Allogeneic bone marrow transplantation versus chemotherapy in the treatment of childhood acute lymphoblastic leukemia in second complete remission

Seventy-six patients between the ages of 2 and 17 years with acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL) achieved a second complete remission induced by polychemotherapy. Twenty-one had an HLA-identical donor and underwent allogeneic bone marrow transplantation (BMT) after conditioning with total body irradiation and cyclophosphamide. The remaining 55 patients lacked a suitable donor and received intensive chemotherapy as treatment. Fifteen patients were excluded from the analysis because they relapsed within 3 months after achieving a second complete remission. Three of the 21 BMT patients died of transplant-related complications and seven relapsed between 90 and 480 days after transplantation. Eleven patients are alive and disease free at 5.5-71 months with an actuarial survival of 47.1%; eight patients are on a plateau extending from 22 to 71 months. Thirty-three patients treated with chemotherapy died from relapse and seven are alive and disease free 7.5-99 months from the second remission, with an actuarial survival of 9%. The probability of survival was significantly higher in the BMT group (p less than 0.025). The probability of remaining in complete remission in the BMT group was 58.5% versus 10.9% in the chemotherapy group (p less than 0.005). Our results show that BMT is the best alternative therapy for children affected by ALL who have had a relapse in the marrow.     

Isolated extramedullary relapse of acute lymphoblastic leukaemia after allogeneic bone marrow transplantation

Isolated extramedullary relapse of acute lymphoblastic leukaemia (ALL) with sparing of the marrow after allogeneic bone marrow transplantation (BMT) is a rare occurrence, and the mechanisms underlying the selective involvement of extramedullary sites remain undefined. These might be due to relapse in sanctuary sites where the leukaemic cells are resistant to chemotherapy, or a stronger putative graft-versus-leukaemia (GVL) effect in the marrow as compared with peripheral tissues. We report two ALL patients with repeated episodes of extramedullary relapse after BMT in whom both mechanisms might be operating. In the first patient, the marrow was in morphologic and molecular remission before isolated leukaemic relapse in the central nervous system (CNS) occurred. Subsequent secondary infiltration of leukaemic cells into the marrow was only evident molecularly but not morphologically, implying that the relapse had arisen in a sanctuary CNS site. In the second patient, a first relapse in the marrow, which was induced into morphologic and molecular remission by chemotherapy and donor lymphocyte infusion, was followed by extramedullary relapses without any subsequent involvement of the marrow. This suggested that factors, likely to be due to a GVL effect, were stronger in the marrow than in peripheral tissues.     

Allogeneic bone marrow transplantation for high-risk acute lymphoblastic leukemia during first complete remission

Fifty-three patients with high-risk acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL) under age 50 with a histocompatible sibling donor received high-dose radiochemotherapy followed by allogeneic bone marrow transplantation (BMT). The high-risk factors used to identify the patients were: white blood cell count at initial presentation, cytogenetic abnormalities, age, extramedullary leukemic infiltration, and time from initial therapy to complete remission. Patients with one or more of the above risk factors who received BMT have a disease-free survival of 61% with a median follow-up of 66 months (range 11 months to 10.6 years), and an actuarial relapse rate of 10%. This study demonstrates that patients with high-risk ALL achieve a significant disease-free survival and cure rate with the use of allogeneic fully matched sibling BMT. However, a properly designed prospective study comparing the outcome of BMT with the best currently available chemotherapy data is required to define the ultimate role of BMT in this group of patients.     

Speed of relapse in children with acute lymphoblastic leukaemia

16 children with acute lymphoblastic leukaemia (ALL) who relapsed on maintenance treatment between September 1978 and December 1981 were studied. Their previous bone marrow aspirates were reviewed to determine the first evidence for marrow relapse and the subsequent rate of evolution of the disease. 60% of children had bone marrow evidence of unsuspected relapse at 8 wk, and 40% had evidence at 12 wk before clinical or peripheral blood relapse occurred. Early detection of relapse will prevent continued use of ineffective maintenance chemotherapy and may also reduce morbidity during subsequent induction therapy. Regular 8-weekly marrow aspirates are therefore recommended during first remission of ALL in children with a histocompatible sibling who would be eligible for bone marrow transplantation in second remission.     

