Immunity to Influenza in Ferrets: II. Influence of Adjuvants on Immunization

Immunization of ferrets with a single intramuscular inoculation of killed A2/Hong Kong virus did not induce serum or nasal antibody, and these animals were found to be completely susceptible to subsequent infection with virulent influenza virus A2/Hong Kong/3/68. A similar result was found for ferrets immunized with 2 inoculations of killed virus vaccine given 2 weeks apart. Ferrets immunized with killed A2/Hong Kong virus in conjunction with Bordetella pertussis produced relatively low levels of serum HI antibody to A2/Hong Kong virus; when infected with virulent influenza virus, these ferrets showed a modified reaction, with a less marked febrile reaction than was observed for non-immunized animals.Immunization of ferrets with killed A2/Hong Kong virus in Freund''s complete adjuvant resulted in the production of relatively high levels of serum HI antibody, but no detectable nasal antibody. These animals were shown to be partially immune to subsequent infection with virulent influenza virus. However, although the serum antibody levels of these animals following immunization was comparable to that found following infection with live virus, the degree of immunity to infection with virulent influenza virus was measurably less.     

Immunity to Influenza in Ferrets: I. Response to Live and Killed Virus

Ferrets were found to react with a sharp febrile response to intranasal infection with influenza virus A2/Hong Kong/3/68. Virus was recovered from nasal washings taken 3 days after infection, and virus antibody was found in serum specimens taken 21 days after virus infection. Virus infection produced a pronounced rhinitis; the protein concentration in nasal washings was found to increase three to five-fold with peak levels occurring on day 7, post-infection. Concomitant with the increased protein levels, detectable levels of HI and neutralizing antibody were found in the nasal washings. However, nasal washings taken 13 days or more after influenza virus infection did not contain either increased levels of protein or detectable antibody. These ferrets were immune to re-infection with homologous virus inoculated 5 weeks after primary infection. Thus, ferrets showed no febrile response; virus was not recovered from nasal washings; serum antibody titres did not increase; no increase in protein levels was found in nasal washings; and HI antibody was not found in nasal washings.Using these criteria to assess susceptibility or immunity to influenza virus infection, infection with attenuated influenza virus A2/Hong Kong/1/68 produced immunity to re-infection with virulent virus. Ferrets infected with influenza virus B/England/13/65 or immunized with killed A2/Hong Kong virus did not induce any immunity to infection with influenza virus A2/Hong Kong/3/68.     

Immunity to influenza in Ferrets

Summary Ferrets inoculated with 300 CCA of inactivated influenza A2/Hong Kong virus vaccine did not produce serum HI antibody, and were completely susceptible to subsequent infection with live A2/Hong Kong virus. Immunization of ferrets with A2/Hong Kong vaccine in Al(OH)₃ induced low levels of serum HI antibody; these animals showed a slightly reduced febrile reaction and reduced titres of virus were recovered from nasal washings following challenge virus infection. Ferrets immunized with inactivated A2/Hong Kong vaccine in Freund's incomplete adjuvant produced relatively high titres of serum HI antibody, but did not produce local antibody detectable in nasal washings. After challenge infection, these animals showed a modified febrile reaction, lower titres of virus were recovered from nasal washings and nasal symptoms were reduced. These results, together with results of similar studies, indicated that the degree of immunity to challenge virus infection was related to the titre of serum HI antibody. However, none of the methods used to induce serum HI antibody gave as solid an immunity as found following live virus infection, although immunization could induce levels of serum HI antibody comparable to that found following virus infection.     

Immunity to influenza in ferrets

Ferrets were infected with influenza A viruses and the production of serum antibodies studied using rate-zonal ultracentrifugation techniques. Following a primary infection 19S antibody was first detected in the serum, with 7S antibody occurring later. The antibody response of ferrets after a second infection with a heterotypic influenza virus appeared to be a modified primary response but occurred later. Ferrets immunized with inactivated influenza virus vaccine after prior infection with a heterotypic influenza virus produced serum antibody to the vaccine virus; this antibody response was rapid and consisted largely of 7S antibody. A secondary antibody response was also observed following infection of ferrets previously inoculated with homologous inactivated influenza virus vaccine, although no detectable serum antibody was produced after vaccination.We wish to thank Prof. Sir Charles Stuart-Harris for his advice and criticism and Mr. M. D. Denton for his excellent technical assistance. The support of the Medical Research Council is gratefully acknowledged.     

