Cell death in the developing retinal ganglion cell layer of the wallaby Setonix brachyurus

The distribution and number of dying cells in the developing retinal ganglion cell layer of the wallaby Setonix brachyurus were assessed by using cresyl violet stained tissue. The density of dying cells has been expressed per 100 live cells for the entire retinal surface, data being presented as a grid of 500 micron squares. For statistical analysis, retinae were divided into 8 regions; dorsal, ventral, nasal, and temporal quadrants, each further divided into center and periphery. This method allowed comparison of the extent of cell death at different retinal locations as the high density area centralis of live cells developed temporal to the optic disk from 60 days onward. Between 30 and 70 days, dying cells were seen across the entire retina; beyond 100 days very few were seen. Initially, there was a significantly higher incidence of dying cells in the central retina compared to the periphery, whereas from 50 days this situation was reversed. Analysis of the central retina before and during area centralis formation consistently indicated a significantly lower number of dying cells per 100 live cells in temporal compared to other retinal quadrants. This differential pattern suggests that cell death lowers live cell densities less in the emerging area centralis than elsewhere, and therefore must play a part in establishing live cell density gradients. However, we cannot exclude the possibility that other factors are also instrumental. Indeed, factors such as areal growth (Beazley et al., in press) presumably operate at later stages since live cell density gradients continue to be accentuated even after cell death is complete. Numbers of dying cells peaked by 50 days, reaching approximately 1% of the live cell population. At this stage, counts were also maximal for live cells with values up to 30% above the adult range.     

Postnatal changes in retinal ganglion cell and optic axon populations in the pigmented rat

The number of ganglion cells in the retina of the postnatal rat has been examined. We estimated both the number of axons in the optic nerve and the number of cells which can be retrogradely labelled with horseradish peroxidase from injections into the brain. In the retina of the newborn rat there are at least twice as many ganglion cells as in the adult rat. By retrograde labelling of the ganglion cells and following transection of their axons 24-48 hrs later we can find no evidence that ganglion cells withdraw their axon without degeneration of the patent cell body. We have found that the excess ganglion cells are lost over the first ten postnatal days and during this period we observe pyknotic nuclei in the ganglion cell layer. From our estimates of the total number of neurones in the ganglion cell layer and the number of ganglion cells found at different ages we conclude that the migration of amacrine cells into the ganglion cell layer occurs in the first five postnatal days.     

Role of cell death in the topogenesis of neuronal distributions in the developing cat retinal ganglion cell layer

The neurons of the developing and adult ganglion cell layer of the cat retina may be morphologically divided into two major populations. One population, the classic neurons, is mainly composed of ganglion cells, and of a small percentage of displaced amacrines, the bar cells. The remaining neurons are microneurons, which make up the majority of the displaced amacrine population. The loss of ganglion cells during the development has been attributed to cell death. It has alternatively been suggested that some ganglion cells may lose their axon and be transformed into displaced amacrine cells, without degeneration of the cell soma. Reexamination of foetal and postnatal cat retinas confirms the presence of degenerating cells in the ganglion cell layer. Their number appears to be at a maximum on embryonic day (E) 57 but declines rapidly until birth. The peak of cell death thus coincides with the decline in optic nerve fibre counts and classical neuron or ganglion cell numbers. Some cells in early stages of degeneration resemble classical neurons, but the original morphology of those advanced stages of degeneration could not be identified, nor was it possible to identify pyknotic microneurons at any stage. Substantial degeneration of the microneurons is not suggested but if it occurs, it is masked by an overall increase in the population of these cells before birth. Cell death in the microneuron population thus cannot yet be ruled out. It has been argued in the literature that fragments of degenerating cells in developing neural tissue are cleared by microglia within 10-14 hours. In order to test the hypothesis that operation of cell death can alone account for the observed loss of classical neurons in the foetal cat retina, we have modelled the effect of various presumed clearance times on corresponding neuronal population magnitudes. It is found that a constant clearance time of 10-24 hours would be consistent with the observed loss of classical neurons before birth. If this is true, then no ganglion cells would remain for transformation into amacrine cells. The absolute density of degenerating or pyknotic cells is found to be relatively constant across the retina. However their density expressed as a percentage of the local population of classical neurons is markedly higher in peripheral than central retina. In the former region, they compose more than 10% of classical neurons at stage E57. On the same day, the percentage distribution maps define an elongated central area containing only 3-5% pyknotic profiles. This region corresponds to the location of the future visual streak.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

