The diagnostic yield in submitting nevi for histologic examination

BACKGROUND: Dermatologists have expertise in the clinical diagnosis of benign melanocytic nevi. However, there are no data to confirm the accuracy of diagnosis. Differences in the diagnostic accuracy between dermatologists and nondermatologists with regard to cutaneous tumors has been infrequently studied. OBJECTIVE: We examined the rate of malignant tumors occurring in lesions submitted for routine microscopic examination that were clinically diagnosed as benign melanocytic nevi. METHODS: We conducted a study at a regional, non-hospital-based dermatopathology laboratory using specimens submitted by physicians of various specialties who were practicing in a 5-state Midwest region of the United States. The preoperative and postoperative diagnoses were examined on the basis of information provided by the clinician and of the subsequent histopathologic diagnosis. A total of 7734 cutaneous pathology reports were reviewed. Specimens submitted with a preoperative clinical diagnosis of mole or nevus, with or without a modifier, were examined and compared with postoperative microscopic diagnoses. RESULTS: Of 1946 specimens clinically diagnosed and submitted as benign nevi, 45 (2.3%) were histologically diagnosed as malignant tumors. This included 12 melanomas, 30 basal cell carcinomas, and 3 squamous cell carcinomas. For specimens submitted by dermatologists, the rate of malignant tumors increased when clinical information suggested findings beyond the classic benign clinical presentation with the addition of modifiers such as irritated or atypical, or if a malignancy was considered in the differential diagnosis (trend for increasing clinical suspicion: P = .00002). Fewer dermatologists than nondermatologists mistook a malignant tumor for a benign nevus (1.3% vs 3.8%, P = .003). CONCLUSION: Our data document that 2.3% of clinically diagnosed benign nevi were microscopically diagnosed as malignant tumors. Whether this malignancy rate in clinically diagnosed, benign, melanocytic nevi is above or below the threshold to establish a policy for submission for histopathologic examination remains to be determined as a collective societal and medical professional responsibility.     

Intraepidermal distribution patterns of melanocytes in the melanocytic lesions on the sole: proposed criteria for histopathologic diagnosis of plantar malignant melanoma in situ

Eighty-eight melanocytic lesions on the soles of Japanese were histologically investigated. Increased numbers of solitary melanocytes above the basal layer of the epidermis were often found in the benign melanocytic nevi on the sole: in 5 lesions of 9 congenital melanocytic nevi, 22 of 65 acquired melanocytic nevi, and 1 of 5 dysplastic nevi. In addition, a moderate degree of nuclear atypia of proliferating melanocytes was frequently observed in the benign melanocytic nevi on the sole: in 3 lesions of 9 congenital melanocytic nevi, 17 of 65 acquired melanocytic nevi, and 2 of 5 dysplastic nevi. Therefore it cannot be said that increased numbers of solitary atypical melanocytes above the basal layer is a characteristic histologic feature of early malignant melanoma in situ. Combining the intraepidermal distribution patterns of melanocytes and maximum diameter of the lesion, we propose criteria for histopathologic diagnosis of plantar malignant melanoma in situ.     

Immunohistochemical expression of cyclooxygenage-2 in melanocytic skin lesions

Background Several reports have shown expression of cyclooxygenase‐2 (COX‐2) in malignant skin tumors. COX‐2 has also recently been reported as a marker of malignant melanoma (MM). Objective Our aim was to investigate whether there is a difference in the immunohistochemical expression of COX‐2 between malignant and benign melanocytic lesions of the skin. Methods We selected 40 archival cases of MM including 10 cases of superficial spreading melanoma, 10 of lentigo maligna melanoma, 10 of nodular melanoma, and 10 of acral lentiginous melanoma. For comparison, we also selected 35 benign melanocytic lesions, which included 15 nonatypical nevi and 10 atypical nevi. The remaining 10 cases were Spitz nevi. COX‐2 immunohistochemical staining was performed, and intensities were assessed quantitatively. Results The MM group and the benign melanocytic nevi group showed a highly statistically significant difference in the intensity of COX‐2 expression (P < 0.0001). Staining intensity in the dermal component of MM cases also showed a tendency to increase with increasing tumor depth. By contrast, the intensity of the dermal component in the melanocytic nevi group decreased with increasing depth as the nevus cells matured from type A to type C cells. No statistical difference was noted between the MM and Spitz nevi cases (P = 0.20). Conclusions Malignant melanoma shows stronger immunohistochemical expression of COX‐2 than benign melanocytic nevi. Although COX‐2 cannot be used alone to differentiate MM from melanocytic nevi, it may serve as an aid in the differential diagnosis of melanocytic skin lesions.     

