Factors affecting symptomatic vs asymptomatic vein graft stenoses in lower extremity bypass grafts

OBJECTIVE: To determine differences in patients undergoing lower extremity vein graft revisions presenting with and without recurrence of preoperative symptoms. DESIGN: Retrospective case-control study of a prospectively maintained database. SETTING: University and veterans' administration hospitals PATIENTS: Two hundred nineteen lower extremity vein graft revisions were performed in 161 patients from January 1995 to January 2007. Patients were categorized as asymptomatic or symptomatic (recurrence of initial symptoms) at the time of revision. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Univariate analysis was performed to assess differences in patient demographics, details of initial operation, site of recurrent lesion, and follow-up surveillance data between symptomatic and asymptomatic patients. Independent predictors of symptomatic recurrence were identified with multivariate logistic regression. Primary assisted patency was compared between revisions performed for symptomatic and asymptomatic lesions. RESULTS: Vein graft stenoses were asymptomatic in 125 cases (57%) and symptomatic in 94 cases (43%). Symptomatic recurrences were associated with a significantly greater drop in ankle brachial index than asymptomatic lesions (mean [SD], 0.21 [0.03] vs 0.11 [0.02]; P = .003). Distal graft or outflow lesions were significantly associated with symptom recurrence (P = .048). Multivariate analysis identified ankle brachial index decrease (odds ratio, 6.803; 95% confidence interval, 1.418-32.258; P = .02) and the use of alternate graft conduit (odds ratio, 2.633, 95% confidence interval, 1.243-5.578; P = .01) as independent predictors of recurrent symptoms. Overall 5-year patency was the same regardless of preoperative symptoms (82% symptomatic and 88% asymptomatic; P = .30). CONCLUSIONS: Symptomatic recurrences are associated with larger decreases in ankle brachial index, distal lesions, and alternate conduit grafts. Duplex surveillance is necessary to identify asymptomatic vein graft stenoses. Because graft patency is independent of preoperative symptoms, surveillance consisting of clinical follow-up with ankle brachial index evaluation warrants further consideration.     

Extra-anatomic bypass grafting in the lower extremity

Between January 1975 and December 1980, 104 extra-anatomic bypasses were performed on 102 patients. Of these, there were 81 femorofemoral bypasses on 80 patients and 23 axillofemoral bypasses on 22 patients. Those who underwent femorofemoral grafting were divided into three groups: group 1 - 18 patients who had undergone previous aortofemoral bypass grafting with occlusion of one limb of the graft, group 2 - 17 patients who were considered to be at high risk and group 3 - 45 patients who could have tolerated a conventional reconstructive procedure. Our results indicate that the cumulative patency rate of the femorofemoral bypass at the end of 1 year and 5 years is good and that this operation is an excellent first choice procedure in cases of unilateral iliac disease, to relieve severe ischemia or disabling claudication, whether the patient is a poor or good operative risk. On the other hand, axillofemoral grafting has a lower patency rate and should be reserved for high-risk patients and for the relief of severe ischemia only.     

The consequences of a failed femoropopliteal bypass grafting: comparison of saphenous vein and PTFE grafts

OBJECTIVES: Although there are numerous reports comparing saphenous vein (SV) and polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) with respect to the patency rates for femoropopliteal bypass grafts, the clinical consequences of failed grafts are not as well described. This study compares the outcomes of failed SV and PTFE grafts with a specific emphasis on the degree of acute limb ischemia caused by graft occlusion. METHODS: Over a 6-year period, 718 infrainguinal revascularization procedures were performed, of which 189 were femoropopliteal bypass grafts (SV, 108; PTFE, 81). Society for Vascular Surgery/International Society for Cardiovascular Surgery (SVS/ISCVS) standardized runoff scores were calculated from preoperative arteriograms. Clinical categories of acute limb ischemia resulting from graft occlusion were graded according to SVS/ISCVS standards (I, viable; II, threatened; III, irreversible). Primary graft patency and limb salvage rates at 48 months were calculated according to the Kaplan-Meier method. RESULTS: Patients were well matched for age, sex, and comorbidities. Chronic critical ischemia was the operative indication in most cases (SV, 82%; PTFE, 80%; P =.85). Runoff scores and preoperative ankle-brachial index measurements were similar for the two groups (SV, 6.0 +/- 2.5 [SD] and 0.51 +/- 0.29; PTFE, 5.3 +/- 2.8 and 0.45 +/- 0.20; P =.06 and P =.12). The distal anastomosis was made below the knee in 60% of SV grafts and 16% of PTFE grafts (P <.001). Grade II ischemia was more likely to occur after occlusion of PTFE grafts (78%) than after occlusion of SV grafts (21%; P =.001). Emergency revascularization after graft occlusion was required for 28% of PTFE failures but only 3% of SV graft failures (P <.001). Primary graft patency at 48 months was 58% for SV grafts and 32% for PTFE grafts (P =.008). Limb salvage was achieved in 81% of SV grafts but only 56% of PTFE grafts (P =.019). CONCLUSIONS: Patients undergoing femoropopliteal bypass grafting with PTFE are at greater risk of ischemic complications from graft occlusion and more frequently require emergency limb revascularization as a result of graft occlusion than patients receiving SV grafts. Graft patency and limb salvage are superior with SV in comparison with PTFE in patients undergoing femoropopliteal bypass grafting.     

