Nontransgenic hyperexpression of a complement regulator in donor kidney modulates transplant ischemia/reperfusion damage, acute rejection, and chronic nephropathy

Complement activation during ischemia and reperfusion contributes to the development of tissue injury with severe negative impact on outcomes in transplantation. To counter the effect of complement, we present a strategy to deliver a novel complement regulator stabilized on cell surfaces within donor organs. The membrane-bound complement regulator is able to inhibit complement activation when the donor organ is revascularized and exposed to host-circulating complement. Application of this construct to donor kidneys protected transplanted tissues from ischemia/reperfusion injury and reduced the deposition of activated complement and histological signs of damage under conditions in which a nontargeted control construct was ineffective. Treatment of donor organs in this way improved graft performance in the short and long term. An analysis of the immune response in allograft recipients showed that reducing graft damage at the time of transplantation through complement regulation also modulated the alloresponse. Additionally, the results of perfusion studies with human kidneys demonstrated the feasibility of targeting endothelial and epithelial surfaces with this construct, to allow investigation in clinical transplantation.     

Complement-mediated inflammation and injury in brain dead organ donors

The importance of the complement system in renal ischemia-reperfusion injury and acute rejection is widely recognized, however its contribution to the pathogenesis of tissue damage in the donor remains underexposed. Brain-dead (BD) organ donors are still the primary source of organs for transplantation. Brain death is characterized by hemodynamic changes, hormonal dysregulation, and immunological activation. Recently, the complement system has been shown to be involved. In BD organ donors, complement is activated systemically and locally and is an important mediator of inflammation and graft injury. Furthermore, complement activation can be used as a clinical marker for the prediction of graft function after transplantation. Experimental models of BD have shown that inhibition of the complement cascade is a successful method to reduce inflammation and injury of donor grafts, thereby improving graft function and survival after transplantation. Consequently, complement-targeted therapeutics in BD organ donors form a new opportunity to improve organ quality for transplantation. Future studies should further elucidate the mechanism responsible for complement activation in BD organ donors.     

Xenotransplantation: how to overcome the complement obstacle?

The xenotransplantation research is driven by the shortage of allografts for transplantation of patients with end-stage organ failure and by lack of success in developing suitable artificial organs. Pigs are now generally accepted to be the donor species of choice, although a possible risk for transmission of xenozoonoses, particularly pig endogenous retroviruses, should be born in mind. A vascular xenograft from pig to human is usually rejected hyperacutely due to naturally occurring antibodies and complement. This hyperacute rejection can be prevented by manipulating with either of these systems. In this review we briefly describe the hyperacute rejection and how it can be prevented by complement modulation. Pigs made transgenic for human complement regulatory proteins seem very promising for future clinical experiments. Control of fluid-phase complement activation should be obtained as well. The latter is discussed based on our own recent studies in this field.     

Reduced graft-versus-host disease in C3-deficient mice is associated with decreased donor Th1/Th17 differentiation

Graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) after allogeneic hematopoietic stem cell transplantation is mediated by the activation of recipient dendritic cells and subsequent proliferation of donor T cells. The complement system was recently shown to modulate adaptive immunity through an interaction of the complement system and lymphocytes. Complement proteins participate in the activation of dendritic cells, antigen presentation to T cells, and proliferation of T cells. Our studies with a murine model of bone marrow transplantation demonstrate that complement system regulates alloimmune responses in GVHD. Mice deficient in the central component of the complement system (C3(-/-)) had significantly lower GVHD-related mortality and morbidity compared with wild-type recipient mice. The numbers of donor-derived T cells, including IFN-γ(+), IL-17(+), and IL-17(+)IFN-γ(+) subsets, were decreased in secondary lymphoid organs of C3(-/-) recipients. Furthermore, the number of recipient CD8α(+)CD11c(+) cells in lymphoid organs was reduced. We conclude that C3 regulates Th1/17 differentiation in bone marrow transplantation, and define a novel function of the complement system in GVHD.     