Immunity to influenza in ferrets

Ferrets were infected with recombinant influenza A viruses which possessed either the haemagglutinin or neuraminidase antigens of A/Hong Kong/68 influenza virus. After five weeks the immunity of the animals was challenged by infection with A/HK/68 virus. Immunity to challenge infection was greatest in those ferrets with serum HI antibody to A/HK/68; the presence of NI antibody conferred a measurably lower degree of immunity. A small degree of heterotypic immunity was observed following challenge infection of ferrets previously infected with influenza virus A/PR/8/34, although the surface antigens of this virus are completely different from those of A/HK/68. Experiments in which ferrets were infected with A/HK/68 virus and subsequently challenged with the recombinant viruses confirmed the results of the first experiment.     

The hamster as an experimental animal for the study of influenza

Hamsters were used to examine the role of serum antibody in protection against influenza virus infection. Following intranasal instillation, influenza viruses replicated well in these animals, and high, reproducible amounts of virus could be subsequently recovered from nasal washings and lung suspensions. A specific serum antibody response to the infecting virus was also observed; but no local antibody production was detected. The passive transfer of serum antibody gave some measurable protection, against homologous influenza virus challenge, to recipient hamsters. However, evidence that protection can occur in the absence of detectable serum antibody in individual hamsters, is also presented.     

Immunity to Influenza in Ferrets X. Intranasal Immunization of Ferrets with Inactivated Influenza A Virus Vaccines

The response of ferrets after intranasal inoculation of inactivated A/Hong Kong/68 (H3N2) influenza virus vaccines is reported. Normal ferrets given either saline vaccine in drops or freeze-dried vaccine in an aerosol intranasally did not produce detectable serum or nasal hemagglutination inhibiting antibody and were found to be completely susceptible to challenge infection with A/Hong Kong/68 virus. Intranasal saline vaccine did not produce an additive effect on the response of ferrets simultaneously given the same vaccine intramuscularly with adjuvant. Ferrets primed by previous infection with A/PR/8/34 (H0N1) influenza virus, however, responded to intranasal immunization with saline A/Hong Kong/68 virus vaccine and produced serum and nasal antibody. These animals were found to be partially resistant to challenge infection, in contrast to similar animals given saline vaccine intramuscularly which were completely resistant to challenge infection. Primed ferrets did not respond after immunization with the freeze-dried aerosol vaccine, but this may have been due to a failure of the aerosol to be inhaled satisfactorily.     

Antibody Response of Hamsters to A2/Hong Kong Virus Vaccine after Priming by Heterotypic Virus Infection

Hamsters previously infected with influenza virus A1/FM/1/47 produced serum hemagglutination inhibition (HI) antibody in response to 1/100 the antigenic dose of inactivated influenza virus A2/Hong Kong vaccine necessary to induce antibody in normal animals. This priming effect was believed to be due to the virus infection which caused an immune response to a virus antigen common to both the infecting virus and the virus vaccine; this antigen acted as a carrier for the specific vaccine virus hemagglutinin and potentiated the immune response to the new antigen. This theory, which has been established in other immune systems, was tested, and the results obtained did not contradict the conditions imposed in the above explanation. Thus, the priming effect could be transferred to normal hamsters by inoculation of spleen cells from virus-infected animals, and the HI antibody response to the virus vaccine was characteristic of a secondary response. The theory also required that the new antigen be coupled to the carrier protein; however, primed hamsters produced serum HI antibody after inoculation with ether-Tween-split virus vaccine, but there was no proof that this vaccine was completely dissociated.     

