Long-term liver disease in methylmalonic and propionic acidemias

Background and objectives

Patients affected with methylmalonic acidemia (MMA) and propionic acidemia (PA) exhibit diverse long-term complications and poor outcome. Liver disease is not a reported complication. The aim of this study was to characterize and extensively evaluate long-term liver involvement in MMA and PA patients.

甲基丙二酸血症患儿MUT基因突变分析

目的 检测甲基丙二酸血症(methylmalonic acidemia,MMA)患儿MUT基因突变类型及突变频率,探讨基因型与临床表型之间的关系.方法 依据串联质谱检测血酰基肉碱、气相色谱-质谱检测尿甲基丙二酸以及维生素B_(12)负荷试验等,诊断21例单纯MMA患儿;采用聚合酶链反应和直接测序法对这些患儿进行MUT基因突变检测分析.结果 在21例单纯MMA患儿中14例检测到17种MUT基因突变,其中8种为未报道突变.以c.323G>A(R108H)、c.729_730insTT(D244LfsX39)与c.1630_1631GG>TA(G544X)较为常见,突变频率分别为14.3%、10.7%及14.3%,以错义突变多见(64.7%).14例MUT突变患儿中10例为早发型,1例为迟发型,3例由新生儿出生筛查检出;11例为维生素B_(12)无效型,3例为有效型.结论 揭示了中国MMA患儿中MUT基因的部分突变谱,MUT基因突变患儿发病较早,多为维生素B_(12)无效型.     

Hereditary and acquired diseases of acyl-coenzyme A metabolism

Coenzyme A (CoA) sequestration, toxicity or redistribution (CASTOR) is predicted to occur in many hereditary and acquired conditions in which the degradation of organic acyl esters of CoA is impaired. The resulting accumulation of CoA esters and reduction of acetyl-CoA and free CoA (CoASH) will then trigger a cascade of reactions leading to clinical disease. Most conditions detected by expanded neonatal screening are CASTOR diseases. We review acyl-CoA metabolism, including CoASH synthesis, transesterification of acyl-CoAs to glycine, glutamate or l-carnitine and hydrolysis of CoA esters. Because acyl-CoAs do not cross biological membranes, their main toxicity is intracellular, primarily within mitochondria. Treatment measures directed towards removal of circulating metabolites do not address this central problem of intracellular acyl-CoA accumulation. Treatments usually involve the restriction of dietary precursors and administration of agents like l-carnitine and glycine, which can accept the transfer of acyl groups from acyl-CoA, liberating CoASH. Many hereditary CASTOR patients are chronically ill, with persistent symptoms and continuously abnormal metabolites in blood and urine despite good compliance with treatment. Conversely, asymptomatic patients are also common in hereditary CASTOR conditions. Future challenges include the understanding of pathophysiologic mechanisms in CASTOR diseases, the discovery of reliable predictors of outcome in individual patients and the establishment of therapeutic trials with sufficient numbers of patients to permit solid therapeutic conclusions.     

Propionyl-CoA and adenosylcobalamin metabolism in Caenorhabditis elegans: evidence for a role of methylmalonyl-CoA epimerase in intermediary metabolism

We have utilized Caenorhabditis elegans to study human methylmalonic acidemia. Using bioinformatics, a full complement of mammalian homologues for the conversion of propionyl-CoA to succinyl-CoA in the genome of C. elegans, including propionyl-CoA carboxylase subunits A and B (pcca-1, pccb-1), methylmalonic acidemia cobalamin A complementation group (mmaa-1), co(I)balamin adenosyltransferase (mmab-1), MMACHC (cblc-1), methylmalonyl-CoA epimerase (mce-1) and methylmalonyl-CoA mutase (mmcm-1) were identified. To verify predictions that the entire intracellular adenosylcobalamin metabolic pathway existed and was functional, the kinetic properties of the C. elegans mmcm-1 were examined. RNA interference against mmcm-1, mmab-1, mmaa-1 in the presence of propionic acid revealed a chemical phenotype of increased methylmalonic acid; deletion mutants of mmcm-1, mmab-1 and mce-1 displayed reduced 1-[(14)C]-propionate incorporation into macromolecules. The mutants produced increased amounts of methylmalonic acid in the culture medium, proving that a functional block in the pathway caused metabolite accumulation. Lentiviral delivery of the C. elegans mmcm-1 into fibroblasts derived from a patient with mut(o) class methylmalonic acidemia could partially restore propionate flux. The C. elegans mce-1 deletion mutant demonstrates for the first time that a lesion at the epimerase step of methylmalonyl-CoA metabolism can functionally impair flux through the methylmalonyl-CoA mutase pathway and suggests that malfunction of MCEE may cause methylmalonic acidemia in humans. The C. elegans system we describe represents the first lower metazoan model organism of mammalian propionate spectrum disorders and demonstrates that mass spectrometry can be employed to study a small molecule chemical phenotype in C. elegans RNAi and deletion mutants.     

