Latency and amplitude compound action potential tuning curves for tonal stimuli with nontraditional envelopes

To evaluate the influence of the acoustic context on the latency and amplitude tuning curves (TCs) of cochlear nerve compound action potentials (CAPs), tonal stimuli were generated with a variety of amplitude modulation envelopes. CAPs were produced by intensity increases (onsets) and decreases (offsets) from the low ambient sound level and by intensity changes from a preexisting tonal level. Onset CAPs from ambient levels generated V-shaped TCs. However, when simultaneous masking was used with onset CAPs which were produced by a 5- to 12-dB increase from preexisting levels of approximately 65 dB SPL, TCs were W-shaped and similar in appearance to those produced by simultaneous masking of offset CAPs. The forward masking of this same CAP resulted in a very sharp V-shaped TC. These data suggest that the preadaptation to 10 ms of a moderate level of a tonal stimulus can increase the tuning of ensembles of cochlear neurons to subsequent transient amplitude changes.     

Tuning of the auditory brainstem OFF responses is complementary to tuning of the auditory brainstem ON response

Continuous masking studies show a complementary pattern of effects on the auditory brainstem responses (ABRs) which are generated by the onset and by the offset of a midfrequency tone. The masking profiles of the two responses are almost opposite with a probe stimulus frequency of 32 kHz (16-32 kHz is the midfrequency region for the CBA/J mouse). The Offset and Onset ABR tuning curves (TCs) also reveal very different properties at the midfrequencies of 16, 20, 24 and 32 kHz. The Offset TC is exquisitely sensitive to masking by very low intensity stimuli at a narrow range of frequencies which are lower than the probe stimulus frequency. Continuous masking produces a well-tuned low frequency tip to the Offset TC. For Offset TCs generated in response to midfrequency tones, the Q+10 dB of this tip averages 8.3. Masking at this low frequency tip of the Offset TC has no observable effect on the Onset ABR. The Offset ABR is also sensitive to masking by a narrow range of frequencies which are higher than the probe stimulus frequency. This occurs at an intensity which also has no observable effect on the Onset ABR. The Q+10 dB of this high frequency tip averages 9.2. The average frequencies where these Offset TC tips occur fit the cubic difference formula (2f1-f2), which describes a distortion product of two-tone suppression. At low probe stimulus frequencies, there is only a high frequency Offset TC tip; at high stimulus frequencies, only a low frequency tip. The high frequency tip has a higher threshold and appears more susceptible to metabolic disturbance. The Offset ABR TC also has a peak which corresponds to the probe stimulus frequency. Continuous masking with the stimulus frequency produces nonmonotonic enhancement of the Offset ABR, while it simultaneously reduces the magnitude of the Onset ABR. The tuning of this Offset TC peak (measured as Q-10 dB) is almost always much sharper than the corresponding Onset TC tip in the same mouse. These values for midfrequency stimuli average 6.2 for the Onset, and 13.6 for the Offset TCs. This fine tuning of the Offset TC at the probe stimulus frequency occurs at SPLs from 50 to more than 90 dB.     

Offset tuning curves generated by simultaneous masking are more finely tuned than those generated by forward masking

The rapid ending of a tone produces an evoked potential which has different properties than that which is produced by the sudden onset of a tone. At the level of the round window, the offset N1 N2 follows the ending of the cochlear microphonic (CM) by approximately the same amount of time as does the onset N1 N2 to the onset of the CM. Both onset and offset responses are abolished with cochlear lesion. Continuous masking was used to generate tuning curves (TCs) from the NI-PI component of the evoked potential recorded from the round window of the gerbil. Those evoked potentials generated in response to the tone onset were complementary in appearance to those generated in response to the tone offset. TCs generated by continuous masking of the NI-PII component of the auditory brainstem response (ABR) of the gerbil show the same pattern. When it is generated by simultaneous masking, the midfrequency offset TC in the gerbil and mouse is W-shaped. It has two well tuned tips which occur at frequencies below and above that of the probe stimulus used to generate the TC. It also has an even better tuned peak occurring at or slightly above the probe stimulus frequency, which becomes sharper as the masker sound pressure level (SPL) is increased from 50 to over 80 dB. Because the midfrequency onset response is approximately 40 dB lower than the midfrequency offset response, probe stimuli for onset TCs are generally set at lower SPLs. When the onset probe stimulus is set to the same level as that of the offset probe, the Q10 dB of the offset TC may be up to 10 times the value of the Q10 dB of the onset TC. The offset TC generated in the CBA/J mouse by forward masking is quite different from that produced by simultaneous masking. Both forward and simultaneous conditions utilized a 40 ms duration tone to mask the PI-NI component of offset and onset ABRs of the mouse which were evoked by a 10 ms duration, 32 kHz tone, presented at an interstimulus interval of 160 ms. Forward masking (when compared with simultaneous masking) resulted in a more sharply tuned onset TC. But the offset TC was much less sharply tuned in the forward masking condition. This suggests that the offset response may reflect functions which are involved with fine tuning at moderate to high intensities in the presence of simultaneous sounds of similar spectral characteristics.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

