household income and absence of convulsions and waking seizures. CONCLUSION: A significant number of patients with poorly controlled seizures drive. Being employed is a major reason these patients continue to drive.     

Is an Application Form Useful To Select Patients with Epilepsy Who May Drive?

Of 1,268 persons who claimed to have epilepsy and were therefore disqualified for military service, 55% had a driving license 5 years later. Only 58% had applied for a driving license. Of those 14% who had answered truthfully the question "have you had fits, epilepsy etc." in the application form, 63% received a license. Fewer persons with epilepsy had a driving license after about 5 years (55%) than did age-matched controls (73%). The application form is of no use in preventing persons with epilepsy from obtaining a driving license. Adequate instruction of the patient and of his physician is to be preferred to the use of an application form.     

Long-Term Prognosis in Childhood Epilepsy: Survival and Seizure Prognosis

All children aged 0-19 years who had active epilepsy in a defined Swedish population were traced and given a clinical and psychometric investigation. Twelve years later, a follow-up study was carried out. Eleven of the 194 children had died, 8 of whom had had signs of neurodeficit, i.e., abnormal neurology and/or mental retardation. A long-standing remission of seizures occurred in 124 of the 194 children. Signs of neurodeficit, frequent seizures, and many types of seizures were negative prognostic factors. The presence of all these factors carried a bad prognosis, seizures persisting during 12 years in greater than 80%. For those who were mentally and neurologically normal and had low seizure frequency, prognosis was excellent, only 11% still having active epilepsy after 12 years. A study of the annual remission rate showed that each year approximately 13% of the children without neurodeficit had remission from epilepsy the next year. This rate appeared to be stable over the 12 years studied. Among those children with neurodeficit, the annual remission rate was high only during the first years after onset, later falling to 3% a year.     

Human bedside evaluation versus automatic responsiveness testing in epilepsy (ARTiE)

Evaluation of behavioral impairment during epileptic seizures is critical for medical decision making, including accurate diagnosis, recommendations for driving, and presurgical evaluation. We investigated the quality of behavioral testing during inpatient video–electroencephalography (EEG) monitoring at an established epilepsy center, and introduce a technical innovation that may improve clinical care. We retrospectively reviewed video‐EEG data from 152 seizures in 33 adult or pediatric patients admitted for video‐EEG monitoring. Behavioral testing with questions or commands was performed in only 50% of seizures ictally, 73% of seizures postictally, and 80% with either ictal or postictal testing combined. Furthermore, the questions or commands were highly inconsistent and were performed by nonmedical personnel in about one fourth of cases. In an effort to improve this situation we developed and here introduce Automatic Responsiveness Testing in Epilepsy (ARTiE), a series of video‐recorded behavioral tasks automatically triggered to play in the patient's room by computerized seizure detection. In initial technical testing using prerecorded or live video‐EEG data we found that ARTiE is initiated reliably by automatic seizure detection. With additional clinical testing we hope that ARTiE will succeed in providing comprehensive and reliable behavioral evaluation during seizures for people with epilepsy to greatly improve their clinical care.     

The Short-Term Impact of Adjunctive Tiagabine on Health-Related Quality of Life

Summary: Combinations of tiagabine (TGB), carbamazepine (CBZ), and phenytoin (PHT) were compared for their impact on health-related quality of life (HRQOL) and adverse effects related to treatment efficacy for people with frequent complex partial seizures. Two independent, randomized, double-blind clinical trials for efficacy and safety were conducted simultaneously with treatment groups: CBZ+PHT versus CBZ+TGB, and PHT+CBZ versus PHT+TGB. Treatment was initiated at week 0 and continued through week 16. HRQOL was evaluated with the QOLIE-89. Treatment success was defined as ≥50% reduction in complex partial seizures. Among patients who achieved a ≥50% reduction in seizures, addition of TGB to baseline PHT enhanced patient perceptions of attention/concentration (13%; p = 0.002), memory (17%; p = 0.042), and language subscales (22%; p = 0.004). Addition of CBZ to PHT led to positive change in the work/driving/social relations subscale (14%; p = 0.004). These improvements were significantly different only between visits, not between the two treatment groups. Seizure worry subscale scores showed improvement among all treatment groups and was probably related to participation in the clinical trial. These exploratory analyses suggest a possible early positive effect of TGB on patient-perceived cognitive domains using the QOLIE-89. These findings are limited by the small sample size and could be related to reduction in seizures.     

