Detection of antibodies to HAV 3C proteinase in experimentally infected chimpanzees and in naturally infected children

Commercial assays for the diagnosis of hepatitis A detect antibody to hepatitis A virus (anti-HAV), but they cannot discriminate between antibody resulting from infection and antibody induced by inactivated vaccine. With the licensing and increasing use of inactivated hepatitis A vaccines, there is a need for a test to distinguish between infection and vaccination. Since antibodies to viral non-structural proteins are elicited by infection but not by vaccination with inactivated vaccine, we developed and evaluated a test for such antibodies. The antibody response to the non-structural 3C proteinase (anti-3C) of virus HAV was studied by ELISA in chimpanzees experimentally infected with virulent (wild type) or with attenuated HAV strains and in children who received inactivated HAV vaccine or placebo during a vaccination trial in Nicaragua. Anti-3C was detected in 89% of 18 chimpanzees infected with wild-type HAV strains and 27% of 26 chimpanzees infected with attenuated HAV strains. There was a direct correlation between severity of hepatitis and magnitude of the anti-3C response. In the vaccine trial, anti-3C was detected only in children who were infected with HAV during the study; IgG anti-3C persisted for at least 15 months after infection in one child. Vaccinated and uninfected children remained negative for anti-3C. The anti-3C response can be regarded as an indicator of viral replication. Its detection should be useful for distinguishing between antibody acquired in response to HAV infection and antibody induced by immunization with inactivated vaccine.     

Development,Production, and Postmarketing Surveillance of Hepatitis A Vaccines in China

China has long experience using live attenuated and inactivated vaccines against hepatitis A virus (HAV) infection. We summarize this experience and provide recent data on adverse events after immunization (AEFIs) with hepatitis A vaccines in China. We reviewed the published literature (in Chinese and English) and the published Chinese regulatory documents on hepatitis A vaccine development, production, and postmarketing surveillance of AEFI. We described the safety, immunogenicity, and efficacy of hepatitis A vaccines and horizontal transmission of live HAV vaccine in China. In clinical trials, live HAV vaccine was associated with fever (0.4%–5% of vaccinees), rash (0%–1.1%), and elevated alanine aminotransferase (0.015%). Inactivated HAV vaccine was associated with fever (1%–8%), but no serious AEFIs were reported. Live HAV vaccine had seroconversion rates of 83% to 91%, while inactivated HAV vaccine had seroconversion rates of 95% to 100%. Community trials showed efficacy rates of 90% to 95% for live HAV and 95% to 100% for inactivated HAV vaccine. Postmarketing surveillance showed that HAV vaccination resulted in an AEFI incidence rate of 34 per million vaccinees, which accounted for 0.7% of adverse events reported to the China AEFI monitoring system. There was no difference in AEFI rates between live and inactivated HAV vaccines. Live and inactivated HAV vaccines manufactured in China were immunogenic, effective, and safe. Live HAV vaccine had substantial horizontal transmission due to vaccine virus shedding; thus, further monitoring of the safety of virus shedding is warranted.Key words: hepatitis A, vaccine, safety, efficacy     

甲肝灭活疫苗接种安全性及免疫效果观察

目的观察甲型肝炎灭活疫苗的安全性及免疫效果.方法挑选甲肝抗体阴性、丙氨酸转氨酶(ALT)正常的健康的恒河猴10只.随机分为5组,每组2只,每只接种1ml甲肝疫苗,分别接种甲肝灭活疫苗吕8株(Lu8)、H₂株及史克疫苗.方案:0、4周接种.接种3天内,每天观察有无局部及全身反应.首次注射后每周采静脉血1次,加强1针后每2周采血1次检测抗HAV及ALT,14周后改为每4周采血1次直至46周.每周采粪便2次,连采4周,用KMB17细胞进行病毒分离.4、8周肝组织穿刺作病理学检查.结果接种疫苗后3天内,所有猴子均无局部及全身反应.ALT正常,4、8周肝脏穿刺无特殊组织病理改变.首次注射后2周100%抗体阳转,4周效价为374.8mIU/ml～937mIU/ml.加强1针后抗HAV效价有10倍以上升高,抗体最高达14992mIU/ml,到46周抗体水平持续在2998.4mIU/ml～7496mIU/ml之间,GMT为31.2～34.2.大便传代2次无排毒.结论4批国产甲肝灭活疫苗接种恒河猴具有很好的安全性和可靠的免疫效果.     