Compound action potential offset and onset tuning curves generated by simultaneous masking in the mongolian gerbil. Effects of varying the intensity of the probe stimulus from 55 to 85 dB SPL

Action potential tuning curves (TCs) were produced by simultaneous masking of both the onset and offset of tone bursts. Offset TCs are much more sharply tuned than onset TCs when both responses are generated by stimuli at SPLs of 55 to 75 dB. The onset TC tip and the offset TC high frequency tip thresholds accurately reflect increases of the probe SPL, but the low frequency tip and the peak of the offset TC compress this change. With increasing probe SPL, the onset TC and low frequency TC tip (but not the high frequency tip and peak) of the offset TC become progressively detuned.     

Latency and Amplitude Tuning Curves of the N1 and N2 Components of the Cochlear Nerve Compound Action Potential

Compound action potential tuning curves (CAP TCs) generated by masking the N1 component of the CAP provide a means of assessing the ability of the cochlea to selectively tune to certain stimuli. This paper examines some of the factors which can influence this TC when a moderately intense (i.e. 40–80 dB SPL) probe stimulus is used. At these levels, each of the four corners of the trapezoidal stimulus envelope is capable of generating a CAP. Also, short stimulus rise times can merge the CAPs produced by the first two corners, but this does not appear to have a major effect on the CAP TC. It was shown that the N2 component of the CAP for the first corner of the stimulus is equally capable of producing a well-tuned TC. Another study has shown that, in addition to amplitude decrements, one can use latency increases as a criterion for CAP TCs. We have demonstrated that latency TCs are more finely tuned than amplitude TCs at high levels, especially when the stimulus rise time is short.     

Latency and amplitude tuning curves of the N1 and N2 components of the cochlear nerve compound action potential

Compound action potential tuning curves (CAP TCs) generated by masking the N1 component of the CAP provide a means of assessing the ability of the cochlea to selectively tune to certain stimuli. This paper examines some of the factors which can influence this TC when a moderately intense (i.e. 40-80 dB SPL) probe stimulus is used. At these levels, each of the four corners of the trapezoidal stimulus envelope is capable of generating a CAP. Also, short stimulus rise times can merge the CAPs produced by the first two corners, but this does not appear to have a major effect on the CAP TC. It was shown that the N2 component of the CAP for the first corner of the stimulus is equally capable of producing a well-tuned TC. Another study has shown that, in addition to amplitude decrements, one can use latency increases as a criterion for CAP TCs. We have demonstrated that latency TCs are more finely tuned than amplitude TCs at high levels, especially when the stimulus rise time is short.     

Masking of short probe sounds by tone bursts with a sweeping frequency

The maske threshold of short ($\text{? 40}\text{ms}$) probe tone or a short one-third octave probe noise appears to increase if the frequency of a tonal masker is swept. Frequency sweeps were exponential (octaves/s) and unidirectional. Probe sounds were presented in the time center of the masker at the center frequency of the masker. The sweep speed, S, appeared to be an important parameter; masker duration was much less important. For 10-ms tonal probes, in-phase with the masker in their common time center, 100-ms maskers, and upward sweeps, increase of the masked threshold appeared to be maximal at a sweep speed of 30 oct/s and the masked threshold was 21 dB higher than the masked threshold found for the stationary masker (S = 0 oct/s). Above 30 oct/s the masked threshold decreased. For downward sweeps masking was maximal at S = 20 oct/s and the threshold was 15 dB higher. Sweeping upward the increase in masking was 12 dB for both noise probes and tonal probes with phase differing by 90° from the masker in their common time center. The results are inconsistent with current models of masking: sweeping the frequency the masked threshold increases whereas the energy within the critical band at the probe frequency decreases.     

