Reduced arousals following obstructive apneas in infants sleeping prone

A decreased arousability and an increased risk for sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS) have been shown in infants sleeping prone. Obstructive apnea, a known risk factor for SIDS, is less often terminated by an arousal reaction in infants than in adults. The effect of body position on the arousal reaction to spontaneous respiratory events had not been previously studied in infants. The aim of our study was to see if body position has an influence on the frequency and delay of the arousal reaction to obstructive apnea. All obstructive events recorded during two successive nights in 20 infants sleeping one night prone and one night supine were studied. During the supine recording 153 obstructive events were detected, and 217 were detected during the prone session. Prone sleep was not associated with an increased frequency of obstructive apneas. Total sleep time was 382 min (range, 283-456) supine and 423 min (range, 325-521) prone (p = 0.003). Obstructive events duration was 6.5 s (range, 3-21.5) when sleeping supine and 8 s (range, 3.5-30.5) when prone (p = 0.002). Behavioral arousal were found in 57.5 % of obstructive events recorded supine and in 31.3 % of those seen prone (p < 0.001). Arousal occurred after 8 s (range, 0-21) from the start of the obstructions when supine and 10.5 s (range, 3.5-23.5) when prone (p = 0.001). Sighs were found in 34 % of supine obstructive events and in 44.7 % of those prone (p = 0.040). A reaction, i.e. arousal or sigh, was found in 91.5 % of supine events and 76 % of those prone (p < 0.001). We conclude that when sleeping supine, infants arouse to obstructive events more often and after shorter delay than when prone.     

Effect of prone sleeping on circulatory control in infants.

BACKGROUND: The mechanism of death in sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS) remains unclear. Progressive bradycardia is the pre-eminent terminal event, suggesting that circulatory failure might be a crucial factor. Vasomotor tone regulates the circulatory system by controlling blood volume distribution while maintaining venous return and blood pressure. AIM: To examine whether prone sleeping, the most consistently identified risk factor for SIDS, has a measurable influence on vasomotor/circulatory control. METHODS: 44 full term infants (mean age, 7.9 weeks) were studied during an overnight sleep. Recordings were made while the infants were horizontal and asleep in the supine and prone positions, and repeated after a head up tilt to 60 degrees, maintained for 30 minutes, while in both sleep positions. Blood pressure, heart rate, anterior shin, and anterior abdominal wall skin temperatures were measured. RESULTS: Systolic blood pressure was lower, but peripheral skin temperature and heart rate were higher during sleep, while horizontal, in the prone rather than the supine position. After tilting, there was a greater reduction in blood pressure and a greater increase in peripheral skin temperature and heart rate when in the prone position. Anterior abdominal wall skin temperature did not vary in either sleeping positions while horizontal or tilted. CONCLUSION: Prone sleeping has a measurable effect on circulatory control, with a reduction in vasomotor tone resulting in peripheral vasodilatation, a higher peripheral skin temperature, a lower blood pressure, and a higher resting heart rate. Because vasomotor tone is crucially important in circulatory control this could be a factor in increasing the risk of SIDS.     

Effects of the supine and prone position on diaphragm thickness in healthy term infants.

BACKGROUND: The physiological basis underlying the decline in the incidence of sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS) associated with changing the sleep position from prone to supine remains unknown. AIMS: To evaluate diaphragm thickness (t(di)) and shortening in healthy term infants in the prone and supine positions in order to determine whether changes in body position would affect diaphragm resting length and the degree of diaphragm shortening during inspiration. METHODS: In 16 healthy term infants, diaphragm thickness at the level of the zone of apposition on the right side was measured using ultrasonography. Heart rate (HR), breathing frequency (f), and transcutaneous oxyhaemoglobin saturation (SaO(2)) were recorded simultaneously during diaphragm imaging with the infants in the supine and prone positions during quiet sleep. RESULTS: At end expiratory (EEV) and at end inspiratory lung volumes (EIV), t(di) increased significantly in the prone position. The change in t(di) during tidal breathing was also greater when the infant was prone. SaO(2), HR, and f were not significantly different at EEV and at EIV in both positions. CONCLUSION: In healthy term infants, placed in the prone position, the diaphragm is significantly thicker and, therefore, shorter, both at EEV and EIV. Diaphragm shortening during tidal breathing is greater when the infant is prone. In the prone position, the decreased diaphragm resting length would impair diaphragm strength, and the additional diaphragm shortening during tidal breathing represents added work performed by the diaphragm. This may compromise an infant's capacity to respond to stressful situations when placed in the prone position and may contribute to the association of SIDS with prone position.     