BRAF mutation: a frequent event in benign, atypical, and malignant melanocytic lesions of the skin

BRAF mutations have recently been detected with a high frequency (66%) in cutaneous melanoma. All those mutations are activating, with a single substitution (T1796A) at codon 599 (V599E) accounting for over 90%. To investigate the stage in which those mutations occur in the currently proposed sequential malignant transformation of melanocytes, 22 benign melanocytic nevi, 23 melanocytic atypical nevi, and 25 primary cutaneous melanoma from 63 different patients were examined for BRAF mutations using DNA extracted from microdissected formalin-fixed and paraffin-embedded tissues, and a two-round PCR-RFLP-based strategy. A subset of samples was sequenced for mutation confirmation. Sixteen benign (73%) and eleven atypical (52%) melanocytic nevi, and thirteen melanoma (56%) demonstrated BRAF mutations at codon 599, and no statistically significant differences were detected among all three types of lesions. No mutations were demonstrated in microdissected epidermal keratinocytes adjacent to melanocytic lesions having BRAF mutations. No correlation was detected between BRAF mutational status and age, sun exposure, and Clark's level in malignant melanoma. However, comparing only atypical nevi and melanoma lesions the frequency of BRAF mutation is significantly greater in male (78%) than female (35%) patients (P = 0.0194). The previously described T1796A point mutation was detected in 17 of 18 mutated samples, and a novel mutation consisting of a substitution of valine for lysine (GT1795-96AA) was detected in one melanoma case. Our findings of a high frequency of BRAF mutations at codon 599 in benign melanocytic lesions of the skin indicate that this mutation is not sufficient by itself for malignant transformation.     

Significant melanocytic lesions in infancy, childhood, and adolescence

Malignant melanoma is diagnosed yearly in approximately 300 persons under age 20 in the United States. Relatively recent advances in dermatology include the recognition of lesions felt to be potential precursors of malignant melanoma. Small congenital melanocytic nevi, present in 1 per cent of all newborn infants, may have a small but definite potential for developing malignant melanoma. Furthermore, despite inconclusive data, many leading dermatologists now advocate removal of these small congenital lesions. Giant congenital melanocytic nevi, with their strong predilection for undergoing malignant change, are removed surgically at an early age, often in multistaged procedures. Dermabrasion, once felt to have a role in the treatment of giant congenital nevi, does not remove the malignant potential of these lesions. The dysplastic nevus syndrome, recognized in 1976, identifies individuals at increased risk for developing melanoma. Adolescents who have the dysplastic nevus syndrome or who are members of families with the syndrome require close medical supervision and patient education. The benign Spitz nevus, with its histologic similarity to malignant melanoma, continues to challenge the dermatopathologist and clinician. These lesions--the Spitz nevus, dysplastic nevus, congenital melanocytic nevus, and malignant melanoma--must all be actively considered when regarding the many other benign melanocytic lesions found in infancy, childhood, and adolescence.     

How well do physicians recognize melanoma and other problem lesions?

