Permeability characteristics of complement-damaged membranes: evaluation of the membrane leak generated by the complement proteins C5b-9.

Permeability characteristics of the membrane lesion generated by the terminal complement proteins are considered in light of recent observations that the measured diffusion of solute across complement-damaged membranes does not conform to the "doughnut hole" model of a discrete transmembrane pore formed by the inserted C5b-9 complex. By using the measured kinetics of steady-state tracer isotope diffusion of nonelectrolytes across resealed erythrocyte ghost membranes treated with C5b-9, a new transport model is developed. This model considers the apparent membrane lesion strictly in terms of the operational criteria of a functional conducting pathway for the observed diffusing solute, independent of a priori assumptions about the geometry or molecular properties of the membrane lesion. With this definition of the unit membrane lesion and the assumption that the exclusion size of the conducting pathway varies directly with the multiplicity of bound C5b-9 (as suggested by previous measurements under conditions of varying input of C5b-9), numerical estimates of te apparent permeability of the complement-damaged membrane to four diffusing nonelectrolytes are derived. These results suggest that the pathway for a particle diffusing across the complement lesion cannot be a pore and is functionally equivalent to an aqueous leak pathway, free of pore constraints. Implications of these results are discussed in terms of current molecular models for the mechanism of membrane damage by the complement proteins.     

Molecular weight of the membrane C5b-9 complex of human complement: characterization of the terminal complex as a C5b-9 monomer.

The hydrodynamic properties of the detergent-solubilized, terminal membrane complex of serum complement components C5-C9 [C5b-9(m)] were studied to obtain an estimate of its molecular weight. In a solution of Triton X-100/deoxycholate, the protein complex binds 17% Triton X-100 and 11% deoxycholate by weight. The sedimentation coefficient of the protein-detergent complex is 26 S as determined by sucrose density gradient ultracentrifugation, and gel filtration indicated a molecular radius of 11 nm. It was ascertained by electron microscopy that these hydrodynamic parameters apply to mono-dispersed C5b-9(m) complexes, which were observed as nonaggregated, hollow protein cylinders and were identical to the complement "lesions" formed on target membranes. The calculated molecular weight of the protein-detergent complex is approximately 1,286,300 to which the protein moiety contributes approximately 1,000,000. The results indicate that the C5b-9(m) complex formed on biological membranes is a monomer entity of the C5-C9 complement components.     

Polymerization of the ninth component of complement (C9): formation of poly(C9) with a tubular ultrastructure resembling the membrane attack complex of complement.

The ninth component of complement (C9) has a marked propensity to polymerize. C9 polymers [poly(C9)] formed spontaneously in Veronal-buffered saline upon incubation of purified C9 for 64 hr at 37 degrees C or within 2 hr at 46--56 degrees C. Poly(C9) formed at 37 degrees C was visualized by electron microscopy as a tubular structure with an internal diameter of 110 A and a length of 160 A. Its ultrastructure suggested a dodecameric composition and resembled that of the membrane attack complex of complement. The wider end of the tubular structure was formed by an approximately 30-A-thick torus with inner and outer diameters of 110 A and 220 A, respectively. Because the dimensions of C9 within poly(C9) were 160 x 55 A (maximal) and 20 A (minimal) and because monomeric C9 has dimensions of approximately 80 x 55 A, it is proposed that monomeric C9 unfolds during polymerization into tubules. Polymerization also occurred upon treatment of C9 for 1 hr at 37 degrees C with 0.6 M guanidine . HCl, 0.1 M octyl glucoside, or 1.5% sodium deoxycholate. Guanidine . HCl-induced C9 polymers consisted of elongated highly curved strands 55--80 A wide, suggesting that these polymers were formed by globular C9 that had not unfolded.     

Steady-state analysis of tracer exchange across the C5b-9 complement lesion in a biological membrane.

