Recurrence rates after selective neck dissection in the N0 irradiated neck

OBJECTIVES: To define patterns of subclinical metastases in irradiated N0 necks with recurrent or persistent primary site disease and to determine the regional control rate when selective neck dissection (SND) is used in this setting. PATIENTS AND INTERVENTION: Individuals included were previously treated for head and neck squamous cell carcinoma with primary radiation therapy or chemoradiotherapy. All had recurrent or persistent disease at the primary site, with no clinical or radiographic evidence of nodal disease. The patients underwent surgical treatment of the primary site along with site-specific SND and were required to undergo at least 1 year of follow-up. Subsequent recurrence at the primary site disqualified the patient from further evaluation. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE: Regional tumor control. RESULTS: Forty-three patients meeting the inclusion criteria underwent 59 SNDs (levels dissected: I-IV [n = 22], II-IV [n = 34], and I-III [n = 3]). Sixteen specimens were positive for nodal disease. The charts of 26 patients, who underwent a total of 35 SNDs, were available for review after 1 year (none of the patients involved died of disease in the neck). There were no neck recurrences (mean follow-up, 25 months; median, 21 months). All patients with more than 2 occult nodal metastases experienced primary site recurrence or distant metastases. CONCLUSIONS: In this small cohort, SND in previously irradiated patients with recurrent primary disease but clinically negative necks has resulted in excellent tumor control in the neck. The usual patterns of nodal spread do not appear to be significantly altered with primary site recurrence after radiation therapy. The presence of more than 2 positive nodes in the neck specimen correlates with poor prognosis.     

Mucosal malignant melanomas of the head and neck with special reference to cases having a prolonged clinical course.

A histological re-examination and re-classification of primary mucosal tumours of the head and neck region, treated at Radiumhemmet and Karolinska Sjukhuset during the period 1927-1970, revealed that 41 tumours were malignant melanomas. All these 41 tumours were located in the nasal cavity, paranasal sinuses and oral cavity and not a single case of primary mucosal malignant melanoma was found in other locations of the head and neck region. In the present study, the long-term prognosis has been analysed. The follow-up period was at least 5 years and ranged up to 48 years. It was found that mucosal malignant melanomas had a very poor prognosis with a five year survival rate of 17% (7 of the total 41 cases) and a ten year survival rate of 7% (3 of the total of 41 cases). The unpredictability of the clinical behaviour of this tumour type is elucidated by cases with a prolonged clinical course despite a primary relatively limited surgery, repeated local recurrences and regional lymph node metastases in an early stage of the disease. Thus, there is always a never-ceasing risk of death in the tumour disease when once a malignant melanoma has occurred. For this reason a meticulous and lifelong follow-up of tumour patients is stressed, and also the value of repeated surgery of local recurrences and regional lymph node metastases.     

Combined treatment of cancer of the posterior oral cavity and oropharynx

Ninety composite resections were carried out as primary treatment for a squamous carcinoma of the tonsillar region between 1970 and 1978. All patients have been followed-up for at least 3 years, except for 5 who have been lost to follow-up. All patients received postoperative radiotherapy (between 50 Gy and 65 Gy depending on the tumour resection status). Sixty-one patients received preoperative chemotherapy and 42% had clinical reduction of tumour size. The overall survival was 45.5% at 3 years and 43% at 5 years. Local recurrences were the most frequent oncological failure (25%). Tumours classed T3, insufficient tumour resection and lymph node invasion had poor prognostic value. We emphasize the necessity for primary surgery with preoperative chemotherapy and postoperative radiotherapy for squamous carcinoma of the posterior oral cavity and oropharynx.     