Representation of acoustic signals in the eighth nerve of the tokay gecko II. Masking of pure tones with noise

Acoustic signals are generally encoded in the peripheral auditory system of vertebrates by a duality scheme. For frequency components that fall within the excitatory tuning curve, individual eighth nerve fibers can encode the effective spectral energy by a spike-rate code, while simultaneously preserving the signal waveform periodicity of lower frequency components by phase-locked spike-train discharges. To explore how robust this duality of representation may be in the presence of noise, we recorded the responses of auditory fibers in the eighth nerve of the Tokay gecko to tonal stimuli when masking noise was added simultaneously. We found that their spike-rate functions reached plateau levels fairly rapidly in the presence of noise, so the ability to signal the presence of a tone by a concomitant change in firing rate was quickly lost. On the other hand, their synchronization functions maintained a high degree of phase-locked firings to the tone even in the presence of high-intensity masking noise, thus enabling a robust detection of the tonal signal. Critical ratios (CR) and critical bandwidths showed that in the frequency range where units are able to phaselock to the tonal periodicity, the CR bands were relatively narrow and the bandwidths were independent of noise level. However, to higher frequency tones where phaselocking fails and only spike-rate codes apply, the CR bands were much wider and depended upon noise level, so that their ability to filter tones out of a noisy background degraded with increasing noise levels. The greater robustness of phase-locked temporal encoding contrasted with spike-rate coding verifies a important advantage in using lower frequency signals for communication in noisy environments.     

Patterns of residual masking

‘Residual masking’ was measured in a tonal forward masking paradigm. In one experiment, psychophysical tuning curves and masking patterns were obtained at several frequencies and levels for a fixed masker—probe time delay. In a second experiment, tuning curves and masking patterns were measured as masker-probe time delay was varied. Our results indicate that tuning curves and masking patterns are sharpest at low levels, high frequencies and brief masker-probe time delays. In addition, we observed that masked probe threshold returned to the level of unmasked probe threshold at approximately the same post-masker time regardless of masker level or the probe-to-masker frequency relationship. These findings suggest that frequency, level and time delay all affect the degree of frequency selectivity observed with these measures.     

Speech recognition in noise: estimating effects of compressive nonlinearities in the basilar-membrane response

OBJECTIVES: This experiment was designed to estimate effects of cochlear nonlinearities on tonal and speech masking for individuals with normal hearing who have a range of quiet thresholds. Physiological and psychophysical evidence indicates that for signals close to the characteristic frequency (CF) of a place on the basilar membrane, the normal growth of response of the basilar membrane is linear at lower stimulus levels and compressed at medium to higher stimulus levels. In contrast, at moderate to high CFs, the basilar membrane responds more linearly to stimuli at frequencies well below the CF regardless of input level. Thus, the hypothesis tested was that masker effectiveness would change as a function of stimulus level consistent with the underlying basilar membrane response. Specifically, with a fixed-level speech signal and a speech-shaped masker that ranges from low to higher levels, the resulting response of the basilar membrane to the masker would be linear at lower levels and compressed at medium to higher levels. This would result in relatively less effective masking at higher masker levels. It was further hypothesized that the transition from linear to compressed responses to both tones and maskers would occur at higher levels for listeners with higher quiet thresholds than for listeners with lower quiet thresholds. DESIGN: Tonal thresholds and speech recognition in noise were measured as a function of masker level. A 10-msec, 2.0-kHz tone was presented in a lower frequency masker ranging from 40 to 85 dB SPL. Moderate-level speech was presented in interrupted noise at six levels ranging from 47 to 77 dB SPL. To minimize differences in speech audibility that could arise during the "off" periods of the interrupted noise, a low-level steady-state "threshold-matching noise" was also present during measurement of speech recognition. Subjects were 30 adults with normal hearing with a 20-dB range of average quiet thresholds. RESULTS: Tonal breakpoints (i.e., the levels corresponding to the transitions from linear to nonlinear responses) were significantly correlated with quiet thresholds, whereas slopes measured above the breakpoints were not. Speech recognition in noise was consistent with the hypothesis that the response of the basilar membrane to the masker was linear at lower levels and compressed at medium to higher levels, resulting in less effective masking at higher masker levels. That is, at lower masker levels, as masker level increased, mean observed speech scores declined as predicted using the articulation index, an audibility-based model. With further increases in masker level, mean scores declined less than predicted. Moreover, for subjects with higher quiet thresholds, masker effectiveness remained constant for a wider range of masker levels than for subjects with lower quiet thresholds, consistent with the hypothesis that the transition from linear to compressed responses occurred at higher levels. Finally, significant negative correlations were obtained between individual subjects' tonal and speech measures. CONCLUSIONS: Results from tonal and speech tasks were consistent with basilar membrane nonlinearities and consistent with changes in nonlinearities with minor threshold elevations, providing support for their role in the understanding of speech in noise with increases in noise level.     

