How Conversational Therapy influences language recovery in chronic non-fluent aphasia

The study aimed to determine the efficacy of a Conversational Therapy approach in the treatment of chronic patients with moderately severe non-fluent aphasia. Eight patients completed a six week intensive language training. Every two weeks, each patient received rehabilitation using a different videoclip depicting everyday life. To elicit verbal communication, patients were required to observe each videoclip and to converse about it with the help of an experienced clinician. To measure any significant improvement in speech production all patients were tested before and after treatment. A significant increase in their ability to produce correct informative words (C-Units), verbs, nouns, adjectives, adverbs, as well as closed-class words (pronouns, articles and conjunctions) and well-formed sentences was found after therapy. Such improvement persisted at one week and one month after the end of the treatment. These results suggest that conversational therapy, applied through intensive language training, has a significant efficacy in the recovery of verbal communication in chronic non-fluent aphasic individuals. This approach should be considered for patients with moderately severe non-fluent aphasia, as it enhances not only the ability to use informative language but also its correct use in daily living.     

The contribution of the left and right hemispheres to early recovery from aphasia: a SPECT prospective study

This prospective study examined the relationship between post-stroke recovery of aphasia and changes in cerebral blood flow (CBF). To address the question of right hemisphere (RH) involvement in restitution of language, we tested the hypothesis that the increase in perfusion of the RH is crucial for early recovery from aphasia. Twenty-four right-handed patients with acute aphasia following left hemisphere (LH) ischaemic stroke were examined twice with a six-month interval. At each session CBF and language scores were measured on the same stroke patients. Language was measured by selected tasks derived from the Boston Diagnostic Aphasia Examination (BDAE). The SPECT scans were obtained using (99m)Tc-ECD on a triple-head gamma camera Multispect-3. Although initial CBF measured for the whole group of aphasic patients was not a predictor for future language recovery for either hemisphere, increased perfusion of the RH during a six-month interval was found to parallel the recovery of aphasic disorders. There was a correlation between the change in the right parietal CBF (but not the left) and a change in numerous language abilities. Nevertheless, only CBF values on the left predicted performance on the language tests at initial and follow-up examinations. When the area damaged on structural imaging was excluded from perfusion analysis, only subcortical CBF change on the left showed a positive correlation with language improvement. Thus, the cerebral mechanism associated with early recovery from aphasia is a dynamic and complex process that may involve both hemispheres. Probably this mechanism involves functional reorganisation in the speech-dominant (damaged) hemisphere and regression of haemodynamic disturbances in the non-dominant (structurally intact) hemisphere.     

The contribution of the left and right hemispheres to early recovery from aphasia: A SPECT prospective study

This prospective study examined the relationship between post-stroke recovery of aphasia and changes in cerebral blood flow (CBF). To address the question of right hemisphere (RH) involvement in restitution of language, we tested the hypothesis that the increase in perfusion of the RH is crucial for early recovery from aphasia. Twenty-four right-handed patients with acute aphasia following left hemisphere (LH) ischaemic stroke were examined twice with a six-month interval. At each session CBF and language scores were measured on the same stroke patients. Language was measured by selected tasks derived from the Boston Diagnostic Aphasia Examination (BDAE). The SPECT scans were obtained using ^99mTc-ECD on a triple-head gamma camera Multispect-3. Although initial CBF measured for the whole group of aphasic patients was not a predictor for future language recovery for either hemisphere, increased perfusion of the RH during a six-month interval was found to parallel the recovery of aphasic disorders. There was a correlation between the change in the right parietal CBF (but not the left) and a change in numerous language abilities. Nevertheless, only CBF values on the left predicted performance on the language tests at initial and follow-up examinations. When the area damaged on structural imaging was excluded from perfusion analysis, only subcortical CBF change on the left showed a positive correlation with language improvement. Thus, the cerebral mechanism associated with early recovery from aphasia is a dynamic and complex process that may involve both hemispheres. Probably this mechanism involves functional reorganisation in the speech-dominant (damaged) hemisphere and regression of haemodynamic disturbances in the non-dominant (structurally intact) hemisphere.     