Results of salvage treatment of the neck in patients with oral cancer

BACKGROUND: About 50% of the patients with neck recurrences after the treatment of oral squamous cell carcinoma are not considered candidates for further treatment, and reported survival is generally poor. OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the prognostic importance of neck recurrences and results of salvage treatment in patients with oral carcinoma. PATIENTS: Five hundred thirteen patients with squamous cell carcinoma of the oral cavity underwent surgical treatment, with follow-up from less than 2 to 119 months (mean, 16.9 months). SETTING: Referral center, private or institutional practice, and ambulatory and hospital care center. INTERVENTION: Four hundred forty-eight patients underwent neck dissection, and 65, resection of the primary tumor only. Postoperative radiotherapy was used for 228. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Rates of neck recurrences and survival after salvage treatment. RESULTS: Eighty-two patients (16.0%) had neck recurrences, including ipsilateral in 44, contralateral in 31, and bilateral in 7. Most neck recurrences (77 [94%]) were diagnosed within 2 years. Salvage treatment was attempted in 51 patients (62%). Of the patients with a previously untreated side of the neck, 27 underwent radical neck dissections (11 ipsilateral and 16 contralateral) and only 5 remained with no evidence of disease. The significant factors associated with survival after neck recurrence were type of previous neck dissection (P<.001), previous postoperative radiotherapy (P =.003), and interval free of neck recurrence (P<.001). CONCLUSIONS: Patients undergoing previous neck dissection and with recurrences diagnosed after 6 months are not usually candidates for curative salvage treatment and are at a high risk for death. Only 5 of 46 patients with recurrences in a previously untreated side of the neck survived after salvage treatment. Patients with neck recurrences have a poor prognosis, despite salvage treatment.     

头颈部韧带样瘤的治疗

目的 探讨头颈部韧带样瘤手术及放疗等治疗方法的效果.方法 回顾性分析复旦大学肿瘤医院头颈外科1987-2002年期间收治的44例头颈部韧带样瘤患者的临床资料和随访情况,评估外科治疗和放疗的疗效.结果 根据患者病情分为3组:单纯手术组15例,均为术后病理检查显微镜下证实切缘均为阴性者,随访12-156个月,局部复发率26.7%(4/15).手术+术后补充放疗12例,均为术后肿瘤残留患者,其中显微镜下病理检查切缘阳性5例,肉眼可见肿瘤残留7例,随访时间16～164个月,均无复发;外院手术后复发再放疗组17例,放疗后肿瘤残留率23.5%(4/17),随访时间15～136个月,局部复发率17.6%(3/17).所有患者未发现远处转移,也没有与此病相关的死亡.结论 对于头颈部韧带样瘤,外科手术难以切除彻底,应尽可能地保留患者的外形与功能,提高患者的生存质量.术后须补允放疗,能取得满意疗效.对于初次手术复发的患者,再行放疗,也能获得较佳预后.     

Treatment of contralateral N0 neck in early squamous cell carcinoma of the oral tongue: elective neck dissection versus observation

OBJECTIVES/HYPOTHESIS: Prophylactic treatment of contralateral N0 neck in early squamous cell carcinoma (SCC) of the oral tongue is a controversial issue. The aim of this study was to analyze the rates of occult metastases and their prognostic effects in stage I and stage II SCC of the oral tongue, and to compare the results of elective neck dissection to observation of the contralateral N0 neck in the treatment of these patients. STUDY DESIGN: Retrospective review. METHODS: We reviewed the medical records of 54 patients who were treated at Severance Hospital from 1992 to 2003 and had been diagnosed with stage I or stage II SCC of the oral tongue and had not received prior treatment. All patients underwent an ipsilateral elective neck dissection simultaneously with the primary lesion. The management of the contralateral N0 necks involved "watchful waiting" in 29 patients and elective neck dissection in 25 patients. Surgical treatment was followed by radiotherapy in 20 patients. Of these, seven patients belonged to the "observation" group who did not receive contralateral elective neck dissection. The follow-up period ranged from 3 to 110 months, with a mean of 56.3 months. Data were analyzed using the Kaplan-Meier method, the log-rank test, and the chi(2) test. RESULTS: Fifteen patients (28%, 15 of 54) had occult metastases. Of these, 14 patients (26%, 14 of 54) had ipsilateral pathologic metastases. The remaining case (4%, 1 of 25) had the only contralateral level II occult neck metastasis without ipsilateral metastasis. Disease recurred in 17 of 54 patients (31%). Of these, eight cases (47%, 8 of 17) had regional recurrences. All regional recurrences developed in the ipsilateral neck; there were no cases of contralateral neck recurrence. The 5-year actuarial disease-free survival rates were 82% for the "observation" group and 68% for the elective neck dissection group. This difference was not statistically significant (P = .182). The 5-year actuarial disease-free survival rates were 83% for the "observation" group when those patients who underwent radiotherapy were excluded (n = 22) and 68% for the elective supraomohyoid neck dissection group (n = 25), which showed no statistically significant difference (P = .127). CONCLUSIONS: This study showed that ipsilateral elective neck management is indicated for stage I and II SCC of the oral tongue. On the other hand, our series suggests that contralateral occult lymph node metastasis was unlikely in early-stage oral tongue SCC, and that there was no survival benefit for patients who underwent elective neck dissection in place of observation. Thus, it may not harmful to observe the contralateral N0 neck in the treatment of early oral tongue cancer.     

