B cell priming for extrafollicular antibody responses requires Bcl-6 expression by T cells

T follicular helper cells (Tfh cells) localize to follicles where they provide growth and selection signals to mutated germinal center (GC) B cells, thus promoting their differentiation into high affinity long-lived plasma cells and memory B cells. T-dependent B cell differentiation also occurs extrafollicularly, giving rise to unmutated plasma cells that are important for early protection against microbial infections. Bcl-6 expression in T cells has been shown to be essential for the formation of Tfh cells and GC B cells, but little is known about its requirement in physiological extrafollicular antibody responses. We use several mouse models in which extrafollicular plasma cells can be unequivocally distinguished from those of GC origin, combined with antigen-specific T and B cells, to show that the absence of T cell-expressed Bcl-6 significantly reduces T-dependent extrafollicular antibody responses. Bcl-6(+) T cells appear at the T-B border soon after T cell priming and before GC formation, and these cells express low amounts of PD-1. Their appearance precedes that of Bcl-6(+) PD-1(hi) T cells, which are found within the GC. IL-21 acts early to promote both follicular and extrafollicular antibody responses. In conclusion, Bcl-6(+) T cells are necessary at B cell priming to form extrafollicular antibody responses, and these pre-GC Tfh cells can be distinguished phenotypically from GC Tfh cells.     

High affinity germinal center B cells are actively selected into the plasma cell compartment

A hallmark of T cell-dependent immune responses is the progressive increase in the ability of serum antibodies to bind antigen and provide immune protection. Affinity maturation of the antibody response is thought to be connected with the preferential survival of germinal centre (GC) B cells that have acquired increased affinity for antigen via somatic hypermutation of their immunoglobulin genes. However, the mechanisms that drive affinity maturation remain obscure because of the difficulty in tracking the affinity-based selection of GC B cells and their differentiation into plasma cells. We describe a powerful new model that allows these processes to be followed as they occur in vivo. In contrast to evidence from in vitro systems, responding GC B cells do not undergo plasma cell differentiation stochastically. Rather, only GC B cells that have acquired high affinity for the immunizing antigen form plasma cells. Affinity maturation is therefore driven by a tightly controlled mechanism that ensures only antibodies with the greatest possibility of neutralizing foreign antigen are produced. Because the body can sustain only limited numbers of plasma cells, this "quality control" over plasma cell differentiation is likely critical for establishing effective humoral immunity.     

Germinal centers without T cells

Germinal centers are critical for affinity maturation of antibody (Ab) responses. This process allows the production of high-efficiency neutralizing Ab that protects against virus infection and bacterial exotoxins. In germinal centers, responding B cells selectively mutate the genes that encode their receptors for antigen. This process can change Ab affinity and specificity. The mutated cells that produce high-affinity Ab are selected to become Ab-forming or memory B cells, whereas cells that have lost affinity or acquired autoreactivity are eliminated. Normally, T cells are critical for germinal center formation and subsequent B cell selection. Both processes involve engagement of CD40 on B cells by T cells. This report describes how high-affinity B cells can be induced to form large germinal centers in response to (4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl) acetyl (NP)-Ficoll in the absence of T cells or signaling through CD40 or CD28. This requires extensive cross-linking of the B cell receptors, and a frequency of antigen-specific B cells of at least 1 in 1,000. These germinal centers abort dramatically at the time when mutated high-affinity B cells are normally selected by T cells. Thus, there is a fail-safe mechanism against autoreactivity, even in the event of thymus-independent germinal center formation.     

