Diffusion tensor imaging studies of mild traumatic brain injury: a meta-analysis

Objectives To assess the possibility that diffusion tensor imaging (DTI) can detect white matter damage in mild traumatic brain injury (mTBI) patients via systematic review and meta-analysis. Methods DTI studies that compared mTBI patients and controls were searched using MEDLINE, Web of Science, and EMBASE, (1980 through April 2012). Results A comprehensive literature search identified 28 DTI studies, of which 13 independent DTI studies of mTBI patients were eligible for the meta-analysis. Random effect model demonstrated significant fractional anisotropy (FA) reduction in the corpus callosum (CC) (p=0.023, 95% CIs -0.466 to -0.035, 280 mTBIs and 244 controls) with no publication bias and minimum heterogeneity, and a significant increase in mean diffusivity (MD) (p=0.015, 95% CIs 0.062 to 0.581, 154 mTBIs and 100 controls). Meta-analyses of the subregions of the CC demonstrated in the splenium FA was significantly reduced (p=0.025, 95% CIs -0.689 to -0.046) and MD was significantly increased (p=0.013, 95% CIs 0.113 to 0.950). FA was marginally reduced in the midbody (p=0.099, 95% CIs -0.404 to 0.034), and no significant change in FA (p=0.421, 95% CIs -0.537 to 0.224) and MD (p=0.264, 95% CIs -0.120 to 0.438) in the genu of the CC. Conclusions Our meta-analysis revealed the posterior part of the CC was more vulnerable to mTBI compared with the anterior part, and suggested the potential utility of DTI to detect white matter damage in the CC of mTBI patients.     

Diffusion tensor imaging in mild traumatic brain injury litigation

A growing body of literature addresses the application of diffusion tensor imaging (DTI) to traumatic brain injury (TBI). Most TBIs are of mild severity, and their diagnosis and prognosis are often challenging. These challenges may be exacerbated in medicolegal contexts, where plaintiffs seek to present objective evidence that supports a clinical diagnosis of mild (m)TBI. Because DTI permits quantification of white matter integrity and because TBI frequently involves white matter injury, DTI represents a conceptually appealing method of demonstrating white matter pathology attributable to mTBI. However, alterations in white matter integrity are not specific to TBI, and their presence does not necessarily confirm a diagnosis of mTBI. Guided by rules of evidence shaped by Daubert v. Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals, Inc., we reviewed and analyzed the literature describing DTI findings in mTBI and related neuropsychiatric disorders. Based on this review, we suggest that expert testimony regarding DTI findings will seldom be appropriate in legal proceedings focused on mTBI.     

Diffusion tensor imaging studies on corticospinal tract injury following traumatic brain injury: a review

The corticospinal tract (CST) is the most important neural tract for motor function in the human brain. Therefore, clarification of CST injury would be an important topic in traumatic brain injury (TBI) rehabilitation. In this review, I reviewed diffusion tensor imaging (DTI) studies on CST injuries in terms of etiology and recovery in patients with TBI. Although DTI has several unique advantages for research on CST injury in TBI, only a dozen DTI studies on this topic have been reported: etiology of CST injury (9 studies), recovery of CST injury (3 studies). As for the etiology of CST injury in TBI, the previous studies have demonstrated the usefulness of DTI in diagnosis of CST injury in cases of diffuse axonal injury, transtentorial herniation, cerebral hemorrhage, and cortical contusion; moreover, according to the severity of TBI. The three studies on recovery of CST injury focused on recovery of a CST injured by diffuse axonal injury. In the future, we suggest an increase in the total number of DTI studies on this topic. In particular, research on recovery of CST injury should be encouraged. Moreover, studies of the various recovery mechanisms related to the CST are necessary.     

