Treatment of ragweed hay fever with intranasally administered disodium cromoglycate*

In a double-blind study the therapeutic effect of a 4% disodium cromoglycate (DSCG) nasal solution was evaluated in thirty-nine patients with acute symptoms of ragweed hay fever. Patients were randomly assigned to the DSCG or placebo group as they presented with allergic rhinitis. Overall, the DSCG was not more effective than placebo in controlling the symptoms of rhinitis or in decreasing the need for concomitant antihistamines or corticosteroids. Among patients with the highest pretreatment serum ragweed-specific IgE (RW IgE) levels, drug-treated patients had some reduction in symptoms as compared to their placebo controls during the peak of the ragweed pollen season. DSCG treatment did not influence the usual seasonal rise in RW IgE. Side effects from both the active and placebo aerosols were frequent but mild. We conclude that DSCG nasal solution used for the treatment of seasonal ragweed allergic rhinitis is relatively ineffective.     

Disodium cromoglycate in anaphylaxis and pollinois.

Because disodium cromoglycate is being used in treating the symptoms of allergic patients and its mode of action remains uncertain, morphological experiments were conducted in an attempt to further elucidate this compound's mode of action. Rabbits with an ear chamber underwent anaphylaxis, lethal or sublethal, with microscopic observations of the microcirculation during anaphylaxis. At death or a chosen interval tissue of the ear chamber was secured for histological examination. The mast cells and the state of their granules were counted for each section. In no instance did disodium cromoglycate have any effect in preventing the gross or microscopic changes and disodium cromoglycate did not protect mast cells in passive anaphylaxis. The nasal mucosa of a subject sensitive to ragweed pollen was exposed to ragweed pollen in a non-pollen season and the gross symptoms of hay fever were noted. When the nasal mucosa was pre-treated with disodium cromoglycate, however, no symptoms were observed and biopsies of nasal mucosa showed more normal mast cells and fewer degranulated mast cells.     

A controlled study of the effectiveness of the Rinkel method of immunotherapy for ragweed pollen hay fever

In a double-blind study, we compared the effects of the Rinkel method of immunotherapy with ragweed pollen extract and placebo on symptoms of ragweed hay fever and immunologic parameters in 24 ragweed-sensitive patients. Each had a skin-test end point by Rinkel serial dilution titration to ragweed pollen extract at 1:312,500 w/v or greater dilution, a 2+ skin test to ragweed AgE at 0.1 μg/ml or greater dilution, and in vitro leukocyte histamine release by ragweed pollen extract. None had had immunotherapy for at least 7 yr. Patients matched on the basis of leukocyte histamine release by ragweed were assigned to two treatment groups (12 patients in each group). One group received ragweed pollen extract, and the other, placebo, both administered by the Rinkel method between June and October, 1978. Treatment doses were derived from skin-test end points. The median maintenance (“optimal dose”) for patients receiving ragweed pollen extract was 0.53 ml of 1:312,500 w/v and the mean cumulative dose of ragweed pollen extract given during the study contained 0.094 μg of ragweed AgE. Symptom-medication scores of all patients rose and fell with ragweed pollen counts. No significant differences were observed in mean daily symptom-medication scores, antiragweed IgG or IgE levels, leukocyte histamine release by ragweed, total IgE levels, or skin-test end-point dilutions with ragweed pollen extract between the group receiving ragweed pollen extract and the group receiving placebo. Despite the absence of specific effect on symptom-medication scores and measured immunologic variates, 10 of the 12 ragweed-treated patients and 10 of the 12 placebo-treated patients were of the opinion that their hay fever symptoms during the ragweed pollen season were less severe in 1978 than in 1977 and that they had been helped by Rinkel method immunotherapy. Under the conditions of the study, Rinkel method immunotherapy with ragweed pollen extract was no more effective than placebo given in an imitation of the Rinkel method.     

Sodium cromoglycate in ragweed-allergic conjunctivitis

Sodium cromoglycate (SCG), in a 4% solution instilled into each eye 4 times daily, was compared with placebo in a double-blind, noncrossover trial in 30 matched patients with troublesome ragweed pollen-induced conjunctivitis. In the SCG group, eye symptom scores were significantly less (p = 0.05), and all patients judged that their symptoms were improved over the previous year (p less than 0.05). Less antihistamine was used by the SCG group but the difference was not significant. It was concluded that SCG was effective in the treatment of ragweed-induced seasonal allergic conjunctivitis.     

Oral disodium cromoglycate in the treatment of systemic mastocytosis.

