In vitro radiosensitivity measured in lymphocytes and fibroblasts by colony formation and comet assay: comparison with clinical acute reactions to radiotherapy in breast cancer patients

Purpose : To compare colony-forming and comet assays on fibroblasts and lymphocytes of 32 breast cancer patients irradiated after breast-conserving operations and to correlate the results with acute clinical radiation reactions in the skin. Material and methods : Skin fibroblasts were isolated and cultivated before radiotherapy and lymphocytes were drawn prior to the first and directly after the final external irradiation. The colony-forming assay was performed with fibroblasts and the comet assay with lymphocytes and fibroblasts of breast cancer patients according to standard protocols. The clinical radiation reactions of the patients were graded according to the RTOG system. Results : No significant correlation (p =0.09) was detected between clinical acute skin reactions and the in vitro clonogenic data in fibroblasts. Results of the comet assay in lymphocytes, however, showed a significant correlation (p <0.05) with the clinical data when patients were divided into two groups with average and elevated acute reactions. Apart from initial damage, fibroblasts did not show significant differences between the two patient groups. Repeated comet assays in lymphocytes of the same patient drawn before treatment and before and after external radiotherapy demonstrated good reproducibility of the test and no significant impact of preceding radiation treatment. There was a good correlation (r =0.65) between the comet assay results in fibroblasts and lymphocytes of the same individual. Conclusions : In this cohort of patients, a significant correlation between the in vitro results of the comet assay in lymphocytes and clinical acute reactions was detected. The results of the comet assay and of fibroblast colony formation did not correlate with in vitro radiosensitivity.     

In vitro radiosensitivity measured in lymphocytes and fibroblasts by colony formation and comet assay: comparison with clinical acute reactions to radiotherapy in breast cancer patients

PURPOSE: To compare colony-forming and comet assays on fibroblasts and lymphocytes of 32 breast cancer patients irradiated after breast-conserving operations and to correlate the results with acute clinical radiation reactions in the skin. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Skin fibroblasts were isolated and cultivated before radiotherapy and lymphocytes were drawn prior to the first and directly after the final external irradiation. The colony-forming assay was performed with fibroblasts and the comet assay with lymphocytes and fibroblasts of breast cancer patients according to standard protocols. The clinical radiation reactions of the patients were graded according to the RTOG system. RESULTS: No significant correlation (p =0.09) was detected between clinical acute skin reactions and the in vitro clonogenic data in fibroblasts. Results of the comet assay in lymphocytes, however, showed a significant correlation (p <0.05) with the clinical data when patients were divided into two groups with average and elevated acute reactions. Apart from initial damage, fibroblasts did not show significant differences between the two patient groups. Repeated comet assays in lymphocytes of the same patient drawn before treatment and before and after external radiotherapy demonstrated good reproducibility of the test and no significant impact of preceding radiation treatment. There was a good correlation (r =0.65) between the comet assay results in fibroblasts and lymphocytes of the same individual. CONCLUSIONS: In this cohort of patients, a significant correlation between the in vitro results of the comet assay in lymphocytes and clinical acute reactions was detected. The results of the comet assay and of fibroblast colony formation did not correlate with in vitro radiosensitivity.     

Analysis of the Action of the Restriction Endonuclease AluI Using Three Different Comet Assay Protocols

