Clinical variability in calpainopathy: what makes the difference?

Limb girdle muscular dystrophies (LGMD) are a heterogeneous group of genetic disorders characterised by progressive weakness of the pelvic and shoulder girdle muscles and a great variability in clinical course. LGMD2A, the most prevalent form of LGMD, is caused by mutations in the calpain-3 gene (CAPN-3). More than 100 pathogenic mutations have been identified to date, however few genotype : phenotype correlation studies, including both DNA and protein analysis, have been reported. In this study we screened 26 unrelated LGMD2A Brazilian families (75 patients) through Single-Stranded Conformation Polymorphism (SSCP), Denaturing high-performance liquid chromatography (DHPLC) and sequencing of abnormal fragments which allowed the identification of 47 mutated alleles (approximately 90%). We identified two recurrent mutations (R110X and 2362-2363AG > TCATCT) and seven novel pathogenic mutations. Interestingly, 41 of the identified mutations (approximately 80%) were concentrated in only 6 exons (1, 2, 4, 5, 11 and 22), which has important implications for diagnostic purposes. Protein analysis, performed in 28 patients from 25 unrelated families showed that with exception of one patient (with normal/slight borderline reduction of calpain) all others had total or partial calpain deficiency. The effects of type of mutation, amount of calpain in the muscle, gender and ethnicity of affected patients on clinical course (age of onset and ascertainment) were analysed. Interestingly, it was observed that, on average, African-Brazilian calpainopathy patients are more severely affected than Caucasians.     

A single c.1715G>C calpain 3 gene variant causes dominant calpainopathy with loss of calpain 3 expression and activity

Recessively inherited limb girdle muscular dystrophy (LGMD) type 2A is the most common LGMD worldwide. Here, we report the first single missense variant in CAPN3 causing dominantly inherited calpainopathy. A 43‐year‐old proband, his father and two sons were heterozygous for a c.1715G>C p.(Arg572Pro) variant in CAPN3. Affected family members had at least three of the following; muscle pain, a LGMD2A pattern of muscle weakness and wasting, muscle fat replacement on magnetic resonance imaging, myopathic muscle biopsy, and elevated creatine kinase. Total calpain 3 protein expression was 4 ± 3% of normal. In vitro analysis of c.1715G>C and the previously described c.643_663del variant indicated that the mutant proteins lack autolytic and proteolytic activity and decrease the quantity of wild‐type CAPN3 protein. Our findings suggest that dominantly inherited calpainopathy is not unique to the previously reported c.643_663del mutation of CAPN3, and that dominantly inherited calpainopathy should be considered for other single variations in CAPN3.     

Mutations in the fukutin-related protein gene (FKRP) identify limb girdle muscular dystrophy 2I as a milder allelic variant of congenital muscular dystrophy MDC1C.

The limb girdle and congenital muscular dystrophies (LGMD and CMD) are characterized by skeletal muscle weakness and dystrophic muscle changes. The onset of symptoms in CMD is within the first few months of life, whereas in LGMD they can occur in late childhood, adolescence or adult life. We have recently demonstrated that the fukutin-related protein gene (FKRP) is mutated in a severe form of CMD (MDC1C), characterized by the inability to walk, leg muscle hypertrophy and a secondary deficiency of laminin alpha2 and alpha-dystroglycan. Both MDC1C and LGMD2I map to an identical region on chromosome 19q13.3. To investigate whether these are allelic disorders, we undertook mutation analysis of FKRP in 25 potential LGMD2I families, including some with a severe and early onset phenotype. Mutations were identified in individuals from 17 families. A variable reduction of alpha-dystroglycan expression was observed in the skeletal muscle biopsy of all individuals studied. In addition, several cases showed a deficiency of laminin alpha2 either by immunocytochemistry or western blotting. Unexpectedly, affected individuals from 15 families had an identical C826A (Leu276Ileu) mutation, including five that were homozygous for this change. Linkage analysis identified at least two possible haplotypes in linkage disequilibrium with this mutation. Patients with the C826A change had the clinically less severe LGMD2I phenotype, suggesting that this is a less disruptive FKRP mutation than those found in MDC1C. The spectrum of LGMD2I phenotypes ranged from infants with an early presentation and a Duchenne-like disease course including cardiomyopathy, to milder phenotypes compatible with a favourable long-term outcome.     

