Somatic cell hybrids between human lymphoma lines. IV. Establishment and characterization of a P3HR-1/Daudi hybrid.

A new human B-lymphoma hybrid line designated DIP-1 was derived from the fusion of the Burkitt lines Daudi and P3HR-1. Cytogenetic analyses proved hybridity and showed that the hybrid was nearly complete from the chromosomal point of view. Hybridity was also confirmed by isozyme marker tests. The Daudi-derived IgM-kappa ring was fully exposed on DIP-1, together with the P3HR-1-derived human beta-2-microglobulin. Expression of C3 receptors was intermediate between the two parents and EBV receptors were some what reduced in comparison with both. The spontaneous low-level EBV antigen (EA and VCA) production of the parents was maintained and amplified in the hybrid. The hybrid, like its Daudi parent, was highly inducible with IdUrd. In P3HR-1 virus super-infection experiments, the Daudi parent was more permissive than the BU-P3HR-1 parent. The hybrid was intermediate, resembling the previously studied Raji/Daudi hybrid and contrasting with Raji/Namalwa and Raji/BJAB hybrids. Virus DNA replication patterns after P3HR-1 virus superinfection resembled the antigen pattern. The implication of these findings for the understanding of virus-host cell relationships and the regulation of the viral cycle is discussed The findings are meant to imply that genetically determined isozyme markers are autonomously expressed, as in other systems. Differentiation-related markers and EBV-cycle-related characteristics are autonomously expressed in some cases (surface immunoglobulin, beta-2-microglobulin, spontaneous EBV-production, IdUrd inducibility) and appear to be under a restrictive control in others (EA inducibility by P3HR-1 virus superinfection, C3 and EBV receptors, viral DNA replication).     

Somatic cell hybrids between human lymphoma cell lines. V. IdUrd inducibility and P3HR-1 superinfectability of Daudi/HeLa (DAD) and Daudi/P3HR-1 (DIP-1) cell lines.

We have studied two types of somatic cell hybrid with regard to expression of the Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) cycle and its regulation. The first, DIP-1, a hybrid formed between two human lymphoma EBV producers (Daudi and P3HR-1), contained EBV DNA, expressed the virus-determined nuclear antigen (EBNA), andwas a producer of the EBV-associated antigens EA (early antigen) and VCA (viral capsid antigen). The second, DAD, a hybrid series of clones formed between Daudi and a HeLa cell derivative (D98), differed with regard to the expression of EBNA, EA, VCA and the content of EBV DNA. EA was regularly induced in the EBV DNA-containing hybrids following treatment with iododeoxyuridine (IdUrd). This induction was greater in lines spontaneously expressing EA. In two hybrids, DIP-1 and DAD10, VCA and virus DNA synthesis were also induced in the presence of IdUrd, the latter being detected by in situ hybridization with P3HR-1 EBV complementary RNA. Finally, while DIP-1 was superinfectable by the P3HR-1 EBV strain, the DAD series of hybrids were refractory to P3HR-1 superinfection and lacked EBV receptors.     

Differential induction of Epstein-Barr virus-related antigens in heterokaryon cultures.

Different paterns of induction of Epstein-Barr virus (EBV)-related antigens were observed in heterokaryons produced by Sendai virus-mediated fusion of producer and non-producer human lymphoblastoid cells with various other cell types. EBV-related early antigens (EA) and viral capsid antigen (VCA) could obviously be induced in heterokaryons between producer cells (P3HR-1 and QIMR-WIL), normally expressing these natigens at very low frequency, and human FL or HeLa cells. Positive cells were detected as early as 3 h after fusion and there often followed a rapid increase in positive cells. In contrast, in heterokaryons between non-producer cells (Raji and NC-37) and FL or HeLa cells, only EA but not VCA was induced. EA induction was also evident in fusion of human lymphoblastoid cells with monkey cells (Vero) but with mouse cells (L-M(TK-) C11D and MCB-2) no EBV induction occurred. The EBV induction in heterokaryons was significantly enhanced by 5-iododeoxyuridine treatment.     

