Cross-reactivity to porcine factor VIII of factor VIII inhibitors in patients with haemophilia in Australia and New Zealand

Abstract Background: Inhibitory antibodies which neutralise factor VIII develop in 10–20% of individuals with inherited haemophilia A and rarely as autoantibodies in normal individuals to cause acquired haemophilia. The antibodies are directed against human factor VIII but cross-react to varying degrees with porcine factor VIII. Porcine factor VIII can be used for treatment in individuals with low cross-reactivity.
Aims: To determine the cross-reactivity of factor VIII inhibitors between human factor VIII and porcine factor VIII, in a population of patients with inherited and acquired haemophilia A. Also, to determine whether patients with inherited haemophilia and inhibitors have a higher incidence of factor VIII gene inversion in intron 22.
Methods: Samples and data sheets from 43 patients with inherited and ten with acquired haemophilia were submitted from hospitals in Australia and New Zealand. Inhibitor levels to human and porcine factor VIII were measured by the Bethesda method in 39 with inherited and nine with acquired haemophilia A.
Results: Of 39 patients with inherited haemophilia A, cross-reactivity was 0% in 17 patients,1–19% in six, 20–39% in 11 and 40–80% in five. In six of nine patients with acquired haemophilia cross-reactivity was 7%. In inherited severe haemophilia A, the frequency of the intron 22 inversion was not greater in 37 study patients than in 28 patients without an inhibitor.
Conclusions: Many patients in Australia and New Zealand with inhibitors to human factor VIII presently show a low or absent level of cross-reactivity to porcine factor VIII. These may respond to treatment with this concentrate at least in the short term. There remains a group of patients with high cross-reactivity who will respond only to recombinant factor Vila or prothrombin complex concentrates.     

Inversions of the factor VIII gene in Swedish patients with severe haemophilia A

Abstract: The series comprised 49 Swedish patients with severe haemophilia A [belonging to 49 families (21 with known and 28 with sporadic haemophilia)], of whom 12 had developed F. VIII inhibitors. Using Southern blotting, 45% (22/49) were found to have inversions, i.e., intrachromosomal rearrangements of the tip of the X-chromosome. Twenty patients had one or the other of the two variants of inversions recently published, whereas 2 patients manifested novel band patterns. Inversions were found in 50% of the families with sporadic haemophilia, and in 38% of those with known haemophilia. Fourteen families with sporadic haemophilia A had inversions, the proband carrying the de novo mutation in 4 cases and the proband's mother in 10 cases. Six inversions derived from a male and five from a female X-chromosome meiosis, the origin of the remaining three was not established. Genetic counselling of patients with severe haemophilia A and their families will be considerably improved, as inversions occur in half the severe cases and can be detected by a simple Southern blotting procedure.     

Laboratory testing for factor VIII and IX inhibitors in haemophilia: A review

Inhibitors are antibodies directed against haemophilia treatment products which interfere with their function. Factor VIII (FVIII) inhibitors in haemophilia A and factor IX (FIX) inhibitors in haemophilia B are significant clinically when they require a change in a patient's treatment regimen. Their persistence may increase morbidity and mortality. Multiple laboratory tests are now available for detecting and understanding inhibitors in haemophilia. Inhibitors are traditionally measured by their interference in clotting or chromogenic factor assays. They may also be detected using immunologic assays, such as enzyme‐linked immunosorbent assay or fluorescence immunoassay. Anti‐FVIII or anti‐FIX antibodies of IgG₄ subclass best correlate with the presence of functional inhibitors. Improvements in inhibitor measurement have been recently introduced. Preanalytical heat treatment of patient specimens allows testing of patients without delaying treatment. Use of chromogenic and immunologic assays may aid in identification of false‐positive results, which are frequent among low‐titre inhibitors. Validated reagent substitutions can be used to reduce assay cost. New methods for defining assay positivity and reporting low‐titre inhibitors have been suggested. Challenges remain in the areas of quality control, assay standardization, monitoring of patients undergoing immune tolerance induction therapy and testing in the presence of modified and novel treatment products.     