A voxel-based meta-analysis of diffusion tensor imaging in mild traumatic brain injury

Microstructural damage to white matter and resultant abnormal structural connectivity are a potential underlying pathophysiological mechanism of mild traumatic brain injury (mTBI). Many Tract-Based Spatial Statics studies have investigated the pathophysiology of mTBI, but they yielded inconsistent results potentially due to insufficient statistical power in spite of methodological homogeneity. We used anisotropic effect size signed differential mapping (AES-SDM) to integrate previous studies that recruited patients without a psychiatric history. AES-SDM revealed that fractional anisotropy values were significantly lower in mTBI patients than in control in three clusters. The peak of the largest cluster was in the left thalamus and the cluster extended to the splenium of the corpus callosum and to the anterior thalamic radiation. The second largest cluster was situated in the left forceps minor, and the third largest cluster was in the right superior longitudinal fasciculus III. These results suggest that the pathophysiology of mTBI includes abnormal structural connectivity between the thalamus and the prefrontal cortex, and abnormal intra- and inter-hemispheric structural connectivity involving the prefrontal cortex.     

Serial measurement of memory and diffusion tensor imaging changes within the first week following uncomplicated mild traumatic brain injury

Patients (n = 8) with uncomplicated mild traumatic brain injury (mTBI) underwent serial assessments (4) with diffusion tensor imaging (DTI) and neuropsychological testing within the first 8 days post-injury. Using a multi-case study design, we examined changes in brain parenchyma (via DTI-derived fractional anisotropy [FA], apparent diffusion coefficient [ADC], axial diffusivity [AD] and radial diffusivity [RD] in the left cingulum bundle) and in memory performance (via Hopkins Verbal Learning Test-Revised). Qualitative inspection of the results indicated that memory performance was transiently affected in most participants over the course of the week, with performance most negatively impacted on the second assessment (days 3–4 or 97–144 h post-injury), and then returning to within normal limits by 8 days post-injury. Alternatively, FA and other DTI metrics showed a more complex pattern, with the trajectory of some participants changing more prominently than others. For example, FA transiently increased in some participants over the study period, but the pattern was heterogeneous. Memory performance appeared to mirror changes in FA in certain cases, supporting a pathophysiological basis to memory impairment following mTBI. However, the pattern and the degree of symmetry between FA and memory performance was complex and did not always correspond. Serial imaging over the semi-acute recovery period may be important in reconciling conflicting findings in mTBI utilizing memory and/or DTI. Serial use of imaging modalities including DTI may aid understanding of underlying pathophysiological changes in the semi-acute post-injury period. Should a consistent pattern emerge that allows identification of patients at-risk for acute and/or persistent symptoms, such knowledge could guide development of therapeutic targets in mTBI and in understanding the most effective administration time window for these agents.     

Optic radiation injury following traumatic epidural hematoma: Diffusion tensor imaging study

Little is known about optic radiation (OR) injury in patients with traumatic brain injury (TBI). We report on a patient who showed an OR injury on diffusion tensor imaging (DTI) following traumatic epidural hematoma (EDH). A 38 year-old man with TBI and 7 age-matched normal subjects were enrolled in this study. The patient had fallen down stairs while in an alcohol intoxicated state. He underwent a craniotomy following diagnosis of traumatic EDH in the left temporo-parietal lobe on brain CT. He complained of right bilateral homonymous hemianopsia, which was confirmed on the Humphrey visual field test. No lesion on the left OR was observed during brain MRI. We were not able to reconstruct the fiber tractography for the left OR in this patient. We found that the left OR had been injured most severely around the midportion between the lateral geniculate body and occipital pole. We determined that DTI would be a useful technique for detection of an OR injury in patients with TBI. Therefore, we believe that DTI should be performed along with conventional brain MRI for patients with visual field defects following TBI.     

Factors moderating neuropsychological outcomes following mild traumatic brain injury: a meta-analysis.

