The clinical significance of exhaled nitric oxide in asthma

Asthma is an inflammatory disease of the airways, for which many therapeutic options are available. Guidelines for the management of asthma suggest a stepwise approach to pharmacotherapy based on assessment of asthma severity and control. However, the assessment of asthma control presently relies on surrogate measures, such as the frequency of symptoms or the frequency of use of short-acting beta₂-adrenergic agonists. There is no simple, noninvasive technique for the assessment of severity of actual airway inflammation in asthma. The collection and analysis of nitric oxide (NO) levels in exhaled breath has recently become feasible in humans. Based on increased exhaled NO (eNO) levels in patients with asthma, eNO analysis has been proposed as a novel, noninvasive approach to the assessment and monitoring of airway inflammation, and as a basis for adjustments in asthma therapy. In the present paper, the relationship of elevated eNO levels in asthma with inflammatory, physiological and clinical markers of asthma in adults was reviewed. Use of eNO is a promising tool for diagnosing asthma, for monitoring asthma control and for guiding optimal anti-inflammatory asthma therapy. However, because of many unresolved questions, eNO cannot be recommended at present for routine clinical management of adults with asthma.     

Markers of airway inflammation and airway hyperresponsiveness in patients with well-controlled asthma.

In steroid-naive asthmatics, airway hyperresponsiveness correlates with noninvasive markers of airway inflammation. Whether this is also true in steroid-treated asthmatics, is unknown. In 31 stable asthmatics (mean age 45.4 yrs, range 22-69; 17 females) taking a median dose of 1,000 microg inhaled corticosteroids (ICS) per day (range 100-3,600 microg x day(-1)), airway responsiveness to the "direct" agent histamine and to the "indirect" agent mannitol, lung function (forced expiratory volume in one second (FEV1), forced vital capacity (FVC), peak expiratory flow (PEF)), exhaled nitric oxide (eNO), and number of inflammatory cells in induced sputum as a percentage of total cell count were measured. Of the 31 subjects, 16 were hyperresponsive to mannitol and 11 to histamine. The dose-response ratio (DRR: % fall in FEV1/cumulative dose) to both challenge tests was correlated (r=0.59, p=0.0004). However, DRR for histamine and DRR for mannitol were not related to basic lung function, eNO, per cent sputum eosinophils and ICS dose. In addition, NO was not related to basic lung function and per cent sputum eosinophils. In clinically well-controlled asthmatics taking inhaled corticosteroids, there is no relationship between markers of airway inflammation (such as exhaled nitric oxide and sputum eosinophils) and airway responsiveness to either direct (histamine) or indirect (mannitol) challenge. Airway hyperresponsiveness in clinically well-controlled asthmatics appears to be independent of eosinophilic airway inflammation.     

Clinical aspects of exhaled nitric oxide.

There has been intense research into the role nitric oxide (NO) plays in physiological and pathological mechanisms and its clinical significance in respiratory medicine. Elevated levels of exhaled levels of exhaled NO in asthma and other inflammatory lung diseases lead to many studies examining NO as potential markers of airway inflammation, enabling repeated noninvasive and standardized monitoring of airway inflammation. In airway inflammation, NO is not merely a marker but may have anti-inflammatory and pro-inflammatory effects. Significant correlation has been found between exhaled NO and skin test scores in steroid naive asthmatic patients, allowing to discriminate patients with and without airway responsiveness. Exhaled NO is significantly elevated in acute asthma, or steroid-resistant severe asthma, or when the maintenance dose of inhaled steroids is reduced, and quickly reduced down to the levels in patients with stable asthma after steroid treatment. Exhaled NO has been successfully used to monitor anti-inflammatory treatment with inhaled corticosteroids in asthma. Exhaled NO is extremely sensitive and rapid marker of the dose-dependent effect of steroid treatment, or asthma deterioration, which is increased to any changes in lung function, provocative concentration causing a 20% fall in forced expiratory volume, sputum eosinophilia or asthma symptoms. Exhaled NO is not increased in stable chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), but patients with unstable COPD, or bronchiectasis have high NO levels. Exhaled and nasal NO are diagnostically low in cystic fibrosis and primary pulmonary dyskinesia. Analysis of exhaled air, including nitric oxide, is feasible and could provide a noninvasive method for use in monitoring and management of lung diseases.     

