Impact of Palliative Care Utilization for Surgical Patients Receiving Prolonged Mechanical Ventilation: National Trends (2009–2013)

BackgroundPatients requiring mechanical ventilation (MV) have high morbidity and mortality. Providing palliative care has been suggested as a way to improve comprehensive management. The objective of this retrospective cross-sectional study was to identify predictors for palliative care utilization and the association with hospital length of stay (LOS) among surgical patients requiring prolonged MV (≥ 96 consecutive hours).MethodsNational Inpatient Sample (NIS) data 2009–2013 was used to identify adults (age ≥ 18) who had a surgical procedure and required prolonged MV (≥ 96 consecutive hours), as well as patients who also had a palliative care encounter. Outcomes were palliative care utilization and association with hospital LOS.ResultsUtilization of palliative care among surgical patients with prolonged MV increased yearly, from 5.7% in 2009 to 11.0% in 2013 (p < 0.001). For prolonged MV surgical patients who died, palliative care increased from 15.8% in 2009 to 33.2% in 2013 (p < 0.001). Median hospital LOS for patients with and without palliative care was 16 and 18 days, respectively (p < 0.001). Patients discharged to either short or long term care facilities had a shorter LOS if palliative care was provided (20 vs. 24 days, p < 0.001). Factors associated with palliative care utilization included older age, malignancy, and teaching hospitals. Non-Caucasian race was associated with less palliative care utilization.ConclusionsAmong surgical patients receiving prolonged MV, palliative care utilization is increasing, although it remains low. Palliative care is associated with shorter hospital LOS for patients discharged to short or long term care facilities.     

临终关怀服务机构住院费用分析与探讨

目的临终关怀服务的医疗机构入院患者的费用情况,也为政策制定提供依据。方法分析2005～2008年已注册临终关怀服务科目的医疗机构的住院费用变化趋势和未注册临终关怀服务科目的医疗机构住院费用变化趋势;同时对4年来两种机构的住院费用进行方差分析和卡方分析。结果已注册临终关怀服务科目的医疗机构的日医疗费和日均药费呈逐年上升趋势;与未注册临终关怀项目的机构在住院费用上的区别存在显著差异（P〈0．05）,而两种机构人均药费所占比例无显著差别（P〉0．05）。结论临终关怀服务项目内容需要进一步完善,服务标准需要进一步规范。     

The business of palliative medicine--part 4: Potential impact of an acute-care palliative medicine inpatient unit in a tertiary care cancer center

In this study, a hematology/oncology computerized discharge database was qualitatively and quantitatively reviewed using an empirical methodology. The goal was to identify potential patients for admission to a planned acute-care, palliative medicine inpatient unit. Patients were identified by the International Classifications of Disease (ICD-9) codes. A large heterogenous population, comprising up to 40 percent of annual discharges from the Hematology/Oncology service, was identified. If management decided to add an acute-care, palliative medicine unit to the hospital, these are the patients who would benefit. The study predicted a significant change in patient profile, acuity, complexity, and resource utilization in current palliative care services. This study technique predicted the actual clinical load of the acute-care unit when it opened and was very helpful in program development. Our model predicted that 695 patients would be admitted to the acute-care palliative medicine unit in the first year of operation; 655 patients were actually admitted during this time.     

A day in the life: a case series of acute care palliative medicine--the Cleveland model

Palliative care in advanced disease is complex. Knowledge and experience of symptom control and management of multiple complications are essential. An interdisciplinary team is also required to meet the medical and psychosocial needs in life-limiting illness. Acute care palliative medicine is a new concept in the spectrum of palliative care services. Acute care palliative medicine, integrated into a tertiary academic medical center, provides expert medical management and specialized care as part of the spectrum of acute medical care services to this challenging patient population. The authors describe a case series to provide a snapshot of a typical day in an acute care inpatient palliative medicine unit. The cases illustrate the sophisticated medical care involved for each individual and the important skill sets of the palliative medicine specialist required to provide high-quality acute medical care for the very ill.     