Effect of High Frequency Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation on Recovery of Chronic Post-Stroke Aphasia

BackgroundBoth hemispheres have role in post-stroke aphasia recovery but better recovery is expected with the restoration of function by the left hemisphere. Transcranial stimulation has been used to favor recruitment of left-hemispheric language networks and increase activity of the left hemisphere, thus helps aphasia recovery. ObjectiveThe aim of this study is to evaluate the effect of excitatory repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) on recovery of post stroke aphasic patients. Materials and methodsTwenty patients with post stroke chronic aphasia were enrolled in the study. Aphasia severity was assessed using Aphasia Severity Rating Scale (ASRS). Linguistic deficits were assessed using Kasr Al-Aini Arabic Aphasia test (KAAT). Real rTMS was applied three for 10 sessions of 10-Hz stimulation, positioned over the left Broca's area of the affected hemisphere. All patients were evaluated before, after the end of treatment sessions and one month later. ResultsThere was a significant improvement in the mean total score and mean scores of components of KAAT scale before, immediately after and after one month of rTMS (P< 0.05). Moreover, there was a significant improvement in mean scores of ASRS before, immediately after and after one month of rTMS (P= 0.000). There was a significant difference in mean scores of ASRS and KAAT before, immediately after the last session and after one month between small, medium and large brain infarcts. (P< 0.05).ConclusionExcitatory rTMS is a beneficial adjuvant therapy that improves language skills in patients with chronic post-stroke non-fluent aphasia in short and long term.The protocol of this observational study was registered in clinical trial registration: www.ClinicalTrials.gov, identifier: NCT04708197     

Non-invasive brain stimulation (rTMS and tDCS) in patients with aphasia: Mode of action at the cellular level

A high proportion of patients who have suffered a stroke also suffer from aphasia. Approximately half of those affected will remain in this state despite intensive language therapy. Non-invasive brain stimulation allows us to directly and focally stimulate areas of the brain. Repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) and transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS), methods used in the treatment of aphasia, are based on an imbalance of mutual interhemispheric inhibition. In open and sham-controlled studies, a low-frequency, 1 Hz stimulation of the non-lesioned hemisphere (the homologue of Broca's area) for a week or more significantly improved spontaneous speech and anomia in patients with non-fluent aphasia. These positive outcomes from rTMS stimulation developed slowly, often over months following treatment, and persisted. Effects of intermittent theta burst stimulation (iTBS) developed faster than the low-frequency stimulation, and high-activity enhancement was detected in the left hemisphere after the stimulation of Broca's region. Both types of tDCS stimulation resulted in improved comprehension and reduced anomia, their primary modes of action are distinct, however, both share a common site of action with regard to the balance that occurs between inhibitory and excitatory neurotransmitters (synaptic and non-synaptic). Both types of non-invasive stimulation prepare the lesioned brain for better outcome.     

Mechanisms of aphasia recovery and brain imaging]

Aphasia recovery may depend on right hemisphere or non-lesioned left hemisphere structures, pre-morbid brain language organization, and de novo learning of language. Here we review the brain imaging evidence supporting these different hypotheses. CT-scan studies have investigated the prognosis value of size and site of left hemisphere lesions. The size of the lesion is a global but not an individual predictor of the initial severity and subsequent recovery of aphasia. Studies on the site of the lesion have given different results for verbal expression and comprehension. There is no consensus on a single critical site for recovery of verbal expression in non-fluent aphasia, which may depend on sub-cortical more than cortical extend of the lesion. Conversely the extend of the lesion in the superior temporal gyrus emerges as a critical negative factor for comprehension recovery. Rest measurements of brain metabolism have consistently shown that aphasia severity depends much more on the degree of dysfunction of language-related areas in the left hemisphere than on the site of the lesion it-self. This suggests that aphasia recovery may depend on metabolic dysfunction recovery in peri-lesional structures. More recently, activation studies have shown consistent right hemisphere activation during language tasks in aphasic subjects, but their role in recovery remains debated. It is likely limited, and may depend on atypical pre-morbid language lateralization. Left hemisphere activations are also found in aphasic patients. They are often relocalized in peri-lesional areas, and emerge in most studies as the main factor of aphasia recovery.     