Calpain 3 participates in sarcomere remodeling by acting upstream of the ubiquitin-proteasome pathway

Mutations in the non-lysosomal cysteine protease calpain 3 cause limb-girdle muscular dystrophy type 2A (LGMD2A). Our previous studies of the calpain 3 knockout mouse (C3KO) suggested a role for calpain 3 in sarcomere formation and remodeling. Calpain 3 may mediate remodeling by cleavage and release of myofibrillar proteins, targeting them for ubiquitination and proteasomal degradation. Loss of proper protein turnover may be the basis for this muscle disease. To test this hypothesis in vivo, we used an experimental model of hindlimb unloading and reloading that has been shown to induce sarcomere remodeling. We showed that the rate of atrophy and especially the rate of growth are decreased in C3KO muscles under conditions promoting sarcomere remodeling. In wild-type mice, an elevated level of ubiquitinated proteins was observed during muscle reloading, which is presumably necessary to remove atrophy-specific and damaged proteins. This increase in ubiquitination correlated with an increase in calpain 3 expression. C3KO muscles did not show any increase in ubiquitination at the reloading stage, suggesting that calpain 3 is necessary for ubiquitination and that it acts upstream of the ubiquitination machinery. We found upregulation of heat shock proteins in C3KO muscles following challenge with a physiological condition that requires highly increased protein degradation. Furthermore, old C3KO mice show evidence of insoluble protein aggregate formation in skeletal muscles. These studies suggest that accumulation of aged and damaged proteins can lead to cellular toxicity and a cell stress response in C3KO muscles, and that these characteristics are pathological features of LGMD2A.     

Hutterite brothers both affected with two forms of limb girdle muscular dystrophy: LGMD2H and LGMD2I

Limb girdle muscular dystrophy (LGMD) is very common in the Hutterite population of the North American Prairies. We have recently reported the homozygous c.1459G>A mutation in TRIM32 associated with LGMD2H. We have also identified Hutterite patients with LGMD2I, homozygous for the common c.826C>A mutation in FKRP. To date, all Hutterites with LGMD have been shown to be homozygous for either the TRIM32 or FKRP mutation. We now report a Hutterite family in which both parents and five sons were all found to be homozygous for the TRIM32 mutation. The father had slowly progressive proximal muscle weakness, whereas three sons and their mother, all currently asymptomatic, had normal physical examinations. The remaining two sons (7 and 10 years old), presented with mild decrease in stamina, had normal neuromuscular examinations and were found to be homozygous for the FKRP mutation in addition to the TRIM32 mutation. These two boys do not differ in age at or mode of presentation, physical findings, or serum CK levels compared to age-matched individuals affected with LGMD2I alone. This suggests that the effects of these two mutations are not acting synergistically at this time. It remains to be seen whether there will be signs of interaction between these two mutations as the patients get older.     

Ahnak1 abnormally localizes in muscular dystrophies and contributes to muscle vesicle release

Ahnak1 is a giant, ubiquitously expressed, plasma membrane support protein whose function in skeletal muscle is largely unknown. Therefore, we investigated whether ahnak would be influenced by alterations of the sarcolemma exemplified by dysferlin mutations known to render the sarcolemma vulnerable or by mutations in calpain3, a protease known to cleave ahnak. Human muscle biopsy specimens obtained from patients with limb girdle muscular dystrophy (LGMD) caused by mutations in dysferlin (LGMD2B) and calpain3 (LGMD2A) were investigated for ahnak expression and localization. We found that ahnak1 has lost its sarcolemmal localization in LGMD2B but not in LGMD2A. Instead ahnak1 appeared in muscle connective tissue surrounding the extracellular site of the muscle fiber in both muscular dystrophies. The entire giant ahnak1 molecule was present outside the muscle fiber and did only partially colocalize with CD45-positive immune cell infiltration and the extracelluar matrix proteins fibronectin and collagenVI. Further, vesicles shedded in response to Ca(2+) by primary human myotubes were purified and their protein content was analysed. Ahnak1 was prominently present in these vesicles. Electron microscopy revealed a homogenous population of vesicles with a diameter of about 150?nm. This is the first study demonstrating vesicle release from human myotubes that may be one mechanism underlying abnormally localized ahnak1. Taken together, our results define ahnak1 in muscle connective tissue as a novel feature of two genetically distinct muscular dystrophies that might contribute to disease pathology.     