Palliativversorgung im Blickwinkel gesetzlicher und regulatorischer Vorgaben in Deutschland

In Germany, palliative care has developed rapidly since the establishment of the first palliative care unit in 1983. More improvements in patient-centered care are only possible if legal requirements as well as education of physicians, nurses, and other professionals involved in palliative care are adapted to current needs. This paper provides an overview of legal and regulatory requirements including a critical appreciation of their influence on palliative care in Germany. Only recently has medical education in palliative medicine been implemented as an integral part of medical studies at German universities. Starting in 2014, physicians applying for a license to practice medicine will have to provide a certificate of basic training in this field. The challenge in upcoming years will be the establishment and enhancement of comprehensive, standardized, and quality-controlled education at the universities. Only six universities have established chairs for palliative medicine, and it will be essential to not only establish more chairs but also to involve medical students in the development of the education. Only minimal requirements are specified for education of nurses in palliative care in the legislation. However, standardized and quality-controlled advanced training courses are available. This training is frequently requested as a prerequisite for nurses working in palliative care. Only limited education programs exist for other professional groups that are an important part of the palliative care team. In addition to the development of palliative care for inpatients with an increasing number of palliative care units, hospices, and first chairs of palliative medicine, different forms of ambulant palliative care services have been developed. Changes in the legislation have influenced the situation for home care enormously in the last 5?years, also making it more complex. With the Law for the Consolidation of the Competition in Compulsory Health Insurance ("Gesetz zur St?rkung des Wettbewerbs in der gesetzlichen Krankenversicherung"), a legal claim for palliative home care has been implemented in the fifth book of the social law in 2007. The ambitious goal of full coverage with comprehensive palliative home care has still not been achieved in most locations. However, after initial negotiation difficulties between palliative care providers and health insurance funds, an increasing number of contracts have been made. As a consequence-in addition to more than 240 palliative care units in Germany-more than one hundred palliative care teams have begun work in the field of specialized palliative home care. Legal regulations for the supply of opioids and other medications for the treatment of patients at home have been adapted recently, thus, facilitating fast and comprehensive medical treatment in emergency situations. Overall, the legislation has been adapted significantly, hence, contributing to improvements for patients requiring palliative care. It remains to be seen whether additional adjustments are required in the future.     

Palliative Care Utilization Among Non-Western Migrants in Europe: A Systematic Review

The paper aims to identify and describe the European evidence on opportunities and barriers to access and utilization of palliative care among non- western migrants. A systematic review in accordance with PRISMA guidelines was conducted in June 2020, searching Medline, CINAHL, PsychINFO and EMBASE databases. PROSPERO# CRD42020193651. Studies included empirical research published between 2011 and 2020. Search words were, for example, ethnic groups and palliative care. Thematic analysis was used to analyze data. Twenty nine qualitative and six quantitative studies were included. Four main themes were identified: communication and language; knowledge and awareness; patient preferences, cultural and religious issues; and lack of resources at different levels of palliative care service provision. Migrants’ access to palliative care is impeded at system, community and individual levels, yet, recommendations are mostly at the individual level. Closer attention is required to these different levels when designing future palliative interventions for migrants.

     

The business of palliative medicine--Part 3: The development of a palliative medicine program in an academic medical center

Palliative medicine is the total continuing care of patients with cancer. Most resources for cancer care focus on curative attempts while often ignoring the symptoms created by the disease and its treatment. Attempts at curative treatment of the malignancy must be coupled with pain and symptom relief psychosocial and spiritual care, and support for the patient and family extending from the time of diagnosis through the bereavement period. To accomplish this important goal, we must establish comprehensive palliative medicine programs in cancer centers throughout the world. These programs must include education, research, and patient care and must work through an interdisciplinary team. The Cleveland Clinic Foundation palliative medicine program (PMP) is composed of a primary inpatient service, consult service, outpatient clinic, hospice homecare, and cancer homecare services. In this article, we describe the structure and development of the program and suggest future avenues for growth.     

How do patients with cancer pain view community pharmacy services? An interview study