Communicating with the non-dominant hemisphere Implications for neurological rehabilitation

Aphasic syndromes usually result from injuries to the dominant hemisphere of the brain. Despite the fact that localization of language functions shows little interindividual variability, several brain areas are simultaneously activated when language tasks are undertaken. Mechanisms of language recovery after brain injury to the dominant hemisphere seem to be relatively stereotyped, including activations of perilesional areas in the acute phase and of homologues of language areas in the non-dominant hemisphere in the subacute phase, later returning to dominant hemisphere activation in the chronic phase. Plasticity mechanisms reopen the critical period of language development, more specifically in what leads to disinhibition of the non-dominant hemisphere when brain lesions affect the dominant hemisphere. The non-dominant hemisphere plays an important role during recovery from aphasia, but currently available rehabilitation therapies have shown limited results for efficient language improvement. Large-scale randomized controlled trials that evaluate well-defined interventions in patients with aphasia are needed for stimulation of neuroplasticity mechanisms that enhance the role of the non-dominant hemisphere for language recovery. Ineffective treatment approaches should be replaced by more promising ones and the latter should be evaluated for proper application. The data generated by such studies could substantiate evidence-based rehabilitation strategies for patients with aphasia.     

Contrasting opinions on the role of the right hemisphere in the recovery of language. A critical survey

Background: The role of the right hemisphere (RH) in the recovery of language is quite controversial.

Aims: The aim of the present survey consisted in taking into account three main models advanced to explain the reconstitution of language systems: (1) the “perilesional hypothesis,” which maintains that language recovery is mainly subsumed by left hemisphere (LH) tissue adjacent to the lesion; (2) the “right hemisphere hypothesis,” which assumes that restitution of language entails an increased participation of the RH; and (3) the “disinhibition hypothesis,” which maintains that recovery is facilitated by disruption of inhibitions exerted by RH regions over LH language areas.

Methods & Procedures: The prognostic factors in poststroke aphasia are discussed first, focusing attention on factors that could subsume an increased participation of the RH to the recovery of language. Then results obtained with techniques of noninvasive brain stimulations of the RH are taken critically into account.

Outcomes & Results: As for the prognostic factors, the following points are stressed: (1) the anatomical extension of the LH lesion plays an important role both on the degree and on the path of recovery; (2) the RH structures involved in the recovery of language are generally mirror structures of the damaged LH areas; and (3) the time elapsed since the onset of aphasia influences the contribution that contralateral and ipsilesional areas give to the recovery of language. As for results obtained with techniques of noninvasive brain stimulations of the RH, this point remains controversial, because most authors support the “disinhibition hypothesis,” but theoretical and factual reasons suggest caution in the interpretation of these results.

Conclusions: Since the meaning of the RH activations and of results obtained with techniques of noninvasive brain stimulations remain controversial, some tentative recommendations to clarify these issues are advanced.     

The memory that's right and the memory that's left: event-related potentials reveal hemispheric asymmetries in the encoding and retention of verbal information

We examined the nature and timecourse of hemispheric asymmetries in verbal memory by recording event-related potentials (ERPs) in a continuous recognition task. Participants made overt recognition judgments to test words presented in central vision that were either novel (new words) or had been previously presented in the left or right visual field (old words). An ERP memory effect linked to explicit retrieval revealed no asymmetries for words repeated at short and medium retention intervals, but at longer repetition lags (20-50 intervening words) this 'old/new effect' was more pronounced for words whose study presentation had been biased to the right hemisphere (RH). Additionally, a repetition effect linked to more implicit recognition processes (P2 amplitude changes) was observed at all lags for words preferentially encoded by the RH but was not observed for left hemisphere (LH)-encoded words. These results are consistent with theories that the RH encodes verbal stimuli more veridically whereas the LH encodes in a more abstract manner. The current findings provide a critical link between prior work on memory asymmetries, which has emphasized general LH advantages for verbal material, and on language comprehension, which has pointed to an important role for the RH in language processes that require the retention and integration of verbal information over long time spans.     