The prevalence of factor VIII inhibitors and genetic aspects of inhibitor development in Chinese patients with haemophilia A

Summary. The prevalence of inhibitors in Chinese haemophiliacs has not yet been reported. The aim of this study was to identify the prevalence of factor VIII (FVIII) inhibitors among haemophiliacs who are treated only with plasma‐derived FVIII (pdFVIII), cryoprecipitate or fresh frozen plasma (FFP), and tried to explore the relationship between the generation of inhibitors and particular FVIII deficiency genotypes. Clinical information and blood samples of 1435 patients with haemophilia A (HA) were collected by six haemophilia centres in China. The Nijmegen modification of the Bethesda assay was used to detect inhibitors. Multiplex PCR, long‐range PCR and direct sequencing were performed for genotyping. The overall prevalence of inhibitors in Chinese HA patients was 3.9% and the prevalence of severe haemophiliacs was 4.3%; 18 of the 56 patients with inhibitors had high titres. A total of 38 different mutations were identified in the 55 patients with inhibitors, including 15 intron 22 and 3 intron 1 inversions, seven large deletions, 14 small deletion/insertions, seven nonsense mutations, one splice site mutations and eight missense mutations. Of 38 mutations, 28 were novel. Patients with large deletions and nonsense mutations were prone to have high titre inhibitors, with incidence rates of 57.1% (4/7) and 42.9% (3/7), respectively. In conclusion, the prevalence of inhibitors in Chinese HA patients is much lower than that reported for other ethnic groups and the large deletion and nonsense mutations are high risk factors for high titre inhibitor development.     

Mechanisms of action of immune tolerance induction against factor VIII in patients with congenital haemophilia A and factor VIII inhibitors

In its most severe form, haemophilia A is a life-threatening haemorrhagic bleeding disorder that is caused by mutations in the factor VIII (FVIII) gene. About 25% of patients who receive replacement therapy with intravenous FVIII products develop neutralising antibodies (FVIII inhibitors) that inhibit the function of substituted FVIII. Long-term application of high or low doses of FVIII has evolved as an effective strategy for eradicating antibodies and inducing long-lasting immune tolerance. Despite clinical experience with the therapy, little is known about the immunological mechanisms that cause the down modulation of FVIII-specific immune responses or the induction of long-lasting immune tolerance against FVIII. This review summarises current knowledge of the immunological mechanisms that might be involved in the induction of immune tolerance against FVIII in patients with haemophilia A who have FVIII inhibitors. In addition to data from patients with haemophilia A, data from patients who have had organ transplants or have immune-related disorders, such as autoimmune diseases, are considered as well as data from animal models.     

Domain specificity of factor VIII inhibitors during immune tolerance induction in patients with haemophilia A

Summary. Introduction‐Frequent administration of high dosages factor VIII (FVIII), so‐called immune tolerance induction (ITI), provides an efficient strategy to eradicate inhibitory antibodies in patients with haemophilia A. At present, our knowledge on the characteristics of inhibitory antibodies in patients undergoing ITI is limited. Aim‐In this study we characterized the domain specificity of FVIII inhibitors in 11 haemophilia A patients during ITI. Results‐In three of six patients who were successfully tolerized, inhibitory antibodies were directed predominantly against the FVIII light chain. In two other patients within this group, a significant contribution of A2 antibodies was observed which did not change during treatment. In the sixth patient the relative contribution of A2 inhibitors declined which coincided with an increase in antilight chain antibodies. In four of five patients who failed ITI, A2 inhibitors were observed. In two patients the contribution of A2 inhibitors increased during treatment, while in two other patients the contribution of A2 inhibitor remained constant. The fifth patient had inhibitory antibodies predominantly directed against the FVIII light chain. Conclusion‐Overall, our findings revealed changes in domain specificity of FVIII antibodies in five of 11 patients analysed. Remarkably, antibodies exclusively directed towards the light chain of FVIII were predominantly observed in patients who were successfully tolerized.     

