Hepatocyte transplantation: clinical experience and potential for future use

Hepatocyte transplantation has been proposed as a method to support patients with liver insufficiency. There are three main areas where the transplantation of isolated hepatocytes has been proposed and used for clinical therapy. Cell transplantation has been used: 1) for temporary metabolic support of patients in end-stage liver failure awaiting whole organ transplantation, 2) as a method to support liver function and facilitate regeneration of the native liver in cases of fulminant hepatic failure, and 3) in a manner similar to gene therapy, as a "cellular therapy" for patients with genetic defects in vital liver functions. We will briefly review the basic research that leads to clinical hepatocyte transplantation, the published clinical experience with this experimental technique, and some possible future uses of hepatocyte transplantation.     

Engraftment measurement in human liver tissue after liver cell transplantation by short tandem repeats analysis

Hepatocyte transplantation has been proposed as a technique for bridging patients to whole-organ transplantation, for providing metabolic support during liver failure, and for replacing whole-organ transplantation in certain metabolic liver diseases. Assessment of hepatocyte engraftment has been difficult to measure, and the degree of engraftment needed to correct various liver disorders is still unknown. A sensitive, simple, and specific method of monitoring engraftment of transplanted hepatocytes for the purpose of bridging human liver failure to native regeneration using short tandem repeats (STRs) was evaluated. The analytical sensitivity of the test was evaluated using DNA mixing curves and established as 0.5% (percentage of donor DNA/ recipient DNA). Sex-matched and mismatched cases were included during the validation. The clinical evaluation of the assay was performed using liver samples from two patients who underwent hepatocyte transplantation. We concluded from this study that the AmpFLSTR Profiler Plus PCR Amplification Kit, a well-established technique in forensic medicine, is specific, sensitive, and a reproducible assay for measurement of engraftment after hepatocyte transplantation in both sex-matched and sex-mismatched cases.     

Monitoring of Intrasplenic Hepatocyte Transplantation for Acute-on-Chronic Liver Failure: A Prospective Five-Year Follow-Up Study

Background

Acute-on-chronic liver failure (ACLF) is defined as an acute deterioration of chronic liver disease. Intrasplenic hepatocyte transplantation is increasingly recognized as a treatment for liver failure and genetic metabolic liver diseases. We describe our experience of intrasplenic hepatocyte transplantation in a small cohort of patients as bridge therapy or as an alternative to orthotopic liver transplantation (OLT).

Methods

Seven patients with ACLF with an expected survival of less than 8 weeks were enrolled into the study. The donor hepatocytes were collected from 2 healthy males and cryopreserved. Donor hepatocytes were transplanted into the spleen of recipients via catheterization of the femoral artery. All patients were followed up for 5 years or to death.

Results

A total of (4.2–6.0) × 10¹⁰ hepatocytes were harvested from the 2 donors' livers and their survival after recovery from the frozen stock was 63% ± 2.8% and 73.5% ± 3.2%, respectively. Following intrasplenic hepatocyte transplantation, 3 patients fully recovered from liver failure, 1 survived and subsequently underwent OLT, and the remaining 3 patients died between 2.5 and 12 months after intrasplenic hepatocyte transplantation. At month 48 post–intrasplenic hepatocyte transplantation, living hepatocyte signals were observed in the spleen using magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) with gadobenate dimeglumine (Gd-BOPTA).

Conclusions

Intrasplenic hepatocyte transplantation is a promising therapy for liver failure that may reduce mortality rates among patients with end-stage liver disease awaiting OLT. Conceivably, intrasplenic hepatocyte transplantation may be considered an alternative to OLT for patients with acute liver failure. MRI (Gd-BOPTA) is a useful tool for detecting living hepatocytes in the spleen after intrasplenic hepatocyte transplantation.     