Cerebral reorganization as a function of linguistic recovery in children: An fMRI study

Characterizing and mapping the relationship between neuronal reorganization and functional recovery are essential to the understanding of cerebral plasticity and the dynamic processes which occur following brain damage. The neuronal mechanisms underlying linguistic recovery following left hemisphere (LH) lesions are still unknown. Using functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI), we investigated whether the extent of brain lateralization of linguistic functioning in specific regions of interest (ROIs) is correlated with the level of linguistic performance following recovery from acquired childhood aphasia. The study focused on a rare group of children in whom lesions occurred after normal language acquisition, but prior to complete maturation of the brain. During fMRI scanning, rhyming, comprehension and verb generation activation tasks were monitored. The imaging data were evaluated with reference to linguistic performance measured behaviorally during imaging, as well as outside the scanner. Compared with normal controls, we found greater right hemisphere (RH) lateralization in patients. However, correlations with linguistic performance showed that increased proficiency in linguistic tasks was associated with greater lateralization to the LH. These results were replicated in a longitudinal case study of a patient scanned twice, 3 years apart. Additional improvement in linguistic performance of the patient was accompanied by increasing lateralization to the LH in the anterior language region. This, however, was the result of a decreased involvement of the RH. These findings suggest that recovery is a dynamic, ongoing process, which may last for years after onset. The role of each hemisphere in the recovery process may continuously change within the chronic stage.     

Language representation in a patient with a dominant right hemisphere: fMRI evidence for an intrahemispheric reorganisation

Studies have suggested that congenital left hemispheric (LH) frontal arteriovenous malformations (AVMs) are associated with an early transfer of language to right hemisphere (RH) frontal regions. The question remains whether such anatomofunctional reorganisation is due to RH compensatory abilities or to a general principle of lateral shift. In this study, we used fMRI language paradigms to investigate the case of a patient presenting aphasic symptoms following an haemorrhage due to a right frontal AVM. Prior to surgery, fMRI showed that language processing was confined to the RH, suggesting that language had not shifted during childhood from this congenitally dominant RH to the LH. After surgery, the patient presented severe aphasia that recovered to presurgical level within 70 days. At this time, fMRI showed that language tasks were still not associated with activations in the LH. These results suggest that the principles of early cerebral reorganisation after congenital lesions may differ in the RH and the LH. In addition, they support the idea that efficient restoration of language is achieved if a sufficiently large neuronal network is preserved around the lesion.     

Role of cognitive control in language deficits in different types of aphasia

ABSTRACT

Background: Although studies show that different facets of cognitive control are impaired in persons with aphasia (PWA), the question how they impact language abilities in different types of aphasia remains open.

Aims: Following the hypothesis that diminished attention contributes to language impairments in aphasia, we predicted that both fluent and non-fluent PWA would perform worse than neurologically intact individuals on verbal and non-verbal cognitive control tasks. Also, testing the view that linguistic disturbances in fluent and non-fluent PWA dissociate, we predicted differential relationships in performance on cognitive control tasks and language impairment.

Methods & Procedures: Fluent PWA (N = 17) and non-fluent PWA (N = 14) were compared to unimpaired speakers (N = 21) on the non-verbal Flanker task tapping domain-general cognitive control, and Stroop task measuring verbal cognitive control, as well as subtests from the Russian version of the Birmingham Cognitive Screen, namely the Auditory Control task tapping verbal cognitive control and the Rule Finding task measuring domain-general cognitive control. All PWA completed picture naming and language comprehension tasks.

Outcomes & Results: All PWA were more impaired on the Stroop and Auditory Control tasks, with no impairment on the non-verbal Flanker task compared to the controls. Non-fluent PWA also performed significantly worse on the Rule Finding that requires forming and updating non-verbal relational representations. Differences between aphasia groups were found on the Auditory Control task only, where non-fluent PWA were more vulnerable to task demands. Correlation analyses found that verbal and non-verbal cognitive control performance was correlated for the non-fluent group, whereas only correlations between verbal cognitive control tasks were significant for the fluent group. For all PWA, non-verbal cognitive control indexed by Flanker interference scores was related to language comprehension, whereas verbal cognitive control was related to picture naming. However, non-verbal relational reasoning as indexed by the Rule Finding task was significantly related to language comprehension in the non-fluent group only.

Conclusions: All PWA had diminished verbal cognitive control. Non-fluent PWA demonstrated higher vulnerability to domain-general cognitive control deficits compared to fluent PWA. Performance on verbal and non-verbal cognitive control tasks significantly overlapped in the non-fluent group only. Both groups recruited non-verbal cognitive control during language comprehension and verbal cognitive control during picture naming. Only non-fluent PWA relied on domain-general relational reasoning during language comprehension. These findings reinforce the importance of cognitive assessment in aphasia.     