There continues to be debate about the long-term neuropsychological impact of mild traumatic brain injury (MTBI). A meta-analysis of the relevant literature was conducted to determine the impact of MTBI across nine cognitive domains. The analysis was based on 39 studies involving 1463 cases of MTBI and 1191 control cases. The overall effect of MTBI on neuropsychological functioning was moderate (d = .54). However, findings were moderated by cognitive domain, time since injury, patient characteristics, and sampling methods. Acute effects (less than 3 months postinjury) of MTBI were greatest for delayed memory and fluency (d = 1.03 and .89, respectively). In unselected or prospective samples, the overall analysis revealed no residual neuropsychological impairment by 3 months postinjury (d = .04). In contrast, clinic-based samples and samples including participants in litigation were associated with greater cognitive sequelae of MTBI (d = .74 and .78, respectively at 3 months or greater). Indeed, litigation was associated with stable or worsening of cognitive functioning over time. The implications and limitations of these findings are discussed.     

轻中型颅脑损伤后认知功能障碍的DTI研究

目的应用弥散张量成像(diffusion tensor imaging,DTI)技术探讨轻中型颅脑损伤病人不同部位脑白质微结构改变与其认知功能障碍的相关性。方法分析127例轻中型颅脑损伤病人的临床资料,伤后10 d采用蒙特利尔认知评估量表(Mo CA)评定有无认知功能障碍,并常规行头颅MRI检查,采集DTI数据,测量两侧额叶、颞叶内侧、顶叶,胼胝体膝部和压部,中脑部位的感兴趣区各向异性分数(FA值)、表观弥散系数(ADC值),并与Mo CA评估结果进行相关性分析。结果以Mo CA量表为标准评定,无认知功能障碍41例(32.28%,无认知障碍组),存在认知功能障碍86例(67.72%,认知障碍组),主要表现为视空间与执行功能、注意力和计算力、语言、抽象能力、延迟记忆的障碍。与无认知障碍的病人相比,认知障碍的病人两侧额叶、颞叶内侧、胼胝体膝部FA值降低,ADC值增加,差异具有统计学意义(P0.01)。结论轻中型颅脑损伤病人早期存在显著认知功能障碍,以视空间与执行功能、注意力和计算力、语言、抽象能力、延迟记忆障碍为主。颅脑损伤后早期认知功能障碍与病人额叶、颞叶、胼胝体白质受损密切相关。     

Diffusion tensor tractography characteristics of axonal injury in concussion/mild traumatic brain injury

The main advantage of diffusion tensor tractography is that it allows the entire neural tract to be evaluated.In addition,configurational analysis of reconstructed neural tracts can indicate abnormalities such as tearing,narrowing,or discontinuations,which have been used to identify axonal injury of neural tracts in concussion patients.This review focuses on the characteristic features of axonal injury in concussion or mild traumatic brain injury(m TBI)patients through the use of diffusion tensor tractography.Axonal injury in concussion(m TBI)patients is characterized by their occurrence in long neural tracts and multiple injuries,and these characteristics are common in patients with diffuse axonal injury and in concussion(m TBI)patients with axonal injury.However,the discontinuation of the corticospinal tract is mostly observed in diffuse axonal injury,and partial tearing and narrowing in the subcortical white matter are frequently observed in concussion(m TBI)patients with axonal injury.This difference appears to be attributed to the observation that axonal injury in concussion(m TBI)patients is the result of weaker forces than those producing diffuse axonal injuries.In addition,regarding the fornix,in diffuse axonal injury,discontinuation of the fornical crus has been frequently reported,but in concussion(m TBI)patients,many collateral branches form in the fornix in addition to these findings in many case studies.It is presumed that the impact on the brain in TBI is relatively weaker than that in diffuse axonal injury,and that the formation of collateral branches occurs during the fornix recovery process.Although the occurrence of axonal injury in multiple areas of the brain is an important feature of diffuse axonal injury,case studies in concussion(m TBI)have shown that axonal injury occurs in multiple neural tracts.Because axonal injury lesions in m TBI patients may persist for approximately 10 years after injury onset,the characteristics of axonal injury in concussion(m TBI)patients,which are reviewed and categorized in this review,are expected to serve as useful supplementary information in the diagnosis of axonal injury in concussion(m TBI)patients.     