Resealed erythrocyte ghosts have been used to define the kinetics of tracer exchange across the membrane-bound terminal complex of the complement cascade (C5b-9). Under steady-state conditions and at net chemical equilibrium, C5b-9 ghosts showed no significant lysis above control levels as measured by hemoglobin efflux. In 1 mM sucrose at 37 degrees C, [14C]sucrose isotopic exchange diffusion into C5b-9 ghosts occurred at 4.8 (+/- 0.5, SEM) X 10(-20) mol sec-1 per functional lesion, equivalent to an apparent permeability coefficient of 4.8 X 10(-14) cm3 sec-1 for the single C5b-9 lesion. No significant uptake of [14C]sucrose above control levels was observed in C5b67 ghosts. The apparent rate of tracer permeation through the complement lesion is one to two orders of magnitude slower than predicted by a model of a transmembrane channel of dimensions permitting free diffusion of sucrose. The data support earlier assertions from this laboratory that diffusion of small molecules across the complement lesion in biological membranes is significantly restricted.     

COMPLEMENT COMPONENT C9 IN GRAVES'' DISEASE

C9, the terminal component of complement, is the key part of the membrane attack complex formed as a result of complement activation; it has also been reported to be an acute phase protein. Its potential role in Graves' disease has been studied by measuring plasma C9 concentrations using an automated two-site immunoradiometric assay employing monoclonal antibodies, whose binding to thyroid tissue has also been investigated. The plasma C9 concentration in patients with hyperthyroid Graves' disease (86.3 +/- 21.6 mg/l, mean +/- SD; n = 49) was significantly increased (P less than 0.001) compared with normal subjects (60.4 +/- 13.4 mg/l; n = 48). In contrast, the plasma concentration of C-reactive protein, a marker of the acute phase response, was not significantly different between the two groups. The plasma C9 concentration in patients with hyperthyroid Graves' disease decreased significantly (P less than 0.01) after treatment with antithyroid drugs (carbimazole or methimazole; n = 14), but not after radioactive iodine (131I) treatment (n = 18). Immunohistochemical staining demonstrated that monoclonal antibody to C9 bound to the basement membranes of thyroid follicular cells of Graves' thyroid tissue but not to normal thyroid tissue. Radiolabelled monoclonal antibody to C9 bound to membrane fragments prepared from thyroid glands from two patients with Graves' disease. We conclude that C9, and by implication the membrane attack complex, may be involved in the pathogenesis of Graves' disease.     

The cytolytic C5b-9 complement complex: feedback inhibition of complement activation

We describe a regulatory function of the terminal cytolytic C5b-9 complex [C5b-9(m)] of human complement. Purified C5b-9(m) complexes isolated from target membranes, whether in solution or bound to liposomes, inhibited lysis of sensitized sheep erythrocytes by whole human serum in a dose-dependent manner. C9 was not required for the inhibitory function since C5b-7 and C5b-8 complexes isolated from membranes were also effective. No effect was found with the cytolytically inactive, fluid-phase SC5b-9 complex. However, tryptic modification of SC5b-9 conferred an inhibitory capacity to the complex, due probably to partial removal of the S protein. Experiments using purified components demonstrated that C5b-9(m) exerts a regulatory effect on the formation of the classical- and alternative-pathway C3 convertases and on the utilization of C5 by cell-bound C5 convertases. C5b-9(m) complexes were unable to inhibit the lysis of cells bearing C5b-7(m) by C8 and C9. Addition of C5b-9(m) to whole human serum abolished its bactericidal effect on the serum-sensitive Escherichia coli K-12 strain W 3110 and suppressed its hemolytic function on antibody-sensitized, autologous erythrocytes. Feedback inhibition by C5b-9(m) represents a biologically relevant mechanism through which complement may autoregulate its effector functions.     

Transient changes in erythrocyte membrane permeability are induced by sublytic amounts of the complement membrane attack complex (C5b-9)

We have previously shown that sublytic heterologous complement induces large but transient increases in erythrocyte membrane permeability. We now report that when erythrocytes are bystanders in zymosan-activated autologous serum, they increase their Na+ permeability 10-fold, indicating that autologous complement can also induce transient membrane lesions. When we isolated the effect of the C5b-9 membrane attack complex of complement by using human C5b-9 assembled from purified components, we found there was minimal lysis but efficient Na+ uptake. Suspension of the sublytically damaged erythrocytes in K+ medium caused the cells to lyse, which is consistent with the cells recruiting a compensatory K+ efflux similar to that observed when human erythrocytes were exposed to heterologous complement. Sublytic C5b-9 exposure also became lytic when extracellular Ca2+ was limited and when the cells were exposed to charybdotoxin, an inhibitor of the Ca(2+)- activated K+ channel. This indicates that Ca2+ is required for the functional termination of the C5b-9 lesion. We also show that the membrane hyperpolarization resulting from activation of the Ca(2+)- dependent K+ efflux does not influence the termination of the C5b-9 lesion. Thus, the influx of Ca2+ through the complement lesion initiates at least two apparently independent adaptive responses: (1) a process that terminates the leak; and (2) a K+ efflux that has a volume regulatory function. Our data support the potential of the sublytic C5b- 9 lesion to act as a physiologic mediator for autologous erythrocytes.     