Sputum induction leads to a decrease of exhaled nitric oxide unrelated to airflow.

Measurement of exhaled nitric oxide (eNO) and analysis of induced sputum are both established noninvasive methods for studying airway inflammation in asthma. Both methods are often used sequentially within short time frames. The aim of the present study was to evaluate the influence of sputum induction on eNO in adults and to follow the kinetics of airway eNO production after induction in relation to forced expiratory volume in one second (FEV1). eNO and FEV1 were measured in 41 adult patients (aged 29 (range 23-50) yrs, 56% male) with asymptomatic atopy or mild asthma (mean FEV1 97.2+/-3% predicted) prior to and immediately after sputum induction with hypertonic saline (4%). Sputum induction with isotonic saline was also performed in 13 subjects (control group). Repeatability of eNO decrease after sputum induction was also studied in 27 patients on separate occasions and kinetics of eNO production after sputum induction were followed over 24 h in another 10 patients. Sputum induction with hypertonic, but not isotonic, saline led to a marked decrease in eNO (log) immediately after the procedure (pre: 3.85+/-0.13 parts per billion (ppb); post: 3.24+/-0.14 ppb). This decrease was shown to be highly reproducible and not related to a fall in FEV1 following sputum induction. While FEV1 returned to baseline within 1 h, decreased eNO levels were observed over 4 h and returned to baseline after 24 h. Hypertonic saline sputum induction leads to a prolonged reduction in exhaled nitric oxide in adult atopics that is reproducible within subjects and not related to a reduction in airflow following sputum induction. This methodological interference should be taken into account when sputum induction and exhaled nitric oxide measurements are performed in the same subject.     

Clinical usefulness of inflammatory markers in asthma

Asthma is a significant and increasing health problem. Airway inflammation and hyperresponsiveness are key pathophysiological mechanisms underlying asthma. Currently, effective treatments target these two processes and can lead to clinically important improvements in disease control. At present, decisions to initiate or modify therapy are based on symptoms and measures of airway caliber, with no direct assessment of airway inflammation or hyperresponsiveness. It is now possible to measure airway inflammation using noninvasive markers such as exhaled gases, induced sputum and serum measurements. Exhaled nitric oxide (eNO) and induced sputum eosinophils show the greatest promise as clinically useful markers of airway inflammation in asthma. Induced sputum can now be applied to the diagnosis of airway diseases, based on its ability to detect eosinophilic bronchitis in cough, and to differentiate between eosinophilic and non-eosinophilic asthma. The place of induced sputum and eNO in the ongoing monitoring of patients with asthma are now being investigated in controlled trials.     

Relationship between exhaled air temperature and exhaled nitric oxide in childhood asthma.

Airway inflammation is a characteristic of asthma. Exhaled nitric oxide (eNO) has been demonstrated to be related to actual levels of airway inflammation in asthmatic patients. The purpose of this study was to investigate whether the temperature of exhaled air is related to eNO levels. Temperature of exhaled air and eNO were measured in 52 asthmatic children with a cross-sectional design. A significant relationship was demonstrated between eNO and temperature of peak and plateau exhaled air temperature. The relationship between both the peak and the plateau values and eNO was more evident when it was corrected for environmental temperature. These results suggest a relationship between exhaled nitric oxide and the temperature of exhaled air in asthmatic patients not treated with systemic steroids.     

Adenosine in exhaled breath condensate in healthy volunteers and in patients with asthma.