Bioartificial liver support devices: historical perspectives

Fulminant hepatic failure (FHF) is an important cause of death worldwide. Despite significant improvements in critical care therapy there has been little impact on survival with mortality rates approaching 80%. In many patients the cause of the liver failure is reversible and if short-term hepatic support is provided, the liver may regenerate. Survivors recover full liver function and a normal life expectancy. For many years the only curative treatment for this condition has been liver transplantation, subjecting many patients to replacement of a potentially self-regenerating organ, with the lifetime danger of immunosuppression and its attendant complications, such as malignancy. Because of the shortage of livers available for transplantation, many patients die before a transplant can be performed, or are too ill for operation by the time a liver becomes available. Many patients with hepatic failure do not qualify for liver transplantation because of concomitant infection, metastatic cancer, active alcoholism or concurrent medical problems. The survival of patients excluded from liver transplantation or those with potentially reversible acute hepatitis might be improved with temporary artificial liver support. With a view to this, bioartificial liver support devices have been developed which replace the synthetic, metabolic and detoxification functions of the liver. Some such devices have been evaluated in clinical trials. During the last decade, improvements in bioengineering techniques have been used to refine the membranes and hepatocyte attachment systems used in these devices, in the hope of improving function. The present article reviews the history of liver support systems, the attendant problems encountered, and summarizes the main systems that are currently under evaluation.     

Trasplante celular hepático: un nuevo tratamiento en las enfermedades hepáticas

Liver transplantation has been remarkably effective in the treatment in patients with end-stage liver disease. However, disparity between solid-organ supply and increased demand is the greatest limitation, resulting in longer waiting times and increase in mortality of transplant recipients. This situation creates the need to seek alternatives to orthotopic liver transplantation.Hepatocyte transplantation or liver cell transplantation has been proposed as the best method to support patients.The procedure consists of transplanting individual cells to a recipient organ in sufficient quantity to survive and restore the function. The capacity of hepatic regeneration is the biological basis of hepatocyte transplantation. This therapeutic option is an experimental procedure in some patients with inborn errors of metabolism, fulminant hepatic failure and acute and chronic liver failure, as a bridge to orthotopic liver transplantation.In the Hospital La Fe of Valencia, we performed the first hepatocyte trasplantation in Spain creating a new research work on transplant program.     

肝细胞移植的新进展

肝细胞移植是继肝移植之后的针对肝功能衰竭的又一有效治疗手段,同时也可以作为急性肝功能衰竭患者等待行肝移植之前的一种桥接治疗手段.与肝移植相比,肝细胞移植具有创伤小、排异反应低等优点,但肝细胞移植同样受到供体短缺的制约.肝细胞移植能否作为一种临床广泛应用的治疗手段主要取决于肝细胞的数量和质量以及合适的移植部位,这方面研究在我国尚未受到充分的重视,因此,本文对肝细胞移植的基础研究与临床应用的新进展作一综述.     

Liver bridging techniques in the treatment of acute liver failure.

The introduction of orthotopic liver transplantation in the management of acute liver failure has dramatically increased the survival rates of patients at the cost of removing the patient's native liver and life-long dependence on immunosuppression. However, it is well known that in many patients with acute liver failure the diseased liver has the potential to recover. Death in these patients is often due to increased intra-cranial pressure or infection. Liver bridging techniques are assigned to temporarily provide liver function and enable the native liver to recover in patients with acute liver failure. They represent an attractive alternative to conventional liver transplantation in the management of acute liver failure, since after recovery of the native liver the patient is freed from immuno-suppression with all associated side-effects and risks. Auxiliary liver transplantation, artificial liver support devices and hepatocyte transplantation represent different ways of bridging liver function in acute liver failure. The aim of this review is to present the ideas and principles of these three different liver bridging techniques. We will discuss the relative importance and the future potential of theses bridging techniques in the treatment of acute liver failure by comparing the experimental and clinical results.     

Hepatic Assist: Present and Future

Fulminant hepatic failure due to acute massive liver cell necrosis is a complex pathophysiological entity, and treatment is still unsatisfactory. Artificial liver supports such as hemodialysis, hemoperfusion, and plasmapheresis have recently been used clinically to treat fulminant hepatic failure. However, survival rate has not improved as expected, although the consciousness of the patient has improved frequently. In this article the present status of clinical artificial liver support and basic research of hybrid artificial liver will be discussed. Moreover, the future aspects of total artificial liver support and hepatocyte transplantation for chronic liver failure will be introduced.     

Hepatocyte transplantation: a review of worldwide clinical developments and experiences

Hepatocyte transplantation is a promising treatment for several liver diseases and can also be used as a "bridge" to liver transplantation in cases of liver failure. Although the first animal experiments with this technique began in 1967, it was first applied in humans in 1992. Clearly, the most important advantage of this treatment, compared with liver transplantation, is its simplicity, since no surgery is required for implantation of the cells. Much work has been done over the years to maximize the number of viable hepatocytes that can be isolated from a liver, to prepare the cells prior to transplantation so that the outcome will be more successful, and to identify the optimal site for implantation. We review these efforts along with the worldwide clinical experience with hepatocyte transplantation during the last 13 years.     