Low-level hypermutation in T cell-independent germinal centers compared with high mutation rates associated with T cell-dependent germinal centers

Exceptionally germinal center formation can be induced without T cell help by polysaccharide-based antigens, but these germinal centers involute by massive B cell apoptosis at the time centrocyte selection starts. This study investigates whether B cells in germinal centers induced by the T cell-independent antigen (4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl)acetyl (NP) conjugated to Ficoll undergo hypermutation in their immunoglobulin V region genes. Positive controls are provided by comparing germinal centers at the same stage of development in carrier-primed mice immunized with a T cell-dependent antigen: NP protein conjugate. False positive results from background germinal centers and false negatives from non-B cells in germinal centers were avoided by transferring B cells with a transgenic B cell receptor into congenic controls not carrying the transgene. By 4 d after immunization, hypermutation was well advanced in the T cell-dependent germinal centers. By contrast, the mutation rate for T cell-independent germinal centers was low, but significantly higher than in NP-specific B cells from nonimmunized transgenic mice. Interestingly, a similar rate of mutation was seen in extrafollicular plasma cells at this stage. It is concluded that efficient activation of hypermutation depends on interaction with T cells, but some hypermutation may be induced without such signals, even outside germinal centers.     

Intrinsic constraint on plasmablast growth and extrinsic limits of plasma cell survival

B cells recruited into splenic antibody responses grow exponentially, either in extrafollicular foci as plasmablasts, or in follicles where they form germinal centers. Both responses yield plasma cells. Although many splenic plasma cells survive <3 d, some live much longer. This study shows that early plasma cell death relates to a finite capacity of the spleen to sustain plasma cells rather than a life span endowed by the cell's origin or the quality of antibody it produces. Antibody responses were compared where the peak numbers of plasma cells in spleen sections varied between 100 and 5,000 cells/mm(2). In each response, plasmablast clones divided some five times, with the peak numbers of plasma cells produced relating directly to the number of B cells recruited into the response. The spleen seems to have the capacity to sustain between 20 and 100 plasma cells/mm(2). When this number is exceeded, there is a loss of excess cells. Immunoglobulin variable region gene sequencing, and 5-bromo-2'-deoxyuridine pulse-chase studies indicate that long-lived splenic plasma cells are a mixture of cells derived from the extrafollicular and germinal center responses and cells derived from virgin and memory B cells. Only a proportion has switched immunoglobulin class.     

Outer Periarteriolar Lymphoid Sheath Arrest and Subsequent Differentiation of Both Naive and Tolerant Immunoglobulin Transgenic B Cells Is Determined by B Cell Receptor Occupancy

