Susceptibility and resistance genes to insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus in the BB rat

Insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM, type I) is an autoimmune disorder exhibiting a strong association with particular haplotypes of the major histocompatibility complex (MHC). We have previously shown that the u haplotype of the rat MHC (RT1) is absolutely required for expression of IDDM in the BB rat model of the disease. To define the precise regions of the RT1 contributing to disease occurrence and to address the mechanism by which the associated haplotype participates in disease pathogenesis, we have transferred recombinant haplotypes bearing the IDDM-associated MHC in defined regions onto the BB rat genetic background. In this report, we present data from two breeding studies utilizing the r8 haplotype (RT1AaBuDuEuCu) that demonstrate that (1) the RT1A locus is not involved in the disease association, (2) the MHC genes determining disease susceptibility are not unique to the BB rat, and (3) IDDM resistance genes are found outside the MHC. We also present evidence that the immunoregulatory defect characteristic of BB rats enhances the incidence of IDDM although it is not absolutely required for disease expression. We were able to track the transmission of the recombinant haplotypes in diabetic progeny using a combination of monospecific alloantisera and restriction fragment length polymorphism analysis using locus-specific MHC gene probes.     

Genetic analysis of susceptibility to diabetes mellitus in F2-hybrids between diabetes-prone BB and various MHC-recombinant congenic rat strains.

The occurrence of diabetes mellitus was analysed in F2 hybrids bred from diabetic BB male rats and females of congenic rat strains carrying different major histocompatibility (RT1) haplotypes on the common LEW strain genetic background. Permissiveness for the disease in BB rats is probably determined by class II genes of the RT1 complex, which are also present in normal rats. Class I and class III genes, notably the Hsp70 genes in the class III region, do not appear to be involved. Among the diabetic F2 hybrids, about 90% are shown by DNA analysis to be homozygous for the class II genes of the permissive RT1 haplotype. The segregation patterns are in accord with the action of two independent recessive genes, one of them being RT1-linked.     

Immunologic and genetic studies of diabetes in the BB rat

The spontaneous development of diabetes in the Bio-Breeding (BB) rat is an excellent model of human insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM). Disease expression is dependent on several genetically determined abnormalities, including specific major histocompatibility complex (MHC) genes. At least one MHC class II locus of the U haplotype is a necessary, but not sufficient, condition for disease expression. The immune system of BB rats is markedly abnormal. There is a striking reduction in the number and function of mature cytotoxic/suppressor T cells, a poor proliferative response to mitogens and in mixed lymphocyte culture, poor interleukin-2 production, and a reduced ability to reject skin allografts. While these immune system abnormalities are closely related to the development of diabetes, the immune recognition and effector mechanisms resulting in islet cell destruction are still poorly understood. The hypothesis that MHC class II induction on pancreatic beta cells serves to target these lymphokines, natural killer (NK) cells, macrophages, etc.) have been implicated in islet cell killing. The incidence of IDDM is reduced by immunosuppressive therapy in both rats and humans, further supporting the role of immune mechanisms in this disease.     

Islet cells but not thyrocytes are susceptible to lysis by NK cells.

BB rats develop both pancreatic insulitis and lymphocytic thyroiditis, but whereas spontaneous autoimmune diabetes is common, hypothyroidism is rare. Splenic natural killer (NK) cells from acutely diabetic (AD) BB rats and from athymic nude rats are known to be cytotoxic to rat islet cells in vitro. To investigate possible differential tissue susceptibility to lysis by NK cells or their cytokines such as cytolysin (perforin) or NK cytotoxic factor (NKCF), we used an in vitro 51Cr-release assay to measure the cytotoxicity of splenocytes, cytolysin or NKCF against Wistar Furth (WF) and Fischer 344 (F-344) rat islet cells, and FRTL-5 F-344-derived and WRT Wistar-derived rat thyrocytes. The results demonstrated that spleen cells from AD-BB (RT1u) rats and athymic F-344 nude (RT11) rats are cytotoxic to WF (RT1u) islets and F-344 (RT11) islets, but not to FRTL-5 (RT11) or WRT (class I RT11) thyrocytes. WF and F-344 rat spleen cells were not cytotoxic to any of these cells. Thyrocytes are known to express class II molecules on their surface in chronic thyroiditis. We found that treatment of thyrocytes with interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma) induced class II expression but did not increase the cytotoxicity of splenocytes against these cells. Cytolysin and NKCF were both cytotoxic to islets in a dose dependent manner, but FRTL-5 thyrocytes were resistant to killing by these cytokines. These findings suggest that islet cells and thyrocytes in vitro are differentially susceptible to lysis by NK cells.     