Safety and immunogenicity of a combined vaccine against hepatitis A and B in patients with autoimmune hepatitis

Patients with autoimmune hepatitis (AIH) are a group at risk of disease exacerbation or relapse of the underlying disease should they fall ill with infectious hepatitis A (HAV) or B (HBV). Therefore, it seems appropriate to protect this group of persons against HAV and HBV disease by vaccination. An open study evaluated the safety, reactogenicity and immunogenicity of a combined HAV and HBV vaccine in 10 patients with AIH (6 patients aged 1-15 years and four patients aged 16+ years). The vaccine was administered using a three-dose vaccination schedule (0, 1 and 6 months). The vaccine course was well tolerated, safe and did not aggravate the clinical course of the underlying disease. Patients responded with 100% seroconversion for antibody to the HAV vaccine component and geometric mean antibody concentration (GIVIC) comparable to healthy cohorts. Response to the HBV component antigen was comparable to previous reports of HBV vaccination in immune compromised individuals with lower GMC than observed in healthy populations. One month after the third vaccine dose (month 7), all six vaccinees in the 1-15 years age group developed protective levels of anti-HBs as compared to two of the four vaccinees in the 16+ years age group.     

Long-term immunity in young adults after a single dose of inactivated Hepatitis A vaccines

We evaluated in a prospective study the immune response of na?ve subjects to a single dose of inactivated Hepatitis A vaccine. Ninety-seven percent of the vaccinees sero-converted 1 month after vaccination and 93% were still positive 2 years later. All of the vaccinees had a strong booster response 2 years after the single dose. Avaxim was more immunogenic than Vaqta for the primary dose (p = 0.01 for sero-positivity, p<0.001 for antibody level) but no differences were found after boosting with Avaxim. Performance of intense physical activity during the first month after a single vaccine dose was associated with lower antibody levels (p = 0.004). This study indicates that a single dose of inactivated HAV vaccine elicits protective immune memory for at least 2 years.     

Hepatitis A virus-specific humoral and cellular immune responses following immunization with a formalin-inactivated hepatitis A vaccine

To evaluate proliferative T cell responses elicited by a formalin-inactivated HAV vaccine, we immunized 10 subjects with an inactivated HAV vaccine, and measured HAV antibody titers and HAV-specific T cell proliferation. gamma-Interferon production by PBMC's was evaluated in selected subjects. By week 30, seroconversion (geometric mean titer=2299 mIU/ml), and HAV-specific proliferation was detected in all subjects. HAV also induced gamma-interferon in the three subjects studied. These data indicate that the inactivated HAV vaccine induces proliferative T cell responses in addition to HAV antibody. This may be important for protection against hepatitis A, and suggests that recall memory for HAV antigen is elicited by the vaccine.     

Safety and immunogenicity of live attenuated quadrivalent human-bovine (UK) reassortant rotavirus vaccine administered with childhood vaccines to infants

The safety and immunogenicity of an orally administered, live rotavirus vaccine comprised of four strains, each with a titer of 10^5.3 or 10^5.8 pfu, and each having 10 genes from the UK bovine strain and the VP7 gene from human rotavirus serotype 1, 2, 3, or 4, were evaluated in adults, young children and infants in randomized, double-blind phase 1 trials. Three doses of rotavirus vaccine or placebo given with childhood immunizations to infants at 2, 4, and 6 months of age were well tolerated and did not inhibit antibody responses to childhood vaccines which included DTP, Hib, hepatitis B and OPV. Serum rotavirus antibody responses were detected in 12 of 20 infants after 1 dose, and in 19/19 of the vaccinees after three doses. Neutralizing antibody responses were detected more often against the bovine rotavirus UK strain (95%) than to human rotavirus VP7 serotypes 1 (37%), 2 (32%), 3 (32%) or 4 (32%). The efficacy of this quadrivalent rotavirus vaccine needs to be evaluated further.     

