Need for occlusal therapy and prosthodontic treatment in the management of temporomandibular disorders. Part II: Tooth loss and prosthodontic treatment

The second part of this review, evaluating the literature on the relationship between dental occlusion and temporomandibular disorders (TMDs), focuses on the aetiological importance of tooth loss and the place of prosthodontic replacement in the treatment of TMD. Loss of teeth and lack of posterior occlusal support seem to have little influence on the development of TMD, which calls into question the use of prosthodontic restoration as prevention or treatment for TMD. In addition, there are practically no studies assessing the benefit of instrumental analysis in diagnosis or comparing the outcome of prosthodontic treatment with simple reversible methods in the management of TMD. There is a trend in the current literature to abandon any treatment, including positioning appliances and prosthodontic measures, to 'recapture the disk' in patients with disk displacements because of the favourable, long-term results achieved after using more simple methods. It is concluded that prosthetic therapy in TMD patients is not appropriate for initial TMD treatment and should only be carried out on prosthodontic indications after reversible treatment has alleviated pain and dysfunction.     

Occlusal adjustment for treating and preventing temporomandibular joint disorders

To assess the effectiveness of occlusal adjustment (OA) for treating temporomandibular disorders (TMD) in adults and preventing TMD. The Cochrane Controlled Trials Register, MEDLINE and EMBASE were comprehensively searched using the Cochrane methods. Reports and review articles were retrieved. Unpublished reports or abstracts were considered from the SIGLE database. All randomized or quasi-randomized controlled trials comparing OA with placebo, reassurance or no treatment in adults with TMD. The outcomes were global measures of symptoms, pain, headache and limitation of movement. Data collection and analysis followed the Cochrane Oral Health Group's statistical guidelines. Results showed no difference between OA and control group in symptom-based outcomes for treatment or incidence of symptoms for prevention. There is no evidence that OA treats or prevents TMD. OA cannot be recommended for the management or prevention of TMD. Future trials should use standardized diagnostic criteria and outcome measures when evaluating TMD.     

An evidence-based assessment of occlusal adjustment as a treatment for temporomandibular disorders.

STATEMENT OF PROBLEM: Occlusal adjustment therapy has been advocated as a treatment modality for temporomandibular disorders. In contrast to this position, a panel at the 1996 National Institute of Health technology assessment conference on TMD indicated that no clinical trials demonstrate that occlusal adjustment is superior to noninvasive therapies. PURPOSE: This article summarizes the published experimental studies on occlusal adjustments and temporomandibular disorders. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Eleven research experiments involving 413 subjects with either bruxism (n = 59), temporomandibular disorders (n = 219), headaches and temporomandibular disorders (n = 91), or chronic cervical pain (n = 40) were selected for critical review from the English dental literature. RESULTS: Three experiments evaluated the relationship between occlusal adjustment and bruxism. Six experiments evaluated occlusal adjustment therapy as a treatment for patients with primary temporomandibular disorders. One experiment looked at occlusal adjustment effect on headache/temporomandibular disorder symptoms; another looked at its effect on chronic neck pain. Most of these experiments used a mock adjustment or a comparison treatment as the control condition in adults who had an existing nonacute general temporomandibular disorder. Overall, the data from these experiments did not demonstrate elevated therapeutic efficacy for occlusal adjustment over the control or the contrasting therapy. CONCLUSION: The experimental evidence reviewed was neither convincing nor powerful enough to support the performance of occlusal therapy as a general method for treating a nonacute temporomandibular disorder, bruxism, or headache.     

Experimental occlusal interferences. Part I. A review

summary This review shows that experimental occlusal interferences (prematurities) may cause changes in the myoelectric contraction patterns of the human jaw muscles, and changes in the translatory motion patterns of the human mandible. However, it has not been unequivocally established that the observed changes have specific long-term detrimental effects. On the other hand, it is apparent that experimental occlusal interferences are associated with short-term clinical symptoms and signs, such as jaw muscle fatigue and pains, headaches, pains and clickings in the temporomandibular joints. This review suggests that new paradigms involving experimental occlusal interferences should be introduced.     

Occlusal adjustment may not provide benefit for nonacute temporomandibular disorders

J Evid Base Dent Pract 2002;2:119-20     

Acupuncture and occlusal splint therapy in the treatment of craniomandibular disorders. Part I. A comparative study.

One hundred and ten patients, 23 males and 87 females, participated in a comparative study of the effect of acupuncture and occlusal splint therapy. All the patients exhibited signs and symptoms of craniomandibular disorders (CMD) and had had pain for more than six months. The participants were randomly assigned to three groups; acupuncture treatment, occlusal splint therapy or control. The patients were evaluated before and immediately after treatment/control time. Ten different subjective and/or clinical assessment variables were used in the evaluation of the treatment effects. Both acupuncture and occlusal splint therapy reduced the symptoms as compared with the control group in which the symptoms remained essentially unchanged. In this short-term study, acupuncture gave better subjective results (p < 0.001) than the occlusal splint therapy.     