Caspase-independent retinal ganglion cell death after target ablation in the neonatal rat

In neonatal rats, superior colliculus (SC) ablation results in a massive and rapid increase in retinal ganglion cell (RGC) death that peaks about 24 h post-lesion (PL). Naturally occurring cell death during normal development, and RGC death after axonal injury in neonatal and adult rats, has primarily been ascribed to apoptosis. Given that normal developmental cell death is reported to involve caspase 3 activation, and blocking caspase activity in adults reduces axotomy-induced death, we examined whether blocking caspases in vivo reduces RGC death after neonatal SC lesions. Neither general nor specific caspase inhibitors increased neonatal RGC survival 6 and 24 h PL. These inhibitors were, however, effective in blocking caspases in another well-defined in vitro apoptosis model, the corpus luteum. Caspase 3 protein and mRNA levels in retinas from normal and SC-lesioned neonatal rats were assessed 3, 6 and 24 h after SC removal using immunohistochemistry, western and northern blots and quantitative real-time polymerase chain reaction. Terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase-mediated dUTP nick-end labelling (TUNEL) was used to independently monitor retinal cell death. The polymerase chain reaction data showed a small but insignificant increase in caspase 3 mRNA in retinas 24 h PL. Western blot analysis did not reveal a significant shift to cleaved (activated) caspase 3 protein. There was a small increase in the number of cleaved caspase 3 immunolabelled cells in the ganglion cell layer 24 h PL but this represented only a fraction of the death revealed by TUNEL. Together, these data indicate that, unlike the situation in adults, most lesion-induced RGC death in neonatal rats occurs independently of caspase activation.     

Involvement of cyclin-dependent kinases in axotomy-induced retinal ganglion cell death

We have tested the role of cyclin-dependent kinases (CDKs) in the type 3B death of axotomized retinal ganglion cells, by injecting intraocularly olomoucine, roscovitine, or butyrolactone I. Each of these inhibits CDK1, CDK2, and CDK5; CDK1 and CDK2 are involved in cell proliferation, whereas CDK5 is involved in neuronal differentiation. The inhibitors partially protected ganglion cells against the effects of axotomy. These agents may affect the ganglion cells directly, because CDK1, its regulatory subunit cyclin B1, and CDK5 were identified immunohistochemically in the perikarya of ganglion cells, and this was confirmed for CDK1 and CDK5 in Western blots of the ganglion cell layer. These blots showed an axotomy-induced phosphorylation of CDK5 occurring remarkably quickly (within 6 hours of axotomy) but little if any change in the phosphorylation state of CDK1. In addition, we studied the expression of proliferation markers, including proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA) and the synthesis of DNA, by immunohistochemical and autoradiographic methods. Normal or axotomized ganglion cells did not express PCNA and did not synthesize DNA. Although we cannot exclude the possibility that axotomized ganglion cells may leave their quiescent state, our data show that they did not progress beyond the G1 phase of the cell cycle. Finally, in contrast to inhibitors of CDKs, cell cycle blockers with different targets than CDKs did not protect ganglion cells. Globally, our results suggest that axotomy-induced death of ganglion cells involves the activation of CDK1, CDK2, or CDK5 (most probably CDK5) but not the full cell cycle machinery.     