The microstructure of quiet and masked thresholds

Factors leading to the microstructure of the audiogram (a constant pattern of threshold maxima and minima as a function of frequency) are shown to influence masked thresholds, changing the shape of masking functions when both constant and variable tonal maskers are used. Simultaneous masking with broadband noise gradually reduces the difference between threshold maxima and minima until no further differences can be seen when masked thresholds are above 40-50 dB SPL. Nonsimultaneous masking with broadband noise reveals a changed microstructure when thresholds are elevated above 30-40 dB SPL. Thus in both simultaneous and nonsimultaneous masking the rate of threshold growth with increasing masker level is different for tones from threshold minima than for tones from threshold maxima. These psychophysical measures are related to measures of evoked cochlear emissions and the results are discussed in terms of the implications for understanding the cochlear mechanisms responsible for the microstructure and for the interpretation of psychophysical measures with low level stimuli.     

The measurement of critical masking bands.

The characteristics of the critical masking band, that spectral region of a wideband noise that is effective in masking a pure-tone signal, were inferred by measuring detectability (d) for tonal signals as a function of the cutoff frequency of a low-pass or high-pass noise masker. As the cutoff frequency of a low-pass noise was decreased from the wide-band (100-7000 Hz) condition toward the signal frequency, (500, 1000, or 4000 Hz) dectability maintained a constant minimum until a further reduction in cutoff frequency increased detectability, presumably due to a reduction in masker power within the critical band. As cutoff frequency was reduced further, detectability increased monotonically until detection reached 100%. This usually occurred when the cutoff frequency is 0.04 to 0.06 octaves below the signal frequency. The range of cutoff frequencies over which detectability changes occurred defines the critical masking band. These ranges correspond closely to well-known critical ratio data. The dependence of d on noise cutoff frequency did not differ at the two signal levels (15 and 25 dB SL) used in this experiment. The critical band appeared symmetrical about the signal frequency for most subjects and most experimental conditions, although some subjects displayed a marked asymmetry in the high frequency direction for some conditions.     

Noise reduction hearing aids: release from masking and release from distortion.

Automatic frequency response (AFR) hearing aids usually reduce their low-frequency gain in the presence of noise; several investigators have reported improved recognition of high-frequency speech information in low-frequency band-limited noise with AFR versus non-AFR hearing aids. In this work, masking patterns (masked threshold for frequency-modulated probe tones as a function of probe frequency) were obtained for a narrowband low-frequency noise. Speech recognition threshold for a set of high-frequency loaded monosyllables also was obtained in the presence of the same noise. Aided speech and masking pattern data for one normal and two hearing-impaired subjects wearing a master hearing aid incorporating a commercially available AFR circuit showed modest AFR effects. Moreover, masking noise spectra measured in ear canals of subjects wearing the master hearing aid showed evidence of substantial hearing aid-generated distortion products in the AFR-off condition. Results obtained from the normal subject listening with a low-distortion laboratory simulation of an AFR hearing aid showed greater release from masking for the same low-frequency attenuation as provided by the hearing aid. Improvements of speech recognition in noise observed with AFR hearing aids may result from some combination of release from upward spread of masking and reduction of distortion products generated by the hearing aid in the non-AFR setting.     

The effects of decreased audibility produced by high-pass noise masking on N1 and the mismatch negativity to speech sounds /ba/and/da.