Diffusion kurtosis imaging in mild traumatic brain injury and postconcussional syndrome

Aims of this study were to investigate white matter (WM) and thalamus microstructure 72 hr and 3 months after mild traumatic brain injury (TBI) with diffusion kurtosis imaging (DKI) and diffusion tensor imaging (DTI), and to relate DKI and DTI findings to postconcussional syndrome (PCS). Twenty-five patients (72 hr = 24; 3 months = 23) and 22 healthy controls were recruited, and DKI and DTI data were analyzed with Tract-Based Spatial Statistics (TBSS) and a region-of-interest (ROI) approach. Patients were categorized into PCS or non-PCS 3 months after injury according to the ICD-10 research criteria for PCS. In TBSS analysis, significant differences between patients and controls were seen in WM, both in the acute stage and 3 months after injury. Fractional anisotropy (FA) reductions were more widespread than kurtosis fractional anisotropy (KFA) reductions in the acute stage, while KFA reductions were more widespread than the FA reductions at 3 months, indicating the complementary roles of DKI and DTI. When comparing patients with PCS (n = 9), without PCS (n = 16), and healthy controls, in the ROI analyses, no differences were found in the acute DKI and DTI metrics. However, near-significant differences were observed for several DKI metrics obtained in WM and thalamus concurrently with symptom assessment (3 months after injury). Our findings indicate a combined utility of DKI and DTI in detecting WM microstructural alterations after mild TBI. Moreover, PCS may be associated with evolving alterations in brain microstructure, and DKI may be a promising tool to detect such changes.     

Diffusion imaging in traumatic brain injury

Traumatic brain injury is a common cause of death worldwide, affecting mostly young people. The most feasible examination to be performed in the emergency room is computed tomography. Magnetic resonance (MR) imaging is becoming a significant tool in the evaluation of severe brain trauma. Diffusion-weighted imaging is an advanced MR imaging sequence that has been used to detect areas of ischemia and tumor malignancy. This article describes the recent advances in trauma based on diffusion-weighted MR imaging findings and in brain injury from head trauma based on diffusion-weighted MR imaging and diffusion tensor MR imaging findings. Current and potential clinical applications are discussed.     

Cognitive impairment associated with major depression following mild and moderate traumatic brain injury

Traumatic brain injury (TBI) and major depression are neuropsychiatric conditions that have been associated with cognitive dysfunction. The aim of this study was to explore the relationship between major depression and cognitive impairment following mild and moderate TBI. Seventy-four TBI patients were assessed for the presence of major depression using the Structured Clinical Interview for the DSM-IV and completed a neurocognitive assessment battery. Subjects with major depression (28.4%), compared to those without, were found to have significantly lower scores on measures of working memory, processing speed, verbal memory and executive function. Potential mechanisms and implications for treatment are discussed.     

A review of magnetic resonance imaging and diffusion tensor imaging findings in mild traumatic brain injury