Morphology and distribution of neurons in the retinal ganglion cell layer of the adult tammar wallaby--Macropus eugenii

The morphology of the ganglion cell layer of the adult tammar wallaby has been examined from Nissl-stained retinal flatmounts. From this material, neurons have been classed as ganglion cells or displaced amacrine cells according to the disposition of Nissl substance. A further subdivision of ganglion cells into a separate group of alphalike cells was assisted by determining the range of soma sizes in neurofibrillar-stained flatmounts, a method which, in the cat, has revealed the presence of alpha cells. Isodensity contour maps prepared from the Nissl-stained flatmounts show a well-developed visual streak and an area centralis in the total neuronal population. A similar pattern was also found in the ganglion cells, thus confirming Tancred's (J. Comp. Neurol. 196:585-603, '81) finding, and, as well, in the alphalike ganglion cells and the displaced amacrine cells. The relative proportions of ganglion cells to displaced amacrines (GC:DA) were evaluated from isodensity profiles drawn along and vertical to the visual streak for the two cell types and also from maps showing the variation in the GC:DA ratio throughout the retina. A comparison with results published for other species shows that the visual streak development in the tammar wallaby is consistent with the expectations of the "terrain" theory and that, in its relative proportion of displaced amacrines, the tammar closely resembles the rabbit but contrasts sharply with the cat, which has half as many ganglion cells and three times as many displaced amacrines as the other two species.     

Development of the human retina: patterns of cell distribution and redistribution in the ganglion cell layer

Neurogenesis in the ventricular layer and the development of cell topography in the ganglion cell layer have been studied in whole-mounts of human fetal retinae. At the end of the embryonic period mitotic figures were seen over the entire outer surface of the retina. By about 14 weeks gestation mitosis had ceased in central retina and differentiation of photoreceptor nuclei was evident within a well-defined area which constituted about 2% of total retina area. This area was approximately centered on the site of the putative fovea, identified by the exclusive development of cone nuclei at that location. The area of retina in which mitosis had ceased increased as gestation progressed. By mid-gestation mitosis in the ventricular layer occupied about 77% of the outer surface of the retina and by about 30 weeks gestation mitosis in the ventricular layer had ceased. Cell density distributions in the ganglion cell layer were nonuniform at all stages studied (14-40 weeks). Densities were highest at about 17 weeks gestation, and by mid-gestation the adult pattern of cell topography was present with maps showing elevated cell densities in posterior retina and along the horizontal meridian. Cell densities generally declined throughout the remainder of the gestation period, except in the posterior retina, where densities in the perifoveal ganglion cell layer remained high during the second half of gestation. There is a rapid decline in cell density in the foveal ganglion cell layer toward the end of gestation, and it is suggested that the persistence of high densities in the perifoveal region may be related to migration of cells away from the developing fovea. The total population of cells in the ganglion cell layer was highest (2.2-2.5 million cells) between about weeks 18 and 30 of gestation. After this the cell population declined rapidly to 1.5-1.7 million cells. It is suggested that naturally occurring neuronal death is largely responsible for this decline.     

Stages in the structural differentiation of retinal ganglion cells

Using a cultured wholemount technique we have studied the morphological differentiation of ganglion cells in the retina of the rat and cat, during normal development. In both species the differentiation of ganglion cells begins in embryonic life, before embryonic day (E) 17 in the rat and E36 in the cat. It is useful to describe the morphological differentiation of ganglion cells as occurring in three stages. In the first stage, each germinal cell becoming a ganglion cell extends an axon into the fibre layer of the retina and towards the optic disc, and the soma of the cell moves towards the ganglion cell layer. As the soma approaches the ganglion cell layer, the processes that attach its poles to the inner and outer surfaces of the retina are withdrawn. When the soma reaches the ganglion cell layer, a stage of active dendritic growth begins, which lasts until shortly before birth in the cat and until several days after birth in the rat. The cell extends stem dendrites that branch profusely and are commonly tipped by growth cones. The major morphological classes of ganglion cell become distinct in the latter part of stage 2, as do the centroperipheral gradients in ganglion cell size apparent in the cat. During the third stage, the dendritic trees of ganglion cells no longer branch or extend by means of active growth cones. Very considerable growth of all parameters of the cell (soma size, dendrite calibre and length, axon calibre) occurs nevertheless, presumably by interstitial addition of membrane throughout the cell.     