Novel mutations in a Thai patient with methylmalonic acidemia

A Thai patient with methylmalonic acidemia (MMA) and no methylmalonyl-CoA mutase (MCM, EC 5.4.99.2) activity in leukocytes in the presence of deoxyadenosyl cobalamin (mut(0)) was found to be heterozygous for two novel mutations: 1048delT and 1706_1707delGGinsTA (G544X), inherited from her mother and father, respectively. The proband was also heterozygous for the polymorphism, A499T, which did not affect the activity of recombinant MCM.     

A homozygous nonsense mutation in the methylmalonyl-CoA epimerase gene (MCEE) results in mild methylmalonic aciduria

Methylmalonic aciduria (MMA-uria) is an autosomal recessive inborn error of amino acid metabolism, involving valine, threonine, isoleucine, and methionine. This organic aciduria may present in the neonatal period with life-threatening metabolic acidosis, hyperammonemia, feeding difficulties, pancytopenia, and coma. Most affected patients have mutations in the methylmalonyl-coenzyme A (methylmalonyl-CoA) mutase gene. Mildly affected patients may present in childhood with failure to thrive and recurrent attacks of metabolic acidosis. Both a higher residual activity of methylmalonyl-CoA mutase as well as the vitamin B12-responsive defects (cblA and cblB) may form the basis of the mild disorder. A few patients with moderate MMA-uria are known in whom no defect could be identified. Here we present a 16-year-old female patient with persisting moderate MMA-uria (approximately 50 mmol/mol creatinine). She was born to consanguineous Caucasian parents. Her fibroblast mutase activity was normal and no effect of vitamin B12 supplementation could be established. Reduced incorporation of 14C-propionate into macromolecules suggested a defect in the propionate-to-succinate pathway. We found a homozygous nonsense mutation (c.139C>T) in the methylmalonyl-CoA epimerase gene (MCEE), resulting in an early terminating signal (p.R47X). Both parents were heterozygous for this mutation; they were found to excrete normal amounts of methylmalonic acid (MMA). This is the first report of methylmalonyl-CoA epimerase deficiency, thereby unequivocally demonstrating the biochemical role of this enzyme in human metabolism.     

Genetic analysis of three genes causing isolated methylmalonic acidemia: identification of 21 novel allelic variants

Isolated methylmalonic aciduria (MMA) is an inborn error of metabolism due to the impaired isomerization of l-methylmalonyl-CoA to succinyl-CoA. This reaction is catalyzed by the mitochondrial protein methylmalonyl-CoA mutase (MCM, EC 5.4.99.2), an adenosylcobalamin-dependent enzyme. Four different forms of isolated MMA have been described: mut MMA associated with defects in the MCM apoenzyme, and phenotypically divided into two subtypes mut- and mut0 MMA, and three different defects involved in the synthesis of the active form of the cofactor adenosylcobalamin, termed cbl MMA, and classified into three different complementation groups cblA, cblB, and cblH associated with defects in the MMAA and MMAB genes and with an unidentified protein, respectively. In this work we describe the genetic analysis of 25 MMA patients, mainly from Spain. Using biochemical and cellular approaches our patients have been classified, identifying 13 mut MMA, 7 cblA, 2 cblB, and 3 noncblA, noncblB deficient patients. cDNA and genomic DNA sequence analysis of the MUT, MMAA, and MMAB genes have allowed us to identify 27 different changes, 21 novel ones. Among the missense mutations identified in the MUT gene only one, the c.970G>A (p.A324T) variant located in the substrate binding domain is likely a mut- mutation. The remaining missense mutations c.326A>G (p.Q109R), c.983T>C (p.L328P), c.1846C>T (p.R616C), and c.1850T>G (p.L617R) are probably mut0. In the MMAA patients analyzed, frameshift mutations are prevalent. We have explored the genotype-phenotype correlation for this clinically heterogeneous disease.     