Porcine factor VIII provides clinical benefit to patients with high levels of inhibitors to human and porcine factor VIII

The development of an inhibitor against Factor VIII is an important complication of haemophilia and occurs in approximately 31% of patients [1]. Despite various approaches to their management, the presence of these inhibitors remains a major cause of morbidity and mortality. Inhibitors may be low level [<5 Bethesda Units (BU)] or high level [>10 BU]. Low-level inhibitors usually remain low and do not respond to administered factor VIII with a rise of the inhibitor titre; high-level inhibitors, in contrast, are characterized by a rapid rise in titre following treatment with factor VIII. Modalities of treatment of acute bleeding episodes in patients with inhibitors include 'overcoming' the inhibitor with very large doses of factor VIII, 'bypassing' the inhibitor blockade with products such as activated prothrombin complex concentrates or recombinant factor VIIa, 'removing' the inhibitor by plasmapheresis or immunoabsorption and 'repressing' it with immunosuppressive drugs and immune tolerance induction. An alternative approach is to use a porcine factor VIII concentrate which does not cross-react with the human factor VIII inhibitor. Following treatment with porcine factor VIII, functional factor VIII can be detected and the therapeutic levels correlate with cessation of bleeding. The use of porcine factor VIII may, however, result in the development of antiporcine factor VIII antibodies, limiting its use. Experience in patients with high-titre inhibitors indicates that porcine factor VIII therapy could be used in the presence of factor VIII inhibitors [2-11], including inhibitors to porcine factor VIII [5,7], and that haemostasis may be obtained in the absence of detectable levels of circulating factor VIII [7,11].     

Hydrolysis of factor VIII mediated by catalytic antibodies occurs in haemophilia A patients with or without factor VIII inhibitors

The major complication of the substitutive treatment of haemophilia A (HA) is the development of antifactor VIII (FVIII) antibodies. Most of these antibodies neutralize FVIII procoagulant activity, and are identified as FVIII inhibitor. A subgroup of these antibodies, ‘catalytic antibodies’, catalyses the FVIII hydrolysis. We investigated the frequency and the activity of catalytic antibodies, according to the phenotype of HA and the presence or absence of FVIII inhibitor. IgG from 16 patients with inhibitor and 17 patients without inhibitor were purified. Rates of FVIII hydrolysis and inhibitor titres were evaluated. Anti‐FVIII catalytic antibodies were detected in 63.6% of patients with HA, irrespective of the HA phenotype and the presence of FVIII inhibitor. The frequency was significantly higher for severe HA patients (73.3%) and patients with inhibitor (87.5%), but their FVIII‐proteolytic activity was not significantly different from patients with mild or moderate HA and patients without inhibitor. The evolution of both catalytic and inhibitory activities was studied for 11 patients with FVIII inhibitor. We observed two profiles. In the profile 1, 18.2% of patients, the catalytic activity and the inhibitor titre coevolved. In contrast, a dissociated evolution of these two parameters was observed in 72.8% patients in profile 2. These data confirm the importance of anti‐FVIII catalytic activity in patients with severe, moderate and mild HA. Interestingly, most of the patients presented a dissociated profile, suggesting that anti‐FVIII antibodies might not systematically act as FVIII inhibitors.     

Early factor VIII exposure and subsequent inhibitor development in children with severe haemophilia A

Recent reports have suggested that the incidence of inhibitors in haemophilia is the highest in those first exposed to factor VIII under 6 months of age. In this study, we investigated inhibitor development in children first exposed to FVIII as neonates and also examined the effect of other genetic and environmental variables. Three hundred and forty-eight children with severe haemophilia A were investigated. Inhibitors developed in 68 of 348 (20%), with 34 of 348 (10%) high titre inhibitors. The incidence in relation to initial FVIII exposure was: <1 month nine of 35 (26%), 1-6 months 13 of 51 (25%), 6-12 months 27 of 130 (21%), 12-18 months 13 of 66 (20%) and >18 months six of 66 (9%). While we observed a significant difference in inhibitor development and age at first exposure across all age groups (P = 0.018), no significant difference was observed in children treated at different time points during the first year of life (P = 0.44). Similar results were obtained for high titre inhibitors. There was also no difference in the incidence of inhibitors in relation to initial FVIII exposure in a subgroup of 144 children with the intron 22 mutation. Inhibitors developed more frequently in those initially treated with recombinant when compared with plasma-derived FVIII (P = 0.006) and in those with a major molecular defect (P = 0.009). In this study, exposure to FVIII during the neonatal period was not associated with a higher incidence of inhibitors than those treated later during the first year of life. Initial treatment with recombinant FVIII and the presence of a major molecular defect were the most important variables affecting inhibitor development.     