The alarming increase in the incidence of cutaneous malignant melanoma in the United States emphasizes the importance of its early detection and treatment. Early detection requires accurate clinical recognition of both malignant and precancerous skin lesions (dysplastic nevi). This study presents data on dermatologists' and nondermatologists' ability to diagnose skin lesions. A total of 105 nondermatologist physicians, from first-year residents to practicing physicians, and forty-eight dermatologists were asked to identify color slides or photographs of eleven cutaneous lesions, including malignant melanomas, dysplastic nevi, and innocuous lesions such as seborrheic keratoses and common moles. Diagnosis of cutaneous lesions was generally inaccurate among nondermatologists. Only 38% correctly identified four or more of the six melanomas as melanoma of any type, and 58% were unable to diagnose dysplastic nevi. Only 17% categorized their relevant training as excellent or good. Improved training in the diagnosis of skin lesions for practicing physicians and house staff is required if mortality from malignant melanoma is to be decreased in the United States.     

Digital computer analysis of dermatoscopical images of 260 melanocytic skin lesions; perimeter/area ratio for the differentiation between malignant melanomas and melanocytic nevi

BACKGROUND: Digital computer analysis of dermatoscopical images has been reported to facilitate the differential diagnosis of pigmented skin lesions in recent years. OBJECTIVE: The aim of our study was to perform digital computer analysis of a set of different melanocytic lesions and compare the objective results. METHODS: The set of 260 melanocytic lesions (150 excised difficult cases (46 melanomas, 47 atypical nevi, 57 common nevi and 110 unexcised common nevi) was automatically analysed by the digital dermatoscopical system microDERM. We searched for differences in asymmetry, size, compactness and colour distribution. Perimeter/area ratio was calculated. RESULTS: The perimeter/area ratio was detected as the most important criterion for differentiation between malignant and benign melanocytic lesions (sensitivity 91.3% and specificity 90.7% for malignant melanomas vs. all benign nevi; sensitivity 91.3% and specificity 80.8% for melanomas vs. clinically atypical nevi). Differences in size of the lesion, shape and asymmetry of colour were found and statistically verified. Using step-wise logistic regression the formula for calculation of probability of malignant nature of every analysed lesion was constructed. CONCLUSION: The perimeter/area ratio is a simple parameter for the differential diagnosis of melanocytic skin lesions.     

Correlation between dermoscopic and histopathological diagnoses of atypical nevi in a dermatology outpatient clinic of the Medical School of S?o José do Rio Preto,SP, Brazil

BACKGROUND

The incidence of cutaneous melanoma is increasing worldwide. Since it is an aggressive neoplasm, it is difficult to treat in advanced stages; early diagnosis is important to heal the patient. Melanocytic nevi are benign pigmented skin lesions while atypical nevi are associated with the risk of developing melanoma because they have a different histological pattern than common nevi. Thus, the clinical diagnosis of pigmented lesions is of great importance to differentiate benign, atypical and malignant lesions. Dermoscopy appeared as an auxiliary test in vivo, playing an important role in the diagnosis of pigmented lesions, because it allows the visualization of structures located below the stratum corneum. It shows a new morphological dimension of these lesions to the dermatologist and allows greater diagnostic accuracy. However, histopathology is considered the gold standard for the diagnosis.

OBJECTIVES

To establish the sensitivity and specificity of dermoscopy in the diagnosis of pigmented lesions suspected of malignancy (atypical nevi), comparing both the dermatoscopic with the histopathological diagnosis, at the Dermatology Service of the outpatient clinic of Hospital de Base, São José do Rio Preto, SP.

METHODS

Analysis of melanocytic nevi by dermoscopy and subsequent biopsy on suspicion of atypia or if the patient so desires, for subsequent histopathological diagnosis.

RESULTS

Sensitivity: 93%. Specificity: 42%.

CONCLUSIONS

Dermoscopy is a highly sensitive method for the diagnosis of atypical melanocytic nevi. Despite the low specificity with many false positive diagnoses, the method is effective for scanning lesions with suspected features of malignancy.     