A double-blind crossover study of the efficacy of disodium cromoglycate given by mouth to control the cutaneous, gastrointestinal and central-nervous-system manifestations of systemic mastocytosis was carried out in five patients for periods of eight to 32 months. In 15 of 18 trials, disodium cromoglycate produced marked amelioration of the clinical manifestations of pruritus, whealing, flushing, diarrhea, abdominal pain and disorders of cognitive function. By contrast, in all 19 trials with placebo, there was no improvement in these symptoms and signs. Histaminuria and peripheral-blood eosinophilia were unrelated to disease activity and were unaffected by drug therapy. Although it is poorly absorbed after administration by mouth, disodium cromoglycate is of clinical benefit to patients with systemic mastocytosis.     

A comparative study of the effectiveness of the Rinkel method and the current standard method of immunotherapy for ragweed pollen hay fever

In a double-blind study, we compared the effects of the Rinkel and the current standard methods of immunotherapy with ragweed pollen extract and those of placebo on symptoms of ragweed hay fever and immunologic parameters in 43 patients highly sensitive to ragweed. Each had a skin-test end point by Rinkel serial titration at 1:312,500 w/v or greater dilution, a 2+ skin test to ragweed AgE 0.01 μg/ml, and in vitro histamine release by ragweed pollen extract. None had had immunotherapy for at least 7 yr. Patients were matched on the basis of leukocyte histamine release to ragweed pollen extract and assigned to treatment groups. Fourteen received ragweed pollen extract by the Rinkel method, 14 received placebo, and 15 received ragweed pollen extract by the current standard method weekly between February and October, 1979. Rinkel method doses were derived from skin-test end points and were advanced to 0.5 ml of the end-point dilution; current standard method doses were advanced to the highest tolerated dose. The median maintenance dose for Rinkel method patients was 0.5 ml of 1:1,562,500 w/v (0.001 μg AgE), and for current standard method patients was 0.3 ml of 1:100 w/v (11 μg AgE). An additional unmatched group of nine similar patients received Rinkel method immunotherapy in both 1978 and 1979. Under the conditions of this study, the current standard method of immunotherapy produced a significant decrease in ragweed hay fever symptom-medication scores, increase in antiragweed IgG levels, and decrease in seasonal rise in antiragweed IgE levels in comparison with the effects of either Rinkel method or placebo. The effect of the Rinkel method on these variates was not significantly different from the effects of placebo.     

Preseasonal IgE ragweed antibody level as a predictor of response to therapy of ragweed hay fever with intranasal cromolyn sodium solution.

Intranasal administration of a 4% solution of cromolyn sodium for the treatment of ragweed hay fever was tested in an 8-week double-blind matched-pair study involving 66 patients. Patients on active drug received 5.2 mg into each nostril 6 times daily; control patients received a placebo spray. The treated group showed a significant reduction in mouth breathing (p less than 0.001), stuffy nose (p less than 0.002), runny nose (p less than 0.003), and postnasal drip (p less than 0.035). Patients receiving the active drug also reported fewer sneezing episodes (p less than 0.003) and nose blowing episodes (p less than 0.015). One patient using cromolyn solution developed nasal ulceration, tongue swelling, coughing, and wheezing. Other side effects were minimal and occurred with equal frequency in both groups. In the treated group relief of symptoms was most marked in patients with high preseasonal levels of IgE ragweed antibody. Intranasal 4% cromolyn solution appears to be an effective drug for the treatment of ragweed hay fever; measurement of the preseasonal level of IgE ragweed antibody is a useful screening test to identify patients most likely to achieve a maximal beneficial response to treatment.     

Exercise induced asthma: response to disodium cromoglycate in skin-test positive and skin-test negative subjects

Thirty-nine asthmatic subjects, aged 5-50 and each with a history of exercise-induced asthma, were classified according to their skin response to prick tests using nineteen common antigens. Ten had negative skin tests, four responded only to D. farinae and twenty-five had multiple positive responses. Each patient then carried out three exercise tests on a treadmill, each test on a separate day. A control test was followed, in random order, by an exercise test after administration of disodium cromoglycate or of a placebo. In all groups, the mean fall in peak expiratory flow rate was less after disodium cromoglycate than after placebo, but the difference was significant only for the skin-test positive groups. Similarly, positive skin-test groups had a higher incidence of drug responders than did the negative skin-test group. These observations are discussed.     

