Functional versus structural matching: can the CTLp test be replaced by HLA allele typing?

Human leukocyte antigen (HLA) incompatibilities are the most important immunological barriers to bone marrow transplant success when using unrelated donors. Until recently, standards for donor selection included serological methods for HLA class I antigens and DNA-based typing for HLA class II alleles. In our center cytotoxic T-lymphocyte precursor (CTLp) assays have been an integrated part of the search selection procedure as well. More recently, DNA-based typing for HLA class I became available. This allowed us to determine the correlation of CTLp frequencies directed against incompatibilities at the HLA-A, -B, and -C locus in 211 donor-recipient pairs. HLA class I incompatibilities are significantly (p < 0.001) associated with high CTLp frequencies. Exceptions did occur, high CTLp frequencies are seen in 14% of the HLA-A, -B, and -C allele matched pairs, whereas in 7% of the pairs mismatched for HLA-A or -B a low CTLp frequency occurred. The successful outcome of transplants performed in the latter cases suggest that the CTLp test can be used as a tool to detect permissible mismatches when no fully matched donor is available. The influence of HLA-C mismatches on the CTLp outcome was less clear. Although in the majority of mismatched pairs (64%) the CTLp frequency was high, in 36% of the pairs the CTLp frequency was low. Analysis of HLA amino acid sequences was performed on the HLA-C allele mismatched group. An amino acid difference was always found at five polymorphic positions 97, 99, 113, 114, and 116 situated at the peptide binding groove in the high CTLp frequency group, whereas in the low CTLp frequency group this was observed in only 9 of 17 combinations (p < 0.001). However, this is mainly due to Cw*0303-0304 mismatches. In conclusion, although there is a highly significant correlation between the outcome of the CTLp frequency test and HLA allele class I typing, exceptions occur. It is unclear whether they are all clinically relevant but they certainly provide additional insight in allograft recognition.     

In vitro CTL precursor frequencies do not reflect a beneficial effect of cross-reactive group (CREG) matching

Adjustment of histocompatibility-based allocation criteria in kidney transplantation from HLA matching to matching on the basis of cross-reactive groups (CREG), was recently suggested to be a good alternative to transplant with more "well-matched" kidneys, without negatively influencing graft survival. Because graft rejection is often mediated by cytotoxic T cells (CTLs), we investigated whether a beneficial effect of CREG matching is reflected in vitro by lower CTL precursor frequencies (CTLpf). Therefore, CTLpf were determined in a group of healthy individuals and analyzed with respect to the number of HLA and CREG mismatches. A clear correlation was found between the number of HLA mismatches and the CTLpf, that is, the lowest mean frequency in case of 0 HLA-A, B mismatches (66 CTL precursors per 10(6) cells) and the highest in combinations with 4 HLA mismatches (mean = 303 CTLp/10(6) cells). The situation was different in the case of CREG mismatches. Although the highest frequency was found in the group of 4 CREG mismatches, no significant differences were observed between 0, 1, and 2 CREG mismatches. High CTLpf, up to 430/10(6), were even seen in the case of 0 CREG mismatches. Also within a well-defined group of single HLA-A or HLA-B mismatches no difference in CTLpf were observed between the subgroups with 0 vs. 1 CREG mismatches. The present study showed that in vitro the CTLpf correlates better with HLA than with CREG matching. These data are consistent with findings reported by several groups that matching for the CREG does not benefit transplant outcome.     

The T-cell repertoire is not dictated by self antigens alone.

The influence of genetic and environmental factors on the functional cytotoxic T cell (CTL) allorepertoire was studied by comparing the CTL precursor frequencies against the same HLA alloantigens in 116 sibling pairs. A significantly different precursor frequency was found in 68%, 61% and 59% of siblings sharing 0, 1 and 2 HLA haplotypes, respectively. These data show that, although HLA is important in determining the T-cell repertoire, this is hardly reflected in the allorepertoire. Even 50% of the monozygotic twin pairs showed a significant disparity in their CTL allorepertoire, indicating that environmental factors play a role as well. The non-inherited maternal HLA antigens could be identified as one of the environmental factors shaping the CTL allorepertoire.     

Analysis of cytotoxic T cell precursor frequencies directed against individual HLA-A and -B alloantigens

We describe here a limiting dilution analysis to determine cytotoxic T lymphocyte precursor (CTLp) frequencies against individual HLA-A or -B antigens. This assay is reproducible and showed that the CTLp frequency of an individual remains stable with time. Significant variations in CTLp frequency against the same alloantigen were found in different individuals and even in monozygotic twins, showing that these differences were not (completely) genetically determined. Within an individual, a wide range of CTLp frequencies can be found against different allo-antigens. Serologically cross-reactivity seems not to interfere in this assay. This LDA is a practicable tool for a systematic analysis of CTLp response against selected individual HLA-A or -B antigens and can be used for the selection of HLA mismatched donors for transplantation patients.     