Suboptimal Humoral Immune Response against Influenza A(H7N9) Virus Is Related to Its Internal Genes

Influenza A(H7N9) virus pneumonia is associated with a high case fatality rate in humans. Multiple viral factors have been postulated to account for the high virulence of the virus. It has been reported that patients with influenza A(H7N9) virus infection have relatively low titers of neutralizing antibodies compared to those with seasonal influenza virus infections. In this study, we compared serum hemagglutination inhibition (HI) and microneutralization (MN) antibody titers of mice challenged with wild-type A(H7N9) viruses [H7N9(Anhui) and H7N9(Zhejiang)], an A(H1N1)pdm09 virus [pH1N1(2009)], and a recombinant A(H7N9) virus with PR8/H1N1 internal genes (rg-PR8-H7-N9). All mice infected by H7N9(Anhui) and H7N9(Zhejiang) developed serum HI antibodies at 14 days postinfection (dpi) but no detectable MN antibodies, even at 28 dpi. A low level of neutralizing activity was detected in H7N9(Anhui)- and H7N9(Zhejiang)-infected mice using fluorescent focus MN assay, but convalescent-phase serum samples obtained from H7N9(Anhui)-infected mice did not reduce the mortality of naive mice after homologous virus challenge. Reinfection with homologous A(H7N9) virus induced higher HI and MN titers than first infection. In contrast, pH1N1(2009) virus infection induced robust HI and MN antibody responses, even during the first infection. Moreover, rg-PR8-H7-N9 induced significantly higher HI and MN antibody titers than H7N9(Zhejiang). In conclusion, the internal genes of A(H7N9) virus can affect the humoral immune response against homologous viral surface proteins, which may also contribute to the virulence of A(H7N9) virus.     

Interference following dual inoculation with influenza A (H3N2) and (H1N1) viruses in ferrets and volunteers

The effects of simultaneous inoculation with two attenuated influenza A viruses was studied in ferrets and volunteers. Groups of ferrets were inoculated with an influenza A (H3N2) or (H1N1), virus or a combination of both viruses: The temperature response, serum and local antibody response, and the change in nasal wash protein concentration was determined. The results showed that both viruses were attenuated for ferrets, and that inoculation with both viruses together did not cause clinical reactions. Serological studies on paired serum samples obtained from ferrets showed that both viruses when given separately infected all the inoculated animals; however, dual infection resulted in all ferrets being infected with the influenza A (H3N2) virus strain, but this infection interfered with infection by the influenza A (H1N1) strain. Similar investigations were carried out in volunteers. Again, the clinical reactions and temperature response of volunteers to infection by one or other of the viruses showed both strains to be attenuated for man even when given together. In addition, no adverse clinical reactions were seen in volunteers inoculated with both viruses simultaneously. Serum antibody studies showed that infection by influenza A (H1N1) virus interfered with infection by the influenza A (H2N2) virus strain. These results show evidence of interference by influenza A viruses; however, the direction of interference was one-way, and differed for ferrets and for volunteers.     

Humoral immune response to the influenza virus: the fractionation of sera from immune animals

The studies demonstrated that antibody synthesis under conditions of the investigated fatal influenza infection differs in certain parameters from that in non-fatal infection. The mouse-pathogenic A/PR8/34 strain of influenza virus actively induced synthesis of antibodies detectable both by HI and NT. The less pathogenic A/Krasnodar/101/59 strain induced synthesis of antibodies detectable by NT sufficiently well but was a poor inducer of antibodies inhibiting virus hemagglutination of chick erythrocytes. Antibodies detectable by HI and NT appear to represent different molecules of immunoglobulins which differ in their immunochemical properties. These antibodies could be separated by means of affinity chromatography on an immunosorbent. The results of the above studies confirm that the protective and virus-neutralizing activity of an immune preparation in passive immunization is determined by the qualitative and quantitative composition of antibodies in a given preparation. The ratio of virus-induced antibodies may possibly determine the severity of the course and outcome of primary influenza infection.     

