Genotype to phenotype correlations in cartilage oligomeric matrix protein associated chondrodysplasias

Pseudoachondroplasia (PSACH) and autosomal dominant multiple epiphyseal dysplasia (MED) are chondrodysplasias resulting in short-limbed dwarfism, joint pain and stiffness and early onset osteoarthritis. All PSACH, and the largest proportion of MED, result from mutations in cartilage oligomeric matrix protein (COMP). The first mutations in COMP were identified in 1995 in patients with both PSACH and MED and subsequently there has been over 30 publications describing COMP mutations in at least 250 PSACH–MED patients. However, despite these discoveries, a methodical analysis of the relationship between COMP mutations and phenotypes has not been undertaken. In particular, there has, to date, been little correlation between the type and location of a COMP mutation and the resulting phenotype of PSACH or MED. To determine if genotype to phenotype correlations could be derived for COMP, we collated 300 COMP mutations, including 25 recently identified novel mutations. The results of this analysis demonstrate that mutations in specific residues and/or regions of the type III repeats of COMP are significantly associated with either PSACH or MED. This newly derived genotype to phenotype correlation may aid in determining the prognosis of PSACH and MED, including the prediction of disease severity, and in the long term guide genetic counselling and contribute to the clinical management of patients with these diseases.     

Novel mutation in exon 18 of the cartilage oligomeric matrix protein gene causes a severe pseudoachondroplasia

Pseudoachondroplasia (PSACH) is a common skeletal dysplasia characterized by disproportionate short stature, early‐onset osteoarthrosis, and dysplasia of the spine, epiphysis, and metaphysis. Multiple epiphyseal dysplasia (MED) is a similar but less severe disorder characterized by dysplasia of the epiphysis. Both disorders are caused by mutations in the cartilage oligomeric matrix protein (COMP) gene. COMP mutations cluster in a region of the gene that encodes calmodulin‐like repeats (CLRs) and correlate closely with disease severity. Typically, mutations in exon 13 that composes the seventh CLR produce severe PSACH phenotypes, whereas mutations found elsewhere in the gene produce mild PSACH or MED phenotypes. We have identified a PSACH patient carrying a novel mutation in exon 18 of COMP that composes the C‐terminal globular domain. This mutation produced a severe PSACH phenotype with marked short stature and deformities of the spine and extremities. Our results extend the range of disease‐causing mutations within the COMP gene and demonstrate the importance of the additional domain of COMP protein in its in vivo function. © 2001 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

MIR204 n.37C>T variant as a cause of chorioretinal dystrophy variably associated with iris coloboma,early-onset cataracts and congenital glaucoma

Four members of a three-generation Czech family with early-onset chorioretinal dystrophy were shown to be heterozygous carriers of the n.37C>T in MIR204. The identification of this previously reported pathogenic variant confirms the existence of a distinct clinical entity caused by a sequence change in MIR204. Chorioretinal dystrophy was variably associated with iris coloboma, congenital glaucoma, and premature cataracts extending the phenotypic range of the condition. In silico analysis of the n.37C>T variant revealed 713 novel targets. Additionally, four family members were shown to be affected by albinism resulting from biallelic pathogenic OCA2 variants. Haplotype analysis excluded relatedness with the original family reported to harbour the n.37C>T variant in MIR204. Identification of a second independent family confirms the existence of a distinct MIR204-associated clinical entity and suggests that the phenotype may also involve congenital glaucoma.     

Exome sequencing reveals a novel COL2A1 mutation implicated in multiple epiphyseal dysplasia

Mutations in the COMP, COL9A1, COL9A2, COL9A3, MATN3, and SLC26A2 genes cause approximately 70% of multiple epiphyseal dysplasia (MED) cases. The genetic changes involved in the etiology of the remaining cases are still unknown, suggesting that other genes contribute to MED development. Our goal was to identify a mutation causing an autosomal dominant form of MED in a large multigenerational family. Initially, we excluded all genes known to be associated with autosomal dominant MED by using microsatellite and SNP markers. Follow‐up with whole‐exome sequencing analysis revealed a mutation c.2032G>A (p.Gly678Arg) in the COL2A1 gene (NCBI Reference Sequence: NM_001844.4), which co‐segregated with the disease phenotype in this family, manifested by severe hip dysplasia and osteoarthritis. One of the affected family members had a double‐layered patella, which is frequently seen in patients with autosomal recessive MED caused by DTDST mutations and sporadically in the dominant form of MED caused by COL9A2 defect.     

