Survey of hand surgeons’ and therapists’ perceptions of the benefit of common surgical procedures of the hand

Objective: The objectives of this survey were (1) to study if surgeons’ perceptions of the benefit of six surgical procedures differ if they consider themselves as patients instead of treating a patient, (2) to evaluate the role of five predetermined factors that may influence decision-making, and (3) to assess how uniformly hand surgeons and hand therapists perceive the benefits of the surgical treatments.

Methods: The members of the national societies for Hand Surgery and Hand Therapy were asked to participate in the survey. Six patient cases with hand complaint (carpal tunnel syndrome, flexor tendon injury, dorsal wrist ganglion, thumb amputation, boxer’s fracture, and mallet fracture) and a proposed operative procedure were presented, and the respondents rated the procedures in terms of the expected benefit. Half of the surgeons were advised to consider themselves as patients when filling out the survey.

Results: A survey was completed by 56 surgeons (61%) and 59 therapists (20%). Surgeons who considered themselves as patients had less confident perception on the benefit of carpal tunnel release compared with surgeons, who considered treating patients. Hand surgeons and hand therapists had similar perception of the benefits of surgery. The expected functional result was regarded as the most important factor in directing the decision about the treatment.

Conclusions: Surgeons tended to be more unanimous in their opinions in cases, where there is limited evidence on treatment effect. The agreement between surgeons and therapists implies that the clinical perspectives are similar, and probably reflect the reality well.     

Dupuytren’s disease of the radial side of the hand

Dupuytren’s disease with involvement of the radial aspect of the hand is a clinical entity, which affects the thumb, the first web space, and the index finger. It can be primary or secondary. The palmar fascia anatomy and the clinical aspects of radial Dupuytren’s disease are described. The authors propose a new classification, which has the advantage in requiring only a clinical evaluation. One hundred and fifteen patients were examined for Dupuytren’s disease with radial involvement, primary or secondary, in the Hand Surgery Unit of the University of Modena between 1985 and 1994. Eighty-two (68.3%) of them were treated surgically as hand function was compromised by first web retraction. The most commonly used incisions of the first commissure are straight-line with Z-plasties or the Hirschowitz incision; either a zigzag incision or a Bruner incision is made over the thumb or index finger; Z-plasties described by Iselin are reserved for patients with severe contraction of the index finger. Results were assessed by improvement coefficient, calculated as the ratio of the difference between preoperative and postoperative scores to postoperative scores. Generally, Dupuytren’s disease with radial prevalence is not aggressive and progresses slowly and may be exclusively radial or associated with ulnar disease. In other patients, as the disease progresses, loss of function becomes apparent owing to retraction in adduction of the first commissure and flexion contracture of the thumb or index finger.     

Angiomyoma of the hand: a post-traumatic tumor?

A 69-year-old woman presented with a tumor of the lateral aspect of the proximal phalanx of the little finger of the right hand. The finger was injured by a ring during a handshake. Excision and histopathological examination revealed the diagnosis of angio-myoma, a benign vascular tumor originating from the smooth muscle cells of arterial or venous walls. Angiomyomas belong to the family of leiomyomas and rare, small tumors (less than one centimeter), preferentially occurring in women between the ages of 40 and 60 years. They may be painful. Only one case of sarcomatous degeneration has been described in the literature. Trauma has never been previously reported as a cause of angio-myoma, but in this case the traumatic origin of the tumor was not in doubt.     

Eating out of the hand,maggots – Friend or foe?

The presence of maggots (fly larvae) in an open wound is a repelling sight to many and documented cases of myiasis in the literature are scant due to the rarity of such infestation in live patients. A unique case of such a presentation is elaborated in a patient who sustained a crush injury to the hand. This case serves to highlight the unique challenges faced in treating such injuries and to raise the profile of maggots and their untapped potential use in biodebridement and management of open wounds in modern day wound care practices.     

Chondrosarcoma of the hand: is a wide surgical resection necessary?

Chondrosarcomas of the hand are rare and generally treated with surgical resection. Thirteen patients with Grade 1 chondrosarcoma of the small bones of the hand were followed up for a mean of 99.8 months (range, 26-293 months). In eight patients (Group 1) curettage and reconstruction with cancellous bone was done and in five patients (Group 2) a wide resection was done. No patient experienced relapse in Group 2. In Group 1 one patient had a local relapse 18 months after intralesional resection. Using the Musculoskeletal Tumor Society score for evaluation, the clinical results showed an average of 98% and 95% of the normal function in Groups 1 and 2, respectively. None of the patients had evidence of systemic spread of the disease. With a relapse rate of 12.5% and no distant metastases after curettage, intralesional resection is the preferred method of treatment in Grade 1 chondrosarcoma of the hand, allowing the patient to avoid amputation and major loss of function.     

The oldest reported mirror hand? The curse of the coal-house frog!

Despite being one of the rarest congenital upper limb abnormalities, a wide spectrum of the typical mirror hand has been described in the literature. We report a very interesting case of a new variant of mirror hand presenting in a 78-year-old man. The unique features of the case include the age at diagnosis, the anatomical features present and the acquired function despite no form of reconstructive surgery.     

“Puffy hand syndrome”

Intravenous drug addiction is responsible for many complications, especially cutaneous and infectious. There is a syndrome, rarely observed in rheumatology, resulting in “puffy hands”: the puffy hand syndrome. We report two cases of this condition from our rheumatologic consultation. Our two patients had intravenous drug addiction. They presented with an edema of the hands, bilateral, painless, no pitting, occurring in one of our patient during heroin intoxication, and in the other 2 years after stopping injections. In our two patients, additional investigations (biological, radiological, ultrasound) were unremarkable, which helped us, in the context, to put the diagnosis of puffy hand syndrome. The pathophysiology, still unclear, is based in part on a lymphatic toxicity of drugs and their excipients. There is no etiological treatment but elastic compression by night has improved edema of the hands in one of our patients.