Diagnostic and prognostic role of galectin 3 expression in cutaneous melanoma

Many of the histopathologic criteria used to diagnose melanoma overlap with atypical but otherwise benign naevi such as dysplastic or Spitz naevi. Galectin-3 is a member of the galectin gene family and is expressed at elevated levels in a variety of neoplastic cell types. The aim of the present study was to investigate the diagnostic value of galectin-3 expression compared with homatropine methyle bromide-45(HMB-45) (one of the established and widely used immunohistochemical melanocytic markers) together with assessment of its prognostic value in melanoma lesions. This study was carried out on 21 cases of melanoma and 20 benign pigmented naevi. Galectin-3 was expressed in all the examined benign and malignant melanocytic lesions. The nucleocytoplasmic pattern of galectin-3 appeared in malignant cases only with 42.86% sensitivity, 100% specificity, and 70.73% accuracy. This pattern tended to be associated with thick melanoma (P = 0.08) and reduced survival (P = 0.22). The intensity of galectin-3 assessed by H-score was significantly of higher values in malignant lesions compared with benign lesions (P < 0.0001). The best cut-off value for discrimination between benign and malignant melanocytic lesions was 295 with 95% sensitivity, 70% specificity, and 83% accuracy. The diagnostic power of galectin-3 in distinguishing between benign and malignant melanocytic lesions relies on the pattern and the intensity of its expression. The nucleocytoplasmic pattern of galectin-3 expression carries greater probability of a malignant phenotype and a poor prognostic impact on patients' outcome.     

Spitz Nevi and Other Spitzoid Neoplasms in Children: Overview of Incidence Data and Diagnostic Criteria

Spitz nevi are benign melanocytic neoplasms characterized by epithelioid or spindle melanocytes or both. In some rare cases their presentation overlaps with the clinical and histopathologic features of malignant melanoma, so a differential diagnosis can be difficult to make. Intermediate forms between Spitz nevi and malignant melanoma, with unpredictable behavior, have been called atypical Spitz tumors. A literature search was performed to review the clinical, dermoscopic, genetic, and histopathologic aspects of spitzoid tumors. Spitz nevi mainly occur in children, with no predilection for sex, and in young women. Common sites are the head and lower arms, where Spitz nevi present as pink nodules or hyperpigmented plaques. Spitzoid lesions may have diverse dermoscopic patterns: vascular, starburst, globular, atypical, reticular, negative homogeneous, or targetoid. The management of spitzoid lesions can be invasive or conservative; surgical excision is usually reserved for those with doubtful features, whereas clinical and dermoscopic follow‐up is preferred for typical pediatric Spitz nevi. The role of sentinel lymph node biopsy in atypical Spitz tumors is debated. Immunohistochemistry and new molecular techniques such as comparative genomic hybridization, polymerase chain reaction, and fluorescence in situ hybridization offer new diagnostic perspectives, investigating genetic alterations that are specific for malignant melanoma or for Spitz nevi.     

Dermoscopic patterns of benign volar melanocytic lesions in patients with atypical mole syndrome

BACKGROUND: Acral benign melanocytic lesions in white populations, particularly in subjects with atypical mole syndrome, have been poorly characterized until recently. The advent of dermoscopy has enabled more specific diagnoses of these pigmented skin lesions. OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the clinical and dermoscopic features of benign volar lesions in a group of white patients with atypical mole syndrome. SETTING: A private medical center specializing in early diagnosis of malignant melanoma and a melanoma unit in a university hospital. METHODS: Acral melanocytic lesions in 511 patients with atypical mole syndrome were studied using standard clinical assessment and dermoscopy. RESULTS: Two hundred ten acral melanocytic lesions were observed in 156 of the patients: 165 lesions were present on the soles of 121 patients and 45 lesions on the palms of 35 patients. No acral malignant lesions were detected. We observed the following patterns of lesions: parallel furrow in 111 lesions (52.9%), latticelike in 26 lesions (12.4%), fibrillar or filamentous in 13 lesions (6.2%), and nontypical in 29 lesions (13.8%). In 31 lesions (14.8%), we observed 3 previously undefined patterns: a globular pattern in 11 lesions (5.2%), a homogeneous pattern in 15 lesions (7.1%), and an acral reticular pattern in 5 lesions (2.4%). CONCLUSIONS: We observed a greater number of benign melanocytic lesions in glabrous skin than expected, probably related to our cohort selection of patients with atypical mole syndrome, although the lesions generally exhibited patterns on dermoscopy similar to those seen in Japanese studies. We defined 3 new benign dermoscopic patterns, which will enable better characterization of acral lesions.     