Biallelic mutation in MYH7 and MYBPC3 leads to severe cardiomyopathy with left ventricular noncompaction phenotype

Dominant mutations in the MYH7 and MYBPC3 genes are common causes of inherited cardiomyopathies, which often demonstrate variable phenotypic expression and incomplete penetrance across family members. Biallelic inheritance is rare but allows gaining insights into the genetic mode of action of single variants. Here, we present three cases carrying a loss‐of‐function (LoF) variant in a compound heterozygous state with a missense variant in either MYH7 or MYBPC3 leading to severe cardiomyopathy with left ventricular noncompaction. Most likely, MYH7 haploinsufficiency due to one LoF allele results in a clinical phenotype only in compound heterozygous form with a missense variant. In contrast, haploinsufficiency in MYBPC3 results in a severe early‐onset ventricular noncompaction phenotype requiring heart transplantation when combined with a de novo missense variant on the second allele. In addition, the missense variant may lead to an unstable protein, as overall only 20% of the MYBPC3 protein remain detectable in affected cardiac tissue compared to control tissue. In conclusion, in patients with early disease onset and atypical clinical course, biallelic inheritance or more complex variants including copy number variations and de novo mutations should be considered. In addition, the pathogenic consequence of variants may differ in heterozygous versus compound heterozygous state.     

A homozygous ROR2 variant in a family with atypical Robinow syndrome and tetramelic transverse deficiency of autopods

We present five members of a consanguineous Pakistani kinship with the most severe familial tetramelic transverse autopod deficiency reported to date and additionally having some of the common autosomal recessive Robinow syndrome-1 (RRS1) features including short stature, short neck, severe vertebral anomalies of kyphoscoliosis, hemivertebrae, fusion of thoracic vertebrae, broad forehead, and dental crowding. We mapped the locus of this atypical RRS and detected homozygous 8-nucleotide deletion c.1353_1360del (p.(Met452Alafs*4)) in ROR2, the gene responsible for RRS1. We did not find any other variant shared by all affected individuals that could possibly act as a modifier of limb defect. Autopods are affected in RRS1, but severe autopod deficiency is not a characteristic feature. Over 30 biallelic variants dispersed throughout the gene are known in ROR2-related RS, with no genotype–phenotype correlation for specific RRS1 features. Considering together with the sporadic case homozygous for variant p.(Arg442*) and the case homozygous for p.(Arg441Thrfs*16) in a family where heterozygous members have brachydactyly type B1, we propose that homozygous truncating variants that originate at residues 441–452 can cause severe autopod reduction anomalies, suggesting some genotype–phenotype correlation for this particular phenotype.     

Partial penetrance and phenotypic variability of aplasia of lacrimal and salivary glands caused by a novel FGF10 donor splice-site mutation

Thirteen affected individuals of six generations of a single kindred presented with epiphora evident from infancy. Physical exam and Schirmer test revealed variable expression of tear deficiency, congenital punctal atresia, and dry mouth with multiple caries, without concomitant abnormalities of the ears or digits, commensurate with a diagnosis of aplasia of the lacrimal and salivary glands (ALSG). Reconstruction of the upper lacrimal drainage system was performed in some of the affected individuals. Genetic analysis, testing six affected individuals and three non-affected family members, identified a single novel heterozygous splice-site variant, c.429 + 1, G > T in fibroblast growth factor 10 (FGF10) (NM_004465.1), segregating throughout the family as expected for dominant heredity. RT-PCR assays of HEK-293 cells transfected with wild type or mutant FGF10 demonstrated that the variant causes skipping of Exon 2. Notably, individuals sharing the same variant exhibited phenotypic variability, with unilateral or bilateral epiphora, as well as variable expression of dry mouth and caries. Moreover, one of the variant carriers had no ALSG-related clinical findings, demonstrating incomplete penetrance. While coding mutations in FGF10 are known to cause malformations in the nasolacrimal system, this is the second FGF10 splice-site variant and the first donor-site variant reported to cause ALSG. Thus, our study of a unique large kindred with multiple affected individuals heterozygous for the same FGF10 variant highlights intronic splice-site mutations and phenotypic variability/partial penetrance in ALSG.     