Combined effect of the extracts from Croton tiglium,Euphorbia lathyris or Euphorbia tirucalli and n-butyrate on Epstein-Barr virus expression in human lymphoblastoid P3HR-1 and Raji cells

The combined usage of n-butyrate and 12-O-tetradecanoylphorbol-13-acetate (TPA) or the oily extracts from Croton tiglium, Euphorbia lathyris or Euphorbia tirucalli exerted a marked effect on induction of Epstein-Barr virus (EBV)-associated early (EA) and viral capsid (VCA) antigens in EBV genome-carrying human lymphoblastoid cell lines. In producer P3HR-1 cells, the enhancing effect of the 2 components was additive both for EA and VCA, while in non-producer Raji cells, a synergistic increase of EA was observed. The possible implication of these findings relating to the cause of EBV-associated diseases is discussed.     

Recovery of transforming EBV from non-producer cells after superinfection with non-transforming P3HR-1 EBV.

Cells of the Raji and NC37 lines can be induced by chemical inducers, such as BrdUrd and IdUrd, or the tumor-promoter TPA to EA-expression only, but do not reveal any VCA synthesis. After superinfection by nontransforming P3HR-1 EBV, however, a varying percentage of the cell population shows VCA synthesis and releases infectious viral particles. The recovered virus differs biologically from P3HR-1 EBV since it transforms human umbilical cord blood lymphocytes into EBNA-positive lymphoblastoid cell lines. Cells of these established lines are susceptible to renewed infection by P3HR-1 EBV which results in EA induction and VCA synthesis. Only cells of one line, NC37-R1, spontaneously produce VCA and EBV particles, which reveal transforming properties and do not induce EA upon superinfection of Raji cells. Infection of P3HR-1 EBV-converted BJA-B cells also leads to EA and VCA induction and the release of viral particles. In contrast to particles recovered from Raji and NC37 cells, no transforming activity was detectable in these virus preparations. According to these data, we propose that viral genomes persisting within Raji and NC37 cells are defective and become complemented by the superinfecting P3HR-1 virus.     

Spontaneous and induced patterns of the Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) cycle in a new set of somatic cell hybrids.

A somatic cell hybrid line and its subclones obtained by fusing two Burkitt lymphoma lines (Raji and Namalwa) were examined for the expression of EBV-specific antigens both spontaneously and after induction. The hybrids retained spontaneous early antigen (EA) production at the level characteristic of Raji. Similarly the more permissive Raji pattern dominated the induction of EA by IUDR treatment or P3HR-1 virus superinfection. These findings accord with our previous results on independently derived Raji/Namalwa hybrids. Virus capsid antigen was induced in the hybrids by P3HR-1 virus superinfection though at a lower level than in the Raji parental cell.     

Sensitivity to EBV superinfection and IUdR inducibility of hybrid cells formed between a sensitive and a relatively resistant Burkitt lymphoma cell line

The sensitivity of Burkitt lymphoma-derived cell lines to Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) superinfection and the inducibility of the latent EBV genome in these lines were studied by somatic cell hybridization. Two non-EBV producer lines; AG R3, an adherent, 8-azaguanine-resistant variant of the Rajiline; and Namalwa, a non-adherent, 8-azaguanine-sensitive line, were fused with the aid of β-propiolactone-inactivated Sendai virus. The resident EBV genome in Raji is inducible with 5-iododeoxyuridine and the line is also sensitive to EBV superinfection. Namalwa is relatively resistant to both super-infection and induction, and synthetizes surface-associated IgM-lambda. Cytological studies showed that hybrid cells appear to be much larger than either parent and attach to culture plates less firmly than the adherent Raji variant parent. Karyological analyses showed that hybrids contain the expected sum of the parental chromosome markers. Membrane immunofluorescence tests also showed that hybrids synthetize IgM. All the hybrid cells appear to be non-EBV producers, but they are sensitive to both EBV super-infection and induction of latent EBV. These findings suggest the following explanations: (1) there is no evidence of any complementation between the two non-EBV producer lines (Raji and Namalwa) to elicit spontaneous EBV production in hybrid cells; (2) Namalwa is deficient in some factors required for the synthesis of EBV-specified early antigens after EBV superinfection and after induction of latent EBV by IUdR; these factors are supplied by the Raji parent in the hybrids; or (3) Raji, Namalwa and hybrid cells or EBV all produce a substance which inhibits activation of a productive viral cycle, but whose action is antagonized in Raji and hybrid cells to allow the synthesis of EBV-specific early antigens.     