Pain experienced by many patients with advanced cancer is often not well controlled and community pharmacists are potentially well placed to provide support. The study objective was to explore the views and experiences of patients with advanced cancer about community pharmacies, their services and attitudes towards having a community pharmacist pain medicines consultation. Purposive sampling of GP clinical information systems was used to recruit patients with advanced cancer, living in the community and receiving opioid analgesics in one area of England, UK between January 2015 and July 2016. Thirteen patients had a semi‐structured interview which was audio‐recorded and transcribed verbatim. Data were analysed deductively and inductively using Framework analysis and incorporating new themes as they emerged. The framework comprised Pain management, Experiences and expectations, Access to care and Communication. All patients reported using one regular community pharmacy citing convenience, service and staff friendliness as influential factors. The idea of a community pharmacy medicines consultation was acceptable to most patients. The idea of telephone consultations was positively received but electronic media such as Skype was not feasible or acceptable for most. Patients perceived a hierarchy of health professionals with specialist palliative care nurses at the top (due to their combined knowledge of their condition and medicines) followed by GPs then pharmacists. Patients receiving specialist palliative care described pain that was better controlled than those who were not. They thought medicines consultations with a pharmacist could be useful for patients before referral for palliative care. There is a need for pain medicines support for patients with advanced cancer, and unmet need appears greater for those not under the care of specialist services. Medicines consultations, in principle, are acceptable to patients both in person and by telephone, and the latter was perceived to be of particular benefit to patients less able to leave the house.     

Wagga Wagga specialist outreach palliative medicine service: a report on the first 12 months of service

OBJECTIVE: This paper reports on and discusses the development of a visiting palliative medicine specialist outreach service for Wagga Wagga New South Wales, Australia, and presents initial data and three case vignettes for reflection. The visiting doctor was flown from Sydney each fortnight for a day and integrated with the local nursing based palliative care team. METHODS: Demographic data was collected over the initial 12 months of service, which included the location of the consult (hospital, home, nursing home), whom the consult was from (specialist, GP), age of the patient, location of death, type of cancer, as well as the complexity of consultation from the perspective of one of the authors. RESULTS: The majority of referrals were for advice on cancer pain control (62.3%) and other symptoms (26.7%) confirming the expectation. Those patients referred were considered appropriate, with over 75% having a palliative care issue that was considered appropriate for direct patient contact by the specialist in palliative medicine. CONCLUSIONS: The provision of a visiting palliative medicine specialist to rural areas has been developed over the last few years in New South Wales and the reporting of the success of this particular service aims to provide evidence for the need and the development of further services, as it is expected that this service would continue but with an increasing number of referrals as the service became increasingly known.     

Palliative care: community nurses' perceptions of quality

OBJECTIVES: To identify community nurses' perceptions of quality care provision for patients requiring palliative care. DESIGN: Semi-structured interviews were conducted with community nurses working within the district nursing service. An adaptation of Flanagan's critical incident technique was employed to elicit factors associated with high or poor quality palliative care. Interviews were tape recorded and transcribed. Data were analysed using thematic content analysis, recurrent themes being agreed by the research team. SETTING: One community healthcare trust. SUBJECTS: 62 members of the district nursing team (grades B-H). RESULTS: Respondents recounted the context in which high quality palliative care could be provided, the actions required, and the indicators that suggested the desired level of care had been achieved. Key factors identified were: the early referral of patients to the district nursing service, family circumstances, the availability of time, the accessibility of services and equipment, and the relationship with other healthcare professionals and informal carers. There was a general view that a positive outcome had been achieved when patients retained control over their circumstances and died a peaceful death, in the place of their choice, supported by their family. CONCLUSIONS: Community nurses were able to articulate clearly the essential components of high quality care. Whilst these factors do not represent a comprehensive list, they are put forward as a useful starting point for standard setting and subsequent audit.     

Acute inpatient palliative medicine in a cancer center: clinical problems and medical interventions--a prospective study

The clinical characteristics and medical interventions of the 100 consecutive cancer admissions to the acute care inpatient palliative medicine unit at the Cleveland Clinic for 2 months are described. Median age was 62 years (range, 31 to 92 years). The male-female ratio was 1:1. Most admissions were referred by hematology-oncology and had prior antineoplastic therapy. Reasons for admission were symptom control and cancer-related complications. Patients underwent invasive diagnostic and therapeutic procedures, hydration, transfusions, radiation, or chemotherapy, or a combination, during their admission. Most were discharged home with hospice care or had outpatient clinic follow-up. The mortality rate was 20%. Aggressive multidisciplinary management of symptoms, disease complications, comorbid conditions, and psychosocial problems were provided. Palliative medicine physicians provided continuity of care in the outpatient clinic and at home. An acute inpatient palliative medicine unit within a tertiary level medical center has a definable and important role in comprehensive cancer care.     