Marital status after epilepsy surgery

PURPOSE: To characterize features influencing marital status in a group of patients with refractory epilepsy before and after epilepsy surgery and to assess the effect of seizure control on marital status after epilepsy surgery. METHODS: We analyzed marital status in 430 epilepsy surgery patients and in a subset with temporal lobe epilepsy. Marital status was assessed in relation to gender and age of epilepsy onset and compared with marital rates for the U.S. population. Patients who had > or =4 years of postsurgical follow-up were examined for change in marital status after surgery. Those patients who changed marital status were then evaluated for change in employment. RESULTS: Marital rates were lower than expected in men. Men with onset of epilepsy by age 11 years were less likely to be married than men whose seizures began after age 11 or women whose seizures began at any age. Men and women with temporal lobe epilepsy had higher marriage rates than those with extratemporal lobe epilepsy. More than 4 years after epilepsy surgery (n = 190), patients who had no recurrent seizures were more likely to change marital status (28 of 124, 23%), than those who had recurrent seizures (five of 66, 8%). Seizure-free women were more likely to divorce (n = 9) than were seizure-free men (n = 1). Most men who married were employed (77%), whereas women who divorced were usually unemployed (67%). CONCLUSIONS: The age at which seizures begin influences later marital status in men, who have reduced marriage rates. The abolition of seizures by epilepsy surgery creates new opportunities for changing social relationships. Location of the epileptic focus may influence psychosocial function.     

EEG Abnormalities in Children with a First Unprovoked Seizure

Summary: We examined EEG findings from an ongoing study of 347 children with a first unprovoked seizure. EEGs were available in 321 (93%), and 135 (42%) had an abnormal EEG. EEG abnormalities included focal spikes (n = 77), generalized spike and wave discharges (n = 28), slowing (n = 43), and nonspecific abnormalities (n = 7). Abnormal EEGs were more common in children with remote symptomatic seizures (60%) than in those with idiopathic seizures (38%) (p < 0.003), more common in partial seizures (56%) than in generalized seizures (35%) (p < 0.001), and more common in children age >3 years (52%) than in younger children (12%) (p < 0.001). Records including both awake and sleep tracings were available in 148 (46%) cases. For 122 (38%) only awake tracings and for 51 (16%) only sleep tracings were available. Fifty-nine (40%) of the 148 patients with both an awake and asleep tracing had abnormal EEGs. Of 50 such EEGs with epileptiform abnormalities, 15 (30%) demonstrated the abnormality either only while awake (n = 8) or only while asleep (n = 7). Of 17 patients with EEG slowing, 8 showed slowing only in the awake tracing and 9 showed slowing in both the awake and asleep tracing. Children with even a single unprovoked seizure have a high incidence of EEG abnormalities. Obtaining a combined awake and sleep EEG significantly increases the yield of EEG abnormalities. In children with an idiopathic first seizure, EEG abnormalities are associated with an increased risk of seizure recurrence.     