Relapse after allogeneic bone marrow transplantation for acute leukaemia: a survey by the E.B.M.T. of 117 cases

A multi-centre retrospective analysis on 117 patients relapsing after bone marrow transplantation (BMT) for acute leukaemia was carried out by the Leukaemia Working Party of the European Group for Bone Marrow Transplantation (E.B.M.T.). Forty-one patients had acute myeloid leukaemia (AML) and 76 had acute lymphoblastic leukaemia (ALL). Relapse occurred between 3 and 30 months after BMT and where investigated the leukaemia was found to have relapsed in recipient cells. In 10 cases the relapse was associated with new cytogenetic abnormalities. 74 patients received further treatment for leukaemia. Of these 21 out of 50 with ALL and 11 out of 24 with AML achieved a complete remission and had a median survival of 12 months compared with a median survival of 4 months for untreated patients or patients not achieving complete remission (P less than 0.001). Factors predictive for successful remission induction were a long interval between bone marrow transplant and relapse in ALL patients; and isolated extramedullary relapse. Presenting blast count, karyotype and remission status and number at the time of BMT were not predictive. Donor bone marrow was shown to be responsible for haemopoietic recovery occurring in the 21 out of 31 patients tested who achieved remission using donor karyotype or red blood cell antigens as markers. Nine patients received a second bone marrow transplant but only one became a long-term survivor. The results show that chemotherapy can usually prolong survival in selected patients with acute leukaemia relapsing after BMT but further BMT has a poor outlook.     

Marrow transplantation for acute lymphoblastic leukemia: factors affecting relapse and survival

Transplant outcome was analyzed in 690 recipients of bone marrow transplants (BMTs) for acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL) in first (n = 299) or second remission (n = 391). Actuarial 5-year leukemia-free survival was 42% +/- 9% (95% confidence interval) and 26% +/- 6%, respectively; relapse rates were 29% +/- 9% and 52% +/- 8%, respectively. Five-year leukemia-free survival was 56% +/- 18% in children and 39% +/- 10% in adults (P less than .02) transplanted in first remission. In first-remission adults, non-T-cell phenotype, male to female donor-recipient sex-match and graft-v-host disease (GVHD) were associated with decreased leukemia-free survival; inclusion of corticosteroids in the regimen to prevent GVHD was associated with increased leukemia-free survival. Variables associated with decreased leukemia-free survival after second-remission transplants were age greater than or equal to 16 years and relapse occurring while on therapy. Variables associated with increased probability of relapse were similar for first- and second-remission transplants and included GVHD prophylaxis without methotrexate and absence of GVHD. In first- remission transplants, leukocyte count greater than or equal to 50 x 10(9)/L at diagnosis was also associated with increased relapse; in second remission, relapse while receiving chemotherapy was also associated with increased posttransplant relapse. These data emphasize the importance of both disease- and transplant-related variables in predicting outcome after BMT. They may be used to explain differences between studies, design future trials, and identify persons most likely to benefit from BMT.     

Slow response to induction chemotherapy is an indicator of poor survival after bone marrow transplantation for acute lymphoblastic leukemia. The Leukemia Working Party of the European Group of Bone Marrow Transplantation (EBMT).

The prognostic value of diagnosis-remission interval on leukemia-free survival (LFS) after bone marrow transplantation (BMT) was investigated retrospectively in 193 adult patients with acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL) transplanted in first remission and reported to the EBMT between 1979 and 1986. Patients achieving remission within 8 weeks of diagnosis ('fast responders') had better LFS after BMT than those with remission after 8 weeks ('slow responders'): LFS at 3 years was 43% vs 32% for fast and slow responders, respectively (p = 0.04). The effect on LFS was particularly severe for slow responders transplanted within 3 months of remission. Only 17% of the slow responders with short remission-BMT interval survived at 3 years. Decreased LFS was caused by both excess of transplant-related mortality and increased relapse incidence. In a multivariate analysis, time intervals (both diagnosis-remission and remission-BMT) were the strongest independent prognostic factor for LFS, probability of relapse and transplant-related mortality. We conclude that the intervals diagnosis-remission and remission-BMT have a strong prognostic value in adult patients with ALL not only for remission duration after conventional treatment, but also for LFS after BMT.     

