Smoking cessation efforts among substance abusing adolescents

Available research demonstrates that substance abusing youth are heavy cigarette smokers for whom the behavior persists into adulthood. As such this population represents an important target for intervention. In order to inform treatment design, the present paper described cessation efforts, including motives and methods for quitting, in a sample of cigarette smoking adolescents who received inpatient or outpatient treatment for substance abuse. The 183 participants were on average 16.2 years old, 45% were females, and 72% were white. Consistent with studies of community and high risk youth samples, the majority of participants had previously attempted cessation, yet reported little success in maintaining abstinence. Health emerged as a frequently endorsed motive for cessation and stopping abruptly (cold turkey) was the most commonly reported strategy for quitting.     

Self-help approaches to smoking cessation: a report from the normative aging study

Self-quitters make up by far the largest proportion of ex-cigarette smokers, yet this population has not been extensively characterized to date. We compared male self-quitters (N = 191) and age-matched recidivists (N = 110) on smoking histories, psychosocial attributes and quitting methods. A number of significant relationships were found, some of which may have clinical implications. those who substituted cigars or pipes for cigarettes were nearly four times more likely to be successful, and those who reported consuming more food/snacks after quitting were 80% more likely to be successful quitters. Subjects who reported using no coping strategies in former smoking settings after cessation because they had no urges to smoke in these settings were also much more likely to be successful quitters. Recidivists were more likely to report using physical activity as a means of coping with temptations to smoke, and were somewhat older at the time of the quit attempt. Withdrawal symptoms and psychosocial stress were reported as reasons for relapse by early relapsers, while late relapsers reported being around other smokers on social occasions, and psychosocial stress.     

Partner interaction and smoking cessation: a pilot study.

This was an exploratory study of precessation interaction between 21 smokers and their partners enrolled in a partner support smoking treatment program. The aim was to identify the partner interactions and proposed quitting strategies that were associated with cessation. Significant results (p less than .05) and trends (p less than .10) were reported. Both smoker and partner interactions predicted cessation. Failure to quit was predicted by smokers' negative behavior (prosmoking statements, interrupting the partner, and criticism/rejection of help) and by partners' suggestion to disengage from the quitting process. Partner's suggestion to disengage may be a reaction to the smokers' negative behavior because it was positively correlated with it. Successful quitters and their partners proposed more self-help strategies than did nonquitters and their partners. Nonquitters proposed more cooperative strategies than did successful quitters. Thus, suggesting strategies that encourage autonomy and self-mastery, rather than dependence on another person, may lead to more positive outcomes.     

Reasons for Quitting and Smoking Temptation among Adolescent Smokers: Gender Differences

Adolescent cigarette smokers from randomly selected classrooms from 24 California and Illinois high schools were assessed regarding their interest in cessation, reasons for quitting, and smoking temptation circumstances. These data were analyzed by gender. Males and females were not found to differ in quit stage or perceived likelihood of ever quitting smoking, although males reported being somewhat more likely to have ever tried to quit in the past. The associations of reasons for quitting were not found to vary by gender in most comparisons. On the other hand, the associations of smoking temptation circumstances with gender showed that a greater percentage of females than males reported more circumstances that would make them tempted to smoke. Smoking cigarettes to regulate one's affective states, and to avoid nicotine withdrawal, may be functions of smoking that impede efforts at quitting, particularly among adolescent females.     

Alcoholics' attributions of factors affecting their relapse to drinking and reasons for terminating relapse episodes

This study was designed to examine alcoholics' attributions about their relapses. The subjects were 36 male alcoholic participants in a study of the effectiveness of group behavioral marital therapy (BMT) for alcoholism. Subjects' treatment condition had been determined by random assignment to either the BMT, interactional marital therapy, or control group. At a two year posttreatment follow-up interview, subjects were asked what they thought the main reasons were for starting and stopping drinking in their two most recent relapses. Subjects' responses showed that both interpersonal and psychological factors were perceived to affect relapses, with some treatment group differences in how relapses were viewed. Subjects reported a variety of factors in their stopping drinking, with anticipation of negative consequences the most frequently reported reason. The treatment groups did not differ on their attributions for relapse termination. The results were interpreted as replicating and extending previous studies of relapse among alcoholics by showing the importance of spouse and other family members in subjects' attributions of relapse and their termination.     