Comparison of the humoral and cytotoxic T-lymphocyte response to individual HLA class I alloantigens in highly immunized patients

In order to investigate the correlation between activation of cytotoxic T-lymphocyte precursor (CTLp) and the formation of antibodies to alloantigens, we studied 21 highly sensitized patients waiting for a kidney transplantation. Both antibody reactivity and CTLp frequencies of these patients were determined against 88 individual HLA class I alloantigens. A high or low CTLp frequency against a certain HLA-A or -B alloantigen was not correlated with the presence or absence of the antibodies to that antigen. Mismatched antigens, towards which the patient had not formed antibodies, can induce either a higher or a lower frequency of CTLp compared to mismatches towards which the patients had formed antibodies. The possible implications of this lack of correlation between the T- and B-cell allorepertoires with regard to donor selection for (highly immunized) patients is discussed.     

Kinetics of the pregnancy-induced humoral and cellular immune response against the paternal HLA class I antigens of the child

Pregnancy can prime the maternal humoral immune response against paternal human leukocyte antigens (HLA) of the child. Previous studies have reported that formation of antibodies against inherited paternal HLA is associated with the presence of primed cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) specific for these antigens. Recently, we reported that primed CTLs can persist for more than 10 years after pregnancy even if the antibodies have disappeared. In the present study we studied the kinetics of the pregnancy induced immune response of the T-cell and B-cell compartment. In 12 women, who had specific antibodies against the paternal HLA antigens of the child (child mismatch) at the time of delivery, we analyzed the CTLp frequencies against the paternal HLA antigens from the time of delivery up to 2 years after. The contribution of primed CTLs to these CTLp frequencies was tested by limiting dilution analysis in the absence and presence of monoclonal antibodies specific for CD8. In contrast to na?ve CTLs, primed CTLs are resistant to CD8 antibodies. Disappearance of the antibodies was not associated with a decrease of the number of CTLp directed against the paternal antigens, towards which the antibodies were originally directed. However, in women where the antibodies disappeared, a decrease of primed child mismatch specific CTLs was found, whereas in women where the antibodies persist, the population of primed CTLs remained stable up to 2 years after delivery. Our data suggest a functional correlation between the T-cell and B-cell allorepertoire. Although the kinetics do not run completely in parallel, disappearance of the anti-HLA antibodies in the first 2 years after delivery is related with a decrease of primed child mismatch specific CTLs. These data may be relevant for transplantation of female recipients with historical, pregnancy-induced HLA alloantibodies.     

Limiting-dilution analysis of the HLA restriction of anti-Epstein-Barr virus-specific cytolytic T lymphocytes.

Human Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) play an important role in maintaining the virus/host equilibrium during persistent infections. We analysed precursors of anti-EBV CTL by the limiting-dilution technique. Seven healthy EBV-seropositive and two EBV-seronegative donors were tested. All the donors seropositive for EBV gave clear-cut positive results, and it was remarkable that the frequency of CTL precursors (CTLp) observed was much higher than that reported for other viruses. In contrast, in the seronegative donors the frequency of CTLp was undetectable. The CTLp were derived from the CD4-CD8+ population only, although EBV-specific CD4+ cytolytic T cell clones have been described. A study of the HLA restriction showed that some HLA-A or HLA-B antigens can function as preferential restricting molecules, but that CTLp restricted by the other HLA-A or HLA-B molecules also exist. However, the dominant population of CTL present in primary responses is sometimes different from that of long term cell lines established from the same donor.     