HAV吕8株生长特性及残余活毒检测方法的研究

[目的]对甲型肝炎病毒吕8株(HAV吕8)培养生长特性进行研究,确定其灭活后残余活毒检测方法的可靠性。[方法]通过一步生长曲线确定HAV吕8株的生长增殖高峰;将活病毒样品作2倍系列稀释后接种于细胞,研究不同接种量的最早检出时间;以统计学方法计算细胞培养方法检测HAV的灵敏性及可靠性;以病毒在细胞上的感染性为指标,经3次传代检测其有无感染性,以确证灭活疫苗残余活毒检测方法的可靠性。[结果]HAV吕8株细胞培养增殖高峰约为d20￣24;细胞培养方法检测甲肝病毒的灵敏性可达1.79CCID50、可靠检出甲肝病毒的最低量为10.23CCID50;凡达到ELISA的检出灵敏度的HAV接种样品,当培养增殖到d12时,均能被检出;当HAV含量达到512Eu/0.1ml时,不论是活病毒还是已灭活病毒,其吸附在细胞上的残余病毒量均能达到ELISA的检测灵敏度。[结论]将甲肝灭活疫苗样品接种细胞进行残余活毒检测,经3次传代,每次培养20d以上,该检测方法有较高的灵敏度,其检测结果是可靠的。     

Comparison of immunogenicity of two hepatitis A vaccines--VAQTA and HAVRIX--in young adults.

Two new hepatitis A vaccines have been developed, and their immunogenicity tested using different immunoassays. The present study was designed to compare the immunogenicity of these two hepatitis A virus (HAV) vaccines--VAQTA and HAVRIX--as determined by seroconversion rates and anti-HAV titers, and using the same immunoassay. Healthy volunteers (15-30 y), seronegative for anti-HAV, were randomized in an open single center study to four groups of 20-21 vaccinees each, to receive either a 25 U or a 50 U dose of VAQTA, or HAVRIX at 720 EU or 1440 EU/dose, administered at 0, 1 and 6 m or at 0 and 6 m, respectively. Four weeks after primary immunization, seroconversion rates were 100% for VAQTA and 95% for HAVRIX, following injection of 50 U or 1440 EU, respectively (p = NS) and anti-HAV GMTs were 40 and 37 mIU/ml for VAQTA and HAVRIX, respectively. At 6 months, prior to the booster dose, seroconversion rates were 100% for both vaccines, with anti-HAV GMTs of 111 and 70 mIU/ml for VAQTA and HAVRIX, respectively (P < 0.05). At month 7, four weeks after the only booster injection, using the two dose regimen, anti-HAV titers were 2212 and 1511 mIU/ml for VAQTA and HAVRIX, respectively (P < NS). Using three doses of 25 U/dose of VAQTA or 720 EU/dose of HAVRIX at 0, 1 and 6 m did not produce any clinically evaluable advantage over the two dose regimen for either vaccine. No significant adverse events were observed using either vaccine. In summary, both vaccines have similar immunogenicity demonstrated using identical immunoassays for evaluation. These results also confirm the outstanding immunogenicity of a single dose of either of the HAV vaccines and support their use in pre- and possibly postexposure prophylaxis against hepatitis A virus infection.     

Immune responses of anti-HAV in children vaccinated with live attenuated and inactivated hepatitis A vaccines

The immunogenicity of a live attenuated HAV vaccine and an inactivated HAV vaccine was compared.Altogether 117 children were vaccinated with either the inactivated or the live attenuated vaccine. Children were bled at months 1, 6, 7, 12 and 24, and the anti-HAV total IgG antibody and IgG subclass profile were assessed. In both vaccinated groups, the geometric mean titer (GMT) of anti-HAV peaked 7 months after the initial dose and declined during the following months. The IgG subclass profiles in both vaccinated groups were highly restricted to IgG1 and IgG3. Both vaccines have been shown highly effective in preventing viral hepatitis A in former studies.     

Concurrent administration of inactivated hepatitis A vaccine with immune globulin in healthy adults

301 healthy adult volunteers were randomized to one of three treatment groups: inactivated hepatitis A vaccine alone; inactivated hepatitis A vaccine with immune globulin (Ig) concurrently; or Ig alone. The first two treatment groups received a second dose of hepatitis A vaccine at week 24. Anti-HAV was measured 4, 8, 12, 24 and 28 weeks after the primary immunization. When comparing subjects receiving inactivated hepatitis A vaccine alone to those receiving vaccine and Ig, the seropositivity rates were not significantly different at 4, 8, 12 and 28 weeks, but at week 24 the seropositivity rate was lower in the group receiving both vaccine and Ig compared to the group receiving vaccine alone (92.0% compared to 97.0%). At weeks 8, 12 and 24 the geometric mean titers (GMTs) were significantly lower for subjects receiving both vaccine and Ig. The GMTs were not significantly different after the second dose of vaccine. At all time points, the lower serum antibody concentrations observed in subjects receiving both inactivated hepatitis A vaccine and Ig were nevertheless substantially higher than the cutoff for assay seropositivity and much higher than after Ig alone; these differences are therefore clinically insignificant.     