Persistent airway inflammation may require the use of different markers for monitoring airway inflammation. In this study, the authors investigated whether adenosine, which may be produced in allergic inflammatory conditions, could be measured with good reproducibility in exhaled breath condensate (EBC), and whether its concentration was elevated in patients with asthma. EBC adenosine and exhaled nitric oxide (eNO), a noninvasive marker of asthmatic airway inflammation, were measured in 40 healthy volunteers and 43 patients with allergic bronchial asthma. Repeatability of adenosine measurement was checked in 20 pairs of samples collected from healthy control subjects. Adenosine was detectable in all EBC samples by the applied high-performance liquid chromatographic method. The mean difference between repeated measurements of adenosine was -0.1 nM and all differences were within the coefficient of repeatability. Adenosine concentration was higher in steroid-naive patients (n=23) compared with healthy control subjects and steroid-treated patients (n=20). In patients with worsening symptoms of asthma (n=23), adenosine concentration was elevated compared with those in a stable condition (n=20). Furthermore, adenosine concentrations were related to eNO levels in asthmatic patients. These results, showing good reproducibility of adenosine measurements and increased adenosine concentrations in steroid-naive patients and in patients with worsening of asthmatic symptoms, indicate that adenosine measurement in exhaled breath condensate might be an acceptable novel method to investigate the role of local production of adenosine in the airways.     

Changes of exhaled nitric oxide during steroid treatment of childhood asthma.

Exhaled nitric oxide (eNO) is elevated in several inflammatory airway diseases and is significantly reduced by anti-inflammatory treatment with inhaled steroids. The aim of this randomized, open clinical trial was to evaluate eNO in relation to conventional lung function parameters at rest and after exercise during sequential changes of inhaled steroids in children with persistent asthma. The study consisted of a 4 week run-in period, a 4 week washout phase and a randomized treatment period during which only one group was treated again with inhaled budesonide. After run-in, eNO was reduced to normal values, and rose again during washout. In the patients randomized to steroid treatment, eNO was again decreased, whereas it remained unchanged in the untreated patients. Forced expiratory volume in one second and forced vital capacity at rest and after exercise improved significantly after run-in, but showed no difference after randomization. However there was a strong correlation of eNO with patient compliance. Exhaled nitric oxide was able to differentiate between children briefly treated with or without steroids, the conventional lung-function variables however could not. In practice exhaled nitric oxide may thus be a valuable parameter to monitor adherence to steroids, but less suitable to describe physiologically relevant impairments of lung function.     

Exhaled markers of inflammatory lung diseases: ready for routine monitoring?

Assessing airway inflammation is important for investigating the underlying mechanisms of many lung diseases, including asthma and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD). Yet these are not measured directly in routine clinical practice because of the difficulties in monitoring inflammation. The presence and type of airway inflammation can be difficult to detect clinically, and may result in delays in initiating appropriate therapy. Non-invasive monitoring may assist in differential diagnosis of lung diseases, assessment of their severity and response to treatment. There is increasing evidence that breath analysis may have an important place in the diagnosis and clinical management of asthma, COPD, primary ciliary dyskinesia (PCD) and other major lung disease. The article reviews whether current noninvasive measurements of exhaled gases, such as nitric oxide (NO), hydrocarbons, inflammatory markers exhaled breath condensate (EBC) are ready for routine use in clinical practice.     

Educational intervention decreases exhaled nitric oxide in farmers with occupational asthma.

Allergic occupational asthma is frequent in farming populations. As educational interventions can improve disease management, the short-term effect of an educational intervention in asthmatic farmers was evaluated on the basis of spirometric indices and exhaled nitric oxide fraction (F(eNO)). Farmers with occupational asthma (n = 81), mostly sensitised against cow dander and storage mites, participated in a 1-day educational programme. Outcome measures were assessed at baseline and after 4-6 weeks, using F(eNO), lung function and a questionnaire. Results were compared with those of a control group without intervention (n = 24). In the educational group, the proportion of subjects reporting work-related symptoms was reduced after the intervention. The F(eNO) decreased from a geometric mean of 28.2 to 25.7 ppb, and, in subjects with an elevated (>35 ppb) baseline F(eNO) (n = 32), from 59.7 to 49.2 ppb. The corresponding changes in the control group were 25.6 versus 27.7 ppb and 49.5 versus 48.1 ppb. Spirometric results were unaltered in the two groups. Thus exhaled nitric oxide fraction, a marker of allergic airway inflammation, indicated a beneficial effect of a short-term educational intervention in farmers with occupational asthma. This suggests a potential for exhaled nitric oxide fraction in assessing the efficacy of preventive measures within a short time with higher sensitivity than spirometry.     