Hepatic tissue engineering for adjunct and temporary liver support: critical technologies.

The severe donor liver shortage, high cost, and complexity of orthotopic liver transplantation have prompted the search for alternative treatment strategies for end-stage liver disease, which would require less donor material, be cheaper, and less invasive. Hepatic tissue engineering encompasses several approaches to develop adjunct internal liver support methods, such as hepatocyte transplantation and implantable hepatocyte-based devices, as well as temporary extracorporeal liver support techniques, such as bioartificial liver assist devices. Many tissue engineered liver support systems have passed the "proof of principle" test in preclinical and clinical studies; however, they have not yet been found sufficiently reliably effective for routine clinical use. In this review we describe, from an engineering perspective, the progress and remaining challenges that must be resolved in order to develop the next generation of implantable and extracorporeal devices for adjunct or temporary liver assist.     

Three different hepatocyte transplantation techniques for enzyme deficiency disease and acute hepatic failure

The effects of three different techniques of hepatocyte transplantation were investigated: transplantation of free hepatocytes into the spleen and intraperitoneal transplantation of microcarrier-attached hepatocytes or of microencapsulated hepatocytes. The liver-supportive functions of these transplanted hepatocytes were analyzed using either the Gunn rat (hyperbilirubinemia) or rats with acute liver failure. In the Gunn rat intraperitoneal transplantation of microcarrier-attached hepatocytes resulted in a significant reduction of plasma bilirubin for 28 days whereas intraperitoneal transplantation of microencapsulated hepatocytes was ineffective notwithstanding immunosuppression by cyclosporin A. Intrasplenic hepatocyte transplantation was only effective in reducing plasma bilirubin for 14 days. During acute liver failure, liver support was achieved temporarily by hepatocyte transplantation in the spleen, by intraperitoneally transplanted microcarrier-attached hepatocytes, and by microencapsulated hepatocytes to equal extents, the microencapsulated hepatocytes being the least effective after 8 h of liver ischemia.     

Human hepatocyte transplantation for acute liver failure: state of the art and analysis of cell sources

Liver transplantation is the only treatment available for acute liver failure. However, mortality rates remain high because of the shortage of donor organs. Indeed up to 20% of patients with acute liver failure may survive without transplantation. In the last two decades, research has focused on the development of alternative or supportive measures to deal with acute liver failure; one of the most studied is hepatocyte transplantation, because it is thought that the function of the liver can only be replaced with a biological substrate characterized by functioning liver cells. Hepatocyte transplantation has been successful in many animal models of acute liver failure, although only several clinical attempts have been made in humans with encouraging but not yet convincing results, mainly because of the lack of a reliable source of live liver cells. Allogenic and xenogenic fresh or cryopreserved hepatocytes have been tested. Recent research has focused on fetal hepatocytes and progenitor liver cells of both hepatic and bone marrow origin. The ability to preserve and bank human hepatocytes would allow pooling of cells from multiple donors to increase the numbers for transplantation. The development of a reliable and large-scale available source of live liver cells would probably have a major impact on the introduction of hepatocyte transplantation in clinical practice.     

Bioengineering of liver assist devices

Over 30 000 patients die annually in the United States from liver failure. In fulminant hepatic failure, a clinical syndrome associated with high mortality, orthotopic liver transplantation is the primary therapeutic option for patients not responding to supportive therapy. However, the persistent scarcity of donor organs has limited this therapeutic modality, resulting in a continued increase in the number of patients who die waiting for a donor liver. An extracorporeal bioartificial liver device could provide vital support to a liver failure patient until a donor liver was available or until the patient's own liver regenerated. Although it is unclear which liver-specific functions must be provided by such a device to be effective, a constant challenge has been to obtain stable, well-differentiated, and normally functioning hepatocytes that can be cultured at high cell densities. Many of the devices currently undergoing clinical trials are limited by designs which are prone to substrate limitations, resulting in compromised hepatocyte function. In devices that avoid substrate limitations, hepatocyte functions can be optimized, thereby leading to increased device efficiency. In this overview, the authors describe the critical issues involved in bioartificial liver development and discuss their experiences in hepatocyte culture optimization within the context of a microchannel, flat-plate bioartificial liver device with an internal membrane oxygenator. Received: March 20, 2002 / Accepted: April 15, 2002 Acknowledgment. The authors thank Dr. Harihara Baskaran for the preparation of Figure 2. This work was partially funded by grants from the National Institutes of Health (DK43371) and The Whitaker Foundation. Offprint requests to: M. Toner     