Comparison of the protective efficacies of the live vaccine RIT 4025 and an inactivated vaccine against a natural heterologous A/Victoria/3/75 infection.

A clinical trial was initiated in South Africa before the winter season of 1976. The study involved 253 volunteers divided into three groups of vaccinees and one control group. Two groups of vaccinees were inoculated with either one or two doses at 2 weeks' interval (10(7.2) EID 50/dose) of the RIT 4025 live recombinant strain [A/Scotland/840/74 (H3N2) serotype] and one group received one injection of an inactivated vaccine [A/Port Chalmers/1/73 (H3N2), 360 i.u., A/Scotland/840/74 (H3N2), 300 i.u. and B/Hong Kong/8/73, 300 i.u./dose]. The serum antihaemagglutinin antibody responses against the heterologous A/Victoria/3/75 strain as measured by the single radial haemolysis test were satisfactory and not statistically different in all groups of vaccinees. On the other hand, the antineuraminidase antibody response was better in the group receiving the killed vaccine. At the end of the influenza season, A/Victoria/3/75 infections were confirmed serologically. Only 12% of the infections were symptomatic. The infection rate was significantly reduced in the live vaccine groups, whereas in the killed vaccine group the percentage of infection was lower but not significantly different from that in the placebo group.     

Immunogenicity trial of inactivated hepatitis A virus vaccine in human volunteers.

An inactivated hepatitis A virus (HAV) vaccine was tested on a group of human adult volunteers. The vaccine was administered subcutaneously, and a control group received a placebo (aluminium hydroxide). The vaccine was found to be relatively well tolerated and non-reactogenic, and levels of anti-HAV were comparable to those in other studies.     

Preliminary human trial of inactivated golden hamster kidney cell (GHKC) vaccine against haemorrhagic fever with renal syndrome (HFRS).

An inactivated golden hamster kidney cell culture (GHKC) vaccine against haemorrhagic fever with renal syndrome (HFRS) has been developed in recent years. A monovalent GHKC vaccine (lot 88-17) was prepared with L99 strain of the rat-type hantavirus, adapted in suckling mouse brain, cultivated in GHKC, and inactivated with 0.025% formalin, and a preliminary trial of the vaccine was carried out in a small number of human volunteers with the approval of the Ministry of Public Health, PRC, in order to identify safety and antibody response of the vaccine. Three inoculations were made on days 0, 7 and 28 respectively, by the intramuscular route with 1 ml vaccine each time for every volunteer. No obvious side effect was observed in vaccinees within 3 days after each inoculation. All 12 vaccinees (10 received three inoculations, and two received two inoculations of the vaccine) showed positive seroconversion of IgG antibody (by IFAT and ELISA) and neutralizing antibody (by enzyme focus reduction neutralization test, EFRNT), and 10 of them were still seropositive 180 and 360 days after the first inoculation. These results suggest that this vaccine would be safe for human use, and could effectively induce IgG and neutralizing antibody responses.     

倍尔来福TM甲、乙型肝炎联合疫苗安全性和免疫原性研究

目的 观察倍尔来福~(TM)甲、乙型肝炎(甲、乙肝)联合疫苗的安全性和免疫原性。方法以高中一年级(成人组)和小学1～5年级(儿童组)学生为研究对象,按对甲、乙肝病毒均易感、只对甲肝病毒易感和只对乙肝病毒易感分为AB组、A组和B组,按0、1和6个月三剂程序分别接种甲、乙肝联合疫苗、灭活甲肝疫苗和重组乙肝疫苗。疫苗剂量成人组每剂含甲肝病毒抗原500U和(或)HBsAg10μg,儿童组减半。疫苗接种后72h内观察副反应,免疫后2、7个月采集血清标本检测抗-HAV和抗-HBs。结果 儿童AB组和成人AB组局部副反应发生率分别为0.58％(2/344)和2.56％(8/312),全身副反应发生率分别为9.88％(34/344)和5.45％(17/212),与对照组相比差异无显著性。局部反应主要是轻度疼痛,全身反应主要是低热。免疫后7个月,两组抗-HAV阳转率均为100％,与A组相同;抗体滴度(GMT)分别为33 910mIU/ml和23 435 mIU/ml,显著高于A组;两组抗-HBs阳转率分别为97.30％和96.63％;GMT为103 mIU/ml和102 mIU/ml,抗-HBs阳转率及GMT均与B组差异无显著性。结论 倍尔来福~(TM)甲、乙肝联合疫苗与单价甲肝灭活疫苗和单价重组乙肝疫苗具有相同的安全性和免疫原性。     