Genome and RNA sequencing in patients with methylmalonic aciduria of unknown cause

PurposeOur laboratory has classified patients with methylmalonic aciduria using somatic cell studies for over four decades. We have accumulated 127 fibroblast lines from patients with persistent elevated methylmalonic acid (MMA) levels in which no genetic cause could be identified. Cultured fibroblasts from 26 of these patients had low [¹⁴C]propionate incorporation into macromolecules, possibly reflecting decreased methylmalonyl-CoA mutase function.MethodsGenome sequencing (GS), copy-number variation (CNV) analysis, and RNA sequencing were performed on genomic DNA and complementary DNA (cDNA) from these 26 patients.ResultsNo patient had two pathogenic variants in any gene associated with cobalamin metabolism. Nine patients had heterozygous variants of unknown significance previously identified by a next-generation sequencing (NGS) panel targeting cobalamin metabolic genes. Three patients had pathogenic changes in genes not associated with cobalamin metabolism (PCCA, EPCAM, and a 17q12 duplication) that explain parts of their phenotypes other than elevated MMA.ConclusionGenome and RNA sequencing did not detect any additional putative causal genetic defects in known cobalamin genes following somatic cell studies and the use of a targeted NGS panel. They did detect pathogenic variants in other genes in three patients that explained some aspects of their clinical presentation.     

Methylmalonic and propionic aciduria

Methylmalonic and propionic aciduria (PA) are the most frequent forms of branched-chain organic acidurias. These autosomal recessive disorders result from deficient activity of methylmalonyl-CoA mutase and propionyl-CoA carboxylase, respectively. Clinically, acute or chronic neurologic signs are caused by the accumulation of toxic compounds proximal to the metabolic block. Phenotype varies from severe neonatal-onset forms with high mortality and poor outcome to milder forms with a later onset. In both cases the clinical course is dominated by the risk of relapses of life-threatening episodes of metabolic decompensation and of severe organ failure. Despite improvement of treatment, the overall outcome remains disappointing with no major differences between the two diseases. The diagnosis is based on the presence of characteristic compounds in body fluids as detected by organic acid analysis in urine and acylcarnitine profile in blood. Therapy is based on low-protein high-energy diet, carnitine supplementation, and metronidazole. Some patients with methylmalonic aciduria (MMA) respond to pharmacological doses of vitamin B12. Given the poor long-term prognosis, liver transplantation has been recently attempted as an alternative therapy to conventional medical treatment to cure the underlying metabolic defect. Nevertheless, the overall experience to date does not clearly demonstrate its effectiveness in preventing further deterioration or improving survival and quality of life. The recent implementation of neonatal screening by electrospray tandem mass spectrometry has decreased early mortality and improved the short-term outcome, without changing the detection rate of both diseases in the screening population compared to clinically detected cases. However, the limited number of patients and the short duration of their follow-up do not yet permit drawing final conclusions on its effect on the long-term outcome of methylmalonic and propionic acidemia.     

Molecular and structural analysis of two novel mutations in a patient with mut(-) methylmalonyl-CoA deficiency

Inherited defects in the gene encoding the methylmalonyl-CoA mutase (MCM) result in the mut forms of methylmalonic aciduria (MMA). Twelve mutations have been identified associated with the mut(-) phenotype. We report two novel mutations (K621N and D156N) in a compound heterozygote mut(-) patient. These two mutations and three previously published ones (H627N, A191E, Y231N) were mapped onto a three-dimensional homology model of the human MCM constructed from the crystal structure of the Propionibacterium shermanii enzyme.     