Abortive expression of the Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) cycle in a variety of EBV DNA-containing cell lines, as reflected by nucleic acid hybridization in situ.

A variety of Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) DNA-containing cell lines have been tested for the expression of the EBV-associated antigens EBNA (nuclear antigen), EA (early antigen), and VCA (viral capsid antigen), and for the presence of cells containing disproportionate amounts of EBV DNA. The antigen tests utilized immunofluorescence and 125I-labelled antibodies combined with autoradiography. EBV-DNA was detected by in situ hybridization with 3H-labelled EBV RNA complementary to P3HR-1 EBV DNA (P-EBVcRNA). The P-EBVcRNA has been shown to represent the majority of the P3HR-1 EBV DNA sequences. It was concluded that EBV DNA-containing cell lines can be divided into those that express only EBNA, those that express EBNA and EA and those that express EBNA, EA and VCA and also contain cells that undergo disproportionate EBV DNA synthesis. Consequently, in some cell lines there is an abortive expression of the EBV cycle in that some cells spontaneously express EA but fail to continue further to viral DNA synthesis. A similar pattern can be found after experimental induction of the EBV cycle, suggesting that related mechanisms govern the spontaneous expression of the EBV cycle and the extent of its inducibility.     

Differential inducibility of Epstein-Barr virus in cloned, non-producer Raji cells.

Cells of the human lymphoblastoid non-producer line Raji were cloned in soft agar. Individual colonies were isolated and analyzed for their inducibility of the Epstein-Barr virus-associated early antigen (EA). The induction of EA by the tumor promoter TPA varied among the different cell clones. Clones with very high and very low inducibility of the resident Epstein-Barr virus genome were further analyzed. Constant differences in the inducibility of EA were observed after activation by tumor promoters, 5-iododeoxyuridine or antibodies to human IgM. Induction of EA synthesis by superinfection with Epstein-Barr virus from the P3HR-1 line, however, did not vary among the clones tested. No differences in expression of the Epstein-Barr virus-associated nuclear antigen (EBNA) were noted in cells of clones with high or low susceptibility to EA induction. DNA reassociation kinetics demonstrated that Raji cells with high susceptibility to EA induction contained a significantly higher number of Epstein-Barr virus genome equivalents per cell than cells with low susceptibility. Treatment of Raji cells with the tumor promoter TPA did not change the ratio of Epstein-Barr virus-specific DNA to cellular DNA.     

Hybridization between a human epithelial line, infectable by Epstein-Barr virus, and Burkitt lymphoma lines: membrane properties, superinfectability, inducibility and tumorigenicity

The human epithelial line U, which is partially infectable with EBV, was hybridized with the EBV-genome carrying Burkitt lymphoma lines P3HR-1 and Daudi. Authenticity of the hybrids U-Put and U-Dut was established by isoenzyme studies. Although the two hybrids carried the EBV genome derived from the lymphoma parent, being 100% positive for Epstein-Barr-virus-associated nuclear antigen (EBNA), they resembled the U parent in many respects: they were deficient for membrane immunoglobulins and Fc receptors, and had a lower concentration of EBV-C3 receptors than either parent. Unlike the P3HR-1 parent, U-Put hybrid was nonpermissive for both the EBV cycle antigens, early antigen (EA) and viral capsid antigen (VCA). The inducing agent 12-O-tetra-decanoyl-phorbol-13-acetate (TPA) caused distinct viral early antigen synthesis (EA) in U-Put, lower, however, than that of the parental P3HR-1. U-Dut was completely nonpermissive and noninducible for early and viral capsid antigens. Thus, even an epithelial parent infectable by EBV restricted, although not completely, expression of EBV antigens, with the exception of EBNA. It has been suggested that EBNA is an autonomous function of the viral genome, independent of host cell control; the latter regulates expression of antigens related to viral cycle. The hybrids U-Put and U-Dut resembled the U parent also in regard to growth in soft agar and tumorigenicity in nude mice, although in this respect the lymphoma parental properties were not completely eclipsed.     