Alleles of diabetes-resistant BN rats contribute to insulin-dependent type 1 diabetes mellitus

Diabetes in the biobreeding (BB) rat results from autoimmune destruction of pancreatic beta cells and thereby it is sharing many features with human type 1 diabetes. Independent crossing studies have demonstrated that diabetes in the BB rat is explained by at least three recessively acting genes termed Iddm1 (major histocompatibility complex), Iddm2 (lymphopenia), Iddm3 (unknown). About 50% of Iddm1 and Iddm2 homozygous first backcross hybrids (BC1) usually develop diabetes. However, 75% of these homozygotes become diabetic when using diabetic BB/HRI and diabetes-resistant BN/Mol rats. That prompted us to carry out a cross between BB/OK and BN/Crl rats in order to localise diabetogenic gene(s) of BB and/or BN rats.Fifty nine Iddm1 and Iddm2 homozygous [(BNxBB)F1xBB] BC1 hybrids (35 M, 24 F) were observed for diabetes occurrence up to an age of 30 weeks. All hybrids were used in a genome-wide scan carried out with 238 microsatellite markers covering about 92% of the genome.Significantly more Iddm1 and Iddm2 homozygous BC1 hybrids became diabetic (69 vs. 50%, p<0.003) with an age at onset of 91+/-31 days. Significant deviations from expected allele distribution between diabetic and non-diabetic BC1 hybrids were found at loci on chromosomes 1, 2, 3, 9, 10, 15, 16 and 19, with the strongest effect observed at locus D10Mgh2, where more heterozygous (91%) than homozygous diabetics (44%) were found. We conclude that BN rats possess more than one gene contributing to type 1 diabetes development.     

Restriction fragment length polymorphisms in the major histocompatibility complex of the non-obese diabetic mouse

The inbred non-obese diabetic (NOD) mouse is a spontaneous model for insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM). As in man and BB rats, IDDM in the NOD mouse has an autoimmune aetiology. The disease is controlled by several genes, one of which, Idd-1, has been mapped to the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) on chromosome 17. However, Idd-1 has not yet been identified. To facilitate the identification of Idd-1 we have further analysed the MHC region for restriction fragment length polymorphisms and we find that the NOD mouse has a distinct haplotype: H-2K1nod Kd A beta nod A alpha d E beta nod TNF-alpha beta. In addition, the NOD mouse shows some similarities with the H-2b haplotype in the Q region, in that either the Q7 or the Q9 gene seems to be like that in the b-haplotype and that the Qa2 antigen is expressed, while other parts of this region are distinct from the b- as well as the d- haplotype. In contrast, the sister strain, the non-obese normal (NON) mouse, derived from the same cataract-prone line of mice as the NOD mouse, has an MHC Class I region indistinguishable from the b-haplotype, but the MHC Class II region is distinct from the NOD mouse as well as the b-, d- and k-haplotype.     

T-cell antigen receptor alpha chain polymorphisms in insulin-dependent diabetes

Insulin-dependent diabetes is a chronic autoimmune disease probably mediated by T cells. We examined the alpha chain of the T-cell antigen receptor in two models of this illness (man and BB rat) to determine any association with autoimmune diabetes. We conducted a population study in man, using a human alpha chain probe, pGA-5, and restriction enzyme Bgl 11. Two allelic forms and three RFLP patterns, 2.8 and 3.0 kb homozygous and 2.8/3.0 heterozygous, were detected. There was no difference in the frequency of these RFLPs among the 50 Type I diabetic patients and 48 controls tested. BB rats develop a spontaneous T-cell mediated autoimmune diabetes. The diabetes has been linked in several breeding studies to an undetermined autosomal recessive gene causing T-cell lymphopenia. We were able to differentiate the T-cell antigen receptor alpha chain of the diabetic BB and control BBN rats using the restriction enzyme EcoR1 and a murine alpha chain probe, TT11. The BB rat had a haplotype characterized by the presence of 4.7 and 5.8 kb bands, and the absence of 1.4, 2.2, 2.6, 3.6, 3.9, 4.1, and 6.1 kb bands. In a breeding study with BB and BBN rats, diabetic animals of the F2 generation demonstrated no linkage with the BBs' alpha chain, nor was lymphopenia linked to the alpha chain of the BB rat. These results suggest that autoimmune diabetes is not linked to the T-cell antigen receptor alpha chain in the BB rat, nor is it associated with alpha chain constant region polymorphisms in Type I diabetes in man.     