Effect of artificial occlusal interferences depends on previous experience of temporomandibular disorders

Studies on artificial interferences in subjects with no temporomandibular (TMD) history have shown adaptation to the interference within a fairly short period of time. The role of occlusal factors in the etiology of TMD has therefore been questioned. The results might have been different, however, if subjects with a prior TMD history had been included in the study groups. To test this assumption in a randomized double-blind clinical set-up, we included healthy women without (n = 26) as well as with (n = 21) an earlier TMD history. Both groups were randomly divided into true and placebo interference groups. Artificial interferences were introduced in the true interference groups and simulated in the placebo groups. The subjects were followed for 2 weeks, after which the interferences were removed. The subjects without a TMD history showed fairly good adaptation to the interferences, but the subjects with a TMD history and true interferences showed a significant increase in clinical signs compared to the other groups. We suggest that the etiological role of occlusal interferences in TMD may not have been correctly addressed in previous studies with artificial interferences and allow no conclusions as regards TMD etiology.     

Effect of artificial occlusal interferences depends on previous experience of temporomandibular disorders

Studies on artificial interferences in subjects with no temporomandibular (TMD) history have shown adaptation to the interference within a fairly short period of time. The role of occlusal factors in the etiology of TMD has therefore been questioned. The results might have been different, however, if subjects with a prior TMD history had been included in the study groups. To test this assumption in a randomized double-blind clinical set-up, we included healthy women without (n = 26) as well as with (n = 21) an earlier TMD history. Both groups were randomly divided into true and placebo interference groups. Artificial interferences were introduced in the true interference groups and simulated in the placebo groups. The subjects were followed for 2 weeks, after which the interferences were removed. The subjects without a TMD history showed fairly good adaptation to the interferences, but the subjects with a TMD history and true interferences showed a significant increase in clinical signs compared to the other groups. We suggest that the etiological role of occlusal interferences in TMD may not have been correctly addressed in previous studies with artificial interferences and allow no conclusions as regards TMD etiology.     

ҧ�ϰ���������ؽ����Ҳ���״

提要：颞下颌关节紊乱病（TMD）是口腔临床常见病之一,其治疗方法众多。咬合板作为一种保守、可逆的治疗方法被广泛应用在TMD的治疗上。然而,各类咬合板治疗TMD的疗效尚不完全明确,本文结合近年来国内外文献对其进行综述。     

Occlusal interferences in retruded contact position and temporomandibular joint sounds

summary In 193 non-patient adolescents, unilateral contacts in retruded contact position (RCP) were seen more often in girls than in boys (P < 0.001) and were more frequent in subjects with than without general joint instability (P < 0.05). A negative correlation (r=−0.70***) was found between the side of the temporomandibular joint sound and the side of unilateral contact in RCP. Boys with unilateral contacts in RCP had more non-reciprocal clicking than girls. No signs were found indicating that a unilateral contact in RCP is an aetiological factor for development of temporomandibular disorders. Unilateral contacts in RCP may in adolescents be considered a predictive factor for temporomandibular joint disturbance. Contradictory causes may determine the sagittal distance between RCP and ICP.     

Soft versus hard occlusal splint therapy in the management of temporomandibular disorders (TMDs)

Aim

To compare between soft and hard occlusal splint therapy for the management of myofacial pain dysfunction (MPD) or internal derangement (ID) of the temporomandibular joint (TMJ) with reciprocal clicking.

Patients and methods

This study included 50 patients (age range: 24–47 years) who had been diagnosed with MPD or ID of the TMJ in the form of reciprocal clicking. Patients were divided into two groups. They were treated for 4 months with either a vacuum-formed soft occlusal splint constructed from 2-mm-thick elastic rubber sheets (soft splint group) or a hard flat occlusal splint fabricated from transparent acrylic resin (hard splint group). Monthly follow-up visits were performed during the treatment period. Before treatment and 1, 2, 3 and 4 months after treatment, the dentist measured all parameters of TMJ function (pain visual analog scores, tenderness of masticatory muscles, clicking and tenderness of the TMJ, and range of mouth opening).

Results

All parameters of TMJ function showed significant improvement in both groups during the follow-up period, with a statistically significant difference between the two groups at the 4-month follow-up visit.

Conclusions

Both forms of occlusal splints (soft and hard) improved TMJ symptoms in patients with MPD or ID of the TMJ. However, the soft occlusal splints exhibited superior results after 4 months of use.     

Association between craniomandibular disorders and occlusal interferences in children.

The association between clinical signs of craniomandibular disorders (CMD) and occlusal interferences was studied longitudinally in two cohorts of children, 5 and 10 years of age at baseline, representing the nonpatient population. They were followed up for 5 years. The range of active participants was 96 to 106 in the younger group, and 64 to 74 in the older group. The subjects were seen annually for registration of signs of CMD and for the presence of interferences, and for a real or placebo occlusal adjustment. The double-blind study design was applied. Baseline data showed no association between the variables studied; parts of data from second and third examinations disclosed significant associations; and fourth, fifth and sixth examinations disclosed a consistent pattern of significant associations.