The quitting experience for smokers in sixth through twelfth grades

The present study examined the withdrawal process for adolescents who had attempted to quit smoking. A sample of 622 6th through 12th graders were interviewed. Smoking status was reported prior to attempting to quit and its relationship with the withdrawal experience was evaluated. Although over half of those who smoked regularly reported trying to quit, 78% of the "quitters" were smoking six months after their quit attempt. Experiencing adverse withdrawal symptoms was related to smoking at daily levels before quitting; delaying trying to quit was associated with initiation of smoking at an early age; and quitting success was predicted by early quitting age, lower pre-quitting smoking levels, a lack of a prior quitting failure, and peer smoking. The results suggest that smoking intervention programs for adolescents should include components facilitating the quitting process that take into consideration youngsters' smoking and quitting histories.     

Attribution and the effects of expectancy: how beliefs can influence the experiences of smoking cessation

Research on smoking cessation has found consistencies and similarities during abstinence, but also that the specific signs and symptoms and their intensity vary greatly from individual to individual. One possible source of this variation is the cognitions associated with quitting. We investigated the experiences and associated cognitions in normal cessation by asking quitting smokers to rate their experiences on a questionnaire and to indicate the most likely reason for each experience. Statistical analyses confirmed that attributions to abstinence were significantly higher for increased negative experiences, and there were significantly more reattributions than would be found by chance for items associated with smoking abstinence. Significantly more attributions to abstinence were made by clinic attendees and significantly more attributions of negative experiences to abstinence were made by unaided quitters using self-help materials. These results can be interpreted in the context of attribution theory; quitters may use the cognitions available to them to attribute their negative experiences to quitting. Consequently, counsellors could use cognitive therapy to alter their clients' expectations and explanations of their experiences, and emphasise the positive outcomes of cessation.     

Assessing the responsiveness of a quality-of-life instrument and the measurement of symptom severity in essential hypertension

A pilot study was conducted to compare symptoms elicited with an open-ended question versus a checklist and to measure the responsiveness of quality-of-life measures to symptom severity. The pilot study was part of a multicentre, randomised, double-blind, placebo-controlled study of clentiazem, a calcium channel blocker, in the treatment of essential hypertension. Symptom and quality-of-life data were obtained from 88 patients at baseline and after 10 weeks of therapy by a trained telephone interviewer. Comparison of the symptom checklist and open-ended question method suggests that both methods are necessary to capture severe symptomatology. The 24-item checklist failed to elicit approximately 50% of the severe symptoms reported on the open question list. On the other hand, only 18% of the most severe symptoms subsequently reported on the checklist were first reported by the open question method. The responsiveness of quality-of-life measures to symptom severity was tested using a 20% change in symptom severity obtained from the checklist as the minimal clinically significant difference. Using Guyatt's formula, a minimum sample size of approximately 428 (alpha = 0.05, beta = 0.10) patients per treatment group is required to detect differences in measures of general health perception, anxiety, depression and limitations in social activities. A larger sample is required to show differences in leisure activities. Differences in limitations of the capability to perform house or yard work might be demonstrable with as few as 17 patients per group. This pilot study demonstrated that the severity of symptoms associated with hypertension, and the side effects of its treatment with drugs, are adequately captured by a symptom checklist preceded by an open-ended method of questioning. Responsiveness testing estimated the sample size required to show a statistically significant difference, assuming a 20% change in symptom severity.     

Access to and use of health care: perceptions and experiences among people who use heroin and cocaine

Objective:?To examine the health care experiences of low-income drug users in order to gain insight into their health care decision-making and barriers to care.

Methods:?Data come principally from open-ended interviews with 71 individuals who use or used heroin and/or cocaine. Interviews focused primarily on health status, health history, and health care received; current and former drug use; and basic demographics. Supplementary data were collected through four focus group discussions with drug users and six open-ended interviews with health care providers.

Results:?Study participants had high morbidity and high utilization of health services. More than 80% of participants reported that their last health care visit occurred within the last six months; 56% of participants reported health care visits within the last two months. These visits were most often to address pressing medical needs including infections, illness, and injury.

Health care experiences were considered most favorably when providers demonstrated concern for comfort and well-being, and most unfavorably when care appeared to be affected by prejudice or preconceptions about drug use. Negative experiences with health care served to discourage consistent utilization of needed services.

Conclusions:?The health care experiences described by heroin and cocaine users suggest provider ignorance and prejudice regarding this population and make evident some reasons underlying drug user avoidance of health care.     