This study investigated the effects of decreased audibility produced by high-pass noise masking on the cortical event-related potentials (ERPs) N1 and mismatch negativity (MMN) to the speech sounds /ba/ and /da/, presented at 65 dB SPL. ERPs were recorded while normal listeners (N = 11) ignored the stimuli and read a book. Broadband masking noise was simultaneously presented at an intensity sufficient to mask the response to the speech sounds, and subsequently high-pass filtered. The conditions were QUIET (no noise); high-pass cutoff frequencies of 4000, 2000, 1000, 500, and 250 Hz; and broadband noise. Behavioral measures of discrimination of the speech sounds (d' and reaction time) were obtained separately from the ERPs for each listener and condition. As the cutoff frequency of the high-pass masker was lowered, ERP latencies increased and amplitudes decreased. The cutoff frequency where changes first occurred differed for N1 and MMN. N1 showed small systematic changes across frequency beginning with the 4000-Hz high-pass noise. MMN and behavioral measures showed large changes that occurred at approximately 1000 Hz. These results indicate that decreased audibility, resulting from the masking, affects N1 and the MMN in a differential manner. N1 reflects the presence of audible stimulus energy, being present in all conditions where stimuli were audible, whether or not they were discriminable. The MMN is present only for those conditions where stimuli were behaviorally discriminable. These studies of cortical ERPs in high-pass noise studies provide insight into the changes in brain processes and behavioral performance that occur when audibility is reduced, as in hearing loss.     

Duration discrimination in listeners with cochlear hearing loss: effects of stimulus type and frequency.

This study examined the effects of cochlear hearing loss on the ability to discriminate increments in the duration of a stimulus under conditions where the frequency and/or amplitude of the stimulus change dynamically. Three stimulus types were used: pure tones, frequency-modulated tones, and narrow bands of noise. The carrier/center frequency of each 250-ms stimulus either remained constant at 1035 Hz or varied randomly from presentation to presentation across the frequency range 432-2804 Hz. Two groups of listeners participated: 9 with bilateral cochlear hearing loss and 7 with normal hearing sensitivity. The results showed no differences in performance between the 2 groups. However, both groups showed poorer duration discrimination for the conditions where the carrier/center frequency changed randomly than for the conditions where the carrier/center frequency remained constant. In addition, performance was poorer for the narrowband noise stimuli than for the tonal stimuli. This pattern of results suggests that across-frequency temporal judgments are more difficult than isofrequency temporal judgments, but that cochlear hearing loss does not exacerbate this difficulty per se.     

Relative Effective Frequency Response of Bone versus Air Conduction Stimulation Examined via Masking

An adaptation of the sensorineural acuity level procedure was employed to obtain thresholds under bone- (BC) vs. air-conducted (AC) white noise masking. For the BC masking condition, a Radioear B71 was placed on one mastoid. An Etymotic ER3 with a foam tip placed in the ear on the same side was used to deliver the pure-tone probe stimulus. This transducer was chosen to approximate the Telephonies TDH-39 earphone response characteristic while reducing occlusion effect. For the AC masking condition, the masker and probe were mixed electrically and delivered to the earphone. Masked threshold data, transformed into frequency response curves, demonstrated greater variance of BC vs. AC response across frequency but less high-frequency roll-off than expected from coupler measurements obtained using an artificial mastoid and 6-cm³ cavity, respectively.     

Effects of low-pass noise masking on auditory event-related potentials to speech

OBJECTIVE: This study investigated the effects of decreased audibility in low-frequency spectral regions, produced by low-pass noise masking, on cortical event-related potentials (ERPs) to the speech sounds /ba/ and /da/. DESIGN: The speech sounds were presented to normal-hearing adults (N = 10) at 65- and 80-dB peak-to-peak equivalent SPL while they were engaged in an active condition (pressing a button to deviant sounds) and a passive condition (ignoring the stimuli and reading a book). Broadband masking noise was simultaneously presented at an intensity sufficient to mask the response to the 65-dB speech sounds and subsequently low-pass filtered. The conditions were quiet (no masking), low-pass noise cutoff frequencies of 250, 500, 1000, 2000, and 4000 Hz, and broadband noise. RESULTS: As the cutoff frequency of the low-pass noise masker was raised, ERP latencies increased and amplitudes decreased. The low-pass noise affected N1 differently than the other ERP or behavioral measures, particularly for responses to 80-dB speech stimuli. N1 showed a smaller decrease in amplitude and a smaller increase in latency compared with the other measures. Further, the cutoff frequency where changes first occurred was different for N1. For 80-dB stimuli, N1 amplitudes showed significant changes when the low-pass noise masker cutoff was raised to 4000 Hz. In contrast, d', MMN, N2, and P3 amplitudes did not change significantly until the low-pass noise masker was raised to 2000 Hz. N1 latencies showed significant changes when the low-pass noise masker was raised to 1000 Hz, whereas RT, MMN, N2, and P3 latencies did not change significantly until the low-pass noise masker was raised to 2000 Hz. No significant differences in response amplitudes were seen across the hemispheres (electrode sites C3M versus C4M) in quiet, or in masking noise. CONCLUSIONS: These results indicate that decreased audibility, resulting from the masking, affects N1 in a differential manner compared with MMN, N2, P3, and behavioral measures. N1 indexes the presence of audible stimulus energy, being present when speech sounds are audible, whether or not they are discriminable. MMN indexes stimulus discrimination at a pre-attentive level. It was present only when behavioral measures indicated the ability to differentiate the speech sounds. N2 and P3 also were present only when the speech sounds were behaviorally discriminated. N2 and P3 index stimulus discrimination at a conscious level. These cortical ERP in low-pass noise studies provide insight into the changes in brain processes and behavioral performance that occur when audibility is reduced, such as with low frequency hearing loss.     