Pseudoachondroplasia and multiple epiphyseal dysplasia: New etiologic developments

Pseudoachondroplasia (PSACH) (OMIM#177170) and multiple epiphyseal dysplasia (MED) are separate but overlapping osteochondrodysplasias. PSACH is a dominantly inherited disorder characterized by short-limb short stature, loose joints, and early-onset osteoarthropathy. The diagnosis is based on characteristic clinical and radiographic findings. Only mutations in the cartilage oligomeric matrix protein (COMP) gene have been reported in PSACH, and all family studies have been consistent with linkage to the COMP locus on chromosome 19. Multiple epiphyseal dysplasia (MED) is a relatively mild chondrodysplasia but like PSACH, MED causes early-onset joint degeneration, particularly of the large weight-bearing joints. Given the clinical similarity between PSACH and MED, it was not surprising that the first MED locus identified was the COMP gene (EDM1). Mutations causing MED have now been identified in five other genes (COL9A1, COL9A2, COL9A3, DTDST, and MATN3), making MED one of the most genetically heterogeneous disorders. This article reviews the clinical features of PSACH and MED, the known mutations, and the pathogenetic effect of COMP mutations on the cartilage extracellular matrix.     

NID1 variant associated with occipital cephaloceles in a family expressing a spectrum of phenotypes

Autosomal dominant Dandy‐Walker malformation and occipital cephalocele (ADDWOC) is a rare, congenital, and incompletely penetrant malformation that is considered to be part of the Dandy‐Walker spectrum of disorders. Affected individuals often present with an occipital cephalocele with a bony skull defect, but typically have normal neurological development. Here, we report on a three‐generation family in which individuals have variable phenotypes that are consistent with the ADDWOC spectrum: arachnoid cysts in the proband and his maternal grandfather, an occipital cephalocele in the proband and his brother, and a small bony defect in the proband's mother. Whole exome sequencing identified a rare heterozygous variant in NID1 (NM_002508.2:c.1162C>T, (p.Gln388Ter)) in the proband, his brother, and his mother. Sanger sequencing confirmed the presence of this variant in the maternal grandfather. The identical c.1162C>T variant was previously identified in variably affected members of a three‐generation family with ADDWOC. This case report provides further evidence that variants in NID1 may be clinically relevant for the development of a phenotype that is consistent with ADDWOC, and extends the phenotype of NID1‐associated ADDWOC to include arachnoid cysts. Given that the Dandy‐Walker malformation itself is not a pre‐requisite to this spectrum of phenotypes, we also suggest a novel term for the NID1‐associated disorder in order to give emphasis to this phenotypic variability: “Autosomal Dominant Posterior Fossa Anomalies with Occipital Cephaloceles.”     

Expanding the clinical spectrum of biallelic ZNF335 variants

ZNF335 plays an essential role in neurogenesis and biallelic variants in ZNF335 have been identified as the cause of severe primary autosomal recessive microcephaly in 2 unrelated families. We describe, herein, 2 additional affected individuals with biallelic ZNF335 variants, 1 individual with a homozygous c.1399 T > C, p.(Cys467Arg) variant, and a second individual with compound heterozygous c.2171_2173delTCT, p.(Phe724del) and c.3998A > G, p.(Glu1333Gly) variants with the latter variant predicted to affect splicing. Whereas the first case presented with early death and a severe phenotype characterized by anterior agyria with prominent extra‐axial spaces, absent basal ganglia, and hypoplasia of the brainstem and cerebellum, the second case had a milder clinical presentation with hypomyelination and otherwise preserved brain structures on MRI. Our findings expand the clinical spectrum of ZNF335‐associated microcephaly.     