The gene for the T lymphocyte alloantigen, RT6, is not linked to either diabetes or lymphopenia and is not defective in the BB rat

In an outcross between a diabetic BB/H rat and a healthy Long Evans Hooded rat, the segregation of the RT6 gene was studied in the 207 F2 animals to look for linkage with diabetes or lymphopenia. The recessive gene, albino (c), was used as a marker for the RT6 gene because of the close proximity of these two genes on chromosome 1. Though most of the albino F2 rats should have been homozygous for the BB RT6 gene, we found no increase in the incidence of diabetes or lymphopenia among them when compared to their hooded littermates. Therefore, the RT6 gene was not linked to diabetes or lymphopenia in the BB rat. Moreover, the non-lymphopenic albino rats displayed normal RT6 expression when compared to the normal hooded rats showing that the RT6 gene from the BB/H grandfather was not defective. Any alteration in lymphocyte composition which could be specifically related to diabetes was studied by measuring all F2 rats for the major lymphocyte subsets including the RT6+ subset. We found that the typical pattern of lymphopenia described in diabetic BB rats was displayed by both diabetic and non-diabetic lymphopenic rats in the F2 generation. Thus, all these lymphocyte abnormalities including the depletion in RT6+ T lymphocytes appeared as a consequence of lymphopenia alone and could not be specifically related to diabetes.     

Role of major histocompatibility complex class II in the development of autoimmune type 1 diabetes and thyroiditis in rats

Although the MHC class II 'u' haplotype is strongly associated with type 1 diabetes (T1D) in rats, the role of MHC class II in the development of tissue-specific autoimmune diseases including T1D and autoimmune thyroiditis remains unclear. To clarify this, we produced a congenic strain carrying MHC class II 'a' and 'u' haplotypes on the Komeda diabetes-prone (KDP) genetic background. The u/u homozygous animals developed T1D similar to the original KDP rat; a/u heterozygous animals did develop T1D but with delayed onset and low frequency. In contrast, none of the a/a homozygous animals developed T1D; about half of the animals with a/u heterozygous or a/a homozygous genotypes showed autoimmune thyroiditis. To investigate the role of genetic background in the development of thyroiditis, we also produced a congenic strain carrying Cblb mutation of the KDP rat on the PVG.R23 genetic background (MHC class II 'a' haplotype). The congenic rats with homozygous Cblb mutation showed autoimmune thyroiditis without T1D and slight to severe alopecia, a clinical symptom of hypothyroidism such as Hashimoto's thyroiditis. These data indicate that MHC class II is involved in the tissue-specific development of autoimmune diseases, including T1D and thyroiditis.     

Major histocompatibility complex gene product expression on pancreatic beta cells in acutely diabetic BB rats.

Type I diabetes mellitus was induced in young, diabetes-prone BB rats by the passive transfer of concanavalin A-activated T lymphocytes from the spleens of acutely diabetic BB rats. The pancreas of the recipients was examined 1-2 days after the onset of glycosuria by immunocytochemistry by means of monoclonal antibodies for determining whether 1) Class I and/or II major histocompatibility gene complex (MHC) products were expressed on beta cells and 2) the mononuclear cell infiltrates were represented by T cells. Marked expression of Class I MHC gene products was evident on beta cells. In contrast, Class II MHC gene products were not identified on normal-appearing beta cells. Dendritic cells dispersed throughout the acinar and interstitial pancreas were markedly increased in number. The mononuclear cell infiltrate contained few cells (1-15%) recognized by a pan-T cell marker. Although it is possible that this passive transfer model might differ considerably from the spontaneously occurring diabetic state in the rat, this study suggests that 1) Class I, rather than Class II, MHC gene expression may be pivotal to beta-cell injury in diabetic rats, and 2) non-T cells may constitute an effector cell population central to beta-cell necrosis in Type I diabetes mellitus.     