A randomized phase 3 trial of the immunogenicity and safety of coadministration of a live-attenuated tetravalent dengue vaccine (TAK-003) and an inactivated hepatitis a (HAV) virus vaccine in a dengue non-endemic country

BackgroundVaccination against hepatitis A virus (HAV) is largely recommended for travelers worldwide. Concurrent dengue and HAV vaccination may be desired in parallel for travelers to countries where both diseases are endemic. This randomized, observer-blind, phase 3 trial evaluated coadministration of HAV vaccine with tetravalent dengue vaccine (TAK-003) in healthy adults aged 18–60 years living in the UK.MethodsParticipants were randomized (1:1:1) to receive HAV vaccine and placebo on Day 1, and placebo on Day 90 (Group 1), TAK-003 and placebo on Day 1, and TAK-003 on Day 90 (Group 2), or TAK-003 and HAV vaccine on Day 1, and TAK-003 on Day 90 (Group 3). The primary objective was non-inferiority of HAV seroprotection rate (anti-HAV ≥ 12.5 mIU/mL) in Group 3 versus Group 1, one month post-first vaccination (Day 30) in HAV-naïve and dengue-naïve participants. Sensitivity analyses were performed on combinations of baseline HAV and dengue serostatus. Secondary objectives included dengue seropositivity one month post-second vaccination (Day 120), HAV geometric mean concentrations (GMCs), and safety.Results900 participants were randomized. On Day 30, HAV seroprotection rates were non-inferior following coadministration of HAV and TAK-003 (Group 3: 98.7 %) to HAV administration alone (Group 1: 97.1 %; difference: ?1.68, 95 % CI: ?8.91 to 4.28). Sensitivity analyses including participants who were neither HAV-naïve nor DENV-naïve at baseline supported this finding. Anti-HAV GMCs on Day 30 were 82.1 (95 % CI: 62.9–107.1) mIU/mL in Group 1 and 93.0 (76.1–113.6) mIU/mL in Group 3. By Day 120, 90.9–96.8 % of TAK-003 recipients were seropositive (neutralizing antibody titer > 10) to all four dengue serotypes. Coadministration of HAV vaccine and TAK-003 was well tolerated, with no important safety risks identified.ConclusionImmune responses following coadministration of HAV vaccine and TAK-003 were non-inferior to administration of HAV vaccine alone. The results support the coadministration of HAV vaccine and TAK-003 with no adverse impact on immunogenicity, safety, and reactogenicity of either vaccine.ClinicalTrials.gov registration: NCT03525119.     

Evidence for antigen production in muscles by dengue and Japanese encephalitis DNA vaccines and a relation to their immunogenicity in mice

This study demonstrated viral antigen production in muscle tissues following inoculation with DNA vaccines and examined its relation to antibody induction in mice using the flavivirus system. To achieve detectable levels of antigen production, we used a needle-free jet injector and examined 10% homogenate of quadriceps muscle for viral antigens in a sandwich enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay. We compared DNA vaccines against dengue type 1 (designated pcD1ME), dengue type 2 (pcD2ME) and Japanese encephalitis (pcJEME). The amounts of viral envelope (E) antigen contained in muscle homogenate 1, 2, 3 and 4 days following inoculation with 50 microg of pcJEME were 1.1, 1.0, 0.3 and <0.1 ng/ml, respectively. Muscles from pcD2ME- and pcD1ME-inoculated mice did not contain detectable levels of E antigen (<0.1 ng/ml) during 4 days following inoculation. The E amounts released from Vero cells transfected with DNAs were in the order pcJEME>pcD2ME>pcD1ME. Levels of neutralizing antibody induced by two immunizations with 100 microg of each DNA vaccine using needle-free or normal needle/syringe injection systems also were in the order pcJEME>pcD2ME>pcD1ME, 2-11 weeks after the first immunization. However, the difference in antibody levels among three DNA vaccines 14-18 weeks after immunization was smaller than that in the early phase of immunization. These results provide fundamental information useful for developing combination DNA vaccines, such as a dengue tetravalent DNA vaccine, which require adjustment of immunogenicity of each component.     