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: The comet assay offers the opportunity to measure the amount of DNA damage and the effectiveness of DNA repair in single cells. In a first part, experiments are presented comparing three different protocols of the comet assay technique with respect to the analysis of the induction of DNA damage after X-irradiation in isolated human lymphocytes and CHO cells. In a second part, the restriction enzyme AluI, an agent producing DNA double-strand breaks exclusively, was introduced into CHO cells by electroporation and the effects were analyzed using the different comet assay protocols. The experiments were carried out in order to test the assertion that comet assay techniques can measure different types of DNA damages at different pH conditions of lysis and electrophoresis. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Three different comet assay protocols were used for the analysis of DNA damage in lymphocytes and CHO cells. RESULTS: The results clearly indicate that among the three protocols the modified comet assay technique used by the authors showed the highest sensitivity in the radiotherapy-relevant dose range between 0 and 2 Gy. All three protocols were capable of detecting an effect by AluI. This effect, however, was clearly different from radiation effects. Whereas after radiation exposure all cell nuclei show a dose-dependent increase in DNA content in the comet tail, most of the cell nuclei were unaffected by an AluI uptake. Nevertheless, there was an effect by AluI that could be detected in all three assay versions: between 5% and 15% of the nuclei showed clearly abnormal comet morphologies. CONCLUSION: Neither the strictly alkaline nor the strictly neutral comet assay is applicable in the radiation dose range of about 2 Gy. The restriction enzyme results show that other factors than just DNA strand breaks contribute to DNA migration into the tail of the comets.     

Relationships between acute reactions to radiotherapy in head and neck cancer patients and parameters of radiation-induced DNA damage and repair in their lymphocytes

PURPOSE: To study the relationship between lymphocyte radiosensitivity measured in vitro and acute reactions to radiotherapy in patients with head and neck cancer. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Acute reactions were measured in 34 patients using the Dische scale. Lymphocyte radiosensitivity was measured using the alkaline comet assay, the micronucleus assay, the nuclear division index and morphological assessment of apoptosis. RESULTS: There was a weak, statistically significant correlation between in vitro radiosensitivity measured as the rate of DNA damage repair and the cumulative radiation dose exerting the maximum acute reaction scored (r = -0.366, p = 0.039, n = 34). Subgroup analyses showed that for patients with a low level of radiation-induced DNA damage there was a statistically significant relationship between lymphocyte radiosensitivity measured as inhibition of proliferation and acute toxicity (r = -0.621, p = 0.007, n = 18). For patients with a high level of residual DNA damage, there was a relationship between lymphocyte radiosensitivity measured using the micronucleus assay and acute toxicity (r = -0.597, p = 0.023, n = 14). CONCLUSIONS: Combining two measures of radiosensitivity improves the ability to correlate in vitro lymphocyte radiosensitivity and acute radiotherapy toxicity data.     

Optimization and Standardization of the “Comet Assay” for Analyzing the Repair of DNA Damage in Cells

BACKGROUND: The "comet assay" has become an interesting and a very useful tool for the analysis of the induction and amount of DNA damage in single cells thus offering the opportunity to measure the effectiveness of DNA repair. On the basis of the Ostling and Johanson protocol we have developed a modified method with increased sensitivity and high reproducibility. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Human tumor cells or isolated human peripheral blood lymphocytes were analyzed in the experiments. The amount of DNA damage and the effectiveness of DNA repair was measured after X-irradiation using the "comet assay" technique. RESULTS: In this presentation the influences of different methodological factors like agarose concentration, buffer pH, electrophoresis time, electric field strength on the applicability of the "comet assay" are described in detail and optimum conditions for "comet assay" experiments have been evaluated. Additionally the authors will show a comparison of different fluorescent DNA dyes pointing out their advantages or disadvantages for "comet" analysis. The usefulness of this technique and its capabilities are exemplified by showing DNA repair kinetics of human lymphocytes of different healthy or radiosensitive donors after in-vitro irradiation with 2 Gy X-rays. CONCLUSIONS: This paper presents data on the optimization and standardization of the original "comet assay" leading to an extremely fast and practicable protocol in the field of single cell gel electrophoresis. After irradiation with 0.1 Gy an increase in the amount of DNA damage can be measured with high statistical significance and the DNA repair capacity of individual cells after X-ray doses of 2 Gy can be analyzed with high reproducibility. The results comparing DNA repair capacities of different donors point out that the "comet assay" may have the potential for the estimation of individual radiosensitivity.     

Association between plasma proteome profiles analysed by mass spectrometry,a lymphocyte-based DNA-break repair assay and radiotherapy-induced acute mucosal reaction in head and neck cancer patients

Purpose:?The plasma proteome was analysed as a potential source of markers of radiosensitivity in patients treated with definitive radiotherapy for head and neck cancer.

