Three cases of panic disorder with agoraphobia in children

The authors report three cases of panic disorder with agoraphobia in children, with characteristic panic attacks, separation anxiety, and fear and avoidance of crowds and public places. The panic and agoraphobic symptoms responded to medications effective with agoraphobic adults, i.e., imipramine and alprazolam.     

Prodromal symptoms in panic disorder with agoraphobia

Of 20 patients suffering from panic disorder with agoraphobia, 18 reported experiencing agoraphobic avoidance, generalized anxiety, and/or hypochondriacal fears and beliefs before the first panic attack. The prevalence of these symptoms in the patients was significantly higher than the prevalence in 20 healthy control subjects. The results indicate that phobic avoidance in panic disorder with agoraphobia may not be secondary to the panic attacks, a finding that runs counter to the current DSM-III-R classification of anxiety disorders.     

Differential drug response of panic and agoraphobic avoidance in a case of panic disorder

A case is presented of a patient with severe panic disorder and agoraphobia in whom initial treatment with clomipramine resulted in complete elimination of panic attacks, with no improvement in agoraphobic avoidance. The addition of phenelzine to the pre-existing clomipramine treatment resulted in rapid and complete disappearance of the agoraphobic avoidance. The possible implications of this case for our understanding of the neurobiological relationship between panic attacks and agoraphobia are discussed.     

The utility of the panic disorder concept

Summary In this paper we discuss the theory that agoraphobic avoidances are central and spontaneous panics an epiphenomenon to the development of agoraphobia. Moreover we discuss the theory that posits a fixed cognitive-catastrophizing set as causal for panic. We conclude these theories do not fit the facts. We argue that it is important to distinguish between spontaneous panic and chronic or anticipatory anxiety and avoidance. Such a distinction allows for an understanding of the roles of anti-spontaneous panic medications such as tricyclics and MAOI's, as well as exposure therapy, in the treatment of panic disorder with agoraphobia. The former serves the purpose of blocking panic attacks while the latter undermines phobic avoidance, but only after the panic attacks have ceased through proper medication. We conclude that recognizing the key role of spontaneous panic and its variants in anxiety nosology is a necessary guide for etiological, psychophysiological and therapeutic research in this rapidly developing area.Parts of this article were presented on the occasion of the inauguration ceremony of the Department of Psychiatry of the University of Mainz on April 2 and 3, 1987     

Derealization and panic attacks: a clinical evaluation on 150 patients with panic disorder/agoraphobia

One hundred fifty patients with Panic Disorder (PD) with or without Phobic Avoidance were subdivided into two groups on the basis of presence/absence of derealization and/or depersonalization (D-D) during panic attacks. D-D was found in 34.7% of the sample. By comparing the two groups, the patients with D-D were found to be younger and had an earlier onset of the disorder; they had a higher prevalence of avoidance behavior and a higher severity of the agoraphobic spectrum phobias. They were also more frequently subject to concomitant disorders such as Generalized Anxiety, Obsessive-Compulsive, and depressive symptomatology. The authors have hypothesized a correlation between the presence of D-D during panic attacks and a more frequent clinical evolution toward agoraphobia. This view is supported by finding that D-D in panic attacks corresponds to severer forms of PD, both in terms of the earlier onset of PD, and because PD shows higher levels of anxiety, depression, and disability.     

Dissemination of Cognitive Therapy for Panic Disorder in Primary Care

This study investigated whether brief training in cognitive therapy for panic disorder (Clark et al., 1994) can improve the outcomes that primary care therapists obtain with their patients. Seven primary care therapists treated 36 patients meeting DSM-IV (APA, 1994) criteria for panic disorder with or without agoraphobia in general practice surgeries. Outcomes for the cohort of patients whom the therapists treated with their usual methods (treatment-as-usual) before the training (N = 12) were compared with those obtained with similar patients treated by the same therapists after brief training and ongoing supervision in cognitive therapy (CT) for panic disorder (N = 24). Treatment-as-usual led to significant improvements in panic severity, general anxiety, and depression. However, only a small proportion (17% of the intent-to-treat sample) became panic free and there was no improvement in agoraphobic avoidance. Patients treated with CT achieved significantly better outcomes on all measures of panic attacks, including panic-free rate (54%, intent-to-treat), and showed significantly greater improvements in agoraphobic avoidance and patient-rated general anxiety. In conclusion, cognitive therapy for panic disorder can be successfully disseminated in primary care with a brief therapist training and supervision programme that leads to significant improvements in patient outcomes.     