Identification of a second HOXA2 nonsense mutation in a family with autosomal dominant non‐syndromic microtia and distinctive ear morphology

Microtia is a congenital defect affecting external ears, which appear smaller and sometimes malformed. Here we describe a five‐generation family with isolated bilateral microtia segregating as an autosomal dominant trait. Similar features have been previously observed in an autosomal dominant family with non‐syndromic microtia and hearing loss segregating with a HOXA2 nonsense variant. HOXA2 biallelic mutations were also described in an inbreed family with autosomal recessive microtia, hearing impairment and incomplete cleft palate. In our family, sequence analysis detected a heterozygous protein truncating nonsense variant [c.670G>T, p.(Glu224*)] segregating in all affected individuals and absent in public databases. This study confirms the role of HOXA2 gene in dominant isolated microtia and contribute to further define the dysmorphogenetic effect of this gene on ear development.     

Locus and allelic heterogeneity and phenotypic variability in Waardenburg syndrome

Waardenburg syndrome (WS) is a disorder of neural crest cell migration characterized by auditory and pigmentary abnormalities. We investigated a cohort of 14 families (16 subjects) either by targeted sequencing or whole-exome sequencing. Thirteen of these families were clinically diagnosed with WS and one family with isolated non-syndromic hearing loss (NSHL). Intra-familial phenotypic variability and non-penetrance were observed in families diagnosed with WS1, WS2 and WS4 with pathogenic variants in PAX3, MITF and EDNRB, respectively. We observed gonosomal mosaicism for a variant in PAX3 in an asymptomatic father of two affected siblings. For the first time, we report a biallelic pathogenic variant in MITF in a subject with WS2 and a biallelic variant in EDNRB was noted in a subject with WS2. An individual with isolated NSHL carried a pathogenic variant in MITF. Blended phenotype of NSHL and albinism was observed in a subject clinically diagnosed to have WS2. A phenocopy of WS1 was observed in a subject with a reported pathogenic variant in GJB2, known to cause isolated NSHL. These novel and infrequently reported observations exemplify the allelic and genetic heterogeneity and show phenotypic diversity of WS.     

Functional characterization of the first missense variant in CEP78, a founder allele associated with cone‐rod dystrophy,hearing loss,and reduced male fertility

Inactivating variants in the centrosomal CEP78 gene have been found in cone‐rod dystrophy with hearing loss (CRDHL), a particular phenotype distinct from Usher syndrome. Here, we identified and functionally characterized the first CEP78 missense variant c.449T>C, p.(Leu150Ser) in three CRDHL families. The variant was found in a biallelic state in two Belgian families and in a compound heterozygous state—in trans with c.1462‐1G>T—in a third German family. Haplotype reconstruction showed a founder effect. Homology modeling revealed a detrimental effect of p.(Leu150Ser) on protein stability, which was corroborated in patients' fibroblasts. Elongated primary cilia without clear ultrastructural abnormalities in sperm or nasal brushes suggest impaired cilia assembly. Two affected males from different families displayed sperm abnormalities causing infertility. One of these is a heterozygous carrier of a complex allele in SPAG17, a ciliary gene previously associated with autosomal recessive male infertility. Taken together, our data indicate that a missense founder allele in CEP78 underlies the same sensorineural CRDHL phenotype previously associated with inactivating variants. Interestingly, the CEP78 phenotype has been possibly expanded with male infertility. Finally, CEP78 loss‐of‐function variants may have an underestimated role in misdiagnosed Usher syndrome, with or without sperm abnormalities.     