Myopathy phenotype of transgenic mice expressing active site-mutated inactive p94 skeletal muscle-specific calpain, the gene product responsible for limb girdle muscular dystrophy type 2A

A defect of the gene for p94 (calpain 3), a skeletal muscle-specific calpain, is responsible for limb girdle muscular dystrophy type 2A (LGMD2A), or 'calpainopathy', which is an autosomal recessive and progressive neuromuscular disorder. To study the relationships between the physiological functions of p94 and the etiology of LGMD2A, we created transgenic mice that express an inactive mutant of p94, in which the active site Cys129 is replaced by Ser (p94:C129S). Three lines of transgenic mice expressing p94:C129S mRNA at various levels showed significantly decreased grip strength. Sections of soleus and extensor digitorum longus (EDL) muscles of the aged transgenic mice showed increased numbers of lobulated and split fibers, respectively, which are often observed in limb girdle muscular dystrophy muscles. Centrally placed nuclei were also frequently found in the EDL muscle of the transgenic mice, whereas wild-type mice of the same age had almost none. There was more p94 protein produced in aged transgenic mice muscles and it showed significantly less autolytic degradation activity than that of wild-type mice. Although no necrotic-regenerative fibers were observed, the age and p94:C129S expression dependence of the phenotypes strongly suggest that accumulation of p94:C129S protein causes these myopathy phenotypes. The p94:C129S transgenic mice could provide us with crucial information on the molecular mech-anism of LGMD2A.     

Pathophysiology of limb girdle muscular dystrophy type 2A: hypothesis and new insights into the IkappaBalpha/NF-kappaB survival pathway in skeletal muscle

Limb girdle muscular dystrophies (LGMDs) are a group of clinically heterogeneous genetic diseases characterized by progressive weakness and atrophy of scapular and pelvic muscles, with either a dominant or recessive autosomic mode of inheritance. The first symptoms of the disorder appear during the first 20 years of life and progresses gradually, and a walking disability develops 10-20 years later. The gene responsible for LGMD2A has been identified and encodes calpain 3, a protease expressed mainly in skeletal muscle. Apoptotic myonuclei were recently detected in muscular biopsy specimens of LGMD2A patients, and apoptosis was found to be correlated with altered subcellular distribution of inhibitory protein kappaBalpha (IkappaBalpha) and nuclear factor kappaB (NF-kappaB), resulting in sarcoplasmic sequestration of NF-kappaB. Calpain 3 dependent IkappaBalpha degradation was reconstituted in vitro, supporting a possible in vivo sequence of events leading from calpain 3 deficiency to IkappaBkappa accumulation, prevention of nuclear translocation of NF-kappaB, and ultimately apoptosis. Therefore calpain 3, present in healthy muscle as sarcoplasmic and nuclear forms, may control IkappaBalpha turnover and indirectly regulate NF-kappaB dependent expression of survival genes. Recent data reported from a new model of LGMD2A in mice and from other muscular disorders strengthen understanding of the molecular links between calpain 3 and the Ikappaalpha/NF-kappaB pathway. Finally, in light of the lack of apoptosis observed in inflammatory myopathies, a unifying model for the control of cell survival in muscle is proposed and discussed     

Muscle‐specific calpain‐3 is phosphorylated in its unique insertion region for enrichment in a myofibril fraction