The epidemiology of panic symptomatology and agoraphobic avoidance

In a random community survey of 1,498 urban adults age 18 to 64 years who were interviewed using the Diagnostic Interview Schedule (DIS), the lifetime prevalence of panic disorder was 2.2% +/- 0.4%. This was higher in women (3.4% +/- 0.7%) than in men (0.9% +/- 0.6%), and in those under the age of 45 years. Lifetime prevalence for panic attacks was 7.8% +/- 0.7%. Panic attacks and panic disorder had a similar distribution by age and sex, with higher rates in women than men, and also in the under 45 age groups. The panic symptomatology reported by those subjects with panic attacks was similar to that described by subjects meeting full criteria for panic disorder. The lifetime prevalence of phobic disorders was 10.7% +/- 0.9% and was more common in women (14.6% +/- 1.3%) than in men (6.8% +/- 1.3%). The lifetime prevalence of agoraphobia was 3.8% +/- 0.5%. The occurrence of panic attacks and phobic disorders were frequently related, and in agoraphobic subjects those with more severe agoraphobic avoidance reported more panic symptoms. Indeed, among agoraphobic subjects with at least moderate agoraphobic avoidance, nearly all had either panic attacks or major depression. Subjects with panic attacks and moderate agoraphobic avoidance compared with patients with panic attacks alone, especially when panic symptoms appear before the age of 15, are more likely to have grown up in a family where there was parental conflict, are more likely to have left school at a younger age and without school exams, and are likely to have had more symptoms of a childhood conduct disorder.     

Higher postdexamethasone serum cortisol levels in agoraphobic than in nonagoraphobic panic disorder patients

The dexamethasone suppression test (DST) was performed in panic disorder (PD) patients with (n = 32) or without (n = 31) agoraphobia and in normal controls (n = 49). Postdexamethasone serum cortisol levels were significantly higher in agoraphobic PD patients (105.3 +/- 19.3 nmol/L) both when compared to PD patients without agoraphobia (47.3 +/- 7.7 nmol/L; p less than 0.01) and when compared to healthy controls (51.7 +/- 8.3 nmol/L; p less than 0.01). The rate of nonsuppressors (i.e., subjects displaying postdexamethasone cortisol levels greater than 138 nmol/L) was 28% and 3% in agoraphobic and nonagoraphobic PD patients, respectively, and 12% in controls. In patients, the postdexamethasone cortisol levels did not correlate with the number of panic attacks per week, baseline anxiety as measured using the Hamilton Anxiety Scale, depressive symptoms as measured using the Montgomery-Asberg Depression scale, or duration of illness. Data from eight patients in whom a second DST was performed after treatment with imipramine or clomipramine for three months indicate that a marked reduction of the number of anxiety attacks is not necessarily accompanied by a normalization of a pathological DST. In conclusion, it is suggested that the elevated postdexamethasone cortisol levels sometimes observed in agoraphobic PD patients are more closely related to the agoraphobic behavior than to the panic attacks per se.     

Daily life situations and anxiety in panic disorder and agoraphobia

Naturally occuring daily life situations and anxiety experiences were studied in panic-disordered patients with different levels of agoraphobic fear. Time-sampled self-reports of mental state, social context, and setting, obtained with the Experience Sampling Method (ESM), have been compared for panic patients with high scores on the agoraphobia scale of the Fear Questionnaire (n = 19), panic patients with low to medium agoraphobia scores (n = 23), and a normal reference group (n = 20). Panic patients with high agoraphobia scores reported more anxiety than panic patients with limited agoraphobic fear. In general, agoraphobic subjects, as defined by the Fear Questionnaire, demonstrated higher frequencies of being at home and with the family. Panic patients with limited agoraphobic fear reported being alone more often when anxious, while patients with extensive agoraphobia were more often in the company of family members during moments of high anxiety. Individual variations in time-sampled anxiety ratings and time allocation data found in this study challenge the validity of retrospective reports about anxiety and avoidance. These results suggest that further research into anxiety disorders should link experimental and natural environment methods.     

Alprazolam treatment for panic disorders

Office records of 27 private patients who were treated with alprazolam for panic disorders were evaluated by a second psychiatrist. Alprazolam treatment led to a complete remission of panic attacks in 85% of the patients; panics ceased within an average of 6 days, at a mean dose of 2.2 mg/day. In addition, alprazolam was found to bring about a complete absence of phobic avoidance behavior in 21 of the 23 agoraphobic patients in the group. This is the first study to demonstrate the efficacy of medication alone as a treatment for agoraphobia.     