Smoking cessation in pregnancy: a self-help approach

During a 3-month recruitment period, a smoking cessation program was provided to all pregnant women who attended an HMO prenatal clinic and reported either that they were currently smokers (n = 35) or that they had quit at pregnancy onset (n = 23). Except for its in-clinic introduction, the behavioral smoking cessation program used a home-correspondence format with seven weekly mailings and a telephone answering system adjunct. At follow-up, all 23 women who identified themselves at baseline as self-initiated quitters reported continued abstinence from smoking. Urine thiocyanate assays confirmed these self-report data in 82% of the cases. Results of a multivariate analysis identified three factors--gravida, number of years a smoker, and number of friends who smoke--as significant predictors of self-initiated quitting. Of the 35 women who indicated that they were still smoking at baseline, 10 (28.5%) reported that they had stopped smoking at the time of the postprogram assessment. Available urine thiocyanate assays confirmed a nonsmoking status in all cases. The multivariate results indicated that four variables--gravida, severe nausea, baseline smoking rate, and spouse's smoking status--were significant predictors of quitting following exposure to the program. The majority of both self-initiated quitters and postprogram quitters reported that the program was useful in helping them to quit smoking and/or to remain abstinent over time. These results lend support to the viability of a home-correspondence, self-help program as a means for facilitating smoking cessation and continued abstinence from smoking during pregnancy.     

Being serious about quitting: a qualitative analysis of Australian ex-smokers’ explanations of their quitting success

BackgroundThe process of successful quitting, and the personal and social conditions required to support it, remain poorly understood.MethodsThis qualitative grounded theory study used in-depth interviews with 37 Australian adult ex-smokers (24–68 years; 15 men and 22 women) who quit in the past 6–24 months to explore how ex-smokers explain their quitting success.FindingsThis analysis provides a framework for understanding the personal, social and structural factors critical to successful quitting. The key analytic finding was the core concept ‘being serious’. Three factors contributed to ‘being serious’: (1) prior experiences of quitting; (2) an identity (or existential) threat; and (3) timing and circumstances. The analysis indicated that the concept ‘being serious’ rather than the oft-cited psychological constructs motivation and willpower more accurately captures how participants talked about and explained their quitting success, how they accounted for their success when previous apparently similar attempts had failed, and the advice they would offer would-be quitters about achieving quitting success. An explanation is provided for why some participants battled with quitting for years, while others quit unexpectedly, even effortlessly. The social and structural factors that made the state of ‘being serious’ easier or harder for the participant to attain are also discussed.Conclusion‘Being serious’ was a term that resonated with participants. Participants’ accounts of quitting indicate that quitting is a complex and gradual process and that social and structural influences have a key role in determining how easy or difficult it was to become serious about quitting.     

An In-Depth Qualitative Examination of the Ecstasy Experience: Results of a Focus Group with Ecstasy-Using College Students

This study examined ecstasy use in 30 college students who participated in one of four 60-minute focus groups with other participants who also had a history of ecstasy use. Ten topics emerged in the sessions: 1) pill ingredients, 2) mechanism of MDMA effects, 3) reasons for initiating ecstasy use, 4) risky behaviors and ecstasy use, 5) sexual activity and ecstasy, 6) positive effects from ecstasy use, 7) negative effects related to ecstasy use, 8) ecstasy and polysubstance use, 9) perceived risks of ecstasy use, and 10) motivational factors related to quitting ecstasy use. Most participants had a basic understanding of the contents of ecstasy pills, and the effects that ecstasy has on the brain and bodily functions. Participants reported positive effects on mood, social pressure, curiosity, availability, boredom, desire for an altered state of mind, desire to escape, self-medication, desire to have fun, and the ease of use of ecstasy in comparison to other drugs as reasons for initiating ecstasy use. They were divided regarding whether ecstasy increased the likelihood of engaging in risky behaviors, including risky sexual behavior. Participants described their experiences of both the positive and negative effects (physical and psychological) that they attributed to their use of ecstasy. All participants were polysubstance users, consuming a number of other substances simultaneously and concurrently with ecstasy. The majority was unaware of specific types of problems ecstasy could potentially cause and discounted its potential harm. Participants varied in their motivation for quitting ecstasy use, including negative personal experiences while using ecstasy, health concerns, and addiction/tolerance. Implications for prevention and intervention are discussed.     