T-dependent B cell responses in the spleen are initiated in the outer periarteriolar lymphoid sheath (PALS) and culminate in the generation of proliferative foci and germinal center reactions. By pulsing anti–hen egg lysozyme (HEL) immunoglobulin transgenic (IgTg) B cells with various concentrations of HEL in vitro before adoptive transfer into normal recipients, it was shown that a critical number of B cell receptors (BCRs) must be ligated for B cells to undergo arrest in the outer PALS. T cell help was manipulated independently of the BCR stimulus by incubating B cells expressing the appropriate major histocompatibility complex class II antigen with a peptide recognized by CD4⁺ TCR Tg T cells. B cells which either failed to arrest in the outer PALS due to a subthreshold BCR stimulus, or arrested only transiently due to the brevity of the BCR stimulus, underwent an abortive response within the follicles when provided with T cell help. In contrast, naive B cells stimulated by a sustained, suprathreshold concentration of either foreign or self-antigen and given T cell help, proliferated in the outer PALS and then differentiated. Outer PALS arrest was not influenced by the nature of the B cells occupying the follicle, but appeared to be determined solely by the magnitude of BCR stimulation. Thus antigen-pulsed B cells arrested in the outer PALS in an identical manner irrespective of whether the follicles comprised a population of normal B cells with multiple specificities, a monoclonal naive population, or a monoclonal population of tolerant B cells. In addition, tolerant B cells were found to relocate from the follicles to the outer PALS of HEL/anti-HEL double Tg mice in which the concentration of soluble self-antigen had been increased by zinc feeding. Similarly, when anti-HEL Tg mice were crossed with a second HEL Tg strain expressing a higher concentration of soluble HEL, the tolerant anti-HEL Tg B cells were located constitutively in the outer PALS. Thus, subtle variations in antigen concentration resulted in dramatic changes in positioning of B cells within the spleen. A series of mixed bone marrow chimeras in which the effective antigen concentration was inversely related to the number of self-reactive B cells due to absorption of antigen by transgene-encoded membrane and secreted Ig, was used to confirm that alteration in B cell position previously attributed to changes in follicular composition could be explained on the basis of available antigen concentration, rather than the diversity of the repertoire.The immune system has evolved to enhance immunity to foreign antigens while limiting the risk of autoreactivity. The sophistication of mammalian immunoregulation is reflected not only in the complexity of molecular interactions between individual cells, but also in the anatomical organization of secondary lymphoid tissue in which immune responses take place. In this paper, the well-characterized hen egg lysozyme (HEL)¹/anti-HEL transgenic (Tg) model (1) has been used to explore the interactions between splenic microarchitecture, pattern of cell migration, dynamics of antigen exposure, and effect of T cell help in regulating the B cell response.B cells enter the splenic white pulp via the central arteriole and its penicillary branches which drain into the marginal sinuses surrounding the follicles (2, 3). They then migrate through the outer periarteriolar lymphoid sheath (PALS), the interface between the T cell–rich inner PALS and the follicles, and gain entry to the B cell–rich follicles (4, 5). Resting B cells migrate onwards to the red pulp and reenter the circulating pool within 24 h. Initiation of collaborative T-dependent B cell responses takes place in the outer PALS, and leads to the formation of proliferative foci at the junction between the red and white pulp, and of germinal centers within follicles (6–10).Our data demonstrate that both arrest and proliferation of B cells in the outer PALS are required for the subsequent formation of proliferative foci and germinal centers. The stimulus for B cell arrest is the ligation of a critical number of B cell receptors (BCRs), whereas proliferation in the outer PALS is dependent on extended antigenic exposure and the provision of T cell help. Reduction in the strength or duration of the BCR signal below the threshold required for the B cells to arrest for a prolonged period in the outer PALS prevents differentiation into germinal centers and proliferative foci, but still allows a T-dependent B cell response to take place within the follicles.It has previously been shown that outer PALS arrest also occurs during the induction of tolerance to self antigen (HEL) in the same Tg model (11, 12). This raises the question of whether the same mechanism is operating under these conditions or whether there is an alternative explanation as suggested by Cyster et al. in their follicular exclusion hypothesis (11–13). According to this hypothesis, arrest of tolerant self-reactive B cells in the outer PALS of normal mice occurs because of competition with the diverse repertoire of B cells located within the follicle. The follicular exclusion hypothesis was based on experiments in which transfer of tolerant B cells into recipients containing an identical tolerant B cell population resulted in survival of donor B cells within the follicles, whereas transfer of tolerant B cells into mice with a diverse follicular repertoire led to arrest in the outer PALS followed by death over the next few days. This censorship hypothesis implies that the B cell repertoire has developed some mechanism for monitoring its own diversity.An alternative explanation for outer PALS arrest of both naive and tolerant B cells is that it is determined entirely by suprathreshold antigenic stimulation of the BCR, irrespective of the specificity of the B cells or the outcome of the interaction with antigen (14). The data presented here from the same HEL/anti-HEL Tg model used by Cyster et al. (11, 12) are consistent with the latter explanation. By manipulating the available antigen concentration and the follicular composition independently of each other, B cell location in the spleen was found to be a function of antigen receptor engagement, independent of follicular composition.     