A prospective surveillance study of factor VIII inhibitor development in the Canadian haemophilia A population following the switch to a recombinant factor VIII product formulated with sucrose

Summary.  The introduction of new factor concentrates has, at times, resulted in an increase in inhibitor development; hence large systematic surveys of inhibitor development are necessary whenever new products are introduced. This study presents the results of a surveillance study conducted by the Inhibitor Subcommittee of the Association of Hemophilia Clinic Directors of Canada that evaluated inhibitor development in patients with haemophilia A following the switch to a second generation recombinant FVIII product (rFVIII-FS; Kogenate^® Bayer). Four hundred and sixty haemophilia A paediatric and adults patients from 17 Canadian Comprehensive Hemophilia Care Centers were enrolled in the study. Of these, 274 patients had evaluable data. Blood samples collected at baseline (prior to the switch to rFVIII-FS), and at 12 and 24 months following conversion were tested for inhibitors by the Nijmegen-modified Bethesda assay. Four subjects had positive inhibitor titres at baseline, with values ranging from 3.3 to 160 BU. Of the 274 patients who had baseline samples collected, 225 had postswitch samples collected at 12 months and 189 subjects had samples collected at 24 months. Only patients with positive baseline inhibitor titres ( n  = 4) had positive inhibitor titres at either the 12- or 24-month postswitch time points; therefore no de novo inhibitors developed over the 2-year evaluation period in this patient population. The results of this surveillance study suggest that the altered formulation of this recombinant FVIII concentrate was not associated with an increased incidence of inhibitor formation.     

Immunoprotective effect of von Willebrand factor towards therapeutic factor VIII in experimental haemophilia A

The development of inhibitory anti-factor VIII (FVIII) antibodies in patients with haemophilia A following replacement therapy is associated with several types of risk factors. Among these, the purity of FVIII concentrates, and in particular the presence of von Willebrand factor (VWF), was controversially proposed to influence the immunogenicity of exogenous FVIII. We re-assessed in vivo and in vitro the immuno-protective effect of VWF towards FVIII. The immuno-protective effect of VWF towards FVIII was investigated in vivo, in a model of haemophilia A. We studied the endocytosis of FVIII by murine bone marrow-derived dendritic cells and evaluated the capacity of VWF to block the internalization of FVIII. We characterized the relevance of VWF for the accumulation of FVIII in the marginal zone of the spleen, a secondary lymphoid organ where the immune response to therapeutically administered FVIII initiates. Our results confirm that VWF reduces the immunogenicity of FVIII in FVIII-deficient mice. Paradoxically, VWF is important for the accumulation of FVIII in the marginal zone of the spleen. We propose that VWF exerts at least two non-mutually exclusive immunoprotective roles towards FVIII in haemophilic mice: VWF prevents the endocytosis of FVIII by professional antigen-presenting cells by blocking the interaction of FVIII with as yet unidentified endocytic receptor(s). Hypothetically, VWF, by virtue of increasing the half-life of FVIII in the circulation, may allow an increased contact time with tolerogenic marginal zone B cells in the spleen.     

von Willebrand factor in factor VIII concentrates protects against neutralization by factor VIII antibodies of haemophilia A patients

We investigated the neutralization activity of factor VIII (FVIII) antibodies of 12 haemophilia A patients, acquired during treatment with plasma-derived FVIII concentrates. All plasma samples, drawn in a clinically stable situation before any immunotolerance treatment, contained anti-A2 domain and anti-light-chain FVIII antibodies. In nine patients' plasmas, containing relatively high amounts of FVIII light-chain antibodies (53-96%), a higher neutralization activity was found against recombinant FVIII concentrate (Recombinate) than against plasma-derived von Willebrand factor (vWF)-containing concentrate (Haemoctin SDH). No difference in neutralization of the two concentrates was found in two patients' plasmas with almost equal content of FVIII light- and heavy-chain antibodies, or one plasma with predominantly heavy-chain antibodies. These results suggest that haemophilia A patients with relatively high amounts of FVIII light-chain antibodies in plasma might benefit by infusion of FVIII concentrates containing vWF because vWF appears to have some protective effect on FVIII. This hypothesis should be tested by a clinical study.     