Differential induction of Epstein-Barr virus-related antigens in human lymphoblastoid cells by virus-mediated cell-to-cell contact.

Differential induction of Epstein-Barr virus (EBV)-related antigens was observed after Sendai virus-medicated fusion of producer and non-producer cells with various human and mouse cells. The EBV-determined early nuclear antigen (ENA), early antigen (EA) and viral capsid antigen (VCA) could be induced at a high rate in producer cells (P3HR-1 and B95-8), normally expressing these antigens at very low frequency, as early as 12-24 h after fusion with each other or with human amnion FL cells. In contrast, only one antigen, ENA, was induced in producer cells following fusion with non-producer cells. This limited induction occurred also in non-producer cells fused with FL cells, but not after fusion with each other. EBV induction did not result from fusion of either producer or non-producer cells with mouse cells (L-M (TK-) Cl1D and MCB-L). The differential induction was not the result of heterokaryon formation as determined by autoradiography. The implications of these findings are discussed.     

Relationship between Epstein-Barr virus (EBV)-production and the loss of the EBV receptor/complement receptor complex in a series of sublines derived from the same original Burkitt's lymphoma.

Virus production, EBV (P3HR-1 substrain) superinfectability, IdUrd inducibility, EBV receptor and complement (C3) receptor expression were assessed in two independently maintained jijoye lines, the derived P3HR-1 clone that releases a growth inhibitory and cytopathic, non-transforming viral mutant, and in non-producer sublines derived from the P3HR-1 line by the spontaneous cessation of virus production. Both jijoye lines were superinfectable, inducible, and carried EBV and C3 receptors. Virus-producing P3HR-1 cells and recently derived non-producer sublines lacked EBV-receptors and C3 receptors, could not be superinfected, but were IdUrd inducible. Two long-passaged, non-producer sublines of P3HR-1 reexpressed EBV and C3 receptors to an equal degree (different in the two sublines). EBV-superinfectability became partially reestablished in the subline with the higher expression of EBV and C3 receptors. These findings support the hypothesis that the EBV-receptor/C3 receptor negativity of the producer P3HR-1 sublines and their recent non-producer derivatives is due to negative selection by the growth-inhibitory, cytopathic P3HR-1 virus variant. The closely linked disappearance and reappearance of EBV-receptors and complement receptors gives further support to the idea that these two receptors are either identical or closely linked constituents of the cell membrane.     

Cellular localization of an Epstein-Barr virus (EBV)-associated complement-fixing antigen in producer and non-producer lymphoblastoid cell lines

Anti-complement immunofluorescence (ACIF) was used to study the complementfixing antigens of human lymphoblastoid cell lines. These cell lines carry the Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) genome although only producer cultures synthetize EBV-specific antigens (virus capsid antigen, VCA and early antigen, EA) detectable by direct and indirect immunofluorescence, usually in less than 5% of the cells. The ACIF test revealed an antigen localized in the nucleus of the lymphoblastoid cells. In contrast to EA and VCA, this antigen was present in over 90% of the cells of both producer and non-producer cultures. The antigen was shown to be specific for EBV by comparing the reactions of 52 sera in the ACIF test. Sera giving the nuclear reaction contained antibodies to VCA, EA or antigens detectable by complement fixation tests on cell extracts, but sera without EBV antibodies failed to give the reaction. Weak, equivocal or discordant reactions occurred with six sera with low titres in VCA, EA or complement fixation tests. Cell lines derived by transformation of human and primate lymphocytes by EBV gave the nuclear reaction. Control cells with no known association with EBV were non-reactive. These included foetal lymphocytes transformed by phytohaemagglutinin, cell lines derived from breast cancer, glioma, normal glia, pleuritis maligna and myeloma, and two marmoset lymphoid lines carrying Herpesvirus saimiri (HVS). In preliminary experiments, the ACIF test was used as a tool to trace the EBV genome at the cellular level. Cells from two Burkitt lymphoma biopsies, one tested after biopsy and one after passaging in nude mice, contained an EBV-specific antigen. Three clones of cells derived from hybrids of mouse somatic cells and a human lymphoblastoid cell line also contained such an antigen, but the number of reactive cells varied from clone to clone. A fourth clone was non-reactive.     