Diabetes prone BB rats are severely deficient in natural killer T cells

Diabetes prone (DP) BB rats develop spontaneous autoimmune hyperglycemia. Coisogenic diabetes resistant (DR) BB rats develop diabetes in response to immunological and environmental perturbants, but not spontaneously. Both are used to model human insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM). Deficiencies in natural killer (NK) T cells have been implicated in the expression of human IDDM, but little is known of their phenotype or function in the rat. We now report that the phenotype of NK T cells in the rat is alphabetaTcR+ CD8+ CD4-, comparable to the NK T cell phenotype reported for humans, which is alphabetaTcR+ CD4- Valpha24-JalphaQ, and either CD8- or CD8alphaalpha+. We also report that DP- but not DR-BB rats are severely deficient in splenic and intrahepatic NKR-P1+ alphabetaTcR+ (NK T) cells. Because RT6+ T cells are deficient in DP-BB rats, and because depletion of cells expressing RT6 induces IDDM in DR-BB rats, we studied NK T cells for expression of this antigen. We observed that the majority of rat NK T cells express RT6+. In addition, injection of cytotoxic anti-RT6.1 monoclonal antibody depleted splenic and intrahepatic RT6+ NK T cells, T cells, and NK cells, but left intact the RT6- subset of each population. These results suggest that deficiencies in NK T cells may play a role in the susceptibility of DP- and DR-BB rats, respectively, to spontaneous and induced autoimmune IDDM.     

Derivation of non-lymphopenic BB rats with an intercross breeding

Previous studies have suggested that the development of diabetes in the BB rats does not require the expression of T lymphopenia. In order to derive non-lymphopenic diabetic rats and define the relationship between the T cell abnormalities, MHC genotype, and diabetes, we performed a cross between BB/H and diabetes resistant BB/control followed by an intercross of the F1. In the F2, the overall incidence of diabetes and lymphopenia was 30% and 27%, respectively. Lymphopenia was strongly associated with diabetes (p less than 0.001) and was seen in 76% of the diabetic F2's. However, 6 of the diabetic were non-lymphopenic (24%) and 3 of the non-diabetics were lymphopenic (5%). In the non-lymphopenic diabetic animals, all T cell levels were within the normal range, but diabetes occurred at an earlier age than their lymphopenic littermates (p less than 0.001). In contrast to the strong association between the inheritance of lymphopenia and diabetes, no relationship between diabetes and Class I MHC restriction fragment length polymorphisms was found. We conclude: 1) Diabetes and lymphopenia are strongly associated inherited abnormalities in the BB rat and are not associated with Class I RFLP defined genotypes within the RTIu haplotype, 2) Animals in whom diabetes occurs in the absence of lymphopenia can be derived using this breeding approach 3) In our non-lymphopenic rats, diabetes occurred at an earlier age possibly reflecting the restoration of quantitative or qualitative T cell defects found in lymphopenic BB rats.     

Susceptibility to the induction of either autoimmunity or immunosuppression by mercuric chloride is related to the major histocompatibility complex class II haplotype

Mercuric chloride (HgCl2) induces in Brown Norway rats a CD4+ T lymphocyte-dependent systemic autoimmune syndrome, involving synthesis of anti-glomerular basement membrane autoantibodies and development of proteinuria. Lewis rats are resistant to HgCl2-induced autoantibody production and, in contrast, develop immunosuppression, mediated by CD8+ T lymphocytes. In the present study, genetic requirements governing autoreactivity or immunosuppression in response to HgCl2 were further explored. Both major histocompatibility complex (MHC) and non-MHC genes are involved in determining susceptibility to HgCl2-induced autoimmunity. Both AO (RT1u) and DZB (RT1u) rats were found to develop a membranous autoimmune glomerulopathy upon exposure to HgCl2. Only the DZB strain, which differs in part of the non-MHC background from AO, developed proteinuria. AO.1P (RT1.AuB1D1Eu) rats, which are genetically identical to AO except for the Lewis haplotype at the MHC class II loci, appeared to develop immunosuppression upon exposure to HgCl2. It is concluded that autoreactivity and immunosuppression, induced by HgCl2, are both dependent on the MHC class II haplotype. In autoimmune responder strains the type of autoimmune glomerulopathy is influenced by non-MHC genes.     