Employment after anterior temporal lobectomy

Purpose: To explore the effect of anterior temporal lobectomy on employment and define demographic and clinical predictors of postoperative employment in a large cohort with a prolonged observational period. Methods: Subjects had an anterior temporal lobectomy for refractory epilepsy. All had an assessment period of 4 years or more with documentation of demographic factors, employment status, and seizure frequency prospectively registered in a database at surgery and at each contact after surgery. McNemar chi‐square and a Wilcoxon matched pairs test were used to compare employment status before and after surgery. A multiple logistic regression assessed independent predictors of postoperative employment status based on preoperative employment status. Key Findings: Three hundred sixty‐nine patients were evaluated. Employment levels were higher and unemployment levels were lower after surgery (McNemar χ² = 3.96; p = 0.047). Working before surgery (Wald’s χ² = 22.69, p < 0.0001) and having a greater percent of seizure‐free years (Wald’s χ² = 34.43, p < 0.0001) were associated with being employed after surgery. Of 131 patients who were unemployed or homemakers before surgery, 67 (51.1%) became employed postoperatively, with a younger age at surgery, a younger age of epilepsy onset, and driving a motor vehicle associated with gaining employment. Of 172 patients who were working at baseline, 27 (15.7%) became unemployed or homemakers after surgery. Gender was the only variable associated with loss of employment, with women being more likely to become homemakers (χ² = 14.98, d.f. = 6, p = 0.02). Most students were working after surgery, with seizure control influencing outcome. Significance: Anterior temporal lobectomy is followed by reduced unemployment and underemployment, with elimination of seizures, relative youth, and operating a motor vehicle serving as the main driving forces for improvement. This is important information for patients and physicians who contemplate surgery as it helps define reasonable expectations, and provides further objective evidence for benefits beyond purely medical outcomes after epilepsy surgery.     

Partial epilepsy in neurologically normal children: clinical syndromes and prognosis

A clinical and electroencephalographic study of 107 neurologically normal children with partial seizures was undertaken to verify the existence and determine the frequency of epileptic syndromes reported in selected populations. Sixty-three children had simple partial seizures, 39 had complex partial seizures, and 5 children were unclassifiable. The syndrome of benign partial epilepsy of children with rolandic spikes (BPEC, 38 cases) was clearly identified and its uniformly benign final prognosis was confirmed even if some of these children had at times severe or poorly controlled seizures. Among the children with simple partial seizures outside the BPEC (25 cases) and complex partial seizures (39 cases), no homogeneous clinical or electroclinical subgroup could be found. Two children with benign partial epilepsy and myoclonic-astatic seizures ("atypical benign partial epilepsy of childhood") and one child with "benign epilepsy with occipital spike-waves" were identified. 74% of children with epilepsy with complex partial seizures (ECP) had a 1-year seizure-free interval, and many children with epilepsy with simple partial seizures outside the BPEC group (ESP) had no more than two seizures. A benign course is thus not limited to the BPEC but is difficult to predict. Prospective studies are necessary to confirm the existence of well-defined benign syndromes among the idiopathic partial epilepsies of childhood, which appear quite rare outside the BPEC.     

减药对儿童癫痫术前评估长程脑电图监测的影响

目的 分析减药对难治性癫痫患儿术前评估进行长程脑电图监测的影响.方法 回顾性分析2018年8月-2019年12月期间北京大学第一医院儿童癫痫中心需术前评估的难治性癫痫患儿,进行术前长程脑电图监测的资料.监测时长:①已监测到3次临床发作,或②监测时间满10天.按既定方案减停抗癫痫药物(AEDs).结果 本研究中共576例...     

An overview of epilepsy and driving

Summary   Operating a motor vehicle is important to people with epilepsy (PWE). Being allowed to legally drive, largely depends on being seizure free for a defined period of time and being physically capable. Each patient's driving situation should be considered individually with advice offered guided by the goals of maximizing safety for both PWE and the public. There are considerable risks associated with driving for PWE or other medical conditions. Unfortunately, laws that govern driving are not uniform from state to state or country to country, requiring individual practitioners to be familiar with the local regulations. Good medical care leading to improved seizure control may allow PWE to drive and improve their quality of life. The privilege of driving a motor vehicle is important for many people with and without epilepsy. Many factors impact the ability to drive and laws governing driving and epilepsy are quite variable around the USA and the world. Being restricted from driving due to seizures represents a significant event in one's life affecting independence, sometimes employment and quality of life. The privilege of operating a motorized vehicle is granted by some form of governmental agency in virtually every state and country.     