CAPN3 (also called p94/calpain‐3) is a skeletal muscle‐specific calpain, an intracellular cysteine protease. Loss of CAPN3 protease activity and/or structural functions cause limb‐girdle muscular dystrophy type 2A (LGMD2A). However, the precise mechanism of action of CAPN3 in skeletal muscles in vivo remains largely elusive. By studying the protein modifications that regulate CAPN3 activity, we found that CAPN3 was phosphorylated. By performing mutagenesis and mass spectrometry analyses, we identified two Ser residues at positions 629 and 636 in human CAPN3 that are phosphorylated and showed that S629 is a major phosphorylation site. Intriguingly, rapid and exhaustive autolysis of CAPN3 was slightly attenuated by the substitution of S629. In skeletal muscles, phosphorylated CAPN3 was enriched in the myofibril fraction. These results imply that phosphorylated CAPN3 is a myofibril structural component and/or participates in myofibril‐based signaling pathways, rather than functions as a protease. We evaluated the relationship between phosphorylated CAPN3 and the pathology of LGMD2A. The level of phosphorylated CAPN3 was greatly reduced in LGMD2A muscles. Our findings suggest that phosphorylated CAPN3 is involved in the pathology of LGMD2A through defects in myofibril integrity and/or signaling pathways. This is the first report that phosphorylation of CAPN3 may be involved in its physiological function.     

Possible functions of p94 in connectin-mediated signaling pathways in skeletal muscle cells

Calpains are intracellular Ca²⁺-requiring ‘modulator proteases’, which modulate cellular functions by limited and specific proteolysis. p94/calpain3, a skeletal-muscle specific calpain, has been one of the representative calpain species which indicates physiological importance of calpain proteolytic system; a defect of proteolytic activity of p94 causes limb girdle muscular dystrophy type2A (LGMD2A, also called ‘calpainopathy’). Immunohistochemical studies on myofibrils showed that p94 localizes at the Z- and N2-line regions of sarcomeres. It was also identified by the yeast two hybrid studies that p94 binds to the N2A and M-line regions of connectin. Furthermore, genetic studies indicate that p94 is indispensable for skeletal muscles, although its precise functions are still unclear. Interestingly, connectin provides sarcomere not only with elasticity but also with binding sites to various multi-functional proteins such as muscle ankyrin repeat proteins (MARPs), muscle RING finger proteins (MURFs), titin-capping protein (T-cap/telethonin), sarcomeric-α-actinin, p94 etc. Binding sites for these proteins are not randomly placed along connectin but rather accumulated in the Z-, N2-, and/or M-line regions, indicating the existence of ‘signal complexes’ unique to each regions. The concept of these complexes are strongly supported by the facts that mutations of connectin or its binding proteins in these regions severely perturb muscle functions, as in the case of LGMD2A caused by mutations in the p94 gene. Therefore, it is hypothesized that the ‘signal complexes’ in the Z-, N2-, and M-lines modulate muscle cell homeostasis by transducing signals of external stimulations/stresses to trigger appropriate response at various different cellular events such as protein modification and gene expressions. In this article, we performed detailed immunohistochemical analyses of p94 on isolated single myofibers. Together with recent findings about p94, it is suggested that sarcomeric localization of p94, especially its M-line localization, is affected by the combination of cellular contexts such as contractile status of myofibrils, fiber type compositions, sarcomeric maturation, and the composition of the ‘signal complexes’ in each region.     

Extensive scanning of the calpain-3 gene broadens the spectrum of LGMD2A phenotypes

Background: The limb girdle muscular dystrophies (LGMD) are a heterogeneous group of Mendelian disorders highlighted by weakness of the pelvic and shoulder girdle muscles. Seventeen autosomal loci have been so far identified and genetic tests are mandatory to distinguish among the forms. Mutations at the calpain 3 locus (CAPN3) cause LGMD type 2A. Objective: To obtain unbiased information on the consequences of CAPN3 mutations. Patients: 530 subjects with different grades of symptoms and 300 controls. Methods: High throughput denaturing HPLC analysis of DNA pools. Results: 141 LGMD2A cases were identified, carrying 82 different CAPN3 mutations (45 novel), along with 18 novel polymorphisms/variants. Females had a more favourable course than males. In 94% of the more severely affected patient group, the defect was also discovered in the second allele. This proves the sensitivity of the approach. CAPN3 mutations were found in 35.1% of classical LGMD phenotypes. Mutations were also found in 18.4% of atypical patients and in 12.6% of subjects with high serum creatine kinase levels. Conclusions: A non-invasive and cost–effective strategy, based on the high throughput denaturing HPLC analysis of DNA pools, was used to obtain unbiased information on the consequences of CAPN3 mutations in the largest genetic study ever undertaken. This broadens the spectrum of LGMD2A phenotypes and sets the carrier frequency at 1:103.     