Development of serotoninergic chick retinal neurons

Numerous neurotransmitters have been studied in detail in the developing retina. Almost all known neurotransmitters and neuromodulators were demonstrated in vertebrate retinas using formaldehyde-induced fluorescence, uptake autoradiography or immunohistochemistry procedures. Serotoninergic (5HT) amacrine neurons were described in the inner nuclear layer (INL) of the retina with their dendrites spreading within the inner plexiform layer (IPL). The present work describes the morphological pattern of development of serotoninergic amacrine neurons with a stratified dendritic branching pattern in the chick retina from embryonic day 12 to postnatal day 7. Serotoninergic-bipolar neurons are also described. 5HT-amacrine neurons have round or pear-shaped somata and primary dendritic trees oriented toward the IPL that runs through the INL, showing several varicosities. Secondary dendrites then go through the INL, without any collateral branch. At the outer and inner margin of the IPL the primary and secondary dendrites originate an outer and an inner serotoninergic network, respectively. When the primary dendritic tree reaches the IPL it deflects laterally in sublayer 1—the outer serotoninergic network. Tertiary branches then arise from the secondary dendrite and deflect in the innermost sublayer of the IPL— the inner serotoninergic network. The final pattern of branching of 5HT amacrine cells was present at embryonic day 14 and was completely developed at hatching. Serotoninergic (5HT) bipolar neurons were also present in the INL at hatching. They are weakly immunoreactive and are probably a subset of bipolar cells that accumulate serotonin from the intersynaptic cleft and are not ‘‘true’’ 5HT neurons.     

Relationships between ganglion cell dendritic structure and retinal topography in the cat

The morphology of ganglion cell dendritic trees varies across the cat retina. Evidence is presented that the variation in two attributes of ganglion cell dendritic structure can be accounted for by specific aspects of the topography of the adult and developing retina. The first attribute considered was the displacement of the center of the dendritic field from the cell body in the plane of the retina. The results of this study provide evidence that most ganglion cell dendritic fields are displaced away from neighboring cells, i.e., down the retinal ganglion cell density gradient. Because of the systematic dendritic displacement locally, the centers of the dendritic fields are arranged in a more precise mosaic than are their cell bodies. The second attribute considered was the elongation and orientation of the dendritic fields. From approximately embryonic day 50 to postnatal day 10 the cat retina undergoes a process of maturation (reviewed by Rapaport and Stone: Neuroscience 11:289-301, '84) that begins at the area centralis and spreads over the retina in a horizontally elongated wave. We found that the elongation and orientation of retinal ganglion cell dendritic fields is significantly correlated with the shape of the wave of maturation. The orientation of a dendritic field is not predicted by the direction of its displacement nor is it directly related to the distribution of neighboring retinal ganglion cells. These results indicate that the displacement of a ganglion cell's dendritic field from its cell body results from mechanisms different from those responsible for the orientation of the dendritic field. Factors that may be responsible for these two attributes of ganglion cell dendritic morphology are discussed.     

Time course of morphological differentiation of cat retinal ganglion cells: influences on soma size

We have examined the growth of ganglion cell somas during development of the cat's retina. Until approximately E (embryonic day) 50, ganglion cell somas show no sign of the several variations in their size apparent in the adult. At about E50, the somas begin to accumulate granular cytoplasm. The accumulation proceeds first among area centralis cells which, for a few days, are the largest ganglion cells in the retina (whereas in the adult they are the smallest). By E57 three of the adult soma size trends have become apparent: the differentiation of soma size related to functional class, the nasal-temporal difference in soma size, and the small mean size of somas in the visual streak. The early appearance of these trends in soma size suggests that individual cells may be intrinsically programmed to develop as cells of a particular class, such as alpha-, beta-, or gamma-cells, even before their morphological differentiation begins. A fourth trend in soma size, the centro-peripheral difference, appears only after an initial period of ganglion cell growth; the small size of ganglion cells at the area centralis seems to be determined, at least partly, by a local "environmental" factor, the crowding of ganglion cells.     