Auxiliary Liver Transplantation and Bioartificial BridgingProcedures in Treatment of Acute Liver Failure

The aim of this review is to discuss the place of auxiliary liver transplantation (ALT) and other cellular based bridging procedures such as hepatocyte transplantation, ex vivo liver perfusion, and bioartificial livers, in the treatment of acute liver failure, vis à vis conventional orthotopic liver transplantation. Hepacocyte transplantation, and ex vivo pig or human liver perfusion are still experimental procedures. Bioartificial livers using human tumoral hepatocytes or porcine hepatocytes have been used in clinical situations as a bridge to transplantation, i.e. to gain the time required to find a high-quality graft for conventional or auxiliary liver transplantation. None of these techniques have yet proved capable of keeping a patient alive long enough for the native liver to recover. Conversely, ALT has been shown to be effective in the treatment of acute liver failure and now appears to be a satisfactory bridging procedure pending native liver (NL) regeneration. We report personal experience of 18 ALT procedures performed in 17 patients between October 1992 and December 1999. The ALT procedure was indicated when patients met criteria for conventional transplantation; it was ultimately selected when a fresh frozen biopsy of the NL did no show any fibrosis. Six patients died within the first 2 postoperative months. The remaining 11 patients are alive, with a follow-up ranging from 2 to 7 years. Regeneration of the NL occurred in 11 of the 17 patients (65%) and in 8 of the 11 survivors (72%), 6 of whom have permanently stopped immunosuppressive therapy. We conclude that liver failure should no longer be handled outside centers where all types of transplantation can be offered, and where innovative therapies such as hepatocyte transplantation and extracorporeal liver-assist devices are being developed and evaluated.     

Human hepatocyte transplantation: worldwide results

The conception and animal modeling of hepatocyte transplantation along with a partial listing of human hepatocyte infusions over the last 13 years have been detailed in authoritative reviews. However, to adequately best represent the worldwide effort of moving from highly successful clinical solid liver transplants "back to" isolated hepatocyte therapy requires repeating important concepts with explanations of how or why not animal experimental data translate to human experience. This overview summarizes 78 human clinical hepatocyte transplant experiences authenticated by the authors. The human cell infusion experiences are categorized by liver disease treated (metabolic, chronic, and acute liver failure), and these are accompanied by seminal in vitro and in vivo experimental data.     

肝细胞分离技术的研究进展

肝细胞移植在治疗急性肝衰竭和遗传代谢性肝病等方面有着十分广阔的应用前景。但肝细胞分离技术仍不完善,需进行深入研究和探讨,以提高细胞的活性和数量,保留细胞功能。文章就肝细胞基本的分离方式及主要实验物种的相关分离方法的进展进行综述。     

Isolated hepatocytes and their potential therapeutic use

Isolated hepatocytes in culture represent an idoneous system for the study of liver physiology and metabolism. Furthermore, they are also widely utilized in pharmacological and toxicological study, in evaluating xenobiotic substance effects on the liver. In this paper, we reviewed the enzymatic methods for liver cell isolation in some mammalian species, as well as the techniques for qualitative and quantitative evaluation of cell number, vitality, purity, morphology and function. Recently, there has been a renewed interest in hepatocyte transplantation and hepatocyte-based liver support systems. From a clinical point of view, isolated hepatocytes could be useful in temporarily substituting an acutely damaged liver, a liver affected by a chronic pathology, or to correct an inherited liver disease carrying a severe metabolic derangement. Early experimental results of allogeneic hepatocyte transplantation, as well as the first clinical trials of bioartificial liver support systems employing xenogeneic hepatocytes are promising and contribute to maintain that interest in liver cell isolation and purification methods.     

Extracorporeal liver perfusion system for successful hepatic support pending liver regeneration or liver transplantation: a pre-clinical controlled trial.