Myotilin is mutated in limb girdle muscular dystrophy 1A

We have identified a mutation in the myotilin gene in a large North American family of German descent expressing an autosomal dominant form of limb girdle muscular dystrophy (LGMD1A). We have previously mapped this gene to 5q31. Symptoms of this adult onset disease are progressive weakness of the hip and shoulder girdles, as well as a distinctive dysarthric pattern of speech. Muscle of affected individuals shows degeneration of myofibers, variations in fiber size, fiber splitting, centrally located myonuclei and a large number of autophagic vesicles. Affected muscle also exhibits disorganization and streaming of the Z-line similar to that seen in nemaline myopathy. We have identified a C450T missense mutation in the myotilin gene that is predicted to result in the conversion of residue 57 from threonine to isoleucine. This mutation has not been found in 396 control chromosomes. The mutant allele is transcribed and normal levels of correctly localized myotilin protein are seen in LGMD1A muscle. Myotilin is a sarcomeric protein that binds to alpha-actinin and is localized in the Z-line. The observed missense mutation does not disrupt binding to alpha-actinin.     

Limb-girdle muscular dystrophy 2I: phenotypic variability within a large consanguineous Bedouin family associated with a novel FKRP mutation

Limb-girdle muscular dystrophies (LGMDs) represent a group of diseases characterized mainly by muscle wasting of the upper and lower limbs, with a wide range of clinical severity. The clinical heterogeneity is paralleled by molecular heterogeneity; each of the 10 forms of autosomal-recessive LGMD recognized to date is caused by mutations in a distinct gene. In a large consanguineous Bedouin tribe living in northern Israel, 15 individuals affected by LGMD demonstrate an autosomal recessive pattern of inheritance. A genome-wide screen followed by fine mapping in this family revealed linkage to a region on chromosome 19 harboring the fukutin-related protein gene (FKRP), with a maximal LOD score of 4.8 for D19S902. FKRP, encoding a putative glycosyltransferase, has been implicated in causing congenital muscular dystrophy 1C (MDC1C), and has recently been shown to be mutated in LGMD2I. We identified a novel missense mutation in exon 4 of the FKRP gene in all the patients studied. Although all affected individuals were homozygous for the same mutation, a marked phenotypic variability was apparent within the family. This finding may suggest a role of modifier genes and environmental factors in LGMD2I. Moreover, the demonstration that an identical, novel mutation in the FKRP gene can cause a muscle disease of either a congenital onset or of a later onset within a single family provides clinical support to the molecular evidence, suggesting that MDC1C and LGMD2I are overlapping ends of one and the same entity.     

Impaired calcium calmodulin kinase signaling and muscle adaptation response in the absence of calpain 3

Mutations in the non-lysosomal, cysteine protease calpain 3 (CAPN3) result in the disease limb girdle muscular dystrophy type 2A (LGMD2A). CAPN3 is localized to several subcellular compartments, including triads, where it plays a structural, rather than a proteolytic, role. In the absence of CAPN3, several triad components are reduced, including the major Ca(2+) release channel, ryanodine receptor (RyR). Furthermore, Ca(2+) release upon excitation is impaired in the absence of CAPN3. In the present study, we show that Ca-calmodulin protein kinase II (CaMKII) signaling is compromised in CAPN3 knockout (C3KO) mice. The CaMK pathway has been previously implicated in promoting the slow skeletal muscle phenotype. As expected, the decrease in CaMKII signaling that was observed in the absence of CAPN3 is associated with a reduction in the slow versus fast muscle fiber phenotype. We show that muscles of WT mice subjected to exercise training activate the CaMKII signaling pathway and increase expression of the slow form of myosin; however, muscles of C3KO mice do not exhibit these adaptive changes to exercise. These data strongly suggest that skeletal muscle's adaptive response to functional demand is compromised in the absence of CAPN3. In agreement with our mouse studies, RyR levels were also decreased in biopsies from LGMD2A patients. Moreover, we observed a preferential pathological involvement of slow fibers in LGMD2A biopsies. Thus, impaired CaMKII signaling and, as a result, a weakened muscle adaptation response identify a novel mechanism that may underlie LGMD2A and suggest a pharmacological target that should be explored for therapy.     