Role of complement in xenotransplantation

The xenotransplantation research is driven by the increasing gap between the number of patients with end-stage organ failure on waiting lists for transplantation and the supply of allografts. The lack of success in developing suitable artificial organs for permanent treatment of organ failure has further strengthened the need for xenotransplantation research. Pigs are now generally accepted to be the source animal of choice. Transplantation of pig organs to humans faces several barriers which have to be overcome before it comes to clinical application: (1) anatomical and physiological conditions; (2) immunological rejection mechanisms; (3) molecular compatibility between signal molecules of the two species; (4) risk of transmission of microorganisms, particularly pig endogenous retroviruses; and (5) legal and ethical aspects both with respect to the animal and the recipient. Here we will focus on the role of the complement system in the rejection of immediately vascularized pig-to-primate xenografts. The hyperacute rejection occurring within minutes after transplantation is mediated by binding of natural antibodies to the Galα(l-3)Gal epitope on the endothelial cells with subsequent complement activation. Whereas inhibition of complement activation protects against hyperacute rejection, the role of complement in the later rejection phases is less clarified.     

Immobilization of soluble complement receptor 1 on islets

Transplantation of pancreatic islets of Langerhans (islets) is a promising method to treat insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus. Control of complement activation is necessary to improve graft survival in alloislet and xenoislet transplantation. In this study, human soluble complement receptor 1 (sCR1) was immobilized on the islet cell surface through poly(ethylene glycol)-conjugated phospholipid (PEG-lipid) without loss of islet cell viability or insulin secretion ability. sCR1 on islets effectively inhibits complement activation and protects islets against attack by xenoreactive antibodies and complement. This method will be an efficient means to control early islet loss in clinical islet transplantation and realize xenoislet transplantation in the future.     

Molecular cloning of a pig homologue of membrane cofactor protein (CD46)

Organs of transgenic pigs that express human complement regulatory proteins are under assessment as an alternative to transplantation. A major barrier to the transplantation of pig organs is the hyperacute rejection caused by pre-existing antibodies and complement. Pig cells are very susceptible to human complement, presumably because pig cell- surface complement regulatory proteins are inefficient against it. Expression of human complement regulatory proteins, such as decay- accelerating factor and membrane cofactor proteins (MCP or CD46), by means of transgenes would confer resistance to human complement upon pig cells, thereby preventing hyperacute rejection. To express sufficient levels of human complement regulatory proteins at appropriate sites, regulatory elements of genes of pig membrane-bound complement regulatory proteins would be useful. To obtain their cDNAs, we transfected human cells with a pig cDNA library, selected cells by incubation with pig complement and rescued the plasmids. We cloned a cDNA for the pig homologue of MCP, pMCP. The cDNA encoded a predicted protein of 363 amino acids with 42% amino acid identity with human MCP. The pMCP consisted of four short consensus repeats, a Ser/Thr/Pro-rich domain, and transmembrane and cytoplasmic domains. Recombinant soluble pMCP that lacked transmembrane and cytoplasmic domains had factor I cofactor activity in C3b cleavage, indicating that it is functionally, as well as structurally homologous to MCP. FACS analysis with anti-pMCP mAb demonstrated that pMCP is expressed on all blood leukocytes, erythrocytes, and on endothelial and epithelial cell lines.      

Clinical xenotransplantation]

The growing numerical gap between the number of patients and available human donor organs have led to a revival interest in xenotransplantation. This review will mainly focus on the clinical affairs of xenotransplantation and the project of producing the gene modified pigs. Trials, designed to overcome xenogenic rejection by the expression of human complement regulatory protein (CRP), such as DAF (CD55), on the pig organ and knocking out the alpha-Gal epitope(Galalpha1-3Galbeta1-4GlcNAc-R), which is biosynthesized by the action of alpha1,3 galactosyltransferase (alpha1,3GT), were accomplished in several institutes, such as Harvard University, Pittsburgh University, Mayo Clinic, and BresaGen. We have also produced the [DAF(CD55)+GnT-III+alpha-Gal KO] pigs in last year. On the other hand, the clinical pig islets transplantation was done in many countries, such as Russia, Sweden, Mexico and China, until 2005. In addition, the new clinical trials of pig islets transplantation will be started in USA within three years. In addition, as the current studies in the xenotransplantation field, the strategies for the downregulation of the glycoantigen, complement activation, NK cell, and other immuno responces on the xenografts, are reviewed. The studies for the infectivity of porcine endogenous retrovirus (PERV) to human cells are also introduced.     