Antibody response to a T-dependent antigen requires B cell expression of complement receptors

Several lines of evidence indicate that antibody responses to T- dependent antigens require complement receptors expressed on either B lymphocytes or follicular dendritic cells. We have used RAG-2 deficient blastocyst complementation to create mice specifically lacking B cell complement receptors. Despite normal expression of complement receptor 1 (CR1[CD35]) and CR2 (CD21) on follicular dendritic cells, these mice have a profound defect in their capacity to mount a T-dependent antibody response. This is the first direct demonstration in vivo that B cell expression of complement receptors is required for a humoral immune response. This is the first direct demonstration in vivo that B cell expression of complement receptors is required for a humoral immune response. This suggests that CD21 and/or CD35 on B lymphocytes may be required for cellular activation, adsorptive endocytosis of antigen, recruitment to germinal centers, and/or protection from apoptosis during the humoral response to T-dependent antigens.     

Germinal Center Founder Cells Display Propensity for Apoptosis before Onset of Somatic Mutation

B lymphocytes undergo affinity maturation of their antigen receptors within germinal centers. These anatomical structures develop in secondary lymphoid organs from the clonal expansion of a few antigen-specific founder B cells, whose isolation and characterization are reported here. Human germinal center founder cells express the naive B cell markers surface IgM and IgD as well as the germinal center B cell markers CD10 and CD38. They express low levels of Bcl-2, high levels of Fas, and undergo rapid apoptosis in culture. The smaller nonproliferating sIgM⁺IgD⁺CD38⁺ B cells displayed a lower level of somatic mutation in their immunoglobulin variable region genes compared with the large proliferating ones. Unmutated sIgM⁺IgD⁺CD38⁺ tonsillar B cells may thus represent germinal center founder cells in which the program for apoptotic cell death is triggered before the onset of somatic mutation, allowing the selection of the germline antibody repertoire at an early stage.     

Viral Superantigen Drives Extrafollicular and Follicular B Cell Differentiation Leading to Virus-specific Antibody Production

Mouse mammary tumor virus (MMTV[SW]) encodes a superantigen expressed by infected B cells. It evokes an antibody response specific for viral envelope protein, indicating selective activation of antigen-specific B cells. The response to MMTV(SW) in draining lymph nodes was compared with the response to haptenated chicken gamma globulin (NP-CGG) using flow cytometry and immunohistology. T cell priming occurs in both responses, with T cells proliferating in association with interdigitating dendritic cells in the T zone. T cell proliferation continues in the presence of B cells in the outer T zone, and B blasts then undergo exponential growth and differentiation into plasma cells in the medullary cords. Germinal centers develop in both responses, but those induced by MMTV(SW) appear later and are smaller. Most T cells activated in the T zone and germinal centers in the MMTV(SW) response are superantigen specific and these persist for weeks in lymph nodes draining the site MMTV(SW) injection; this contrasts with the selective loss of superantigen-specific T cells from other secondary lymphoid tissues. The results indicate that this viral superantigen, when expressed by professional antigen-presenting cells, drives extrafollicular and follicular B cell differentiation leading to virus-specific antibody production.     

bcl-2 transgene expression inhibits apoptosis in the germinal center and reveals differences in the selection of memory B cells and bone marrow antibody-forming cells

Immunization with T cell-dependent antigens generates long-lived memory B cells and antibody-forming cells (AFCs). Both populations originate in germinal centers and, predominantly, produce antibodies with high affinity for antigen. The means by which germinal center B cells are recruited into these populations remains unclear. We have examined affinity maturation of antigen-specific B cells in mice expressing the cell death inhibitor bcl-2 as a transgene. Such mice had reduced apoptosis in germinal centers and an excessive number of memory B cells with a low frequency of V gene somatic mutation, including those mutations encoding amino acid exchanges known to enhance affinity. Despite the frequency of AFCs being increased in bcl-2-transgenic mice, the fraction secreting high-affinity antibody in the bone marrow at day 42 remained unchanged compared with controls. The inability of BCL-2 to alter selection of bone marrow AFCs is consistent with these cells being selected within the germinal center on the basis of their affinity being above some threshold rather than their survival being due to a selective competition for an antigen-based signal. Continuous competition for antigen does, however, explain formation of the memory compartment.     