Correlates of prone infant sleeping position by period of birth

Intervention to avoid the prone sleeping position during infancy has occurred in various countries after evidence that it increases the risk of sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS). This study examined cohort data to determine if correlates of the prone position differed by period of birth, before intervention (1 May 1988 to 30 April 1991) compared with after intervention (1 May 1991 to 30 April 1992). The usual prone sleeping position was more closely associated with the following factors after intervention: teenage motherhood, low maternal education, paternal unemployment, unmarried motherhood, non-specialist antenatal care, not reading books to prepare for a baby, poor smoking hygiene, and bottle feeding. For example, the association of usual prone position with being unmarried shown by the odds ratio (95% confidence interval) was 0.54 (0.47 to 0.63) in the period before intervention and 1.92 (1.18 to 3.15) in the period after intervention. The alteration in correlates of the prone position reported here provide an example to support the theoretical concept that well known 'modifiable' risk factors for disease tend to be associated with each other in both populations and individuals. This phenomenon was not evident in the population before intervention, that is, before the prone sleeping position became a well known SIDS risk factor.     

Transcutaneous oxygen saturation in sleeping infants: prone and supine.

Pulse oximetry was used to measure transcutaneous arterial oxygen saturation in infants aged 2 to 11 months prone and supine in quiet sleep. Groups of healthy infants (n = 34), infants with upper respiratory tract infections (n = 13), and infants with generalised moderately severe lower respiratory tract infections (n = 17) were studied. No clinically important differences were demonstrated in any of these groups, although there was a small advantage in the prone position in the group with lower respiratory tract infection. The effect of posture on infants with more severe lower respiratory tract infection and during active sleep has yet to be determined.     

Further evidence supporting a causal relationship between prone sleeping position and SIDS

Abstract A 3 year case-control study identifying the risk factors for SIDS was undertaken. Preliminary analysis of the data from the first year suggested that SIDS mortality could fall by 50% if the prevalence of the prone sleeping position changed from 40 to 0%. During the 3 year study the prevalence of the prone sleeping position among infants has fallen from 43% in the first year to 20% in the third year. SIDS mortality has fallen to 3.1/1000 live births, which is very close to that predicted. When considered with other available evidence this strongly supports a causal relationship between the prone sleeping position and SIDS.     

Effects of maternal tobacco smoking,sleeping position,and sleep state on arousal in healthy term infants

OBJECTIVES: To investigate whether a history of maternal tobacco smoking affected the maturation of arousal responses and whether sleeping position and infant age alters these relations. DESIGN: Healthy term infants (13 born to mothers who did not smoke and 11 to mothers who smoked during pregnancy) were studied using daytime polysomnography on three occasions: (a) two to three weeks after birth, (b) two to three months after birth, and (c) five to six months after birth. Multiple measurements of arousal threshold in response to air jet stimulation were made in both active sleep (AS) and quiet sleep (QS) when infants slept both prone and supine. RESULTS: Maternal smoking significantly elevated arousal threshold in QS when infants slept supine at 2-3 months of age (p<0.05). Infants of smoking mothers also had fewer spontaneous arousals from QS at 2-3 months in both prone (p<0.05) and supine (p<0.001) sleeping positions. In infants of non-smoking mothers, arousal thresholds were elevated in the prone position in AS at 2-3 months (p<0.01) and QS at 2-3 weeks (p<0.05) and 2-3 months (p<0.001). CONCLUSIONS: Maternal tobacco smoking significantly impairs both stimulus induced and spontaneous arousal from QS when infants sleep in the supine position, at the age when the incidence of sudden infant death syndrome is highest.     