Cephalic vein grafts for lower extremity revascularization.

From 1980 to 1989 infrainguinal revascularization was performed with cephalic vein grafts in a consecutive series of 34 patients (35 limbs) whose saphenous veins were either inadequate or already had been harvested for previous coronary (N = 16, 47%) or ipsilateral lower extremity bypass (N = 19, 56%). Surgical indications included ischemic rest pain or focal tissue necrosis in 25 limbs (71%), disabling claudication in six (17%), and popliteal aneurysms or prosthetic femoropopliteal graft infections each in two (6%). Preliminary arteriovenous fistulas were constructed in the arms of 23 patients (68%) to enhance the diameter of their cephalic veins, and 24 (69%) of the 35 infrainguinal procedures in this series were performed with use of cephalic vein alone. The distal popliteal artery was used for the outflow anastomosis in 10 limbs (29%), a tibial vessel was used in 12 (34%), and the peroneal artery was used in 13 (37%). Fourteen graft occlusions (40%) and six amputations (17%) have occurred during follow-up intervals of 1 to 107 months (mean, 28 months; median, 27 months). At 3 years the cumulative primary patency rate is 40%, the secondary patency rate is 46%, and the limb salvage rate is 82%. Despite their relative inconvenience, cephalic vein grafts appear to be preferable to prosthetic materials for infrainguinal revascularization below the knee.     

Choice of autogenous conduit for lower extremity vein graft revisions

BACKGROUND: Surgical revision to repair stenosis is necessary in about 20% of lower extremity vein grafts (LEVGs). Alternate conduit, especially arm vein, is often necessary to achieve a policy of all-autogenous revisions. Although basilic vein harvest necessitates deep exposure in proximity to major nerves, it typically uses a large vein unaffected by prior intravenous lines and as such appears ideally suited for revisions in which a segmental interposition conduit is needed for revision within the graft or for extension to a more proximal inflow or distal outflow site. In this report, we describe our experience with the use of the basilic vein for LEVG revisions compared with other sources of autogenous conduit. METHODS: All patients who underwent LEVG were placed in a duplex scan surveillance program. LEVGs that developed a focal area of increased velocity or uniformly low velocities throughout the graft with appropriate lesions confirmed with angiography were candidates for revision. All patients who underwent graft revision with basilic vein segments from January 1, 1990, to September 1, 2001, were identified, and their courses were reviewed for subsequent adverse events (further revision or occlusion) and complications of harvest. These revisions were compared with revisions in which cephalic and saphenous vein were used. RESULTS: One hundred thirty basilic veins were used to revise 122 LEVGs. The mean follow-up period after revision was 28 +/- 27 months. Ninety-three grafts (71%) remained patent with no further revision, and 37 grafts (29%) either needed additional revisions (22 grafts) or were occluded (15 grafts). Only four of these adverse events (11%) were directly attributed to the basilic vein segment. Ten of 43 grafts revised with cephalic vein (23%) were either revised or occluded, of which three were related to the cephalic vein segment (P = not significant, compared with basilic vein). Twenty-four of 81 grafts revised with saphenous vein (30%) were either revised or occluded, of which 11 were attributed to the saphenous vein segment (P <.01, compared with basilic vein). Two patients (1.5%) had complications from basilic vein harvest (one hematoma, one arterial injury). No neurologic injuries resulted from basilic vein harvest. CONCLUSION: The basilic vein is a reliable and durable conduit when used to segmentally revise LEVGs. Stenoses rarely occur within interposed basilic vein segments, and excellent freedom from subsequent revision or occlusion is possible. We conclude the basilic vein can be safely harvested with minimal complications and is ideally suited for use as a short segment interposition graft for LEVG revision.     