Molecular studies in mutase-deficient (MUT) methylmalonic aciduria: identification of five novel mutations

Mutase-deficient (MUT) methylmalonic aciduria (MMA) is an autosomal recessive inborn error of organic acid metabolism, resulting from a functional defect in the nuclear encoded mitochondrial enzyme methylmalonyl-CoA mutase (MCM) (EC.5.4.99.2). The enzyme requires 5'-deoxyadenosylcobalamin as a cofactor. Isolated MMA results from either apoenzyme or cofactor defects, and is classified into several genotypic classes and complementation groups. These are designated mut(-) or mut(0) (together termed mut), depending on minimal or no apoenzyme activity respectively and cobalamin A or B (cbl A/B) for cofactor defects. To date various studies have identified over 53 disease-causing mutations from patients with mut(0/-) MMA. These are predominantly missense/nonsense nucleotide substitutions. In this study, we report the genotype analysis on 7 patients diagnosed with mut MMA. Five novel mutations were identified (R403stop, 497delG, P615T, 208delG and R467stop) and one novel polymorphism (c712A->G). The previously reported R228Q mutation was found in one patient, who is a compound heterozygote for this mutation and the R467stop mutation. A recently reported N219Y mutation was found in one patient. The 497delG mutation was detected as a homozygous deletion. The remaining mutations were observed in compound heterozygotes, with the second mutation yet to be identified. Many of the unidentified mutations may occur within the promotor or intronic regions.     

Liver transplantation is not curative for methylmalonic acidopathy caused by methylmalonyl-CoA mutase deficiency

Methylmalonic acidopathy resulting from severe methylmalonyl-CoA mutase deficiency causes acute, potentially lethal ketoacidotic episodes, renal failure, and acute and chronic neurologic disease. As dietary and alkali therapy is suboptimal, liver transplantation during infancy has been touted as a potential cure. However, reports in liver transplant recipients about new onset neurologic disease, in the absence of ketoacidosis, and progressive renal insufficiency have cast doubt about its effectiveness. We report the long-term (9 years) outcome for the first patient with severe methylmalonic acidopathy transplanted in the USA and provide new biochemical data that indicate why transplanted patients are still susceptible to "metabolic strokes". In our 10-year-old male patient, there is clear evidence that the de novo synthesis of propionyl-CoA within the CNS leads to brain methylmalonate (MMA) accumulation that is largely unaffected by transplantation. Liver replacement is not a cure for methylmalonic acidopathy.     

Molecular analysis of methylmalonyl-CoA mutase deficiency: identification of three missense mutations in mut 0 patients

Genetic defects in the methylmalonyl-CoA mutase (MCM) gene cause methylmalonic acidemia (MMA). Only three mutations have been reported among Oriental patients to date. We studied fibroblast cell lines established from three Japanese patients with MCM deficiency. Enzymatic study showed that these patients had the mut ⁰ type of MMA. Nucleotide sequencing of MCM cDNAs identified three missense mutations: a T to A change at nucleotide position 2082, which results in an amino acid substitution of Glu669 for valine (V669E); a T to A change at position 1179 with the corresponding amino acid substitution of Asp368 for valine (V368D); and a G to A change at position 1182 with the corresponding amino acid substitution of His369 for arginine (R369H). Each of the three missense mutations abolished MCM activity according to a transient expression study. Alignment of these mutations with a recently reported homology model of human MCM allowed us to speculate on the effect of these nonconservative amino acid substitutions on MCM activity: V368D and R369H affected residues in the β/α-(TIM-) barrel domain, on one of the two α-helices that form the dimer interface, while V669E altered a residue in the adenosylcobalamin-binding domain in the C terminus. Received: July 28, 1998 / Accepted: September 4, 1998     