Domiciliary desensitization therapy for young boys with haemophilia and factor VIII inhibitors

Summary Immune tolerance was induced in five consecutive young boys with haemophilia and factor VIII inhibitors using frequent conventional doses of human factor VIII.
All therapy was given at home by parents and the four youngest boys had surgically implanted central venous catheters (Port-a-Cath). Two catheters eventually became infected after 2 and 4 years respectively, otherwise the devices were trouble-free and liked by the families concerned.
Regular domiciliary factor VIII therapy in pre-school children is not difficult with an aid to venous access and immune tolerance can be achieved in those developing factor VIII inhibitors.     

Persistent factor VIII inhibitors and orthopaedic complications in children with severe haemophilia A

Summary. Persistence of inhibitors against factor VIII (FVIII) may be a risk factor that increases physical disability in haemophilia A (HA) patients. This study aimed to evaluate prevalence of FVIII inhibitors in previously treated children with severe HA and the impact of persistent inhibitors on knee joint status and lumbar bone mineral density (BMD). Fifty children with severe HA, FVIII <1%; aged 5–16 years were enrolled in this study; they received plasma‐derived FVIII on‐demand treatment for 50–250 exposure days (EDs). Inhibitors were checked at basal visit and were followed up for 1 year, using Bethesda assay. Cross‐sectional clinical scoring and radiological evaluation of the knee joint (by Arnold‐Hilgartner staging and Pettersson score), along with lumbar BMD by Dual Energy X‐ray Absorptiometry (DEXA) were performed. Patients with persistent inhibitors for 1 to 5 years, median 2.5 years, were 10 (20%). Six had high titre and none of them had completely normal knees, seven had advanced knee arthropathy and six had low lumbar BMD in comparison to 2 and 8 of the 40 patients without inhibitors respectively (P < 0.05). Persistence of inhibitors for more than 2 years without immuno‐prophylaxis was a risk factor for joint damage. Low lumbar BMD was found in 88.9% of patients with stages four and five knee arthropathy and in 66.7% of patients with positive hepatitis C. Severe HA children in this Egyptian study had a relatively low prevalence of persistent FVIII inhibitors, which, if not treated, may increase the risk of knee arthropathy and lumbar osteopenia.     

In vitro kinetics of factor VIII activity in patients with mild haemophilia A and a discrepancy between one-stage and two-stage factor VIII assay results

In some mild haemophilia A patients (discrepant haemophilia), factor VIII coagulant activity (FVIII:C) levels, by one-stage assay are more than double than those by two-stage assay. This may be due to the longer incubation times (10-12 min) in the two-stage assay. This study aimed to determine the time course of the activation phase of the two-stage assay, using both classical coagulation and chromogenic detection methods. In both systems, for equivalent patients (equivalent FVIII:C levels by one-stage and two-stage assays, n = 6, all different mutations), similar FVIII:C results were obtained with short- or long-incubation times. In contrast, plasma from discrepant patients (n = 8, five different mutations) showed higher FVIII:C at shorter incubation times than after longer incubation times. In the chromogenic assay, FVIII:C levels were higher after incubation for 2 min (23-56%, mean 41%) than after 10 min (19-41%, mean 29%). In the classical coagulation assay, FVIII:C levels were higher at shorter incubation times (21-64%, mean 37%) than with the longer incubation times usually used (13-29%, mean 23%). These time-course experiments have verified that the longer incubation time used in the two-stage assay is at least partly responsible for the lower FVIII:C measured by that assay in discrepant haemophilia.     

The concept of idiotypic vaccination against factor VIII inhibitors in haemophilia A

Summary.  Idiotypic vaccination has proven successful in several animal models and human trials. Here we suggest that the expression of cross-reactive idiotypes on factor VIII (FVIII) inhibitors of patients with haemophilia A, patients with anti-FVIII autoimmune disease and natural anti-FVIII antibodies of healthy individuals, together with the ability of anti-idiotypic reagents to neutralize anti-FVIII antibodies, provides a rationale for designing a vaccine strategy aimed at preventing the occurrence of or suppressing inhibitors, based on the induction of protective anti-idiotypes. Here we discuss the rationale supporting the concept of using idiotypic vaccination to prevent the occurrence of FVIII inhibitors in patients with haemophilia A.     