Differential immunogenicity of paternal HLA Class I antigens in pregnant women

More insight into the differential immunogenicity of human leukocyte antigen (HLA) mismatches will be beneficial for donor selection in clinical transplantation. In this study the immunogenicity of HLA antigens was analyzed by examining the antibody profiles in women who have been pregnant. In total 888 women, who had pregnancy induced HLA alloantibodies, were included in this study, while 413 women who had not been immunized by their pregnancy, served as controls. First it was analyzed whether women expressing particular HLA antigens are more likely to produce HLA alloantibodies. Next we determined whether certain HLA mismatches of their children are more immunogenic than other ones. Finally we studied whether the immunogenicity of specific HLA mismatches is dependent on the HLA phenotype of the women. Women expressing HLA-A3, HLA-A32, and HLA-B21 are more likely to produce alloantibodies whereas women expressing HLA-B13 and HLA-B17 have a significantly lower incidence of alloantibodies compared with women expressing other HLA antigens. Children with HLA-A2 or HLA-B5 mismatches induced alloantibodies significantly more often whereas children with HLA-A30, -A31 or -A33 and HLA-A28 induced alloantibodies significantly less often than children with other HLA class I mismatches. Finally we could demonstrate that the immunogenicity of a particular HLA mismatch is dependent on the HLA phenotype of the women. Information on the differential immunogenicity of HLA mismatches may be of benefit for the determination of acceptable and taboo mismatches in the case of donor selection for (highly sensitized) patients.     

Characteristics of graft-infiltrating lymphocytes after human heart transplantation HLA mismatches and the cellular immune response within the transplanted heart

The influence of HLA mismatches between donor and recipient on the phenotypes, function, and specificity of T-lymphocyte cultures derived from endomyocardial biopsies was studied in 118 heart transplant recipients. In case of HLA-DR mismatches, the majority of the EMB-derived cultures were dominated by CD4⁺ T cells while, in patients with HLA-A and -B mismatches but without DR mismatches, CD8⁺ T cells comprised the predominant T-cell subset. Cytotoxicity against donor antigens was observed in 75% of the cultures. A significantly (p < 0.005) lower proportion of the cultures showed cytotoxicity against HLA-A antigens (36%) when compared with HLA-B (53%) or HLA-DR (49%). An HLA-A2 mismatch elicited a cytotoxic response that was comparable to that found against HLA-B and -DR antigens: 62% of the cultures from HLA-A2 mismatched donor-recipient combinations was reactive against A2. A higher number of A, B, or DR mismatches resulted in a higher number of cytotoxic cultures directed against these antigens. A higher number of HLA-B and -DR mismatches was associated with a lower freedom from rejection. Our data indicate that, despite the use of adequate immunosuppressive therapy, the degree of HLA matching plays a crucial role in the immune response against a transplanted heart, resulting in a significant effect on freedom from rejection.     

HLA-DQ mismatches stimulate de novo donor specific antibodies in heart transplant recipients

The development of donor specific antibody is associated with graft rejection and increased mortality in solid organ transplant recipients. The majority of de novo donor specific antibodies (dnDSA) are against HLA-DQ antigens, but it has not been investigated if this is caused by more mismatches in the HLA-DQ locus between the recipient and donor. Here we examined the impact of HLA mismatches in eight HLA loci on the development of dnDSA and on rejection in a large cohort of heart transplant recipients. We evaluated HLA mismatches at the antigen level, the eplet level using HLAMatchmaker, and the epitope level using the PIRCHE algorithm. We found that the majority of dnDSA were against HLA-DQ antigens, and the number of dnDSA per mismatch is highest for HLA-DQ compared to other HLA loci. Furthermore, mismatches of HLA-DQ at the epitope level were associated with antibody-mediated rejection. Our results suggest that HLA mismatches at the HLA-DQ locus are more immunogenic than mismatches at other HLA loci to stimulate the development of dnDSA and to cause graft rejection.     

Pregnancy can induce long-persisting primed CTLs specific for inherited paternal HLA antigens

Previous studies showed that pregnancy can prime the maternal cellular immune response directed against paternal HLA antigens. Primed CTLs specific for inherited paternal HLA antigens (IPA) were found in women who had formed HLA allo antibodies, whereas naive CTLs were present in women who did not form antibodies against the paternal HLA antigens. As HLA allo antibodies may disappear in time, it is not clear which women on the waiting list for transplantation have been sensitized to paternal HLA antigens and are at risk for graft rejection if paternal HLA antigens are shared by the donor organ. The presence of primed CTLs specific for a particular antigen is considered to be a reflection of sensitization.In the present study we investigated whether these primed CTLs persist in women who had been pregnant and had formed antibodies against the inherited paternal HLA class I antigens. For this purpose 14 women who had their last pregnancy 10 years ago were analyzed with respect to IPA-specific CTLp frequencies and the presence of high avidity CTLs directed against inherited paternal HLA class I antigens.Although primed CTLs specific for IPA's were found more frequently in women with persisting alloantibodies, they still can be detected when the antibodies have disappeared. The current data show that primed CTLs directed against inherited paternal HLA antigens towards which antibodies have been formed in the past can persist for more than 10 years after pregnancy. The cellular test used in our study can be useful to detect presensitization in women with a history of pregnancy, who enter the waiting list for transplantation.     