Neonatal giant congenital nevi with proliferative nodules: a clinicopathologic study and literature review of neonatal melanoma

BACKGROUND: Review of the literature reveals that congenital malignant melanoma is an exceptionally rare occurrence and has a generally poor prognosis when it does occur. However, benign proliferative melanocytic lesions are known to occur within giant congenital nevi (GCN). This entity is not well recognized and can be confused clinically and histologically with malignant change. OBSERVATIONS: We report 2 cases of GCN in neonates demonstrating benign proliferating nodules present at birth. An initial diagnosis of malignant melanoma was assumed in both cases. Careful histologic analysis, however, revealed these lesions to be benign, as did long-term follow-up of 3.5 years, with both patients remaining well with no evidence of melanoma. Review of the literature suggests that there are 2 clinical patterns of these benign nodules arising within GCNs: small (<1 cm) and large (>1 cm) dermal nodules with varying histologic patterns that we have attempted to categorize. CONCLUSIONS: Our cases illustrate the difficulty in accurate diagnosis of melanocytic lesions in the neonate. We recommend caution in making a diagnosis of malignant melanoma and highlight the possibility that benign lesions can be mistaken for melanoma in this age group. We encourage the acquisition of fixed histologic specimens for accurate diagnosis of melanocytic lesions.     

Comparison of pHH3, Ki-67, and survivin immunoreactivity in benign and malignant melanocytic lesions

Differentiating malignant melanoma from benign melanocytic lesions can be challenging. We undertook this study to evaluate the use of the immunohistochemical mitosis marker phospho-Histone H3 (pHH3) and the proliferation markers Ki-67 and survivin in separating malignant melanoma from benign nevi. Sixty-six melanocytic lesions (18 malignant melanomas, 8 Spitz nevi, 20 dysplastic nevi, and 20 compound nevi) were stained with antibodies to pHH3, Ki-67, and survivin. No pHH3 expression was detected in the dermis of compound and dysplastic nevi. Rare mitoses were observed in the superficial dermis in 3 of 8 Spitz nevi (37%). Staining for pHH3 was higher in malignant melanomas [average 25 per 10 high-power field (HPF), range 2-75 per 10 HPF] than in Spitz nevi (average 0.5 per 10 HPF, range 0-2 per 10 HPF) and was heterogeneously distributed in the malignant melanomas compared with a superficial dermal location in Spitz nevi. There was no cytoplasmic staining for survivin in any of the 66 melanocytic lesions and no nuclear staining in any of the benign ones. Survivin nuclear staining was present in 12 of 18 cases of malignant melanoma (67%) with an average index of 7% (range 0%-15%). In benign melanocytic lesions, the Ki-67 index was less than 5% (range 0%-4%) and staining was present close to the dermo-epidermal junction compared with an average index of 27% in melanomas (range 5%-50%) and a generally heterogeneous pattern of staining throughout the dermis. pHH3 and Ki-67 can be useful adjuncts to histopathology to separate malignant melanoma from benign nevi. pHH3 is especially useful to highlight mitoses and to rapidly assess the mitotic activity in melanocytic lesions.     