Communication in palliative medicine: a pilot study of a problem list to capture complex medical information

We developed a one-page, structured problem list to facilitate communication of complex patient information in palliative medicine. The problem list was developed to provide a concise record of the complex problems presented by patients with advanced disease. It was also seen as a mechanism to facilitate interdisciplinary and multidisciplinary communication and continuity of care in the hospital and in the community. One hundred consecutive patients, who were newly referred to our palliative medicine program, were prospectively surveyed to gain clinical experience with the problem list. Ninety patients had cancer diagnoses. The median age was 69 (range 20-90 years), the male to female ratio was 2:1, and the median Eastern Cooperative Oncology Group (ECOG) performance status was 3 (range 0-4). The population was 78 percent Caucasian. The median number of symptoms per patient was 5 (range 0-13), which was similar for cancer and noncancer patients. Overall, gastrointestinal symptoms and pain were the most common symptoms. Pain was more common in cancer patients, and respiratory problems were the most common among noncancer patients. Noncancer patients had better performance status. Based on this experience, we believe a problem list facilitates succinct communication of complex patient information essential to optimal patient care. Proposed modifications are discussed.     

姑息关怀服务模式对癌症晚期患者生命质量的影响研究

目的 评估姑息关怀服务对癌症晚期患者生命质量的影响并提出管理建议。方法 采用问卷调查的方式对H医院接受姑息关怀治疗和常规抗癌治疗的248名癌症晚期住院患者的生命质量进行调查。选取中国癌症患者生命质量量表对癌症晚期患者的生命质量进行评估,然后通过统计分析探讨不同治疗方式下患者生命质量的差异。结果 癌症晚期患者生命质量普遍较差(36.38±4.82),其中躯体症状得分最低,依次是精神心理和社会关系。接受姑息关怀后患者生命质量及各指标得分均有显著提高。治疗前生命质量更差、疼痛程度更高的姑息关怀组患者,其治疗后的生命质量评分与常规抗癌组患者相比无显著差异,疼痛程度更是低于常规抗癌组。两组治疗方式下患者生命质量治疗前后的差值对比(6.82±2.71 vs 2.53±2.95),姑息关怀组的改善效果更明显(t=11.908,P<0.05)。结论 姑息关怀治疗相对于常规抗癌治疗,对癌症晚期患者生命质量的改善效果更为显著,应加强对以价值为核心的姑息关怀服务模式的宣传和推广。     

The Harry R. Horvitz Center for Palliative Medicine (1987-1999): development of a novel comprehensive integrated program

The Cleveland Clinic is a large multispecialty group practice. The need for a palliative care program was identified and the program started in 1987. A key concept has been that the existing structure of hospice care as defined by Medicare is insufficient to address the needs of patients with incurable disease. The field of palliative medicine implies physician expertise in several key areas: (1) communication; (2) decision-making; (3) management of complications; (4) symptom control; (5) care of the dying; and (6) psychosocial care. The development of the program (the first in the United States) since 1987 has put in place the following major services, listed consecutively: (1) hospital consultation service; (2) outpatient clinics; (3) acute care inpatient service; (4) hospice and home care service; (5) acute-care palliative medicine inpatient unit; and (6) hospice inpatient facility. Program development has meant that a new program has been introduced approximately every 18 months since the start of the program. This has considerable implications for staffing, the management of change, and competition for scarce resources within a contracting health care budget. The staffing of the program has focused on developing specialized attending physicians using a multidisciplinary approach dedicated to enhancing the role of nursing in the field. The major budgeted areas are (1) the acute-care palliative medicine unit, and (2) the hospice and home care service. Specific commitment has been made to research and education because of the desire to develop an intellectual basis for the practice of palliative medicine. This requires structured activities in both areas with a systematic approach to research and education. The complexity of developing a service should not be underestimated. There has been consistent support for the program by senior leadership within the Cleveland Clinic Foundation, including the cancer center. The major lessons learned during program development have been: (1) to focus on quality of patient care; (2) to commit to academic endeavor in research and education; (3) to secure institutional commitment to program development; (4) to establish a positive, proactive, businesslike approach; (5) to defend budget and personnel, albeit within a difficult time in health care; and (6) to commit to success, i.e., never promise anything on which you do not deliver. The future development of post-acute-care services serving predominantly the chronically ill elderly population suggest an expanded administrative and conceptual role for the future development of palliative medicine to help serve the needs of the aging population in the United States.     