Efficacy of semantic–phonological treatment combined with tDCS for verb retrieval in a patient with aphasia

Recent studies reported enhanced performance on language tasks induced by transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) in patients with aphasia. One chronic patient with non-fluent aphasia received 20 sessions of a verb anomia training combined with off-line bihemispheric tDCS applied to the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (DLPFC) – anodal tDCS over left DLPFC plus cathodal tDCS over right DLPFC. A significant improvement in verb naming was observed at all testing times (4, 12, 24, and 48 weeks from post-entry/baseline testing) for treated and untreated verbs. Our findings show beneficial effects of verb anomia training in combination with tDCS in chronic aphasic patient, suggesting a long-lasting effect of this treatment.     

经颅直流电联合持续θ短阵快速脉冲刺激语言双模通路治疗脑卒中后非流畅性失语症的疗效观察

目的观察经颅直流电（tDCS）联合持续θ短阵快速脉冲刺激（cTBS）语言双模通路治疗脑卒中后非流畅性失语症疗效。 方法将绵阳市第三人民医院康复医学科自2017年1月至2019年6月收治入院的64例非流畅性失语症患者采用随机数字表法分为治疗组32例，对照组32例。2组患者均使用常规言语康复训练，治疗组增加tDCS联合cTBS刺激，对照组采用假刺激，假刺激部位、治疗模式、治疗时间都与治疗组相同。2组患者均治疗1次/d，每周6次，连续5周。治疗前后均使用汉化版西方失语成套量表及功能独立性量表进行评估，观察2组患者在治疗前后的失语商（AQ）、操作商（PQ）和大脑皮质商（CQ）评分变化及功能独立性评分变化。 结果2组治疗前后对比，治疗后AQ、PQ、CQ评分均显著优于治疗前，差异有统计学意义（P<0.05），2组治疗都有效，但治疗组治疗后的AQ、CQ评分优于对照组（P<0.05），差异有统计学意义，PQ评分比较差异无统计学意义（P>0.05）；治疗后，2组的功能独立性评分均较治疗前升高，差异有统计学意义（P<0.05），但2组改善程度对比差异无统计学意义（P>0.05）。 结论tDCS联合cTBS刺激语言双模通路能显著改善脑卒中后非流畅性失语症患者的语言功能。     

Neural correlates of phonological and semantic-based anomia treatment in aphasia

Most naming treatments in aphasia either assume a phonological or semantic emphasis or a combination thereof. However, it is unclear whether semantic or phonological treatments recruit the same or different cortical areas in chronic aphasia. Employing three persons with aphasia, two of whom were non-fluent, the present study compared changes in neural recruitment associated with phonologic and semantic-based naming treatments. The participants with non-fluent aphasia were able to name more items following both treatment approaches. Although this was not the case for the participant who had fluent aphasia, her naming errors decreased considerably following treatment. Post-treatment fMRI revealed similar changes in neural activity bilaterally in the precuneus among the two non-fluent participants--increased activity was noted in the right entorhinal cortex and posterior thalamus on post-treatment scans for the third participant. These findings imply that cortical areas not traditionally related to language processing may support anomia recovery in some patients with chronic aphasia.     

Broca aphasia with neologisms]

Patients with jargon aphasia generally have fluent speech with poor comprehension. However, outstanding jargons may appear in non-fluent aphasics. We report a 69-year-old left-handed woman with non-fluent jargon aphasia due to lesions in the right frontoparietal area. Features of her speech included non-fluent meaningless sequences of syllables, i. e., phonetic jargon, which was obvious in all the tasks including spontaneous speech, repetition, naming and reading. Her utterance was sparse, but not effortful or anarthric. She understood most of spoken single words, but was confused by complex sentences. Brain CTs revealed acute lesions affecting the inferior and middle frontal gyri, insular cortex, precentral and postcentral gyri, and a part of the angular gyrus in the right hemisphere. Old infarcts were also noted in the right frontal pole and prefrontal area. The unique feature of her language impairment suggested somewhat deviated lateralization and localization of her language function.     