Inducibility of the Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) cycle and surface marker properties of EBV-negative lymphoma lines and their in vitro EBV-converted sublines.

Two EBV-negative lymphoma lines of human B-cell origin, BJAB and Ramos, were compared with altogether six of their in vitro EBV-converted, EBNA- and EBV-DNA-carrying sublines (four of Ramos and two of BJAB derivation). All converted lines closely resembled the parental line with regard to karyotype and HL-A and B antigen typing. Induction of EBV antigens (EA and VCA) by P3HR-1 virus superinfection was either similar in the converted and the negative lines, or somewhat increased in certain converted lines. These findings argue against a simple, virally determined repressor model and emphasize the role or cellular controls in restricting the EBV cycle in virus-carrying B-lymphocyte lines of human origin. IUdR inducibility varied in the different converted lines. There was a possible relationship between average number of EBV-genome equivalents per cell and inducibility. Converted sublines did not differ from the original negative lines with regard to surface immunoglobulin and Fc receptors. There was a dramatic increase in complement-consuming ability, however, following EBV conversion. Among the EBV-positive lines, there was a linear relationship between complement-consuming and EBV-receptor activity, the latter measured by a quantitative absorption test.     

Productive Epstein-Barr viral infection of the human lymphoblastoid cell line 6410 with release of early antigen inducing and transforming virus.

The human lymphoblastoid cell line 6410 was superinfected with P3HR-1 derived Epstein-Barr virus. Subsequent to the first cycle of infection, characterized by early (EA) and virus capsid (VCA) antigen synthesis, the culture, designated 6410-EBV, continued to synthesize VCA. Further immunofluorescence and electron microscopic examination over 18-24 months showed the 6410-EBV culture to be productively infected with EBV. Virus was recovered, in quantity, from the culture fluids and assayed for ability to induce EA synthesis in Raji cells and to transform human umbilical cord lymphocytes. The virus was found to possess both properties, in contrast to P3HR-1 virus which only induces EA. HLA and karyologic analyses of P3HR-1, 6410 and 6410-EBV cultures showed relatedness of 6410-EBV to 6410 cells and dissimilarity to P3HR-1. The biologic activity data coupled with the cytologic analyses confirm a productive infection of the target cells. The reason for differences in biologic activity between the infecting (P3HR-1) and progeny virus is unresolved. It may be speculated that the endogenous EBV genome of 6410 cells was activated and gave rise to a different strain of EBV or to a mixed progeny-parent population as a result of dual infection. Alternatively, the parent strain of virus may have been modfied as a result of interaction with the new host cell.     

Immunofluorescence and anti-complement immunofluorescence absorption tests for quantitation of Epstein-Barr virus-associated antigens.

Immunofluorescence absorption methods are described which permit quantitative estimation and differentiation of Epstein-Barr virus (EBV)-associated antigens (virus capsid antigen, VCA, early antigen, EA and EBV-determined nuclear antigen, EBNA) in cell extracts. EBNA was present in all cell lines (producer and non-producer) which carried the EBV-genome, while VCA and EA were present in producer lines only. All the antigens were absent from a lymphoid cell line (MOLT-4) which lacked the EBV-genome, as well as from leukemia cells from peripheral blood. The techniques demonstrated antigenic identity of the various antigens when prepared from different cell lines.     