Kidney Injury in Murine Models of Hematopoietic Stem Cell Transplantation

Acute graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) affects different organs, including the skin, liver, and gastrointestinal tract. Although kidneys are not among the organs commonly known to be the target of acute GVHD, kidney damage is frequently reported after allogeneic hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (allo-HSCT). We have studied the effect of bone marrow transplantation (BMT) on the kidneys in different murine models of GVHD. We found that glomerular damage in the kidneys is a common pathological finding in mice after BMT. The histopathological features of glomeruli damage included mesengiolysis, mesangial proliferation and edema, subendothelial and endothelial thickening, splitting of capillary walls in glomeruli, narrowing and collapsing of capillary lumens, fibrinoid necrosis of afferent arterioles, intimal hyperplasia, and microthrombi. These pathological features are similar to those detected in kidneys of patients with thrombotic microangiopathy (TMA) after allo-HSCT. We previously showed that activation of the complement system plays a role in GVHD-induced tissue injury in mice. Here we report the presence of complement activation products in the kidney specimens of mice after BMT. We also report that complement deficiency reduced the extent and severity of post-BMT glomerular damage in mice. We conclude that BMT in mice is associated with glomerular injury and tubulointerstitial nephritis, and that kidney damage is at least partially mediated by activation of the complement system.     

Presence of Human Chromosome 1 with Expression of Human Decay-Accelerating Factor (DAF) Prevents Lysis of Mouse/Human Hybrid Cells by Human Complement

Xenogeneic organs transplanted to phylogenetically distant species are subject to rapid destruction mediated by complement. In humans, the complement activation is regulated by several proteins encoded by a series of closely linked genes (RCA locus) located on chromosome 1. The mouse/human hybrid cell line B10 was found to have retained human chromosome 1. FACS analysis confirmed that RCA products such as decay-accelerating factor (DAF) were expressed on the membrane surface of B10 cells. When exposed to human or rabbit complement in the presence of 'naturally occurring' human anti-mouse antibodies these cells were not lysed by human complement but were killed by rabbit complement. This effect could be abrogated by addition of anti-DAF monoclonal antibody (IC6). The results offer potential for genetic manipulation of the human complement regulatory products in animals to overcome xenograft hyperacute rejection.     

Perspectives on complement in xenotransplantation

The crucial role of complement and naturally occurring anti-Gal antibodies in hyperacute rejection of pig transplants to Old World monkeys, apes and humans is well established. This rejection can be prevented by manipulating either system. Although cells, tissues or organs from pigs made transgenic for human complement regulatory proteins escape hyperacute rejection, there is an increasing evidence of a role for complement also in the subsequent acute vascular or delayed xenograft rejection. Furthermore, complement contributes in a general manner to ischemia-reperfusion injury (IRI), irrespective of the organ source. Early complement-mediated endothelial cell activation, although not sufficient to induce hyperacute rejection, may contribute to reduced long-time graft performance. Control of fluid-phase complement activation by soluble complement inhibitors might be an important adjuvant to transgenic organs from the time of organ harvesting through the first post-transplant period. Pharmacologic manipulation of complement is a field in expansion, though still in its infancy. Although an optimal transgenic and cloned pig may be close to reality, the role of complement in xenotransplantation needs to be fully elucidated and a treatment regimen for fluid-phase inhibition is warranted. The story of complement in xenotransplantation is not completed but under continuous revision.     

Low molecular weight dextran sulfate as complement inhibitor and cytoprotectant in solid organ and islet transplantation

Complement is an essential part of the innate immune system and plays a crucial role in organ and islet transplantation. Its activation, triggered for example by ischemia/reperfusion (I/R), significantly influences graft survival, and blocking of complement by inhibitors has been shown to attenuate I/R injury. Another player of innate immunity are the dendritic cells (DC), which form an important link between innate and adaptive immunity. DC are relevant in the induction of an immune response as well as in the maintenance of tolerance. Modulation or inhibition of both components, complement and DC, may be crucial to improve the clinical outcome of solid organ as well as islet transplantation. Low molecular weight dextran sulfate (DXS), a well-known complement inhibitor, has been shown to prevent complement-mediated damage of the donor graft endothelium and is thus acting as an endothelial protectant. In this review we will discuss the evidence for this cytoprotective effect of DXS and also highlight recent data which show that DXS inhibits the maturation of human DC. Taken together the available data suggest that DXS may be a useful reagent to prevent the activation of innate immunity, both in solid organ and islet transplantation.     