自体大隐静脉旁路术治疗下肢动脉硬化性闭塞症

下肢动脉硬化性闭塞症是血管外科的常见病,目前在治疗上多采用血管移植旁路术进行动脉重建。自体大隐静脉是较常用的旁路材料,主要用于腹股沟以远的动脉重建。由于其取材上的独特优势,在人造材料研制日新月异的今天,仍占有重要地位,并已成为评价其他材料疗效的标准。最早的自体静脉移植试验是由Gluck在1894年报告的,但公认的最早研究为190 6年Carrel和Guthrie成功地用犬的静脉代替颈总动脉和股动脉。190 7年,Lexer在切除1例腋动脉巨大创伤性假性动脉瘤后,用一段10cm大隐静脉作旁路术,虽然病人术后5d死于并发症,但在尸检时发现移植静脉仍然…     

Nonreversed saphenous vein grafts for coronary artery bypass grafting

Between August 1985 and December 1988, valvotomized saphenous vein grafts were used in 365 patients undergoing coronary artery bypass grafting (CABG). In this operation, the femoral end of the vein is attached to the aorta and the pedal end is attached to the coronary artery. Vein diameters measured 8 +/- 2 mm at the femoral end, 4.5 +/- 1.2 mm at the knee level, and 3.5 +/- 1.3 mm at the ankle. Ratios between levels were as follows: knee to femoral end, 0.56, and ankle to femoral end, 0.43. The ratio of knee to femoral end was 0.42 in cases with vein midthigh bifurcation. There were 1,310 grafts implanted (3.6 per patient). In 341 patients, CABG alone was performed, and 24 patients had combined procedures: 11 had CABG with mitral valve replacement, 9 had CABG with aortic valve replacement, 2 had CABG with repair of postinfarct ventricular septal defect, and 2 had CABG with automatic defibrillator implantation. Follow-up (up to 3.5 years) was attained in 97% of patients. For various reasons, 34 patients had a second angiogram between 3 and 41 months postoperatively. Of 120 vein grafts, 108 (90%) were patent. At autopsy, 11 patients with 45 vein grafts had 43 patent and clean grafts and two thrombosed. Use of nonreversed saphenous vein for coronary bypass is recommended. It assures a large proximal anastomosis, natural vein bifurcations can be used with fewer proximal anastomoses, better vein-coronary artery size matching is obtained, and the patency rate is satisfactory.     

Meta-analysis of femoropopliteal bypass grafts for lower extremity arterial insufficiency

BACKGROUND: In femoropopliteal bypass surgery, the use of saphenous vein grafts is preferable, but synthetic grafts are widely used above the knee. The objective of this meta-analysis was to assess the long-term patency of femoropopliteal bypass grafts classified as above-knee polytetrafluoroethylene, above-knee saphenous vein, or below-knee saphenous vein. METHODS: Studies published from 1986 through 2004 were identified from electronic databases and reference lists; 73 articles contributed 1 or more series that used survival analysis, assessed femoropopliteal bypasses in one of the foregoing configurations, reported a 1-year graft patency rate, and included at least 30 bypasses. The series with a predominance of claudicant patients were included in meta-analysis C, and the series in which critical ischemia predominated were included in meta-analysis CI. Pooled survival curves of graft patency were constructed. RESULTS: In meta-analysis C, the pooled primary graft patency was 57.4% for above-knee polytetrafluoroethylene, 77.2% for above-knee vein, and 64.8% for below-knee vein at 5 years; there was a significant difference between above-knee grafts at 3, 4, and 5 years (P < .05). The corresponding pooled secondary graft patency was 73.2%, 80.1%, and 79.7%, respectively (P > .05). In meta-analysis CI, the pooled primary graft patency was 48.3% for above-knee polytetrafluoroethylene, 69.4% for above-knee vein, and 68.9% for below-knee vein at 5 years; there was a significant difference between above-knee grafts until 4 years (P < .05). The corresponding pooled secondary graft patency was 54.0%, 71.9%, and 77.8%, respectively, with a significant difference between above-knee grafts at 2, 3, and 4 years (P < .05). CONCLUSIONS: The great saphenous vein performs better than polytetrafluoroethylene in femoropopliteal bypass grafting and should be used whenever possible.     