Materials and methods:?Acute mucosal reactions that developed during radiotherapy were assessed in 55 patients. Blood samples were collected from each patient before the treatment and also from 50 healthy donors. The low-molecular-weight fraction of the plasma proteome (2,000–10,000 Da range) was analysed by the Matrix-Assisted Laser Desorption Ionisation mass spectrometry. The capacity for DNA break repair was assessed by the comet assay using lymphocytes irradiated in vitro.

Results:?Spectral components registered in plasma samples were used to build classifiers that discriminated patients from healthy individuals with about 90% specificity and sensitivity (components of 4469, 6929 and 8937 Da were the most essential for cancer classification). Four spectral components were identified (2219, 2454, 3431 and 5308 Da) whose abundances correlated with a maximal intensity of the acute reaction. Several spectral components whose abundances correlated with the rate of DNA repair in irradiated lymphocytes were also detected. Additionally, a more rapid escalation of an acute reaction was correlated with a higher level of unrepaired damage assessed by the comet assay.

Conclusions:?The plasma proteome could be considered as a potential source of predictive markers of acute reaction in patients with head and neck cancer treated with radiotherapy.     

Relationship between cellular radiosensitivity and DNA damage measured by comet assay in human normal, NBS and AT fibroblasts

PURPOSE: To study the relationship between cellular radiosensitivity and DNA damage measured by the comet assay. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Experiments were performed with nine human fibroblast lines (six normal, one NBS, and two AT). Cellular radiosensitivity was determined by colony assay and DNA damage was assessed by the comet assay. RESULTS: The cellular radiosensitivity of the fibroblast lines used covered a broad range with SF2 values varying between 1.3% and 53%. The comets analysed immediately after irradiation with doses up to 5 Gy showed marked differences among the cell lines; the relative initial tail moment at a dose of 5 Gy, ITM5, varied from 2.7+/-0.2 to 5.0+/-0.3. This variation was considered not to result from different numbers of DNA strand breaks induced but from differences in chromatin structure. There was an inverse correlation between SF2 and ITM5, i.e. radiosensitive cell lines exhibited a higher initial tail moment than radioresistant cell lines. In contrast, the repair kinetics measured with the comet assay for a dose of 2Gy followed by an incubation of up to 2h showed little variation and were found not to correlate with SF2. Repair kinetics as well as the amount of residual damage measured by this version of the comet assay were fairly similar to those measured by the alkaline unwinding technique and unlike that measured by neutral gel electrophoresis, indicating that this comet assay detects primarily single-strand breaks and alkali-labile sites, not double-strand breaks. CONCLUSIONS: The correlation between SF2 and the initial tail moment at 5 Gy found here suggests that the cellular radiosensitivity of human fibroblasts also depends on the chromatin structure.     

Comparison of chromosomal radiosensitivity of normal cells with and without HRS-like response and normal tissue reactions in patients with cervix cancer

PURPOSE: In our previous study, using the micronucleus (MN) assay, the low- and high-dose radiation response of fibroblasts and keratinocytes from cancer patients was assessed. We reported that a hyper-radiosensitivity (HRS)-like phenomenon was observed for fibroblasts of two and keratinocytes of four of the 40 patients studied. In this paper, we report the comparison of these in vitro results and normal tissue reactions in patients with cervix cancer and answer the question of the predictive value of the MN assay. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Of the 40 patients with cervix cancer whose cells were previously studied in vitro, 32 received radiotherapy. The treated group included two patients with HRS-like positive fibroblasts and four patients with HRS-like positive keratinocytes. In 26 patients both types of cells were HRS-like negative. The in vitro results (MN induction measured in patients' fibroblasts and keratinocytes after in vitrogamma-irradiation with doses ranging from 0.05-4 Gy) were compared with the maximum grade of acute and late reactions. RESULTS: Five of the six patients whose cells demonstrated low-dose chromosomal hypersensitivity in vitro, did not suffer from any mild or severe side effects after radiotherapy. Although individual variations in the grade scores of normal-tissue reactions were observed in cancer patients, no significant relationship was found between MN induction, either in fibroblasts or keratinocytes, and acute and late effects. CONCLUSION: Since the MN assay showed no predictive value, it is rather impossible that the severe late complication observed in one of the six HRS-like positive patients reflects her low-dose chromosomal hypersensitivity in vitro.     