Immunity to influenza in ferrets. XIV: Comparative immunity following infection or immunization with live or inactivated vaccine.

Immunization by live influenza virus induced a greater protective effect against subsequent challenge by the homologous virus than by the corresponding killed virus vaccine. Furthermore, tracheas excised from 11-day and 28-day influenza-virus-infected ferrets were more resistant to reinfection than tracheas excised from ferrets immunized by killed influenza vaccine, despite equivalent serum antibody titres at these times. Histological examination of trachea sections taken from vaccinated and virus-infected animals showed an increased cellular inflammatory infiltrate in the latter at Days 11 and 28 after immunization. The amount of IgG detected in these sections, measured by a fluorescent antibody technique, correlated with the extent of cellular infiltration, the fluorescence being both intra- and extracellular for sections from virus-infected animals, but only extracellular in sections from Day-28 vaccinated animals. In contrast there was little or no cellular infiltration into lung tissues, the levels of IgG detected being comparable to those in sections taken from control animals. These results provide further evidence that live influenza vaccines induce local antibody in the upper respiratory tract of ferrets, in contrast to killed influenza vaccines, and that this local induction may play a significant role in the greater protective efficacy of live influenza vaccines.     

Immunity to influenza virus infection induced by heterologous,inactivated vaccines

The ability of inactivated influenza A vaccines to induce serum HI antibody and immunity to challenge infection was studied in hamsters and in volunteers. Groups of hamsters were immunized with 200 IU of influenza virus A/Scotland/74, A/Port Chalmers/73, A/England/72, or A/Hong Kong/68. The serum HI antibody response of animals to, and immunity to challenge infection was directly related to the known relationship between the vaccine and test viruses. Thus, hamsters given A/Hong Kong/68 or A/England/72 vaccine produced serum HI antibody and immunity to A/Hong Kong virus infection, and animals given A/Scotland/74, A/Port Chalmers/73, and A/England/72 produced antibody and immunity to A/Scotland infection.In a volunteer study, groups of students were immunized with 400 IU of the same vaccines as used above. The ability to infect these volunteers with WRL 105 virus given 4 weeks later was directly related to the vaccine-induced serum HI antibody to the challenge virus. The highest titers of serum HI antibody to A/Scotland virus were found in volunteers inoculated with homologous vaccine, lower titers were found in volunteers given A/Port Chalmers or A/England/ 72 vaccine and the lowest levels were seen in volunteers given A/Hong Kong/68 vaccine: the largest number of infections by the challenge virus was seen in volunteers given A/Hong Kong/68 vaccine, less were observed in volunteers given A/England/72 vaccine, and least were found in groups given A/Port Chalmers or A/Scotland/74 vaccine. Compared with the incidence of infection in volunteers given B/Hong Kong/73 vaccine, all groups given heterologous influenza A vaccines showed some immunity to challenge infection.     

Immunization of Ferrets against Influenza: A Comparison of Killed Ferret Grown and Egg Grown Virus

Both killed unadjuvanted ferret and egg grown A/Moscow/1019/65 (H₂N₂) influenza virus failed to immunize ferrets against challenge with homologous virus; the preparations were given in 2 doses, 2 weeks apart, distributed intranasally, intramuscularly and intraperitoneally. However, small doses (<2 HA units) of both preparations induced immunity in ferrets previously “primed” with a live heterologous virus (A/FM/1/47 (H₁N₁)) according to the method of Potter et al. (1973a, b). Although no difference in immunizing activity was detected between ferret and egg grown virus, the former induced greater HI titres than the latter. There was no correlation between HI titres in serum and protection to challenge; in fact, some protection seemed to be afforded by the “priming” virus in the absence of HI antibody to the challenge virus.These results are discussed in relation to the possibility that a previously unrecognized antigen different from haemagglutinin and neuraminidase may contribute to immunity to influenza.     

Host defenses in experimental scrub typhus: role of cellular immunity in heterologous protection.