The treatment of recurrence following fast neutron therapy for head and neck malignancy

Twenty-eight patients received fast neutron therapy for head and neck malignancy. Of these, seven had no recurrence, 13 had a recurrence at the primary site, five had a recurrence in the neck and three had a recurrence in the neck and at the primary site. Treatment of a primary site recurrence was difficult with seven of the eight patients submitted for major surgical resection developing serious complications. Of the six patients developing a fistula four required flap repair. The tumour specific 5-year survival for the whole group of 28 patients was 29%. The surgical treatment of locoregional recurrence following fast neutron therapy is fraught with problems and some type of flap repair is usually necessary.     

Neck dissection in the management of regional metastases in patients with undifferentiated nasopharyngeal carcinomas

Residual regional disease after the primary treatment of nasopharyngeal carcinoma is still considered to be a therapeutic problem. The limitations of prophylactic radical radiation, further doses of irradiation as a useful salvage procedure, and the effects on vital structures were the reasons that we employed a therapeutic protocol consisting of radical neck dissection after 40 Gy of radiotherapy and a full tumor dose after surgery. The initial treatment consisted of chemotherapy. Between 1977 and 1991 surgical removal of residual neck metastases was performed in 44 patients with undifferentiated nasopharyngeal carcinomas who had regional metastases at the time of diagnosis. Fourteen patients (group A) had radical neck dissections after initial chemotherapy (using doxorubicin, etoposide, bleomycin and/or 5-fluouracil) and between two courses of locoregional radiotherapy. The remaining 30 patients (group B) were operated on after finishing chemotherapy and locoregional radiotherapy (group B 1) or receiving only full-dose locoregional radiotherapy (group B 2). All patients had histopathologically proven complete remission of primary tumors before neck surgery. The five-year survival rates for group A were 78%, 40% for group B 1 and 27% for group B 2. There were statistically significant differences between groups A and B (P < 0.01), but not between groups B 1 and B 2. In group A one patient died from subsequent distant metastases and two from local tumor recurrences. Twenty patients died in group B, regional relapses occurred in 40% of the patients in group B 1 and 33% in group B 2, while distant metastases developed in 40% of group B 2. These findings again showed that radical neck dissection was an effective approach for controlling neck disease. When performed after initial chemotherapy and between two courses of radiotherapy, surgery significantly improves the prognosis of patients with positive regional lymph nodes at the time of diagnosis. Received: 2 June 1998 / Accepted: 21 October 1998     

Selective neck dissection in the management of the clinically node-negative neck

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the efficacy of the selective neck dissection (SND) in the management of the clinically node-negative neck. STUDY DESIGN: Case histories were evaluated retrospectively. METHODS: The results of 300 neck dissections performed on 210 patients were studied. RESULTS: The primary sites were oral cavity (91), oropharynx (30), hypopharynx (16), and larynx (73). Seventy-one necks (23%) were node positive on pathological examination. The number of positive nodes varied from 1 to 9 per side. Of necks with positive nodes, 17 (24%) had extracapsular spread. The median follow-up was 41 months. Recurrent disease developed in the dissected neck of 11 patients (4%). Two recurrences developed outside the dissected field. The incidence of regional recurrences was similar in patients in whom nodes were negative on histological examination (3%) when compared with patients with positive nodes without extracapsular spread (4%). In contrast, regional recurrence developed in 18% of necks with extracapsular spread. This observation was statistically significant. Patients having more than two metastatic lymph nodes had a higher incidence of recurrent disease than the patients with carcinoma limited to one or two nodes. Recurrence rate in the pathologically node positive (pN+) necks was comparable to recurrence in those pathologically node negative (pNO) necks in the patients who did not have irradiation. CONCLUSION: SND is effective for controlling neck disease and serves to detect patients who require adjuvant therapy.     