Long-term follow-up of relapsed childhood acute lymphoblastic leukaemia

We have reviewed the outcome after relapse in a cohort of 505 children with acute lymphoblastic leukaemia (ALL) seen at a single institution. The majority of relapses (74%) occurred within 3 years from diagnosis, and most involved the bone marrow alone or with overt extramedullary relapse. Early relapse was more common in children with T-ALL and those with unfavourable cytogenetics. Factors influencing second remission included length of first remission and type of relapse. Children who had not received previous cranial irradiation had a superior survival. The German relapse score involving length of first remission, site of relapse and immunophenotype was highly predictive of outcome: event-free survival with 95% confidence intervals at 6 years for patients who received modern treatment [intensive chemotherapy or bone marrow transplantation (BMT)] was 78% (51-92%) for standard risk, 41% (33-49%) for intermediate risk and 19% (10-31%) for highest risk. Retrospective comparison of BMT with chemotherapy showed no difference in the intermediate-risk group but a possible advantage in the highest risk group. Follow-up of 235 patients who relapsed after chemotherapy and received a third course of treatment showed an extremely high early attrition rate, but a small number of patients survived in third remission. We conclude that new approaches are needed to individualize therapy in intermediate-risk patients and to improve the outcome for those in the highest risk group. Only a small number of children can be treated effectively in third remission.     

Allogeneic bone marrow transplantation for high risk acute lymphoblastic leukemia. Results from a single institution.

We present our experience with bone marrow transplantation (BMT) in 30 consecutive patients with high risk acute lymphoblastic leukemia. With a median follow-up of 4 years the disease-free survival (DFS) was 44% for the whole group, with a significant difference between patients in first or second complete remission (CR 1 and 2, as one group), compared with patients with more advanced disease (greater than CR2), 69.5% versus 15.4% (p less than 0.01). The main cause of BMT failure was leukemic relapse, with a relapse rate of 15% for patients in CR 1 and 2 and of 77% for patients with greater than CR2 (p less than 0.01). Among patients with active disease at BMT those who had 15% blast cells or less in the marrow fared better than those with more advanced disease or extramedullary relapse. Transplant-related death was 17%. Graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) was associated with an antileukemic effect; the DFS for patients with acute and/or chronic GVHD was better than for patients with no GVHD at all.     

Influence of karyotype on outcome of allogeneic bone marrow transplantation for adults with precursor B-lineage acute lymphoblastic leukaemia in first or second remission

The prognostic relevance of karyotype has been established in adult acute lymphoblastic leukaemia (ALL) patients treated with chemotherapy but not definitively evaluated in an allogeneic bone marrow transplantation (BMT) setting. To determine the factors affecting the outcome of allogeneic BMT for adults with precursor B-lineage ALL in first or second complete remission (CR), a total of 41 consecutive patients with a successful karyotype were enrolled in this study. There were 21 men and 20 women with a median age of 27 (15-43) years. The distribution of French-American-British (FAB) subtypes was as follows: L1 (n = 26), L2 (n = 15). Unfavourable karyotypes (n = 12) were defined as Ph+ or t(4;11). Disease status at the time of transplant was first CR (n = 35) or second CR (n = 6). With a median follow-up of 36 months, the 3-year probabilities of relapse and disease-free survival (DFS) were 36.3 +/- 8.4% and 57.3 +/- 8.4% respectively. Potential variables predicting worse relapse and DFS were FAB subtype (L2), extramedullary involvement, pre-BMT status (second CR), unfavourable karyotype and type of graft-versus-host disease (GVHD). Further multivariate analysis showed that karyotype and pre-BMT status were independently associated with relapse and DFS. In addition, chronic GVHD was found to be significantly associated with a lower relapse rate.     