Exhaled biomarkers

Assessing airway and lung inflammation is important for investigating the underlying mechanisms of asthma and COPD. Yet these cannot be measured directly in clinical research and practice because of the difficulties in monitoring inflammation. Noninvasive monitoring may assist in early recognition of asthma and COPD, assessment of its severity, and response to treatment, especially during disease exacerbations. There is increasing evidence that breath analysis may have an important place in clinical management of asthma and COPD. The article reviews the role of current noninvasive measurements of exhaled gases, such as nitric oxide (NO), inflammatory markers in exhaled breath condensate (EBC), and exhaled breath temperature, as well as novel methods in monitoring and management of asthma and COPD.     

Smoking is associated with an age-related decline in exhaled nitric oxide.

Age-related declines in forced expiratory volume in one second are accelerated in smokers. Smoking is associated with decreased exhaled nitric oxide fraction (F(eNO)). The aim of the present study was to determine the impact of age on F(eNO) in otherwise healthy smokers and nonsmokers. F(eNO) and serum cotinine levels were measured in 994 healthy subjects aged 18-40 yrs. American Thoracic Society questionnaire data on smoking habits was used to validate serum cotinine levels as a surrogate marker for categorisation of smokers and nonsmokers in the cohort. Serum cotinine levels were a good discriminator of smokers (n = 99) and nonsmokers (n = 895). F(eNO) levels were significantly lower in otherwise healthy smokers compared with nonsmokers. There was an inverse correlation of serum cotinine levels with F(eNO). No correlation of age with F(eNO) was found in nonsmokers but an inverse correlation of F(eNO) with age in smokers was found. F(eNO) was significantly lower in smokers aged 21-40 yrs compared with nonsmokers aged 21-40 yrs, but was not lower in smokers aged 18-20 yrs compared with nonsmokers of the same age. Smoking was associated with decreased exhaled nitric oxide. The greatest smoking-related declines in exhaled nitric oxide occurred in older subjects. This suggests that smoking is associated with age-related declines in exhaled nitric oxide and justifies future mechanistic studies that address the impact of exhaled nitric oxide decline on lung function.     

Clinical use of noninvasive measurements of airway inflammation in steroid reduction in children

The use of noninvasive methods of monitoring airway inflammation, such as exhaled nitric oxide (eNO) and induced sputum, has been shown to improve asthma monitoring and optimize treatment in adult patients with asthma. There is a lack of comparable data in children. Forty children with stable asthma eligible for inhaled steroid reduction were reviewed every 8 weeks, and their inhaled steroid dose halved if clinically indicated. eNO, sputum induction combined with bronchial hyperreactivity testing, and exhaled breath condensate collection were performed at each visit to predict success or failure of reduction of inhaled steroids. Thirty of 40 (75%) children tolerated at least one dose reduction, 12 of 40 (30%) were successfully weaned off, and in total, 15 of 40 (38%) children experienced loss of asthma control. Treatment reduction was successful in all children who had no eosinophils in induced sputum before the attempted reduction. Using multiple logistic regression, increased eNO (odds ratio, 6.3; confidence interval, 3.75-10.58) and percentage of sputum eosinophils (odds ratio, 1.38; confidence interval, 1.06-1.81) were significant predictors of failed reduction. These findings suggest that monitoring airway inflammation may be useful in optimizing treatment in children with asthma.     

In stable lung transplant recipients, exhaled nitric oxide levels positively correlate with airway neutrophilia and bronchial epithelial iNOS