FGF2 mediates DNA repair in epidermoid carcinoma cells exposed to ionizing radiation

Abstract Purpose: Fibroblast growth factor 2 (FGF2) is a well-known survival factor. However, its role in DNA repair is poorly documented. The present study was designed to investigate in epidermoid carcinoma cells the potential role of FGF2 in DNA repair. Materials and methods: The side population (SP) with cancer stem cell-like properties and the main population (MP) were isolated from human A431 squamous carcinoma cells. Radiation-induced DNA damage and repair were assessed using the alkaline comet assay. FGF2 expression was quantified by enzyme linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA). Results: SP cells exhibited rapid repair of radiation induced DNA damage and a high constitutive level of nuclear FGF2. Blocking FGF2 signaling abrogated the rapid DNA repair. In contrast, in MP cells, a slower repair of damage was associated with low basal expression of FGF2. Moreover, the addition of exogenous FGF2 accelerated DNA repair in MP cells. When irradiated, SP cells secreted FGF2, whereas MP cells did not. Conclusions: FGF2 was found to mediate DNA repair in epidermoid carcinoma cells. We postulate that carcinoma stem cells would be intrinsically primed to rapidly repair DNA damage by a high constitutive level of nuclear FGF2. In contrast, the main population with a low FGF2 content exhibits a lower repair rate which can be increased by exogenous FGF2.     

DNA damage and repair in individual cells: applications of the comet assay in radiobiology.

The comet assay is a single-cell gel electrophoresis method that can measure a variety of types of DNA damage, and repair of damage, in individual cells. It is now in widespread use in genetic toxicology and oncology. This review describes the history of the development of this method and its applications in radiation biology, with particular emphasis on the use of the comet assay to measure heterogeneity in DNA damage in cells exposed to ionizing radiation.     

FGF2 mediates DNA repair in epidermoid carcinoma cells exposed to ionizing radiation

Abstract

Purpose: Fibroblast growth factor 2 (FGF2) is a well-known survival factor. However, its role in DNA repair is poorly documented. The present study was designed to investigate in epidermoid carcinoma cells the potential role of FGF2 in DNA repair.

Materials and methods: The side population (SP) with cancer stem cell-like properties and the main population (MP) were isolated from human A431 squamous carcinoma cells. Radiation-induced DNA damage and repair were assessed using the alkaline comet assay. FGF2 expression was quantified by enzyme linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA).

Results: SP cells exhibited rapid repair of radiation induced DNA damage and a high constitutive level of nuclear FGF2. Blocking FGF2 signaling abrogated the rapid DNA repair. In contrast, in MP cells, a slower repair of damage was associated with low basal expression of FGF2. Moreover, the addition of exogenous FGF2 accelerated DNA repair in MP cells. When irradiated, SP cells secreted FGF2, whereas MP cells did not.

Conclusions: FGF2 was found to mediate DNA repair in epidermoid carcinoma cells. We postulate that carcinoma stem cells would be intrinsically primed to rapidly repair DNA damage by a high constitutive level of nuclear FGF2. In contrast, the main population with a low FGF2 content exhibits a lower repair rate which can be increased by exogenous FGF2.     