Vasoconstriction following spontaneous sighs and head-up tilts in infants sleeping prone and supine

The cutaneous vasoconstrictor responses following a 60 degrees head-up tilt and a spontaneous sigh were measured in 36 infants at 1 and 3 months age to investigate the effects of age, sleep state and sleep position on these responses. The vasoconstrictor response was determined by a measure of cutaneous blood flow using a laser Doppler flowmeter. The mean reduction in blood flow (vasoconstriction) was 52% following the tilt, and 33% following the sigh. Prone positioning 1-month-old infants as compared to supine, reduced the degree of vasoconstriction following the tilt (P=0.027) and sigh (P=0.026). The supine to prone reduction was: tilt, -11% in quiet sleep (QS) (from 55.1 to 49.1% vasoconstriction) and -18% in active sleep (AS) (from 52.0 to 42.9%) and; sigh, -26% in QS (35-26%), and -15% in AS (31-26%). The degree of vasoconstriction following the sigh was significantly greater in 3- compared to 1-month-old infants (+26%, P=0.040). The mean response to the tilt in the older age group was 12% greater but this did not reach significance (P=0.069). Sleep state did not affect the degree of vasoconstriction but influenced transmission of the response so that latency to minimal vasoconstriction was 1 s shorter in AS than QS. This study provides data on two simple measures of sympathetic activity during sleep that have not previously been described in any detail in infant studies, and add more evidence that autonomic activity is reduced in the prone position compared to supine during sleep.     

Survey of sleeping position recommendations for prematurely born infants

The risk of sudden infant death syndrome is increased in prematurely born infants compared to those born at term, particularly if they are either slept prone or on their side. The aim of this study was to determine whether a national campaign “Time to get back to sleep” had influenced the recommendations made by neonatal practitioners regarding the sleeping position for prematurely born babies prior to and after neonatal unit discharge. A questionnaire survey was sent to all UK neonatal units, of which 90% responded. The results were compared to those of a survey carried out prior to the national campaign. Analysis of the responses demonstrated that there was no significant difference in the proportion of units which recommended supine sleeping at least 1–2 weeks before discharge (78% versus 83%). Still, a minority of units provided written information for staff (26% versus 33%), but a greater proportion of units provided written information for parents (95% versus 90%, p = 0.047). All units recommended supine sleeping following discharge, and compared to the results of the previous survey, a smaller proportion of units additionally recommended side sleeping after discharge (8% versus 17%, p = 0.01) and a greater proportion actively discouraged prone sleeping (62% versus 38%, p < 0.0001). Conclusions: The majority but, importantly, not all neonatal units are giving appropriate recommendations regarding sleeping position following neonatal unit discharge. These results highlight that further education of neonatal staff regarding appropriate sleeping position for prematurely born babies remains imperative.     

An overview of retrospective case-control studies investigating the relationship between prone sleeping position and SIDS

A critical overview of 19 case-control studies that have investigated the relationship between prone sleeping position and sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS) is presented. Issues relating to the non-comparability of the studies are described in terms of: (i) case definition; (ii) selection of controls; (iii) quality of the sleeping position data; (iv) recall bias; and (v) adjustment for confounding factors. All studies showed a positive association (2 out of the 19 studies were not significant) between prone sleeping position and SIDS. Meta-analysis techniques applied to six of these studies, based on 'usual' sleeping position in cases and population representative controls, has confirmed an overall higher risk of SIDS in infants who usually sleep prone. The most common odds ratio for an association between prone sleeping position and SIDS was 2.72 (95% confidence interval 2.27-3.26). The extent to which the methodological problems of retrospective case-control studies interfere with our interpretations of this association are discussed.     

A scientific review of the association between prone sleeping position and sudden infant death syndrome

A meeting was held in Canberra on 29 and 30 July 1991 to discuss the relationship between prone sleeping position and sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS). It was sponsored by the Australian Rotary Health Research Fund in association with the Sir Robert Menzies Memorial Foundation. The catalyst for the meeting was the recent paper in the Lancet reporting the results of the prospective study carried out by the Menzies Centre for Population Health Research in Hobart which reported an increased risk of SIDS for infants sleeping prone.     

Effects of prone and supine position on cerebral blood flow in preterm infants

We evaluated the effect of prone and supine position on cerebral blood flow (CBF) in stable preterm infants. CBF, PO(2), and PCO(2) were measured in the two positions. Peripheral oxygenation increased and CBF decreased in prone position. We speculate that CBF autoregulation may compensate for increased peripheral oxygenation, by decreasing CBF.