Intestinal permeability in irritable bowel syndrome. Effect of diet and sodium cromoglycate administration

We studied 14 patients with irritable bowel syndrome for the presence of increased intestinal permeability to food antigens and their responses to diet with and without disodium cromoglycate. After a standardized oral challenge with cow milk, serum beta-lactoglobulin was increased above control values in three patients. This finding did not correlate with response to hypoallergenic diet or treatment with disodium cromoglycate for 3 weeks. However over 50% of patients improved after diet with and without DSCG (2/5 on diet only and 5/7 with disodium cromoglycate of 12 evaluable cases). Since only two patients had elevated serum IgE levels, our results suggest that intolerance rather than hypersensitivity to foods may play a role in the disease. The tests we used to identify immunologic mechanisms could not predict which patients would do better on the diet and/or the drug.     

Comparison of ketotifen, disodium cromoglycate and placebo in the treatment of adult patients with mild extrinsic asthma

Sixty-four patients with mild or moderate extrinsic asthma were treated with placebo for i month and thereafter with ketotifen (1 mg twice daily, orally), disodium cromoglycate (inhalation of 20 mg, four times daily), or placebo for 2 subsequent months. The trial was performed at four different centres and the treatments were compared using double-blind technique. We found no difference between the effect of ketotifen, disodium cromoglycate and placebo on the patients' daily measurements of evening peak expiratory flow, daily score values for respiratory symptoms or the number of salbutamol puffs required to control symptoms. There was no difference between the treatment groups with regard to the patients' estimates of changes in airway sensitivity to different non-specific stimuli: fumes, tobacco smoke, cold air, and exercise. The only significant effect of DSCG was a minor (4%) increase in the mean morning value for peak expiratory flow. The findings suggest that the addition of ketotifen or disodium cromoglycate to the regimen is unlikely to give further benefit in asthmatic patients, whose symptoms are reasonably well controlled by small doses of bronchodilating drugs.     

Clinical evaluation of intranasal topical flunisolide therapy in allergic rhinitis.

A double-blind, vehicle control, parallel clinical trial evaluated the effectiveness and safety of the local application of flunisolide, a potent new topical steroid, in the treatment of ragweed hay fever. Fifty patients with well-defined, poorly controlled ragweed allergy were studied during the 1974 ragweed season. Analysis of the data showed that the active drug group had a significant decrease in individual symptoms of sneezing, nasal stuffiness, and nasal secretions, compared with the placebo group. Antihistamine usage was statistically decreased in the active drug over placebo group. There was no evidence of adrenal suppression. This study indicates that intranasal administration of flunisolide in adult patients is both efficacious and safe in the treatment of seasonal allergic rhinitis.     

Effect of ragweed hyperimmune human gamma globulin on in vivo and in vitro parameters of ragweed sensitivity.

The effect of ragweed hyperimmune human gamma globulin upon in vitro and in vivo parameters of ragweed sensitivity was examined. In a double-blind study, 40 ragweed sensitive patients were divided into 2 groups and received either ragweed hyperimmune human gamma globulin (treated) or normal pooled globulin (control). Parameters of ragweed sensitivity studied before and following injections of the gamma globulin included skin test and nasal provocation end point titration, specific IgE antibody as measured by the RAST, leukocyte histamine release, total serum ragweed antibody level, and total serum IgE. Changes in measured parameters varied in both groups of patients. In the "treated" patient group, 1 wk later nasal sensitivity decreased significantly, and there was a trend toward decreased histamine release from leukocytes. No discernable effect was noted upon the other parameters. Thus, with the dosage used, the parenterally administered hyperimmune gamma globulin did not influence most measurements of ragweed hypersensitivity. The concept of this therapeutic approach might warrant further investigation.     

A steroid sparing effect of ketotifen in steroid-dependent asthmatics

In a multicentre, double-blind trial, the steroid sparing effect of a new anti-anaphylactic agent ketotifen was assessed against placebo in eighty-six steroid-dependent asthmatics. Mean reduction in total daily prednisolone dosage in patients on ketotifen was 4.0 ± 3.6 mg compared to 1.7 ± 2.8 mg on placebo, a result significantly in favour of the active drug (P <0.01). This suggests that ketotifen has a place similar to that of disodium cromoglycate or steroid aerosols in the managment of steroid-dependent asthmatics. It has the advantage of requiring only twice-daily oral administration.     