Pre-vaccine plasma levels of soluble inflammatory indices negatively predict responses to HAV,HBV, and tetanus vaccines in HCV and HIV infection

BackgroundChronic hepatitis C virus (HCV) and HIV infections are associated with impaired responses to neo-antigens contained in hepatitis A virus (HAV)/hepatitis B virus (HBV) vaccines, yet responsible mechanisms are unclear.MethodsACTG 5232 and CFAR0910 were clinical trials where pre-vaccine levels of plasma IP10, IL-6, sCD163 and sCD14 were measured in viremic HCV- (n = 15) or HIV-infected participants (n = 24) and uninfected controls (n = 10). Accelerated dosing HAV/HBV vaccine and tetanus booster were administered and antibody response was measured at 0, 1, 3, 8, and 24 weeks.ResultsPre-vaccine plasma IP10, IL-6, and sCD14 levels were elevated in both HCV and HIV-infected participants, while sCD163 was also elevated in HCV-infected participants. Pre-immunization tetanus antibody levels were lower in HIV-infected than in uninfected participants, while vaccine induced antibody responses were intact in HCV and HIV-infected participants. After HAV/HBV vaccination, HCV and HIV-infected participants had lower and less durable HAV and HBV antibody responses than uninfected controls.Among HCV-infected participants, pre-vaccine plasma IP10, IL-6, sCD14, and sCD163 levels inversely correlated with HAV, HBV and tetanus antibody responses after vaccine. Low HAV/HBV vaccine responses in HIV-infected participants prohibited assessment of immune correlates.ConclusionsDuring HCV and HIV infection markers of systemic inflammation reflect immune dysfunction as demonstrated by poor response to HAV/HBV neo-antigen vaccine.     

Mucosal immunization against hepatitis A: antibody responses are enhanced by co-administration of synthetic oligodeoxynucleotides and a novel cationic lipid

Hepatitis A caused by hepatitis A virus (HAV) transmitted by the fecal-oral route, results in considerable morbidity and economic loss. Mucosal immunization can be more effective than conventional injection at inducing both local and systemic immunity to HAV. Here we show that co-administration of killed HAV with synthetic oligodeoxynucleotides (ODNs) containing CpG sequences, and a novel polycationic sphingolipid (CCS)/cholesterol liposomal delivery system, markedly enhances the HAV-specific antibody response at the intestinal interface, particularly when delivered intrarectally or intranasally, to Balb/c mice at low HAV doses. A mucosally delivered, antigen-sparing HAV vaccine that is easily administered without specialized equipment or personnel, is an attractive alternative for facilitating mass immunization in hepatitis A outbreaks.     

Dose range evaluation of a new inactivated hepatitis A vaccine administered as a single dose followed by a booster

A total of 242 healthy adults were immunised with a first dose of an investigational inactivated hepatitis A vaccine. Three concentrations (3, 6 and 12 EU [ELISA units]) of the experimental vaccine were used and compared to a licensed reference vaccine. The aim was to determine the antigenic concentration of the study vaccine inducing the highest seroconversion rate and anti-Hepatitis A virus (HAV) antibody response at 2 weeks after the primary immunisation. A booster dose was given at month 6. At 15 days after the primary immunisation the seroconversion rates in subjects vaccinated with the 6 and 12 EU vaccines were 78 and 94%, respectively. At 30 and 180 days after the primary immunisation the percentages of seropositivity were 100% for both groups. The antibody response to the 12 EU study vaccine was similar to that to the reference vaccine. The percentages of seropositivity at 15 and 180 days after the primary immunisation were 94 vs 93%, and 100 vs 93% in the experimental and reference vaccine respectively. Thus, because it induces early and lasting seroconversion, the 12 EU study vaccine seems to be the most effective as a high potency HAV vaccine.