The relationship of panic disorder to agoraphobia

Twenty patients with agoraphobia or panic disorder were compared to each other using multiple variables of clinical illness. No differences were found. Only one of thirteen agoraphobic patients did not experience panic attacks. The agoraphobia symptoms never preceded the panic attacks in those twelve patients experiencing both agoraphobia and panic attacks. This study data and that of others is most consistent with the hypothesis that agoraphobia is a secondary manifestation of panic disorder.     

Comparing panic disorder uncomplicated and panic disorder with agoraphobia in cardiology patients with atypical or nonanginal chest pain

Thirty-eight cardiology patients with either atypical or nonanginal chest pain and current panic disorder were divided into two groups, those with agoraphobia (N = 8) and those without agoraphobia (N = 30). The agoraphobia group reported marginally longer duration of panic disorder (17.0 ± 21.1 years vs. 3.0 ± 3.2 years) and significantly more panic symptoms (10.6 ± 3 vs. 7.3 ± 2.2) during the last major attack. The agoraphobia group also scored significantly higher on measures of anxiety, depression, phobic avoidance, somatization, interpersonal sensitivity, and psychoticism and also scored higher on three of three global measures of distress. This agoraphobia group differed from previously reported agoraphobics with panic attacks in that they all had current panic disorder, while previously reported groups were categorized according to DSM-III, which required only a history of panic attacks. These findings suggest that patients who have current panic disorder and agoraphobia are more symptomatic. Of interest is the low proportion of agoraphobics compared to nonagoraphobics found in this panic disorder population.     

Brief treatment of emergency room patients with panic attacks.

OBJECTIVE: Most research on treatment for panic disorder has involved chronic forms of the illness. To determine the efficacy of early intervention, the authors examined the effects of treatment for patients with panic attacks who were seen in the emergency room, which is the first point of contact with the health delivery system for many persons with panic attacks. METHOD: The subjects were 33 patients with panic attacks seen in two emergency rooms. The presence of panic attacks was confirmed with a modified version of the Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-III-R; approximately 40% of the patients met the DSM-III-R criteria for panic disorder with agoraphobia. The patients were randomly assigned to groups receiving reassurance (N = 16) or exposure instruction (N = 17). Scores on the Fear Questionnaire agoraphobia subscale, Mobility Inventory, and Beck Depression Inventory and the frequency of panic attacks were determined at baseline, 3 months, and 6 months. RESULTS: The subjects who received exposure instruction significantly improved over the 6-month period on depression, avoidance, and panic frequency. The reassurance subjects did not improve on any measure and eventually reported more agoraphobic avoidance. CONCLUSIONS: These results suggest that early intervention with exposure instruction may reduce the long-term consequences of panic attacks. The exposure instruction was of value even though the subjects had relatively low levels of avoidance at the outset of the study.     

DSM-III-R Axis I and II disorders in agoraphobic patients with and without panic disorder

Patients attending an inpatient phobia treatment program were diagnosed for DSM-III-R Axis I and II disorders, using the Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-III-R Disorders, and completed a set of self-report instruments. They were divided into 3 groups: (a) those who met the criteria for panic disorder with agoraphobia (n= 57), (b) those who met the criteria for agoraphobia without a history of panic disorder (n= 21), and (c) those who met criteria for other anxiety disorders, but not for panic/agoraphobia (n= 14). On Axis I, more of the panic with agoraphobia than of the agoraphobia without panic patients had obsessive-compulsive disorder. On Axis II, no significant differences between the agoraphobic patients with and without panic occurred. However, the number of hysterical traits was related to the presence of panic disorder among the agoraphobic patients. Avoidant and dependent traits were related to symptom severity.     

Panic and avoidance in panic disorder with agoraphobia: clinical relevance of change in different aspects of the disorder

Different aspects of change were examined in 62 patients who fulfilled the DSM-IV criteria for a primary diagnosis of panic disorder with agoraphobia of moderate to severe magnitude, and who were treated with 16 sessions of behavioral therapy. The treatment resulted in substantial effects on panic attacks and agoraphobic avoidance. Panic-free status only differentiated the patients regarding mood at pre- and post-treatment. Changes in panic and avoidance were related to each other, but change in avoidance was more related to change in negative affect. Change in quality of life (QOL) was also more associated with change in avoidance at post-treatment. At follow-up change in QOL was more related to change in panic than change in avoidance.     