Spike train signatures of retinal ganglion cell types

The mammalian retina deconstructs the visual world using parallel neural channels, embodied in the morphological and physiological types of ganglion cells. We sought distinguishing features of each cell type in the temporal pattern of their spikes. As a first step, conventional physiological properties were used to cluster cells in eight types by a statistical analysis. We then adapted a method of P. Reinagel et al. (1999: J. Neurophysiol., 81, 2558-2569) to define epochs within the spike train of each cell. The spike trains of many cells were found to contain robust patterns that are defined by the (averaged) timing of successive interspike intervals in brief activity epochs. The patterns were robust across four different types of visual stimulus. Although the patterns are conserved in different visual environments, they do not prevent the cell from signaling the strength of its response to a particular stimulus, which is expressed in the number of spikes contained in each coding epoch. Clustering based on the spike train patterns alone showed that the spike train patterns correspond, in most but not all cases, to cell types pre-defined by traditional criteria. That the congruence is less than perfect suggests that the typing of rabbit ganglion cells may need further refinement. Analysis of the spike train patterns may be useful in this regard and for distinguishing the many unidentified ganglion cell types that exist in other mammalian retinas.     

Ultrastructure of retinal ganglion cell death after axotomy in chick embryos

Axotomy often leads to neuronal death, which occurs after a particularly short delay in immature animals. Tectal lesions were made in embryonic day (E) 12 chick embryos, thereby axotomizing the retinal ganglion cells of the contralateral eye, which then died within 3 days. We here describe the ultrastructural changes in the axotomized ganglion cells. The main changes were nuclear invagination and type 3B (cytoplasmic type) cell death characterized by dilation of the perinuclear space, endoplasmic reticulum, and Golgi apparatus. However, nuclear invagination was never seen in type 3B dying cells. All the axotomy-induced retinal ganglion cell death appears to have been of type 3B; apoptosis was not induced by axotomy, as was confirmed by additional light microscopic experiments showing that it did not increase the frequency of apoptotic markers revealed by terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase-mediated biotinylated UTP nick end labeling (the TUNEL method) labeling and immunoreactivity for activated caspase-3. However, the latter methods did show small numbers of apoptotic cells dying naturally even in control retinas. After the death of the axotomized ganglion cells, they were phagocytosed mainly in Müller processes. The present findings open up the chick tectal lesion model as a system for analyzing type 3B neuronal death in vivo.     

Action of iontophoretically applied dopamine on cat retinal ganglion cells

Iontophoretically applied dopamine reversibly altered both the spontaneous firing rates and the light evoked responses of retinal ganglion cells in the intact eye of the cat. The effects of dopamine were the same for all cell classes encountered: on brisk-transient, off brisk-transient, on brisk-sustained, off brisk-sustained, sluggish and non-concentrically organized cells. Dopamine reduced the spontaneous firing rates of all cells. In response to light stimulation, the inhibitory response phase (light off in on ganglion cells, light on in off ganglion cells) was also reduced by dopamine. However, the excitatory response phase (light on in on ganglion cells, light off in off ganglion cells) was only consistently reduced for optimal spot stimulation: for wholefield or annular stimulation the excitatory response phase was reduced in 76% of cells, whereas for the remaining cells it was unchanged or even increased. The net effect of these alterations was to cause a shift in the centre surround balance of the cell output in favour of the centre for 82% of concentrically organized cells. These results are discussed in the context of present anatomical knowledge.     

Genesis of neurons in the retinal ganglion cell layer of the monkey.

We have analyzed the genesis of various neuronal classes and subclasses in the ganglion cell layer of the primate retina. Neurons were classified according to their size and the time of their origin was determined by pulse labeling with 3H-thymidine administered to female monkeys 38 to 70 days pregnant. All offspring were sacrificed postnatally, and their retinas processed for autoradiography. The somata of cells in the retinal ganglion cell layer generated on embryonic day (E) 38 ranged from 9 to 14 microns in diameter. Between E40 and E56, the minimum soma diameter remained around 8-9 microns, while the maximum gradually increased to 22 microns. As a consequence, the means of the distributions of labeled cells also increased with age, from 11.8 microns diameter for cells generated on E38 to 14.6 microns diameter at E56. Over this period the percentage of labeled cells in the 10.5-16.5 microns and greater than 16.5 microns diameter range gradually increased. The proportion of the labeled cells in the less than 10.5 microns diameter range decreased from E38 to E45, but subsequently increased rapidly. At the end of neurogenesis in the retinal ganglion cell layer, around E70, most labeled cells were considerably smaller (7-9 microns) than those generated earlier. Our results indicate that within the ganglion cell layer of the macaque, neurons of small caliber are generated first, followed successively by medium sized cells. Large, putative P alpha cells are generated late. The production between E56 and E70 of cells with the smallest somata suggests that the last-generated neurons in the ganglion cell layer are predominantly displaced amacrine cells. Within the same sector of retina, different classes of neurons in the ganglion cell layer of the rhesus monkey appear to have a sequential schedule of production.     