Refractory generalized seizures: response to corpus callosotomy and vagal nerve stimulation

PURPOSE: The vagal nerve stimulator (VNS) and corpus callosotomy can reduce seizure frequency when seizures are refractory to medications. However, the efficacy and safety of these two procedures have not been compared. This study evaluates the two procedures for generalized seizures. METHODS: All patients with refractory generalized seizures (generalized tonic-clonic, tonic, or atonic) who underwent a corpus callosotomy (anterior or complete) (n = 53) without other forms of epilepsy surgery and those who underwent VNS placement (n = 25) were evaluated for this study. Seizure response and procedure complications were evaluated. RESULTS: For those with a corpus callosotomy and generalized tonic-clonic seizures (n = 50), 79.5% had >or=50% decrease in the frequency of generalized tonic-clonic seizures, and 60% had >or=80% seizure reduction. For those with a VNS and generalized tonic-clonic seizures (n = 21), 50% had >or=50% seizure reduction, and 33% had >or=80% seizure reduction. Tonic and atonic seizures decreased after either VNS or a corpus callosotomy. The complication rate for corpus callosotomy was higher (21% all complications, 3.8% permanent) than that for VNS (8%; none permanent), but complications for both corpus callosotomy and VNS were rarely permanent. CONCLUSIONS: Both corpus callosotomy and VNS are effective in reducing generalized seizures. Corpus callosotomy is associated with greater efficacy but higher risk for complications, although these were generally transient.     

Long‐term outcome of phenobarbital treatment for epilepsy in rural China: A prospective cohort study

Purpose: To evaluate the long‐term outcome of phenobarbital treatment for convulsive epilepsy in rural China, and to explore factors associated with overall seizure outcomes. Methods: We carried out follow‐up assessments of people who took part in an epilepsy community management program conducted in rural counties of six provinces in China. People with convulsive epilepsy who were previously untreated (or on irregular treatment) were commenced on regular treatment with phenobarbital. Information was collected using a standardized questionnaire by face‐to‐face interviews of the individuals (and their families where necessary). Information collected included treatment status, medication change, seizure frequency, and mortality. Key Findings: Among the 2,455 people who participated in the original program, outcomes were successfully ascertained during the follow‐up assessment in 1986. Among them, 206 had died. Information on treatment response was obtained in 1,780 (56% male; mean age 33.9 years, range 3–84; mean duration of follow‐up 6.4 years). Among them, 939 (53%) were still taking phenobarbital. The most common reasons for stopping phenobarbital were seizure freedom or substantial seizure reduction, socioeconomic reasons, and personal preference. Four hundred fifty‐three individuals (25%) became seizure‐free for at least 1 year while taking phenobarbital, 88% of whom did so at daily doses of 120 mg or below. Four hundred six (23%) reported adverse events, which led to withdrawal of phenobarbital in <1%. The most common adverse effects were malaise/somnolence (7.4%), dizziness (3%), and lethargy (2.6%). At the follow‐up assessment, 688 (39%) individuals had been seizure free for at least the previous year. People with persistent seizures had significantly longer duration of epilepsy and higher number of seizures in the 12 months before treatment. People who were taking AED treatment irregularly at recruitment were less likely to become seizure‐free. Significance: We observed long‐term benefits of regular treatment with phenobarbital for convulsive epilepsy in rural China. One hundred years after the discovery of its antiepileptic effect, phenobarbital is still playing an important role in the management of epilepsy.     