The Impact of Palliative Medicine Consultation on Readmission Rates and Hospital Costs in Surgical Patients Requiring Prolonged Mechanical Ventilation

BackgroundThe use of palliative care for critically ill hospitalized patients has expanded. However, it is still underutilized in surgical specialties. Postsurgical patients requiring prolonged mechanical ventilation have increased mortality and costs of care; outcomes from adding palliative care services to this population have been poorly investigated. The objective of this study was to determine the impact of palliative medicine consultation on readmission rates and hospitalization costs in postsurgical patients requiring prolonged mechanical ventilation.MethodsThe Nationwide Readmissions Database was queried for adults (> 18 years) between the years 2010 and 2014 who underwent a major operation (Healthcare Cost and Utilization Project [HCUP] data element ORPROC = 1), required mechanical ventilation for ≥ 96 consecutive hours (ICD-9-CM V46.1), and survived until discharge. Among these, patients who received a palliative medicine consultation during hospitalization were identified using the ICD-9-CM diagnosis code V66.7.ResultsOf 53,450 included patients, 3.4% received a palliative care consultation. Compared to patients who did not receive a palliative care consultation, patients who did receive a consultation had a lower readmission rate (14.8% vs. 24.8%, p < 0.001) and lower average cost of hospitalization during the initial admission ($109,007 vs. $124,218, p < 0.001), findings that persisted after multivariable logistic regression.ConclusionUtilization of palliative care in surgical patients remains low. Palliative care consultation in postsurgical patients requiring prolonged mechanical ventilation was associated with lower cost and rate of readmission. Further work is needed to integrate palliative care services with surgical care.     

A syllabus for fellowship education in palliative medicine

Recent years have seen significant growth in palliative medicine training programs and positions. There are plans to pursue palliative medicine specialty status with the American Board of Medical Specialties and accreditation of fellowship programs with the American College of Graduate Medical Education. A work group of program directors, supported initially by the Cleveland Clinic and then by the American Board of Hospice and Palliative Medicine, has recently published standards for fellowship training. Despite this, fundamental questions remain about defining the field and delineating the knowledge and skills expected following completion of specialty training. In this article, we describe the first fellowship program in palliative medicine (PMP) in the United States, developed and supported by the Cleveland Clinic Foundation. The program has been implemented as part of the Harry R. Horvitz Center for Palliative Medicine, founded in 1987 as the first comprehensive integrated US program in this field. This training program, in existence since 1989, features a traditional rotational structure with an inpatient primary care service, inpatient consult services, and an outpatient consult/hospice service. This article outlines the syllabus developed for this fellowship, given what we believe to be the essential knowledge base for the field of palliative medicine.     

恶性疾患晚期姑息照护中潜在的法律问题

对晚期恶性疾病患者进行护理的郑重点不是疾病的根治，而在于提高服务对象尚存在的生命质量，维护其人格尊严，使其在生命的最后历程中，安详地面对死亡，在病人入院至出院或死亡的全过程中，在姑息照护的每一个环蒸上，均有可能涉及到各种各样的潜在的法律问题。现在，卫生法规日益健全，医疗纠纷裁决程序越来越法制化，病人作为消费者，自我保护意识和法律意识也日益增加，护理人员应该认真学法，促使自己自觉地在工作中约束自己的行为，尽职尽责地为晚期患者服务，避免不必要的医疗纠纷。     

Organizational and methodological issues in the development of palliative care for oncological patients

The share of patients, who apply to oncology facilities with advanced pathologies, shapes up a new situation for oncologists: the sphere of palliative care of both managerial and methodological types must be promoted. Thus, 451299 patients with malignant neoplasms, including those with wide-spread forms (i.e. stages III-IV: 59.1%), were registered in Russia in 2001. One hundred and thirty structural subunits of palliative care were set up in Russia's regions for today; another 58 are being established: however, none of them could be referred to as a perfect one because the role and functions have not yet been defined for palliative care, while all subject-related publications are isolated and scanty. The functioning of hospices and palliative-care subunits is not as a rule coordinated with the oncology service or with oncology experts. This problem should be resolved through setting up the palliative-care regional systems with the role and functions of palliative care being specified for them on the basis of the existing oncology institutes, hospitals and other patient-care facilities. This would maintain the continuity of medical care rendered to oncology patients at all disease stages.