Relationship between cellular radiosensitivity and DNA damage measured by comet assay in human normal,NBS and AT fibroblasts

Purpose : To study the relationship between cellular radiosensitivity and DNA damage measured by the comet assay. Materials and methods : Experiments were performed with nine human fibroblast lines (six normal, one NBS, and two AT). Cellular radiosensitivity was determined by colony assay and DNA damage was assessed by the comet assay. Results : The cellular radiosensitivity of the fibroblast lines used covered a broad range with SF2 values varying between 1.3% and 53%. The comets analysed immediately after irradiation with doses up to 5 Gy showed marked differences among the cell lines; the relative initial tail moment at a dose of 5 Gy, ITM5, varied from 2.7 ±0.2 to 5.0 ±0.3. This variation was considered not to result from different numbers of DNA strand breaks induced but from differences in chromatin structure. There was an inverse correlation between SF2 and ITM5, i.e. radiosensitive cell lines exhibited a higher initial tail moment than radioresistant cell lines. In contrast, the repair kinetics measured with the comet assay for a dose of 2Gy followed by an incubation of up to 2h showed little variation and were found not to correlate with SF2. Repair kinetics as well as the amount of residual damage measured by this version of the comet assay were fairly similar to those measured by the alkaline unwinding technique and unlike that measured by neutral gel electrophoresis, indicating that this comet assay detects primarily single-strand breaks and alkali-labile sites, not double-strand breaks. Conclusions : The correlation between SF2 and the initial tail moment at 5 Gy found here suggests that the cellular radiosensitivity of human fibroblasts also depends on the chromatin structure.     

Comparison of chromosomal radiosensitivity of normal cells with and without HRS-like response and normal tissue reactions in patients with cervix cancer

Purpose: In our previous study, using the micronucleus (MN) assay, the low- and high-dose radiation response of fibroblasts and keratinocytes from cancer patients was assessed. We reported that a hyper-radiosensitivity (HRS)-like phenomenon was observed for fibroblasts of two and keratinocytes of four of the 40 patients studied. In this paper, we report the comparison of these in vitro results and normal tissue reactions in patients with cervix cancer and answer the question of the predictive value of the MN assay.

Materials and methods: Of the 40 patients with cervix cancer whose cells were previously studied in vitro, 32 received radiotherapy. The treated group included two patients with HRS-like positive fibroblasts and four patients with HRS-like positive keratinocytes. In 26 patients both types of cells were HRS-like negative. The in vitro results (MN induction measured in patients' fibroblasts and keratinocytes after in vitroγ-irradiation with doses ranging from 0.05–4 Gy) were compared with the maximum grade of acute and late reactions.

Results: Five of the six patients whose cells demonstrated low-dose chromosomal hypersensitivity in vitro, did not suffer from any mild or severe side effects after radiotherapy. Although individual variations in the grade scores of normal-tissue reactions were observed in cancer patients, no significant relationship was found between MN induction, either in fibroblasts or keratinocytes, and acute and late effects.

Conclusion: Since the MN assay showed no predictive value, it is rather impossible that the severe late complication observed in one of the six HRS-like positive patients reflects her low-dose chromosomal hypersensitivity in vitro.     

In vitro cellular radiosensitivity in relationship to late normal tissue reactions in breast cancer patients: a multi-endpoint case-control study

Purpose: A minority of patients exhibits severe late normal tissue toxicity after radiotherapy (RT), possibly related to their inherent individual radiation sensitivity. This study aimed to evaluate four different candidate in vitro cellular radiosensitivity assays for prediction of late normal tissue reactions, in a retrospective matched case-control set-up of breast cancer patients.

Methods: The study population consists of breast cancer patients expressing severe radiation toxicity (12 cases) and no or minimal reactions (12 controls), with a follow-up for at least 3 years. Late adverse reactions were evaluated by comparing standardized photographs pre- and post-RT resulting in an overall cosmetic score and by clinical examination using the LENT-SOMA scale. Four cellular assays on peripheral blood lymphocytes reported to be associated with normal tissue reactions were performed after in vitro irradiation of patient blood samples to compare case and control radiation responses: radiation-induced CD8+ late apoptosis, residual DNA double-strand breaks, G0 and G2 micronucleus assay.