Diagnosis and treatment of methylmalonic aciduria: a case report

The methylmalonic aciduria is an organic acidemia, inherited as autosomic recessive trait, caused by a deficiency of the methylmalonyl-CoA mutase, or by defects in the biosynthesis of the cofactor adenosylcobalamin. Regarding the enzymatic defect, there are two forms: mut(o) with no detectable enzymatic activity and mut(-) with reduced activity. Its clinical presentation may vary from a severe neonatal form with acidosis and death, up to a progressive chronic form. Here we describe the case of a four year-old boy, with diagnosis of methylmalonyl-CoA mutase deficiency type mut(-) with an acute presentation. Molecular analysis of MUT gene identified two mutations c.607G>A (G203R) and c.2080C>T (R694W), later confirmed in the parents. The aim of this report is to highlight the importance of including the organic acid analysis in urine among the first line exams in acutely and severely ill children with undefined etiology. The definitive diagnosis is important because it may allow a specific treatment and a favorable evolution to prevent the secuelae.     

Homozygous nonsense mutation in the MCEE gene and siRNA suppression of methylmalonyl-CoA epimerase expression: a novel cause of mild methylmalonic aciduria

Methylmalonyl-CoA epimerase (MCE) catalyzes the interconversion of D- and L-methylmalonyl-CoA in the pathway responsible for the degradation of branched chain amino acids, odd chain-length fatty acids, and other metabolites. Despite the occurrence of metabolic disorders in the enzymatic step occurring immediately upstream of MCE (propionyl-CoA carboxylase) and downstream of MCE (adenosylcobalamin-dependent methylmalonyl-CoA mutase), no disease-causing mutations have been described affecting MCE itself. A patient, formerly identified as belonging to the cblA complementation group of vitamin B12 disorders but lacking mutations in the affected gene, MMAA, was tested for mutations in the MCEE gene. The patient's fibroblasts had normal levels of adenosylcobalamin compared to controls, whereas other cblA cell lines typically had reduced levels of the cofactor. As well, this patient had a milder form of methylmalonic aciduria than usually observed in cblA patients. The patient was found to be homozygous for a c.139C>T (p.R47X) mutation in MCEE by sequence analysis that was confirmed by restriction digestion of PCR products. One sibling, also with mild methylmalonic aciduria, was homozygous for the mutation. Both parents and one other sibling were heterozygous. A nearby insertion polymorphism, c.41-160_161insT, heterozygous in both parents, showed the wild-type configuration on the mutant alleles. To assess the impact of isolated MCE deficiency in cultured cells, HeLa cells were transfected with a selectable vector containing MCEE-specific small interfering RNA (siRNA) to suppress gene expression. The reduced level of MCEE mRNA resulted in the reduction of [14C]-propionate incorporation into cellular macromolecules. However, siRNA only led to a small reduction in pathway activity, suggesting that previously postulated non-enzymatic conversion of D- to L-methylmalonyl-CoA may contribute to some flux through the pathway. We conclude that the patient's MCEE defect was responsible for the mild methylmalonic aciduria, confirming a partial requirement for the enzymatic activity in humans.     

Clinical and molecular findings in Thai patients with isolated methylmalonic acidemia

Isolated methylmalonic acidemia (MMA) is a genetically heterogeneous organic acid disorder caused by either deficiency of the enzyme methylmalonyl-CoA mutase (MCM), or a defect in the biosynthesis of its cofactor, adenosyl-cobalamin (AdoCbl). Herein, we report and review the genotypes and phenotypes of 14 Thai patients with isolated MMA. Between 1997 and 2011, we identified 6 mut patients, 2 cblA patients, and 6 cblB patients. The mut and cblB patients had relatively severe phenotypes compared to relatively mild phenotypes of the cblA patients. The MUT and MMAB genotypes were also correlated to the severity of the phenotypes. Three mutations in the MUT gene: c.788G>T (p.G263V), c.809_812dupGGGC (p.D272Gfs*2), and c.1426C>T (p.Q476*); one mutation in the MMAA gene: c.292A>G (p.R98G); and three mutations in the MMAB gene: c.682delG (p.A228Pfs*2), c.435delC (p.F145Lfs*69), and c.585-1G>A, have not been previously reported. RT-PCR analysis of a common intron 6 polymorphism (c.520-159C>T) of the MMAB gene revealed that it correlates to deep intronic exonization leading to premature termination of the open reading frame. This could decrease the ATP:cobalamin adenosyltransferase (ATR) activity resulting in abnormal phenotypes if found in a compound heterozygous state with a null mutation. We confirm the genotype-phenotype correlation of isolated MMA in the study population, and identified a new molecular basis of the cblB disorder.     