A multi-institutional trial of polymerized whole ragweed for immunotherapy of ragweed allergy

Eighty ragweed-sensitive patients in four cities were recruited to study the safety and efficacy of partially purified, polymerized whole ragweed (PRW) as an improved form of immunotherapy. Groups of 20 patients in Chicago, Boston, Memphis, and St. Louis had blood drawn for immunologic studies before and after the 1978 and 1979 ragweed seasons and completed detailed daily symptom score sheets each day of the 1978 and 1979 ragweed pollen seasons. Beginning in March, 1979, all patients except one received 15 weekly injections of PRW totaling 50,000 protein nitrogen units (PNU) and containing about 500 μg ragweed AgE. One patient received 25,000 PNU. Symptom score indices of the posttreatment 1979 season were compared with those from the pretreatment 1978 season and also with the scores of similar groups of ragweed-sensitive patients in each city treated only with medication for symptomatic relief during the 1979 season. Local reactions to polymerized ragweed immunotherapy were minimal. No abnormalities in complete blood count, erythrocyte sedimentation rate, chest x-ray film, urinalysis, or rheumatoid factor occurred in the immunotherapy-treated groups. Total serum antibody binding of ragweed AgE increased 12-fold following immunotherapy. When compared either with their 1978 untreated group scores or when compared with scores from the untreated group in each city in 1979 (control group), the symptom score indices of the immunotherapy-treated groups in 1979 were significantly improved. PRW is efficacious in the treatment of ragweed hay fever and can be administered more safely and in higher doses with fewer injections than conventional extracts. It represents an improved form of immunotherapy.     

Clinical and physiological assessment of asthmatic children treated with beclomethasone dipropionate

Forty-two perennial asthmatic children were selected for a 12-wk study using beclomethasone dipropionate. The groups included 21 steroid-dependent children (Group I and 21 patients (Group II) whose disease was of sufficient severity that corticosteropd therapy was contemplated. All children received the drug in a dose of 100 μg 4 times daily. During the study, oral prednisone was withdrawn from the steroid-dependent children while other therapy was essentially unchanged. Group II children underwent a double-blind trial, receiving beclomethasone for 6 wk and placebo for 6 wk. Objective assessment of adrenal and pulmonary function was obtained at regular intervals. For the latter, total lung capacity and its subdivisions, airways resistance, maximum expiratory flow volume, and oxygen tension, were measured in both groups. In Group II static elastic recoil was measured also. For most tests the results were statistically significant. In both groups, 18 of 21 patients demonstrated an excellent clinical response, no evidence of adrenal suppression, and improvement in pulmonary function. Forty of 42 patients were followed for another 12 wk, and 19 of each group did well. After 20–24 wk of therapy, 16% of patients harbored monilia in their oropharynx, and 1 patient had clinical monilial stomatitis. Within the limits of the time of the study, beclomethasone dipropionate appeared to provide adequate clinical control in many chronic, severe, steroid-dependent and nonsteroid-dependent asthmatic children.     

The clinical and immunologic specificity of immunotherapy

In order to study the specificity of immunotherapy for respiratory allergy, a group of patients sensitive to both ragweed and grass pollens were selected. From 87 volunteers with a history of both spring and fall hay fever, 42 patients with evidence of strong sensitivity by basophil histamine release to both ragweed pollen and mixed grass pollen extracts were selected for study. On the basis of the histamine release data, the patients were divided into two groups matched for sensitivity to both grass and ragweed pollens. In 1970, May and June symptom diaries showed the two groups to suffer quite similar severity of symptoms during the grass pollination season. One group of patients was started on a preseasonal course of immunotherapy with alum-precipitated aqueous extract of ragweed pollen while the other group received placebos containing histamine. By fall there had been a considerable rise in IgG-blocking antibodies to ragweed in the treated group. Symptom diaries in August and September showed that the treated group showed significantly less severe symptoms than the placebo group. Both groups received booster injections at 2-wk intervals from the fall of 1970 to the fall of 1971. Doses in the treated group were raised to attempt to administer the largest possible dose. Again there was no difference in the symptoms reported by the two groups during the grass pollination season, but an even greater difference emerged between the two groups during the ragweed season. The following year 1972 the same results were obtained. These data demonstrate that treatment with ragweed pollen extracts has little or no effect on grass pollen symptoms and confirm that immunotherapy is clinically as well as immunologically specific. Antibody responses to the second year of high-dosage booster injections was not greater than responses to a comparatively short preseasonal course given the first year.     