An in-depth qualitative examination of the ecstasy experience: results of a focus group with ecstasy-using college students

This study examined ecstasy use in 30 college students who participated in one of four 60-minute focus groups with other participants who also had a history of ecstasy use. Ten topics emerged in the sessions: 1) pill ingredients, 2) mechanism of MDMA effects, 3) reasons for initiating ecstasy use, 4) risky behaviors and ecstasy use, 5) sexual activity and ecstasy, 6) positive effects from ecstasy use, 7) negative effects related to ecstasy use, 8) ecstasy and polysubstance use, 9) perceived risks of ecstasy use, and 10) motivational factors related to quitting ecstasy use. Most participants had a basic understanding of the contents of ecstasy pills, and the effects that ecstasy has on the brain and bodily functions. Participants reported positive effects on mood, social pressure, curiosity, availability, boredom, desire for an altered state of mind, desire to escape, self-medication, desire to have fun, and the ease of use of ecstasy in comparison to other drugs as reasons for initiating ecstasy use. They were divided regarding whether ecstasy increased the likelihood of engaging in risky behaviors, including risky sexual behavior. Participants described their experiences of both the positive and negative effects (physical and psychological) that they attributed to their use of ecstasy. All participants were polysubstance users, consuming a number of other substances simultaneously and concurrently with ecstasy. The majority was unaware of specific types of problems ecstasy could potentially cause and discounted its potential harm. Participants varied in their motivation for quitting ecstasy use, including negative personal experiences while using ecstasy, health concerns, and addiction/tolerance. Implications for prevention and intervention are discussed.     

Process of counseling support persons to promote smoker treatment utilization

This qualitative study describes the process of providing a telephone intervention for adult non-smoking support persons to motivate and encourage a smoker to call the QUITPLAN Helpline. The intervention consisted of written materials and three consecutive, weekly, 15–30?min telephone sessions. Themes, issues, and concerns were summarized using content analysis. Participants were 212 support persons (94% female, 93% Caucasian) who completed at least one session. The intervention had a reported positive impact on participants’ understanding of the process of quitting smoking. The concept of readiness to quit including the Contemplation Ladder as a visual aid, education on nicotine dependence, and learning to recognize and reinforce small steps toward quitting or seeking help to quit were valuable tools to help participants understand their smoker's behavior, determine where the smoker was in the process of quitting and to use appropriate support strategies. Common issues and concerns raised are described along with strategies counselors used to address these during sessions. In addition, quantitative data on the types of goals and strategies used by support persons to motivate their smoker toward calling the Helpline and quitting are summarized. The themes of this study, along with counselor responses and suggestions, as well as goals and strategies used by support persons, could help providers to effectively guide and support non-smokers who want to help someone seek treatment to quit smoking.     

Evaluation of a smoking cessation programme that uses behaviour modification

AIM: To obtain an up-to-date measure of the end-of-course success rate of the Isis Stop Smoking Programme and to determine which demographic, socioeconomic and behavioural factors were predictors of success in the programme. METHOD: Data from a questionnaire completed at the outset of course participation were available for 1016 Isis participants. The data were statistically analysed. RESULTS: "Success" was defined as having consumed no cigarettes during the final 24 hours of participation on the Isis Programme. The overall success rate at completion of the programme was 69% of participants. For both males and females, the number of cigarettes consumed on beginning the programme was the strongest predictor of success. Other predictors were commitment to quitting, nicotine yield of the usual cigarette, number of years of smoking and age. Young females had a particularly good success rate. Participants were categorised according to the New Zealand Socioeconomic Index of Occupational Status. Professional and technical workers were the most successful quitters and the unemployed, self-employed and students had particularly low success rates. CONCLUSION: Assuming proportionality of recent end-of-course success rates with comparable figures from the late 1970s, the proportion of Isis participants who continue to be non-smokers one year from completing the course would be approximately 33%. Further investigation to confirm this is warranted.     

The effect of successful and unsuccessful smoking cessation on short-term anxiety,depression, and suicidality

Research on the mental health effects of quitting smoking is limited. Smokers with mental illness appear to be at a higher risk of unsuccessful smoking cessation. Recent work suggests they are at elevated risk for post-cessation increases in anxiety, depression and suicidal ideation. The current study tested the effects of successful and unsuccessful smoking cessation on short-term psychopathology in 192 community participants. Smoking cessation outcomes were classified using expired carbon monoxide levels that were taken at quit week, 1 and 2 week follow-up and 1 month follow-up. We found no psychopathology increases in participants who successfully quit smoking. For individuals struggling to quit our results partially supported a recently proposed struggling quitters hypothesis. However, the vast majority of individuals posited to be vulnerable by the struggling quitters hypothesis did not experience clinically significant increases in psychopathology. These findings have implications for clinicians whose clients are interested in smoking cessation.     