Experience with reconstructive surgery in 137 cases of head and neck cancer

A retrospective analysis of 137 patients treated with reconstruction of defects following head and neck cancer surgery is presented. From 1976 through 1984, 151 regional flaps were used: 43 pectoralis myocutaneous, 29 deltopectoral, 19 forehead, 17 nasolabial, 14 combinations of the aforementioned and 15 other types. The minimum follow-up was two years. Of 62 patients (51 stage III and IV) operated as part of the primary treatment, 20 (32%) died due to relapse, of which 14 (23%) occurred within the region reconstructed. The corresponding figures for 64 patients receiving salvage surgery for recurrences were 53% and 39% respectively. Eleven patients had repair of wounds following surgery or irradiation. Major flap necrosis necessitating reoperation occurred in 11%. The average duration of hospitalization was 35 days. We feel that these results justify these resource-demanding operations.     

Selective vs modified radical neck dissection and postoperative radiotherapy vs observation in the treatment of squamous cell carcinoma of the oral tongue

OBJECTIVES: To assess the role of selective neck dissection in patients with squamous cell carcinoma (SCC) of the oral tongue with advanced nodal disease, and to assess the role of postoperative radiotherapy in patients with SCC of the oral tongue with pathologically N1 necks. DESIGN: Retrospective study of the medical records of all patients who underwent neck dissection for SCC of the oral tongue from January 1, 1980, to December 31, 1995. Median follow-up was 5.7 years. SETTING: The University of Texas M. D. Anderson Cancer Center, Houston, a tertiary care cancer hospital. PATIENTS: A total of 220 patients with SCC of the oral tongue who received surgical treatment of both the primary tumor and the neck and who had an identifiable type of neck dissection, no synchronous or metachronous lesions, and no evidence of local recurrence. INTERVENTIONS: All patients underwent resection of the primary tumor and neck dissection. The extent of neck dissection was determined by surgeon preference. Some patients received radiotherapy to the neck as well. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Clinical and pathological nodal status, type of neck dissection, and use of radiotherapy. The end points evaluated included the regional control rates. RESULTS: For clinically N+ patients, 5 of 45 treated with selective neck dissection and 1 of 19 treated with radical or modified radical neck dissection had recurrences in the ipsilateral neck. If only patients with significant tumor burden on final pathological examination (clinically N+/pathologically N2) are considered, 4 (25.0%) of 16 patients undergoing selective neck dissection had recurrences in the neck, while none of the 14 patients treated with radical or modified radical neck dissection had recurrences in the ipsilateral neck (P = .07). Of the 50 patients who had pathologically N1 disease, 25 received postoperative radiotherapy and 25 did not. Of the latter, 2 had recurrences in the neck, while none of the 25 patients who received radiotherapy had recurrences in the neck (P = .24). CONCLUSIONS: Selective neck dissection may be sufficient for many N+ patients with SCC of the oral tongue, but some patients with extensive nodal disease may benefit from more aggressive treatment of the neck. Radiotherapy may be beneficial for all of the node-positive patients, but further studies are needed. Prospective, randomized clinical trials will be useful in further defining the role of selective neck dissection in the clinically N2 neck and radiotherapy in the N1 neck for patients with SCC of the oral tongue.     

Selective neck dissection for the treatment of neck metastasis from squamous cell carcinoma of the head and neck

OBJECTIVE: Our objective was to determine the proportion of patients disease free in the neck, with the primary site controlled, who have been treated with a selective neck dissection (SND) for squamous cell carcinoma (SCCa) of the upper aerodigestive tract, and who had cervical metastasis less than 3 cm. STUDY DESIGN: A cohort of patients who fit the inclusion/exclusion criteria was identified retrospectively. Then all surviving patients were followed for a minimum of 2 years. METHODS: A group of 52 patients who had 58 selective neck dissections for cervical metastases from SCCa of the upper aerodigestive tract were identified. The mean age was 56 years (range, 20-85 y), there were 40 males and 12 females, and mean follow-up was 24.5 months (range, 1-64 mo). Twenty-six patients had clinically negative (cNo) neck examinations and 26 had clinically positive neck examinations. Postoperative radiation was given for extracapsular spread, greater than 2 positive nodes, T3, T4, or recurrent disease if the patient had not received radiation before surgery. These radiation criteria excluded 18 patients from postoperative radiation treatment. RESULTS: Kaplan-Meier survival analysis showed that the regional control rate with the primary site controlled was 0.94. Six patients developed recurrent neck disease. Three of these 6 patientswere surgically salvaged. Four recurrences were in the dissected field and 2 were out of the dissected field (level V). CONCLUSIONS: With similar indications for radiation therapy, the regional control rate in this cohort is comparable to control rates obtained with modified radical neck dissection.     