Mild traumatic brain injury (mTBI), also referred to as concussion, remains a controversial diagnosis because the brain often appears quite normal on conventional computed tomography (CT) and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scans. Such conventional tools, however, do not adequately depict brain injury in mTBI because they are not sensitive to detecting diffuse axonal injuries (DAI), also described as traumatic axonal injuries (TAI), the major brain injuries in mTBI. Furthermore, for the 15 to 30 % of those diagnosed with mTBI on the basis of cognitive and clinical symptoms, i.e., the "miserable minority," the cognitive and physical symptoms do not resolve following the first 3 months post-injury. Instead, they persist, and in some cases lead to long-term disability. The explanation given for these chronic symptoms, i.e., postconcussive syndrome, particularly in cases where there is no discernible radiological evidence for brain injury, has led some to posit a psychogenic origin. Such attributions are made all the easier since both posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and depression are frequently co-morbid with mTBI. The challenge is thus to use neuroimaging tools that are sensitive to DAI/TAI, such as diffusion tensor imaging (DTI), in order to detect brain injuries in mTBI. Of note here, recent advances in neuroimaging techniques, such as DTI, make it possible to characterize better extant brain abnormalities in mTBI. These advances may lead to the development of biomarkers of injury, as well as to staging of reorganization and reversal of white matter changes following injury, and to the ability to track and to characterize changes in brain injury over time. Such tools will likely be used in future research to evaluate treatment efficacy, given their enhanced sensitivity to alterations in the brain. In this article we review the incidence of mTBI and the importance of characterizing this patient population using objective radiological measures. Evidence is presented for detecting brain abnormalities in mTBI based on studies that use advanced neuroimaging techniques. Taken together, these findings suggest that more sensitive neuroimaging tools improve the detection of brain abnormalities (i.e., diagnosis) in mTBI. These tools will likely also provide important information relevant to outcome (prognosis), as well as play an important role in longitudinal studies that are needed to understand the dynamic nature of brain injury in mTBI. Additionally, summary tables of MRI and DTI findings are included. We believe that the enhanced sensitivity of newer and more advanced neuroimaging techniques for identifying areas of brain damage in mTBI will be important for documenting the biological basis of postconcussive symptoms, which are likely associated with subtle brain alterations, alterations that have heretofore gone undetected due to the lack of sensitivity of earlier neuroimaging techniques. Nonetheless, it is noteworthy to point out that detecting brain abnormalities in mTBI does not mean that other disorders of a more psychogenic origin are not co-morbid with mTBI and equally important to treat. They arguably are. The controversy of psychogenic versus physiogenic, however, is not productive because the psychogenic view does not carefully consider the limitations of conventional neuroimaging techniques in detecting subtle brain injuries in mTBI, and the physiogenic view does not carefully consider the fact that PTSD and depression, and other co-morbid conditions, may be present in those suffering from mTBI. Finally, we end with a discussion of future directions in research that will lead to the improved care of patients diagnosed with mTBI.     

Morphometric changes in the cortex following acute mild traumatic brain injury

Morphometric changes in cortical thickness(CT),cortical surface area(CSA),and cortical volume(CV) can reflect pathological changes after acute mild traumatic brain injury(m TBI).Most previous studies focused on changes in CT,CSA,and CV in subacute or chronic m TBI,and few studies have examined changes in CT,CSA,and CV in acute m TBI.Furthermore,acute m TBI patients typically show transient cognitive impairment,and few studies have reported on the relationship between cerebral morphological changes and cognitive function in patients with m TBI.This prospective cohort study included 30 patients with acute m TBI(15 males,15 females,mean age 33.7 years) and 27 matched healthy controls(12 males,15 females,mean age 37.7 years) who were recruited from the Second Xiangya Hospital of Central South University between September and December 2019.High-resolution T1-weighted images were acquired within 7 days after the onset of m TBI.The results of analyses using Free Surfer software revealed significantly increased CSA and CV in the right lateral occipital gyrus of acutestage m TBI patients compared with healthy controls,but no significant changes in CT.The acute-stage m TBI patients also showed reduced executive function and processing speed indicated by a lower score in the Digital Symbol Substitution Test,and reduced cognitive ability indicated by a longer time to complete the Trail Making Test-B.Both increased CSA and CV in the right lateral occipital gyrus were negatively correlated with performance in the Trail Making Test part A.These findings suggest that cognitive deficits and cortical alterations in CSA and CV can be detected in the acute stage of m TBI,and that increased CSA and CV in the right lateral occipital gyrus may be a compensatory mechanism for cognitive dysfunction in acute-stage m TBI patients.This study was approved by the Ethics Committee of the Second Xiangya Hospital of Central South University,China(approval No.086) on February 9,2019.     