BACKGROUND: There is a well recognized need for a system capable of providing effective support for patients with hepatic failure pending liver regeneration or liver transplantation. Recent attempts of using bioartificial liver containing encapsulated porcine hepatocytes, the deployment of emergency whole liver, or hepatocyte transplantation are complex and not consistently successful. The technique of ex vivo hepatic perfusion developed and used clinically by Abouna in the 1970s, has now been redesigned in a perfusion circuitry that mimics the physiological conditions of a normal liver. Before clinical application of this system, a preclinical trial was carried out in dogs with induced hepatic failure. METHODS: Acute hepatic failure was induced in dogs by an end-to-side porto caval shunt, followed 24 hr later, by a 2-hr occlusion of the hepatic artery. All animals (n=18) were medically supported and were divided into three groups. In the control group (n=6) only medical support was used. In the experimental group (n=12) the animals were connected to the ex vivo liver support apparatus during acute hepatic failure via an AV shunt using a dog liver (n=6) or calf liver (n=6) (after a temporary extracorporeal bovine kidney transplant to remove preformed xeno antibody). Hepatic perfusion was carried out at 37 degrees C through the hepatic artery and portal vein at physiological pressures, and blood flow rate for 6-8 hr. RESULTS: All control animals died of progressive hepatic failure at 14-19 hr after clamping the hepatic artery. The animals treated with ex vivo liver showed remarkable clinical and biochemical improvement. Five animals survived for 36-60 hr. Another seven animals recovered completely and became long-term survivors with biochemical and histological evidence of regeneration of their own liver. Biopsy of the allogeneic ex vivo liver at the end of perfusion showed some interstitial edema. Similar biopsy of the xenogeneic calf liver showed only mild and delayed xenograft rejection, which was most likely due to removal of preformed xeno antibody by temporary transplantation of the calf kidney before liver perfusion. CONCLUSIONS: The observations and results obtained in this trial strongly confirm that extracorporeal perfusion through a whole liver, using the system described, is very successful and cost effective for the treatment of acute, but reversible hepatic failure, as well as serving as a bridge to liver transplantation. The time has come for this form of liver support technology to be reintroduced and widely used.     

Development of a hybrid bioartificial liver.

OBJECTIVE: The authors developed an extracorporeal liver support system and tested its efficacy in experimental animals with liver failure. The first clinical use of this system to treat a patient with liver failure is reported. SUMMARY BACKGROUND DATA: Multiple attempts have been made, ranging from plasma exchange to use of charcoal columns, to develop liver support systems for treating patients with acute severe liver failure. None of these systems has achieved wide clinical use. There is a need for providing liver support as a "bridge" to transplantation and for treating patients with potentially reversible liver dysfunction. METHODS: A hybrid liver support system has been developed consisting of plasma perfusion through a charcoal column and a porous hollow fiber module inoculated with 5 x 10(9) matrix-attached hepatocytes. The system was tested in dogs with ischemic liver failure (n = 7) who underwent plasmapheresis; a control group (n = 6) underwent charcoal perfusion alone. A patient with liver failure was treated with this hybrid system. RESULTS: After 6 hours of hybrid liver support treatment, animals had significantly decreased serum ammonia and lactate levels, increased glucose level, normal prothrombin time, and increased systolic blood pressure compared with controls treated with charcoal perfusion alone. Use of the system to treat a patient was well tolerated with evidence of clinical improvement. CONCLUSIONS: Plasma perfusion through a system consisting of a charcoal column and matrix-attached porcine hepatocytes had significant beneficial effects in animals with liver failure and was well tolerated by a patient with liver failure.     

Use of mammalian liver cells for artificial liver support

Advances in orthotopic liver transplantation have improved the survival rate of both acute and chronic liver failure patients to nearly 70%. However, the success of this treatment modality has created an international organ shortage. Many patients die while awaiting transplantation in part due to the minimal capacity to store viable transplantable livers beyond 24 h. Additionally, for many areas of the world, routine use of whole liver transplantation to treat liver disease is impractical due to the demands on both financial and technical resources. Potentially, these issues may be alleviated, at least in part, by the use of liver cell transplantation or cellular-based liver assist devices. The well-documented regenerative capacity of the liver may obviate the need for whole organ transplantation in some instances of acute failure, if the patient may be provided temporary metabolic support. Although other patients ultimately may require transplantation, a longer period of time to find a suitable organ for transplantation may be gained by that supportive therapy. The field of liver cell transplantation may offer solutions to patients with inherited metabolic deficiencies or chronic liver disease. The potential to treat an hepatic disorder by using only a fraction of the whole liver would increase the number of whole organs available for orthotopic liver transplantation. Research in the fields of hepatocyte based intra-and extracorporeal liver support is providing evidence that these therapeutic modalities may ultimately become routine in the treatment of severe liver disease. A historic overview of that technology along with its current status is discussed.