The shift-effect enhances X- and suppresses Y-type response characteristics of cat retinal ganglion cells

Responses to a number of stimuli have been studied during the continuous movement of a “global” pattern covering a large part of the retina but excluding the receptive field of the ganglion cell under investigation. With remarkable consistency, the motion of the pattern induced a reinforcement of response properties usually associated with X-cells. In particular, the following responses characteristics of Y-cells were abolished or strongly reduced: (1) the response to simultaneous increment and decrement swithching in a bipartite field in the receptive field center; (2) the “discrete” shift-effect, elicited by a jerk of the global pattern; and (3) the relative elevation of the mean discharge rate as a response to a fine drifting grating.Furthermore, responses to center illumination became sustained, and the ongoing discharge rose (“continuous shift-effect”).Y-type responses were most strongly affected, except for the sustained components of center responses which increased in a rather unpredictable way. The results strengthen the view that the shift-effect accounts for most of the functional differences between X- and Y-cells. Saturating the shift-effect mechanism by continuous stimulation is a tool by which the shift-effect components in Y-type responses can be largely removed so that essentially X-type responses are left. Possible neuronal pathways involved in the transmission of the responses are discussed.     

Patterns of cell death in the ganglion cell layer of the human fetal retina

The distribution of dying cells in the ganglion cell layer (GCL) of retinae from human fetuses has been analysed. Both whole-mounted and sectioned retinae have been studied. Results suggest that cells are lost from the GCL between weeks 14 and 30 of the gestation period, approximately. This period corresponds to the period during which axons are lost from the developing optic nerve. Cell loss is greatest between weeks 16 and 21 of the gestation period. The pattern of cell loss is nonuniform, and between weeks 16 and 24, the relative frequency of pyknotic cells (pyknotic cells:viable cells) in peripheral retina is considerably higher than in central retina. This pattern of cell loss predominates during the period in which a distinct centroperipheral gradient of cell densities emerges in the GCL of the human fetal retina (between 18 and 23 weeks gestation). It is suggested that the regional loss of ganglion cells may contribute to the formation of the cell density gradient.     

Extrinsic determinants of retinal ganglion cell structure in the cat

The degree to which a retinal ganglion cell's environment can affect its morphological development was studied by manipulating the distribution of ganglion cells in the developing cat retina. In the newborn kitten there is an exuberant ganglion cell projection from temporal retina to the contralateral lateral geniculate nucleus (LGNd) (Leventhal et al., 1988) and from nasal retina to the ipsilateral LGNd. Neonatal, unilateral optic tract section results in the survival of many of these ganglion cells (Leventhal et al., 1988). The morphology of ganglion cells which survive in regions of massively reduced ganglion cell density was studied. As reported previously (Linden and Perry, 1982; Perry and Linden, 1982; Ault et al., 1985; Eysel et al., 1985), we found that the dendritic fields of all types of ganglion cells on the border of an area depleted of ganglion cells extended into the depleted area. The cell bodies and dendritic fields of alpha and beta cells within depopulated areas, as well as on the borders of the depopulated areas, were larger than normal. The dendritic fields of these cells also exhibited abnormal branching patterns. For alpha and beta cell types the relative increase in size tended to be greatest where the relative change in density was the greatest. In fact, isolated beta cells within the cell-poor area centralis region resembled normal central alpha cells in the cell-rich region of the area centralis in the same retina. Interestingly, in the same regions of reduced density where alpha and beta cells were dramatically larger than normal, the cell body and dendritic field sizes of other cell types (epsilon, g1 and g2 were unchanged. These results indicate that neuronal interactions during development contribute to the morphological differentiation of retinal ganglion cells and that different mechanisms mediate the morphological development of different classes of cells in cat retina.