HLAMatchmaker-Defined Triplet Matching Is Not Associated with Better Survival Rates of Patients with Class I HLA Allele Mismatched Hematopoietic Cell Transplants from Unrelated Donors

This report addresses the concept that permissible HLA mismatching, that is, mismatches that do not generate an allogeneic response, in hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (HCT) can be determined with structural similarity of polymorphic regions. We have applied the triplet version of a structural algorithm called HLAMatchmaker, which considers short sequences involving polymorphic amino acid residues on the molecular surface as key elements of immunogenic epitopes. The triplet matching effect was analyzed in a National Marrow Donor Program dataset consisting of 744 unrelated hematopoietic cell transplantation cases with 1 HLA-A, -B, or -C mismatch and 1690 fully HLA-A, -B, -C, -DR, or -DQ allele matched cases. In multivariate models adjusting for other significant clinical risk factors, the degree of triplet mismatching did not significantly correlate with patient survival, engraftment, or acute graft-versus-host disease (aGVHD). Other structurally based strategies should be pursued to identify permissible HLA mismatches in HCT.     

Differences in the antigens recognized by cytolytic T cells on two successive metastases of a melanoma patient are consistent with immune selection

We have studied the patterns of antigens recognized by autologous cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL) on two melanoma cell lines derived from metastases that were removed from patient LB33 at several years distance. Cell line LB33-MEL. A was obtained after surgery in 1988. A large number of CTL clones directed against LB33-MEL. A was obtained with blood lymphocytes collected from the patient in 1990. In vitro selection of melanoma cells that were resistant to these CTL clones indicated that at least five different antigens were recognized on LB33-MEL. A by autologous CTL. Four of these antigens were found to be presented by HLA-A28, B13, B44 and Cw6, respectively. The patient remained disease-free until 1993 when a metastasis was detected and was used to obtain cell line LB33-MEL. B. This cell line proved resistant to lysis by all the CTL clones directed against the LB33-MEL. A cells and showed no expression of HLA class I molecules except for HLA-A24. Using LB33-MEL. B cells to stimulate blood lymphocytes collected from the patient in 1994 we derived CTL clones that lysed these cells. All these CTL clones recognized a new antigen presented by HLA-A24. These results suggest that in patient LB33 the melanoma cells may have lost the expression of several HLA molecules under the selective pressure of an anti-tumor CTL response.     

HLA and Kaposi's sarcoma in solid organ transplantation

Of 188 cases of Kaposi's sarcoma arising de novo after transplantation, HLA-A, -B typing was available for 135 and HLA-DR typing available for 67. Compared to the reported HLA phenotype frequencies of renal transplant recipients in the Southeast Organ Procurement Foundation (SEOPF), there is a significantly decreased frequency of HLA-A1 and HLA-B7, and increased frequency of HLA-B5, -B8, -B18, and -DR5. The most striking characteristic of the Kaposi's sarcoma group was its ethnic background. Fifty-six percent of patients were Italian, Greek, Jewish, or Arabic. When this ethnic background is considered, the expected HLA phenotype frequencies are almost exactly the same as in the Kaposi's sarcoma population. The quality of donor-recipient HLA match was evaluable for 106 patients. Only 22% had four or more mismatches, and 59% had at least two antigens matched. This argues against poor donor-recipient matching as a risk factor for developing Kaposi's sarcoma after transplantation.     

Association of Bw4/Bw6 mismatch across class I HLA loci with renal graft outcomes in first time transplants

Bw4 and Bw6 are strongly immunogenic epitopes routinely assigned based on HLA-B typing results per Organ Procurement and Transplantation Network (OPTN) policies. These public epitopes and their variants are shared by some cross-reactive HLA-A and -C antigens. Although epitope mismatch has been associated with poor transplant outcomes, previous studies did not find such associations for Bw4/6 mismatch as defined by HLA-B antigens only. We hypothesized that a broader definition for Bw4/Bw6 mismatch that includes cross-reactive HLA-A and -C antigens may reveal the risk associated with these epitopes. In this retrospective cohort study, we examined kidney transplantations between 2000 and 2016 in the OPTN database and determined the association of Bw4/6 mismatch across all class I HLA antigens and renal graft outcomes. Even by this broader definition, Bw4/6 mismatch was not independently associated with 1-year graft rejection (adjusted OR: 0.99, 95%CI 0.93–1.06) or death-censored graft survival (adjusted HR: 1.02, 95%CI 1.00–1.05). There was no significant association among recipients who were already sensitized at transplant either. Our findings suggest that Bw4/6 mismatch alone is not associated with poor renal graft outcomes despite their strong immunogenicity, and the load of epitope mismatches over a certain threshold is likely required to cause adverse clinical consequences.     