Deficiency of the 9th component of complement (C9) in a patient with systemic lupus erythematosus

We describe the first case of systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) showing the 9th component of complement (C9) deficiency. In the serum of this patient, a low level of serum total hemolytic complement (CH50) and the absence of C9 was demonstrated. The patient's sister, with normal level of C9, was also found to have an autoimmune disorder.     

Enhanced complement-mediated lysis of type III paroxysmal nocturnal hemoglobinuria erythrocytes involves increased C9 binding and polymerization.

The interaction of terminal complement proteins (C5-C9) with normal erythrocytes and type III paroxysmal nocturnal hemoglobinuria erythrocytes (PNH-E) has been compared in terms of binding of the C5-9 complex, C9 polymerization, and C9 insertion into membranes. Complement components C5, C7, and C8 bind equally well to both types of erythrocytes, whereas the binding of C9 to PNH-E is 5-6 times greater than that to normal erythrocytes. The kinetics of C9 binding was compared with the kinetics of lysis for both types of cells under conditions leading to 100% lysis. There was a noticeable lag time between C9 binding and lysis of normal erythrocytes, but the lysis of PNH-E proceeded without a lag and the kinetics of lysis more closely paralleled C9 binding. The efficiency of C9 insertion was similar for both types of cells, but C9 polymerization was significantly enhanced on PNH-E. These data indicate that the enhanced susceptibility of type III PNH-E toward lysis by C5-9 can be correlated with abnormally high C9 binding and increased formation of poly(C9).     

Antiphospholipid antibody-dependent C5b-9 formation

The relationship between the presence of antiphospholipid antibodies (APA) and the production of the terminal membrane attack complex (MAC) of complement (C5b-9) was studied. Serum samples from known high positive APA patients induced platelet activation and destruction which was inhibited by heat-inactivation of the sera. The response was restored if the heat-inactivated APA-positive sera were supplemented with normal sera. Adsorption of the APA-positive sera with phospholipid (PL)-coated polystyrene beads inhibited platelet destruction. Addition of monoclonal antibody (mAb) to C5b-9 (aE11) also inhibited platelet destruction, suggesting that the APA-dependent platelet destruction might be complement-mediated. Purified APA, in the presence of normal serum, induced C5b-9 formation and binding to PL-coated beads in a dose-dependent manner as detected by flow cytometry. Prospective analysis of 200 serum samples for C5b-9 production showed that all sera testing negative for the presence of APA also tested negative for C5b-9 production. All sera with high levels of IgG binding to PL (GPL) showed evidence of C5b-9 production. Sera with low or moderate GPL values showed varying levels of C5b-9 production. These data suggest that complement may play a key role in APA-dependent platelet activation, in vivo .     

慢性肺源性心脏病患者血清补体C1q和C5及C9水平的变化及临床意义

目的探讨慢性肺源性心脏痛患者血清补体C1q、C5、C9水平的变化及临床意义。方法选择我院慢性肺心病患者25例（观察组），另选同期健康体检者20例（对照组），采用免疫比浊法测定两组患者血清补体C1q、C5、C9水平。结果两组患者血清C1q、C5、C9水平间差异均有显著性意义（P〈0．05）。结论 测定慢性肺心病患者血清补体C1q、C5、C9水平，对于判断该病病情程度及发生发展规律有一定意义。     

Ultrastructure of the membrane attack complex of complement: detection of the tetramolecular C9-polymerizing complex C5b-8.