Low molecular weight dextran sulfate as complement inhibitor and cytoprotectant in solid organ and islet transplantation

Complement is an essential part of the innate immune system and plays a crucial role in organ and islet transplantation. Its activation, triggered for example by ischemia/reperfusion (I/R), significantly influences graft survival, and blocking of complement by inhibitors has been shown to attenuate I/R injury. Another player of innate immunity are the dendritic cells (DC), which form an important link between innate and adaptive immunity. DC are relevant in the induction of an immune response as well as in the maintenance of tolerance. Modulation or inhibition of both components, complement and DC, may be crucial to improve the clinical outcome of solid organ as well as islet transplantation. Low molecular weight dextran sulfate (DXS), a well-known complement inhibitor, has been shown to prevent complement-mediated damage of the donor graft endothelium and is thus acting as an endothelial protectant. In this review we will discuss the evidence for this cytoprotective effect of DXS and also highlight recent data which show that DXS inhibits the maturation of human DC. Taken together the available data suggest that DXS may be a useful reagent to prevent the activation of innate immunity, both in solid organ and islet transplantation.     

The role of complement in transplantation

The complement system contributes critically to the barrier to transplantation of cells and organs. In the case of tissues and organs transplanted between individuals of the same species, that is in allotransplantation, the barrier posed by complement is seemingly eclipsed by the barrier posed by cellular immune responses. In the case of cells and organs transplanted between individuals of disparate species, that is xenotransplantation, the complement system has been thought to pose a nearly insurmountable barrier. With our understanding on how the complement system contributes to rejection, it is now clear that the complement system is more important in allotransplantation and more forgiving in xenotransplantation than was previously thought.     

Complement activation and regulator expression after anoxic injury of human endothelial cells

Complement activation is involved in the ischemia-reperfusion injury of various organs, but the mechanisms leading to activation of the complement system are incompletely understood. In this study we show that EA.hy 926 human endothelial cells cultured under anoxic conditions (24 or 48 h) become activators of the homologous complement system. Flow cytometric analysis indicated that C1q, C3c, C3d, C4, C5, C9 components of complement are deposited on anoxic but not on normoxic cells after incubation with normal human serum. Cell membrane-associated regulators of complement, membrane cofactor protein (CD46), decay-accelerating factor (CD55) and protectin (CD59) were expressed on EA.hy 926 cells grown under normal oxygen tension. Under anoxic conditions the expression of protectin was clearly decreased, whereas the expression of CD46 and CD55 diminished only slightly. Our results suggest that anoxia can convert human endothelial cells to activators of the complement system. The diminished expression of protectin, CD46 and CD55 can sensitize the cells to complement-mediated damage. Activation of the complement system due to the anoxic injury of human endothelial cells might be an important triggering mechanism in the pathogenesis of ischemia-reperfusion injury of human heart.     

Complement in transplant rejection: diagnostic and mechanistic considerations

After decades of neglect, complement has been rediscovered as a potent mediator and diagnostic indicator of inflammation and rejection in organ transplants. In part, this reflects a better understanding of the biology of complement, but it also reflects changes in clinical practice. The relevance of complement to clinical transplantation has increased as access to transplantation continues to be extended. Extended criteria for organ donors include older donors and non-heart beating donors. Simultaneously, the criteria for recipients have been extended to include more presensitized and blood group incompatible recipients. All of these variables can increase complement activation. As a result, several components of complement have received attention as potential diagnostic tools, and, with more sophisticated reagents, evidence of complement activation has been found in larger numbers of biopsy samples. Understanding the biology of complement is important to appreciate fully the diagnostic and mechanistic implications of complement activation in organ transplants. Mechanistically, a series of effector molecules in the complement cascade mediate proinflammatory functions that can account for chemotaxis and activation of cells of the innate immune system, such as granulocytes and monocytes. Simultaneously, many of these same complement mediators activate and disrupt the endothelial cell interface between the recipient and the transplant. In addition, there is growing appreciation that complement can stimulate B and T lymphocytes of the adaptive immune system. More recent evidence indicates that complement participates in the non-inflammatory clearance of apoptotic cells. Therefore, the complement cascade can be activated by multiple mechanisms and various components of complement can modulate the response to transplants in different directions.     

A membrane cofactor protein transgenic mouse model for the study of discordant xenograft rejection

Background:  In recent years, interest has been revived in the possibility of transplanting organs into humans from a phylogenetically disparate species such as the pig (xenotransplantation). Such discordant xenografts, however, are subject to hyperacute rejection (HAR) and activation of host complement plays a major role in this rejection. This problem may be solved through the use of transgenic technology by providing the grafted tissue with molecules that down-regulate the action of host complement.
Results: Transgenesis with a yeast artificial chromosome (YAC) was used to produce transgenic mice with the complete genomic gene of the human complement regulator membrane cofactor protein (MCP). Transgenic mice were obtained that exhibit full regulation of MCP as normally observed in humans. Hearts from these mice were shown to be significantly protected from HAR caused by human serum in an in vivo experimental procedure.
Conclusions:  We conclude that MCP can protect discordant xenografts from HAR caused by human serum and that transgenic mice can be used effectively as in vivo models for the study of the role of human complement regulatory molecules in xenotransplantation.     

