Optimal electrocardiographically triggered phase for reducing motion artifact at electron-beam CT in the coronary artery

RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES: The authors performed this study to (a) investigate coronary movement with electron-beam computed tomography (CT) and (b) find the optimal electrocardiographic (ECG) triggering phase for eliminating motion artifact. MATERIALS AND METHODS: One hundred fifty-one patients without arrhythmia were examined with electron-beam CT. First, movie scans were obtained to create displacement and velocity graphs of coronary artery movement. Then, a volume scan with an exposure time of 100 msec was obtained with various ECG trigger settings. RESULTS: Movement patterns of coronary arteries varied with heart rate. Optimal triggering phase was before atrial systole (near 71% of the R-R interval) when heart rate was slower than 68 beats per minute and at ventricular end systole when heart rate was fast. Rate of severe motion artifacts decreased from 43% to 0% when triggering was altered from 80% of the R-R interval to the individual optimal value. Experimental values of the optimal phase at different heart rates were derived, and severe motion artifact was only 3.0% with these values. CONCLUSION: ECG triggering set according to the heart rate enables a great reduction in motion artifacts at electron-beam CT with a 100-msec exposure time. The results may have implications for magnetic resonance imaging of the coronary artery.     

Report on the 86th Scientific Assembly and Annual Meeting of the Radiological Society of North America: motion artifact caused by heart pulsation observed on an electron beam and a multidetector-row CT

Recently developed technologies in CT imaging have allowed higher temporal resolution and less motion artifacts caused by heart pulsation. However, complete deletion of motion artifacts has not altogether been accomplished. In interpreting images, differentiation of motion artifacts and true lesion is essential. In this exhibition, the ascending aorta, outer contour of the heart, valve, lung adjacent to the heart, and other structures in the mediastinum are demonstrated focusing on the characteristics of motion artifact. Images obtained with an electron beam CT (Imatron 150XL) and a MDCT (LightSpeed QX/i, GEMS) are comparatively demonstrated. In electron beam CT, the temporal resolution ranged from 50 msec to 2,000 msec. In multidetector-row CT, half reconstruction algorithm (500 msec) and newly developed algorithm (130 msec) can be applied to reduce temporal resolution, although temporal resolution (800msec) of a full scan is fixed. Degree, shape, and site at which motion artifacts arise are analyzed with respect to the temporal resolution on two different CT systems. Learning objectives: Motion artifacts are correlated with the temporal resolution of the CT scanner. Electron beam and multidetector row CT provides different kinds of solutions to reduce motion artifacts.     

Artifacts in spiral CT protocols: The importance of the spatial reconstruction

Purpose

This study recorded and analysed streak and motion artifacts in spiral CT examinations and evaluated the elimination and minimization of them by the use of segmental reconstruction with and without alterations of the initial examination protocol.

Materials and methods

One hundred CT scans of the chest and 300 CT scans of the brain have been included in this study. All studies were performed by a helical CT scanner (Philips 5000 SR) with the standard protocol and were randomly selected due to the presence of either streak or motion artifacts. Segmental reconstruction was applied in all cases by the same experienced radiographer. Image evaluation was performed by two experienced radiologists using a scoring system for each artifact and a grading system for classifying post-processing images.

Results

Among series of images that were evaluated after the application of segmental reconstruction, brain examinations demonstrated the following results: 10.9% of the cases showed no artifact improvement, 19.6% showed slight artifact improvement 31.5% showed moderate improvement and 38% showed significant improvement. The results of chest examinations were as follows: 27% of the cases showed no artifact improvement, 23% showed slight artifact improvement, 26% showed moderate improvement and 24% of showed significant improvement. Spatial reconstruction was useless in brain CT images when a patient moved during the entire scan and in chest CT images when streak and motion artifacts co-existed.

Conclusions

Spatial reconstruction may improve the image quality in brain and chest CT examinations and thus may contribute to more diagnostic images. Elimination of motion artifacts is also suggested due to the limitation of intravenous contrast medium that can be administered per patient per day and in cases of non-cooperative patients.     