Acquired factor VIII inhibitor associated with chronic interferon-alpha therapy in a patient with haemophilia A

SUMMARY. Both the development of factor VIII inhibitors and infection by hepatitis C virus are serious complications of haemophilia A. We describe the first reported case of the subsequent development of a factor VIII inhibitor in a patient with haemophilia A after treatment with interferon-alpha for chronic active hepatitis C.     

No immunological changes after factor VIII product switch: An in depth analysis in haemophilia A patients

Background

A challenging complication in the treatment of haemophilia A is the formation of neutralizing anti-FVIII antibodies (inhibitors). There is ongoing debate on the effect of FVIII product and inhibitor risk, rendering patients and physicians reluctant to switch FVIII-products.

Aim

This study aimed to evaluate changes in the immune profile of haemophilia A patients after switching FVIII products and their possible relation to inhibitor development. Secondary, FVIII efficacy after switching were assessed.

Methods

Patients, who switched FVIII-products between 2017–2019, were included in this single centre cohort study. Prospective comparison of immunoregulatory cells and markers by flow-cytometry before and after the switch was performed in a subgroup. For the total cohort clinical data regarding inhibitor development and FVIII efficacy 1 year before and after switching were retrospectively collected.

Results

One-hundred patients (including 39 with prospective immunological assessment) were analyzed, of which 31% switched from plasma-derived (pdFVIII) to recombinant standard half-life FVIII (SHL-rFVIII), 47% between different SHL-rFVIII, and 22% from pdFVIII/SHL-rFVIII to rFVIII-Fc. No remarkable changes in immunoregulatory cell functions were observed after switching, regardless the type of switch. None of the patients developed an inhibitor. FVIII efficacy, that is, FVIII usage, half-life and annual bleeding rate (ABR), was similar before and after switch for the SHL products, whereas rFVIII-Fc associated with a longer half-life (13.1 vs. 15.0 h) and lower ABR (3.0 vs. 1.0).

Conclusions

Switching to a different FVIII product was not associated with inhibitor development, nor with differences in the immune profile. Switching to rFVIII-Fc lead to lower ABR.     

Immune tolerance therapy utilizing factor VIII/von Willebrand factor concentrate in haemophilia A patients with high titre factor VIII inhibitors

Summary.  Factor VIII (FVIII) inhibitors remain a serious complication of treatment for patients with haemophilia A. Immune tolerance induction (ITI) can eliminate inhibitors in the majority of patients, but there are major concerns related with this therapy. Investigators have raised the possibility that the use of FVIII/von Willebrand factor (FVIII/VWF) concentrates may improve the success rate of ITI and may shorten the duration of therapy necessary to attain tolerance. This retrospective study describes 25 patients at five institutions in the USA, who were treated with FVIII/VWF concentrate as part of their ITI. These were all patients who were considered poor prognosis because of clinical and laboratory characteristics, which made ITI less likely to be successful or because of a poor response to initial ITI with a monoclonal/recombinant FVIII concentrate. Overall success (complete tolerization) was 32% with another 40% attaining partial tolerization, but not complete tolerization. Of those patients attaining only partial tolerization, two patients ultimately discontinued ITI and had return of their high titre inhibitors. Eight percent of patients failed to attain either partial or complete tolerization and discontinued ITI. Another 24% are continuing with ITI but have titres of >10 BU. This study adds further retrospective data to the information regarding the use of FVIII/VWF concentrate in ITI.     

In vivo recovery and early half-life of infused factor VIII in haemophilia A

Between 1980 and 1994, 169 in vivo recovery studies were performed in one haemophilia centre on casually-recruited outpatients with severe haemophilia A, and 149 early-phase half-life studies were performed on patients scheduled for elective surgery. Average recoveries improved from 80% to 97% of the expected values over the study period. No relationship of recovery to level of product purification was seen. In the disappearance studies, plasma factor VIII levels fell to half the peak levels by 3.25h after infusion, on average.