Functional activity of the membrane-associated complement inhibitor CD59 in a pig-to-human in vitro model for hyperacute xenograft rejection.

Hyperacute rejection triggered by activation of the recipient's complement system represents the major barrier to successful xenotransplantation. Transfer of human membrane-associated complement regulators to donor organs has been suggested as one strategy to interfere with complement-mediated hyperacute xenograft rejection. Pigs are discussed as potential organ donors. We therefore investigated a putative protective function of the membrane-bound complement inhibitor CD59 in a pig-to-human in vitro model of hyperacute xenograft rejection. Aortic porcine endothelial cells were transfected with human CD59 cDNA. Expression of human CD59 was demonstrated by cytofluorimetric and RNA analysis. Removal of CD59 from the cell surface by phosphatidylinositol-specific phospholipase C (PI-PLC) demonstrated its production as a glycosyl phosphatidylinositol (GPI)-anchored protein. Functional activity of the transfected CD59 was tested by a lactate dehydrogenase (LDH) release assay for complement-mediated lysis. Porcine endothelial cells expressing human CD59 were significantly protected from lysis by human serum complement compared with CD59- cells. The protective effect was abolished by preincubating the cells with anti-CD59 antibodies or PI-PLC. We calculated by Scatchard analysis that the established CD59+ cell line expressed a CD59 level comparable to that of human endothelial cells. Our results recommend the production of pigs transgenic for CD59.     

Mechanism of complement activation in the hyperacute rejection of porcine organs transplanted into primate recipients.

The authors investigated the importance of natural antibody and complement in the pathogenesis of hyperacute xenograft rejection using in vivo and in vitro pig to primate models. Studies were carried out in rhesus monkeys transplanted with a pig heart or kidney in which hyperacute rejection was observed within a few hours. The rejected organs showed deposits of IgM, C3, C4, C5, and C9 neoantigen along small blood vessels, but few deposits of factors B and P. Removal of anti-endothelial cell "natural" antibodies by plasmapheresis, immunoabsorption, and immunosuppression techniques resulted in marked prolongation of the survival of a subsequently transplanted heart, even when complement levels were within the normal range. Thus, complement, in the absence of natural antibodies, did not initiate hyperacute rejection in this species combination. The requirements for complement activation in human serum to cause cytotoxicity of porcine endothelial cells were then evaluated. Cytotoxicity was abrogated by depleting human serum of IgM, C2, or C5, but not of factor B. Restoration of the effect of serum on endothelial cells was achieved by reconstitution of the respective depleted sera with purified IgM or with the corresponding complement proteins, indicating that IgM and the classical, but not the alternative, pathway of complement, were involved. Identical conclusions were drawn from experiments to ascertain the requirements for complement activation in human serum to mediate binding of iC3b to porcine endothelial cells. The authors conclude that in a pig to primate xenograft complement does not directly initiate injury to the graft but rather requires activation by bound xenoreactive natural antibodies; IgM antibodies directed against endothelial cells activate the classical complement pathway, which then contributes to endothelial cell activation and subsequent events characteristic of hyperacute rejection.     

Layer-by-layer co-immobilization of soluble complement receptor 1 and heparin on islets

Early graft loss due to instant blood-mediated inflammatory reactions (IBMIRs) is a major obstacle of clinical islet transplantation; inhibition of blood coagulation and complement activation is necessary to inhibit IBMIRs. Here, human soluble form complement receptor 1 (sCR1) and heparin were co-immobilized onto the surfaces of islet cells. sCR1 molecules carrying thiol groups were immobilized through maleimide-poly(ethylene glycol)-phospholipids anchored in the lipid bilayers of islet cells. Heparin was immobilized on the sCR1 layer via the affinity between sCR1 and heparin, and additional layers of sCR1 and heparin were formed layer-by-layer. The sCR1 and heparin molecules in these layers maintained anti-complement activation and anti-coagulation activities, respectively. This promising method could be employed to reduce the number of islet cells required to reverse hyperglycemia and prolong graft survival in both allo- and xeno-islet transplantation.