Good kidney transplant outcome in recipients with presensitization against HLA class II but not HLA class I

It is a matter of debate whether pretransplant anti-human leukocyte antigen (HLA) class II antibodies contribute to the increased graft rejection rate found in presensitized recipients. We investigated the influence of preformed anti-HLA class II antibodies on graft survival in 5949 cadaver kidney transplants. Pretransplant recipient sera were tested in enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) for immunoglobulin (Ig)G-anti-HLA class I and IgG-anti-HLA class II antibodies. A total of 672 recipients with antibodies against HLA class II but not against HLA class I had a 3-year graft survival rate of 80 +/- 2%, identical to the 80 +/- 1% rate in 4561 recipients who were negative for anti-HLA class I and II (p = NS). Graft survival was significantly lower in 365 recipients who were positive for both anti-HLA class I and II (65 +/- 3%, p < 0.0001). Compatibility for HLA-A+B+DR influenced graft survival significantly in anti-HLA class I- and II-positive recipients (p = 0.0016), whereas no significant HLA effect was found in patients with antibodies directed against only class I or II. Surprisingly, not even incompatibility for HLA class II antigens of the DR locus caused a significant impairment of graft survival in anti-class II-positive recipients. We conclude that the risk associated with sensitization against HLA class II in the absence of sensitization against HLA class I is negligible.     

Racial differences in the survival of cadaveric renal allografts. Overriding effects of HLA matching and socioeconomic factors.

BACKGROUND. The long-term survival of cadaveric renal allografts is lower in black recipients than in white recipients, although the one-year graft survival is similar in these racial groups. We sought to determine what factors account for this disparity. METHODS. We studied 100 consecutive recipients of primary cadaveric renal allografts (57 were black and 43 white) at least 1 year after transplantation (mean, 40 months); all had received identical immunosuppressive therapy. We evaluated differences in the cause and duration of end-stage renal disease, the number of pretransplantation transfusions, age, matching for HLA-A, B, and DR antigens, race of the donor, insurance coverage, and compliance to assess their effect on graft survival in both groups. RESULTS. Allograft survival after one year was significantly lower in black than in white patients (P = 0.025). According to univariate analysis, only the recipient's age at transplantation, the number of mismatches for HLA antigens, the type of insurance coverage, the source of referral for transplantation, and the degree of compliance correlated significantly with the rate of graft survival. The frequency of all variables that reduced graft survival was higher among the blacks. According to proportional-hazards analysis, the only factors contributing to a lower rate of graft survival were age of less than 30 years at transplantation (relative risk, 2.3; 95 percent confidence interval, 1.3 to 4.6), mismatches for all six HLA antigens as compared with three or fewer mismatches (relative risk, 5.6; 95 percent confidence interval, 3.3 to 9.6), and coverage by Medicaid or Medicare (relative risk, 2.2; 95 percent confidence interval, 1.5 to 3.2). Race had no additional effect. Noncompliance was more frequent among blacks (16 percent vs. 2 percent) and could substitute for insurance status in the model. CONCLUSIONS. When immunosuppression is equivalent in black and white transplant recipients, apparently race-related differences in the long-term survival of renal cadaveric allografts appear to be related to other factors that affect graft survival unfavorably, notably poor HLA matching and unfavorable socioeconomic factors.     

Anti-influenza human T killer cells present an intertypic activity anti-A and -B type viruses in a secondary reaction in vitro.

In man influenza viruses induce a cytolytic T lymphocyte (CTL) activity directed against autologous or HLA-A or -B compatible target cells infected with the immunizing virus. While only type specific CTL are characterized in man, we report here experiments showing intertypic activities of human CTL from donors vaccinated with both A and B type influenza viruses. Their peripheral blood leucocytes (PBL) restimulated in vitro with live influenza virus of one type gave rise to both anti-A and -B activities, when non-infected or Sendaï infected target cells were not lysed. These intertypic activities were restricted by HLA-A or -B antigens and were inhibited by OKT3 antibody. When u.v.-inactivated viruses were used as restimulating antigen, no intertypic CTL were obtained. The results of competition experiments with cold targets show that no common antigens were recognized by anti-A and anti-B CTL. Moreover the restricting HLA-A or -B molecules seen in association with A or B types viruses appeared different in the same experiment, confirming that different antigens were probably involved for the agents of A and B subgroups. This influenza specific intertypic activity was therefore probably due to an intertypic stimulation of type specific CTL activities, possibly arising at the level of T helper cells.