Diffusion tensor imaging and white matter lesions at the subacute stage in mild traumatic brain injury with persistent neurobehavioral impairment

Mild traumatic brain injury (mTBI) can induce long‐term behavioral and cognitive disorders. Although the exact origin of these mTBI‐related disorders is not known, they may be the consequence of diffuse axonal injury (DAI). Here, we investigated whether MRI at the subacute stage can detect lesions that are associated with poor functional outcome in mTBI by using anatomical images (T₁) and diffusion tensor imaging (DTI). Twenty‐three patients with mTBI were investigated and compared with 23 healthy volunteers. All patients underwent an MRI investigation and clinical tests between 7 and 28 days (D15) and between 3 and 4 months (M3) after injury. Patients were divided in two groups of poor outcome (PO) and good outcome (GO), based on their complaints at M3. Groupwise differences in gray matter partial volume between PO patients, GO patients and controls were analyzed using Voxel‐Based Morphometry (VBM) from T₁ data at D15. Differences in microstructural architecture were investigated using Tract‐Based Spatial Statistics (TBSS) and the diffusion images obtained from DTI data at D15. Permutation‐based non‐parametric testing was used to assess cluster significance at p < 0.05, corrected for multiple comparisons. Twelve GO patients and 11 PO patients were identified on the basis of their complaints. In PO patients, gray matter partial volume was significantly lower in several cortical and subcortical regions compared with controls, but did not differ from that of GO patients. No difference in diffusion variables was found between GO and controls. PO patients showed significantly higher mean diffusivity values than both controls and GO patients in the corpus callosum, the right anterior thalamic radiations and the superior longitudinal fasciculus, the inferior longitudinal fasciculus and the fronto‐occipital fasciculus bilaterally. In conclusion, PO patients differed from GO patients by the presence of diffusion changes in long association white matter fiber tracts but not by gray matter partial volume. These results suggest that DTI at the subacute stage may be a predictive marker of poor outcome in mTBI. Hum Brain Mapp, 2011. © 2010 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

Metabolic imaging of mild traumatic brain injury

Traumatic brain injury results in a metabolic cascade of changes that occur at the molecular level, invisible to conventional imaging methods such as computed tomography or magnetic resonance imaging. Non-invasive metabolic imaging tools such as single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT), positron emission tomography (PET), and magnetic resonance spectroscopy (MRS) are the ideal methods for providing insight to these changes by measuring regional cerebral blood flow, glucose metabolism, and brain metabolite concentrations, respectively, after mild traumatic brain injury (mTBI). The purpose of this review is to provide an overview of the different methodologies and provide an up-to-date summary of recent findings with SPECT, PET, and MRS technologies, specifically after mTBI, as defined by standardized criteria. Given that the different physiological and pathological responses are heterogeneous, efforts will be made to separate studies at different time points after injury (acute, subacute, and chronic stages) as well as to the different types of mTBI such sports-related head injury where repetitive head injuries are much more common and may present a unique signature.     

Predicting depression following mild traumatic brain injury

CONTEXT: Minimizing negative consequences of major depression following traumatic brain injury is an important public health objective. Identifying high-risk patients and referring them for treatment could reduce morbidity and loss of productivity. OBJECTIVE: To develop a model for early screening of patients at risk for major depressive episode at 3 months after traumatic brain injury. DESIGN: Prediction model using receiver operating characteristic curve. SETTING: Level I trauma center in a major metropolitan area. PARTICIPANTS: Prospective cohort of 129 adults with mild traumatic brain injury. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Center for Epidemiologic Studies Depression Scale score and current major depressive episode module of the Structured Clinical Interview for the DSM-IV. RESULTS: A prediction model including higher 1-week Center for Epidemiologic Studies Depression Scale score, older age, and computed tomographic scans of intracranial lesions yielded 93% sensitivity and 62% specificity. CONCLUSION: This study supports the feasibility of identifying patients with mild traumatic brain injury who are at high risk for developing major depressive episode by 3 months' postinjury, which could facilitate selective referral for potential treatment and reduction of negative outcomes.