Follow-up of melanocytic skin lesions with digital epiluminescence microscopy: patterns of modifications observed in early melanoma, atypical nevi, and common nevi

BACKGROUND: Digital epiluminescence microscopy (DELM) has been reported to be a useful technique for the follow-up of melanocytic nevi. One of the promises of this technique is to identify modifications over time that indicate impending or incipient malignancy and to facilitate surveillance of melanocytic skin lesions, particularly in patients with multiple clinically atypical nevi. OBJECTIVE: Our purpose was to report on patterns of modifications over time observed in benign melanocytic skin lesions and melanoma. METHODS: A total of 1862 sequentially recorded DELM images of melanocytic lesions from 202 patients (mean age, 36.1 years; 54.0% female patients) with multiple clinically atypical nevi were included in the analysis. The median follow-up interval was 12. 6 months. Melanocytic lesions with substantial modifications over time (enlargement, changes in shape, regression, color changes or appearance of ELM structures known to be associated with melanoma) were excised and referred to histopathologic examination. RESULTS: A total of 75 melanocytic skin lesions (4.0%) from 52 patients (mean age, 33.3 years; 63.5% female patients) showed substantial modifications over time and were excised and referred to histopathologic examination. Eight changing lesions were histologically diagnosed as early melanomas. These lesions frequently showed focal enlargement associated with a change in shape as well as appearance of ELM structures that are known to be associated with melanoma. In contrast, the majority of benign changing lesions (common and atypical nevi) showed symmetric enlargement without substantial structural ELM changes. Six of the 8 patients in whom melanoma developed were unaware of the fact that the lesion had changed over time. CONCLUSION: We demonstrate that follow-up of melanocytic lesions with DELM helps to identify patterns of morphologic modifications typical for early melanoma. DELM may therefore serve as a useful tool to improve the surveillance of patients with multiple atypical nevi.     

Multiple skin metastases of malignant melanoma with unusual clinical and histopathologic features in an immunosuppressed patient

Immunosuppressive regimens may have significant impact on the number of pigmented lesions and the clinical appearance of nevi. Whether immunosuppression can also influence the clinical and histopathologic appearance of malignant melanocytic lesions is still a matter of debate. A patient was immunosuppressed because of heart and bone marrow transplantation. A clinically inconspicuous mole was removed from the left flank and was considered to be a papillomatous nevus. After 1 year, the patient developed multiple pigmented lesions over the entire body, which presented clinically as benign papillomatous nevi and histologically as atypical Spitz nevi. Three months later melanoma metastases were removed from the patient's left axilla, which finally resulted in the death of the patient. Thus, in retrospect, the eruptive pigmented lesions have to be considered as cutaneous melanoma metastases. The atypical clinical and histopathologic appearance of the melanocytic lesions as well as the course of disease may have been influenced by the immunosuppression.     

Nevo de Spitz y otros tumores spitzoides en la infancia. Parte 1: aspectos clínicos,histológicos e inmunohistoquímicos

A Spitz nevus is a melanocytic neoplasm of epithelioid and/or spindle cells that usually appears in childhood. These lesions are by nature benign, but their features can sometimes make them difficult to distinguish from melanomas. Spitzoid melanocytic lesions have been grouped into 3 types in recent decades: Spitz nevi, atypical Spitz tumors, and spitzoid melanomas. Atypical Spitz tumors are spitzoid melanocytic proliferations that have atypical histopathologic features that are insufficient to support a diagnosis of melanoma. The malignant potential of these lesions is at present uncertain. This review examines the clinical, dermoscopic, and histopathologic features of this group of lesions.     