Forty-millisecond MR imaging of the abdomen at 2.0 T

The ability of an ultrafast magnetic resonance (MR) imaging technique to provide abdominal MR images free of motion artifacts was studied. Individual T2-weighted transverse MR images were acquired in as little as 40 msec on a whole-body system operating at 2.0 T. Clinical evaluation was undertaken with fat-suppressed images in which only protons of water molecules contributed to image signal intensity. The ultrafast MR images were compared with conventional MR images obtained at 0.6 T. In 22 patients and two healthy volunteers, ultrafast MR images were of diagnostic quality and free of motion artifacts. Images obtained at an echo time (TE) of 30 msec (imaging time, 40 msec) had liver signal-to-noise ratios of 56.3 +/- 22.6 (n = 19). Because of a smaller data matrix, ultrafast MR images had soft-tissue interfaces that were less sharp than those of the highest-quality conventional MR images in which no motion artifacts were present. However, ultrafast MR images demonstrated high T2-dependent soft-tissue contrast, and pathologic and normal anatomies were readily detected with both imaging techniques. This ultrafast imaging technique has significant promise in whole-body MR imaging, in which motion artifacts often degrade image quality.     

CT反向扫描对消除慢阻肺患者呼吸运动伪影的应用价值

目的 探讨CT反向扫描对消除慢阻肺(COPD)患者在CT扫描中呼吸运动伪影的价值. 方法 随机抽取40例COPD志愿受检者,采用GR-Helical肺扫描技术进行顺向和反向扫描,所获得的图像由3名高年资影像诊断医师进行双盲质量评价. 结果 40例病例中,出现呼吸运动伪影17例,其中70.59%居下肺野,64.7%好发于60岁以上人群.顺向扫描伪影率为35%,经反向扫描伪影率降低到7.5%,下肺野未见明显伪影,图像质量提高了27.5%,2种扫描方法在统计学上具有显著性差异(P<0.05 ). 结论 CT反向扫描可有效抑制和消除下肺野呼吸运动伪影的发生,是慢阻肺患者的首选扫描技术.     

Clinical potentials of the prototype 256-detector row CT-scanner

RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES: To evaluate clinical potentials of the 256-detector row computed tomography (CT) in healthy volunteers. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Eight healthy males (22-63 years) participated in the present study. They underwent a noncontrast-enhanced examination with a contiguous axial scan mode either for head, chest, abdomen, or pelvis. Dose was the same as routinely used for multislice CT examinations. Image quality was interpreted by three board-certified radiologists. RESULTS: With the 256-detector row CT, 0.5-0.8 mm isotropic volumetric data could be acquired in one rotation. Main promising findings are as follows. Three-dimensional structures were visualized clearly in the multiple planes without secondary reconstruction, whereas the axial images had nearly the same image quality as conventional CT. Shading or streak artifacts were observed at the edge of the scan region. The latter are also known as Feldkamp artifacts. Coronal chest images showed a motion artifact from the heart beating. CONCLUSION: The 256-detector row CT promises to be useful in clinical applications with its ability to provide three-dimensional visualization of fine structures. The Feldkamp artifacts observed did not generally affect interpretation of images. Investigations are now continuing on image correction along the craniocaudal direction to improve the overall image quality.     

Malignant right coronary artery anomaly simulated by motion artifacts on MDCT

OBJECTIVE: The aim of our study was to determine the prevalence of anomalous right coronary artery imitation due to motion artifacts in MDCT. Routine chest MDCT for reasons other than cardiac or vascular imaging is usually performed using breath-hold technique but without retrospective ECG gating and consequently yields pulsating motion artifacts. A possible artifact in front of the aortic root imitates an anomalous right coronary artery originating from the left posterior sinus. This course of the right coronary artery is considered a malignant variant and raises the question of far-reaching consequences such as a bypass operation. SUBJECTS AND METHODS: We performed a prospective study involving 355 patients undergoing routine chest CT examinations. To determine the prevalence of anomalous right coronary artery imitation caused by this motion artifact, all images were evaluated prospectively by an experienced radiologist. RESULTS: Twenty-one patients (5.9%) were suspected of having a malignant variant of the right coronary artery. However, in all patients prior chest CT or additional coronary MR angiography showed a normal origin of the right coronary artery. CONCLUSION: Routine chest MDCT without retrospective ECG gating may produce artifacts around the aorta simulating a malignant variant of the right coronary artery. Considering the low incidence of this malignant interarterial variant, the need for routine chest CT examinations combined with ECG gating and further workup can be disputed from an economic point of view. This artifact should be known to avoid unnecessary further examinations.     