Outcome of observing the N0 neck using ultrasonographic-guided cytology for follow-up

OBJECTIVE: To assess the outcome of patients who underwent transoral tumor excision and a wait-and-see policy for the NO neck, using ultrasonographic-guided fine-needle aspiration cytology (US-FNAC) of the neck for both selecting patients for neck treatment or observation and for follow-up. DESIGN: Retrospective outcome analysis of a patient cohort without palpable or US-FNAC detectable nodal metastases undergoing transoral tumor excisions. Patients were followed up for 1 to 4 years using palpation and US-FNAC. SETTING: Academic center. PATIENTS: A consecutive sample of 77 patients mainly with oral carcinomas. Excluded were patients who had neck dissections, radiotherapy, or no US-FNAC during follow-up. INTERVENTION: Transoral tumor excision. Neck dissection with radiotherapy for regional failure. OUTCOME MEASURE: The recurrence rate in the neck, without failure at the primary site and the salvage rate of these neck recurrences were the most important measures. Treatment delay and histopathologic findings were assessed as well. RESULTS: Fourteen patients (18%) had occult lymph node metastases and neck failures. Of the 14 neck failures, 9 were detected within 7 months of which 6 were not palpable. Ten (71%) of these 14 patients were successfully salvaged, and 4 died of uncontrolled disease. Three of the 4 patients also had distant metastases. CONCLUSIONS: The low recurrence rate (18%) can be attributed to the initial US-FNAC. The high salvage rate (71%) indicates that strict US-FNAC follow-up enables early detection of recurrence in the neck. A wait-and-see policy thus seems warranted, provided regular US-FNAC examinations during follow-up can be guaranteed.     

Juvenile malignant melanoma of the head and neck

Malignant melanoma of the head and neck is a potentially lethal disease and considered rare among juveniles. Treatment patterns have historically been dictated by experience with adults, however a paucity of data is available to determine the natural history and treatment guidelines for juveniles and children with malignant melanoma. Therefore a retrospective computer-aided analysis of patients less than 20 years of age having malignant melanoma were obtained from the records of 4,843 patients with malignant melanoma recorded from 1972 through 1986. Eighty-seven patients were identified from this group with 17 patients having primary malignant melanomas confined to the head and neck. Parameters evaluated were age at diagnosis, sex, type of melanoma, Clark Level, Breslow depth of invasion, pathologic classification, site of primary, nodal status at diagnosis, surgical treatment, recurrence rate and site of recurrence, and follow-up status. Two of 17 patients had stage II disease and were treated with wide local excision and therapeutic radical neck dissection. Fifteen of 17 patients initially presented with stage I disease were treated with wide local excision. Two of these patients underwent elective radical neck dissection both of which proved to have positive occult nodal disease. Both are alive without evidence of disease 2 1/2 to 7 years later. Of the 13 patients who were initially treated with only wide local excision, nine patients developed local (3), regional (3), or systemic (3) disease within 3 months to 9 years from the date of diagnosis. Seven of the nine died of their disease 5 months to 20 years later. When juvenile patients with melanomas of the head and neck are compared to a comparable age group of patients with melanomas at other primary body sites, the head and neck group had a significantly higher frequency of death. Compared to the adult head and neck population, juvenile patients had identical actuarial survival time, but shorter disease-free intervals, even though the adult population had a higher percent of poor prognostic indices (presence of ulceration and thickness of lesions). Failure to control local and regional disease coupled with the overall poor survival rate, indicates that malignant melanoma occurs in the young as a biologically active tumor and suggests an aggressive approach for better control of local and regional disease and, hopefully, survival.     

Management of cervical metastases in advanced squamous cell carcinoma of the base of tongue