Donor lymphocyte infusion for childhood acute lymphoblastic leukaemia relapsing after bone marrow transplantation

Four children with acute lymphoblastic leukaemia (ALL) who relapsed after allogeneic bone marrow transplantation (BMT) were treated with donor lymphocyte infusion (DLI) without prior conditioning. Three patients had previously received a non-T-cell-depleted matched sibling BMT and the fourth had a T-cell-depleted matched unrelated BMT. Two patients developed grade III–IV acute graft-versus-host-disease (GVHD) of the skin, which required intervention. Both are alive in complete haematological remission 7 and 10 months from DLI with chronic GVHD of the skin requiring immunosuppressive therapy. A third patient went into haematological remission 6 weeks after DLI, but with no clinical evidence of GVHD. His bone marrow remained in remission 11 months post-DLI despite the disease (ALL) relapsing in extramedullary sites. The fourth patient showed no clinical or haematological response to three consecutive doses of DLI given at 4-weekly intervals and died from progressive disease 11 months after relapse. These preliminary observations indicate that in constrast to experience in adult ALL, DLI may be effective in inducing sustained remission in children with ALL relapsing after BMT, and a response may occur even in the absence of clinical evidence of GVHD.     

Prediction and prevention of relapse of acute lymphoblastic leukaemia after bone marrow transplantation

Results of bone marrow transplantation (BMT) in 63 adults and children with ALL transplanted in the 5-year period 1979-83 were analysed. Twenty-one patients (33%) relapsed, 25% of the group died in relapse and 19% died from complications of BMT. The actuarial disease-free survival at 6 years was 38%. Relapse after BMT could be predicted by standard prognostic diagnostic features such as age, sex, cell type and presenting blast cell count. Patients transplanted in first remission selected for their poor prognosis had a lower relapse risk than a similar group of poor prognosis patients transplanted in second or subsequent remission (P less than 0.05). Relapse following second and subsequent remission BMT was predicted by a score based on standard prognostic features or by the pace of the disease: patients with an interval of less than 2 years between diagnosis and first relapse having a 15% actuarial disease-free survival, compared with 81% for patients with an interval greater than 2 years (P less than 0.001). These results emphasize that ALL is a heterogeneous disease and establishes the importance of determining relapse risk when selecting BMT and other treatment schedules for ALL patients.     

Allogeneic bone marrow transplantation versus chemotherapy for childhood acute lymphoblastic leukaemia in second remission

Thirty-six children with acute lymphoblastic leukaemia (ALL) in second remission were treated with conventional chemotherapy or with cyclophosphamide and fractionated total-body irradiation followed by an allogeneic bone marrow transplant; the choice of treatment was dictated by the availability of an HLA-identical sibling. The age, sex, clinical data at presentation of the disease and duration of first remission were comparable for the two groups of patients. In the bone marrow transplantation group two patients died of graft-versus-host disease and five of leukaemia. Ten patients survive, nine disease free, 13-53 months from second remission (6-51 months post-bone marrow transplantation). In the chemotherapy group 14 patients died of leukaemia (2-29 months from second remission) and five survive (22-34 months from second remission). The actuarial survival for patients with bone marrow transplantation is 48% at 4 years as compared with 22% for those of the chemotherapy group (P = 0.04); the actuarial probabilities of being in remission are 58 and 18% in the two groups respectively (P = 0.01). This study confirms that allogeneic bone marrow transplantation is superior to chemotherapy in patients in second remission with ALL and should be considered in the presence of an HLA-identical sibling.     

Fractionated total body irradiation and high-dose etoposide as a preparatory regimen for bone marrow transplantation for 99 patients with acute leukemia in first complete remission

Ninety-nine consecutive patients with acute leukemia in first complete remission under age 50 (median age 27 years; age range 1 to 47 years) with a histocompatible sibling donor were treated with fractionated total body irradiation (1,320 cGy) and high-dose etoposide (60 mg/kg) followed by allogeneic bone marrow transplantation. Sixty-one patients were diagnosed with acute myelogenous leukemia (AML), 34 patients with acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL), 3 patients with biphenotypic acute leukemia, and 1 patient with acute undifferentiated leukemia. Thirty of the 34 patients with ALL had at least one of the following high-risk factors: age greater than 30, white blood cell count at presentation > 25,000/microL, extramedullary disease, certain chromosomal translocations, or the need for greater than 4 weeks of induction chemotherapy to achieve first complete remission. Cumulative probabilities of disease-free survival and relapse at 3 years were 61% and 12%, respectively, for the 61 patients with AML and 64% and 12%, respectively, for the 34 patients with ALL. By stepwise Cox regression analysis, significant prognostic variables for patients with acute myelogenous leukemia were the presence of acute graft-versus-host disease and increasing age, whereas for patients with acute lymphoblastic leukemia, significant variables were age and the development of cytomegalovirus-associated interstitial pneumonia. Complications related to graft-versus-host disease and relapse of leukemia were the major causes of death.     