Significance of dermoscopic patterns in detecting malignant melanoma on acral volar skin: results of a multicenter study in Japan

OBJECTIVE: To determine diagnostic variables such as sensitivity and specificity of the major dermoscopic patterns observed in melanocytic lesions on acral volar skin, with particular attention to the significance of the parallel ridge pattern and irregular diffuse pigmentation in detecting acral melanoma. DESIGN: Multicenter, retrospective study. SETTING: University hospitals in Japan. PATIENTS: Patients with melanocytic lesions on acral volar skin. A total of 712 melanocytic lesions (103 malignant melanomas, including 36 in situ lesions, and 609 melanocytic nevi) were consecutively collected from the files of 3 hospitals. Diagnoses of all the lesions had been determined histopathologically. INTERVENTIONS: Dermoscopic examination. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: The sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value, negative predictive value, and diagnostic accuracy of the major dermoscopic patterns seen in benign and malignant melanocytic lesions on acral volar skin. RESULTS: The parallel ridge pattern and irregular diffuse pigmentation showed extremely high specificity (99.0% and 96.6%, respectively) and very high negative predictive value (97.7% and 97.5%, respectively) in malignant melanoma. For melanoma in situ, the positive predictive value and diagnostic accuracy of the parallel ridge pattern were significantly higher than those of irregular diffuse pigmentation (P = .009 and P = .006, respectively). In melanocytic nevi, the specificity and positive predictive value of the parallel furrow pattern and/or the latticelike pattern were found to be very high (93.2% and 98.3%, respectively). CONCLUSIONS: Dermoscopy is immensely helpful in differentiating malignant melanomas from melanocytic nevi on acral volar skin. Moreover, the parallel ridge pattern aids in detecting acral melanomas in early, curable stages.     

Melanocytic nevi clinically simulating melanoma

Melanoma and other benign or malignant pigmented skin tumors can significantly overlap in their clinical and dermoscopical presentations. Thus, pigmented skin lesions may be misdiagnosed in a large number of cases. An extensive review of the published work provides numerous examples of benign lesions mimicking melanoma. Although a number of melanocytic nevi may have been identified as melanomas, information about their clinical appearance is limited. In this report, we present the clinical appearances of two melanocytic nevi on the vulva and the upper extremity that were difficult to diagnose clinically. Detecting melanoma at an early stage is of the utmost importance. However, more attention should be given to the diagnostic accuracy of benign pigmented skin lesions, which otherwise may be diagnosed and treated as melanoma.     

Melanocytic proliferations associated with lichen sclerosus.

OBJECTIVES: To describe the clinicopathologic features of melanocytic proliferations associated with lichen sclerosus (LS) and to compare these findings with those in controls. DESIGN: Cohort study. SETTING: Academic and private practice dermatology and dermatopathology services. PATIENTS: Cases of melanocytic proliferations associated with LS and consecutive controls with persistent (recurrent) melanocytic nevi, persistent malignant melanomas, and compound melanocytic nevi. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Diagnostic criteria and disease recurrence. RESULTS: Eleven patients, all female, with a mean age of 40 years (range, 8-83 years), presented with pigmented lesions clinically suspected to be malignant melanoma or atypical melanocytic nevi affecting the vulva (7 patients), perineum (3 patients), or chest (1 patient). Lichen sclerosus was first identified in the biopsy specimen and subsequently confirmed clinically. In 10 cases, a melanocytic nevus was superimposed on LS (overlying or entrapped by sclerosis), whereas LS was found at the periphery of vulvar malignant melanoma. After complete excision, no recurrences have been reported for the melanocytic nevi in LS (mean follow-up, 29 months; range, 4-60 months). Compared with control lesions, the LS melanocytic nevi most closely resembled persistent melanocytic nevi and could be distinguished from persistent malignant melanoma histologically. Melanocytes, nevoid or malignant, proliferating contiguously with fibrotic or sclerotic collagen, contained abundant melanin, diffusely expressed HMB-45, and had a higher Ki-67 labeling index than ordinary melanocytic nevi. However, persistent malignant melanoma exhibited mitotic figures, significantly higher Ki-67 labeling index, and deep dermal HMB-45 expression compared with LS melanocytic nevi and persistent melanocytic nevi. CONCLUSIONS: Melanocytic nevi occurring in LS have features in common with persistent melanocytic nevi and can mimic malignant melanoma. An "activated" melanocytic phenotype is seen in LS melanocytic nevi, implicating a stromal-induced change.