Results: A significant difference was observed for all cellular endpoints when matched cases and controls were compared both pairwise and grouped. However, it is important to point out that most case-control pairs showed a substantial overlap in standard deviations, which questions the predictive value of the individual assays. The apoptosis assay performed best, with less apoptosis seen in CD8+ lymphocytes of the cases (average: 14.45%) than in their matched controls (average: 30.64%) for 11 out of 12 patient pairs (p?p?p?Conclusion: This matched case-control study in breast cancer patients, using different endpoints for in vitro cellular radiosensitivity related to DNA repair and apoptosis, suggests that patients’ intrinsic radiosensitivity is involved in the development of late normal tissue reactions after RT. Larger prospective studies are warranted to validate the retrospective findings and to use in vitro cellular assays in the future to predict late normal tissue radiosensitivity and discriminate individuals with marked RT responses.     

DNA damage formation, DNA repair, and survival after exposure of DNA repair-proficient and nucleotide excision repair-deficient human lymphoblasts to UVA1 and UVB

PURPOSE: The comet assay has been used to visualize DNA damage in single cells after exposure to UV light. These comets are commonly thought to reflect transient, repair-induced DNA breaks. The goal of the work presented here was to further characterize the nature of UV-induced comets and to further elucidate DNA damage formation by different wavelengths of ultraviolet light. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Detailed dose-response and time-course experiments with comet formation were carried out with normal and nucleotide excision repair (NER)-deficient xeroderma pigmentosum (XP) lymphoblasts. Irradiation was carried out with low, intermediate, or high doses of UVA1 or UVB, comet formation was observed, cell survival and viability were determined, and UV-induced apoptosis was measured. RESULTS: All responses were dose-dependent. With the intermediate dose of UVA1, a pronounced comet formation was observed without subsequent growth inhibition. Raising levels of porphyrins, which act as photosensitizers, by preincubation with 5-amino-levulinic acid increased comet formation with UVA1, but not with UVB. UVA1-sensitivity and comet formation in XP cells was not significantly different from the normal cells. With UVB no comet formation was seen without subsequent apoptotic cell death. XP cells exhibited the known UVB-hypersensitivity, but their comet formation was not significantly different from that of normal cells. CONCLUSIONS: The findings are compatible with the hypothesis that UV-induced comets represent transient repair-induced DNA breaks. Both, the NER of dimers and the base excision repair of oxidative DNA modifications are thought to contribute to comet formation.     

Measurement of DNA damage after acute exposure to pulsed-wave 2450 MHz microwaves in rat brain cells by two alkaline comet assay methods

PURPOSE: To investigate the effect of 2450 MHz pulsed-wave microwaves on the induction of DNA damage in brain cells of exposed rats and to discover whether proteinase K is needed to detect DNA damage in the brain cells of rats exposed to 2450 MHz microwaves. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Sprague-Dawley rats were exposed to 2450 MHz pulsed-wave microwaves and sacrificed 4 h after a 2-h exposure. Rats irradiated whole-body with 1 Gy (137)Cs were included as positive controls. DNA damage was assayed by two variants of the alkaline comet assay on separate aliquots of the same cell preparation. RESULTS: Significant DNA damage was observed in the rat brain cells of rats exposed to gamma-rays using both versions of the alkaline comet assay independent of the presence or absence of proteinase K. However, neither version of the assay could detect any difference in comet length and/or normalized comet moment between sham- and 2450 MHz pulsed-wave microwave-exposed rats, regardless of the inclusion or omission of proteinase K in the comet assay. CONCLUSIONS: No DNA damage in brain cells was detected following exposure of rats to 2450 MHz microwaves pulsed-wave at a specific absorption rate of 1.2 W kg(-1) regardless of whether or not proteinase K was included in the assay. Thus, the results support the conclusion that low-level 2450 MHz pulsed-wave microwave exposures do not induce DNA damage detectable by the alkaline comet assay.     

Evaluation of radioadaptive response induced in CHO-K1 cells in a non-traditional model

Purpose:?The present study was designed to evaluate the effects of sequential exposures to low doses of gamma-radiation that induce a radioadaptive response to a later high-dose of radiation in CHO-K1 cells.