Optimization of the Scan Protocol for the Reduction of Diaphragmatic Motion Artifacts Depicted on CT Angiography: a Phantom Study Simulating Pediatric Patients with Free Breathing

Objective

This study was designed to optimize the scan protocol of CT angiography to reduce diaphragmatic motion artifacts in pediatric patients with free-breathing.

Materials and Methods

A phantom with twelve tubes with different diameters was constructed. To simulate free-breathing, the phantom was connected to a motor, and the phantom moved along the axis of scan. Scans were performed under several conditions: different pitch (1, 1.5) and gantry rotation time (0.37 and 0.75 sec), and different movement range (1 cm, 3 cm) and rates (20/min, 40/min). For CT scanning, a 16-channel CT scanner was used and fixed factors of the CT protocol were as follows: 100 effective mAs, 80 kVp, reconstruction with a soft-algorithm, beam collimation 16×75 mm, reconstruction thickness of 1 mm, and an interval of 0.5 mm. CT scans were repeated five times. Each tube was evaluated with the use of a grading system (0 for images where tubes were not discriminable and 2 for images where tubes were clearly discriminable).

Results

A higher pitch and shorter gantry rotation time produced images with a higher grade. Average grades for the higher pitch (1.5) and faster gantry rotation time (0.37 sec) for each combination of movement were as follows: 1.94 (range 1 cm and rate 20/min), 1.42 (range 1 cm and rate 40/min), 0.86 (range 3 cm and rate 20/min) and 0.52 (range 3 cm and rate 40/min). Average grades for the lower pitch (1) and slower gantry rotation time (0.75 sec) for each combination of movement were 1.08, 0.56, 0.32 and 0.08, respectively.

Conclusion

The scanning speed and especially the pitch are important parameters for CT scans to overcome a respiratory motion artifact.     

Motion artifacts in subsecond conventional CT and electron-beam CT: pictorial demonstration of temporal resolution.

To visually demonstrate the effective temporal resolution of subsecond conventional (slip-ring) and electron-beam computed tomographic (CT) systems, two phantoms containing high-contrast test objects were scanned with a slip-ring CT system (effective exposure time, 0.5 second) and an electron-beam CT system (exposure time, 0.1 second). Images were acquired of each phantom at rest, during translation along the x axis at speeds of 10-100 mm/sec, and during rotation about isocenter at speeds of 0.1 and 0.5 revolution per second. Motion artifacts and loss of spatial resolution were judged to be absent, noticeable, or severe. For 0.5-second conventional CT images, motion artifacts and loss of spatial resolution were noticeable at 10 mm/sec and 0.1 revolution per second and were severe at speeds greater than or equal to 20 mm/sec and at 0.5 revolution per second. For 0.1-second electron-beam CT scans, noticeable, but not severe, motion artifacts and loss of spatial resolution occurred at speeds between 40 and 100 mm/sec and at 0.5 revolution per second. Over the range of physiologic speeds examined, the images provide visually compelling evidence of the effect of improving temporal resolution in CT.     

心肌灌注显像中位移伪影的辨析

目的 探讨心肌灌注显像时位移伪影的影像学特征、不同轴向、发生位移起始点和帧数与伪影的相关性。方法 在心肌显像过程中依次沿x,y和z轴方向,分别在不同起始点,对不同帧数作一定距离的位移。其图像与正常对照比较判断有无伪影。结果作多因素分析。结果 轻度位移伪影的特征为：x轴位移表现为下壁突出的结节状热区;y轴位移表现为间隔和侧壁呈对称分布的热区;z轴位移表现为前壁的局部热区;这些表现仅见于短轴像上。重度伪影表现为“三角形”分布的壁内热区以及典型的“双三角形”改变。位移距离相同,方向相反,伪影的“冷”“热”分布的壁内热区以及典型的“双三角形”改变。位移距离相同,方向相反,伪影的“冷”“热”区位置相反。伪影与位移帧数和轴向有关,与起始点无关。结论 不同轴向位移伪影各有特征。移动帧数和y轴位移对伪影产生的影响最大。     