In conditions characterized by airway inflammation, exhaled nitric oxide (eNO) levels are increased. Variable degrees of airway inflammation are present in stable lung transplant recipients (LTR), and may lead to airway remodeling and chronic graft dysfunction. The hypothesis tested is that in stable LTR, eNO concentrations would reflect the expression of inducible (iNOS) (but not constitutive [cNOS] nitric oxide synthase) in the bronchial epithelium as well as the degree of airway inflammation. We determined eNO concentrations in 20 stable LTR, free of infection, rejection, or obliterative bronchiolitis (OB). At routine bronchoscopy, we measured the differential cell count on bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) and a quantitative assessment of iNOS and cNOS expression in endobronchial biopsies by immunohistochemistry. Mean +/- SEM eNO concentrations in stable LTR were not significantly different from control subjects (13 +/- 0.7 ppb versus 14.2 +/- 0.49; p = 0.42). Percent BAL neutrophils was 11.5 +/- 3.2 which was significantly higher than in a group of local control subjects (1.7 +/- 0.6; p < 0.001). The bronchial epithelium and lamina propria contained abundant iNOS but cNOS was present only in the lamina propria. Using regression analysis, percent BAL neutrophils (r(2) = 0.82; p < 0.0001) and iNOS expression in the bronchial epithelium (r(2) = 0.75; p < 0.0001), but not in the lamina propria (r(2) = 0.16; p = 0.08), were positively predictive of eNO. There was an inverse relationship between cNOS and eNO. We conclude that eNO concentrations although normal for the group, still reflect the degree of airway inflammation in stable LTR. Epithelial iNOS appears to be the major source of eNO and expression of cNOS may be downregulated with increasing iNOS expression.     

Genetic and environmental effects on exhaled nitric oxide and airway responsiveness in a population-based sample of twins.

Elevated levels of exhaled nitric oxide (eNO) and airway hyperresponsiveness are intermediate phenotypes of asthma. Using population-based data collected from a sample of twins, the present authors estimated the relative contribution of genes, family environment and nonshared environmental influences to variations in eNO and airway responsiveness (AR). In addition, the genetic and environmental sources of covariation between these two asthma-related phenotypes were investigated. The study population comprised a random sample of 377 adult twins identified through the Norwegian Twin Registry. The main outcome variables were eNO and AR to methacholine. Genetic effects accounted for 60% of the variation in eNO. Family environment accounted for 30% of the variation in AR, while nonshared environmental influences explained the remaining variation for both measures. For both eNO and AR, there were significant regression effects for atopy and smoking. The small, but significant association between eNO and AR was primarily explained by genetic factors. Sub-analyses restricted to atopic and nonsmoking twins strengthened the observation. In conclusion, variations in exhaled nitric oxide and airway responsiveness appear to be explained by different genetic and environmental variance structures. Variation in exhaled nitric oxide is explained by genetic and nonshared environmental effects, whereas an environmental model best explains the variation in airway responsiveness. Common genetic effects explain the small but significant association between exhaled nitric oxide and airway responsiveness.     

Exhaled nitric oxide is not reduced in infants with cystic fibrosis.

Fractional exhaled nitric oxide (F(eNO)) has been reported to be reduced in cystic fibrosis (CF) patients. However, data from young children are conflicting and it is not clear whether this is a primary feature of the disease or a secondary response. The present study compared F(eNO) between CF and healthy infants using a validated single-breath technique. A total of 23 healthy infants (11 females; mean age 40.1 weeks) and 18 infants with CF (nine females; 64.9 weeks) underwent tests of lung function and F(eNO). Bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) was collected from all CF infants 2-5 days after lung function testing. There was no significant difference in F(eNO) between the CF and healthy infants (geometric mean: 23.1 parts per billion (ppb) and 17.0 ppb, respectively). There was an inverse relationship between age and F(eNO) in the CF patients, but not in the healthy group. Within the CF group, there was no association between F(eNO) and any marker of airway inflammation measured in the BAL. Exhaled nitric oxide is not reduced in cystic fibrosis infants, but does decrease with age. The current data indicate that F(eNO) is not a good marker of airway inflammation in cystic fibrosis.     

Exhaled nitric oxide in paediatric asthma

Assessment of airway function is difficult in young children with asthma, and in addition, only reflects the status of the disease at the time of the measurement. Thus, there is increasing interest in monitoring airway inflammation in asthma, which may provide a longer term assessment of disease activity. Most methods of assessing asthmatic inflammation are invasive, and are not feasible in the paediatric population. This review discusses exhaled nitric oxide as a marker of asthmatic inflammation, and compares it with other recognized markers. Exhaled nitric oxide has the potential to become a noninvasive method of assessing asthma control in the paediatric population.     