Clinical Features in Panic Disorder with Agoraphobia: A Comparison of Men and Women

This study compared 96 women and 58 men suffering from panic disorder with agoraphobia. Participants completed questionnaires assessing various clinical features associated with panic disorder with agoraphobia (PDA), general adjustment, and drug/alcohol use. Results showed that PDA is a more severe condition in women. Women reported more severe agoraphobic avoidance when facing situations or places alone, more catastrophic thoughts, more body sensations, and higher scores on the Fear Survey Schedule. Also, women more often had a comorbid social phobia or posttraumatic stress disorder. The lower agoraphobic avoidance of men was associated with their alcohol use. However, there were no differences between genders in other dimensions, including depression, situational and trait anxiety, stressful life events, social self-esteem, marital adjustment, and drug use.     

Onset of panic disorder with agoraphobia. Toward an integrated model

Of 57 patients with panic disorder with agoraphobia, more had their first panic in late spring and summer than in fall and winter, and in warm weather than in cold weather. In the month before the first panic 52% of the patients had prodromal depression or anxiety. Agoraphobic avoidance preceded the first panic in 23%, began within days after the first panic in 32% (without prodromal anxiety or depression in only 20%), and after more than one panic (1 week to 11 years later) in 41%. The site of the first panic was from the agoraphobic cluster (public places) in 81%, at work or school in 11%, and inside the home in 8%. Thirty-eight percent of patients were with a familiar adult at the time. Many features of the syndrome can be explained by an integrated model with several interacting factors contributing in varying degrees to the different routes by which it develops. To the learning and biological factors already suggested we add an evolutionary factor to explain why most first panics occur outside the home and mainly in public places. Certain extraterritorial cues constituting an agoraphobic cluster seem to be prepotent and prepared triggers or modifiers of fear during stress.     

Behavioral aspects of panic disorder

The behavioral approach to panic disorder distinguishes between agoraphobia and nonsituational panic and emphasizes the handicap to the patient caused by avoidance of agoraphobic situations. Agoraphobia is a more viable label than panic disorder. Behavioral treatment consists of delineating the patient's agoraphobic avoidance and panic profile and developing a self-exposure program to produce habituation. Systematic exposure to agoraphobic situations is usually of durable efficacy, and the treatment requires little time from clinicians. Antidepressant drugs, which do not interfere with exposure, are a useful addition when dysphoria is present, but they can have troublesome side effects.     

Agoraphobic behavior and panic attack: a study of male twins

We used data from 3372 pairs of male twins from the Vietnam Era Twin Registry to examine comorbidity and familial influences on the frequently observed association between agoraphobic behavior and panic. Due to low prevalence of DSM-III-R-defined panic disorder, we also examined subjects who had experienced at least one panic attack during their lives. Agoraphobic behavior among individuals with a history of panic attacks showed familial aggregation (odds ratio = 5.7; P = .018 ). Probands with panic attacks and agoraphobic behavior and their co-twins had higher risk of major depression than probands without agoraphobic avoidance and their co-twins (P = .01). Groups did not differ for alcohol dependence or antisocial personality. Agoraphobic behavior associated with panic attack is familial and associated with comorbid major depression. Agoraphobia following panic attack does not seem to reflect severity as agoraphobic behavior in the proband was unrelated to risk of panic attacks in the co-twin.     

Serotonergic modulation of the balance system in panic disorder: an open study

Experimental evidence suggests that panic disorder is characterized by abnormalities in the balance system function and that these abnormalities might be related to the severity of agoraphobic avoidance. Since the balance system can be modulated by the serotonergic system, we investigated the effect of a 6-week treatment with citalopram on the balance system function in patients with panic disorder. Fifteen patients with panic disorder with/without agoraphobia underwent static posturography on days 0 and 42. Static posturography and clinical assessments were carried out by different investigators who were blind to each other. Static posturography showed high percentages of abnormal scores. Patients with no or low agoraphobic avoidance showed less abnormal posturographic measures than those with moderate to severe agoraphobia. After 6 weeks of treatment with citalopram there was a significant decrease of four out of six posturography measures in eyes-closed and neck extension conditions, whereas no significant effect was found in the eyes-open condition. This is the first report that suggests that the modulation of the serotonergic system can improve the balance system function in patients with panic disorder, particularly when visual information is lacking. In addition, our findings confirm the observation that many patients with panic disorder have abnormalities in their balance system function, supporting the idea that these abnormalities are mainly related to agoraphobic avoidance.