Treatment of hemophagocytic lymphohistiocytosis with chemotherapy and bone marrow transplantation: a single-center study of 22 cases

Twenty-two children with hemophagocytic lymphohistiocytosis were treated with a chemotherapy regimen consisting of VP16-213, corticosteroids, and intrathecal methotrexate. A sustained clinical and biologic complete remission was obtained in 15 children and a partial remission in one child; six children died early of opportunistic infection (n = 4) or of disease progression (n = 2). Of the 16 children who were placed in first remission, 10 received maintenance chemotherapy alone, while six underwent bone marrow transplantation (HLA matched in five, HLA mismatched in one). Of the children who received chemotherapy alone, only two are in long-term remission after cessation of treatment. The remaining eight patients relapsed after a mean period of 5.4 months (range 2 to 8 months). Further treatment using the same regimen induced second remissions of short duration; death occurred after a median period of 2.3 months (range 0.5 to 6 months). A total of nine patients received allogeneic bone marrow transplantation (BMT). Among the six children transplanted in remission, four are in long-term unmaintained remission, 1 to 6 years after HLA-matched BMT. However, the relapse that occurred in one patient 1 year post BMT is difficult to interpret because the donor, the patient's 5-year-old sister, also developed the disease 1 year later. An HLA-nonidentical BMT resulted in unmaintained remission for 1 year, with autologous hematologic reconstitution followed by disease relapse. HLA-nonidentical BMT failed in three other patients with active disease at time of transplant. The poor long-term results of chemotherapy alone justify the use of related HLA-matched BMT in complete remission.     

Allogeneic bone marrow transplantation in second remission of childhood acute lymphoblastic leukemia: a population-based case control study from the Nordic countries

This study compares allogeneic BMT with conventional chemotherapy for childhood ALL in second remission. Seventy-five children were transplanted between July 1981 and December 1995. For each patient two control patients matching the following criteria were selected from the Nordic database of ALL: (1) time of diagnosis, (2) T vs. non-T ALL, (3) site of relapse, (4) initial risk group, (5) sex and (6) relapse < or > or =6 months after cessation of therapy. The minimal time of follow-up was 24 months. Mortality rate in CR2, leukemic relapse rate and the proportion in continued second remission were 16/75 (21%), 22/75 (29%) and 37/75 (50%), respectively. P2.-EFS for the BMT group was significantly better than that for the control group (0.40 vs. 0.23, P = 0.02). Children transplanted for bone marrow relapses in particular had a higher P2.-EFS (0.35 vs. 0.15 for the control group, P<0.01). Also, children grafted for early BM relapses had a higher P2.-EFS (0.32 vs. 0.11 for the control group P = 0.01). The outcome was similar when children were transplanted after early or late relapse. Also, there was no difference in outcome between the BMT and the chemotherapy group for children with late relapses. We conclude that allogeneic BMT with an HLA-identical sibling donor or other family donor should be performed in children relapsing in bone marrow during therapy or within 6 months of discontinuing therapy.     

Comparison of bone marrow transplant and chemotherapy for relapsed childhood acute lymphoblastic leukaemia: the MRC UKALL X experience

We examined the outcome of the 489 children with acute lymphoblastic leukaemia (ALL) who relapsed in the UKALL X trial, and produced graphical displays of adjusted comparisons of event-free survival (EFS) for chemotherapy versus bone marrow transplantation (BMT) from a sibling or volunteer unrelated donor, and autologous BMT (ABMT).
EFS at 5 years was only 3% (95% CI 0–6%) for children who relapsed in the bone marrow (BM) within 2 years of diagnosis, irrespective of type of post-relapse treatment, whereas for those with late extramedullary relapse it was 66% (95% CI 48–85%). Comparison of the types of treatment did not show benefit for ABMT. For allogeneic BMT the overall reduction in the odds of an event was 26% (95% CI 1–51%) (2 P  = 0.05), resulting in an absolute increase in 5-year event-free survival of 14% (from 26.4% to 40.7%).
New approaches are needed for children with early BM relapses whose prognosis is virtually hopeless with current therapy; however, a conventional chemotherapy approach may be justifiable for late extramedullary relapses. For the remaining patients (71%), with later BM or early extramedullary relapses, the optimal treatment is still not clear. This uncertainty warrants a formal randomized comparison of BMT and chemotherapy, to avoid the biases due to unmeasurable selection factors.     