Materials and methods:?Cells were cultured in four dilution cycles and grown to confluency. Radiation treatment was performed once per cycle with 0.1 Gy gamma-rays. After the last radiation period (chronic radiation) the culture was irradiated with a higher dose (1 Gy). Each cell culture was immediately divided into two fractions: one of them was used to carry out the comet assay and the other for the structural chromosome aberration test. In the first fraction, genotoxic damage was evaluated by degree of damage in 300 cells per experimental point. The second assay was performed with 400 cells per treatment. The statistical analysis was carried out using the χ²-test.

Results:?Results from these assays demonstrated a genotoxic effect for both the adaptive and acute treatments (p < 0.001). The comet assay showed a significant increase in damage for the combined treatment when compared with 1 Gy treatment (p < 0.001). The frequency of chromosomal aberrations (CA) was lower for the combined treatment than for that using the highest radiation dose.

Conclusions:?These results suggest the possible induction of a radioadaptive response after the sequential exposure to very low doses of radiation. The finding of decreased cytogenetic damage after one cell cycle and not immediately after radiation could indicate the eventual potentiation of repair mechanisms.     

High levels of chromosome aberrations correlate with impaired in vitro radiation-induced apoptosis and DNA repair in human B-chronic lymphocytic leukaemia cells

Purpose : To investigate the relationship between the susceptibility of B-chronic lymphoid leukaemia (B-CLL) cells to DNA damage-induced apoptosis, the kinetics of DNA strand-break rejoining, and chromosome damage after exposure to ionizing irradiation. Materials and methods : Lymphocytes from B-CLL patients were γ-irradiated in vitro with 0.2-5 Gy and stimulated by Staphylococcus aureus cowan I (SAC I) for estimation of chromosomal damage. Induction of apoptosis after irradiation was studied in 50 patients by two methods: morphological characterization of apoptotic cells after fluorescent staining (Hoechst), and specific quantification of mono- and oligonucleosomes in cytoplasmic cell fractions (ELISA assay). Morphological chromosome damage was scored in the first cell generation after irradiation (13 patients). In parallel, the kinetics of DNA single-strand break rejoining were investigated by the alkaline comet assay (12 patients). Results : Ionizing irradiation did not induce apoptosis in lymphocytes from a subset of B-CLL patients. The results suggest that B-CLL cells resistant to radiation-induced apoptosis could repair DNA strand-breaks more rapidly and showed a higher level of chromosome aberrations than radiation-sensitive B-CLL cells. Conclusion : Each of three biological effects observed (apoptosis, kinetics of DNA single-strand-break repair, chromosomal damage) might be explained by different modifications occurring in irradiated B-CLL cells. Their convergence strongly suggests that resistance to apoptotic death initiation by DNA damage may be impeded by a rapid engaging of the DNA repair mechanisms. The higher level of chromosome aberrations observed in these cells suggests that the type of DNA repair system involved may generate inaccurate repair.     

Comparison of repair and rejoining fidelity between two isogenic human ovarian carcinoma cell lines

PURPOSE: The difference in radiosensitivity between two isogenic tumour cell lines was evaluated to determine whether factors such as sublethal and potentially damage repair, DNA double-strand break repair and fidelity of repair can be related to differences in radiosensitivity. MATERIALS AND METHODS: The cell lines used were the ovarian carcinoma A2780s and a radiation-resistant derivative A2780cp. Radiation response was measured in terms of cell survival, recovery of sublethal (SLD) and potentially lethal damage (PLD), induction of and recovery of DNA strand breaks, and fidelity of DNA repair using a cell-free plasmid assay. RESULTS: While A2780cp was more resistant to radiation than A2780s, it showed less ability for recovery of SLD and PLD. DNA strand-break induction was the same for both cell lines, while only at very high doses did A2780cp show greater DNA strand-break recovery than A2780s. Fidelity of rejoining DNA was significantly higher in the A2780cp cell line. CONCLUSION: The difference in radiosensitivity between these two cell lines was not related to recovery of PLD or SLD or to the induction of DNA damage. It appears that fidelity of DNA rejoining, which was significantly higher in the resistant cell line, may be related to the difference in radiosensitivity.