Changes in Language-specific Brain Activation after Therapy for Aphasia using Magnetoencephalography: A Case Study

A patient with chronic aphasia underwent functional imaging during a language comprehension task using magnetoencephalography (MEG) before and after constraint induced language therapy (CILT). In the pre- and immediate post-treatment (TX) scans MEG activity sources were observed within right hemisphere only, and were located in areas homotopic to left hemisphere language areas. There was a significant increase in activation in these areas between the two sessions. This change was not observed in an age-matched patient with chronic aphasia who underwent sequential language testing and MEG scanning across a similar time period without being administered therapy. In the 3-month post-TX scan bilateral activation was observed, including significant activation within the left temporal lobe. The changes in the spatial parameters of the maps of receptive language function after therapy were accompanied by improvement in language function. Results provide support, in the same individual, for a role for both hemispheres in recovery of language function after therapy for chronic aphasia.     

Changes in language-specific brain activation after therapy for aphasia using magnetoencephalography: a case study

A patient with chronic aphasia underwent functional imaging during a language comprehension task using magnetoencephalography (MEG) before and after constraint induced language therapy (CILT). In the pre- and immediate post-treatment (TX) scans MEG activity sources were observed within right hemisphere only, and were located in areas homotopic to left hemisphere language areas. There was a significant increase in activation in these areas between the two sessions. This change was not observed in an age-matched patient with chronic aphasia who underwent sequential language testing and MEG scanning across a similar time period without being administered therapy. In the 3-month post-TX scan bilateral activation was observed, including significant activation within the left temporal lobe. The changes in the spatial parameters of the maps of receptive language function after therapy were accompanied by improvement in language function. Results provide support, in the same individual, for a role for both hemispheres in recovery of language function after therapy for chronic aphasia.     

A case of crossed aphasia with echolalia after the resection of tumor in the right medial frontal lobe]

We report a right-handed woman, who developed a non-fluent aphasia after resection of astrocytoma (grade III) in the right medial frontal lobe. On admission to the rehabilitation department, neurological examination revealed mild left hemiparesis, hyperreflexia on the left side and grasp reflex on the left hand. Neuropsychologically she showed general inattention, non-fluent aphasia, acalculia, constructional disability, and mild buccofacial apraxia. No other apraxia, unilateral spatial neglect or extinction phenomena were observed. An MRI demonstrated resected areas in the right superior frontal gyrus, subcortical region in the right middle frontal gyrus, anterior part of the cingulate gyrus, a part of supplementary motor area. Surrounding area in the right frontal lobe showed diffuse signal change. She demonstrated non-fluent aprosodic speech with word finding difficulty. No phonemic paraphasia, or anarthria was observed. Auditory comprehension was fair with some difficulty in comprehending complex commands. Naming was good, but verbal fluency tests for a category or phonemic cuing was severely impaired. She could repeat words but not sentences. Reading comprehension was disturbed by semantic paralexia and writing words was poor for both Kana (syllabogram) and Kanji(logogram) characters. A significant feature of her speech was mitigated echolalia. In both free conversation and examination setting, she often repeated phrases spoken to her which she used to start her speech. In addition, she repeated words spoken to others which were totally irrelevant to her conversation. She was aware of her echoing, which always embarrassed her. She described her echolalic tendency as a great nuisance. However, once echoing being forbidden, she could not initiate her speech and made incorrect responses after long delay. Thus, her compulsive echolalia helped to start her speech. Only four patients with crossed aphasia demonstrated echolalia in the literature. They showed severe aphasia with markedly decreased speech and severe comprehension deficit. A patient with a similar lesion in the right medial frontal lobe had aspontaneity in general and language function per se could not be examined properly. Echolalia related to the medial frontal lesion in the language dominant hemisphere was described as a compulsive speech response, because some other 'echoing' phenomena or compulsive behavior were also observed in these patients. On the other hand, some patients with a large lesion in the right hemisphere tended to respond to stimuli directed to other patients, so called 'response-to-next-patient-stimulation'. This behavior was explained by disinhibited shift of attention or perseveration of the set. Both compulsive speech responses and 'response-to-next-patient-stimulation' like phenomena may have contributed to the echolalia phenomena of the present case.