A comparison of busulphan versus total body irradiation combined with cyclophosphamide as conditioning for autograft or allograft bone marrow transplantation in patients with acute leukaemia

We retrospectively compared the outcome in patients in the EBMT database transplanted for acute leukaemia from January 1987 to January 1994 who received busulphan and cyclophosphamide (BU/CY) as a pretransplant regimen versus those who received cyclophosphamide and total-body irradiation (CY/TBI). The patients were matched for type of transplant (autologous bone marrow transplantation (ABMT) versus allogeneic (BMT)), diagnosis (acute lymphoblastic leukaemia (ALL) or acute myeloid leukaemia (AML)), status (early (first complete remission, CR-1) versus intermediate (second or later remission, first relapse)), age, FAB classification for AML, prevention of graft-versus-host disease and year of transplantation. In ABMT recipients (matched paired 530 × 2) with ALL CR-1, AML CR-1 and AML intermediate disease, transplant-related mortalities (TRM), relapse incidence (RI) and leukaemia-free survival (LFS) did not differ significantly in patients treated with BU/CY or CY/TBI. However, in ABMT recipients with ALL intermediate disease, the probability of relapse was 82 ± 5% (±95% confidence interval) in the BU/CY group compared to 62 ± 6% in the CY/TBI group (P = 0.002) and the 2-year leukaemia-free survival 14 ± 4% and 34 ± 6%, respectively (P = 0.002). In BMT recipients of bone marrow from HLA-identical siblings (matched paired 391 × 2), the TRM, RI and LFS did not differ significantly between the two treatments in all groups. In particular, the 2-year LFS in patients with AML CR-1 was 64 ± 3% in those treated with BU/CY (n = 237) compared to 66 ± 3% in those given CY/TBI (n = 237). In all groups the findings were confirmed in a multivariate analysis of prognostic factors. Veno-occlusive disease (VOD) of the liver (P < 0.05) and haemorrhagic cystitis (P < 0.001) was more common in the BU/CY group compared to the CY/TBI group for ABMT and BMT patients. In conclusion, BU/CY and CY/TBI as pretransplant regimens gave similar results in all situations, except ABMT for ALL intermediate stages with more than 2 years from diagnosis to transplantation, where a lower RI and a higher LFS were associated with CY/TBI.     

Chemotherapy compared with bone marrow transplantation for adults with acute lymphoblastic leukemia in first remission

OBJECTIVE: To compare efficacy of intensive postremission chemotherapy with allogeneic bone marrow transplantation in adults with acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL) in first remission. DESIGN: Retrospective comparison of two cohorts of patients. SETTING: Chemotherapy recipients were treated in 44 hospitals in West Germany in two cooperative group trials; transplants were done in 98 hospitals worldwide. PATIENTS: Patients (484) receiving intensive postremission chemotherapy and 251 recipients of HLA-identical sibling bone marrow transplants for ALL in first remission. Patients ranged from 15 to 45 years of age and were treated between 1980 and 1987. MAIN RESULTS: Similar prognostic factors predicted treatment failure (non-T-cell phenotype, high leukocyte count at diagnosis, and 8 or more weeks to achieve first remission) of both therapies. After statistical adjustments were made for differences in disease characteristics and time-to-treatment, survival was similar in the chemotherapy and transplant cohorts: Five-year leukemia-free survival probability was 38% (95% CI, 33% to 43%) with chemotherapy and 44% (CI, 37% to 52%) with transplant. No specific prognostic group had a significantly better outcome with one treatment compared with the other (6% for the difference; CI, -3% to 15%). Causes of treatment failure differed: With chemotherapy, 268 (96%) failures were from relapse and 11 (4%) were treatment-related; with transplants, 43 (32%) failures were from relapse and 92 (68%) were treatment-related. CONCLUSIONS: These results suggest that bone marrow transplants currently offer no special advantage over chemotherapy for adults with acute lymphoblastic leukemia in first remission.