The relative contributions of cellular and humoral immunity in scrub typhus infections were studied in inbred mice employing paired strains of Rickettsia tsutsugamushi differing in virulence. An infectious dose (100 MID50) of the less virulent Gilliam strain resulted in heterologous immune protection against an otherwise lethal challenge (1,000 MLD50) of the virulent Karp strain. Partial heterologous protection against lethal Karp challenge was observed in animals preimmunized with the Gilliam strain as early as 3 days prior to challenge, whereas complete protection against illness and death existed in animals immunized at least 7 days prior to challenge. In the heterologous protection provided by prior Gilliam infection, the role of humoral immunity was not of primary importance for the following reasons: (i) significant levels of complement-fixing antibody against R. tsutsugamushi were not detectable until long after animals were solidly immune; (ii) antibody eventually appearing after Gilliam immunization exhibited a consistently low complement-fixing titer against the immunizing homologous (Gilliam) strain and contained no detectable activity against the heterologous challenge (Karp) strain; and (iii) passive transfer of large quantities of serum from Gilliam immune mice, themselves immune to Karp challenge, failed to protect recipients against a similar challenge. However, protection was afforded by the passive transfer of serum containing antibody against Karp, suggesting a major role for antibody in protection against homologous infection. This heterologous challenge system was particularly useful because it minimized the role of humoral immunity, at least early in the course of infection, and allowed a definitive examination of the cellular response. Cell-mediated immunity played a major role in the heterologous protection observed after Gilliam immunization. This was evidenced by the significant protection against Karp challenge afforded by the passive transfer of spleen cells from animals immunized with Gilliam 7 to 63 days previously. Of the immune spleen cells, only those which were nonadherent, presumably lymphocytes, were capable of transferring passive heterologous protection. This protective effect of nonadherent cells could be ablated by depleting the cell population of thymus-derived or T cells with anti-theta serum and complement prior to transfer but not by use of anti-immunoglobulin serum and complement, which selectively removes bone marrow-derived or B cells. These results suggested that the cell in immune spleens capable of conferring heterologous protection was a T lymphocyte.     

Humans and Ferrets with Prior H1N1 Influenza Virus Infections Do Not Exhibit Evidence of Original Antigenic Sin after Infection or Vaccination with the 2009 Pandemic H1N1 Influenza Virus

The hypothesis of original antigenic sin (OAS) states that the imprint established by an individual''s first influenza virus infection governs the antibody response thereafter. Subsequent influenza virus infection results in an antibody response against the original infecting virus and an impaired immune response against the newer influenza virus. The purpose of our study was to seek evidence of OAS after infection or vaccination with the 2009 pandemic H1N1 (2009 pH1N1) virus in ferrets and humans previously infected with H1N1 viruses with various antigenic distances from the 2009 pH1N1 virus, including viruses from 1935 through 1999. In ferrets, seasonal H1N1 priming did not diminish the antibody response to infection or vaccination with the 2009 pH1N1 virus, nor did it diminish the T-cell response, indicating the absence of OAS in seasonal H1N1 virus-primed ferrets. Analysis of paired samples of human serum taken before and after vaccination with a monovalent inactivated 2009 pH1N1 vaccine showed a significantly greater-fold rise in the titer of antibody against the 2009 pH1N1 virus than against H1N1 viruses that circulated during the childhood of each subject. Thus, prior experience with H1N1 viruses did not result in an impairment of the antibody response against the 2009 pH1N1 vaccine. Our data from ferrets and humans suggest that prior exposure to H1N1 viruses did not impair the immune response against the 2009 pH1N1 virus.     

Immunity to Chlamydial Infections of the Eye V. Passive Transfer of Antitrachoma Antibodies to Owl Monkeys

Previous studies have shown that owl monkeys which have had a trachoma agent infection were subsequently highly resistant to challenge by both homologous and heterologous organisms. In the present study, passive transfer of owl monkey serum containing antitrachoma antibody from immune monkeys did not protect recipient monkeys from infectious challenge with homologous trachoma. Antibody was not detectable in eye secretions of the recipient monkeys until the intensity of infection was waning, suggesting but not proving that local antibody synthesis rather than simple transudation of serum antibody occurs.     