N219Y, a new frequent mutation among mut(degree) forms of methylmalonic acidemia in Caucasian patients

Mutations in the MUT locus encoding for the methylmalonyl-CoA mutase (MCM) apoenzyme are responsible for the mut forms of methylmalonic acidemia (MMA). To date, 49 different mutations have been identified in mut MMA. Only two frequent mutations have been reported in the Japanese population and in African-Americans. Here we report a new missense mutation N219Y (731 A-->T) which we found in five unrelated families of French and Turkish descent. All the patients exhibited a severe mut(degree) phenotype and three of them were homozygotes for N219Y. Direct involvement of the mutation in the loss of enzyme activity was demonstrated by mutagenesis and transient expression study. Mapping of the mutation onto a three-dimensional model of human MCM constructed by homology with the Propionibacterium shermanii enzyme shows that it lies in a highly conserved secondary structure motif and might suggest impaired folding and/or poor stability compatible with the mut(degree) phenotype. Finally, a 1% N219Y carrier frequency was observed in a French anonymous control population. Thus, N219Y is the first frequent mut mutation to be reported in the Caucasian population.     

mut0 methylmalonic acidemia: eleven novel mutations of the methylmalonyl CoA mutase including a deletion-insertion mutation

Methylmalonic aciduria (MMA) is an autosomal-recessive disorder caused by inadequate function of methylmalonyl-CoA mutase (MCM), a nuclear-encoded, mitochondrial enzyme that uses adenosylcobalamin as a cofactor. Biochemical cell studies have delineated phenotypic variants: mut(0) phenotypes in which there is no detectable enzymatic activity and mut- phenotypes in which there is residual cobalamin-dependent activity. Mutation screening in MMA has led to the detection of 30 disease-specific mutations. In 14 patients with the mut(0) phenotype we found 11 novel mutations (K54X, A137V, F174S, 620insA, G203R, Q218H, A535P, H627R, 2085delG and 2270del4/ins5), 6 of them homozygous, consisting of 1 nonsense, 6 missense, 1 splice site, and 3 frame shift mutations. The position in relation to different functional domains in MCM allow for an interpretation of the identified mutations. Hum Mutat 16:179, 2000.     

甲基丙二酸血症cblA型12例分析

目的探讨甲基丙二酸血症(methylmalonic acidemia,MM A)cblA型患儿的临床特点、基因变异类型及治疗效果。方法分析12例cblA型MMA患儿的临床表现,治疗方案及预后,对先证者及其父母进行MMAA基因的变异分析。结果MMA cblA型患儿主要表现为呕吐、气促和嗜睡。维生素B12治疗对11例(91.7%)患儿有效。治疗后患儿血丙酰肉碱、丙酰肉碱与乙酰肉碱比值、尿甲基丙二酸及甲基枸椽酸水平均显著降低,差异有统计学意义(均P<0.05)。8例患儿生长发育正常(66.7%),4例智力运动发育落后(33.3%)。检测到14种MMAA基因变异,包括6种新变异:c.54delA(p.A19Hfs*43)、c.275G>A(p.G92V)、c.456delT(p.G153Vfs*8)、c.667dupA(p.T223Nfs*4)、c.1114C>T(p.Q372X)和c.1137_1138delCA(p.F379Lfs*27)e最常见的变异为c・365T>C(p.L122P)(29.2%)。结论cblA型MMA患儿主要表现为呕吐、气促和嗜睡,大部分患儿为维生素B12治疗有效型。c.365T>C为中国MMAA基因的常见变异。