Exhaled NO and assessment of anti-inflammatory effects of inhaled steroid: dose-response relationship.

Exhaled nitric oxide (eNO) is an easily measured marker of airway inflammation. This study was undertaken to evaluate the usefulness of serial eNO in investigating the dose-response relationship for inhaled beclomethasone (BDP), and to compare eNO with other markers of airway inflammation. Following withdrawal of inhaled corticosteroid (ICS) therapy, 65 patients entered a double-blind, parallel-group, placebo-controlled trial of 50, 100, 200 or 500 microg x BDP x day(-1) for eight weeks. eNO and spirometry were performed weekly and a hypertonic saline challenge with sputum induction was performed at the beginning and end of treatment. The relationship between the dose of ICS and changes in eNO and forced expiratory volume in one second (FEV1) was linear at 1 week and at the end of treatment. A linear dose-response relationship was also seen for sputum eosinophils. Changes in eNO correlated significantly with changes in sputum eosinophils. Changes in the provocative dose of saline causing a 15% fall in FEV1 saline did not differ across the treatment groups nor did they correlate with changes in other measurements. Exhaled nitric oxide may be used to assess the dose-response relationship for the anti-inflammatory effects of inhaled beclomethasone. The relationship found in this study was linear over the dose range 0-500 microg x day(-1) soon after commencing therapy and continued over time.     

Latex allergen exposure increases exhaled nitric oxide in symptomatic healthcare workers.

The objective of this study was to investigate the clinical and diagnostic impact of baseline exhaled nitric oxide (eNO) levels and latex allergen-induced eNO changes in different healthcare worker groups. Healthcare workers, 31 latex-sensitised and 14 nonsensitised, underwent occupational-type challenge tests with powdered allergenic latex gloves. Sensitised as well as nonsensitised healthcare workers developed a significant eNO increase 1 h after challenge. Conversely, only latex-sensitised employees showed a significant eNO increase 22 h after challenge, which showed a significant relationship with bronchial obstruction (specific airway resistance changes). However, there was no difference in either baseline eNO level or eNO increase after 22 h between asthmatic (n = 13) and rhinitic only (n = 20) responders. The specificity and sensitivity of a 50% eNO increase after 22 h in responders were 100 and 56%, respectively. These results support the assumption that the whole respiratory tract is involved in a combined allergic rhinitis and asthma syndrome. Smoking healthcare workers showed reduced baseline exhaled nitric oxide levels, but, as shown for the first time, an allergen-induced exhaled nitric oxide increase comparable to that of nonsmokers. Corticosteroid therapy inhibited the allergen-induced exhaled nitric oxide change but not the clinical response in the challenge test. These findings suggest that cigarette smoke and corticosteroids initiate distinct molecular mechanisms influencing nitric oxide concentrations in the airways.     

Exhaled nitric oxide in bronchiectasis: the effects of inhaled corticosteroid therapy.

SETTING: While exhaled nitric oxide (eNO) levels are reduced by inhaled corticosteroid therapy in asthma, such treatment effect is unclear in bronchiectasis. DESIGN: Stable non-smoking bronchiectasis patients were randomised to receive either fluticasone (1 mg/daily) or identical placebo via the Accuhaler device. RESULTS: Sixty non-smoking patients (38 women; mean age 56.4 +/- 12.7 years) were recruited. Of these, half received inhaled fluticasone and half placebo therapy. eNO was measured using a chemiluminescence analyser at 0, 4, 12, 24, 36 and 52 weeks. There was no significant difference in eNO levels between fluticasone and placebo patients over the study period. There was no correlation between baseline eNO with age, FEV1, FVC, 24 h sputum volume or number of bronchiectatic segments. Patients with Pseudomonas aeruginosa (PA) infection, but not their counterparts, displayed a correlation between 0- and 52-week eNO levels. PA infection was associated with significantly lower eNO levels among the patients. CONCLUSIONS: Inhaled fluticasone therapy, despite being an effective anti-inflammatory agent, has no significant effect on eNO production, either at individual time points or over the entire 52-week profile, in bronchiectasis. It appears that eNO might not reflect the extent of airway inflammation in bronchiectasis.