Stages of B cell differentiation in human lymphoid tissue

Monoclonal antibodies reactive with B cell-specific differentiation and other antigens were used to investigate stages of B cell maturation in human lymphoid tissue, using an immunoperoxidase technique on frozen tissue sections. Lymphoid follicles, which represent the major anatomic compartment of B cells, demonstrated cellular antigenic expressions that appear to reflect differentiation of B cells. The majority of cells in the primary follicles and the mantle zones of secondary follicles expressed surface antigens similar to those of circulating B cells, namely IgM, IgD, Ia, B1, and B2. In contrast, the germinal center cells of secondary follicles stained for IgM, IgG, B1, B2, and Ia antigens, but not for IgD, and furthermore, acquired the T10 antigen. The germinal centers stained much more intensely than mantle zones with anti-B2, whereas no such striking difference in the staining intensity was observed with anti B1. Plasma cells, which represent the end stage of B cell differentiation, showed intense cytoplasmic staining with the anti-T10 antibody. The results indicate that the generation of germinal center cells in primary lymphoid follicles involves phenotype changes that correspond largely to those previously observed after both antigenic and mitogenic activation of B lymphocytes.     

In situ studies of the primary immune response to (4-hydroxy-3- nitrophenyl)acetyl. I. The architecture and dynamics of responding cell populations

After primary immunization with an immunogenic conjugate of (4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl)acetyl, two anatomically and phenotypically distinct populations of antibody-forming cells arise in the spleen. As early as 2 d after immunization, foci of antigen-binding B cells are observed along the periphery of the periarteriolar lymphoid sheaths. These foci expand, occupying as much as 1% of the splenic volume by day 8 of the response. Later, foci grow smaller and are virtually absent from the spleen by day 14. A second responding population, germinal center B cells, appear on day 8-10 and persist at least until day 16 post-immunization. Individual foci and germinal centers represent discrete pauciclonal populations that apparently undergo somatic evolution in the course of the primary response. We suggest that foci may represent regions of predominantly interclonal competition for antigen among unmutated B cells, while germinal centers are sites of intraclonal clonal competition between mutated sister lymphocytes.     

Increased IL-12 inhibits B cells' differentiation to germinal center cells and promotes differentiation to short-lived plasmablasts

B cells activated by antigen in T cell-dependent immune responses can become short-lived plasma cells, which remain in the spleen, or germinal center-derived memory or plasma cells, which show evidence of affinity maturation and, in the case of plasma cells, migrate to the bone marrow. We show that this cell fate decision can be governed by the cytokine environment engendered by activated dendritic cells (DCs). DCs from mice lacking the Fc receptor gamma chain exhibited an activated phenotype in vitro. They secreted more of the proinflammatory cytokine IL-12, which led to the preferential generation of short-lived splenic plasma cells, with ensuing low affinity antibodies and a diminished recall response. Understanding the factors that regulate antigen-activated B cell differentiation and memory cell formation has implications for both antibody-mediated autoimmune disease and protective antibody responses.     

Negative selection of human germinal center B cells by prolonged BCR cross-linking

The antigen receptors on T and B lymphocytes can transduce both agonist and antagonist signals leading either to activation/survival or anergy/death. The outcome of B lymphocyte antigen receptor (BCR) triggering depends upon multiple parameters which include (a) antigen concentration and valency, (b) duration of BCR occupancy, (c) receptor affinity, and (d) B cell differentiation stages. Herein, using anti- immunoglobulin kappa and lambda light chain antibodies, we analyzed the response of human naive, germinal center (GC) or memory B cells to BCR cross-linking regardless of heavy chain Ig isotype or intrinsic BCR specificity. We show that after CD40-activation, anti-BCR (kappa + gamma) can elicit an intracellular calcium flux on both GC and non-GC cells. However, prolonged BCR cross-linking induces death of CD40- activated GC B cells but enhances proliferation of naive or memory cells. Anti-kappa antibody only kills kappa + GC B cells without affecting surrounding gamma + GC B cells, thus demonstrating that BCR- mediated killing of GC B lymphocytes is a direct effect that does not involve a paracrine mechanism. BCR-mediated killing of CD40-activated GC B cells could be partially antagonized by the addition of IL-4. Moreover, in the presence of IL-4, prestimulation through CD40 could prevent subsequent anti-Ig-mediated cell death, suggesting a specific role of this combination in selection of GC B cells. This report provides evidence that in human, susceptibility to BCR killing is regulated along peripheral B cell differentiation pathway.     