The ultrastructure of the membrane attack complex (MAC) of complement had been described as representing a hollow cylinder of defined dimensions that is composed of the proteins C5b, C6, C7, C8, and C9. After the characteristic cylindrical structure was identified as polymerized C9 [poly(C9)], the question arose as to the ultrastructural identity and topology of the C9-polymerizing complex C5b-8. An electron microscopic analysis of isolated MAC revealed an asymmetry of individual complexes with respect to their length. Whereas the length of one boundary (+/- SEM) was always 16 +/- 1 nm, the length of the other varied between 16 and 32 nm. In contrast, poly(C9), formed spontaneously from isolated C9, had a uniform tubule length (+/- SEM) of 16 +/- 1 nm. On examination of MAC-phospholipid vesicle complexes, an elongated structure was detected that was closely associated with the poly(C9) tubule and that extended 16-18 nm beyond the torus of the tubule and 28-30 nm above the membrane surface. The width of this structure varied depending on its two-dimensional projection in the electron microscope. By using biotinyl C5b-6 in the formation of the MAC and avidin-coated colloidal gold particles for the ultrastructural analysis, this heretofore unrecognized subunit of the MAC could be identified as the tetramolecular C5b-8 complex. Identification also was achieved by using anti-C5 Fab-coated colloidal gold particles. A similar elongated structure of 25 nm length (above the surface of the membrane) was observed on single C5b-8-vesicle complexes. It is concluded that the C5b-8 complex, which catalyzes poly(C9) formation, constitutes a structure of discrete morphology that remains as such identifiable in the fully assembled MAC, in which it is closely associated with the poly(C9) tubule.     

Interactions of C-reactive protein and complement with liposomes.

Interactions between C-reactive protein (CRP) and liposomal model membranes containing phosphatidylcholine were investigated. These interactions, in the presence of human serum, resulted in consumption of each of the components of the classical complement pathway (C1-C9) and also resulted in complement-dependent damage and release of trapped glucose from certain types of liposomes. CRP-initiated lysis of liposomes was strongly dependent upon membrane lipid composition. Optimal activity occurred with positively charged liposomes containing galactosylceramide (galactocerebroside); positively charged liposomes lacking galactocerebroside released much less glucose, while negatively charged liposomes, either with or without galactocerebroside, did not release glucose at all. Glucose release was inhibited by free phosphocholine. Lesser, but significant, "background" glucose release independent of the presence of CRP also was observed with positively charged liposomes containing galactocerebroside, and this was associated with marked preferential consumption of the later-acting complement components (C3-C9). C2-deficient human serum failed to support CRP-dependent glucose release, but glucose release was observed upon reconstitution of the serum with C2. Guinea pig complement also did not support CRP-mediated glucose release, but upon addition of human C1q substantial glucose release was observed. We conclude that (i) CRP can sensitize appropriate liposomes for complement-dependent damage via the primary complement pathway starting at the level of C1q; (ii) of those studied, liposomes that are most susceptible to membrane damage contain phosphatidylcholine, have a positive charge, and contain a ceramide glycolipid; and (iii) such liposomes also are sensitive, although to a much lesser degree, to complement-dependent lysis initiated in the absence of CRP and involving consumption of terminal in excess of early acting complement components.     

Increased ion permeability of planar lipid bilayer membranes after treatment with the C5b-9 cytolytic attack mechanism of complement.

The ion permeability of planar lipid bilayers, as measured electrically, was found to increase modestly upon treatment with purified complement complex C5b,6 and complement components C7 and C8. The subsequent addition C9 greatly amplified this change. No permeability changes occurred when components were added individually to the membrane, or when they were used in paired combinations, or when C5b, C7, C8, and C9 were admixed prior to addition. Thus, there is a significant parallel between the permeability changes induced in the model membrane and damage produced in biological membranes by the C5b-9 complement attack sequence. The efficiency of membrane action by C5b-9 was critically dependent on the order in whcih components were added to the membrane. There were also differences in the electrical properties of membranes treated with C5b-8 and C5b-9, though in both cases the enhanced bilayer permeability is best attributed to the formation of trans-membrane channels. Collectively, the data are consistent with the hypothesis that the mechanism of membrane action by complement involves the production of a stable channel across the lipid bilayer, resulting in cell death by colloid-osmotic lysis.     