Specific immunity to influenza virus in ferret organ cultures

Ferret tracheal organ cultures prepared from animals previously infected intranasally with influenza A virus required approximately 130 times more homologous virus (A/PR/8/34(HON1) or A/Port Chalmers/1/73 (H3N2)) to become infected in vitro than similar cultures from normal ferrets. Also, these cultures from convalescent ferrets required 9 times more heterologous virus (A/PR/8/34(HON1) or Sendai) to become infected in vitro than similar cultures from normal animals challenged in vitro with the hererologous virus. We conclude that these tracheal rings are specifically immune. Once tracheal rings are infected, they continue to shed viruses for at least 60 days, the longest period any cultures were kept. Virus sheeding in the intact ferret lasts normally 5-7 days. Thus recovery in the intact ferret seems to be dependent upon factors which are not present, or at least not functional, in the tracheal explant. This is consistent with the hypothesis that recovery is dependent upon systemic rather than local phenomena. Bladder tissue from normal and previously infected ferrets was also cultured and challenged with homologous and heterologous virus. The bladder from previously infected ferrets exhibited specific immunity, although the immunity was more varible.     

Specific immunity to influenza virus in ferret organ cultures.

Ferret tracheal organ cultures prepared from animals previously infected intranasally with influenza A virus required approximately 130 times more homologous virus (A/PR/8/34(HON1) or A/Port Chalmers/1/73 (H3N2)) to become infected in vitro than similar cultures from normal ferrets. Also, these cultures from convalescent ferrets required 9 times more heterologous virus (A/PR/8/34(HON1) or Sendai) to become infected in vitro than similar cultures from normal animals challenged in vitro with the hererologous virus. We conclude that these tracheal rings are specifically immune. Once tracheal rings are infected, they continue to shed viruses for at least 60 days, the longest period any cultures were kept. Virus sheeding in the intact ferret lasts normally 5-7 days. Thus recovery in the intact ferret seems to be dependent upon factors which are not present, or at least not functional, in the tracheal explant. This is consistent with the hypothesis that recovery is dependent upon systemic rather than local phenomena. Bladder tissue from normal and previously infected ferrets was also cultured and challenged with homologous and heterologous virus. The bladder from previously infected ferrets exhibited specific immunity, although the immunity was more varible.     

Increased influenza pneumonia mortality of mice adoptively immunized with node and spleen cells sensitized by inactivated but not live virus.

Syngeneic mice adoptively immunized intravenously with 25 million washed node and spleen cells from donors vaccinated subcutaneously with formolized influenza A PR8 had a higher mortality with influenza pneumonia after challenge with homologous virus than occurred in recipients of similar cells from unsensitized donors, and this increased mortality was prevented by treatment of the sensitized cells with antithymocyte serum. Mice adoptively immunized with cells from donors vaccinated with formolized influenza A PR8 also had a higher mortality than recipients of unsensitized cells after challenge with heterologous influenza B Lee. Mice who received PR8-sensitized cells and survived challenge with influenza B Lee developed antibody only to the challenge virus, and serum antibody titers to the challenge virus in surviving recipients of sensitized cells were similar to those of recipients of unsensitized cells in all studies. Influenza mortality of recipients of antibody-containing mouse serum after homologous virus challenge was similar to that of recipients of antibody-free mouse serum in this model. Washed node and spleen cells from donor mice who had survived respiratory infection or received subcutaneous vaccination with live influenza A PR8 and those from donor mice given typhoid vaccine subcutaneously all failed to alter mortality from that observed in recipients of unsensitized cells after challenge with influenza A PR8. These results suggest that subcutaneous vaccination with inactivated influenza establishes a reactivity of the cell-mediated immunologic system which can increase the severity of influenza infection of the respiratory tract under certain conditions, and that sensitization by live influenza fails to produce this effect.