Comparative review of early and intermediate patency rates of polytetrafluoroethylene and autogenous saphenous vein grafts for lower extremity ischemia

One hundred nine primary bypass operations were performed on 97 patients who had limb ischemia caused by arteriosclerosis obliterans, over a 32-month period starting in January, 1978. The majority of those procedures were done for rest pain or gangrenous changes. The greater saphenous vein was used whenever possible (44 of 109 procedures), and a polytetrafluoroethylene (Gore-Tex) prosthesis was used in 65 of 109 procedures. Average follow-up was 9.3 months. The cumulative patency rate in all vein grafts was 93.1% at 1 month and 73.4% after 31 months, whereas the cumulative patency rate for polytetrafluoroethylene was 83.3% at 1 month and 51% at 31 months. The difference is not statistically significant (0.10 less than P less than 0.25). In above-knee procedures for claudication, polytetrafluoroethylene performed identically to vein (P greater than 0.50), although vein appeared to perform better in above-knee procedures done for rest pain or necrosis. A limited number of below-knee revascularizations were performed, and although no conclusions of statistical significance can be drawn, cumulative patency of vein appeared to be better than polytetrafluoroethylene. For additional comparative analysis, this study was compared to a previous study in which Dacron was used in femoropopliteal arterial reconstructions. Patency rates in above-knee revascularizations appeared to be comparable in Dacron and polytetrafluoroethylene. Diabetes did not appear to alter age of onset of disease or patency rates, although smokers became symptomatic 10 years earlier than nonsmokers. Although the early and long-term results of arterial reconstructions in the ischemic extremity are known, the availability of new alternate arterial prostheses raises the question of the optimum material depending on the specific clinical circumstances.     

Totally autogenous venovenous composite bypass grafts. Salvage of the almost irretrievable extremity

When a suitable single length of saphenous or arm vein is unavailable, the elderly patient with a profoundly ischemic extremity, poor runoff, and a distal outflow vessel frequently undergoes amputation. Rather than performing primary amputation or resorting to nonautogenous conduites, we used 21 different combinations of available vein segments of ipsilateral or contralateral greater saphenous, lesser saphenous, cephalic, and basilic veins as composite autogenous bypass grafts. Fifty-four extremities, of which 21 (39%) had one or more failed previous bypasses, were revascularized. Tissue necrosis necessitated operation in 74% (40 instances) and rest pain in 19% (ten instances). All grafts extended below the knee, 22% (12 grafts) to the infrageniculate popliteal artery, 78% (42 grafts) to an infrapopliteal runoff vessel, and 28% (15 grafts) to the ankle or foot. The patency rate at one month was 81%. Thrombectomy alone or with local graft repair increased the one-month patency rate to 96%. At one year, the patency and limb salvage rates were 74% and 82%, respectively.     

The lesser saphenous vein: autogenous tissue for lower extremity revascularization

From December 1980 to December 1985, 54 patients underwent 56 lower extremity arterial procedures with the use of lesser saphenous vein (LSV) as graft material. LSV was used in all cases because a satisfactory greater saphenous vein (GSV) was unavailable to accomplish the proposed revascularization. Indications for operation were rest pain, ulceration, and gangrene (74%), and 26% had claudication alone. Fifty of the 56 procedures were femorotibial and femoroperoneal bypasses. Three graft combinations were used: LSV alone (29), lesser saphenous vein and other autogenous vein composites (LSV/AUTO) (14), and lesser saphenous vein with synthetic composite grafts (LSV/SYN) (13). Graft patency rates were determined by life-table analysis. The 3-year patency rate for LSV was 60% and for LSV/AUTO was 38%. LSV/SYN graft composites had a graft patency rate at 18 months of 21%. These data suggest that the LSV may function as an autogenous venous graft for lower extremity revascularization when sufficient GSV is not available.     

Long term results of autogenous vein bypass grafts in femoropopliteal arterial occlusion

The results of 329 consecutive autogenous vein grafts carried out between January 1962 and June 1973 have been reviewed. The 5- and 10-year mortality rates were 14.6 per cent and 18.7 per cent respectively. The corresponding patency rates were 70 per cent at 5 years and 34 per cent at 10 years, the lowest patency (27.8 per cent) occurring in below-knee anastomoses with grafts of 5 mm or less in diameter. As other have noted, the state of the popliteal--tibial run-off vessels had a considerable influence on long term patency rates. In severely ischaemic limbs, the limb salvage rate following this operation was 77 per cent. An analysis of symptoms, associated disease and complications is presented and discussed. No valid conclusions could be made regarding the effect of lumbar sympathectomy and postoperative anticoagulants on long term patency. This review has confirmed the findings of earlier studies that a satisfactory 5-year patency rate and a gratifying limb salvage rate can be achieved with an extremely low operative mortality rate of 0.37 per cent. Despite the presence of widespread atherosclerotic arterial disease, the 5-year mortality rate is 14.6 per cent, indicating that an attempt at reconstructive surgery is usually well worth while.