Multiple SLC26A2 mutations occurring in a three-generational family

Multiple epiphyseal dysplasias (MED) are a group of heterogeneous skeletal dysplasias, which share a common phenotype: short stature, skeletal deformities, joint pain and early onset osteoarthritis. Mutations in COMP account for approximately half of autosomal dominant MED cases whilst SLC26A2 mutations account for ～25% of the recessive cases in the Caucasian population. We present here an interesting family, which was thought to initially have an autosomal dominant skeletal dysplasia. Using a targeted sequencing skeletal dysplasia panel, the proband was found to be a compound heterozygote for two mutations in SLC26A2, one novel mutation, p.Ser522Phe and the other, the common mutation, p.Arg279Trp. In addition to the classical characteristics of MED, she presented with an atypical feature, bilateral synostoses between the 2nd and 3rd metatarsals. The parents were confirmed to be heterozygous for the two mutations but interestingly, the maternal grandfather, who had MED, was found to be homozygous for the common SLC26A2 mutation.     

A family study implicates GBE1 in the etiology of autism spectrum disorder

Autism spectrum disorders (ASD) are neurodevelopmental disorders with an estimated heritability of >60%. Family-based genetic studies of ASD have generally focused on multiple small kindreds, searching for de novo variants of major effect. We hypothesized that molecular genetic analysis of large multiplex families would enable the identification of variants of milder effects. We studied a large multigenerational family of European ancestry with multiple family members affected with ASD or the broader autism phenotype (BAP). We identified a rare heterozygous variant in the gene encoding 1,4-ɑ-glucan branching enzyme 1 (GBE1) that was present in seven of seven individuals with ASD, nine of ten individuals with the BAP, and none of four tested unaffected individuals. We genotyped a community-acquired cohort of 389 individuals with ASD and identified three additional probands. Cascade analysis demonstrated that the variant was present in 11 of 13 individuals with familial ASD/BAP and neither of the two tested unaffected individuals in these three families, also of European ancestry. The variant was not enriched in the combined UK10K ASD cohorts of European ancestry but heterozygous GBE1 deletion was overrepresented in large ASD cohorts, collectively suggesting an association between GBE1 and ASD.     

Fanconi anemia caused by biallelic inactivation of BRCA2 can present with an atypical cancer phenotype in adulthood

Inherited biallelic pathogenic variants (PVs) in BRCA2 cause Fanconi Anemia complementation group D1 (FA-D1), a severe pediatric bone marrow failure and high-risk cancer syndrome. We identified biallelic BRCA2 PVs in a young adult with multiple basal cell carcinomas, adult-onset colorectal cancer and small cell neuroendocrine carcinoma, without bone marrow failure. No PVs were identified in any other known cancer susceptibility gene, and there was no evidence of reversion mosaicism. The proband's deceased sister had a classic FA-D1 presentation and was shown to carry the same biallelic BRCA2 PVs. A lymphoblastoid cell line derived from the proband demonstrated hypersensitivity to DNA damaging agents, and bone marrow showed aberrant RAD51 staining. Family expansion demonstrated the presence of BRCA2 related cancers in heterozygous family members. Our data highlight the striking phenotypic differences which can be observed within FA-D1 families and expands the clinical spectrum of FA-D1 to include adult presentation with a constellation of solid tumors not previously thought of as characteristic of Fanconi Anemia. Early recognition of this syndrome in a family could prevent further morbidity and mortality by implementation of hereditary breast and ovarian cancer screening and treatment strategies for heterozygous family members.     

Exome sequencing identifies ZFPM2 as a cause of familial isolated congenital diaphragmatic hernia and possibly cardiovascular malformations

Using exome sequencing we identify a heterozygous nonsense mutation in ZFPM2 as a cause of familial isolated congenital diaphragmatic hernia in 2 affected siblings. This mutation displays variable phenotypic expression being present in a third sibling with a mild diaphragmatic eventration and a cardiovascular malformation. The same variant is seen in 2 additional family members, both of whom are asymptomatic, thus highlighting that ZFPM2 haploinsufficiency is associated with reduced penetrance. Our finding adds further evidence for ZFPM2 having a role in diaphragm and cardiovascular development.