Molecular diagnosis in LGMD2A: Mutation analysis or protein testing?

Limb girdle muscular dystrophy (LGMD) type 2A (LGMD2A) is caused by mutations in the CAPN3 gene encoding for calpain-3, a muscle specific protease. While a large number of CAPN3 gene mutations have already been described in calpainopathy patients, the diagnosis has recently shifted from molecular genetics towards biochemical assay of defective protein. However, an estimate of sensitivity and specificity of protein analysis remains to be established. Thus, we first correlated protein and molecular data in our large LGMD2A patient population. By a preliminary immunoblot screening for calpain-3 protein of 548 unclassified patients with various phenotypes (LGMD, myopathy, or elevated levels of serum creatine kinase [hyperCKemia]), we selected 208 cases for CAPN3 gene mutation analysis: 69 had protein deficiency and 139 had normal expression. Mutation search was conducted using SSCP, denaturing high performance liquid chromatography (DHPLC), amplification refractory mutation system (ARMS-PCR), and direct sequencing methods. We identified 58 LGMD2A mutant patients: 46 (80%) had a variable degree of protein deficiency and 12 (20%) had normal amount of calpain-3. We calculated that the probability of having LGMD2A is very high (84%) when patients show a complete calpain-3 deficiency and progressively decreases with the amount of protein; this new data offers an important tool for genetic counseling when only protein data are available. A total of 37 different CAPN3 gene mutations were detected, 10 of which are novel. In our population, 87% of mutant alleles were concentrated in seven exons (exons 1, 4, 5, 8, 10, 11, and 21) and 61% correspond to only eight mutations, indicating the regions where future molecular analysis could be restricted. This study reports the largest collection of LGMD2A patients so far in which both protein and gene mutations were obtained to draw genotype-protein-phenotype correlations and provide insights into a critical protein domain.     

cDNA analyses of CAPN3 enhance mutation detection and reveal a low prevalence of LGMD2A patients in Denmark

Calpainopathy or limb-girdle muscular dystrophy type 2A (LGMD2A) is generally recognized as the most prevalent form of recessive LGMD and is caused by mutations in the CAPN3 gene. Out of a cohort of 119 patients fulfilling clinical criteria for LGMD2, referred to our neuromuscular clinic, 46 were suspected to have LGMD2A, based on western blot results. Four of these patients were shown to have LGMD2I upon molecular analysis, whereas 16 of the remaining 42 patients harbored mutations in CAPN3 by both direct genomic sequencing and cDNA analyses. In 10 patients, we identified both mutant alleles. In three other, only one heterozygous mutation could be identified on the genomic level; however, CAPN3 cDNA analyses demonstrated homozygosity for the mutant allele, indicating the presence of an unidentified allele that somehow compromise correct CAPN3 RNA processing. In the three remaining patients, only a single heterozygous mutation could be identified both at the genomic level and on full-length CAPN3 cDNA. All three patients exhibited a highly abnormal western blot for calpain-3 and clinical characteristics of LGMD2A. Only three of the genetically confirmed LGMD2A patients were of Danish origin, indicating a five- to sixfold lower prevalence in Denmark compared to other European countries. A total of 16 different CAPN3 mutations were identified, of which 5 were novel. The present study demonstrates the value of cDNA analysis for CAPN3 in LGMD2A patients and indicates that calpainopathy is an uncommon cause of LGMD in the Denmark.