Somatic cell hybrids between human lymphoma lines. III. Surface markers.

Hybrids between two human lymphoma lines, Raji and Daudi (8A) and Raji BJAB (83) were examined for genetically determined and/or differentiation-related surface markers. HL-A B ce-l alloantigens, Fc and complement receptors, EBV receptors and beta2 microglobulin showed an autonomous ("co-dominant") expression in the hybrid. This is in contrast to most previous studies on other differentiation markers, involving as a rule crosses between cells of different lineages, where the differentiated pattern usually became "eclipsed" in the hybrid. Staining of activated complement and complement consumption tests showed intermediate or partially suppressed expression in the hybrids. This may be viewed in relation to the fact that these reactions do not merely depend on complement binding to the receptor, but also on subsequent activation and binding of the activated complement. A more complex interaction is also suggested for immunoglobulin production. Surface immunoglobulin showed a suppressive or intermediate pattern in both hybrids, whereas intracellular kappa chain production showed an amplification in the 83 hybrid. The beta2 microglobulin deficiency of the Daudi parent was corrected in the Raji/Daudi hybrid. Two new HL-A specificities,A10 and BW17, appeared on this hybrid which were not present on the parental lines. This suggests that the HL-A deficiency of the Daudi cell is due to its lack of beta2 microglobulin.     

Early and late components of Epstein-Barr virus-associated membrane antigen in superinfected Daudi cells and their reactivity with sera from nasopharyngeal carcinoma patients.

Investigations were carried out on newly synthesized MA, VCA and EA in Daudi cells superinfected with the P3HR-1 strain of EBV and treated with trypsin to remove previously adsorbed MA-positive material from the cell surface. Synthesis of MA, VCA and EA was completely blocked by puromycin. A marked reduction in the frequency of MA-positive cells was observed in the infected cell cultures in the presence of either Ara-C or PA, but a fraction of the MA-positive cells was insensitive to the inhibitors. Differential absorption of an EBV antibody-positive human serum with Ara-C-treated or -untreated infected cells revealed two antigenically different components of MA: early (Ara-C-insensitive) and late (Ara-C-sensitive) MA. Three of five sera from patients with NPC, but none of five sera from normal adults, showed an apparent 'prozone' phenomenon in their reactivity against late but not early MA.     

Re-exposure of human lymphoblastoid cell lines to Epstein-Barr virus

Human lymphoblastoid lines of various origins which harbour Epstein-Barr virus (EBV)-specific nucleic acid were re-exposed to EBV. Following infection, cells of the non-virus-producing lines, Raji and S 95, predominantly synthesized EBV-specific early antigens (EA), whereas only a small percentage of cells revealed viral capsid antigens (VCA). In Raji cells, the number of VCA-producing cells was paralleled by the percentage of virus-specific DNA-synthesizing cells. In S 95 cells, however, viral DNA-synthesizing cells exceeded the number of VCA-producing cells by a factor of more than 10. Induction of EA in Raji cells was dose-dependent and inversely related to cell growth. Irradiation of the virus by ultraviolet light prior to infection led to reduced infectivity. This reduction seemed to follow single-hit kinetics. Raji cells, previously re-exposed to EBV, showed reduced EA induction after re-infection with EBV, as compared to Raji control cells not previously exposed. Of 10 lines which spontaneously synthesize EBV-specific antigens, seven lines proved to be refractory to re-infection, whereas three were as susceptible as the Raji and S 95 controls. From three of the refractory lines infectious virus could be recovered from the culture medium prior to infection. These results permit the following interpretations: (1) the response of human lymphoblastoid cells after re-infection with EBV results from the infecting virus and not from stimulation of endogenous genomes; (2) cells demonstrating EA synthesis ultimately die; (3) re-exposure to EBV increases the resistance to re-infection of the surviving cells; and (4) cell lines producing infectious EBV are refractory to re-infection. It is suggested that the spontaneous synthesis of infectious virus favours the selection of resistant cells.