OBJECTIVE: To clarify the role of neck dissection following primary radiotherapy for treatment of squamous cell carcinoma of the base of tongue. DESIGN: Case series. SETTING: Academic, tertiary care medical center. PATIENTS OR OTHER PARTICIPANTS: A consecutive series of 45 patients with biopsy-proven squamous cell carcinoma of the base of tongue and cervical metastases treated with primary radiotherapy at The University of California, San Francisco, was examined. Patients with a prior history of neck irradiation, neck dissection, or head and neck cancer within 5 years were excluded. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Overall survival and regional control. RESULTS: Of the 45 patients treated with definitive radiotherapy, 25 (56%) achieved a complete response, 13 (29%) achieved a partial response, 4 (9%) were nonresponders, and 3 (7%) did not complete radiotherapy. Two thirds of the complete responders had N2 or N3 disease; 3 had recurrences in the neck, 1 of which was an isolated neck recurrence. Of the 13 partial responders, 5 had isolated persistence of disease, with 4 undergoing neck dissections. The only long-term survivors among the partial responders were those 4 who underwent a neck dissection. Overall survival was 50% at 3 years and 32% at 5 years. Regional control for complete responders was 84% at 5 years. CONCLUSIONS: The low rate of isolated regional recurrence in patients with a complete response to radiotherapy supports the practice of surveillance alone in such patients. Patients with less than a complete response appear to benefit from prompt surgical salvage.     

Sentinel lymph node biopsy in squamous cell carcinoma of the head and neck: 10 years of experience

Sentinel node (SN) biopsy of head and neck cancer is still considered investigational, and agreement on the width of the surgical sampling has not yet been reached. From May 1999 to Dec 2009, 209 consecutive patients entered a prospective study: 61.7% had primary tumour of the oral cavity and 23.9% of the oropharynx. SN was not found in 26 patients. Based on these data and definitive histopathological analysis, we proposed six hypothetic scenarios to understand the percentage of neck recurrences following different treatments Among patients with identified SN, 54 cases were pN+: 47 in SN and 7 in a different node. Considering the six hypothetic scenarios: "only SN removal", "SN level dissection", "neck dissection from the tumour site to SN level", "selective neck dissection of three levels (SND)", "dissection from level I to IV" and "comprehensive I-V dissection", neck recurrences could be expected in 6.5%, 3.8%, 2.18%, 2.73%, 1.09% and 1.09% of cases, respectively. SN biopsy can be considered a useful tool to personalize the surgical approach to a N0 carcinoma. The minimum treatment of the neck is probably dissection of the levels between the primary tumour and the level containing the SN(s). Outside the framework of a clinical study, the best treatment can still be considered SND.     

Selective neck dissection in the management of squamous cell carcinoma of the upper digestive tract

Selective neck dissection has been used clinically in elective treatment of carcinoma, although many surgeons continue to advocate modified radical or radical neck dissection for therapeutic management of the neck. In a retrospective study 167 previously untreated patients were reviewed following curative laser microsurgical resections of oral or pharyngeal primary tumors and a unior bilateral selective neck dissection. In all, 221 (54 bilateral) neck dissections were performed. In patients with oral primary disease lymph nodes of levels I–III were removed, while nodes in levels II and III were removed in patients with pharyngeal tumors. Level IV was dissected when several metastases were suspected during operation. The posterior triangle was not dissected. Lymph nodes were histopathologically negative in 73 patients and positive in 94 patients. Twenty-five of these latter cases had pN1 disease, 55 had pN2b disease and 10 had bilateral lymph node metastases. Twenty patients in the pN0 group and 63 patients in the pN⁺ group received postoperative radiotherapy (to 56.7 Gy to the primary site and 52.5 Gy to the neck). With a median follow-up interval of 34 months, recurrence in the dissected neck occurred in 3 of 73 patients (4.1%) with pN0 disease and 6 of 90 patients (6.6%) with pN⁺ necks. Four patients with pN⁺ necks had simultaneous recurrences at the primary site. The addition of adjuvant radiotherapy seemed to improve disease control in the neck and improve overall survival in patients with an unfavorable prognosis due to multiple metastases or metastases with extracapsular spread.Presented at the 66th Annual Meeting of the German Society for Otorhinolaryngology, Head and Neck Surgery, Karlsruhe, 27–31 May 1995     

Treatment of neck nodes after induction chemotherapy in patients with primary advanced tumours