Lymph node germinal centers form in the absence of follicular dendritic cell networks

Follicular dendritic cell networks are said to be pivotal to both the formation of germinal centers (GCs) and their functions in generating antigen-specific antibody affinity maturation and B cell memory. We report that lymphotoxin beta-deficient mice form GC cell clusters in the gross anatomical location expected of GCs, despite the complete absence of follicular dendritic cell networks. Furthermore, antigen-specific GC generation was at first relatively normal, but these GCs then rapidly regressed and GC-phase antibody affinity maturation was reduced. Lymphotoxin beta-deficient mice also showed substantial B cell memory in their mesenteric lymph nodes. This memory antibody response was of relatively low affinity for antigen at week 4 after challenge, but by week 10 after challenge was comparable to wild-type, indicating that affinity maturation had failed in the GC phase but developed later.     

ICOS-dependent extrafollicular helper T cells elicit IgG production via IL-21 in systemic autoimmunity

The role of specialized follicular helper T (T_FH) cells in the germinal center has become well recognized, but it is less clear how effector T cells govern the extrafollicular response, the dominant pathway of high-affinity, isotype-switched autoantibody production in the MRL/MpJ-Fas^lpr (MRL^lpr) mouse model of lupus. MRL^lpr mice lacking the Icos gene have impaired extrafollicular differentiation of immunoglobulin (Ig) G⁺ plasma cells accompanied by defects in CXC chemokine receptor (CXCR) 4 expression, interleukin (IL) 21 secretion, and B cell helper function in CD4 T cells. These phenotypes reflect the selective loss of a population of T cells marked by down-regulation of P-selectin glycoprotein ligand 1 (PSGL-1; also known as CD162). PSGL-1^lo T cells from MRL^lpr mice express CXCR4, localize to extrafollicular sites, and uniquely mediate IgG production through IL-21 and CD40L. In other autoimmune strains, PSGL-1^lo T cells are also abundant but may exhibit either a follicular or extrafollicular phenotype. Our findings define an anatomically distinct extrafollicular population of cells that regulates plasma cell differentiation in chronic autoimmunity, indicating that specialized humoral effector T cells akin to T_FH cells can occur outside the follicle.     

Early appearance of germinal center-derived memory B cells and plasma cells in blood after primary immunization

Immunization with a T cell-dependent antigen elicits production of specific memory B cells and antibody-secreting cells (ASCs). The kinetic and developmental relationships between these populations and the phenotypic forms they and their precursors may take remain unclear. Therefore, we examined the early stages of a primary immune response, focusing on the appearance of antigen-specific B cells in blood. Within 1 wk, antigen-specific B cells appear in the blood with either a memory phenotype or as immunoglobulin (Ig)G1 ASCs expressing blimp-1. The memory cells have mutated V(H) genes; respond to the chemokine CXCL13 but not CXCL12, suggesting recirculation to secondary lymphoid organs; uniformly express B220; show limited differentiation potential unless stimulated by antigen; and develop independently of blimp-1 expression. The antigen-specific IgG1 ASCs in blood show affinity maturation paralleling that of bone marrow ASCs, raising the possibility that this compartment is established directly by blood-borne ASCs. We find no evidence for a blimp-1-expressing preplasma memory compartment, suggesting germinal center output is restricted to ASCs and B220(+) memory B cells, and this is sufficient to account for the process of affinity maturation.