Identification of the complement 9-binding protein in Setaria equina excretory-secretory products

The current study aimed to detect the complement-binding proteins in the excretory-secretory (ES) products of adult filarial parasite Setaria equina (SeqES). Tests for complement activation pathways (CH₅₀ and APH₅₀) in normal human serum (NHS) after incubation with SeqES were performed. Quantitative detection of complement activation products like C3d and sC5b-9 by ELISA in inulin-activated NHS before and after addition of SeqES was estimated. Immunoblotting for 1D and 2D electrophoresed SeqES were performed for detection of C9-binding protein. MALDI mass sequencing and multiple sequence alignment were performed for identification of the protein. The results showed an inhibitory effect of SeqES for complement activation pathways. This was confirmed by an obvious reduction in C3d and sC5b-9 in inulin-activated NHS. Immunoblotting showed the reaction of a protein at 21 kDa with human C9. The latter protein was identified as OV-16 based on MALDI mass sequencing and multiple sequence alignment. In conclusion, S equina OV-16 is the complement regulatory protein by its ability to bind C9 and inhibit the classical and alternative pathways of complement activation. This protein can be used as a target for therapeutic treatment or as an anti-inflammatory agent in human diseases.     

Complement activation by isolated myelin: activation of the classical pathway in the absence of myelin-specific antibodies.

Many pathological conditions of the central nervous system involve damage to and removal of myelin membrane. Very little is known about initiation of this membrane damage and the mechanisms of disposal of the damaged tissue. We are interested in the interaction between complement (the components of complement are designated C1, C2, C3, etc.) and myelin membranes and the possible role of complement in amplifying myelin damage and in the disposal of damaged myelin in vivo, because activation of complement generates both membrane-attack complexes and opsonin(s). In this study, we found that isolated rat or human myelin consumes complement in the absence of specific antibodies. Activation of complement was demonstrated by showing C3 cleavage in fresh serum incubated with myelin. Incubation of central nervous system myelin with C2-deficient serum produced no C3 consumption and only minor factor B conversion, thus excluding the alternative pathway of activation. Involvement of the classical pathway was shown directly by the C1 fixation and transfer assay. Myelin incubated with C2-deficient serum or with purified C1 and then washed contained C1 activity that could lyse sheep erythrocytes sensitized with anti-Forssman IgM antibody and carrying C4, together with C2 and C3-C9. Membranes in brain tissues other than myelin (heavy membrane fraction obtained on sucrose density gradient centrifugation) were unable to activate C1.     

Isolation of a human erythrocyte membrane protein capable of inhibiting expression of homologous complement transmembrane channels.

Erythrocytes are poorly lysed by homologous complement, whereas they are readily lysed by heterologous complement. This phenomenon had been attributed to an interference by the cell surface with the action of complement components C8 and C9. To isolate the responsible membrane constituent, detergent-solubilized human erythrocyte (EH) membranes were subjected to affinity chromatography by using human C9-Sepharose. The isolated protein had a mass of 38 kDa and, incorporated into liposomes, was highly effective in inhibiting complement-mediated channel expression, including the C5b-8, membrane attack complex, and tubular polymer of C9 channels. Antibody produced to the 38-kDa protein caused a 20-fold increase in reactive lysis of EH by isolated C5b6, C7, C8, and C9. The antibody did not enhance C5b-7 uptake, but it affected C9 binding to the target cell membrane. Antibody to human decay-accelerating factor, used as a control, had no effect on reactive lysis of EH. Anti-38-kDa protein did not enhance the action on EH of C8 and C9 from other species, indicating that the action of this regulatory protein is species specific. It was therefore termed homologous restriction factor (HRF). Blood cells other than erythrocytes, such as polymorphonuclear leukocytes, also exhibited cell-surface HRF activity. In immunoblots of freshly isolated EH membranes, anti-38-kDa HRF detected primarily a 65-kDa protein, suggesting that the 38-kDa protein constitutes an active fragment of membrane HRF. Because of the specific binding reaction observed between HRF and C8 or C9, HRF was tested with anti-human C8 and anti-human C9. A limited immunochemical relationship of HRF to C8 and C9 could be established and solid-phase anti-C9 proved an efficient tool for the isolation of HRF from solubilized EH membranes.     

Regulation of complement functional efficiency by histidine-rich glycoprotein.