Seizure impact on the school attendance in children with epilepsy

RATIONALE: Epilepsy has a significant influence on the patient's quality of life. The objective of this study was to evaluate the impact of ongoing seizures on school attendance amongst children with epilepsy. METHODS: This was a prospective study, conducted at the University of Campinas, in the pediatric epilepsy clinic, from January 2005 to August 2006. We enrolled 50 consecutive children who had a diagnosis of epilepsy. Parents were interviewed by one of the authors using a semi-structured questionnaire that included questions specifically addressing the impact of epilepsy on the child's academic life. RESULTS: Fifty patients were evaluated, 34 boys and 16 girls; ages ranged from 6 to 18 years old (mean=11). Eighty-eight percent of patients in the study missed at least 1 day of school due to seizures. The reason given by parents for a school absence was seizure in 75%, medical appointment in 79.5%, epilepsy related tests (EEG, MRI, etc.) in 68.2%, and other in 0.03%. Almost half of the parents (46%) believed that if the child had a seizure at school he/she should leave school immediately. Sixty percent of families allowed the child to skip a school day even if there was no illness and the child had no seizures on that day. Among those patients with siblings, 12.5% had a brother or sister who was absent from school for at least 1 day due to his/her sibling's epilepsy. CONCLUSION: Seizures have a significant impact on school attendance, and as a result may increase the academic difficulties faced by children with epilepsy. This effect may be especially pronounced in children with symptomatic epilepsy and medically intractable seizures.     

Ganglioglioma and Intractable Epilepsy: Clinical and Neurophysiologic Features and Predictors of Outcome After Surgery

Summary: Purpose: To review the clinical, neurophysiologic, and radiological data of patients with ganglioglioma who had undergone evaluation and surgery in our Epilepsy Program.
Methods: The medical and neurophysiologic records of 38 patients with intractable epilepsy and ganglioglioma were re- viewed. Data underwent statistical analysis.
Results: There were 28 temporal and 10 extratemporal resections, with a mean age at seizure onset of 10.5 years and mean age at surgery of 22 years. Five tumor resections performed earlier were recorded. Twenty-nine patients had auras and 20 had secondarily generalized seizures. All 28 patients with temporal tumor had complex partial seizures. Preoperative MRI demonstrated the tumor in 36 of 36 patients: 17 of 29 demonstrated gadolinium enhancement, and 17 of 36 had mass effect. Scalp interictal sharp waves were present in 32 patients, and in 15 they were multiregional. In two patients, scalp EEG seizure onset was from the hemisphere contralateral to the tumor. Postoperatively, 79% of patients (30 of 38) were seizure-free (Engel's class I) at 6 months, 72% at 1 year (26 of 36), and 63% at 2 years (20 of 32). Excellent outcome was associated with a lower age at operation (p = 0.008), shorter duration of epilepsy (p = <0.01), absence of generalized seizures (p = <0.01), and no epileptiform discharges on a postoperative EEG (p = 0.01).
Conclusions: Good surgical outcome is expected in patients with ganglioglioma despite years of medically resistant seizures. Good outcome may be achieved despite EEG findings that may conflict with tumor location, and is more likely when surgery is performed relatively soon after epilepsy onset.     

EEG and Seizure Outcome After Epilepsy Surgery

Summary: The significance of the EEG after epilepsy surgery is not fully understood. We investigated the as- sociation between postoperative EEG abnormalities and persistent seizures after epilepsy surgery as they relate to pathologic lesions. Among 254 patients who underwent epilepsy surgery between 1987 and 1991, we identified 78 patients who had mesiotemporal sclerosis (MTS) and 47 patients who had low-grade brain tumors, all of whom had 6-to 18-month postoperative follow-up including EEG. Patients who had other pathology, multiple operations, callosotomy, or hemispherectomy, or who were aged <18 years or who had insufficient EEG data, were excluded. Patients were classified as having persistent seizures or being seizure-free since operation. EEG abnormalities were abstracted from EEG reports 6–18 months postoperatively. Seizures persisted in 24% of the MTS group and in 27% of the tumor group. Of those with normal EEGs, none of the MTS patients and only 1 of the tumor patients had persistent seizures (p = 0.03 for MTS and p = 0.42 for tumor). Epileptiform discharges and focal slowing were associated with seizure persistence in both groups, but to a significant extent only in the MTS group. In the MTS group, patients who had both epileptiform discharges and focal slowing were more likely to have persistent seizures than were those with either abnormality alone.