Responsiveness of neck nodes to induction chemotherapy often differs from that of the primary tumour. We have conducted a retrospective study to evaluate the results of treating the neck in a cohort of 350 patients with locally advanced (T3–4) head and neck carcinomas treated with radiation therapy at the primary location of the tumour after induction chemotherapy. One hundred and thirty-nine patients (40%) did not have neck nodes on diagnosis (N0). The treatment of the neck included surgery in 65 patients. Neck dissections were carried out before radiotherapy in 37 patients and after radiotherapy in 28 patients. The frequency of neck treatment failure was 24%. There was a tendency to better neck control when treatment included neck dissection, independently of the neck stage or response to chemotherapy. This tendency was statistically significant in patients with an advanced regional tumour (N2–3) who did not achieve a complete regional response after chemotherapy. In a multivariate analysis the variables that were related to the regional failure were the relapse of the tumour at the primary site, the neck stage (N), the type of treatment used in the neck, and the grade of regional response after induction chemotherapy. Our results lead us to suggest that after induction chemotherapy neck surgery is advisable in all cases with advanced regional disease (N2–3), independently of the grade of response achieved after induction chemotherapy, and is also advisable in N1 patients in whom induction chemotherapy does not achieve a complete response. Received: 27 December 1999 / Accepted: 6 June 2000     

Aggressive concurrent chemoradiotherapy for squamous cell head and neck cancer: an 8-year single-institution experience

BACKGROUND: Since 1989, 105 patients with squamous head and neck cancer have been treated with combined chemoradiotherapy. OBJECTIVE: To examine the effectiveness of using combined chemoradiotherapy on patients with squamous head and neck cancer. DESIGN: Eight-year (1989-1997) single-institution evaluation of 105 patients. METHODS: Treatment consisted of fluorouracil, 1000 mg/m2 per day, and cisplatin, 20 mg/m2 per day, both given as continuous infusions during 4 days beginning on day 1 and 22 of a concurrent radiotherapy course. Radiation was given in single daily fractions of 1.8 to 2 Gy, to a total dose of 66 to 72 Gy. Salvage surgery was performed for any residual or recurrent locoregional disease. Planned neck dissection was recommended for all patients with N2+ neck disease, irrespective of clinical response. RESULTS: The 105-patient cohort consisted of 79 men and 26 women. The primary site was identified in the oral cavity in 6, oropharynx in 46, larynx in 30, and hypopharynx in 20 patients. Two patients had multiple primaries and 1 patient had an unknown primary. There were 4 patients with stage II, 24 with stage III, and 77 with stage IV disease. Grade 3 and 4 chemoradiotherapy toxic effects included mucositis in 88% of patients, cutaneous reaction in 50%, neutropenia in 49%, thrombocytopenia in 12%, and nausea in 5%. There were no deaths secondary to treatment. The mean weight loss was 12% of initial body weight. To date, primary site persistence or recurrence has occurred in only 14 patients (13%). With a mean follow-up of 39 months, 66 patients (63%) are alive and free of disease. The Kaplan-Meier 4-year projected overall survival is 60% with a disease-specific survival of 74%, a distant metastasis-free survival of 84%, and an overall survival with primary site preserved of 54%. CONCLUSIONS: This chemoradiotherapy regimen, although toxic, is tolerable with appropriate supportive intervention. Locoregional and distant control are likely. Primary site conservation is possible in most patients. Chemoradiotherapy appears to have an emerging role in the primary management of head and neck cancer.     

Controlling advanced neck disease: efficacy of neck dissection and radiotherapy

OBJECTIVE: Neck dissection remains the standard method of treating cervical metastasis from head and neck squamous cell carcinoma. In light of recent trends to modify the classic radical neck dissection (RND) for early neck disease, we reviewed our experience with radical and modified RND (MRND) plus radiotherapy as treatment for N2/N3 neck disease in head and neck squamous cell carcinoma. METHODS: We retrospectively reviewed our clinical records from July 1989 to June 1996 to identify 43 neck dissections in 39 patients who were found to have pathologically N2 or N3 neck disease treated primarily by neck dissection and postoperative radiotherapy. All patients had head and neck squamous cell carcinoma with a minimum follow-up of 24 months. RESULTS: Nine percent (4/43) of the dissected necks were pathologically N2a, 72% (31/43) were N2b, 7% (3/43) were N2c, and 12% (5/43) were N3. Of these, 28% (12/43) underwent a RND and 72% (31/43) underwent a MRND. The most common modification of RND was preservation of the spinal accessory nerve. All patients underwent postoperative radiotherapy with a mean dose of 55 Gy. Only 4 of 43 dissected necks had isolated treatment failure, for a regional control rate of 91%. CONCLUSIONS: The combination of RND or MRND and radiotherapy is highly effective in controlling neck disease in the absence of persistent or recurrent local disease. Also, in our experience, MRND appears to be as effective as RND in controlling even advanced neck disease, which supports preservation of the spinal accessory nerve whenever oncologically feasible.