The modulation of complement functional efficiency by serum histidine-rich glycoprotein (HRG) was investigated. Addition of exogenous HRG to prewarmed diluted serum, followed immediately by sensitized sheep erythrocytes (EA), resulted in enhanced hemolysis. However, when HRG was incubated with diluted serum for 10 minutes at 37 degrees C, inhibition of hemolysis occurred. The biphasic modulation of complement function was also obtained with the complement alternative pathway when HRG was added to diluted serum for hemolysis of rabbit erythrocytes. Partial reduction of complement functional activity was shown when serum was absorbed by an HRG-Sepharose 6MB column. Western blot analysis showed that complement C8, C9, factor D, and S-protein in diluted serum were bound by nylon membrane-immobilized HRG. However, by immunoprecipitation of relatively undiluted serum with anti-HRG IgG beads, HRG was found to coprecipitate with S-protein and plasminogen, which suggested that HRG may complex with these proteins in serum. In functional tests, HRG inhibited C8 hemolytic activity, probably by preventing C8 binding to EAC1-7 cells. HRG also enhanced polymerization of purified C9 as well as the generation of a 45-Kd C9 fragment. Such an effect was even more pronounced in the presence of divalent cations with the reaction mixtures of C9 and HRG. Partial dimerization of C9 was shown when exogenous HRG was added to normal serum. In contrast, polymerization of serum C9 was inhibited by exogenous HRG during poly I:C activation of serum or incubation under low ionic strength conditions. HRG was further shown to inhibit factor D-mediated cleavage of factor B when bound by cobra venom factor. The molecular basis by which HRG regulates serum complement function is not clear. Hypothetically, the tandem repetitions of a consensus histidine-rich penta-peptide sequence in HRG may provide a highly charged area that interacts with complement components.     

CD59 (homologous restriction factor 20), a plasma membrane protein that protects against complement C5b-9 attack, in human atherosclerotic lesions.

Blood cells express a cell membrane protein, termed homologous restriction factor 20 (HRF20) and identical to CD59, that can inhibit complement C5b-9 insertion into their membranes. In this report, we investigated by immunohistochemistry whether CD59 was present on cells in human atherosclerotic lesions since membranous C5b-9(m) has been found in lesions. Using a monoclonal anti-CD59 antibody, a cellular CD59 staining pattern was apparent in nearly all lesion specimens. CD59 stain co-localised with macrophage (CD14), T lymphocyte (CD7), endothelial cell (anti-factor VIII related antigen) and smooth muscle cell cytoskeletal-specific antigens (anti-alpha actin and muscle myosin). Endothelial cells always exhibited a more intense stain than the other cell types. CD59 antigen was not localised to any one area of the lesions. Usually CD59-positive cells occurred in clusters rather than as randomly spaced individual cells. CD59 did not stain all cells of the lesion and in particular did not appear to stain all smooth muscle cells. Areas of CD59-negative cells were sometimes observed to exhibit a cellular C5b-9 staining pattern. C5b-9 deposits were also observed in CD59-positive regions. Normal saphenous vein stained strongly for CD59 at the endothelial lining and weakly in the media. Capillaries in atherosclerotic intima always stained strongly for CD59. We conclude that HRF20 is constitutively expressed on endothelium and is under regulatory control in smooth muscle cells. Cellular C5b-9 attack in atherosclerotic lesions is therefore most likely to occur on smooth muscle cells.     

Immunohistochemical localization of the terminal C5b-9 complement complex in human aortic fibrous plaque

The terminal C5b-9 complex of the complement system was localized in 26 aortic, 3 iliac and 4 femoral human fibrous plaques using indirect immunofluorescence and immunoperoxidase. IgG, IgA, IgM, Clq, C3c, C4, C9 and fibrinogen were investigated simultaneously. All the fibrous plaques presented C5b-9 deposits appearing like thin threads in the fibrous cap and masses and spots in the amorphous areas. The extent and intensity were in agreement with the size of the fibrous plaques. The intimal thickenings presented less intense deposits which were absent in atherosclerosis-free samples. The C5b-9 deposits were frequently associated with immunoglobulins and complement components in the same areas. Whereas the demonstration of complement components reflected only a nonspecific trapping, the presence of assembled C5b-9 in the damaged tissues is more indicative of the involvement of complement activation in the tissue injury. The absence of C5b-9 in the atherosclerosis-free intima and its presence at lower intensity in the intimal thickenings than in the fibrous plaques suggest a pathogenic involvement in the chronic progression of the atherosclerotic lesion.