Conventional and fast spin-echo MR imaging: Minimizing echo time

Magnetic resonance imaging is frequently complicated by the presence of motion and susceptibility gradients. Also, some biologic tissues have short T2s. These problems are particularly troublesome in fast spin-echo (FSE) imaging, in which T2 decay and motion between echoes result in image blurring and ghost artifacts. The authors reduced TE in conventional spin-echo (SE) imaging to 5 msec and echo spacing (E-space) in FSE imaging to 6 msec. All magnetic gradients (except readout) were kept at a maximum, with data sampling as fast as 125 kHz and only ramp waveforms used. Truncated sine radio-frequency pulses and asymmetric echo sampling were also used in SE imaging. Short TE (5.8 msec) SE images of the upper abdomen were compared with conventional SE images (TE =11 msec). Also, FSE images with short E-space were compared with conventional FSE images in multiple body sites. Short TE significantly improved the liver-spleen contrast-to-total noise ratio (C/N) (7.9 vs 4.1, n = 9, P <.01) on T1-weighted SE images, reduced the intensity of ghost artifacts (by 34%, P <.02), and increased the number of available imaging planes by 30%. It also improved delineation of cranial nerves and reduced susceptibility artifacts. On short E-space FSE images, spine, lung, upper abdomen, and musculoskeletal tissues appeared crisper and measured spleen-liver C/N increased significantly (6.9 vs 4.0, n = 12, P <.01). The delineation of tissues with short T2 (eg, cartilage) and motion artifact suppression were also improved. Short TE methods can improve image quality in both SE and FSE imaging and merit further clinical evaluation.     

Free-breathing inner-volume black-blood imaging of the human heart using two-dimensionally selective local excitation at 3 T

Black-blood fast spin-echo imaging is a powerful technique for the evaluation of cardiac anatomy. To avoid fold-over artifacts, using a sufficiently large field of view in phase-encoding direction is mandatory. The related oversampling affects scanning time and respiratory chest motion artifacts are commonly observed. The excitation of a volume that exclusively includes the heart without its surrounding structures may help to improve scan efficiency and minimize motion artifacts. Therefore, and by building on previously reported inner-volume approach, the combination of a black-blood fast spin-echo sequence with a two-dimensionally selective radiofrequency pulse is proposed for selective "local excitation" small field of view imaging of the heart. This local excitation technique has been developed, implemented, and tested in phantoms and in vivo. With this method, small field of view imaging of a user-specified region in the human thorax is feasible, scanning becomes more time efficient, motion artifacts can be minimized, and additional flexibility in the choice of imaging parameters can be exploited.     

Pseudo-gating: elimination of periodic motion artifacts in magnetic resonance imaging without gating

This note explains and illustrates a technique of reducing artifacts produced by periodic motion without using physiologic gating. The method is simple and can be applied on any standard MRI unit. For periodic motion, effective gating can be attained by setting the product of the number of acquisitions (at each phase-encoding step), N, times the repeat time, TR, equal to the period of the motion, T. This pseudo-gating can be used with any TR but, if changes in the period occur, is most robust with short TR values. The method is also applicable to multislice and volume imaging. For fast field echo methods, the above rule can be used if the period of the motion is smaller than the total scan time. Otherwise, the scan need only be repeated N times to avoid artifacts and improve signal-to-noise. The method has been implemented to remove both respiratory and/or cardiac motion artifacts.     

Placenta Accreta: MRI antenatal diagnosis and surgical correlation

We describe a case of a placenta previa accreta that was diagnosed antenatally by MRI with subsequent surgical confirmation. We show the advantages of ultrafast MRI single shot (SS) fast spin echo (FSE) techniques for accurate diagnosis with minimal scan time and fetal motion artifacts.     