Preseasonal intranasal immunotherapy with nebulized short ragweed extract

We determined the effect of preseasonal intranasal short ragweed (SRW) immunotherapy in a double-blind, nonpaired, 20-wk study involving 33 SRW-sensitive patients. Patients were selected on the basis of an elevated IgE serum antibody level, a positive intradermal skin test, and a positive intranasal challenge to SRW antigen. SRW-treated patients sprayed SRW solutions intranasally six times a day for 12 wk preseasonally. Placebo-treated patients used nebulized solutions containing buffer or histamine that were interchanged randomly throughout this period. The SRW-treated group reported more preseasonal symptoms than the placebo-treated group (p < 0.003); however, during the SRW pollination season, the SRW-treated group reported significantly less sneezing, nasal congestion, rhinorrhea, red/itchy eyes, itchy nose/throat, and cough/wheeze. Supplemental antihistamine usage was similar in both groups. The treatment did not affect serum IgE antibody levels to crude SRW, AgE, Ra3, or Ra5 in either group at any time during the study. No significant production of IgG antibody to SRW was seen in either group. One SRW-treated patient developed acute sinusitis after 2 wk of treatment; otherwise no side effects other than symptoms of hay fever were noted. Although intranasal SRW immunotherapy may offer an effective and less costly alternative to parenteral immunotherapy, reduction in hay fever symptoms during the pollination season was achieved at the expense of provoking these symptoms during the preceding weeks.     

Effect of lodoxamide ethyl on allergy skin tests

Lodoxamide ethyl is a new cromolyn-like drug which prevents antigen-induced mediator release from mast cells and antigen-induced bronchoconstriction in sensitive animals and man. The purpose of this study was to determine the effect of a single administration of lodoxamide ethyl on allergy skin tests. The effect of this drug on allergy skin testing was studied in a double-blind design on ten adult subjects allergic to ragweed. Serial end-point titrations with short ragweed extract and with histamine were performed after a placebo and 1- and 3-mg capsules of lodoxamide ethyl. The immediate wheal-and-flare responses as well as the late allergic reaction were recorded. No statistically significant difference was found between lodoxamide ethyl and placebo in the suppression of the allergen-induced immediate wheal-and-flare response or the late allergic reaction. Furthermore, 1 and 3 mg of oral lodoxamide ethyl did not inhibit the histamine-induced cutaneous reactions.     

The role of ragweed pollen in autumnal asthma

Thirty-nine ragweed-allergic seasonal asthmatics were studied from 1972 to 1974. After quantitative skin tests, antigen E-induced leukocyte histamine release, quantitative inhalation bronchial challenge with ragweed extract to determine PD35 (provocation dose of allergen causing 35% decrease in specific airways conductance), and radioallergosorbent test (RAST) determinations were done, patients were paired based on PD35 values and randomly assigned to treatment or placebo groups, receiving either aqueous ragweed extract or placebo prior to the 1973 ragweed season. Treated patients received a mean cumulative dose of extract equivalent to 11.7 microng antigen E (4,180 protein nitrogen units [PNU]). Twenty-nine patients were followed through the ragweed season with daily symptom diaries and biweekly physician examinations. Severity of disease was not predictable by PD35 data, skin tests, leukocyte histamine release, or radioallergosorbent test (RAST) values. Although all patients were ragweed-allergic by objective tests, only 13/29 had asthma symptoms correlating with ragweed counts. Mold spore counts were related significantly to symptoms in some patients. Asthma and hay fever symptoms correlated significantly in 24/29 patients. This dose of immunotherapy caused no significant difference to be found in asthma or hay fever symptoms in treated versus placebo patients for the 1973 reporting period as determined by physician evaluations or daily symptom diaries. No patients showed significant improvement in PD35 values after treatment in 1973. Similar findings were obtained for a smaller group of patients followed through the 1974 ragweed season who received a mean dose of 31.2 microng antigen E (11,140 PNU). The failure of these patients to show a response to immunotherapy could be due to a combination of the relatively low dose of ragweed extract and their sensitivity to other allergens.     

Cromolyn sodium nasal solution in the prophylactic treatment of pollen-induced seasonal allergic rhinitis.

A large-scale multicenter investigation was undertaken in 3 cities with comparable pollen seasons and atmospheric pollen concentrations in order to obtain more definite information about the safety and efficacy of cromolyn sodium in the treatment of pollen-induced seasonal rhinitis. The 9-wk double-blind study was conducted in 104 patiets in Pittsburgh, Pa., Cleveland, Ohio, and Louisville, Ky., during the 1975 ragweed season. It indicated that a nebulized 4% aqueous solution of cromolyn sodium is effective in reducing sneezing, rhinorrhea, nasal congestion, and ocular irritation in ragweed hay fever patients. The efficacy of the drug was notable despite the fact that patients used an average of 52 mg instead of the recommended 62.4 mg daily. Cromolyn sodium did not appear to have a significant effect on transseasonal antiragweed IgE (IgEAR) levels. Patients acceptance of the cromolyn nasal solution was good, and there were no significant adverse reactions. The side effects, which were distributed equally between the drug and placebo groups, were mild and of limited duration.