Association of tumor necrosis factor (TNF) and class II major histocompatibility complex alleles with the secretion of TNF-a and TNF-0 by human mononuclear cells: a possible link to insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus

We have investigated the correlation between different tumor necrosis factor (TNF) and class II major histocompatibility complex alleles in the lipopolysaccharide- or phytohemagglutinin-induced secretion of TNF-α and TNF-β by human monocytes and peripheral blood mononuclear cells in 87 unrelated Danish male individuals. Significant differences in TNF-α secretory capacity between TNF Ncol restriction fragment length polymorphisms, TNFa and TNFc micro-satellite alleles and DR alleles were identified. No correlation with TNF-β secretory capacity was found for any of the markers studied. TNF genotyping allowed us to define four extended HLA haplotypes which correlate with TNF-α secretory capacity. Two of these are DR4 positive: DQw8, DR4, TNFB*1, TNFa6, B44, A2 and DQw8, DR4, TNFB*2, TNFa2, B15, A2. Individuals carrying the TNFB*2, TNFa2 haplotype had a higher TNF-α secretory capacity than those carrying the TNFB*1, TNFa6 haplotype. In a group of DR3/DR4 heterozygous patients with insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM), the frequency of the TNFa2 allele was higher than in HLA-DR matched controls, whereas theTNFa6 allele was more frequent in control individuals. In the DR3/DR4 heterozygous diabetic group 12/26 had the alleles combination DQw8, DR4 (Dw4), C4A3, TNFB*2, TNFa2, B15, whereas only 1/18 controls had this haplotype. This diabetogenic haplotype is identical to the DR4 haplotype which correlates with a higher TNF-α response. These observations suggest a direct role for the TNF locus in the pathogenesis of IDDM.     

BB-DR/Edinburgh: a lymphopenic, non-diabetic subline of BB rats.

Diabetes-prone (DP) and diabetes-resistant (DR) sublines of the BB rat have been established in Edinburgh, U.K., separately from other existing colonies. In an examination of the lymphoid status of the two lines, BB-DP/Ed and BB-DR/Ed, it has been found that both lines have very low T-cell numbers, depressed B-lymphocyte numbers and a complete absence of peripheral CD8+ T cells, all features characteristic of the previously described genetic lymphopenia lesion. It was also noted that the peripheral T cells of both BB/Ed lines were larger than normal. The DP/Ed and DR/Ed lines were indistinguishable in all these respects, and furthermore, they were both shown to type as RT1u at the major histocompatibility complex (MHC). The genetic combination of lymphopenia and RT1u without expression of diabetes is not present in other extant BB lines and makes BB-DR/Ed a uniquely useful control strain for BB rat studies as well as a valuable genetic resource for the further genetic analysis of diabetes susceptibility in rats.     

Genetic susceptibility to the development of spontaneous insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus in the rat

Spontaneous insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus in the rat is a multigenic, multifactorial condition. We have identified three phenotypic characteristics of the syndrome. The first is an association with the RT1u haplotype of the rat major histocompatibility complex. A single RT1u haplotype is permissive, although the relative risk of developing the disease is increased when the animal is homozygous. An immunoregulatory defect, which is characterized phenotypically by a severe T lymphocyte depletion, behaves as if it were regulated by a single autosomal recessive gene which segregates independently of the RT1. The third phenotype characteristic is the presence of lymphocytic infiltration of the pancreas. The genetics of this characteristic have not been delineated, although there is evidence that it behaves as a dominant. In addition to the requirement for several genes, environmental events are important for full expression of the syndrome.     

Brain-reactive autoantibodies in BB/d rats do not recognize glutamic acid decarboxylase.