The treatment of mixed affective disorders in general practice: a comparison of trazodone and dothiepin

The efficacy and tolerance of trazodone in the treatment of mixed affective disorder was compared with that of dothiepin in a double-blind, parallel group study in 228 general practice patients at 10 centres. After satisfying entry criteria, patients were randomized to receive either 150 mg trazodone at night, or 75 mg dothiepin at night for a 6-week period. Efficacy was assessed using the Hamilton Rating Scales for Depression and Anxiety. Significant improvements were observed in the condition of patients in each of the two treatment groups during the 6-week treatment period (p = 0.0001), with no statistically significant difference between the groups. There were no marked differences between the two treatment groups in the type of side-effects reported in response to open questioning, although a higher percentage of symptoms in the trazodone group were mild compared to the dothiepin group, and a lower percentage were severe. The incidence side-effects recorded by means of a checklist of common psychotropic side-effects was similar for the two treatment groups: dry mouth and drowsiness were the most frequent. A slightly higher proportion of patients withdrew from the dothiepin group, and of those who withdrew a higher percentage was due to side-effects than in the trazodone group.     

The influence of message framing, intention to quit smoking, and nicotine dependence on the persuasiveness of smoking cessation messages

This study explores the combined effect of message framing, intention to quit smoking, and nicotine dependence on the persuasiveness of smoking cessation messages. Pre- and post-message measures of quit intention, attitude toward smoking cessation, and perceived behavioral control were taken in two separate waves from current cigarette smokers with varying levels of nicotine dependence (N=151). In the second wave, participants were randomly assigned to one of two groups. In the first group, participants read a smoking cessation message which emphasized the benefits of quitting (positive frame). In the second group participants read a message which emphasized the costs of not quitting (negative frame). Results show that smokers' intentions to quit smoking and their level of nicotine dependence jointly influence the persuasiveness of positive and negative message frames. When nicotine dependence and quitting intention are both high, a negative frame works best. Conversely, a positive frame is preferable when nicotine dependence or quitting intention is low. Smokers' level of processing is proposed as the underlying mechanism explaining the different effects of message frames.     

Perceived barriers to quitting smoking among alcohol dependent patients in treatment

Little is known about the perceived barriers to quitting smoking among alcohol abusers. In addition to the usual barriers perceived by smokers, alcohol dependent smokers may have a few barriers unique to their addictive lifestyle. The Barriers to Quitting Smoking in Substance Abuse Treatment (BQS-SAT) was administered to 96 alcohol dependent smokers in residential substance abuse treatment. The BQS-SAT is designed to assess perceived barriers to quitting smoking among alcohol abusers using eleven true-false items. One open-ended item was included to gather information about potential additional barriers. The majority of respondents reported withdrawal-related barriers such as expecting to feel irritable, anxious, restless, and about half expected intolerable urges to smoke if they were to quit smoking, as most smokers do. However, concerns about effects on sobriety and needing cigarettes to cope with feeling down were also endorsed by almost half of the patients. Total number of perceived barriers was significantly related to smoking history, expected effects from smoking, and smoking temptation but was not associated with severity of alcohol use or dependence on admission. Providing corrective feedback about these barriers could be useful when addressing smoking with patients who have alcohol abuse or dependence.     

What Chinese Adolescents Think About Quitting Smoking: A Qualitative Study

The aim of this study was to investigate the attitudes of Chinese adolescents toward smoking, giving up smoking, and smoking cessation programs presently available. The study was a qualitative study carried out in 2002 by focus groups of 32 male secondary school students in Hong Kong who were either current smokers or had recently given up smoking. Subjects were students (grades 8–10) attending two full-day secondary schools in Hong Kong. Participants did not feel the need to make any serious psychological preparation for quitting. They underestimated the addictive nature of cigarette smoking and felt that they could choose to quit smoking at any time with little difficulty. Several barriers to quitting were reported, including boredom, peer influence, the urge to smoke, school work pressure, the wish to do something with their hands, difficulty in concentrating, and the ready availability of free cigarettes from peers. Those who had attempted to quit smoking (26/32) reported that peer influence and boredom were the main reasons why they started smoking and insisted that willpower and determination could have helped them in their quitting attempt. Participants were unanimous that pressure or encouragement from teachers, parents, or girlfriends did not help them to stay off cigarettes. Most (24/32) of the current smokers knew that smoking cessation services were available in Hong Kong, only 50% (12/24) of those who knew had made use of such services. None of the participants were able to identify any effective way of quitting smoking, though some suggested that the best practical measure was to avoid friends who smoked. The study suggests that attempts to persuade young people to quit smoking might benefit if they were framed to address issues such as the strong influence of their peers, the ease with which tobacco products can be obtained, the casual attitudes of young people toward smoking cessation, the perceived pros and cons of quitting, and (given that underage smoking is frowned upon by many parents and teachers) the need to respect confidentiality when offering support.