Change in the z-axis location of the sternal notch in an arms-raised vs arms-down position on CT examinations

The aim of the study was to determine whether the sternal notch changes in its z-axis position in the arms raised vs arms down position on CT scans. A retrospective study was made of 132 consecutive CT scans of the neck and chest. We recorded the table position of the sternal notch and the most inferior slice through the thyroid gland on both scans, and the table position on the chest CT where the configuration of the head and neck vessels most closely corresponded to their configuration on the sternal notch slice of the neck CT. The sternal notch moved up an average of 8.4 mm (p<0.0001) when the arms were raised. In 44 cases (33.3%), the sternal notch moved up by > or =10 mm. In 6% of cases, the sternal notch moved upwards > or =20 mm. There was a slightly greater upward movement of the sternum in males of 2.57 mm (p = 0.0208). Mean upward motion of the sternal notch relative to the vessels was 7.74 mm (p<0.0001). Mean upward motion of the sternal notch relative to the thyroid was 8.98 mm (p<0.0001). In conclusion, the sternal notch moves upwards relative to the CT table and soft tissues in the neck and upper mediastinum when the arms are raised; the degree of upward motion is greater in males. This may have implications when categorizing nodes at the cervicothoracic junction on staging CT examinations, when deciding if nodes might be accessible to ultrasound-guided biopsy, and in classifying goitres.     

Optimal ECG Trigger Point in Electron-Beam CT Studies: Three Methods for Minimizing Motion Artifacts

RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES: The authors hypothesized that electrocardiographic triggering near end systole could minimize motion artifacts in electron-beam computed tomography (CT) of the coronary artery. MATERIALS AND METHODS: The study included 2,660 patients who underwent coronary artery calcium scanning with electron-beam CT. Trigger times were as follows: end of T wave, 120 to 25 msec before end of T wave, 25-50 msec after end of T wave, 40%, 45%, 50%, 55%, 60%, 70%, 75%, 80%, 90%, and 100% of R-R interval. The authors divided each group into seven subgroups according to heart rate. The percentages of cases with motion artifact in the right coronary artery were computed. Optimal trigger times were defined for each group, as well as for scan acquisitions of 250 and 200 msec. RESULTS: The optimal trigger times were as follows for heart rates of less than 50, 51-60, 61-70, 71-80, 81-90, 91-100, and more than 100 beats per minute, respectively: for 100-msec scans, 359 (27% of the R-R interval), 228 (31%), 314 (34%), 304 (38%), 289 (41%), 283 (45%), and 274 msec (48%) after the R wave; for 250-msec scans, 840 (63%), 654 (60%), 240 (26%), 224 (28%), 219 (31%), 208 (33%), and 200 msec (35%) after the R wave; and for 200-msec scans, 722 (65%), 687 (63%), 249 (27%), 248 (31%), 244 (35%), 233 (37%), and 223 msec (39%) after the R wave. CONCLUSION: The use of these new electrocardiographic triggers before end systole yielded the lowest percentage of motion artifacts (<3% across all heart rates), much lower than for conventional triggers (51% of cases with motion artifact for 80% trigger, P < .001).     

Band artifacts due to bulk motion.

Band artifacts due to bulk motion were investigated in images acquired with fast gradient echo sequences. A simple analytical calculation shows that the width of the artifacts has a square-root dependence on the velocity of the imaged object, the time taken to acquire each line of k-space and the field of view in the phase-encoding direction. The theory furthermore predicts that the artifact width can be reduced using parallel imaging by a factor equal to the square root of the acceleration parameter. The analysis and results are presented for motion in the phase- and frequency-encoding directions and comparisons are made between sequential and centric ordering. The theory is validated in phantom experiments, in which bulk motion is simulated in a controlled and reproducible manner by rocking the scan table back and forth along the bore axis. Preliminary cardiac studies in healthy human volunteers show that dark bands may be observed in the endocardium in images acquired with nonsegmented fast gradient echo sequences. The fact that the position of the bands changes with the phase-encoding direction suggests that they may be artifacts due to motion of the heart walls during the image acquisition period.     