The BB rat spontaneously develops insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM) similar to that in humans. The most practical markers of beta cell autoimmunity are circulating antibodies to islet cell components. In particular autoantibodies to the enzyme glutamic acid decarboxylase (GAD) are a common feature of IDDM development in humans. This study aims at investigating the prevalence and levels of autoantibodies in BB rats to antigens in a semipurified, GAD-enriched preparation from rat brain. Eighteen diabetes-prone BB/d rats (10 male and eight female) were tail bled weekly from age 28 days to 113 days and antibodies detected on the rat brain preparation by ELISA. Antibody levels were expressed as arbitrary units relative to a standard positive serum. Individual rats varied in the time and order of antibody appearance and IDDM onset, with the earliest occurrence being 42 days and 69 days, respectively. In some rats antibody production was maintained but declined in others. By 113 days 85% of diabetic rats had at some time been positive for autoantibodies to brain components, compared with 25% of non-diabetics (P = 0.09 by Fisher's exact test). Immunoabsorption studies using recombinant rat GAD-65 or recombinant human GAD-67 failed to inhibit the binding of BB rat sera to the original rat brain preparation. A capture ELISA using GAD-6 MoAb to capture GAD-65 from rat brain preparation or from a preparation of recombinant rat GAD-65, failed to detect anti-GAD antibodies in BB rats. Immunofluorescent staining of tissue sections showed the autoantibodies to be brain-specific, but having distinct staining patterns to the anti-GAD antibodies of Stiff Man Syndrome serum. In conclusion, BB rats possess autoantibodies reactive with rat brain antigens which may be associated with IDDM. However, these are not directed against GAD.     

BB rat lyp mutation and Type 1 diabetes

Summary: BioBreeding (BB) rats spontaneously develop an autoimmune diabetic syndrome similar to that observed in humans and NOD mice. One of the diabetes susceptibility loci maps to the lyp locus on chromosome 4. In this article we describe the consequences of the BB rat lyp mutation on T-cell homeostasis, repertoire and function, as well as its role in the pathogenesis of type I diabetes.     

Genetics of the antibody response to an endothelial transplantation antigen in the rat

Immunization of MAXX (RT1n) rats with pooled spleen and lymph node cells from the BN (RT1n) strain results in the formation of alloantibodies against a nonmajor histocompatibility complex (MHC) encoded transplantation antigen on peritubular capillary and venous endothelium of the kidney. Since ACI (RT1a) strain animals did not respond to the antigen, the genetics of the in vivo humoral immune response to repeated immunization were investigated in 43 animals of the second filial generation from the responder MAXX and the nonresponder ACI strain, as well as in 13 animals produced by backcrossing (MAXX X ACI)F1 and ACI. Because 38/40 RT1n-positive animals responded, while 16/16 RT1a/a recipients did not, it was shown that the RT1n haplotype was required for responsiveness. Using the intra-MHC recombinant strains DA.1I (RT1.AnBaDaEu) and WRC (RT1.AnBnDa), the immune response was mapped within the class II region of the MHC-complex. Effects of MHC-(in)compatibility between donor and recipient on the response were ruled out, since MAXX rats formed endothelial antibodies upon immunization with the MHC-incompatible BN.1L (RT1(1), BN.1A (RT1a), and WKY (RT1k) cells, whereas ACI animals failed to produce endothelial antibodies after immunization with BN.1A cells. Furthermore, the response appears to be thymus dependent because congenitally athymic WAG/rnu (RT1u) rats failed to produce endothelial antibodies, in contrast to the euthymic WAG/Rij (RT1u) strain.     

Evaluation of TAP1 polymorphisms with insulin dependent diabetes mellitus in finnish diabetic patients

Insulin dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM) is an autoimmune disease with a strong association between disease and the HLA class II region. Because abnormal antigen processing, in part characterized by altered class I processing, has been identified in patients with IDDM, the TAP (transporter associated with antigen processing) genes located in the HLA class II region make attractive candidate genes for IDDM. Five coding region variants of TAP1 were typed in a cohort of well characterized Finnish patients with diabetes (n = 119) and compared to racially matched control subjects (n = 92). We found that although no single TAP1 polymorphism was associated with IDDM, a genotypic combination of Ile/ Val at codon 333 with Asp/Asp at codon 637 was found more frequently in subjects with IDDM (9.4%) compared to controls (1.2%; p = 0.025). This could not be accounted for by an association with any particular haplotype defined by class I or class II serology.