Responses of primary auditory fibers to combined noise and tonal stimuli

Responses to tonal stimuli, with and without added noise of different bandwidths, were obtained from anesthetized cat auditory-nerve fibers using glass micropipettes. When low-pass noise with a cut-off frequency at least one octave below best (or characteristic) frequency was used, every fiber tested at high enough intensities showed a suppression of the tonal response. This suppression did not cause a general reduction of neural responsiveness to all sounds, but rather took the general form of a frequency-specific reduction in the effective intensity of the tonal stimuli. The suppression mechanism(s) involved thus adjust the sensitivity of these fibers to cover higher intensity ranges in the presence of noise. The frequency of the most severely affected tones was always at or near best frequency, in confirmation of previous work (Abbas, P.J. and Sachs, M.B. (1976): J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 59, 112–122; Kiang, N.Y.-S. and Moxon, E.C. (1974): J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 55, 620–630). The suppression is a direct but highly nonlinear function of the intensity and bandwitth of the noise. The effects on tonal response of wide-band noise were more variable, sometimes causing suppression similar to that induced by the low-pass noise and sometimes causing only ‘strong-signal capture’ effects. A model of noise-induced suppression has been developed whereby each sound produces both an excitatory effect, sharply tuned at best frequency, and a suppressive effect, which also had its lowest threshold at best frequency but is more broadly tuned.     

3种不同条件短纯音诱发听性脑干反应频率特异性观察

目的 :观察比较线性窗短纯音、加宽频带噪声掩蔽的线性窗短纯音及Blackman窗门控短纯音对听性脑干反应 (ABR)频率特异性的影响。方法 :16例听力正常成年人分别接受 3种不同条件短纯音诱发的ABR测试 ,记录各自在 1、2、4kHz不同声强下的ABR波V潜伏期。结果与结论 :① 4、2kHz各刺激声强及 1kHz 70dBnHL以下声强时 ,3种不同条件短纯音有着相同的频率特异性 ;在低频 (1kHz)高声强 (≥ 70dBnHL)时 ,线性窗短纯音因有频谱播散现象而需加用掩蔽噪声来改善频率特异性或需直接采用Blackman窗门控短纯音。②宽频带噪声掩蔽短纯音及Blackman窗门控短纯音在 1、2、4kHz各刺激强度下可获得相同的频率特异性反应 ,但宽频带噪声掩蔽短纯音诱发的反应振幅相对较小 ,因此Blackman窗短纯音更为可取     

Acoustic hemifields in the spatial release from masking of speech by noise

The Hearing-in-Noise Test (HINT) is able to measure the benefit to speech intelligibility in noise conferred when the noise masker is displaced 90 degrees in eccentricity from a speech source located at zero degrees azimuth. Both psychoacoustic and neurophysiological data suggest that the perceptual benefit of the 90-degree azimuth separation would be greatest if the speech and noise were presented in different acoustic hemifields, and would be smallest if the two sources were in the same acoustic hemifield. The present study tested this hypothesis directly in ten normal-hearing adult listeners. Using the HINT stimuli, we confirmed the hypothesis. Release from masking scores averaged 8.61 dB for "between-hemifield" conditions, 6.05 dB for HINT conditions, and 1.27 dB for "within-hemifield" conditions, even though all stimulus configurations retained a 90-degree angular separation of speech and noise. These data indicate that absolute separation of speech and noise alone is insufficient to guarantee a significant release from masking, and they suggest that what matters is the location of the stimulus elements relative to the left and right spatial perceptual channels.