DTI常用扫描序列原理及比较

磁共振弥散张量成像技术是利用水分子的弥散各向异性进行成像,可用于脑白质纤维研究,常用扫描技术包括单次激发平面回波成像(EPI),线阵扫描弥散成像,导航自旋回波弥散加权成像(LSDI),半傅立叶探测单发射快速自旋回波成像等。每种成像技术各有其优缺点,EPI扫描时间短,图像信噪比高,但存在化学位移伪影、磁敏感性伪影、几何变形;LSDI精确度高,几乎无伪影及变形,但扫描时间过长;导航自旋回波弥散加权成像运动伪影少,但扫描时间长;半傅立叶探测单发射快速自旋回波成像扫描时间短,但图像模糊。综合比较,单次激发平面回波成像是用于临床研究较适宜的方法。     

Physical evaluation of the weighted Feldkamp algorithms applied to the 256-detector row CT scanner for volumetric cine imaging

RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES: To improve effective scan time and image quality in cone-beam computed tomography (CT), Parker's weighting function (half scan [HS]-Feldkamp-Davis-Kress [FDK]) extended to a larger range up to 2pi was proposed as new half-scan algorithm (NHS-FDK). We conducted a practical physical evaluation of NHS-FDK and HS-FDK using 256-detector row CT. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Three types of weighting function (full-scan [FS-FDK], HS-FDK, and NHS-FDK) were evaluated by using 256-detector row CT for five variables, ie, point spread function, image noise, CT number uniformity, Feldkamp artifact, temporal resolution, and clinical evaluation. RESULTS: Image noise, Feldkamp artifact, and temporal resolution were dependent on weighting function. Image noise magnitude was independent of projection angle for all regions of interest with FS-FDK, but showed a symmetric pattern with projection angle with HS-FDK and NHS-FDK. With regard to temporal resolution, NHS-FDK did not remove the motion artifact in the heart except in such slower motion organs as the pulmonary vessels, whereas HS-FDK reduced the motion artifact in the heart. HS-FDK had an even more incomplete data region in the Radon space than FS-FDK, suggesting that it would provide poor image quality distant to the midplane in the longitudinal direction. In practical testing in human subjects, HS-FDK showed inferior performance in all variables except temporal resolution. CONCLUSION: Despite its inferiority to FS-FDK for static objects, HS-FDK may be useful in chest imaging. Contrary to previous findings using static images, NHS-FDK failed to show advantages over HS-FDK or FS-FDK in a moving phantom and human subjects.     

Trial of artifact reduction in body diffusion weighted imaging development and basic examination of "TRacking Only Navigator"(TRON method)

In recent years, the utility of body diffusion weighted imaging as represented by diffusion weighted whole body imaging with background body signal suppression (DWIBS), the DWIBS method, is very high. However, there was a problem in the DWIBS method involving the artifact corresponding to the distance of the diaphragm. To provide a solution, the respiratory trigger (RT) method and the navigator echo method were used together. A problem was that scan time extended to the compensation and did not predict the extension rate, although both artifacts were reduced. If we used only navigator real time slice tracking (NRST) from the findings obtained by the DWIBS method, we presumed the artifacts would be ameliorable without the extension of scan time. Thus, the TRacking Only Navigator (TRON) method was developed, and a basic examination was carried out for the liver. An important feature of the TRON method is the lack of the navigator gating window (NGW) and addition of the method of linear interpolation prior to NRST. The method required the passing speed and the distance from the volunteer's diaphragm. The estimated error from the 2D-selective RF pulse (2DSRP) of the TRON method to slice excitation was calculated. The condition of 2D SRP, which did not influence the accuracy of NRST, was required by the movement phantom. The volunteer was scanned, and the evaluation and actual scan time of the image quality were compared with the RT and DWIBS methods. Diaphragm displacement speed and the quantity of displacement were determined in the head and foot directions, and the result was 9 mm/sec, and 15 mm. The estimated error was within 2.5 mm in b-factor 1000 sec/mm(2). The FA of 2DSRP was 15 degrees, and the navigator echo length was 120 mm, which was excellent. In the TRON method, the accuracy of NRST was steady because of line interpolation. The TRON method obtained image quality equal to that of the RT method with the b-factor in the volunteer scanning at short actual scan time. The TRON method can obtain image quality equal to that of the RT method in body diffusion weighted imaging within a short time. Moreover, because scan time during planning becomes actual scan time, inspection can be efficiently executed.